The moderation of the Church of England considered as useful for allaying the present distempers which the indisposition of the time hath contracted by Timothy Puller ...

THE MODERATION OF THE Church of England .

CHAP. I Of Moderation in general .

§ . 1. The loud demands of late among us for Moderation taken notice of . § . 2. The specious pretences of several Factions thereunto , exposed . § . 3. The general meaning of Moderation noted . § . 4. The use of the Greek word for Moderation ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) as it is borrowed from the Law , explained . § . 5. The forensic notion of Moderation applied to Moderation in Religion . § . 6. What is justly expected of those who causlesly blame our Church with want of Moderation . § . 7. Moderation considered not only as a vertue of publick , but of private persons ; both toward their Governours first , and also toward one another . § . 8. Some general rules or measures according to natural Justice and Christianity , whereby we may judge of the Moderation of the Church ; with the design of this Treatise , declared .

§ . 1. WE have of late with both Ears , heard the loud demands made for Moderation among us : even since the Restitution of our Church , to its own admirable and equal temper ; even since the unspeakable Clemency of our most Gracious King , and the extraordinary indulgence of the Laws , have really anticipated so much Moderation , as reasonably might have dampt some of those vehement out-cries , which seem still to offer violence to our senses , as well as to the peace of the Kingdom , and the Church .

But that the sound might come more awful to religious Ears , on both sides the cry hath been set up in the words of Holy Scripture : Let your Moderation be known unto all , the Lord is at hand . ( Phil. 4. 5. )

Moderation therefore being the word in fashion , by which all divided parties among us use to sanctify their appeals , and make their pretences seem virtuous ; It is first to be wisht that real Truth and Goodness , which are the genuine effects of true Moderation , were as common as the noise of either .

§ . 2. All agree that Moderation is an excellent vertue , as they said of Hercules , Who ever dispraised him ? hence the several Factions make such specious pretences thereunto : The sanctimonious Pharisees affected the appearance of mighty moderate Men : they could in the very twinkling of an eye , cast their countenances into a solemn mortify'd guize : and they were the first that inveighed against Persecution ; and cryed out : If we had been in the days of our forefathers , we would not have been partakers with them in the bloud of the Prophets : ( S. Matt. 23. 30. ) however they were in their principles prepared to fill up the measure of their Fathers : Wherefore our Blessed Lord called them Serpents ( v. 33. ) a subtle , nimble , insinuating generation , full of folds and intrigues , humble and flexible in all appearances of Moderation , to wind and turn their pretences , but they were a generation of Vipers , immoderately cruel and dangerous .

In this ( as in many other Instances ) many of the Romanists and the Enthusiasts , exceedingly agree , as acted by the same spirit and practice of Pharisaism . The first compass some Emissaries of Rome take to make a Proselyte , or a Novice ( as our Homily calls him a a Hom. of good Works . ) is with all goodly semblance of Moderation : This they shew , this they promise , this they challenge from others , as especially their due : this upon sundry occasions they extol as peculiarly signal among themselves .

In the Recantation framed for Antonius de Dominis , he is made to extol the mild and fatherly care of the Holy Inquisition b b Sanctae Inquisitionis benigna ac paterna cura super Dominicum gregem . Consil . reditus , p. 23. Engl. transl . p. 29. ; which watcheth attentively over our Lords flock ; the ordinary armour of which tribunal , are sound doctrine and instruction full of charity . The Answer also made in his name c c P. 56. Parum absuit quin ego Philarides & Mezentios apud vos experirer . Ibid. to Bishop Hall , saith : The Roman Church doth by no means persue those who differ from it , but teacheth and instructeth them friendly , hears them peaceably , &c. And the Catholick Apologist d d P. 305. very earnestly contends , that Papists are more merciful than Protestants to Dissenters ; and do use them very kindly : Mark in this matter ( saith the Rhemist e e Pref. to the Rhem. Transl . of N. T. ) the wisdom and moderation of Holy Church . After I knew ( saith de Cressy f f Exomolegesis , c. 41. p. 290. ) that the Church of Rome was more moderate and condescending than before , &c. Yea the pretences to Moderation have swell'd to that height among some in the Roman Church , that Erasmus g g Erasin . in N. T. ad . 1 Tim. 1. hath noted , Some in his time disputed , whether the Pope was not more mild and moderate than Christ himself , who never was read to have recalled any from the pains of Purgatory . But of all methinks Card. Bellarmine hath a most V. Apologiam Smytheam de benignitate Ecclesiae . Non est quòd querantur onus legum Pontificiarum & numero & gravitate esse impossibile . Lorinus in 15. Actor . 28. pleasant Chapter , only to shew the exceeding gentleness and Moderation of the Church of Rome , in the mild obligation , and sparing number of its Laws ( which we shall afford a particular consideration , Ch. 12. §. 9. )

By almost infinite arts of this nature they are very industrious to decoy the credulous into the belief of themselves : always representing the Bosom of their Church , as a warm , soft , easy place , full of mercy and indulgencies : And thus far their pretences may be allow'd of , that they both recommend and use all soft and gentle means to bring men to an allowance of that Doctrine they would insinuate ; but as it is only there where they cannot use more forcible ones , so that course continues no longer than till they have brought them over to their Church , whose authority over its own members is always kept up in its utmost force and rigour .

S. Austin h h Contra Gaudentium , l. 2. tells us , how the Enthusiastic Donatists ( though both they and after them the Circumcellions , were intolerably severe to the Catholicks when they had power , yet ) were great Advocates for Liberty of Conscience in the free practice of it : Which because Julian i i Monebat Julianus ut quisque ( nullo vetante ) religioni suae serviret intrepidus : quod agebat adeo obstinatè , ut dissentiones augente licentiâ non timeret unanimem plebem . Am. Marc. l. 22. §. 3. the Apostate granted them ( in crafty design to confound Christianity k k Eo modo Christi nomen de terris perire putavit , si sacrilegas dissentiones liberas esse permitteret . S. Aug. Ep. 166. ) how did they magnify him as a mighty Moderate l l Quod apud eum solum Justitia locum haberet . S. Aug. c. Petil. l. 2. c. 97. Prince , and set up his Image ? and Ecclesiastic History abounds with instances of most Hereticks , who invaded the Church by this serpentine way of insinuation : entring in by all supple accommodation to the innocence and mildness of the Dove : but afterwards they appeared of another spirit : like the Locusts of the bottomless pit : Rev. 9. 9. Which had hair as the hair of Women , but their teeth were as the teeth of Lions ; and they had tayls like unto Scorpions , and they had stings in their tayls : v. 10. So among the Disciplinarians to the fifth Monarchy man ; when they want power and opportunity , they have all shew of gentleness , and of calmness , as a Lamb m m Nulla bestia mansueta dicitur quae neminem mordet cùm dentes & ungues non habet . ; but when the evil spirit moves them to resist and overthrow ; how full are they of the highest Corybantick Fury !

§ . 3. Since then so many opposite parties pretend all to Moderation n n O mites Diomedis equi , Busiridis arae Clementes , Tu Cinna pius , Tu Spartace lenis ! , as the special vertue in which they themselves excel , and require it of others with a countenance of pity that they want it : the mistake is , either they know not what true Moderation is , or else they judge amiss of them to whom it belongs . To proceed therefore more clearly , We shall first enquire into the name and thing it self : for the better understanding also of that Text , Phil. 4. 5. Let your Moderation be known unto all : and for the right application thereof .

Moderation in general may note that fit and proper temper which is observed in matters of judgment and practice : a taking right measures ( as the phrase is ) and avoiding all undue extremes : and therefore is the effect of such a Prudence as doth contain the affections and endeavours within those proportions and bounds as are most suitable to the goodness of the end , and the necessity and use of the means : and thus it doth not differ much from that Mediocrity , in which Aristotle placeth the formal reason of vertue , the definition of which he doth no otherwise establish o o 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Arist. Eth. l. 2. c. 6. , than in the judgment of a truly prudent man : All vertue consisting either in a Mean , or in a Moderation ; and being the effect of prudence , it may receive several names p p Potest tamen esse quod nomen 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 apud Graecos per quandam similitudinem transferatur ad omnes moderationes . D. Thom. 2. 2 dae . Q. 120. art. 2. , according to the condition of the matter about which it is conversant .

§. 4. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , or 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ( which we commonly render ) Moderation is a word frequently used by Aristotle : and was taken from the Greeks into the Treatises of the Roman Laws : Yea , so excellent is the sense of the word , according to the explication of the Philosopher ; that the most skilful in the Roman Laws and Language ; and Justinian himself , and his Reformers of the Laws , never fitted any Latine word for the same entire sence : Neither doth any common language reach the full comprehension of the same signification : wherefore the Civilians q q Bonam fidem Graeci 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , nos bonum & aequum dicimus . Minsinger . l. 4. Tit. 6. , and Schoolmen r r D. Tho. 2. 2 ae . Q. 120. art. 1. V. Suarez . de Legibus . , and others , do very frequently accept of the same Greek word , thereby to express that kind of Equity , which sometime gives a remission to the rigour of Laws ; sometime doth supply their deficiencies .

So that 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , Moderation as it is now generally used , is a word borrowed from the Law , and is used by the Masters thereof to denote such a gentle and benign temper , as disposeth those who have the administration of the Laws to remit of their rigour , where either ( first ) they press too hard upon particular persons ; or else ( secondly ) to supply the defects of the said Laws , where they provide not sufficiently for particular Cases : in order thereunto , squaring their determinations by the natural rules of justice and goodness , rather than by the letter of the Law .

§ . 5. The reason why I first make gentleness , or meekness , a part of the definition of this ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation , is , because of the derivation of the word : and because those who are presumed best to understand the sense of words ( as Phavorinus s s 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Phavorinus . , Hesychius t t 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Hesychius . , Suidas u u 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Suidas . , and the Glossary x x 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , Glossario mansuetudo , clementia , modestia . Gro. , and others ) do unanimously interpret what we render Moderation ( and y y 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Suidas . such words as have cognation with the same ) by those other expressions of gentleness , meekness , and a mild disposition , to yield to those we have to do with : but especially they aim to express in its signification , such a calm and quiet temper , as is not ruffled with passion : A temper of mind , not only exceedingly requisite in a Judge , but also pre-required to that benignity and kindness which we have said this 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Moderation doth include : Rough and angry minds being not likely to consult the ease of those that are to be judged by them .

Secondly , There is the like evidence from the same authorities z z 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Phavorinus . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Hesych . , for including benignity and kindness in the definition of ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation ; which is much according to Aristotles mind a a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Arist. Nicom . l. 5. c. 14. ; and the Latines also generally render the same by aequum and bonum b b Male igitur Accursius aequum & bonum distinxit . Bud. in Pandec . : and indeed this goodness and kindness properly belong to the account of this Moderation , because of those benign effects which we have affirm'd it disposeth men to , which are next to be considered .

For the better understanding whereof , we are to remember , that though 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Moderation , may in a more general sense extend to other things which may stand in need of Correction ; yet in the forensic sense wherein we take it , it refers only to the Laws , and is defined by Aristotle c c 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Aris . Eth. l. 5. c. 14. to be the Correction of the Laws wherein because of their universality they are deficient . From whence , as it must be supposed , to be confined to those to whom the administration of the Laws is committed , who alone can have the power of correcting them : So nothing therefore will be further requisite to shew , than that it disposeth them , where the Laws press too hard upon particular persons , to relax the rigour of them ; as on the other side , where they do not sufficiently provide for them , to supply their defect .

All Laws we know are for the punishment of evil doers , or for the praise of them that do well : but it being impossible so to provide for the punishment of evil doers , as not sometime to bring even the innocent within the compass of it ; because what generally considered , ought to be lookt upon and censured as evil , may yet upon sundry considerations and circumstances have nothing of evil in it , or at least be worthy of pardon ; Either the innocent must suffer together with the nocent ( which so benign a vertue as that we treat of cannot allow ) or it must dispose those to whom the administration of the Laws is committed , to remit of their rigour in such particulars , and exempt them from the undergoing of it : It being in like manner impossible for Laws so to provide for the encouragement of those who deserve well , as that sometime such may not be past over neglected ; partly because all cases cannot be foreseen by the Lawgiver ; and partly by reason of the shortness of his expressions ; Either some who may deserve encouragement may be excluded from partaking of it ( which so benign a vertue as we speak Est scriptum legis angustum interpretatio diffusa . Sen. l. 4. controv. 27. of cannot easily permit ) or it must dispose those to whom the administration of the Laws is committed to ampliate their favours ; and to take such within the compass of them .

Only , whereas the excess and defect Jusfinitum est propter circumscripta mandata , at bonitas sive aequitas est veluti sons perpetuò scatens & perennis . Tract . de legib. l. 2. c. 6. of Laws in these particulars , cannot be supposed to be corrected by such measures of justice and goodness as are not of a certain and fixed nature ; so there being no such measures , beside the natural rules of justice and goodness ; the same ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation must consequently be thought to prompt them , to whom it belongs , to govern their determinations by these rules , in order to the attaining its benign and equitable designs . And indeed the true love of the common good doth properly lead to this benignity which tempers justice d d Aequitas est benignitas juris . Est rationabilis modus sive temperamentum recedens ex causâ à communibus regulis Juris . Bartol. l. 1. F. de legibus . : wherefore Equity and Moderation is the publick honesty of the Laws ; without which , Justice often would be turned into Wormwood : It contains the excellent spirit ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) the mind and reason of the Law , and is the most sacred and venerable part of it : As it is the honour and perfection of the Laws e e Quid aliud est restituere in integrum , nisi laxare juris rigorem ? Calv. lex . jurid . ; so it is the Sanctuary of such as happen to be oppressed by the rigour of the Letter .

I have insisted somewhat long upon this notion of ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation , as because it is the primary one , and the standard of all the rest ; so because it will help us to discover what is the true notion of it in Religion ( which is that we are most especially to enquire into . ) Taking it in the strictest sense ; so it can have no other meaning when applyed unto Religion , than such a meek and benign temper as may dispose those to whom the administration of it is committed , to relax the rigour of the Laws ; where they press too hard in particular Cases : or secondly , To supply the defects of those Laws where they provide not sufficiently for them .

§ . 6. But as those who would blame our Church for the want of this ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation , ought first of all to shew , that there are such rigours , or defects in her Laws as to particular persons ; and then that they are not considered : So , if they cannot do this , they must acknowledge that which they would blame in the Church to belong to themselves . 2. Such ought to evidence their charge from the natural principles of justice and goodness ; or at least by those which Christianity hath taught us : these , and these alone , being the measures by which this ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation is to proceed , and therefore to be satisfied of the other by .

§ . 7. But because words do not alway continue in their strict and proper sense , but extend also to such senses as hold Analogy with the other : and because too , it is certain , that the Scriptures make use of this very word in other significations ( as their making it the duty of private as well as publick persons , doth sufficiently demonstrate ) therefore it must be granted , that there are other sorts of ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation required , beside that before mentioned ; but which must be judged of by the Analogy they hold with it ; yea , with the whole definition of it : for otherwise they may not only not deserve the name , but may have nothing commendable in them ; for even lenity and benignity ( how excellent soever in themselves ) may become evil , when employed where severity ought to be used : Wherefore that we be not condemned in what we seem to approve , it will be requisite that we have that notion in our Eye , which is the standard of all the rest : I mean ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation truly so call'd .

Which may be considered : as a Vertue in private , or in publick persons . As in private persons again with reference to publick persons ( and particularly the Governours of the Church ) or with reference to one another . 1. If we consider the ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation of private persons to publick persons , so it will be found to consist in the judging of the Laws of their Superiours , by the rules of Justice and Charity ; and particularly by that Charity the properties whereof are described by S. Paul , in the 1 Corinth. 13 Ch. For if that be a Charity which is due from Existunt etiam injuriae saepe calumniâ quâdam & nimis callidâ & malitiosâ juris interpretatione . one to another , even to the meanest Members of Christs Body ; how much more to the Governours thereof ? For as Cicero f f Cic. de off . l. 1. truly saith , There are often injuries done by a too crafty and malicious interpretation of the Law : which is a dishonour and reproach to Government , and is most remov'd from ( bona fides ) fair and equal behaviour . Some by their own ill tempers make the Laws appear to them more rigorous than they are : Others by their weakness , and fear , and scrupulousness , cannot fully satisfy their own thoughts with that real benignity which the Laws do exhibite ( non aequi & boni consulentes ) not taking them in good part , but interpreting almost every thing to the worst sense g g 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Arist. Eth. l. 5. ; torment themselves by their own scrupulous and superstitious humour . Both these extremes the Wise man seems to refer to in his double admonition , ( Eccles. 7. 16. ) Be not righteous over-much , neither make thy self over-wise , why shouldest thou destroy thy self h h Noli esse justus nimiùm : debet enim justitiam temperare moderatio . S. Ambr. de poen . l. 1. c. 1. , or why shouldest thou be desolate ? as it were by thy own rigour and scrupulousness deprive thy self of the great benefits of Society ?

2. If we consider the ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation of private persons toward one another , so it will be found to consist in judging of one anothers actions by the same equitable and charitable measures . And is often taken for such actions themselves as are joined with gentleness , benignity , and good will i i 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . 2 Macc. 9. 27. : such as are forgiving personal wrongs ; bearing with the infirmities of those we have to do with ; interpreting doubtful things fairly , determining our liberty in a real indifferent matter with compliance and condescension to others ; accommodating our selves and our matters , according to the possibility and necessity of our Neighbours ; governing those impressions of self-love which are in us all , by such considerations and ends , as rational nature hath sometimes a more principal regard to , namely the greater good of our Neighbour , the ends of Peace , and our superiour relation to God . The instances of this ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation are shown also in one mans requiring less of another than in right he might exact k k Dummodo non se acerbum exactorem prabeat sed Moderatum , & cum efficaci● benignum & cum instantiâ humanum . Ulpian . : or in granting more than of right could be required , which is using ( as we say ) a Conscience : wherefore Equity is called not only the Religion of the Judge , but the Piety of a good man ; the equitable man being esteemed in the same breath a good man . So the good and gentle are by S. Peter join'd in opposition to the froward ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , 1 Pet. 2. 18. ) and the Apostles injunctions comprehend not only whatsoever things are just , but whatsoever things are lovely , and such being true Moderation , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 quaecunque accommoda Er. ( Phil. 4. 8. ) it is but the proper effect of that Wisdom which comes down from above , which is pure , and peaceable , and gentle l l 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Jam. 3. 17. : Which disposeth private persons one toward another , to remit what is rigorous , and to supply all defects they may , by kindness , courtesy , and benignity .

§ . 8. The ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation of publick persons consists either in the equitable and benign administration of Laws ( spoken of before : ) or ,

2. In the framing of such Laws as are in themselves equitable and benign .

Now whether the Laws of this or any other Church be such , is to be judged by comparing them with the natural Rules of Justice and Goodness , but more particularly with such Rules as our Christianity doth offer for the direction of our Judgments .

Some of those Rules which natural Justice , and Christian Prudence may direct us to , are such as these .

1. Benignity is not to exclude Justice : The Rules of which therefore are to be considered in this ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation , as well as those of the other .

2. In those Laws which respect Ecclesiastical Polity , and particularly the administration of the publick Assemblies , there is to be considered a Justice to God , as well as to one another ; because it is his worship and service which is to be celebrated .

3. The Justice which we owe to God cannot be satisfyed , nor his honour consulted , unless all things be done decently and in order , because God is the God of Order and not of Confusion .

4. That all things be done decently and in order , some certain Rules are to be prescribed , within such bounds and for such ends as there is general direction given ; without which Rules , order among a multitude can never be preserved .

5. Against which Rules so prescribed , no such exception can reasonably be allowed or considered , which tends alike to the overthrow of all .

6. 'T is fit the Governours of every particular Church should consider the same in its relation to the Church Universal , of which it is a part ; and in their particular Society , benignity to one sort of men ought not to exclude the consideration of others , especially the major part .

7. Benignity is to be shewed to the humble and peaceable , but it can in no wise be challenged by the proud and froward : especially who are manifestly prepared to make ill use of the benignity of the Church , as much as possible to the ruine of the Church , and their own and others greater mischief .

8. True benignity aims more at the real profiting any person whatsoever , than the gratifying their humours and sickly phancies . These and the like Rules seem to be the proper measures of ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation where they are observed : And that these and such other rules as are comprehended in the nature of true Moderation , are wisely and faithfully observed by our Church ; the design of this Treatise is by variety of proper proofs and instances to make evident : and that it may the more certainly appear , I shall for the most part compare this Moderation of our Church with the extreams of Popery and Enthusiasm .

CHAP. II. Of the false notions of Moderation which many have taken up .

§ . 1. How it comes to pass that the name of Moderation is so seldom apply'd to what it ought to be . § . 2. The sense of that Text inquired into , Phil. 4. 5. Let your Moderation be known unto all . § . 3. Those words of the Apostle purposely are directed to the suffering sort of Christians . § . 4. Some false notions and evil meaning of the word . Moderation briefly animadverted on and overthrown .

§ . 1. THE reason why this word Moderation is so seldom apply'd in its most proper and useful sense , by them that make most noise about it , is because the licentious humour and wanton appetites of those who affect novelty in Religion , are ( through the liberty they have had ) become more and more insatiable ; like the Horseleech , they are ever crying , Give , Give ; and the more Moderation is used , the more their cries are renewed ; and to make their demands more plausible , Moderation is called for by the Authority of St. Paul , Let your Moderation be known unto all men , the Lord is at hand .

§ . 2. The continual claim for Moderation being so often repeated in those words of the Apostle : Since they are so exceedingly misunderstood by some , or obstinately misapply'd by others ; it may be judged very fit to render the true sense of the words as evident as may be , before we proceed . Those who consider the context may find the Blessed Apostle exhorting the Philippians , and in their name all that should be persecuted in the glorious cause of Christianity ; that they would endure their tryals at least with all patience and equanimity ; and if it might be , that they would rejoice in the midst of their suffering condition : v. 3. Rejoice in the Lord always , and again I say rejoice . Let your Moderation be known unto all : as if the Apostle had said a a See Erasmus Paraphrase Commended in the Injunctions of K. Edw. 6. 1547. of Q. Eliz. 1559. §. 6. Ordered to be had in every Church : and by all the Clergy under B. D. , O ye Christians , in the midst of your afflictions I exhort you again and again to rejoice in God , because of the double need thereof in your suffering condition , and that you would maintain a present and an upright mind ; although the iniquity of your persecutors is immoderate against you , yet let your Moderation and patience be known unto all men , not only your Brethren and Fellow-sufferers for their encouragement and support , but even to the adversaries and opposers b b 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . S. Chrys. in loc ; that by your goodness and even temper , they may be won over and reconciled to the Christian Religion they now persecute : I would not have you bear any revengeful mind , nor envy them their prosperity , for the coming of the Lord is at hand , who can and will in due time execute his justice on the Enemies of his Church , and deliver his people as he pleases , or reward their patience abundantly : For in the third and fourth verses , S. Paul solemnly mentions his Fellow-sufferers with honour , and according to a right Apostolick care of them , v. 3. I intreat thee true Yoke-fellow , help those women which laboured with me in the Gospel , with Clement also , and with other my fellow-labourers whose names are in the book of life : where by Fellow-labourers certainly are meant his Fellow-sufferers , which only could be understood by those Women who suffered with him in the Gospel ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Rogo eis opitulare quae mecum certaverint in evangelio , Foeminas nempe quae unà cum Beato Paulo p●ssae essent afflictiones . Erasmi Paraphr . ) who for the Faith strove together and contended with himself through sundry difficulties and sufferings : whom in the sixth verse , he further continues his speech to : Be careful for nothing , but in every thing by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving , let your requests be made known unto God , and the peace of God shall keep your heart , &c. And when the Blessed Apostle wrote this Consolatory Epistle to the Philippians , S. Paul was not only in bonds in defence and confirmation of the Gospel , Ch. 1. v. 7. But unto them of Philippi also , was this grace given , in the behalf of Christ , not only to believe in him , but also to suffer for his sake , v. 29.

§ . 3. Thus it is evident that this Exhortation of S. Paul here to Moderation , is indeed directed by him absolutely to the patient and suffering sort of Christians . Which let those take notice of especially who affect so much to be counted the suffering party , which if they are who call themselves so , then the Apostle speaks more to them than any , Let your Moderation be known unto all d d Of this perhaps they may be better satisfied from Mr. Pools Synopsis Criticorum . De afflictionibus hîc agitur . Zanch. Ver. Er. Bez. &c. .

But it is the cause only makes the Martyr : Some may suffer indeed justly as a due reward of their deeds ( through their own ill will : ) Others according to the will of God ( 1 S. Pet. 4. 16 , 19. ) when they have done nothing amiss : S. Luke 23. 41. and this I take to be the real Case of the Church of England .

Wherefore we seriously wish they would present themselves real examples of the thing it self who make so much noise of the word : We may heartily wish , they who seem so earnest for Moderation , would consider whether it seems not agreeable to that equal temper of mind recommended in the Text , for all to be disposed to interpret every thing to the best , and to go as far as they can for peace and unity in the Church , and compliance with what is enjoin'd . I wish such would please to consider and read the words in their true sense : with any of those Versions which are given of them : Let your equity e e Bez. Castell . : Your gentleness f f Trem. Dr. Ham. : Your patient mind g g Our old English Tr. Erasm . Par. : Your taking all in good part h h Bez Com. : Your reasonable Conversation i i S. Ambr. : Your modesty k k Vulg. Lat. S. Hier. : Your giving way one to another l l Erasmus . : Your Moderation be known unto all .

§ . 4. That we may the more clearly understand the Moderation of our Church , we will further inquire into their false notions of Moderation , who so vehemently seem to require it in our Church : which requiries are made either to private persons , or to those in authority . 1. When private persons are called upon to let their Moderation be known unto all men : They ( as far as they know their own minds themselves , and are not averse to declare it in their writings and other expressions of their meaning undeniable ) by Moderation would have

1. Either an Indifferency , whether they do or do not what is required : or , 2. They mean an Omission of what is appointed : or , 3. They understand by it the doing quite contrary .

When appeal for Moderation is made to Governours : by Moderation they would understand , either

1. A forbearance of the execution of Laws , ( especially which relate to matters Ecclesiastical : ) or 2. An abolition of them : or 3. An utter alteration of Government : So that all the burden for Moderation relates to the remission of the obligation and observance of the Laws ( especially ) of the Church : and their whole sense of Moderation doth contain many odd suppositions : particularly , that the conditions of our Communion are very unlawful , very immoderate , and inexpedient .

Wherefore if in the following discourse we make it appear , that the entire constitution of our Church doth exhibite as great Moderation , and as equal temper , as any Church in the Christian World doth or ever did since the Primitive Times ; we shall justify our Constitutions from those exceptions mentioned , and a thousand times as many more as they can raise .

For supposing at present , which afterward I shall plainly demonstrate , that the conditions of our Communion are not unlawful , and that the appointments of the Church as they are , and what relates thereunto , are very moderate : then it will plainly and necessarily follow ,

1. That an indifference in doing or not doing what is required : or an omission of what is matter of duty : or doing quite contrary , must needs be so far from Moderation , that it will appear to be a great affront to the authority of a well-setled Kingdom and Church : and the more moderate this is , the higher will be the aggravation of their crime .

2. As to the forbearance of the execution of such Laws , I shall only say thus much : That if for political considerations Superiours should give way at any time to such a forbearance , it may not be unseasonable to consider , as among the Jews there were some things permitted or tolerated ; not for their own goodness , but because of the hardness of the hearts of the people :

So when Constitutions equal in themselves are remitted in consideration only of the weakness of the people , the people ought to be instructed of the reason they have to be humbled for their own imperfection , that they may not glory in their shame , lest they go on to take heart against the Laws , and accustom themselves to frowardness .

3. As to change , or abolition of Laws , I only here touch upon what hereafter will be more amply shew'd .

That the Moderation of our Church is such , that she always hath publickly profest , That the Rites of the Church , and particular forms of worship , are in their own nature indifferent and mutable : And it is notorious matter of fact among us , that the Church hath often made those alterations which occasion hath required , and for the same reasons can do the like again .

4. As to an utter alteration of the Government , which some there are would look at as a prime point of Moderation : I should be very injurious to truth if I should not observe , That some who begin with but desires of Moderation , never leave till they end in the utter subversion and extirpation of what they declare themselves averse from : which renders this undertaking more necessary . Thus King Charles I. m m 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Med. 11. took notice of some Reformers , who by vulgar clamours and assistance , did demand not only Toleration of themselves in their vanity , novelty , and confusion , but also abolition of Laws against them , and a total extirpation of that Government , whose Rights they have a mind to invade .

Lastly : To take their words in the most mild sense , not for an absolute change of the entire Government , but for such an alteration of the Laws as seems to be meant by the word ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation : as it is sometimes taken for a correction of the Laws by Equity .

Most known unto all it may be that the Church of England never refuseth this : But in cases of such mitigations and remissions as are called for , we must consider , there is generally supposed either an unjust sentence , or some rigour of the Law ; or some great inconvenience attending : All which the wisdom of Government will not hastily and at every motion determine : especially when such alterations are challenged as matter of duty , and when they cannot be done without a publick acknowledgment of some great errour or sin before admitted n n See the Proclamation of K. Edw. 6. for the authorizing an Uniformity of Common-Prayer . : Wherefore such Concessions are not properly admitted without great reasons moving thereunto , because of the publick honour of Laws in them concerned : Lest also the frequent change of publick Laws , encourage the mutable vulgar in their common unreasonable levity , and desire of Innovation : Lest well-setled Order and the common Peace be disturbed , and lest good men be discouraged in their regular obedience : therefore Christian ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation doth not in such like Cases encourage alterations , especially when there is no end of gratifying such sick phancies , and where it is not agreed between the parties complaining what they would have relieved .

This would be to expose the dignity of the Church , and of Constitutions setled by such long prescription , to the scorn of every bold dissenter , which can have no other effect but to encourage them in their Schism , and heap contempt upon our selves , when we prostitute Law and authority to such affronts . Vnless our dissenters had the humility and the honesty to confess they had been mistaken , and were now resolved to go as far towards the repairing of breaches as their Consciences could allow ; and did propose a clear Scheme of what they would submit to , and on what terms they would again enter into the Communion of the Church ; then I am confident such candid dealing would find an entertainment beyond what they can justly hope for o o Modest Survey of Naked Truth . .

CHAP. III. Of Moderation with respect to the Church of England .

§ . 1. What is to be understood by the Church of England . § . 2. The Moderation of our Church frequently confessed by her Adversaries : sometime truly , sometime upon design ; but most often our Church is reproached and opposed for her Moderation by each sort of Adversaries . § . 3. From the joint opposition made against our Church by her Adversaries on either hand , is taken the chief inartificial proof of her Moderation .

§ . 1. TReating of the Moderation of the Church of England , some will not be ashamed to ask what is meant by the Church of England a a V. Reasons for the necess. of Reform ▪ p. 3. . 'T is pretty odd , that in a setled Church as ours is , such a question should be so confidently made as it is by some , who while they ask it , may be members of it , if they please . But because this Treatise is so immediately concerned in this question , I shall make the answer more clear from all exceptions , if I come thereunto by some steps .

The Church in general is a select Society ; that is , of such as are called out of the World to the worship of God b b 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 coetus evocatorum . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Clem. Alex . Strom. l. 7. . This Society is either that invisible Company of all the faithful throughout the World , who are inwardly and really holy , known unto God : Or is the Society of those who confess Christ before men , and by this visible profession of the true Faith , have right to the Sacraments and other priviledges of their spiritual Community ; especially those which are a necessary and publick sign before God and Man , that such do confess Christ Jesus : For God who is the alone searcher of hearts hath left only this presumption for the rule of mortal men , that the visible profession of the Faith should give right to the outward priviledges of the Church : without granting which , even the true members of the invisible Church could never communicate in any outward Society : which all that call themselves Christians are oblig'd to do : and therefore the nineteenth Article of our Religion begins thus : The visible Church is a Congregation of faithful people , &c. In every moderate Constitution as I show ours is , the Rule obtains , Every one is presumed to be good , till the contrary appears in a lawful manner : Wherefore , that visible Company of faithful people , who here under the Dominion of our Sovereign Lord the King , call themselves Christians , and profess the Faith of Christ ; which he defends ( They ) are the Church of England : c c Hooker 's Eccl. Pol. l. 3. §. 1. For as the main body of the Sea being one , yet within divers Precincts hath divers names ; so the Catholick Church is in like sort divided into a number of distinct Societies ; every one of which is termed a Church within it self ; so the name of Church is given betokening severally ; as the Church of Corinth , Ephesus , England , and the like d d Multas quidem Ecclesias & tamen unam modò unaquaeque intra seipsam , & cum universali , adeoque cum omnibus ejus partibus servat Catholicam unitatem . Forbesi , Iren. l. 2. c. 20. .

But to come to the head of the exception , which commonly is this ; If the Church be a Congregation of faithful people , as the Article defines the visible Church ; How comes the determination of the Convocation , the Orders of the Bishops , to be lookt upon as the appointments of the Church ? which are also governed by the will of the King ; What of all this is the Church of England ?

In answer hereunto , let such take notice , that the people among us , do bear as great a part as they ought , in what is constituted in our Church ; whether they will own it or no : For where the consent of the people is not actually required , it is either included in the Laws of the Land ( by which they are governed ) or in the will of the King ; to whom , beside his own power over the Church in his own Kingdoms , which is very great ; in many Cases they have made over their right e e Refertur ad universos quod publicè fit per majorem partem . ff. de reg. ju . ad sect. refertur . , whatever it is , themselves : and frequently by their Ecclesiastical Governours , they also consent to what is constituted in the Church : For we must remember what our Article expresseth , That the Church is a Congregation of faithful people ( as it there follows ) according to Gods Ordinance : We must also remember , that the Church in its beginning did not form it self ; neither did it ordain or appoint its own Rulers : For Christ gave some Apostles , Pastors , Teachers ( Eph. 4. 11. ) 1 Cor. 12. 28. Yea , they had their power given them , somewhat before the Church was formed , Mat. 28. 18 , 19. to shew that they were not to depend upon the people for their power .

Whatever voluntary condescensions were made by the heads of Ecclesiastical Communion in the tender beginnings of the Church , to oblige them more firmly in their Christian Fellowships : yet all rights of Administration of the spiritual power of the Church did always properly belong to the Rulers of the Church , within their own limits : So S. Ignatius , Cyprian f f Cum Ecclesia quae Catholica , una est , connexa & cobaerentium sibi invicem sacerdotum glutine copulata . S. Cypr . l. 4. Ep. 9. Hierom , and others of the Fathers fitly call the Church a Company united to their Pastor : For the Administration of the power of the Church cannot belong to the body of this Society considered complexly , but to those Officers in it , whose care and charge is to have a peculiar over-sight and inspection over the Church , and to redress the disorders in it : Wherefore the Church is not improperly exprest by the Clergy , which may be justly counted , the Church representative , that as S. Cyprian saith , Every act of the Church may be governed by its Rulers g g Vt omnis actus Ecclesie per praepositos suos gubern●tur . S. Cypr. Ep. 27. ; For when we speak of the Church making Laws , we must mean the governing part of the Church * * Du● . dub . l. 3. ch. 4. p. 589. .

In the form of Church Policy presented to the Parliament in Scotland , 1578. by Andrew Melvill h h V. Spots . Hist. l. 6. p. 289. , it was agreed , That sometime the Church was taken for them that exercise the spiritual Function in particular Congregations . More certain it is , that the Form of Christs Church is that outward disposition and order of superiour and inferiour communicating mutually to the conservation of the whole body and the edification and encrease of every member thereof . Eph. 4. 15 , 16. Col. 2. 19. And in those things which concern the outward form and manner of Government in a National Church ; where the King is supreme , in all Causes , and over all Persons ; many matters necessarily and properly belong to the disposition of the supreme Power , the people exhibiting their consent by the King ; upon these and the like good Foundations , The third Canon declares the Church of England a true and Apostolical Church : and the ninth Canon declares the same , the Communion of Saints , as it is approved by the Apostles Rules in the Church of England ; upon which account the Authors of Schisms in the same Canon are censured , and the 139th Canon of the Church concerning the Authority of National Synods doth thus declare , Whosoever shall affirm , that the sacred Synod of this Nation , in the name of Christ , and by the Kings Authority assembled , is not the true Church of England , by Representation , Let him be Excommunicated , and not restored till he repent and publickly revoke that wicked Error .

§ . 2. Having now explained what is meant by Moderation , and what by the Church of England ; we may more intelligibly proceed in justifying the Moderation of the Church of England : of which some inartificial proofs may be premised . The first of which may be the Confession and acknowledgments of our Adversaries on both sides : Yea , if the scattered Concessions which have been made by our Adversaries at sundry times and upon divers occasions , should be gathered together in a bundle ; there is scarce any judgment , or practice , or constitution of our Church , but hath been acknowledged sometime by some or others of them , as reasonable and moderate .

Yea , there is scarce any extravagance among themselves , but hath been also confest and decryed by several of their own Communion : so great is the force of truth upon the minds of men at some times ; when they are in a free humour to disclose themselves ; and it might make a very pleasant and useful Collection , to have these well gathered and set together : particularly , they have in their lucid intervals acknowledged the Moderation of our Church , sometime as really convinced thereof : Notwithstanding ( saith one who left our Communion De Cressy 's Exomolog . c. 9. ) the English Church hath been more moderate and wary than publickly to pretend to such a private spirit , and by consequence hath left a latitude and liberty for them in her Communion to renounce it , as many of the most Learned among them have done . Another of them speaks thus of the Church of England k k Conference between a Prot. and a Papist , 1673. p. 6 , 7 , 8. . I believe her Moderation hath preserved what may one day yet much help to close the breach betwixt us . We observe that she , and peradventure she alone , has preserved the face of a continued mission , and uninterrupted Ordination : Then in Doctrines , her Moderation is great . In those of greatest concern hath exprest her self very warily . In Discipline she preserves the Government by Bishops , but above all we prize her aversion from Fanaticism , and that wild error of the private spirit , with which it is impossible to deal : from this obsurdity the Church of England desires to keep her self free : She holds indeed , that Scripture is the Rule of controversy ; but she holds withal , That it is not of private interpretation : for she is for Vincentius his method . But I see that moderate counsels have been discountenanced on both sides .

Others of the same denomination have appeared to acknowledge the Moderation of our Church , but it is manifest they have done it upon design ; using that acknowledgment only as an Art , either to Proselyte some uncertain ones of our Communion , or else to divide us : thinking by their publick owning our Moderation , thereby to render us more odious to those of another immoderate extreme . Yet the generality of both extreme adversaries join together in reproaching us for this Moderation ; and by their immoderateness in so doing , do also justify the Moderation of our Church .

Thus do the great Bigots of the Church of Rome , and the rigid Disciplinarians and other Novellists , in their zeal count all merciful Moderation lukewarmness l l 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Med. 12. .

Wherefore these apply to us what the Spirit said to the Angel of the Church of Laodicea m m Vid. Mr. Henderson 's 1. & 2d. Paper . Collegium Laodicensium est senatus Moderatorum hominum . Brightman in Apocal. c. 3. p. 105. Antitypum est nostra nimirum Anglicana . ibid. p. 101. , Rev. 3. 16. Because thou art lukewarm , and neither hot nor cold , I will spue thee out of my mouth : reproaching commonly our Moderation by the name of neutrality and want of zeal n n Cesset igitur Anglia Medietatem suam quae mera neutralitas est , sub titulo prudentiae & moderationis palliare , poti●● serve & resipi●ce . Parker de Eccl. Pol. l. 1. c. 25. ; and when some temperate interpretations have been offered the Romanists o o Scio enim ejusmodi Modificationes ( ubi aliquid temperatum offerebatur ) nihil aliud esse quàm Satanae dolos , &c. Ep. c. Bellarm. ad Archipresb . Anglic. , they have received them with invidious reflexions , lest any of their Company should be won over to us by the Moderation of our Church : In the mean while none persue the Church of England upon this account so much as the rigid and severe of either extreme ; the hot heads among the Romanists with their Anathema's , and the other Zelots with their Curse ye Meroz .

Whereas the learned men of other reformed Churches , have not only observed frequently , and admired the Moderation of our Constitution ( as Dr Durel in his View of the Reformed Churches , hath plentifully instanced ) but so far forth as they judge the same Moderation found among themselves ; they seem to mention it with a great joy p p Retinemus ex singulis regiminibus exquisitam temperaturam : J. A. Comenius , de Ord. Eccl. apud Bohem. , and count the same worthy of imitation q q Atque hîc Commemorare libet ad Exemplum quantâ sapientiâ , quantoque temperamento , compositae fuerint precationum formulae quibus Gall. & Genev. utuntur . Amyrald . de secess . ab Eccl. Rom. p. 225. .

§ . 3. Wherefore the most general and inartificial , but most plain proof of the Moderation of our Church ( such a proof as is sufficient to evince the whole enquiry ) is the consideration of the condition of our Church among her Adversaries ; that is , as the 7. Canon 1640. hath it , between the groundless suspicions of the weak , and the aspersions of the malicious ; r r Pref. to the Liturgy conc . Cerem . between those addicted to their old Customs , and the new-fangled who would innovate all things ; the Church of England hath been a patient sufferer .

And as the true Religion hath always been tryed by real persecution of its extreme Adversaries , and thereby hath become more approved and more glorious ; so by the wonderful Providence of God , this temper and Constitution of the Church of England , hath had its Essayes in two very refining Tryals . 1. Immediately after the Reformation in its persecution from those of the Romish Communion ; and lately in its second Tryal , from other Domestick Adversaries : from both which sufficient proofs , the Moderation of our Church may be known unto all , 'T is a hard condition : The Church of England professeth the ancient Catholick Faith , and yet the Romanist condemns her of Novelty in her Doctrine : She practiseth Church Government as it hath been in use in all Ages and places where the Church of Christ hath taken any rooting , both in and ever since the Apostles times , and yet the Separatist condemns her for Anti-Christianism in her Discipline : The plain truth is , she is betwixt these two Factions as between two Milstones : And it is very remarkable , that while both these press hard upon the Church of England ; both of them cry out upon Persecution t t Arch-Bishop Laud against Fisher . Pref. : among whom she is placed as an humble representation of her Blessed Saviour : for as he was Crucified amidst Criminals : so the Church of England hath most constantly suffered betwixt such Factions and Sects of Men , as have run into the utmost extremes , from the judgment and practices of the Universal Church of Christ : such are the Romanists , and other Sectaries and Schismaticks amongst us : Thus Manasseh vexed Ephraim , and Ephraim Manasseh , and both against Judah . ( Is. 9. 21. ) Thus Herod and Pontius Pilate , otherwise at variance , became Friends , to be but the worse Enemies to our Saviour : thus both the Jews and Gentiles opposed the Christian Religion : and afterward the later Jews and the Circumcellions , joined against the Catholick Christians : and since Judaism and Gentilism have been overcome by the light of the Gospel , the corruption of the Christian Religion hath arisen from its own Professors ; which is the corruption of Christianity into Popery , and other Sects amongst us ( for what is best in it self , is worst when corrupted : ) and as the Christian Religion is the perfection of other Philosophies ; so these corruptions of Christianity have in them much of the very dregs of Judaism , and the worst imitation of Gentilism . And now how earnestly do the several Factions from Rome , and the whole gang of Sects among us , oppose our Church ? whose wise Moderation and excellent Constitution do place her amidst such extremes : Between the ( Ignes fatui ) pretenders to new lights on one hand , and the Boutfeaus , the male-contented Incendiaries on the other hand : Between both these we must be served as the Guests of Procrustes t t 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Plutarch . in Theseo . were in his famous Bed ; the Romanists think us too short and deficient in most of our measures , and therefore they would needs have us stretcht , ( if not upon the rack : ) the Sectaries count us redundant in many superfluities , and would fain have us cut precisely according to their Models : so their mutual testimony rightly applyed , may thus far be accepted ; that indeed we are guilty of neither extreme , but really do bear the Test to be in the golden Mean .

To this purpose , the Excellent Hammond begins his Preface to his View of the Directory : There is no surer evidence ( and 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) by which to discern the great excellency of Moderation in that Book ( of the Liturgy of the Church of England ) and so the apportionateness of it to the end to which it was designed ; than the experience of these so contrary fates which it hath constantly undergone betwixt the Persecutors on both extreme parts ; the Assertors of the Papacy on the one side , and the Consistory on the other ; The one accusing it of Schism , the other of compliance : The one of departure from the Church of Rome , the other of remaining with it ; Like the poor Greek Church , our Fellow Martyr , devoured by the Turk for too much Christian Profession , and damn'd by the Pope for too little : It being the dictate of natural reason in Aristotle , That the middle vertue is most infallibly known by this , that it is accused by either extreme as guilty of the other .

For as S. Greg. Nazianzen , in his third Oration of Peace u u 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , , saith : Whatsoever is peaceable and moderate doth suffer much of both the extremes ; and either is despised or resisted : of which sort , while we are now , who blame what is amiss ; we therefore are placed as in a seat of strife and envy , and no wonder if we are bruised in pieces between both . Neither is there any more certain Argument of the equal and just Constitution of the Church of England , than that the Factions among us are so ready to join with the Romanists in the very same accusations .

It follows now , that we give more particular instances of the real Moderation of the Church .

CHAP. IV. Of the Moderation of our Church in respect to her Rule of Faith .

§ . 1. In holding to her true and just measure , as is proved from her Articles and Canons , and other Monuments of the Church . § . 2. In her avoiding the extremes of those who take away from the due perfection of Holy Scripture , and of others who seem officiously to add thereunto . § . 3. In her judgment of the letter and sense of Scripture , and in the use of such consequences as are duly drawn from thence . § . 4. In reference to the Versions and Translations of Holy Scripture , several instances of Moderation in our Church . § . 5. In her Orders also for dispensing the Holy Scripture to all within her Communion . § . 6. In governing the reading of the Scripture ; and communing on the same . § . 7. In her judgment of the Canonical and Apocryphal Books . § . 8. The Divine Authority of the Holy Scripture , our Church rather doth take for granted , than prove too laboriously or uncertainly . § . 9. All immoderate extravagancies concerning interpretation of Holy Scripture , avoided by our Church .

§ . 1. WHereas Moderation hath its name ( and being ) from the equal measures observed by it : the first instance of the Moderation of our Church is most properly to be taken from the right rule and measure in Religion , which this Church of ours constantly receives and holds close to : by which she is safely preserved from all undue extremes ; having to her self the same rule and measure of her Moderation which the universal Church of Christ in all Ages hath had , such a rule as is beyond all exception , and is of undeniable Authority , namely the Holy Scriptures ; which are the same right and just measure by which she measures out to others , and desires to be measured by her self ; in whatever she receives and delivers out as matter of Faith and required practice , in the necessary parts of Religion , and the worship of God . Whereas ( next to the extreme of them who have no Religion nor no Rule ) the vanity and extravagance of those is very notorious , who set up themselves to be their own Rule ; which is done in the pretences of infallibility on one hand , and enthusiasm on the other : between that Rock and this Gulf ; the Moderation of our Church doth safely conduct its own judgment and practice , and all that follow her . In the Sixth Article of Religion , see how our Church doth own the perfection of Holy Scripture as a Rule . Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to Salvation ; so that whatsoever is not read therein , nor may be proved thereby , is not required of any man that it should be believed as an Article of Faith , or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation : and the reason why the Church of England doth require her self to be acknowledged of her own a a Canon 3. 1603. as a true and Apostolical Church , is because she teacheth and maintains the Doctrine of the Apostles ; and in the fourth Canon , the Church censures all Impugners of the worship of God , and whosoever shall affirm her Form containeth any thing in it repugnant to the Scriptures .

In the 36. Canon , Article 2. All who are to subscribe , are willingly ( and ex animo ) to affirm , That the Book of Common-Prayer , and of ordering Bishops , Priests , and Deacons , containeth in it nothing contrary to the word of God : and Article 3. That he acknowledgeth all and every of the 39. Articles to be agreeable to the word of God . In the 19th Article of Religion , The visible Church of Christ is defined ; a Congregation of faithful men , in the which the pure word of God is Preached , and the Sacraments be duly administred according to Christs Ordinance .

And in the ordering of Bishops and Priests , it is asked : Be you perswaded that the Holy Scriptures contain sufficiently all Doctrine required of necessity for eternal Salvation through Faith in Jesu Christ ? And are you determined with the said Scriptures to instruct the people committed to your Charge ; and to teach nothing ( as required of necessity to eternal Salvation ) but that you shall be perswaded may be concluded and proved by the Scriptures ? The Answer is , I am so perswaded , and have so determined by Gods grace .

In the 20th Article of Religion , it is declared , It is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing contrary to Gods word written ; neither to expound one place that it be repugnant to another . From all which passages ( and many more which might be repeated out of the Monuments of our Church ) it is evident , that as our Church is formed in her whole Constitution , with an uniform respect to this Rule ; and hath framed her Articles , Liturgy , Homilies , and Orders thereby ; so it doth require her self to be acknowledged in those , but in subordination to this Rule and measure as before , and superiour to it self : which doth manifest the exceptions of many of the Separation to be very unreasonable , who seem to give such deference to the Holy Scriptures , and at the same time renounce Communion with the Church of England ; which doth so religiously hold to the Sacred Scriptures ; of which our Church in union with the whole Church of God , is a sure Keeper , a faithful Witness , a zealous Defender , and a most sober Interpreter .

§ . 2. The Moderation of the Church of England further appears , in avoiding the extremes of those who take away from the true perfection of Scripture ; and of others , who seem officiously to add thereunto . Of the first sort of those who detract from the true perfection of Scripture , are they who frame an additional Canon of their own , as the Church of Rome doth ; who declares , that the Apocryphal Writings and Traditions of men , are nothing inferiour nor less Canonical , than the Sovereign dictates of God ; as well for the Confirmation of doctrinal points pertaining to Faith , as for ordering of Life and Manners ; and that both the one and the other ought to be embraced with the same affection of Piety , and received with the like religious Reverence b b Concil. Trid. Sess . 4. Decr. 1. , not making any difference between them : Thus ( as it is in the second part of the Homily of good works ) Christ reproved the Laws and Traditions of the Scribes and Pharisees , because they were set up so high , as though they had been equal with Gods Laws and above them : They worship Me in vain , that teach for Doctrines the Commandments of men : For you leave the Commandments of God to keep your own Traditions : Yet He meant not thereby to overthrow Mens Commandments ; for He Himself was obedient to the Princes and their Laws made for good order . On the other extreme , They of the Separation among us , are busy to attribute to the Holy Scriptures , such a perfection as God never intended them ; namely , particularly to determine of all actions of Mankind , and every matter of order and decency in Religion . Between these two , see by how even a thred our Church divides the controversy : first asserting the real perfection of Scriptures as a Rule to be as much as need to be , to be as great a perfection as God hath given it , in order to its end , namely to guide our belief and practice in things needful to Salvation : Article 20. Besides the same ( namely Gods word written ) ought not the Church to enforce any thing to be believed for necessity of salvation : and in the same Article : It is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing contrary to Gods word written : Yet the Article begins thus : The Church hath power to Decree Rites and Ceremonies , and hath Authority in controversies of Faith : Wherein , according to an accurate Moderation the Church doth behave itself , in attributing to the Holy Scriptures their just and full perfection .

On the other hand , our Church doth thankfully accept of that Christian Liberty which God hath left her , and indeed which he hath given all particular Christians according to their measures ; namely , leave to determine their particular actions according to the general Rule of Holy Scriptures , and sometimes of Prudence , where other Laws are not given to determine their Liberty .

And indeed this Article of the sufficiency of the Scriptures , and the use of them as a Rule , is the very dividing point , at which those of the Separation on either hand leave our Church and her Moderation at once : For those who are ready on one hand to receive all Traditions which the Church of Rome can offer , with affection and reverence equal to the written word of God ; so that ( as it is in our Homily c c Homily of good works , 3 d. Part. ) The Laws of Rome ( as they said ) were to be received of all men as the four Evangelists , No Moderation can contain the extravagancies such belief leads them to . On the other hand , to accept of no appointment for outward order and government in the Church or Kingdom , but what is set out in the express word of God for the direction of every particular action , under pretence of defending Christian Liberty , is verily so gross and unreasonable a Pharisaical confining it , that this principle is the first Sanctuary of ignorance , and disobedience in most of our Separatists ; who under an immoderate pretence to Religion , and the honour of Scriptures , really offer great abuse and disservice to both : as it is a real abuse to a person , though of honour , to give him Titles which do not belong to him ; so it is an occasion to Atheists and prophane persons , captiously to detract from the true perfection of Holy Writings , when they find attributed to them such Titles as are false and imaginary : We must take heed ( saith the judicious Hooker d d Eccles. Pol. l. 3. §. 8. ) lest in attributing to Scripture more than it can have , the incredibility of that do cause even those things which it hath most abundantly , to be less reverently esteemed .

On this foundation of our Churches Moderation in what she judgeth concerning the perfection of Holy Scripture ; both the Protestant and the Christian Religion is established : For as Bishop Sanderson saith e e Pref. to his Sermons . , The main Article of the Protestant Religion is , The Holy Scriptures are a perfect Rule of Faith and manners : so the very mystery of Puritanism is , That no man may with a safe Conscience do any thing for which there may not be produced either command or example in Scripture .

§ . 3. We are to note the Moderation of the Church in her judgment of the letter and sense of Holy Scripture : and in the use of such consequences as are duly drawn from thence .

Whereas the Romanists 1. look on the letter of Holy Scripture , but as so many dead and unsensed Characters f f Richworth's Dialogues . J. S. Sure-footing . , of variable and uncertain signification g g Ni● . Cus●nus Card. Ep. 7. ad ●●hem . . 2. They make the sense of Scripture entirely depend on the Authority of their Church h h V. Concil. Trid. Sess . 4. Decret. de usu S. Scr. . 3. They presume the Church of Rome only can make authentick all the Books of Holy Scripture i i Nullum Capitulum nullusque liber Canonicus habetur absque illius authoritate . Greg. 7. Dict. 16. in Concil. Rom. : and by her sole Authority is to determine which are to be Canonical . 4. They will not allow the clear consequences of Scripture to prove any matter of doctrine k k V. Discourse upon a Conference , Apr. 3. 1676. .

In these ( as in many other instances ) our Sectaries generally agree with the Romanists : 1. They also make the Holy Scripture a dead Letter without their interpretation . 2. In making the sense which they vouch , to be the Word of God . 3. Such Scriptures as seem to serve their turn they allow , others they reject . 4. The clear consequences from Holy Scriptures against them , they cast by , as only the results of carnal reason .

Between these two opposers of Holy Scripture , at present there appears this difference : instead of an external infallible Interpreter on one side , the other sets up the witness of their own private spirit for an infallible interpreter also .

When time serves , They that make the difference , can compromise it .

Amidst these extremes , observe we the Wisdom and Moderation of the Church of England .

1. It gives all due honour to the Letter of Holy Writ , referring her self and her Sons chiefly to the Originals l l V. B. of Homilies , passim . Caeterùm in lectione D. Scripturarum si quae occurrerint ambigua vel obscura in V. Test . earum interpretatio ex fonte Hebraicae veritatis petatur : in N. autem Graeci codices consulantur . Reform . Leg. Eccles. de fide Cathol. c. 12. ; using all care in keeping the Letter of Holy Scripture : and preserving the Originals , and setting them forth correctly , and translating them as faithfully as may be .

2. The sense of Scripture , our Church accounteth chiefly as Scripture , viz. The Word of God therein : The mind of God being thought by our Church to consist not in words but in sense . For is the Kingdom of God , words , and syllables m m Translators of the Bible , Pres . ?

3. The clear consequences in Scripture are in our Church accounted a good proof in matters of doubtful Doctrine .

Whatsoever is not read therein , nor proved thereby , is not to be required , saith our sixth Article . Wherefore Mr Chillingworth n n Chillingworth 's Pref. § 28. did not without reason thus declare . I profess sincerely , I believe all those Books of Scripture which the Church of England accounts Canonical , to be the infallible word of God : I believe all things evidently contained in them , or even probably deducible from them o o Simpliciter necessaria Rex appellat quae vel expressè Verbum Dei praecipit — vel ex verbo Dei necessaria Consequentiâ vetus Ecclesia elicuit . Rex Jacobus ad Card. Perr . .

§ . 4. In our Church no one Version nor more are made equal , much less superiour to the original : Nothing is declared authentick but what is judged truly and originally so . Although the Church of Rome hath declared the vulgar Translation to be only the authentick Scripture p p Conc. Trid. Sess . 4. Decr. 2. , according to which , all points in Question are to be decided : and though the same in our Church hath been convinced by sundry learned men of some imperfections ; yet wherein it is most faithfully performed ; the innovations of Popery , even from thence , may be sufficiently manifested .

Other ancient Versions and Translations , which have been of Holy Scripture , our Church is so far from rejecting or undervaluing , that it hath made great use of them , and doth constantly acknowledge their usefulness : and doth esteem them according to their antiquity and the approbation they have had in the Church of God . Yea , in the worst of our late times , when the true Church of England was most of all accused of Popery and opposition to the Scriptures , then were sundry learned and religious Sons of the Church , diligently employed in defending and illustrating the Holy Scriptures , in the admirable Edition of their Originals , and their most famous and approved Versions . Although our Sacred Polyglot Bible hath no more escaped its Prohibition at Rome q q Indice librorum probibitorum Alexandri 7. Pontif. Max. jussu edito . Biblia Briani Waltoni Angli cui Titulus , &c. , than it did the feeble assaults of some others here at home .

2. Whereas the Church of Rome will not allow Translations ordinarily to be made into the vulgar tongue r r Prohibentur Biblia linguà vulgari , &c. Monition . general . Reg. 5. cum Indic● libr. prohib . Alex. 7. P. V. Concil. Trid. Sess. 22. Can. 9. , unless in a particular policy to serve some extraordinary occasion : as when the Doway Translation was admitted ( as they tell us ) because of the importunity of Hereticks : And when such Translations are unwillingly made , they are not suffer'd without particular Licence s s Non sine jac●ltate in scriptis habita . Reg. In l. Concil. T●id . : obtained under the hand of the Bishop or Inquisitor , by the advice of the Confessor : which some call a Prudential dispensing of Scripture t t V. Pref. to the Doway Bible . : Yea such Faculties of licensing sometimes in shew of Moderation , are granted to the Bishops ( as was done by Pope Pius IV. ) but soon after they are recalled again very strictly : which was performed by P. Clement VIII . and also by P. Paul . V. in a very smart Breve , dated 1612. u u The Translators of the Engl. Bibl. to the Reader . So much are they afraid of the light of the Scripture , that they will not trust the people with it , no not as it is set forth by their own sworn men ; no not with the licence of their own Bishops and Inquisitors .

The Church of England from time to time hath taken a just care to have the holy Originals rendred into the common Language , that all Gods people may be enriched more and more in the knowledg of God ; as Epiphanius tells us , the ancient Church had its ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Interpreters of the Divine Books : and therefore the Translation of the Holy Bible in English hath by the Command of Authority had its several reviews , and its Translation also into the Welch or British Language , hath been ordered in the fifth year of Queen Elizabeth .

3. Whereas in the Translation of the Holy Bible , many have attemper'd their Versions to their own private and particular sentiments , as is notoriously done in the English Translations at Doway , and Rhemes : and as Grotius x x Inter multa quae fidei nocent hoc non est minimum , quod versionem quisque attemperat ad suas sententias , & sua cuique Deus fit dira cupido : hoc vero non est Idola sacere ? imò semet collocare in templo Dei . Gro. Animadv . ad Artic. 32. hath charged Beza , and Piscator , and others , for inclining their Translations somewhat to their particular suppositions and opinions ; and as King James ( at the Conference at Hampton-Court ) noted the same of the Geneva Version : The Moderation of the Church of England hath been such ( even beyond the care of all kind of Elective Philosophers ) that she appears sincerely to have espoused the Truth it self , without any Dowry y y Veritas sine Dote . Herbert de Verit. of interest and affection to opinions . The more gross was the calumny of Gregory Martin to our Translators of the Bible . It is evident , you regard neither Hebrew nor Greek , but only your Heresy . Whereas our Church hath followed no particular Versions , but wisely consulted the others then extant , which could come to the Translators hands ( as they themselves testify and enumerate in the Preface to the Bishops Bible ) the better to enable them to attain the true sense of the Original : Not making a second hand Translation , such as the Rhemish , which was but a Translation of the vulgar ; yet avoiding ( also ) as the Translators of our Bible themselves profess , On one side the scrupulosity of the Puritans , who leave the old Ecclesiastical words , and be take themselves to other , as when they put washing for baptism , and Congregation instead of Church : as also on the other side , we have shunned the obscurity of the Papists , in their azymes , tunike , holocausts , prepuce , and a number of such like ; yet such is the further modesty and Moderation of our Church ; it doth not assume to her self to have perfected or made absolute her labour herein , but owns it such as may be made more consummate upon further light and experience .

§ . 5. Between the extremes of those who on one hand keep the Holy Scriptures from the vulgar , as doth the Church of Rome : and on the other hand , those who account the Scriptures fit only for the vulgar ( as many of our Sectaries who think themselves already so perfect as to be above consulting the word of God ( as they call it ) without them : )

The Church of England according to an excellent Moderation , commends unto all of her Communion , even to the vulgar , a diligent hearing and reading the Holy Scriptures z z K. Edw. 6. Inj. 1547. Q. Eliz. Inj. 1559. : as appears in sundry places of the Homilies , more particularly in the first Homily , which is , a fruitful exhortation to the reading and knowing of Holy Scripture . That man ( saith the Homily a a Homily 1. ) is ashamed to be called a Lawyer , Astronomer , Physician , Philosopher , that is ignorant in the Books of Law , Astronomy , Physick , Philosophy ; and how can any man then say , that he professeth Christ and his Religion , if he will not apply himself to read , hear , and know the Books of Christian Doctrine b b The Collect for the second Sunday in Advent . Inter Libros prohibitos non habet Ecclesia Anglicana Libros sacros & à Deo profectos . Rex Jacobus . c c Severi Homines centum circiter Bibliorum editiones prohibent & proscribunt . Bened. Turretinus 1619. . And though the people by daily hearing of Holy Scripture read in the Church , should continually more and more encrease in Christian Knowledge ; yet it is intended and required , that especially , the Clergy and Gods Ministers in the Congregation , should by often reading and meditating on Gods word , be stirred up to Godliness themselves , and be more able to exhort others , and confute the Adversaries of the Truth : as we observe from the Preface concerning the service of the Church : and at the beginning of the second part of the Homilies , there is a particular Admonition to all Ministers Ecclesiastical , That they above all others do aptly , plainly , and distinctly , read the Holy Scriptures .

§ . 6. For the governing our reading of Holy Scriptures : whereas before the Reformation , the Godly and decent order of the ancient Fathers was broken d d Pres . of the service of the Church . and neglected by planting in uncertain stories and legends ; so that many Books of the Bible were but begun and never read through : Now the order e e Preface concerning the Service of the Church . for Prayer and for reading the holy Scripture , is made agreeable to the mind and purpose of the old Fathers , and a great deal more profitable and commodious .

It is more profitable because there are left out many things , whereof some are untrue , some uncertain , some vain and superstitious , and nothing is ordained to be read , but the very pure word of God , the holy Scriptures , or that which is agreeable to the same ; and that in such a language and order as is most easy and plain for the understanding , both of the Readers and the hearers .

It is also more commodious both for the shortness thereof , and for the plainness of the order , and that the rules be few and easy .

Since the Reformation , those who love not to be contain'd in any good bounds , when they read the Bible , chuse to do it out of all Canonical Order , or generally snap upon the Chapters fortuitously ; or affect for their most common reading the most difficult Books and Chapters : The wisdom of our Church hath provided , that the Old Testament may be read out every Year once : f f Tale aliquid audio esse nunc in Ecclesiâ Anglicanâ in quâ Psalterium singulis mensibus al solvitur , & totum utrumque Testamentum unico anno continuatâ lectione percurritur . Vtinam reliquae Ecclesiae reformatae , &c. Spala●ensis l. 7. c. 12. All the Psalms once every Month : and the New Testament thrice every Year g g V. The Order how the Holy Scripture is appointed to be read . : Yet with this Moderation , some difficult and very mysterious places are excepted : Yet so that the Church declares : Though the rehearsal of the Genealogies and Pedigrees of the Fathers , be not so much to the edification of the plain ignorant people : Yet there is nothing so impertinently uttered in all the whole Book of the Bible , but may serve to spiritual purpose in some respect , to all such as will bestow their labours to search out the meaning h h Homily of certain places of Scripture , 2d Part. .

Thus manifest is it , that our Church doth really intend edification in her Institutions : and can the wit of man i i B. Jer. Taylor Pref. to his Collection of Offices . conceive a better temper and expedient , than this of the Church of England ; that such Scriptures only and principally should be laid before them , in daily Offices which contain in them all the mysteries of our Redemption , and all the Rules of good Life ? That the people of the Church may not complain that the Fountains of our Salvation are stopt from them ; nor the Rulers of the Church , that the mysteriousness of Scripture is abused .

And further to prevent the inconvenience of the vulgars use of Scripture : there was a wholsome Injunction of Queen Elizabeth k k 1559 ▪ §. 37. , fit here to be mentioned : That no man should talk or reason of Holy Scripture rashly or contentiously , nor maintain any false doctrine or errour , but shall commune on the same when occasion is given , reverently , humbly , and in the fear of God , for his comfort and better understanding .

For as it is in the Homily against contention . Too many there be which upon Ale-benches , and other places , delight to set forth certain Questions , not so much pertaining to edification as to Vain-glory : whence they fall to chiding and contention .

With reference to which Injunction , it was , that some Bishops in their Articles of enquiry , had this for a Question , Whether any were known in their Diocese , who profaned the Holy Scripture in Table-talk : which was captiously misunderstood by many in their intemperate heats against the Bishops ; as if they thereby did forbid all sober Conference on any places of Holy Scripture : whereas the Injunction of the Queen ( which ought still to have effect ) should reasonably interpret their enquiry ; which certainly was the ground thereof .

Besides , many of those Bishops themselves , when Masters of Colledges in the Universities , observed , and caused to be observed , those Statutes which in most Colledges require reading of Scripture at Meals ; Ordering , that Communication which is thereon , to be such , as in the Queens Injunction was before-mentioned .

§ . 7. Our Church according to great wisdom hath received such Books as Canonical , of whose authority there was never any doubt in the Church l l 39. Article 6. Scio tamen Vualdensem tenere quod declarandi & approbandi Libros sacros sit in serie Patrum omnium & fidelium ab Apostolis succedentium . Fr. S. Clara. ad Artic. Confess . Angl. 6. : rejecting what truly are not of the Canon , which the Church of Rome thrusts in of its own head ; and doth not leave out any which are , as many have done in other times and places : In relation to those Books whose Title is the Apocrypha , the Moderation of our Church expresseth an excellent temper . 1. In that in their Title , as of uncertain Writings , they are distinguisht from Canonical . 2. All the Apocryphal Books are not recommended to be read in the Church . 3. Nor on all days , particularly not on the Lords Day , ( as such . ) 4. Those our Church doth use ( together with other Canonical Scripture , as it plainly and publickly declares , in her sixth Article of Religion , and as St Hierom saith m m S. Hier. Pres . ad ●ild . V. E●●phan . c. 〈◊〉 . ) for example of life , and instruction of manners ( as Clemens Romanus to the Corinthians , and other such Writings were read in the ancient Church n n Sunt & alii libri qui leguntur quidem sed nonscribuntur in Canone . H. de S. Vic. Cap. 6. de scripturis , &c. : ) but doth not apply them to establish any Doctrine : as if they had such authority alone by themselves .

Our Church indeed doth prefer them before any other Ecclesiastical or private Writings , because of the many excellent and sacred instructions in them : for which good and religious use , which may be made of them by all ; we do them the honour to bind them up with our Bibles , though we make them not of equal authority thereby , or of divine inspiration , ( as we do not also either the English Meeter of the Psalms , or the Epistle of the Translators of the Bible . )

§ . 8. The Divine Authority of the Holy Scriptures , our Church according to great wisdom doth rather take for granted than labour much to prove such an undoubted principle of Religion ; justly supposing there is no reason either to question , that the Church hath surely received those Divine Oracles , or surely delivered them : and therefore our sixth Article speaks of them as of whose authority there was never any doubt in the Church : Our Church ( justly thus supposing ) immediately therefore applies her self in an Exhortation to a diligent reading the Holy Scriptures ( Homily 1. ) and so long as those of her Communion are by any just means convinced of their authority , our Church according to a great Moderation leaves it to the Providence of God by what particular arguments ( of the many which lie before us ) we may come to this satisfaction : Not causing the satisfaction of any to depend upon one sort of means to the neglect of another : Because there are so many Arguments which may sufficiently satisfy any of their Authority ; because some are convinced by some , others by others . We are encouraged in our Church to receive the Holy Scriptures as the word of God , both from inward and outward motives ; both of divine and moral consideration : But for our greater certainty and safety in a matter of so great concern ; our Church doth not lay the weight of so great a cause , on slight or uncertain Foundations ; as the infallibility of the Church ( much less demonstration from the evidence of oral tradition ) or the testimony only of the Divine Spirit , held by some so absolutely necessary to convince every one of the Divine Authority of Scriptures , that without such an inward testimony there can be no kind of certainty whatsoever . The Moderation of our Church excellently governs her judgment herein ; neither refusing the just Authority of Gods true Church , nor denying any necessary influence of the Holy Spirit of God : according to which Moderation , guiding our selves , we shall have occasion elsewhere to justify the real certainty of our Faith , ch. 6. §. 8.

In convincing also those of the Authority of Holy Scripture , who do deny the same ; the wisdom and temper of our Church prudently hath omitted a twofold medium , as improper to confute obstinate Adversaries : The one is , of proving the Divine Authority of the Scriptures by Scriptures themselves ; which though it be a sufficient proof among them who have received them as divine , yet to others it can never stop the objection from returning infinitely , if the objector please to be dissatisfied : The other method is , alledging the Testimony of the Spirit ; for though the Church of God hath the Holy Spirit , yet those that dispute this point may not have the Spirit ; neither can any ones saying so , be a proper Argument to convince another : Thirdly , Our Church avoids the Circle of proving the Scripture by the Church , and the Church by the Scriptures again , because our Church doth first acknowledge the Holy Scriptures as superiour to it self o o Article 6. & 20. , as one of the first principles of its Doctrine , and against those who deny that principle of the Holy Scriptures veracity , it doth dispute no otherwise than by reasons convincing the certainty of Tradition . But as Archbishop Laud ( in his Preface against Fisher ) takes notice , While one Faction cries up the Church above the Scripture , and the other the Scripture to the neglect of the Church : According to Christs Institution , the Scripture where it is plain should guide the Church ; and the Church where there is doubt should expound the Scripture .

§ . 9. Whereas many run into very immoderate extravagancies concerning the interpretation of Holy Scripture ; our Church contains it self within very wise and just proportions in its judgment and practice concerning this matter .

1. Concerning Holy Scripture , it doth own what the Ancient Fathers p p S. Chrys. Hom. 3. in ● Thess. S. Aug. in Ps . 8. V. Second Part of the Homily of the knowledge of H. Scrip. have testified , That what is absolutely necessary unto Salvation of all , either for knowledge or practice , is so fair and intelligible and plain to be understood of any , that there needs no interpreter of the meaning of the sense to them who understand the words .

2. For the understanding other places in Holy Scripture which are more obscure ; our Church doth suppose and acknowledge plentiful means allowed of God , both to the Church , and by and in the Church to all particular persons , as much as is necessary , that such places be understood : For those which are mysterious and intricate , are for the curious and wise to enquire into : They are not the repositories of Salvation , but instances of labour , and occasions of humility , and arguments of mutual forbearance , and an endearment of reverence and adoration : [ as the Archbishop of Spalato , and our Bishop Taylor use to speak . ]

Such means for the interpretation of Scripture are the ordinary assistances of the Holy Spirit of God : The instructions of the Church , the use of our Reason ; especially in comparing one Scripture with another : which excellent means of finding out the sense of Holy Writ , our Church her self doth often use , and recommends the same to those of her Communion , according to the ancient practice of the Church : Yet if we speak properly , we do not call the Scripture the interpreter of it self ; nor properly a Judge of matter of Faith q q S. Scripturam Judicem qui sentiunt , rectè sentiunt , sed siguratè ●oquuntur . Gro. de Imp●rio sum . pot . . Though it be the Rule according to which the judgment which is of Doctrines is made : and in Analogy with which Interpretations of Scripture also are to be govern'd . But because of the danger of the vulgars being misled , our Church doth send them frequently to their Pastors and Ministers , for publick instruction , and private advice and counsel : and inferiour Ministers it refers to their Bishop r r Exhortation to the Holy Communion . Canon 53. .

The same method our Church directs for resolution of doubts which may arise referring to the Liturgy .

Preface concerning the Service of the Church . Forasmuch as nothing can be so plainly set forth but doubts may arise in the use and practice of the same ; to appease all such diversity ( if any arise ) and for the resolution of all doubts concerning the manner how to understand , do , and execute the things contained in this Book ; the parties that so doubt shall alway resort to the Bishop of the Diocess , who by his discretion shall take order for the quieting and appeasing of the same . And if the Bishop be in doubt , he may send for the resolution thereof to the Archbishop .

3. Our Church doth not attribute more or less authority to the means of interpreting Scripture , or any part thereof , than God hath given it for that purpose : and here the Moderation of the Church might be illustrated from the manifold extravagancies others have run into , in this matter , on all sides .

1. Some make the Holy Spirit of God the only immediate interpreter of Scripture ( unto all persons whatsoever , that at any time understand any thing thereof . ) Others run into another extreme of slighting the illumination and assistance of the Holy Spirit . 2. Some assert the Church ( of Rome only ) to have an infallible and absolute Authority herein : others deny both the Church Universal , and all parts thereof , all authority to teach those under her Discipline , or interpret any Scripture to them . 3. Some have maintained , that the publick Magistrate is the only interpreter of Scripture : others deny him any kind of authority over or about the Church . 4. There are those who make humane reason the only interpreter of Scripture : Others reject all use of reason in divine matters . Among these and many more extravagancies of men , The Moderation of our Church keeps on one hand from the Tyranny of those who make such Authorities the Rule of interpreting Scripture , which never were so appointed : And on the other from the wild inordinacy of them who make their own private principle ( whatsoever it be ) the rule of Scripture interpretation . Among all , wisely making use of , and asserting and recommending such means as are given for the conveyance , or interpretation ( or both for the conveying and interpreting ) of Divine Writ . Something further of which will more distinctly appear in the next Chapter .

CHAP. V. Of the Moderation of the Church in applying the Rule of Faith to it self .

§ . 1. Avoiding extremes on either hand , in relation to the authority of the Vniversal Church . § . 2. The Decrees of Councils . § . 3. The Testimony of the Fathers . § . 4. Other Traditions . § . 5. Our Churches own Testimony . § . 6. The use of Reason . § . 7. The Testimony of the Spirit . § . 8. Of the testimony and operation of the Holy Spirit ; the judgment of our Church according to great Moderation , more largely declared .

§ . 1. THE Moderation of the Church of England appears very great in her due applying this Rule of Faith to her self : wisely and fitly making use of all those Instruments which are most proper and useful in conveying to us that Rule , or which are most subservient to the right understanding our Rule , avoiding either extreme of those who attribute too much or too little to those instruments of conveyance and interpretation : Such as the Authority of the Universal Church : The Decrees of Councils : The Testimony of the Fathers : Other Traditions : The Witness of our own particular Church : Right Reason alone : The Testimony of the Spirit .

To all and every of these enumerated instruments ; either of certain conveyance , or interpretation of Scripture ; our Church gives their due place and esteem , according to their influence and use , and no more : which must needs demonstrate a great deal of Wisdom and Moderation in the judgment of the Church .

1. The Universal Church it self is no where by the Church of England made the Rule of her Faith , but a Witness and Keeper of Holy Writ : Art . 20. Yet the judgment of the Catholick Church of Christ , was always by the Church of England held in greatest veneration next unto the testimony of the Spirit of God himself ; because of those famous Promises made by Christ himself to the Church , which we read of in the New Testament : Yea , in the Old Testament , The Prophecies concerning the Messias , and concerning the Church , and the Ministers of the Church , always are join'd together , as I have sometime heard a great Prelate of our Church teach us : And because whatever Arguments we have for the truth of Holy Scriptures ( as thanks be to God we have many beside ) yet also from the witness and keeping of the Church a a Ecclesia non discernit sed ni●a traditioni legitimae testatur quae sint Canonicae Scripturae . Spalatens . l. 7. ch. 1. we receive the Holy Scriptures themselves : and in the sixth Article , In the name of Holy Scriptures , the Church doth understand those Canonical Books of the Old and New Testament , of whose Authority there was never any doubt in the Church . So that as the Archbishop of Spalato hath it , we have recourse to the Church , not as to an Authoritative Judge , but as to a Treasure and Repository b b Haec sunt quae Patres intra Canonem concluserunt : Haec nobis à Patribus tradita . S. Hieron . Ruffinus . in which the Canonical Books , and all things necessary to Salvation , are preserved by faithful Tradition . Wherefore the Catholick Church it self is called not a Judge nor a Rule c c Credo Ecclisiam : credo Ecclesiae : per E●clesiam . Non di●imus credo in Ecclesiam , ●●t credo in Ecclesi● . Ep-Es●en● . , but more truly a Witness and Keeper of Holy Writ : and for interpretation of Scripture , and for our help in judging of Doctrines according to our Rule , the Church of England values above all others the Judgment of the Catholick Church , so far forth as we can attain the testimony of the Catholick Church , by such instruments as are approved and undoubted . For though d d Second Di●●native against Popery , l. 1. ● . 1. , If by Catholick you mean all particular Churches in the World ; then though truth doth infallibly dwell amongst them , yet you can never go to School to them all to learn it , in such questions as are curious and unnecessary , and by which the Salvation of Souls is not promoted : Yet we know , that in the Primitive Time the Christian Church was in a less compass , and more undivided . Wherefore if such matters which are most essential to the being and well-being of the Church , are both delivered from that time , and with their conveyance have been approved by the Church in common ever since : If the Church may be a sure instrument of conveyance of the Books of Holy Scripture , why not also of such matters wherein all so well agree from the first , and do in no sort thwart the Tradition of the Holy Scripture it self ? Wherefore in the Canon set forth in our Church , with the Articles of Religion , 1571. it is caution'd , That nothing be at any time taught , either to be held or believed upon the account of Religion , but what is agreeable to the Doctrine of the Old and New Testament ; which the Catholick Fathers and antient Bishops have gathered from thence : Which Golden Rule of our Church , I find twice extoll'd by the Illustrious Grotius : once e e De imp. sum . potesta . c. 6. §. 9. p. 181. in these words : I cannot but commend that famous Canon of the Church of England , That &c. And again , in one of his Epistles f f Apologi● Eccl. Anglicanae . Accessimus verò ad illam Ecclesiam in quâ — omnia castè & reverenter & quantum nos assequ● pot●imus proximè ad priscorum temporum rationem . §. 118. Inde enim putavimus restaurationem petend●m esse unde prima Religionis initia ducta essent . §. 150. , He takes occasion from this Canon of the Church to say , He wonders any should deny , In England they attribute more to the ancient Church than they do in France . The form also of profession in the admission of Professors in Divinity in the University , because it doth very fully express the sense of the Church of England , I repeat the tenour thereof .

I from my heart do embrace and receive all the Holy Canonical Scripture , in the Old and New Testament comprehended : and all those things which the true Church of Christ , Holy and Apostolick , subject to the word of God , and governed by the same , doth reject ; I reject ; whatsoever it holds , I hold —

Concerning the Church of England , in this matter , hear we what the Learned Casaubon hath declared in an Epistle to Heinsius g g Ep. Ecclesiasticae , p. 345. : This ( saith he ) is my judgment , Whereas there will and can be but one true Church ; we are not hastily to recede from those Doctrines of Faith which the consent of all the ancient Catholick Church hath approved ; and whereas I own no other Foundation of true Religion , than the Holy and Divine inspired Scriptures , with Melancthon , and the Church of England , I wish all Doctrines of Faith were brought to us , derived from the Fountain of Scripture , by the Channels of Antiquity ; otherwise , what end will there be of innovation ? And thus our King James of Happy Memory did declare ( in the words of St Austin ) That what could be proved the Church held and observed from its first beginning to those Times ; That to reject He did not doubt to pronounce to be an insolent piece of madness : So that the counsel and judgment of the Church of England seems to be moderated according to the Sentence of St Hierom , in his Epistle to Minerva : My purpose is , to read the Ancients , to prove all , to hold fast what is good , and never to depart from the Faith of the Catholick Church : and conformably King Charles I. h h His Majesties fifth Paper to Mr. Henders . My Conclusion is , That albeit I never esteemed any Authority equal to the Scriptures , yet I do think the unanimous consent of the Fathers , and the universal practice of the Primitive Church , to be the best and most authentical Interpreters of Gods word . For who can be presumed to understand the Doctrine and practice of the Christian Religion better than those who lived in the first and purest times ? Wherefore i i Of Heresy , §. 14. Dr Hammond reckons it among the piè Credibilia , that a truly general Council cannot erre .

§ . 3. And because the Catholick Church is , and hath been so much divided , and the Monuments of the ancient Church Universally accepted , do contain but a few determinations , Therefore the Church of England moderately remits her Sons to the first four general Councils ; as in the 28th year of K. Henry 8. k k Fullers Eccl. Hist ; ad An. 1536. it was Decreed , That all ought and must utterly refuse and condemn all those opinions contrary to the said Articles , contained in the three Creeds , contained in the four Holy Councils , that is to say , in the Council of Nice , Constantinople , Ephesus , and Chalcedon ; and all other since that time in any point consonant to the same .

So in the Institution of a Christian Man , set forth 1537. and approved by the Convocation , 1543. 't is there said , A true Christian man ought and must condemn all those opinions contrary to the twelve Articles of the Creed , which were of a long time past condemned in the four Holy Councils ; that is to say , &c.

Isaac Casaubon also in the name of King James to Cardinal Perron , saith , l l Primo R. Eliz. c. 1 The King and the Church of England do admit the four first Oecumenical Councils ; and following the judgment of the Church , the Law of the Kingdom doth declare , m m Dicimus Ecclesiam Britannicam adeò venerari Concilia generalia , ut speciali statuto caverit , nè quisquam spirituali jurisdictione praeditus praesumat censuras suas Ecclesiasticas aliter distringere vel administrare , aut quicquam Haereticum pronunciare quod non à scripturis Canonicis & quatuor Conciliis generalibus aut alio quocunque Concilio pro tali judicatum fuerit . J. B. de antiq. libertate Eccl. Brit. Thes. 4. That none however Commission'd , shall in any wise have authority or power , to order or determine , or adjudge any matter or cause to be Heresy , but only such as heretofore have been determin'd , ordered , or adjudged to be Heresy , by the authority of the Canonical Scriptures , or by the first four general Councils , or any of them , or by any other general Council , wherein the same was declared Heresy , by the express and plain words of the said Canonical Scriptures , or such as hereafter shall be ordered , judged , or determined to be Heresy by the Court of Parliament of this Realm , with the Clergy in their Convocation . Thus the authority of the four first general Councils , are placed by our Church in the superiour order of Tradition ; forasmuch as Spalatensis ( according to St Austin n n A plenariis Conciliis tradita : Quarum est in Ecclesiâ salubr●●ima authoritas . S. Aug. Ep. 118. ) speaks of such Councils , they have obtained a wholsom authority , because from the Apostolick Declarations faithfully received , they have explained the Holy Scriptures : and beside , because they have been approved by the Universal Church : which with great reason contradicts what Curcellaeus p p Curcell . Rel. Christianae Instit. l. 1. c. 15. hath delivered to depreciate the honour , even of the first four Oecumenical Councils . So that Mr Cressy , in Answer to Dr Pierce , might very well cite the Protestant acknowledgments of the Authority of Councils : as that of Ridley ( Acts and Mon. p. 1288. ) Councils indeed represent the Vniversal Church , and being so gathered together in the name of Christ , they have the promise of the gift and guiding of the Spirit into all truth : To the same purpose are named Bishop Bilson , Hooker , Potter , &c. Instead of all these , he might have owned , if he had pleased , the judgment of our Church it self , giving all due honour to general and Provincial Councils , whose wholsome Decrees she hath accepted and imitated : Yea , our Church maintains the right of Provincial Synods , taken away by the See of Rome q q Tertullianus veneratur Provinciale Concilium quasi esset Oecumenicam , assentiente sc. universali , vel iis decernentibus secundùm universale , quomodo fit repraesentatio totius nominis Christiani , & virtualiter tota Ecclesia . . Neither is this honour diminisht by the further Moderation which our Church hath shown , in not taking those for Councils , or general Councils , which are not such , as neither the Council of Florence , nor Lateran , nor of Trent : and we know that our Articles , though they are very moderately framed , are many of them directly oppos'd to those of Trent , being in those points of Doctrine wherein the Church of Rome hath departed from the Catholick Church , and made her Doctrines of design more than truth , the unjust conditions of Communion . A truly free , and general Council , we look upon as the best expedient on Earth for composing the differences of the Christian World , if it might be had ; but we cannot endure to be abused by meer names of Titular Patriarchs , but real Servants and Pensioners of the Popes , with Combinations of interested parties , instead of general Councils r r Dr. Stillingfleet's first Part of an Answer , &c. 284. . When Pope Paul III. call'd a Council ( then ) to be held at Mantua , and King Henry VIII . refusing thither to send , He defended his Protestation in a Letter to the Emperour and other Christian Princes ( 1538. ) In which the King declares t t Acts and Monuments , p. 11●2 . :

Truly as our Forefathers invented nothing more holy than general Councils , used as they ought to be ; so there is almost nothing that may do more hurt to the Christian Faith and Religion , than general Councils , if they be abused to lucre , to gains , to the establishment of errors : And verily , we suppose that it ought not to be called a General Council , where alone those men are heard which are determined for ever in all points to defend the Popish party , and to arm themselves to fight in the Bishop of Romes quarrel , though it were against God and the Holy Scriptures : It is no general Council , neither ought it to be called general , where the same men be only Advocates and Adversaries : defending his Primacy , born by the ignorance of the World , nourished by the ambition of the Bishops of Rome , defended by places of Scripture falsly understood .

Neither secondly , is our Churches honour to general Councils lessened , because she declares , they are not infallible , as in our 21. Article of Religion . When they be gathered together , Forasmuch as they be an Assembly of Men , whereof all be not governed with the spirit and word of God , they may erre and sometime have erred even in things pertaining to God ; wherefore things ordained by them as necessary to Salvation , have neither strength nor authority unless it be declared , that they be taken out of Holy Scripture t t Itaque legantur Concilia quidem Cum honore , sed interim ad scripturam piam , certam rectamque regulam examinentur . Reform . leg . Eccl. c. 14. . Notwithstanding they are not infallible , yet for the establishing consent , King James may be presumed to declare the sense of our Church , of the use of such Councils lawfully assembled : Come ( saith He u u Rex Jacobus ad Card. Perr . ) put it to the Issue , allow a free general Council , which may not depend upon the arbitrary will of one man , and the Church of England is prepared to give a Reason of its Faith : For even anciently it was a great complaint in the Church , as the Fond of all their mischiefs x x Nilus Archiep . Thes●al . l. 1. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . , That Controversies were not determined after the Primitive Rite and manner .

§ . 3. Concerning the Testimony of the Fathers , the Church of England hath observed the same wise Moderation in her judgment , and use of them also ; no where judging of them as unliable to error : according to the arguing of the 21. Article . Because they are but men , and sometimes have erred in things pertaining to God , neither hath our Church any where swallowed their errors through the Veneration of their Piety and Antiquity .

Yet because of their Proximity to the Apostolick times , and the just authority in the Church , which for their Learning and Piety they have obtained , and all along hath been given them , Our Church in her Monuments , gives a great deference to their judgment , testimony , and practice .

In the 31. Canon . Forasmuch as the ancient Fathers of the Church , led by the example of the Apostles , appointed , &c. We following their Holy and Religious Example , do Constitute and Decree . Canon 32. According to the judgment of the ancient Fathers , and the practice of the Primitive Church , We do Ordain . Canon 33. It hath been long since provided by many Decrees of ancient Fathers : That , &c. According to which Examples , we do Ordain . Canon 60. Forasmnch as it hath been a solemn , ancient , and laudable Custom in the Church of God , continued from the Apostles time , That , &c. We will and appoint .

So in the 30. Canon : The lawful use of the Cross in Baptism , is explained from the practice of the Primitive Times . And in King Edw. VI. Proclamation before the Common Prayer Book , the reason for our Forms and Rites , is justified from the practice of the Primitive Church , and in the Preface concerning the Service of the Church , Here you have an Order for Prayer and reading the Holy Scripture , much agreeable to the mind and purpose of the old Fathers : and in many other places where they are named , and where they are not named . The footsteps of their ancient Piety , have very discernable impressions throughout the whole Constitution of our Church .

Wherefore as it is in the Reformation of the Ecclesiastical Laws of England , as was intended y y Reform . leg . Eccles. Angl. c. 15. : Let the Authority and Reverence be continued to the Ancient and Orthodox Fathers , but such as may be subject to the determination , truth , and authority of the Holy Scriptures . For always the ancient Fathers z z Neque enim quorumlibet disputationes quamvis Catholicorum & laudatorum hominum velut seripturas Canonicas habere debemus , ut nobis non liceat ( salvâ Honorificentiâ quae illis debetur hominibus ) aliquid in eorum seriptis improbare — Talis ego sum in scriptis aliorum , Tales volo esse intellectores meorum . S. Aug. Ep. 3. V. Ep. 19. ad S. Hier. Chilingw . Pref. §. 25. themselves refused any other kind of honour or respect : frequently admonishing the Reader , that he admit their opinions , or interpretations , but so far as he sees them agree with the Holy Writings . So that since Protestants are bound by Canon to follow the ancient Fathers ; whosoever doth so with sincerity , it is utterly impossible he should be a Papist .

And indeed the Reverence of the Church of England , to the ancient Fathers , as it is most regular and well govern'd , so it is most uniform and constant , whereas nothing is more ordinary with the Romanists , than when they are prest and urg'd by the authority of the ancient Fathers against them , to depreciate their testimonies , and add some scurvy false insinuations concerning them : as hath been often observed of C. Baronius , Bellarmine , Stapleton , and others . Whereas the constant Reverence of the Church of England to the ancient Fathers , is such , that the Romanists cannot but acknowledge it very often , as De Cressy a a Exomolog . p. 102. 135. saith , Indeed the Protestants in England make honourable mention of the Fathers . They profess greater Reverence to Antiquity than any other Sect whatsoever .

§ . 4. There are many things of excellent use in themselves , which come to be suspected and reproached , because of the abuse they have had in the Roman Church : Of which , Tradition may be a great instance : Because the Church of Rome hath made Tradition equal if not superiour to Holy Scripture ; therefore others run to the other extreme of undervaluing all kind of good and lawful Tradition , not considering that Holy Scripture is Tradition Recorded . And forgeting that in the Church of God , one great proof of the integrity of the Canon of Holy Scripture it self , hath been always Tradition ; which these men so confidently despise . There are also some Traditions not contrary to the Holy Scripture which if they be rightly qualify'd , have and ought to have great authority with us : Wherefore upon all occasions is celebrated among us , that famous passage of Vincentius Lirinensis b b Vinc. Lir. adv. Haer. c. 3. : Whatsoever is universally delivered , which every where , which always , which of all is believed , that is accounted as indubitable and certain .

We receive not ( saith Bishop Bramhall to M. Militiere ) your upstart Traditions , nor unwritten Fundamentals , but we admit genuine , universal , Apostolical Traditions . — And we are so far from believing Tradition without allowing the Papacy ; That one of the principal motives why we rejected the Papacy , was the constant Tradition of the Vniversal Church .

§ . 5. Concerning our Churches own Testimony , Her Modesty and Moderation hath been always exemplary , so far from assuming the Title of Catholick to her self only ( as ( St Austin tells us ) the Arians did , and since them the Romanists ) c c S. Aug. Ep. 48. ad Vincen. That she hath counted it a sufficient honour to be an humble ( and nevertheless for that , eminent ) Member of the Universal Church ; and with her a Witness and Keeper of Holy Writ ; and though she vindicates to her self an authority to interpret the Holy Scripture , within the bounds of her own Discipline , for the edification of her own Family , in Truth and Love , and also asserts to her self an Authority in Controversies of Faith , Article 20. namely , for the avoiding diversities of opinions , and for the establishing consent touching true Religion ; yet I cannot well omit to observe , the wise modesty of our Church in her asserting her own authority in Controversies of Faith : which expression , I may have leave to illustrate from such another instance of Wisdom and Moderation , in the recognition required to be made of the Kings Supremacy in our subscription ( according to the 36. Canon ) and in our Prayers , wherein we acknowledge Him Supreme Governour of this Realm , in all Causes , and over all Persons : It is not said , over all Causes as over all persons ; forasmuch , as in some Causes , Christian Kings do not deny some spiritual power of Gods Church distinct from its temporal Authority ; which yet refers to the King , as their Supreme Keeper , Moderator , and Governour : Even so the Church declares her Authority in Controversies of Faith , not that the Church of England , or any other Church , no not the Universal Church , hath power to make any thing which is in controversy matter of Faith , which God hath not so made : The Church owns that she hath no power against the truth , but for the truth . Neither may it expound one place of Scripture , that it be repugnant to another : ( Article 20. ) But she hath power to declare her own sense in the Controversy : and ( that I may express my own meaning in better words than my own d d Pref. of Bishop Sparrow's Collection of Eccl. Records , &c. ) To determine which part shall be received and profest for truth by her own Members , and that too under Ecclesiastical penalty and censure , which they accordingly are bound to submit to , not as an infallible verity , but as a probable truth ; and rest in her determination , till it be made plain by as great authority , that this her determination is an error ; or if they shall think it so by the weight of such reasons as are privately suggested to them , yet are they still obliged to silence and peace , where the decision of a particular Church is not against the Doctrine of the Vniversal ; Not to profess in this case against the Churches determination ( because the professing of such a controverted truth is not necessary , but the preservation of the peace and unity of the Church is ) is not to assert infallibility in the Church , but authority . Wherefore Mr Chilingworth e e Chilingw . Pres . §. 28. had very just reason to declare , Whatsoever hath been held necessary to salvation , either by the Catholick Church of all Ages , or by the consent of Fathers , measured by Vincentius Lirinensis his Rule ; or is held necessary , either by the Catholick Church of this Age , or by the consent of Protestants , or even by the Church of England , That against the Socinians , and all others whatsoever , I do verily believe and embrace . Whereas the Pope and Church of Rome do challenge to themselves an authority supreme , over all Causes and Persons , by their Infallibility , by which they exclude all others from their peace , and themselves from emendation : Neither are their followers much in the way thereunto , by what Card. Bellarmine doth assert of this supreme Authority : If the Pope ( saith he f f C. Bellarm. de Pontif. Ro. l. 4. c. 5. ) should err , in commanding any Vices , or forbidding any Vertues , The Church is bound to believe those Vices are good , and those Vertues are evil , unless it would sin against Conscience g g In bono sensu , dedit Christus Petro potestatem saciendi de peccato non peccatum , & de non peccato peccatum . c. Bell. c. 31. in Barklaium . . ( However in his Recognitions h h Locuti sumus de actibus dubiis vi●t●tum aut vitiorum . Recogn . operum c. B. p. 19. , he minceth the matter in a distinction of doubtful and manifest Vices and Vertues . ) O Blessed Guides of Souls ! How did the Illustrious Cardinal miss being Canoniz'd for that glorious Sentence ? and to help him for a Miracle to qualify him for an Apotheosis , why did not some cry out of it ; So many words , so many Miracles ? Thus many of the Romanists make the Pope such a Monarch in the Church , as Mr Hobbs doth his Prince in the State i i Hobbesius de Cive c. 7. art. 26. c. 12. art. 1. . The interpretation of Holy Scripture , the right of determining all Controversies , to fix the rules of good and evil , just and unjust , honest and dishonest , doth depend on his authority , in the power of whom is the chief Government . But this Doctrine is as bad Philosophy as that of the Cardinals is Divinity . Among these excesses , let us not forget the Moderation of our Church , which holds , she may revise what hath slipt from her : wherefore in her 19. Article she declares : As the Church of Jerusalem , Alexandria , and Antioch , have erred , so also the Church of Rome hath erred : ( a charge agreeable to the Moderation of our Church , considering what might have been further said : ) which by the same proportions of reason she supposeth true of her self , and of all others , viz. That they are fallible and may erre .

§ . 6. Of the use of Reason , with Reference to divine matters , there may be elsewhere occasions in this Treatise to discourse * * Ch. 6. §. 9 , 10. . Yet here it is to be observed , our Church doth not make its own reason a rule of Faith ; nor the sole Interpreter of Scripture , much less the reason of private men : yet because mankind hath no reasonable expectation of Miracles , especially , when ordinary means are sufficient and abounding ; and because the Holy Spirit of God in the testimony of his Church , hath all along certainly conveyed to us the sense of many places ; beside , That what is most needful to be heeded is very plain ; our Church doth allow and suppose rational mens perceiveing the sense of Scripture by the due use of their understanding ; which practice must also necessarily engage such to a high regard of what was anciently received in the Catholick Church . For as nothing is held among us more agreeable to reason than our Religion , so in expounding our Religion , and in interpreting Scripture , our Church makes use of the best and the truest reasons ( as is manifest in what she declares and enjoins ) and encourageth also those other helps which are any ways useful to the better understanding the sense of Holy Scripture : as namely , the knowledge of Tongues , Arts , and Sciences , and whatever else may improve the industry and sincerity of the enquirer . Because as our Homily saith k k Hom. of Com. Pr. and Sacraments . , No man cometh to the knowledge of Tongues , otherwise , than by diligent and earnest study : and elsewhere l l Hom. of the peril of Idolatry , 2. Part. , The Church ( taking notice , how the worshipping of Images came in times of ignorance , negligence , and barbarity ) laments the wasts made on learning , by the Goths , and Vandals , and Hunns , They burning Libraries , so that learning and true Religion went to wrack , and decayed incredibly .

Wherefore the Church of England hath been always a bountiful and careful cherisher and Patron of our Famous Vniversities ; as They have been and are , most dutiful and zealous observers of the Church .

And because our Church governs it self according to such just measures in the Interpretation and Exposition of Scripture , we see she doth neither practise nor encourage the turning of Holy Scripture into Cabala's and Allegory , as too many have precariously and groundlesly done , according to the humour of their own imaginations : our Church observing that Moderation which St Austin commends m m De Civ . Dei l. 17. c. 3. , when he blames some for one extreme , that will allow no type or signification in things done and recorded ; and others who contend , all things in Scripture recorded , have their Allegorical Interpretation n n Mihi multùm errare videntur qui nullas res gestas aliquid aliud praeter id quod eo modo gesta sunt significare arbitrantur : it a multùm audere qui prorsus ibi omnia significationibus allegoricis involuta esse contendunt . Erasin . Eccles. l. 3. Nunquam dubia aenigmatum intelligentia ad autoritatem dogmatum proficere . S. Hieron . in Mat. 13. , even the Doctrines of Catholick Faith ; which ( in his Epistle to Vincentius ) he calls a grievous piece of impudence to hold : yet as Erasmus ( in his Ecclesiastes ) adds , It is not fit to doubt of such Types and Allegories , which Canonical Scripture have revealed to us .

§ . 7. Though the Moderation of the Church shews it self in that it doth not vain-gloriously boast of the Spirit , yet it may well consist with her excellent modesty to believe of her self , That in the interpretation of Holy Scripture , she hath such an assistance of the Spirit of God as is promised to the Church in general : The Church of England being a true part thereof , subject to and governed by the word of God : upon which account in 139. Canon , it requires , That the sacred Synod of this Nation , in the name of Christ , and by the Kings Authority assembled , be acknowledged the true Church of England by Representation : and it may be presumed , That where the lawful representative of the Church is gathered together rightly , the assistance of Gods Spirit is not wanting ; wherefore it argues immoderate presumption in them who receive with impious scorn , our Confession of our undoubted hope , that the Church of England hath the testimony of the Spirit of God in her interpretation of Scripture ; and yet these depravers of the Scripture o o Qui ingenium suum faciunt Ecclesiae sacramenta . S. Hier. Ep. 9. , shall with glorious assurance affirm to themselves and their Complices , the wonderful illapses and impulses of the divine Spirit , when at the same time they contradict the Holy Catholick Church p p Neque — id defendere velim contra consensum antiquitatis & spiritum qui Ecclesiae corpus : Quod si mecum in rebus aliis caveant ilii , jam spiritus ille privatus Ecclesiae Divisor perdet fascini sui efficaciam . Grotius ad Riv. art. 1. and themselves ; and when also many pretenders to a double portion of the Spirit , have acted as the eldest Sons of Belial .

Whereas indeed the testimony of the Spirit , in the hearts of the faithful themselves , for the interpreting Holy Scripture , and determining doubtful matters , hath been more often urged than understood ; yea , if we could suppose it was not a precarious assertion , to be sure it is an improper method to convince Gainsayers : yet to those who are out of Communion with the Church , it must needs be a most uncertain and insufficient testimony .

§ . 8. Many we know there have been and are , who pretend to such extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit , as were peculiar to the first Ages of the Church : thus doth the Church of Rome ( as did the Donatists of old ) make such miraculous testimonies , the necessary sign of a true Church : and somewhat like both these , are the Enthusiasts of our late age , who would make the priviledges of the Holy Spirit , special and singular to their enclosures ; affirming a particular inspiration of the Spirit absolutely necessary , To convey into our minds the sense and interpretation of Holy Scripture : To assure all Christians of the certainty of their Salvation : To furnish them with words and petitions in Prayer : To convince any of the authority of Holy Scriptures , and the certainty of Faith ,

Our Church declares q q Homily for Whit-sunday , 2d Part. , It is not the part of a Christian under pretence of the Holy Ghost , to bring in his own dreams and phantasies into the Church , for such blaspheme and bely the Holy Ghost : whereas , the proper office of the Holy Ghost is not to institute and bring in new Ordinances , contrary to the doctrine before taught , the doing of which the Homily declares , is the sign of a false Church , and of such as are deceivers .

It is to be acknowledged , that the discourses concerning the operation and testimony of the Spirit are liable to many difficulties : but , The principal conclusions which are rightly made in this matter , I suppose may be truly made out to be the sense of our Church declared in her own words .

1. For interpretation of Holy Scripture , the reason why our Church holds such extraordinary illumination not necessary , is because r r 2d Homily of Scripture . , All things necessary for our Salvation are plain to understand , that is , as the Homilies deliver , to such as use the means : and so far as their explicite knowledge is required .

For our Church doth speak of the illumination of the Spirit and interpretation of Scripture , as generally joined with the use of means : When any apply their minds to the study of the Scripture , to hear , read , and search , thus God openeth the dark things of Scripture unto faithful people : It cannot be , saith St Chrysostom , that such should be left without help . When our Homily mentions the Holy Ghost inspiring the true meaning of the Scripture , it adds , to them that with humility and diligence do search therefore : which clause is not to be left out ( as it is by the Author of the Scriptures genuine interpreter , p. 5. ) Those that thus thankfully , chearfully , and diligently hear , read , meditate , and ruminate on Holy Scripture ; such have the sweet juice , spiritual effect , tast , comfort , and consolation of them : which Doctrine of our Church is most intelligible and sober , and different from what some others mystically have discoursed of concerning spiritual gusts , which they attribute to unaccountable Communications .

The ordinary means to which the interpretation of Scripture is generally annexed , our Church judgeth the same which Dr Hammond mentions in his Postscript concerning Divine Illuminations : Study , search , Meditation , the Collation of places of Scripture , ( or bringing one place together with another s s Homily 1. ) the use of reason , and learning , and skill in original Languages ; the help of our spiritual guides ; the Declarations of Gods Church ; the analogy of received doctrines constant Prayer for Gods blessing ; the necessary assistance and gracious aids of Gods Spirit .

Our Church indeed teacheth us , that Carnal reason is an enemy to God , and to perceiving the things of the Spirit : which carnal reason , some do expound the Article 9 wisdom , some the sensuality , some the affection , some the desire of the flesh . But our Church esteems it a great reproach to humane nature , and the Creation of God , to call that carnal reason , which is our rational perception and use of what is delivered us to understand : or a comparing , and as we said out of the Homily , a bringing together one place with another ; and drawing easy and plain consequences from Scriptures , which we are to search : whereas the Scriptures are propounded to the reasons of Men ; and the belief of them is an act of the greatest reason that can be . Indeed in the things revealed , when any thing exceeds the comprehension of our reason ; our Church adviseth us to sequester our reason : In such cases , saith the Homily t t Hom. of Places of Script . 2. Part. , Reason must give place to Gods holy Spirit .

From the Doctrine of our Church , it is also very plain , That no more supernatural and immediate operation of the Holy Spirit is necessary to the interpretation of the Scriptures than what is necessary to make us faithful and good Christians .

Wherefore our Church lays down the same means for improvement in divine knowledge , as it doth for obtaining the Holy Spirit : namely ,

u u 1 & 2d. Homily of Scripture . The love of God and Godliness , the having a care of being drown'd in worldly vanities ; leaving sin and the world : Our forsaking the corrupt judgment of fleshly men .

x x 3d Part of the Homily for Rogation Week . Let us endeavour our selves ( saith our Church ) diligently to keep the presence of the Holy Spirit : Let us renounce all uncleanness , for he is the Spirit of purity : Let us avoid all hypocrisy , for this Holy Spirit will flee from that which is feigned : Cast off all malice and evil will , for this Spirit will never enter into an evil willing Soul : Let us cast away all the whole lump of sin that standeth about us ; for he will never dwell in that body which is subdued to sin : If we do our endeavour , we shall never need to fear : And the Holy Spirit will suggest to us what is wholsome , and confirm us in all things .

To attain also the spiritual Wisdom of the Scriptures , Our way , saith the Church , is to attend the time , and win the time with diligence , and apply our selves to the light and grace which is offered us .

Lastly , Let us meekly call upon that bountiful Spirit , the Holy Ghost , which proceedeth from our Father of mercy , and from our Mediator Christ . That he would assist us and inspire us with his presence , That in him we may be able to hear the goodness of God declared unto us , to our Salvation ; for this cannot be obtained but by the direction of the Spirit of God , and therefore it is called spiritual wisdom .

2. Our Church doth not judge , that the particular immediate Testimony of Gods Spirit is necessary to every Christian for his comfortable assurance of Salvation ; but supposeth that the best assurance of Salvation , is from the sure trust and belief of Gods promises : and a certain consciousness of our own sincerity , according to what is required of us .

* * Homily of Salvation . V. Homily of Almes-deeds , 2. Part. V. Homily of falling from God , 1. Part. If you would be sure of your Faith , try it by your living ; the true Christian Faith is no dead , vain , or unfruitful thing : Therefore let us by such Vertues as spring out of Faith , shew our Election to be sure and stable .

3. Our Church doth not judge an immediate gift of the Spirit necessary to every Christian , to furnish them with words in Prayer ; but doth rightly suppose , that the Holy Spirit doth effectually assist every sincere devout person using a good form of Prayer : because he by whom the Spirit is given to the Church , did teach his Disciples , and in them all Christians , a form of Prayer ; requiring them to use the same . Our Church also hath furnished those of her Communion with general Prayers , according to their occasions : judging also that such common Prayers Homily of Prayer . are most available before God : And the means of obtaining the Holy Spirit , to be most assisting us in our Prayers , our Church declares , is for us , to humble our selves in his sight , and in all our Prayers both publick and private , to have our minds fully fixed on him ; so that our Church supposeth those that are thus humble to pray by the Spirit .

How far the testimony of the Holy Spirit is necessary to convince us of the certainty of our Faith , and of the authority of Holy Scriptures , See Chap. 6. §. 8.

From which few passages already cited ( in comparison of those very many to the same purpose , which abound in the Homilies for Whit-sunday ; the Homily of good works ; of Salvation ; of falling from God ; of Alms-deeds : ) It is most evident , that our Church judgeth rightly concerning the Holy Spirit of God ; and lays down the best Rules for discerning who have the Holy Spirit ; for according to the Doctrine of our Church , believing and obeying the Gospel , and having the Spirit are all one .

y y Homily of Salvation , 3. Part. For how can a man have true faith , when he liveth ungodly , and denieth Christ with his deeds : contrariwise , he is most inspired with the Holy Ghost , who is most changed in his life .

So then this is to be taken for a most true lesson taught by Christs own mouth , z z Homily of good works , 2. Part. That the works of the moral Commandments of God be the very true works of Faith , which lead to the blessed life to come .

Our Church also doth suppose , that those who receive most of the Spirit , are such as are most truly vertuous and good ; such have most of the divine grace , to confirm and strengthen them in all goodness ; as it is in the Office for the Holy Communion : If with a true penitent heart and lively faith we receive the Holy Sacrament , then we dwell in Christ and Christ in us , &c.

a a 1. Part of the Sermon for Whitsunday . Wherefore if any say , O , but how shall I know that the Holy Ghost is within me ? Some man perchance will say , forsooth as the tree is known by the fruit , so is also the Holy Ghost : The fruits of the Holy Ghost , according to the mind of St Paul , are these ; Gal. 5. Love , Joy , Peace , Long-suffering , Gentleness , Goodness , Faithfulness , Meekness , Temperance , &c. Contrariwise , the deeds of the flesh are these , Adultery , Fornication , Vncleanness , Wantonness , Idolatry , Witchcraft , Hatred , Debate , Emulation , Wrath , Contention , Sedition , Heresy , Envy , Murder , Drunkenness , Gluttony , and such like : Here now is the Glass wherein thou must behold thy self , and discern whether thou hast the Holy Ghost within thee , or the spirit of the flesh . If thou see thy works be vertuous and good , consonant to the prescript rule of Gods word , savoury and tasting , not of the flesh but the Spirit ; then assure thy self thou art endued with the Holy Ghost : otherwise , in thinking well of thy self , thou dost but deceive thy self : The Holy Ghost doth always declare himself by his fruitful and gracious gifts .

b b 2d Part of the Hom. for Whit-sunday . But to conclude , ye shall briefly take this short lesson . Wherever ye find the spirit of arrogance and pride , the spirit of envy , hatred , contention , cruelty , &c. Assure your selves , that there is the spirit of the Devil , and not of God ; albeit they pretend to the world outwardly ever so much Holiness : for as the Gospel teacheth us , The Spirit of Jesus is a good , holy , sweet , lowly , merciful Spirit , full of charity and love , full of forgiveness and pity , not rendring evil for evil , extremity for extremity . According to which rule , If any man live uprightly , of him it may be safely pronounced , That he hath the Holy Ghost within him ; if not , there is a plain token , he doth usurp the name of the Holy Ghost in vain .

As for the manner and measure of the operations of the Holy Spirit , The modesty and Moderation of our Church doth not decree any thing , lest ( as St Austin saith ) Humane infirmity proceed beyond what is safe .

Yet our Church gives a right account in sundry places of its Homilies , c c Second Part of the Homily of Falling from God . How the Holy Spirit comes to be withdrawn from men : By all these Examples of Holy Scripture , we know , that as we forsake God , so shall he even forsake us : When he withdraweth from us his word , the right doctrine of Christ ; his gracious assistance and aid ( which is ever joined with his Word ) and leaveth us to our own wit , and will , and strength ; He declareth then he beginneth to forsake us : d d First Part of the Homily of falling from God . which is ( as it follows ) after any do neglect the same ; if they be unthankful to him , if they order not their lives according to his Example and Doctrine , &c.

From whence we see also that our Church judgeth the promise of the spirit is ( as the blessings of the Gospel are generally ) conditional : For as God , for his part , delivered his Son to suffer death for us : so again , we for our parts , should walk in a godly life , as becometh his Children so to do . e e 2. Part of the Homily of Alms-deeds . He that is first made good by the Spirit and Grace of God , afterward bringeth forth good fruits .

As for those who affirm a supernatural and immediate illumination necessary , without which , other ordinary means are insufficient , either to give us certainty of the authority , or interpretation of Divine Writ ,

1. They affirm that which no where is declared :

2. That which we have little reason to credit from them that affirm so : We having neither experience of their extraordinary knowledge , or goodness : but have found them most mistaken of any in their interpretations of Scripture : and also by the notes of having the Spirit ( delivered in Scripture ) what is quite different hath appear'd .

3. The holding such an opinion , tends to lessen the authority of the written word of God ; and to make the dictates of the humane spirit ( if not sometime the Diabolical ) equal with the Holy Canon . And those others who lay the stress of the proof of the authority of Scripture , and the certainty of Faith , and the interpretation of Scripture , upon such uncertainties as only the internal testimony of the Spirit ( as is yet neither proved necessary or real ; however , of which there is no proof unto others ) verily , such labour unprofitably to overthrow Christianity , and render all our Faith uncertain .

4. Their Doctrine leads to such Enthusiasm , as is not consistent with the peace of Kingdoms , much less the peace of Gods Church .

But such is the constant Moderation of our Church , though it doth reject and oppose all fanatical and ungrounded pretences to the Spirit : Yet our Church most frequently , and with all humble reverence , owns the necessity of the gracious aids and assistance of the Spirit ( as the phrase is in our Homilies several times used ) as without which we can do nothing pleasing to God : For in the power and vertue of the Holy Ghost , resteth all wisdom and all ability , to know God and to please him f f 3d Part of the Homily for Rogation Week . : Therefore we pray , that in all things he will mercifully direct and rule our hearts : we pray to God , to grant us his Spirit , that those things which we do may please him g g In the Absolution , Collect after the H. C. Hom. of falling from God ▪ : To prevent us in all our doings , &c. because of the ill condition of those who are not governed by the Spirit of God .

CHAP. VI. The Moderation of the Church in its judgment of Doctrines .

§ . 1. Our Church doth wisely distinguish between what is necessary for Salvation , and what is not . § . 2. Her Articles are few . § . 3. Which are generally exhibited , not as Articles of Faith , but consent . Concerning subscription . § . 4. Our Articles are propounded so as to avoid unnecessary controversy . § . 5. The wise Moderation of the Kings of England , in their Injunctions to Preachers , and Orders taken to preserve Truth , Vnity , and Charity . § . 6. The Controversies of the late Age are well moderated , by the determinations of our Church . § . 7. As our Church requires our consent in nothing contrary to sense or reason , so it hath also contain'd it self from immoderate curiosity , in treating of venerable mysteries . § . 8. Our Church doth not insist upon such kinds of certainty as others without just cause do exact . § . 9. Doctrines are so propounded to those in our Churches Communion , as not to render useless their own reasons and judgments : The reasonableness of which is proved , and the Objections answered . § . 10. The use which we are all allowed of our private judgments , is requir'd to be menag'd with a due submission to the Church . The duty of which submission is laid down in sundry Propositions .

§ . 1. BEcause all things in Divine Revelation are alike true , but not alike necessary for furtherance of Faith and Piety , and establishing Union among Christians , and Peace in the Church ; Our Church hath wisely distinguished , between what is necessary absolutely , and what only in some circumstances is necessary to Salvation : Those things ( saith the Homily a a 2d Part of the Homily of Scriptures . ) that be plain to understand , and necessary for Salvation , every mans duty is to learn them ; and as for dark mysteries , to be contented to be ignorant in them till such time as it shall please God to open those things unto them : b b Hom. 1. If it shall require to teach any truth , — or to do any thing requisite for our Salvation . All those things ( saith St Chrysostom ) we may learn plentifully of the Scripture . And in the 19. Article of the Church : The Preaching of the pure word of God , and the Administration of the Sacraments , are made indispensable notes of the visible Church : namely , in all things that of necessity are requisite to the same : and the 8th Article declares , The three Creeds ought throughly to be believed and received , for that they may be proved by most certain warrant of Holy Scripture ; where our Church gives the reason of her Faith , and sheweth her earnestness in contending for it : But the Moderation of our Church contains her self within the bounds of what is before made necessary . The principal and essential points of the Doctrine of Salvation ( such as are fit to make up the unity of the Faith , and constitute a Church ) are no other among us , than what Christ and his Apostles at first made necessary , which also the ancient Church received as necessary unto Baptism , and for distinction of Heresy : which fundamental Maxims of Christian Science , are frequently and plainly repeated in Scripture , and by our Church were first of all insisted on at the reformation of our Church : as we see in the Institution of a Christian Man ( 1537. ) in the first Injunctions of our Kings , and our Form of Catechism . Whereas the Catechisms and Systems which have been set up in opposition to the Catechism and Articles of the Church of England , have abounded with many doubtful and unnecessary definitions ; yet so insisted upon by some , as if the Hinges of the Gate of Heaven turn'd upon those Propositions : whereby many have agreed with Pope Pius the Fourth , who by his Bull set out the Apostles Creed in a larger Edition of about as many more Articles , without belief of which is declared no Salvation c c Extra quam Nemo salvus esse potest . Bulla Pii quarti , super formâ Juramenti professionis fidei , sub finem Concilii Trid. : Unto such a strange Circumference is the body of their unnecessary belief extended : whereas the Religion of our Church tends to the Center . Which distinction of things necessary , from what was not so , King James ( according to the sense of our Church ) declares of great use to lay a foundation for the publick peace of the Church d d Vt de necessariis conveniat omnis opera insumatur , in non-necessariis libertati Christianae locus . Rex Jacobus ad Card. Perr . , and of particular mens minds , and the furtherance of true Faith and Piety .

§ . 2. Those Articles which are delivered by our Church , for the avoiding of diversities of opinions , and establishing consent touching true Religion : 1. They are few , especially those of positive Doctrine , and the other negative positions were necessary to assert our liberty from the abuses and encroachments of the Romanists in their contrary affirmatives : few , if we consider , either the time , or the occasion of their being framed ; it being just about the meeting at Trent , made it necessary for our Church to declare her sense of many Doctrines , for the better satisfaction and directions of her Sons , and to testify her equal conditions of Communion : Especially also , if we consider the cruel number of Articles , which either the Westminster Divines , or the Trent Councellors have imposed on their followers .

e e Bishop ●ramball , fol. p. 1018. Indeed the Romanists do call our Religion a negative Religion , because in all the Controversies between us and them , we maintain the negative ; that is , we go as far as we dare or can , with warrant from holy Scriptures , and the Primitive Church , and leave them in their excesses , or those inventions which they themselves have added ; but in the mean while , they forget that we maintain all those Articles and truths which are contained in any of the ancient Creeds of the Church , which I hope are more than negative .

The Church of England ( saith Archbishop Laud f f Archbishop Laud against Fisher , 5. 14. ) comes far short of the Church of Romes severity ; whose Anathema's are not for 39. Articles , but for very many more , above one hundred in matter of Doctrine , and that in many points as far remote from the foundation , though to the far greater rack of Mens Consciences ; they must be all Fundamental if that Church have determined them . Whereas the Church of England never declared , that every one of her Articles are fundamentals in the Faith ; For it is one thing to say , no one of them is superstitious or erroneous , and quite another to say , every one of them is fundamental : Besides , the Church of England prescribes only to her own Children , and by those Articles provides but for her peaceable consent in those Doctrines of truth ; but the Church of Rome severely imposeth on all the World her Doctrine , and that under pain of damnation .

§ . 3. These Articles of Religion are generally exhibited as Articles of Peace and consent , not as Articles of Faith and Communion , and as such they are propounded to all the Communicants in our Church g g Schisin guarded , p. 150. Bishop Lanies Sermons , p. 48. in general . For the avoiding Diversities of Opinions ( as the Title of the Articles is . ) Not such a consent as Curcellaeus h h Curcellaeus : Religionis Christianae Institut . C. 15. means , where he supposeth some in the dregs of the Age of the Reformation , obtrude their Confessions and Catechisms , as a secondary rule , if not of truth , yet of consent ; such as ought to be urged only to an infallible truth ; 't is likely he might know many who did so : But the consent designed to be established by our Articles , is such a consent as may keep the Peace of our Church undisturbed : according to the sense of the fifth Canon : Where the Prohibition is directed against such as should speak against the 39. Articles , as superstitious and erroneous : such as may not with a good Conscience be subscribed to : Whosoever shall hereafter affirm i i Quicunque in posterum affirmabit , &c. Ecclesiae Anglic. Canon 5. , — not as the Council of Trent k k Si quis contrà senserit , Anathema sit . Concil. Trid. de peccato Originis . directs its Anathema against those that shall so much as think diversly . Wherefore our Church no where delivers our Articles as necessary to be believed , neither by vertue of their own necessity , or her own Command : as several with Bishop Bramhall have noted : For which reason , subscription unto them is not required of any Lay-person whatsoever , meerly in order to his Communion with our Church : Although the Church of Geneva l l A quibus discedere neque Ministris neque●ivibus liceret : Be●a in vita Calvini . urgeth subscription , not of the Ministers only but the people m m Extet forma quaedam Doctrinae ad quam omnes Episcopi & Parochi jure-jurando astringantur , ut nemo ad munus Ecclesiasticum admittatur nisi spondeat . Calvin . ad Angl. Protect . . There is perfectly another reason why subscription is required of all who receive the priviledge of degrees in our Universities : and in Case of factious Appellants n n Canon 98. ; who are inhibited , unless they first subscribe ; and especially of the Ministers of the Church o o Discrimen latum est inter verbi Ministros & plebeios homines quos Ministri informant : Testis enim est historia Ecclesiastica non per plebeios sed poti●s per Clericos introductas esse haereses & Schismata . Forbesius in Irenico l. 2. c. 12. : namely , because she may be as secure as she can of them to whom she commits so great a trust in the instruction of the people . Wherefore of them who are entrusted with the Ministry of the Church , it is required that they disavow all obligations and opinions to break the Peace of the Church , and that they assent to the use of those things which are for the unity of Christians in this Kingdom among themselves ; which is no more than the Law of Nature hath granted every Society , which the Church hath in all Ages practised , and which our Adversaries themselves did use : For the p p Vi. Disc. of Toler . Sect. 13. Presbyterians required a subscription to their solemn League , and the Independants had their Church Government : Therefore in that our Church takes all the security she can by Sponsors at Baptism , and by subscription of Ministers , is a proof of her wisdom and great care of her own ; especially among us , where the Ministers of the Church have , blessed be God , another Tenure than in Holland , during the precarious pleasure of their Pay-Masters : Beneficed men among us having a Freehold , and not to be turned out but in a legal way upon great cause deserving . Neither is subscription required by our Church of its Ministers , unless they can do it willingly , and [ ex animo ] , nor unless they can with freedom of mind assent and consent to the uniform practice of the Church . This if they cannot do with a quiet mind , they are left free by the Church to enjoy a laical indulgence , which is very large , and exceeding bountiful . As for dissatisfaction or weakness : what said King James q q Conference at Hampton Court . , How long will such Brethren be weak ? Are not 45 years sufficient r r Qui decennali disciplinâ nondum usque●o prosecerunt ut tam faciles in Theologiá quaestiones intelligant , non possunt apti esse ad sustinendum onus pastorale in E●clesiâ Dei . Forbes . Iren . l. 2. c. 12. to grow strong in ? Some of them are strong enough , if not Head-strong . But I wonder there should be such earnest Recusants to subscription , of the followers of Calvin among us : whenas he to the English Protector writes thus : 'T is fit to look after the desultory humour of them who would have too much lawful to themselves . The door is to be shut to curious doctrines ; and one expedite means for that purpose is , if there were a summary of doctrine received of all , which all may follow in Preaching ; to the observing of which , all Bishops and Parish Priests , may be bound by an Oath , that no one may be admitted to any Ecclesiastical Office , unless he first engage that he will keep inviolate that consent of Doctrine . And so for Catechism . And as to a Form of Prayer and Ecclesiastical Rites , I very much approve , that there be a constant Form extant , from which it may not be lawful for the Pastors in their Functions to depart , in regard of the simplicity and unskillfullness of some , and that the consent of the Churches among themselves may more certainly be manifest . Lastly , to prevent the desultory levity of those who affect Novelties . And in his Epistle to Farellus s s Calv. Ep. 87. , Calvin writes , It always prevail'd in the Church which was decreed in ancient Synods , That those who would not be subject to the Laws of Common Discipline , should be dismissed from their Function .

§ . 4. The very frame of the Articles shews the great Moderation and Wisdom of the Church , they being propounded on purpose so as to avoid unnecessary controversy : propounded not with a Laodicean indifference , or lukewarmness , in what we ought to contend for t t Parkers Eccles. Pol. l. 1. c. 25. ( as some charge our Church with ) It is not meant here or elsewhere by Moderation such a Latitude which ( Bishop Taylor saith u u Ductor Dub. l. 3. ● . 4. §. 23. ) hath something of craft , but very little of ingenuity : which can only serve the ends of peace and external Charity , or a fantastick Concord , but not the ends of truth and holiness , and Christian simplicity .

It is not meant here as if our Articles were framed like the dubious Oracles of Delphos , that the Subscribers might understand them which way they please : like a shoe for every foot : as if they were to deceive by ambiguous terms x x Conference at Hamp . C. p. 15. .

The Judicious Bishop Sanderson y y Pax Ecclesiae , p. 52. , in his directions for the Peace of the Church , lays down this as the first :

That particular Churches would be as tender as may be in giving their definitions and determinations , especially where there may be admitted a Latitude of dissenting without prejudice done , either to the substance of the Catholick Faith , or to the tranquillity of the Church , or to the Salvation of the dissenter : In which respect the Moderation of the Church of England is much to be commended , and to be preferred ; not only before the Roman Church , which with unsufferable tyranny bindeth all her Children upon pain of Damnation , to all her determinations , even in those points which are no way necessary to Salvation : but also before sundry other Reformed Churches , who have proceeded further than this Church hath done .

It is a sufficient proof of the sincerity of our Church , if what it hath declared and intended to declare , hath a true , clear , and certain meaning : and her Articles do surely conduce to peace , if it appear all agree in the true , usual , literal meaning : But in respect of what is not intended to be declared by them : z z King Charles I. Declaration 1630. published with the Articles . If even in these curious points in which the present differences lye , most men of all sorts take the Articles of the Church of England for them ; then may be infer'd what the Right Reverend Bishop of Chester hath said :

a a No necessity of Reformation of the Doctrine of the Church of England , 1660. This rather gives a Testimony of the great Wisdom and Moderation of the Church , which in points doubtful and controverted , hath propounded only that which no sober man can make matter of doubt , or subject of controversy . As in the 16th Article 't is said , Not every deadly sin willingly committed after Baptism , is sin against the Holy Ghost : Now certainly , this is in it self a most sound , certain , infallible , plain , and perspicuous Doctrine ; and being so , the want of liberty to interpret one term of it deadly sin , cannot render it doubtful : for interpret it which way you will , either all sins are deadly , or say all sins are not deadly , it will be equally true , that every deadly sin is not the sin against the Holy Ghost .

In the like manner , whether we may fall from grace totally and finally , which hath a great doubt ; Without any question , After we have received the Holy Ghost , we may depart from grace given ; of that there hath never been any question .

In the third Article of Christs descent into Hell b b Compare the Articles of K. Edw. 6. 1552. and those of 1562. , The Church purposely hath waved all the Controversies thereof ; and plainly propounded the Article c c Hujus Articuli verum & genuinum sensum neque Apostoli ●●●dideru●● neque Ecclesia definivit . Rem itaque credimus , modum nescimus . Archiep. Spalat. l. 7. c. 12. §. 125. . In the 17th Article there is not one word of the horrible decree of absolute reprobation : rather in the close of the Article , there is a wholsome caution against extreme curiosity : Furthermore , we must receive Gods promises as they are set forth to us in Holy Scriptures , and in our doings That will of God is to be followed which is expresly declared to us in the word of God ; and in the Homilies our Church d d 2d Part of the Homily of falling from God . takes notice of some who Hearing the loving and large promises of Gods mercy , and so not conceiving a right Faith thereof , make those promises larger than ever God did , &c.

So evident is it , that the Church of England was intent on Peace and Edification of her Sons ; Wherefore the Articles of the Protestant Church in the Infancy thereof , were drawn up in general terms , foreseeing that posterity would grow up to fill the same : meaning that these holy men did prudently discover , that differences in judgment would unavoidably happen in the Church , and were loth to unchurch any , and drive them off from an Ecclesiastical Communion for petty differences , which made them pen the Articles in comprehensive words to take in all who differing in branches meet in the root of the same Religion e e Historia quinque articularis , Part 2. Ch. 8. . So that I think the modest survey of Naked Truth f f p. 4. did not fly one jot too high , when he saith , It cannot be denied but the Articles of our Church were compiled with the highest discretion and Moderation that ever was used by un-inspired men ; so that it is a most unreasonable charge on the Church of England , to say , she has tyrannically imposed many unnecessary conditions on her Members , in point of Faith and Doctrine : so large a Scope is left in our Church for mutual charity , and the enquiries of the studious . Bishop Bramhall was far from one of those which some called Latitudinarians ; yet he saith g g Fair Warning , Ch. 1. , If it were not for this Disciplinarian humour which will admit no Latitude h h Sunt ergo res aliquae ita comparatae ut benignam sibi interpretationem suo quodam jure concedi postulent ; quae sc. non sit interclusa verborum angustiis , sed cum quodam ( ut Ciceronis verbo utar ) Laxamento liberior . De Juram . oblig . prael . 2. §. 8. in Religion , but makes each nicety a fundamental , and every private opinion an Article of Faith , which prefers particular errours before general truths ; I doubt not but all reformed Churches would easily be reconciled : Wherefore , in such points which may be held diversly of divers men ( salvâ fidei compage ) I i i Chilingworth Pref. §. 28. would not take any mans liberty from him , and humbly beseech all men , that they would not take mine from me k k Non per difficiles quaestiones nos Deus ad beatam vitam vocat . S. Hilar. l. 10. de Trin. Sunt quidem nonnullae quaestiones è curiosis & inquietis hominibus excitatae , etiam doctis & piis viris negotium faciunt , in his ea Moderatio adhibenda , &c. Spalat. de officio pii viri . .

And here I think the Judgment of l l Jur. praedest . p. 21. Bishop Andrews may fitly be repeated , as most agreeable with the Moderation of our Church .

I truly ingenuously confess , I have followed the counsel of St Austin ; These mysteries which I cannot unfold , I admire them shut : and therefore for these sixteen years , since I was made Priest , I neither publickly , nor privately , have disputed nor Preacht of them : and now I had rather hear than speak of them : And truly since it is a slippery place , and hath on either side its Precipices ; and since these places of St Paul are always esteemed among those which are hard to be understood ; and many of the Clergy are neither fit to explain them , nor many of the people can be idoneous hearers ; I would e'ne perswade silence enjoin'd on both sides : and truly , I judge it more expedient , that our people be taught to seek their Salvation in the plain way of a holy and upright life , than in the hidden paths of the divine Counsels : into which , too curious inspection , use to cause giddiness in their Heads , and mists before their Eyes .

§ . 5. In persuance of the same design of the Church , for Peace and Moderation , it is very proper here to mention the seasonable and wise Declarations and Injunctions of our Kings of England , to Preachers and all others , to keep them within the bounds of the same peaceful Moderation .

In the Injunctions of King Edw. VI. 1547. Of Sermons , It is injoin'd , That they shall purely and sincerely declare the word of God , and in the same , exhort their hearers to the works of Faith , Mercy , and Charity ; especially prescribed and commanded in Holy Scripture .

In Queen Elizabeth's Articles for Doctrine and Preachers , They are admonished , to use sobriety and discretion in teaching the people ; namely , in matters of controversy ; and to consider the gravity of their office , and to foresee with diligence the matters which they shall speak , to utter them to the edification of the Audience .

King James ( Jan. 18. 1616. ) sent instructions to the Universities ; That young Students in Divinity should be excited to study such Books as were most agreeable to the Doctrine and Discipline of the Church of England : and bestow their time in the Fathers , and Councils , and Schoolmen , Histories and Controversies ; and not to insist too long on Compendiums and Abbreviations , making them the ground of their study . August 4. 1623. In his Letter to the Archbishop : Whereas divers young Students , by reading of late Writers and ungrounded Divines , do broach many times unprofitable , seditious and dangerous Doctrines , to the scandal of the Church : He injoin'd , That none under a Bishop or Dean , do presume to preach in any popular Auditory , the deep points of Predestination , Election , Reprobation ; or of the Vniversality , Resistibility , or Irresistibility of Gods Grace . But rather confine themselves wholly to those two Heads , of Faith and a good Life , which are all the subject of the ancient Sermons and Homilies : That no Preacher of any denomination whatsoever , shall presume to fall into bitter invectives , and undecent railings , against the Persons of either Papists or Puritans ; but modestly and gravely , when they are occasion'd by their Text , free both the Doctrine and Discipline of the Church of England , from the Aspersions of the Adversaries .

King Charles ( of Blessed Memory ) set forth with the Articles a Declaration 1630. wherein he required thus : In these curious and unhappy differences which have for so many hundred years in different times and places exercised the Church of Christ ; We will that all further curious search be laid aside , and these disputes shut up in Gods promises , as they be generally set forth to us in Holy Scriptures , and the general meaning of the Articles of the Church of England .

It is to be wisht , that all the Directions concerning Preachers , in the several Kings Reigns , since the Reformation , were Imprinted on the minds of all the Clergy and others ; especially , His present Majesties Directions , Dated October 14. 1662. Which among other great reasons inducing , were set forth because of the extravagance of sundry young Divines , who took upon them in their popular Sermons , to handle the deep points of Gods Eternal Counsels and Decrees , and other fruitless controversies , serving rather to amuse than profit the hearers ; which is done for the most part , and with greatest confidence by such persons as least understand them .

Therefore they are admonisht not to spend their time in the search of such abstruse and speculative notions . However , that they presume not positively and doctrinally to determine anything concerning the same : And for the edifying the people in Faith and Godliness , That they in their ordinary Sermons insist chiefly on Catechetical Doctrines ( wherein are contained all the necessary and undoubted verities of Religion ) declaring withal , unto their Congregations , what Influences such Doctrines ought to have into their Lives and Conversations ; and stirring them up effectually , as well by their Examples as their Doctrines , to the practice of such religious and moral duties as are the proper results of the said Doctrines ; as Self-denial , Contempt of the World , Humility , Patience , Meekness , Temperance , Justice , Mercy , Obedience , and the like , and to a detestation , &c. And because these licentious times have corrupted Religion in the very roots and foundations , That where there is an Afternoons Exercise , it be especially spent , either in explaining some part of the Church Catechism , or what may conduce to the Exposition of the Liturgy , and Prayers of the Church , as occasion shall be offered , The only cause they grew into contempt among the people being this , that they were not understood .

The subscription for University Preachers in the University of Cambridge , keeps its Subscribers within the same bounds ; and by the way , I may note the Moderation and Excellent temper of our Vniversities at this time : Having known for many Years together , in Cambridge , there have seldom been disputed in our Schools , those Controversies , which in the Age before did so much divide both Foreign Churches and ours , and also our Vniversities themselves : of our other Vniversity , I am assured the same , from my most Reverend Diocesan , the Lord Bishop of Lincoln .

Having mentioned our Vniversities , I conceive a very proper proof of the Moderation of our Church of England , may be taken from the general practice in our Universities ( those noble Seminaries of the Church ) where among the Theses which are disputed in the Divinity Schools , commonly one is given to assert our Church against the Romanists , the other to defend our Church against other Sectaries .

The care of very many of our Bishops hath been also the same , as may appear from one of their Exemplars of Subscription ; I have set it down in the Margent m m Ego Curatus cui licentia praedicandi verbum Dei concedenda est , sacras literas purè & sincerè tractabo , easque prudenti simplicitate populo exponam , nec in sermonibus meis de rebus jam constitutis suscitabo Controversias , nec spargam contentiones , neque innovationem ullam doctrinâ vel Ceremoniis suadebo . V. 1. Vol. Episcopii praes. Praevorstii de concionibus . , because of its excellent use .

In the Instructions of King James 1618. to the Divines He sent over to the Synod of Dort , One was , That they should advise the Ministers of those Churches , that they do not deliver in the Pulpit to the people , those things for ordinary Doctrines which are the highest points of Schools , and not fit for vulgar capacity , but are disputable on both sides ; and that they carry themselves with that advice , moderation and discretion , as became them , &c.

After all these great Testimonies of Moderation in our Church , it is proper to mention what we meet with in the Pacific Dr Hammonds Discourse of Gods Grace and Decrees , § . 24. This I suppose the reason , both of our Churches Moderation in framing the Article of Predestination , and of our late Kings Declaration in silencing the debate of the Question : For if by these methods the Church could but have prevailed to have the Definitions of the several pretenders forgotten : All men contenting themselves as our Article prescribes , with the Promises of God as they are declared in Scripture ; the turmoil , and heat , and impertinence of disputes , had been prevented , which now goes for engagement in Gods cause .

And blessed be God , the design of the Churches Moderation , and of our Gracious King ( the Churches Moderatour and Governour ) hath thus far had excellent effect in the Church and our Universities ; that for a long time there hath been a great silence from that noise and learned squabble , which sometimes formerly disturbed the Churches Peace : so that now we may be more at leisure , without prejudice and passion , to review and admire the wise and excellent determinations of our Church .

§ . 6. To shew how well the Controversies of the late Age have been moderated by our Church , might deserve a just Treatise by it self : But our Church seems to observe the same advice which King James gave to the Divines going over to Dort , 1618. In case of opposition between any over-much addicted to their own opinions , their endeavours should be , that certain Positions be moderately laid down , which may tend to the mitigation of heat on both sides .

Our Church throughout hath done the same thing , as might be instanced at large in the Controversies between us and the Romanists ; and between others also : Indeed the Articles , and especially the Homilies , do copiously and fitly moderate in these disputes , which not long since very much exercised Christendome : as for instance , when the Homilies declare , Justification is not the office of man , but of God only , which we receive of him by his free mercy , and by the only merits of his most dearly beloved Son . Yet our Faith in Christ ( as it were ) saith unto us , It is not I that take away your sins , but it is Christ only ; nevertheless by Faith we embrace the promise of Gods mercy . Such a Faith , whereof doth follow a loving heart to obey his Commandments . Justification by Faith , only freely and without works , is spoken to take away clearly all merit of works , as being unable to deserve our justification at Gods hand , and thereby doth express the weakness of man , and the goodness of God : ( Yet ) the true , lively , and Christian Faith , is no dead , vain , or unfruitful thing , but a thing of perfect vertue , and of wonderful operation , and working , and strength ; bringing forth all good motions and good works : therefore let us by such vertues as spring out of Faith , shew our Election to be sure and stable .

In such and many like passages , are known the excellent Wisdom and Moderation of our Church : particularly , as we have seen , attributing unto good works , no more nor no less , than what is consistent with the grace of the Gospel : declaring most earnestly against the Roman opinion of merit by them : and yet ( according as K. Edward's , and Q. Elizabeth's Injunctions have it ) doth recommend Charity and Hospitality as a true worshipping of God . And albeit the Romanists have much vaunted in this particular , it hath not been doubted but the Church of England since the Reformation , hath as great Monuments of Charity as ever were before ( under Papacy ) in the same compass of time and place : so truly doth the publick Exhortation , to the Contribution of St Paul's building , conclude : Our adversaries of Rome may be convinced , that our Piety is as generous and charitable as theirs , but would not be so arrogant and presumptuous ; and whilst we disclaim the merit , yet we most stedfastly believe the obligation and necessity of good works .

How far our Sectaries are deficient in this matter , it shall not be our business here to enquire , nor to repeat how slightly and reprochfully they have spoken against the truth in this matter .

It may suffice to observe from what hath been said , Nothing hath more vindicated the Doctrine of the Gospel , the Grace of God , and merits of our Saviour , and established the necessity of a good life , and prepared us for a comfortable death , than the doctrine of our Church rightly understood : wherein she hath delivered her self from all those fond opinions on which the Church of Rome and other , have founded their peculiar Doctrines , which have disquieted and confounded so many Christians , and disturbed the Church : Insomuch that some who have been otherwise much addicted to their own suppositions , yet in many matters of controversy have readily acknowledged the Moderation of our Church .

The Presbyterian Brethren in their first Paper of Proposals to his Majesty , say : We take it for granted , that there is a firm agreement between our Brethren and us , in doctrinal truths of the Reformed Religion , and in the substantials of divine worship .

Very famous ( saith Dr Tully ) through the whole World , is the most prudent Moderation of the Church of England in her definitions of Faith , in which surely to all she offers her self in so equal a poise , that she can afford no offence to sober minds and lovers of truth ; nor doth she give any occasion of cavilling to slight and petulant dispositions , of which in our Age , there is such a swarm . And Sancta Clara saith , The English Confession goes on safely within this Latitude , neither binding its followers to one side or other , but freely leaves these matters ( of Controversy ) to Scholastic disputation .

§ . 7. As of Doctrines , some are plain , others mysterious : and as our Church requires consent in nothing contrary to sense and reason ; so also she hath always contained her self from immoderate curiosity , even in treating of mysteries ; using good caution , and yet not so much as to become sceptical : making good search for her own and others satisfaction , as is fit ; and yet not too much , so as to run into extreme or nice curiosity .

Of such mysteries as are revealed , our Church hath faithfully declared those which God hath made requisite for us to know ( so far forth as is necessary ) yet such Moderation is used in the manner of declaring them , that she hath prudently kept to the form of sound words in holy Scripture , and the Declarations of the ancient Church : not disclaiming the use of such expressions which the authority of the first Councils , and the great consent of the learned have received , while the words follow the thing it self delivered in Holy Scripture , though in so many syllables perhaps there not set down : which are not introduced into our Church to corrupt primitive simplicity , but to prevent the double meaning which others have invented for other Scripture expressions : and as our Church doth not intermeddle with what is above humane enquiry ( n n First Part of the Sermon for Rogation Week . It shall better suffice us in low humility , to reverence the Divine Majesty which we cannot comprize , than by overmuch curious searching to be over-charged with the glory ) so it doth not determine in those things which are ( as I may say ) below its enquiry : namely , in things unnecessary to be known o o Quod legit Ecclesia Angl. piè credit ; quod non legit , pari pietate non inquirit . Rex Jac. ad . C. Perr . .

§ . 8. In giving a reason of our hope , and in convincing our selves or others , of the truth of matters of Faith and Christian Doctrine ; our Church doth not insist upon such kind of certainties as others without reason do exact : The point of certainty is a nice step which is taken in the first consideration of Religion , and of great consequence ; wherefore we cannot but observe the great Moderation and care of our Church :

1. Resolving the first motive and reason of believing , into the Testimony of God only , submitting all rational enquiries unto the Divine Testimony : when once there is assurance that the same testimony is Divine , our Church doth not make ( nor suppose that there can be made by ) any humane Judgment , a measure of what is incomprehensible .

2. Our Church doth accept and use such rational evidences , as God hath given us , as the means of being assured of the certainty that the Revelations which we receive as Divine , are such : Because the Divine Testimony is not immediate to us , nor necessary it should be so , but is conveyed to the assent of the understanding by some proper and just evidence . The ordinary way of knowledge ( allow'd us ) is the conviction of our judgments and reasons , concerning the truth of the Proposition we assent to : which conviction is made by such proper arguments as may sufficiently induce our belief : now , though there are innumerable arguments which convince us of the certainty of the Divine Testimony in the matters we have received ; yet such is the Moderation of our Church , she doth not require every one in her Communion , necessarily to know and receive all the reasons of certainty which are and may be given ; nor yet to rely on one to the neglect of another ; but leaves us to be satisfied according to the means and opportunities , which we have abundantly offered unto us : justly supposing there are so many reasons perswading the truth of what we believe , that some are convinced by some , others by others , as the Providence of God disposeth things .

3. Our Church no where makes infallible certainty of assent , a necessary condition of Faith : it being sufficient to make our Faith certain , if our Rule be infallible , and that applyed with moral evidence ; that is , such an evidence as we can have of things and actions past , as is sufficient to guide and govern our manners and behaviour .

Some of late have contended ( with very ill success ) that an infallible certainty of assent is necessarily wrought by demonstration ( and what they love to call scientific Evidence ) in every Believer : which doctrine of J. S. is condemned by his Adversaries , even of Rome p p Animadv . P. Talboti Arch. Dubl . in Prop. 2. p. 54. , as the pith of Manicheism : because it lays this burden on the Church , or an Oecumenical Council , evidently to demonstrate its own infallibility .

If destroying the first foundation of the Roman infallibility were all , we might dispense with that inconvenience , as it renders their motives of credibility insufficient , which before the doctrine of infallibility is received , used to be the only way they had to recommend the Church of Rome to the approbation of Proselytes : but to affirm , that all certainty of Christian Faith is generally wrought by such demonstration ; in case that doctrine proves false , the consequence is , If Christian Faith have no other certainty , Christianity it self is left uncertain in its very foundations .

Others there are who deliver , that an infallible certainty of assent wrought only by the immediate extraordinary operation of the Spirit of God , is necessarily in every true Believer .

Now , though our Church doth as much as any can do , own the necessity of Gods Grace and holy Spirit , to prevent , assist , and follow us ; especially in what concerns divine matters : yet our Church is not so bold with the Holy Spirit of God , to affirm , that such an inward testimony of the Divine Spirit ( working together in our Spirits an infallible assent ) is so necessary to assure us of the certainty of Faith , and of the authority of Holy Scriptures , and of the truth of other Doctrines in question ; as without which , we could have no such belief as is required to Salvation .

Which precarious presumption tends to render useless , all those sufficient evidences we have of Divine truth , by the gracious means which God hath appointed ordinary in his Church : and whereas the assertors of this extraordinary spirit , exclude all other means of real certainty as insufficient ; such a Doctrine being false , must needs tend also to overthrow all Christian Religion .

Such is the sad consequence of the Doctrines both of Dr I. O. and Mr I. S. in making ( though on differing grounds ) an infallible assent necessary to a true belief .

They agree together also in the injury they do Christian Religion , by traducing our Faith as a probable , fallible , humane , natural Faith , ( which are the very words they q q V. Dr I. O. Reason of Faith , p. 72. Mr I. S. Faith Vindicated . both unite in , to expose our belief to contempt ) which is grounded on such evidences as God hath abundantly afforded us , to assure us of the truth of his Divine Testimony . Which evidences , especially in matters of Faith , necessary to Salvation , since they are so plain and certain ; Our Church hath always held needless , such an infallible guide , as the Romanists would impose upon us : And for the same reasons that we do not expect any new Revelations , nor any ostentation of new miracles necessary to a true Church or true Faith ( they being superseded by the ordinary means of Faith which are sufficient : ) for the same reasons we cannot presume to expect ( much less to make necessary to every true belief ) such extraordinary illapses of the Divine Spirit ( which makes those who only think they have it , think themselves only infallible . ) And thus we may discern how many are led to Popery , by the way of Enthusiasm : For it is usual for those into whose head Enthusiasm is flown , to reel from one extream to another .

4. To preserve us from these uncertainties , among the very many reasons which we have from rational and moral evidence , whereby the truth of the Divine Testimony is confirmed to us abundantly ; Our Church owns no one greater ( since the miraculous gifts ) than the testimony of Gods Church , now and in all Ages since Christ and his Apostles time , because of the sundry Evidences also which confirm to us the truth of the Churches testimony : All which amount to more than high probability ; for as r r ● . Lomini Hi●l . & Consul . haeres . Blacklo . P. 2. c. 4. §. 5. Lominus tells J. S. Probability on one side doth not exclude probability also on the opposite side : but the reason of moral evidence and certainty , doth exclude any probability on the contrary part , and that so manifestly , that only grievous ignorance and pertinacy can incline a man thereunto .

§ . 9. As the Moderation of our Church allows us to be reasonably satisfied of the certainty of our Faith : much more are other doctrines so propounded to those of our Communion , as not to render useless their own reasons and judgments . Notwithstanding our Church doth sufficiently vindicate her own just power , and the authority of what she testifies and determines , Article 20. 34. &c. and by her Canons requires a just submission : All care being also taken by the Church to prevent error , and dissentions , and wresting the Scriptures : ( Canon 34. 49. 139. )

Yet all is performed among us with a most excellent and golden mean : And in that nothing in our Church is determin'd contrary to truth , nor the judgment of the Catholick Church , nor right reason , the Church of England can the better allow her Sons their right to search , examine and discern , what they must approve : Which Bishop Davenant , and Bishop Bramhall , and some others , understand by their judgment of discretion : though the word sounds not so pleasing to some Religious Ears , because it seems by the use of the phrase in English , to incline private persons to a power of refusing what the Church rightly determines , which is not to be allowed : For as the suffrage of our Church hath been constantly unanimous with that of the Apostle , We can do nothing against the truth but for the truth : much more ought private persons to be bounded thereby , if the Apostles and the Church are .

The Moderation of the Church will appear the more remarkable if we compare it with other extreams .

The Church of Rome calls her self the Mother and Mistress of all other Churches s s Credo & agnosco Ro. Eccl. omnium Ecclesiarum Matrem & Magistram . Bulla Pii IV. Vid. Concil. Trid. Sess . 7. Can. 3. Con●il . Rom. sub Greg. 7. Concil. Lugd. Concil. Flor. Concil. Lat. sub Lion . X. S●ss . 2. ; holds her self and her Bishop the Universal Monarch . Supreme over the whole Catholick Church diffusive , and over all particular Churches and Bishops : Infallible also , in determining all Controversies , in interpreting all Scriptures ; in whatsoever Articles he or they please to add to our Faith .

Hereupon he requires an absolute obedience from all , without allowing any judgment of discerning , instead thereof , commanding an implicite Faith , and which is more insolent , not from private Christians only within its own district , but over all other Christian Churches in the World : Which our Church in the 5th Homily against wilful Rebellion , calls an intolerable usurpation .

I shall not stay the Reader to compare t t Ita in Talmude quando due Rabbini in contrarias sententias diversi abeunt , neminem ob●●qui debere , utru●● ; enim Doctrinam suam accepisse per Traditionem oral●● à monte Sinai : Amborum verba etsi contradictoria verba sunt Dei viventis . Buxtorf . Synag . Jud. c. 1. the Church of Rome with the model of Mr Hobs his City ; but to set out the show , we may cast an eye upon the other extreme of those , who because some under the name of the Church Catholick , assume so unmeasurably to themselves ; therefore affrighted thereat , have seem'd to run out of their wits into another excess ; and in the place of the Church and its true authority , have set up their own private Images , diversly by them called ; whereby they have only chang'd the Idol u u Idolum fori in Idolum specus . Verulamius . ; like some that pull'd down the Crosses , and then set up other inventions of their own , every jot as unreasonable .

The Romanists ( saith Bishop Sanderson x x De oblig : Consc. Prael : 4. §. 25. ) while they use all endeavour that nothing be lost of the authority of their Church , they allow little to reason : On the other hand the Socinians rejecting all authority of the Church , they measure Faith only by reason : there is one error to both , though it deceives under various shapes : either Rock , will be avoided , if authority with reason , and reason with authority , be discreetly join'd .

Among the intemperate Assertors of humane reason some have supposed , There are no mysteries in Religion but such as their humane reason adaequately comprehends ; and have declared , That submitting our judgment to authority , or any thing else whatsoever , gives universality and perpetuity to every error . [ in a late Tract of Humane Reason , p. 4. ] That they are most guilty of Schism who will not allow difference of opinions : ( p. 37. ) These Diseases of the Soul ( errors ) are not so deadly as the Physicians of the Soul make them for the exalting of their own reputation : That under various errors all may retain the same entire Conscience and Obedience toward God ( p. 19. p. 39. ) That all opinions may be lawfully held and maintained .

How well in our Church all these Rocks and Gulss on either hand are avoided , by that accurate Moderation by which she governs us ; in this Chapter , and divers other places of this Treatise will appear .

As for the Romanists , that we may with one Shovel cast away that heap of Controversy ; let me here only repeat what from the Church of England they have often heard ; Let the Romanists bring their Books , and shew us one lawful proof where there is appointed any such Infallible Judge or Interpreter ; and that from some stronger Authority than that of Pasce Oves y y Mirabile est quot officia , quot dignitates , quot potestates unic● illo Pasce contineantur . Spalatensis l. 7. ; otherwise , we shall presume that our Blessed Saviour knew better than they how to procure the Peace of his Church , and the Salvation of Mankind .

Wherefore the Church of England owns no such living Oracles upon Earth as the Church of Rome pretends to ; our Church hath no publick Conscience , nor publick Faith , nor publick Merits of her own which she makes shew of to invite to her Communion , much lefs to set to sale for Worldly lucre sake : She saith with the Apostle : z z 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . — Gal. 6. 4 , 5. Qui noll●t cúm debet 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 do●ec 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 inv●●t●● it , id à D●o justè impetret ut eum tradat 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . i. e. In s●n●●m m●●temque quae nec probet Deum neque approbetur à D●o . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , ▪ &c. Rom. 1. 28. Let every one prove his own work , and then he shall have rejoicing in himself alone , and not in another ; for every man shall bear his own burden . According to this Apostolical Equity and Moderation , our Church doth no where go about to take from those of her Communion , that fundamental right of Christianity , as well as of humane nature ; to discern and examine what they must know , and what they must assent to , in a matter of such great and intimate concern as is our Religion ; especially , since the sober use of our reasons and judgments , is most agreeable to the nature of Mankind ; and the very frame of our Religion doth admit and invite such a search , which the more it is made , the more reasons are discovered to convince our minds of its truth a a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Origen . l. 1. : Yea , the very Laws of our Religion , do require such a voluntary and reasonable service , as is the effect of right judgment , as well as of conformable wills and affections : And the more we improve our powers by their use and exercise , and our inward senses to discern and compare the Truths of God one with another , and the clear consequences which may be drawn from them , the more we may advance our Faith , and Knowledge , and spiritual Comfort b b Oportet in e● re maximè in quâ vitae ratio ver●atur , sibi quemque considere suoque judicio & propriis sensibus uti ad investigan●um veritatem ; quàm credentem aliis erroribus decipi tanquam rationis expertem : Quare cùm sapere , id est veritatem quaerere omnibus sit i●natum , sapientiam sibi adimunt qui sine ullo judicio inventa probant majorum & pecudum more ducuntur . Lactantius l. 4. c. 8. .

For indeed nothing hath more obstructed a great and laudable progress of all sorts of knowledge in the Christian World , than some mean and servile abdications , which some men of great understandings have made of their own judgments . For as in the Church there are grievous inconveniencies by renouncing the due government of the Church ; so on the other extream , no where have errors grown more thick and tough than where men have suffered themselves in all things to understand by Proxy ; such are in ready disposition to swallow all Poysons , and are liable to the guilt , not only of their first solitary error , but all which are consequent thereon : whereas those who use a sober examination , after they are convinced of one error , will be more cautious of others ; and the truth they come to of choice and judgment , is also more praise-worthy and more tenible .

I should swell this head into too great a bulk , if I should enumerate the sundry places wherein our Blessed Lord , and his Holy Apostles , did stir up and provoke the industry of the Christian Disciples ; to search , discern , prove , try , examine what they received , lest at any time they were seduced by false Prophets : The same admonitions and method have the ancient Fathers of the Church persued . Both which would be endless here to recite .

Indeed all sorts of perswasions of men , seem to confess the necessity of first convincing the reason and judgment of what is to be received as truth : And therefore the Romanists use so many motives of credibility to induce belief of their Church , in which , if once the Proselyte is caught , they serve him as the Chaldees did King Zedekiah , after they had taken him Captive , they put out his Eyes c c Caeco judicio imperata facere quantumvis ea blasphema sint atque impia . Apol. Eccl. Anglic. §. 138. : ( 2 Kings 25. 7. )

Where indeed the mystery we are sure is certainly declared and delivered by God , there we ought to captivate , not only our imaginations , but our reasons , to the obedience of Faith ; not staying for a connexion of the parts of the Proposition to be believed by Scientific evidence : ( which Mr Sergeant makes his Sure-footing : ) But where we are not assured of the matter of fact of the Divine Revelation ; nor otherwise understand the reasons for such an assent ; No one can put off humane nature so far , as to believe what they please d d Nullus credit aliquid verum esse quia vult credere id esse verum , nam non est in potestate hominis sacere aliquid apparer● intellectui suo verum quando voluerit . Picus Mirandula . .

Indeed it is the great honour of our Church , that it doth not testify nor require attestation unto any thing but where some good reason why we do so is sufficiently manifest ; which right as she maintains toward others , so she vindicates the same to her self : namely , of examining what is offered to her under the venerable name of the Catholick Church ; and if need be , of reforming any abuses or errors within the bounds of its own Discipline ; and so separating the pretious from the vile ; which power of examining Doctrines being forbid by the Church of Rome to her Sons , seems to prevent the first occasion and means of Reformation e e 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . De Eutychianis inter Athanasii opera . Consulatur integer Tractatus . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . , and renders her even incorrigible in her errors and corruptions , and remaining so , irreconcilable .

But some do Object : That if we allow a right of private judgment , it will be a direct means to establish among us an enthusiastic private Spirit , which will rely upon its own judgment to the despising all others : and if all may use a private judgment , why may they not follow it and profess it ? Then you open a Window to all Divisions and Heresies , and render the Church useless , and all her Guides .

We Answer : It is one thing to use our Faculties of discerning in a discreet manner , which includes all due Reverence to all those instruments which God and the Church have given us for our direction and conduct : and another thing , to rely on our own prudence , to wrest the Scripture to our own sense ( as the Council of Trent f f Nemo prudentiae suae innixus S. Scripturam ad suos sensus contorqueat . Conc. Trid. Sess. 4. Decr. 2. speaks ) which the Church of England first of all detests : [ Article 20. ] Every private person being here required to hear and obey the publick reason of our Church : Which being also clear and true , can allow the being searcht into ; and for that purpose she desires but her Sons to open their own Eyes : Wherefore the sober use of our own faculties , ought not to be called a private Spirit ; which judgeth according to the general notices of Truth and Good , and the common sense of Mankind , and the judgment also of the Church : such a Spirit is the Candle of the Lord . Not an evil Spirit , nor a Spirit of Innovation , nor Dissention , nor a Spirit of Pride , nor Temptation : as many of the Church of Rome blazon it .

As for the growth of Schisms and Heresies , from the use of such a private judgment as the Church allows : ( Which Objection was anciently made against the Christian Religion , as of old , by Celsus to Origen : ( l. 3. ) Unto which was answered , That where any thing was received which was very excellent , such differences were common ; as among the Philosophers and Jews , so among Christians : but ) These now who make the Objection ( generally those of the Romish Communion ) yet know , that though they carry as well as they can an outward shew of unity to their people . they have as great divisions as any are : And though indeed the corruption of good things is greatest by the abuse of ill men ; This ill consequence through the Vice of some , ought not to take away the common right of all , no more , than the contentions which arise from the Laws , should be thought to render them dangerous to be proclaimed . The Christian Religion of it self is sufficient to keep all from error or vice , if all men would comply with its wholsome and pacific Decrees ( as Arnobius g g Quòd si omnes omnino salutaribus ejus pacificisque decretis aurem vellent accommodare paulisper , & non fastu & supercilio Luminis suis potius sensibus quàm illius Comminationibus crederent , universus jamdudum orbis mitiora in opera conversis usibus ferri , tranquillitate mollissimâ degeret , & in Concordiam salutarem incorruptis foederum sanctionibus conveniret . Arnobius l. 1. long since hath delivered : ) And the Church in observance hereof , doth procure her own Peace as much as may be , in that all are bound not to publish their private sense to the detriment of publick Peace , and by her Censures hath a power of repressing publick Dissenters ; and in case of doubt arising , our Church wisely sends the parties so doubting to their Superiours h h Preface concerning the Service of the Church . .

And whereas Gods true Religion is but one , the profession of which ( Article 19. ) and no other ( Article 18. ) is absolutely necessary to the being of Gods Church , and therein to our Salvation : Blessed be God , in our Church there is abundant care taken of Gods Holy Religion , both by the Laws of the Kingdom and Church , for the instruction and government of its members unto edification and peace : and every one may be satisfied in his Conscience and Judgment , of the Religion he professeth . Yet , This reserves him not a right of liberty in Religion ; but only supposeth that he hath a right of trying , examining , and using his best judgment , in order to the satisfaction of his Conscience : which right , if he duly useth , it will certainly fix him in the true Religion ; whether that Religion be professed by his Prince , or Nation , or no : [ 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ] Prove or try all things ; Hold fast that which is good : saith the Apostle , 1 Thess. 5. 21. Here is a right to try , examine , and judge , but no right or liberty in Religion : This tryal is only in order to the holding fast that which is good i i Dr J. Beaumonts Observations upon the Apology , 1665. As the Royal Coyn , no one can refuse , every one may examine , and try the same , before he receives it : So every Christian keeping himself within the bounds of due obedience and submission to his lawful Superiours , hath a judgment of Discretion : He may apply the rule of Holy Scripture , for his own private instruction , comfort , edification and direction , and for the framing of his Life and belief accordingly : The Pastors of the Church — have more than this , a judgment of direction , to expound and interpret the Scriptures to others , and out of them to instruct the ignorant , &c. The Chief Pastors — have yet a higher judgment of Jurisdiction to prescribe , to enjoin , to constitute , to reform , to censure , to condemn , to bind , to loose judicially , authoritatively in their respective charges k k Bishop Bramhall's Answer to M. Militeira , p. 72. .

Thus the danger of using a private judgment , is prevented . If it be further Objected , 2. That such a permission is vain , because of the impossibility in the vulgar to make use of it : We Answer : That such a meer ineptitude doth not take away ones right l l Vt ratus sit actus pauciora requiruntur quàm ut recta sit actio . Grotius de Imperio . pag. 111. .

Beside , our Gracious God requires of none otherwise than according to that ability which he hath given . Wherefore the Moderation of our Church imitates the grace of God herein ; which requires nothing necessarily but what is so clearly propounded as to leave all inexcusable : and therefore those that have skill to look to themselves in the common business of Life , may discern as much as is required : Those who have not use of their abilities ( the Idiotae ) the Moderation of the Church leaves to the mercy of God , and the care of their Governours , so far as they are capable ; for as Origen argues , when Celsus objected to the Christians , that they did ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 m m Origen c. Celsum l. 1. believe without any reason or examination : The contrary thereunto Origen shews at large : Yet of the vulgar , he saith , indeed it is impossible that all people should attain to the reasons of all Doctrines . How can he get wisdom who is diligent to give the Kine Fodder , &c. ( Eccles. 38. 26. )

Wherefore ( saith Origen ) what more compendious way could be contrived to relieve the poor multitude , than the plain doctrine of Jesus ; for this we find by experience , that they that before wallowed in Vice , thereby now are delivered : but why should the Stoicks and Platonists quarrel at Christians for believing , when all of them believe those they apply themselves to , in the Sect they judge most excellent ?

§ . 10. So great being the Moderation of our Church ; because ( never the less , as the temper of men generally now is among us , since these licentious times especially have corrupted them ) the most are very captious of what hath the femblance of priviledge ( and such also are most apt to neglect their duty ) It is very great justice and equity , that all be convinced of the due submission we also owe to the Church , in reference to this matter : The sum of which duty , I shall lay down in such brief Propositions as are agreeable to an easy reason to infer from the comparing of relations .

1. All good Christians who love the Church of God , and its Peace , will for Truth and Conscience sake , hearken to the Church , and those set over them , on purpose to guide and direct them : especially in case of doubt .

2. Such will well weigh the moments of reasons which the Church offers , and be ready with all due regard to entertain what the Church resolves : and readily also approve of those resolutions , unless it appear manifestly , that such determinations contradict the word of God , and the sense of the Universal Church ; which no good man will unadvisedly conceive , much less seek occasions for exception .

3. In a doubtful and equal Case , such will encline to what is publickly determin'd : because of the relation of superiority between the Church and its Members : and because of the many great advantages they know the Church hath in its judgment above themselves ; because also the better any are , and the more humble and sincere , the more they are prepared to suspect and distrust their own judgments , and not to lean unto their own understandings .

4. If in any case it should happen that such should differently opine or judge , however such will afford a practical submission in many Cases which they may and ought ; the liberty of their own thoughts remaining , which is sufficient , if they cannot but dissent . Modest and pious persons will upon many occasions have their Faith to themselves , and reserve their different apprehensions in a continent silence , which is to be wise unto sobriety .

5. If before they come to know the judgment of the Church , they should go about to divulge their sense in speaking or writing , such will do it with submission to the Church , and to those to whom is committed the care of censure . If there should happen such a lawful and necessary occasion which they cannot avoid , to declare their apprehension different from the Church ; If the dissenter errs , and cannot submit with consent , he must e'ne bear patiently the inconvenience of his error : which , if in a less principal matter , on this side Heresy and Schism , such an infirmity n n Aliter sapere quam se res habet , humana tentatio est . S. Aug. de Bapt. l. 2. , and temptation incident to humane nature happen o o Qualiter pro hoc ipso falsae opinionis errore in die judicii puniendi sunt , nullus potest scire nisi judex . Salvianus de gubern . Dei , c. 11. §. 4. :

They that would retain their integrity , must preserve ,

1. An entire Charity to others .

2. A reverent respect to the Church , and as much as is possible an inviolable Communion therewith .

3. Such ought to endeavour to comply in other points more diligently .

4. Such ought to profess their dissent from the Church with great reluctancy and sorrow .

5. They must be very willing to own their error when they are convinced thereof . In the mean while they are bound to lay it aside .

Whereby retaining inviolable Communion with the Church , such already being in preparation of mind disposed to renounce their error when they know it to be such , are in a hopeful and ready way to be reduced .

Lastly , If the dissenter from the Church err not , but the Church doth manifestly enjoin unjust conditions of its Communion ; whoever they are who from the word of God Catholickly interpreted , and the use of their own reasons come into the profession of the true Faith and Christian Doctrine , If they are divided from that part of the Church which is unjust in its conditions of union , ( they themselves not being the cause of the Division ) they in very deed ( notwithstanding ) are united mean while to the Church Catholick .

I conclude this Chapter with that in the Answer to the Bishop of Condom . ( Part. 6. p. ● . ) Error as Vice , is for the most part in extreams ; we owe respect , teachableness and submission unto all them whom God sets over us to instruct us ; this is not contested : But this is no reason , to change this submission into voluntary blindness , which is rather a Spirit of servitude .

CHAP. VII . Of the Moderation of our Church in what relates to the worship of God .

§ . 1. Our Prayers are not mingled with controversy . § . 2. They are framed according to a most grave and serious manner , with moderate variety , and proper length . § . 3. In the zeal of Reformation our Church did not cast off what was good in it self . § . 4. In all our Churches there are the same Rules . § . 5. Common Prayers for the vulgar required in English . To Ministers and Scholars a just and moderate liberty allowed . § . 6. The obligation of the Church leaves the method of private Devotions to a general liberty . § . 7. Of the Moderation of the Church , in appointing her hours and times of Prayer . § . 8. In her use and judgment of Sermons . § . 9. In what is required of people with reference to their Parish Church . § . 10. The excellent Moderation of the Church in her Orders for the reverent reading of Divine Service , and Consecrating the Sacraments in such a voice as may be heard . § . 11. In her Form and use of Catechizing . § . 12. The interest of inward and outward worship , are both secured according to an excellent Moderation in our Church . § . 13. The Moderation of the Church in what relates to Oaths .

§ . 1. IN treating of the Moderation of our Church , in what relates to the Divine Worship ; I first speak of Prayer ( because the matter of the Sacraments is handled by it self , Ch. 10. ) In our publick Prayers , our Churches Moderation is apparent , in that it never intended to intermingle matters of doubtful Controversy ; but hath sufficiently provided for the simplicity of the plainest , and the devotion of the most intelligent : Thus our Bishops according to great Moderation also , justified our Church in their debate with the Presbyterian Brethren .

The Church hath been careful to put nothing into the Liturgy , but what is either evidently the word of God , or what hath been generally received in the Catholick Church ; neither of which can be called private opinion : and if the contrary can be proved , we wish it out of the Liturgy . Yet , because as ( Bishop Taylor saith ) they could not Prophesie ; they put in some things which since have been called into question a a Exorti sunt in Angliâ , morosi , scrupulosi & delicatuli nimium ( ne superstitiosos planè dicam ) homines , quibus Ecclesiae suae hactenus usurpata Liturgia , visa est multis abroganda , &c. Ludo. Capellus de Liturg. by persons whose interest was highly concerned to find fault with something b b Quaedam sunt quae rapi possunt ab inquietis in materiam contentionis . Bucer . de Liturgiâ Anglic. .

§ . 2. Our Prayers are framed , both according to a grave , modest , and serious manner ; every one of them being moderately short , and all together not immoderately long ; and so , more accommodate to render Devotion more earnest and intent : and properly intermitted by other parts of Divine Service , that by a moderate variety , the Devotions of Christians may be both entertained and advantaged . And to stir up Devotion in Christian people , they bear in our Church a moderate part in the publick Prayers and Praises : for ( as Mr Baxter well notes c c Christian Direct . p. 856. ) It was the decay of zeal in the people , that first shut out the Responses : The use of the tongue keepeth awake the mind , and stirreth up Gods Graces in his Servants : and so much doth the edification of the people give measure to the appointments of our Church , that the parts of Divine Service are to be used in the accustomed place of the Church , Chappel , or Chancel ; Or in such place as the Bishop of the Diocess , or Ecclesiastical Canon 14 ▪ Ordinary of the place shall think meet for the largeness or straitness of the same , so as the people may most be edifyed .

§ . 3. The Moderation of the Church is always to be admired , That in the heat of Reformation , when the Essays were first had for the refining our Liturgy from Romish corruption and innovation ; our Church was not so transported with zeal , but that it retained what was pious and profitable among the Prayers in use : And whereas generally oppositions are most fierce at first , and in process of time they become moderate ; the excellent temper of our Church was such , it was most moderate at first : which wisdom and mercy of God , in tempering the Spirits of the first Reformers , can never be enough taken notice of : Wherefore the use of some Collects and passages in our Liturgy , which before were had in the Romish Communion ; is so far from being a real argument against our Church , that it is a proper proof of our Churches just Reformation , that it maintained its freedom from prejudice and passion , in the midst of its zeal . If some parts of the Prayers themselves , and Liturgy , have been drawn into matter of debate ; it is no more than what all words and writings are liable to , when they meet with those who are concern'd to be displeas'd : But the exceptions against them being such , that ( I speak my Conscience in what I know ) the most probable means to reconcile any to a just apprehension of our Liturgy , and to confirm them in the same , is well to consider the feeble weakness of the exceptions which are used against it : Which King James noted long since ; How mighty and vehement informations against the Common Prayer , were supported with weak and slender proofs ! But ( saith the King d d King James's Proclamation for Uniformity , 1603. ) we were nice , or rather jealous , that the publick Form thereof should be free , not only from blame , but from suspicion ; so as neither the common adversary should take advantage , nor the troublesome at home cavil ; between which two sorts of Adversaries , the Moderation of the Church hath always been tryed .

So that all these things considered , Archbishop Cranmer e e Archbishop Cranmer's Letter . had very good reason to declare , that he with some others , he should chuse , would ( by Gods Grace ) take upon him to defend not only the Common-Prayers of the Church , the Ministration of Sacraments , and other Rites and Ceremonies ; but also the Doctrine and Religion set out by King Edw. VI. to be more pure , and according to Gods word , than any other used in England these thousand Years , &c.

§ . 4. In all the Churches of this Kingdom , Cathedral and Parochial , the Church now hath moderately appointed the same Rules and Cautions , and the same use among us every where , and those few in number , plain and easy to be understood ; f f The Preface to the Common-Prayer Book . Whereas the Rubricks and Orders of the Church of Rome , are so innumerable , intricate , and various , that scarce an Apprentiship may suffice to learn the practice of them ; which , whether it suit with the simplicity of the Christian Gospel , may without difficulty be judged . Among us an easy Calendar is prefixt , with few Canons and Prescriptions , and those very intelligible : wherein according to an excellent Moderation the People have their parts for excitation sake , and to unite their affections : ( although no where in what is properly ministerial . )

§ . 5. The Moderation of our Church is sufficiently known to the whole World , in requiring our Common Prayers to be in the vulgar tongue , for the general benefit of all ; According to our 24. Article . It is a thing plainly repugnant to the word of God , and the Custom of the Primitive Church ; to have publick Prayer in the Church , or to administer the Sacraments in a tongue not understood of the people . Which Article is further confirmed and proved in the Homilies , especially in that of Common-Prayer and Sacraments : from the nature and end of Prayer : Resolving also : As for the time since Christ , till that usurped power of Rome begun to spread it self , and to enforce all the Nations of Europe to have the Romish Language in admiration , it appeareth by the consent of the most ancient and learned Writers , there was no strange tongue used in the Congregation of Christians .

Yet for the same reason that common people should have their Prayers in English among us ; those who have been educated in sufficient learning , are allowed to use them in another tongue : as in Vniversities and Colleges . The use of the Latin Form of Prayers is also commended to the Ministers of the Church of England , by Queen Elizabeth's Letters , Dated April 6. 1560 g g Bishop Sparrow's Collection , and also the first Rubrick before the Preface of Ceremonies . . In all which , the Moderation of our Church doth comply ( as the Queens Letters doth express it ) with the necessity of those who do not understand other tongues , and the desire of those who de .

§ . 6. Notwithstanding , the Church hath provided most excellent Prayers , for the use of private devotion upon all general occasions , and what is readily and properly applicable to more occasions particular : yet the Moderation of the Church hath not thought fit any where , to bind all who are of her Communion to the use of her Common Prayers in private Families or Closets .

The Rubrick which enjoins , All Priests and Deacons , to say daily the Morning and Evening Prayer , either privately or openly , is set down with great Moderation .

Not being let by sickness , or some other urgent cause .

In the Family , or in Visitation of the sick , if the particular condition of the one or the other do require it ; and in private , and in the Closet , It is not supposed by our Church , but that every one may ask their own wants in what form of words he shall think fit h h Dr Hammonds Pract. Cat. of Prayer . . The Consideration of which Liberty indulged by the Church , caused I suppose another excellent Writer i i Dr Patricks Devout Christian , Preface . thus also to express himself : It is possible also , that some may judge this whole work to be but a needless labour , since they have the Book of Common Prayers at hand , which they can use at home as well as at the Church . With these persons I shall not contend , but only deliver my opinion freely about this matter : which is , that the reverence due to that Book , will be best preserved , by employing it only in the publick Divine Service , or in the private , where there is a Priest to officiate : However , the design of it is not to furnish the people with Prayers for all those particular occasions , wherein devout Souls would make their requests known to God ; and the constant opinions of pious Divines , in this and other Churches , we see by their Writings hath been , that other Books of Prayers are necessary for the flock of Christ , beside their publick Liturgy . Though in the choice of such Prayers as are so accommodate to the occasions of humane Life , and such Cases as are incidental to the spiritual needs and circumstances of Christian people , there hath been sometimes wished , some further advice and recommendation made common by Authority .

The 55. Canon thus directs , That before all Sermons , Lectures , and Homilies , Preachers and Ministers shall move the people to join with them in this Form , or to this effect : as briefly as conveniently they may [ in hunc aut similem modum . ] The Title in the Latine Canons is , Precationis formula à concionatoribus in Concionum suarum ingressu imitanda : In the English Canons , the Title is , A Form of Prayer to be used by Preachers before their Sermon .

From all which I only note , That the Moderation of the Church is certain and undoubted : But the disagreeing variety in practice consequent thereon ; whether it be so convenient , it remains for Superiours to judge .

§ . 7. Although some of the ancient Christians used the distinction of Hours of Prayer , which at first was thought orderly and useful , as a voluntary task ; and determining of the Christian Liberty of those , who profess Gods Service is perfect freedom : Yet our Church considering the common employment of most , and the natural infirmities of all , hath appointed and required only a daily Sacrifice of Morning and Evening Service ( as of constant observance ) not excluding , but inviting other voluntary oblations of a sincere Devotion to God according to our leisure and opportunity : But our Church doth no where countenance the novelties of those that put any trust in the bare recital only of a few Prayers k k Dr Cosins of the antient times of Prayer . , or place any vertue in the Bedroll , or certain number of them at such and such hours ; notwithstanding many of the said Prayers are also directed otherwise than Prayers should be .

§ . 8. Although according to the judgment of the Church , and in truth , the entire worship of God is complete in the Divine Service of the Church ( even as among the Jews ; Sacrifices , Prayers , and Thanksgivings , made up the entire notion of Divine Worship ; so under the Gospel , the Sacrifices of Prayer and Thanksgiving , do absolutely compleat the worship of God : ) yet our Church judgeth according to an excellent temper of the use and necessity of Sermons , acknowledging their great use as occasion requires , to convince , reprove , to excite and comfort Christian people : Let Archbishop Laud be heard for once by those who have doubted his judgment in this matter l l Archbishop Laud , §. 16. Num. 31. . I ever took Sermons and do still , to be the most necessary Expositions and applications of Holy Scripture , and a great ordinary means of Salvation : ( To the same purpose , Hooker's Eccles. Pol. l. 2. §. 22. ) Neither hath the Church of God , ever had any where more useful , practical , and judicious Preachers , than those , who with the Church of England , have thus ingenuously and equally judged of the use and necessity of Preaching : on one hand esteeming its real use and benefit ; on the other hand , not judging it the chief exercise of Religion , and the worship of God ; nor allowing , that for the hearing of a Sermon , which spends its Life in its Birth ( as Mr Hooker saith ) the Prayers of the Church should be slighted , neglected , or mangled m m In concione solâ totum fermè Divini cultûs ritum collocant , non tales erant antiquae & piae Synaxes . Ar. Spalat. l. 7. c. 12. .

At the Conference at Hampton-Court , the Bishop of London humbly desired his Majesty , That there might be a praying Ministry among us , it being now come to pass , that men think it the only duty of Ministers to spend their time in the Pulpit : I confess ( saith he ) in a Church newly to be planted , Preaching is most necessary , not so in one long established , that Prayer should be neglected . I like ( saith King James ) your motion exceeding well , and dislike the Hypocrisy of our time , who place all Religion in the Ear.

At the very dawning also of the Reformation , Preaching was also especially useful , and few were exercis'd therein , and had a right skill therein ; which made the Institution of a Christian man , ( set out 1537. ) because of the difficulty thereof , say : Surely the office of Preaching is the chief and most principal office , whereunto Priests or Bishops be called by the authority of the Gospel : though by Preaching there might be meant , the Annunciation of the Gospel , which is done by lively reading of the Scriptures , and in sundry other Ministerial Offices . Wherefore in the Church of England , we have the lively Oracles of the Holy Scriptures declared and read among us n n Coimus ad divinam Literarum commemorationem . Tert. Apol. : We have Catechising , and Expositions on the Church Catechism . We have also excellent Homilies too much despised for their plainness ; yet the same which Bucer o o Quid illi qui non sustineant audire erectis animis & cupidis tam breves easque tam salutares Homilias totas ? Censura M. Buceri . magnify'd , as short and wholsome Sermons : not only for the help of non-Preaching Ministers , but withal a pattern , and as it were a boundary for the Preaching Ministers : ( as King James hath it in his Directions , 1623. ) of which how modestly and moderately , doth the Church her self speak in its 35. Article : That they contain a Godly and wholsome Doctrine , necessary for these times .

We have also the Lives and Counsels of the Church's Ministers ( which are living Sermons too p p Vereor nè pancae extant inregno vivae conciones , Calv. Ep. 87. : ) So that among us , we have all sorts of Preaching , if the commonness of it did not make it despised . Great care also is taken for other Sermons too q q Canon . 45 , 46. Rubrick after the Nicene Creed . : Yea , our Church hath used all possible means , that the Preaching of her Ministers may be useful , and as they ought to be : as appears from the exhortations which are made at the Ordinations of Bishops , Priests , and Deacons , and the subscriptions which are made before the Bishops ; which are also incomparably enforced by r r V. librum quorundam Canonum , 1597. Can. 50. & C. 54. Q. Elizabeth's Articles for doctrine and Preaching , 1554. their Majesties directions from time to time : ( as hath been instanced , Ch. 6. §. 5. ) Notwithstanding , many are of the mind with those in Scotland , who esteemed the Directions of King James to Preachers , to be Limiting of the Spirit of God s s Spotswood History of Scotland , ad an. 1622. . What would they have thought of the Proclamation of King Edw. VI. which inhibited all Preaching throughout the Kingdom , that the Clergy might apply themselves unto Prayer : ( The Copy of which Inhibition , is in Fuller's Church History t t Fuller 's History Ec. ad . an. 1548. 2 Ed. 6. . )

In the Preface to the Directory , we see the Prelates accused for the crime of making Preaching inferiour to the Common-Prayer : which charge contains a fallacy like that of a complex Interrogation : For our Liturgy doth not exclude , but suppose and require Preaching : and doth contain in its daily Offices , sundry sorts of real Preaching : beside , Among professed Christians ought Preaching to contend with Prayer ? either as to the necessity of it , or dignity ; when Prayer is our duty to God immediately , and doth suppose people already instructed .

In the Notes on the view of the Civil and Ecclesiastical Law u u P. 3. Ch. 4. §. 3. , it is very well concluded . All this while we should not detract any thing from Preaching , considering our selves to live under a State so maturely composed , and so throughly advised and setled in the Faith ; it would be expected that we should so far moderate our opinion of Preaching , as that our magnifying thereof may no way tend to the discredit or disadvantage of most necessary Prayer .

Our Church doth not admit to the Office of Preaching , any but who are ordained and licensed thereunto : Yet our Church doth allow such kind of Sermons as we call in the Colleges , Common places , for the training up of Candidates in Divinity , and for their tryal of skill before competent Judges .

The Moderation in our Church is further known , in that among us its Ministers are not expected , nor do they endeavour to take the people in their Preaching by mysterious non-sense , or by storm and sensible noises , and uncouth tones and grimaces , whereby a tumult and confusion is rais'd in the animal passions ; scaring weak people almost out of their wits and common sense : just as the Valentinian Hereticks x x 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Euseb. Hist. l. 4. used hard words and thundring noises in their Conventicles to cause astonishment in the people : y y Nihil tam facile quàm vilem plebeculam & indoctam concionem linguae volubilitate decipere , quae quicquid non intellexit plus miratur . S. Hier. ad Nepotian . Ep. 3. Our design is otherwise , by a rational and sober surrender of their minds to gain our Hearers to truth and goodness : Whence it follows , that among such ( as Mr Hooker well notes z z Eccles. Pol. l. 5. §. 2. ) The vigour and efficacy of Sermons do grow from certain accidents , which are not in them but in their maker , his gesture , his zeal , his motion of body , inflexion of voice , &c.

Here it is not improper also to justify the Moderation and good reason our Church hath for the distinction it hath made between a Preaching , and a non-Preaching Minister a a Canon 46 , 67. Preface to the Homilies . ; who , though he be not so profoundly learned as others ( of which learned sort blessed be God we have some good abundance , ) yet if he be blameless in his Life , and faithful in his Office , and observant of the appointments of the Church , by the grace of God , there are so many helps ready provided by the wisdom of the Church among us , That a not-Preaching Minister may perform a Ministerial Office , both for the necessary edification of the people , and the just satisfaction of the Church , more than many Preaching Ministers , of whose discretion , and wise order , the Church cannot be so well secured . Hear we Archbishop Whitgift : b b Answer to the Admon . 1572. I am fully perswaded , That he cometh nearer the mind of the Apostle , who orderly preacheth once a Month , than some who are back-biters at other Mens Tables , and run up and down , seldom or never studying , though they preach twice a day .

For though no Church doth more promote and encourage the proficiency of her Sons in all useful literature , yet the Church thinks it not reason to reject the Ministry of a not-preaching Minister , otherwise reasonably qualified ( Can. 34. ) where it is necessary ; especially , when as the Church declares , the Sacraments are effectually administred by them that have not the gift of Preaching ( Artic. 26. ) The care of the Church is also to be taken notice of ; in requiring those who are beneficed to procure at least a Sermon to the people once a Month c c Can. 46 , 47. : And especially , there being wholsome Homilies for the other Days ; the Church hath done her part in providing for the spiritual sustenance of her Children , both for their necessity and entertainment : and those who can Preach , as ( Blessed be God ) there are many , think it their duty to do the same , frequently and constantly .

§ . 9. The order of the Church is also , That none neglect their own Parish Church : and with great reason to avoid unspeakable confusion : Yet even in d d Stat. 1. R. Eliz. c. 2. 32 Eliz. c. 1. Q. Elizabeth's Injunctions , 1559. §. 33. the Precept is exprest with this indulgence , Except it be by the occasion of some extraordinary Sermon in some Parish of the same Town : and in the Articles for enquiry , in the first Year of her Reign ; one was , Whether you know any that in contempt of their own Parish Church , do resort to any other Church : So in the Homily e e The Homily of the right use of the Church . , 't is said , That to the said House or Temple of God , at all times , by common order appointed , are all people that be Godly indeed , bound with all diligence to resort ; unless by sickness , or other most urgent causes , they be letted therefrom : So willing was always our Church , and the Constitution of the Kingdom , to allow all reasonable Liberty , provided it might not be abused : No Man ( saith the Bishop of London-Derry , in his Vindication ) was ever punisht for instructing his own Family , but it may be for holding unlawful Conventicles ; or for instructing them in Seditious , Schismatical , or Heretical Principles : Nor for going to the next Parish to hear a Sermon : thousands did it daily , and never suffered for it : But it may be for neglecting , or deserting his Parish Church f f Quisque in suâ Parochiâ sacris coetibus ad●● & ibi Christi Ceremoniis vacet , Sacramentaque omnia percipiat , ut qui haec sacere ●●●ligal , Excommunicetur . Eucer . de Eccs . Angl. Censura , c. 3. , and gadding up and down after Non-Conformists , and strange unknown Forms of serving God .

§ . 10. Because ( as Bucer observed ) too many did not in the reading or reciting the Divine Service , use that devout , reverent , and intelligible manner as was fit ; The special care of the Church hath always been very great of this : as appears from the admonition to all Ministers Ecclesiastical , in the beginning of the second Part of the Homilies ; and in Queen Elizabeth's Injunctions , 1559. and in the several Articles for enquiry : by all which all care is taken , g g Vi. Librum quorundam Canonum , 1571. That all Ministers , and Readers of publick Prayers , Chapters , and Homilies , shall be charged to read leisurely , plainly , and distinctly h h 39 Article 35. ; and the Rubrick requires the Minister , to read the Lessons standing , and turning himself so as he may best be heard of all such as are present .

Which Precepts contain as much as the general Missal i i Liquet omnino requiri ut Ministri Ecclesiarum has preces , Psalmos & conciones recitent summâ gravitate , & religione , disertè quoque & perspicué . Bucer . de Ordin . Eccl. Anglic. c. 1. Canatur & legatur drticulatim explanatè & reverendo gestu ad aedificationem orantis interea laici . Wicelii Meth. concor . c. 17. Rubricks , which require the Priest to read neither too precipitantly fast , nor too morosely slow ; with a voice mean and grave , fit to excite Devotion , and which is accommodate to the Hearers .

But whereas in the Mass , the Romanists are enjoin'd a secret and private whispering ; In our Church it is otherwise Ordered for the common benefit : which Order our Homily of the Common-Prayer and Sacraments defends , from divers testimonies of Scriptures and Doctors , and the Constitution of Justinian k k Justin . Novel . Constit. 23. , who lived 527 Years after Christ , which is this .

We Command that all Bishops and Priests do celebrate the Holy Oblation , and the Prayers in Holy Baptism , not speaking low , but with a clear or loud voice , which may be heard of the people , that thereby the minds of the hearers may be stirred up with great Devotion , in uttering the Prayers of the Lord God , for so that Holy Apostle teacheth in his first Epistle to the Corinthians , c. 14. Therefore for these causes it is convenient , that among other Prayers , those things also which are spoken in the holy Oblation , be uttered and spoken ( of the most religious Priests , unto our Lord Jesus Christ our God , with the Holy Ghost ) with a loud voice . Which is , as our Homily takes notice , a plain Decree of Justinian , for Praying and Administring of Sacraments in a known tongue , contrary to the opinion of them that would have ignorance make devotion .

To this head of right reading the Divine Service , belongs the Order of our Church to use the Divine Service in publick , as Order hath prescribed l l Non transcu●●●ndo 〈◊〉 Syncopando Syn. Ling. 14 4. Can. 14. : not chopping and changing , adding and plucking away m m Second Part of the Homily for Whit-sunday . , as the Homily speaks of the Romanists intermingling their own Traditions .

Yet though the Church doth not allow her Clergy to mangle her Offices ; yet , where need is , remissions are allow'd ; as in the Office of private Baptism , Communion of the sick , and the like .

And if any Liberties left to the prudence and discretion of the Ministers , be a proper instance of the Moderation of the Church , many might be given which are allowed ( with which , such may be contented : ) as in some cases where some present resolution and practice is required ; in other matters of less concern , where an indifferent variety is allowed : but more instances there are of what is left to the discretion of the Ordinary n n See the Preface concerning the Service of the Church , Canon 53. Second Rubrick before the Preface of the Ceremonies . Admon . to Min. Eccles. before the second Part of the Homilies . Sundry Rubricks . .

§ . 11. Having spoken of the Moderation and Wisdom of the Church in what relates to Sermons : because Catechising o o Canon 59. 1603. Lib. quor . Canonum . 1571. is an useful sort of Preaching , I cannot but note the Moderation of the Church , in framing such a Form of Catechism , as the ancient Fathers p p S. Aug. de Catechizandis rudibus . S. Ambros . de iis qui S. Mysteriis initiantur . commended . So full and comprehensive is the Exposition of the foundations of our Religion , and yet without those curious questions which are not needful to trouble the green heads of those who are to be Catechised ; however , which are not to be set forth as fundamental . This was the excellent judgment of King James q q Conference at Hampton-Court . , who approved of one uniform Catechism , in the fewest and plainest affirmative terms that may be , all curious and deep questions being avoided : not like the ignorant Catechisms in Scotland , set out by every one who was the Son of a good Man . Thus the judicious r r Pax Ecclesiae , p. 54. Bishop Sanderson , for the Peace of the Church , and to preserve Unity and Charity ; his third direction is , That Catechisms should not be farced with School points and private tenets , but contain only clear and undoubted Truths . Whereas the Church of Rome , and many other Sects , have stuft their Catechisms with some of their private opinions ; even so much , that sometimes their Catechisms are not only to contain the sums of Christianity , but they are the distinctive notes of their party , in maintaining which , some of them place so great a part of Religion ; and therefore no wonder , if according to their great wisdom in other things , they enamel their Catechisms with what is to them so pretious .

I shall only here add , what Dr Hammond saith , of this our Church Catechism s s Vindication of the ancient Liturgy of the Church of England , §. 40. : If we would all keep our selves within that Moderation , and propose no larger Catalogue of Articles to be believed by all than the Apostles Creed , as 't is explain'd in our Catechism , and lay greater weight upon the Vow of Baptism , and all the Commands of God , as they are explain'd by Christ , and only add the Explication and use of the Sacraments , in those commodious and most intelligible expressions ( and none other ) which are there set down ; I should be confident there would be less hating and damning one another , more Piety and Charity , and so true Christianity among Christians and Protestants , than hitherto hath been met with .

§ . 12. This Chapter ought not to be dismissed before we take notice , how the interest both of the inward and outward worship of God , is according to a just Moderation secured in our Church .

For 1. In all the Instructions and Precepts of the Church , Her designs and intent appear very sincere to promote the worship of God according to his Will : Wherefore our Church makes none else partakers of the Divine Worship ; as neither Saints nor Angels , nor the Blessed Virgin .

The Ceremonies ( as will be further shewed ) are not held by our Church as any part of the Divine Worship : but only outward signs and helps of Devotion . Our Church lays also greatest stress upon the inward affection and intention of the mind , as the most necessary and principal part of the Divine Worship ; as that which only can render all outward expressions of our Honour of God acceptable : Because in the affection of the Heart is the consummation of all moral goodness t t Actus exterior nihil addit bonitatis aut malitiae actui interiori nisi per accidens . D. Tho. 1. 2● . q. 20. Art. 4. ; especially in the worship of God ; For the best Being is to be served with the most excellent operations of our best Faculties ; Therefore God , who is the most Excellent , most Infinite , and most pure Spirit , must be worshipped in Spirit and in Truth ; in due regard to which just consideration , all the Offices of our Church are framed , so as to promote chiefly a due sense of God , and of the Divine Attributes ; a Heavenly and spiritual disposition of Mind , a real and unaffected Piety , a sincere and hearty Devotion : For ( as the Homily saith u u Of Holy Scripture , first Part. ) Without a single eye , pure intent , and good mind ; nothing is allowed for good before God . But notwithstanding , the inward worship of the Heart is held most necessary and principal ; in our Church is instantly required the outward worship of God also : as in all acts of outward as well as inward obedience ( in many of which , the affection cannot be sincere , without the outward exercise of such acts , when they can be performed ) as in consecrating also a just portion of our time and Estates to the honour of God , the humble service of our bodies , reverend gestures and behaviour , which are but proper and fit to encrease in our selves and others the inward honour of God also : In respect to both these parts of worship , those who duly honour God , may be fitly denominated devout persons . But the probable reason why many who call themselves Saints , do disdain the name of Devout , is , because the Attribute of Devotion seems to intimate also the outward reverent behaviour of body , as the necessary Companion of the inward integrity of the mind ; which outward reverence such judge too meanly of .

Lastly , In our Church , the worship of God is supposed to proceed , not so much from a principle of fear and dread , as of love and thankfulness : Whereas some in a way to overthrow all Religion , have given out , That the fear of God is only the dread men have of some unknown , arbitrary , and uncontroulable power : Such a fear , they suppose the only motive to the worship of God ; the only foundation and bond of Justice : An Experiment taken up to keep men obedient to Laws . The Moderation of our Church governs it self very justly in this matter , accounting the due fear of the Soveraignty and power of God , very useful to the good as well as the bad , to make all heedful and careful in their duty : Therefore in the Office of Commination , as in many other places also , the threats of God against impenitent Sinners , are by our Church denounced : Yet the first and the chief reason of our worship of God , is frequently owned ( in the Offices of our Church ) and supposed to be a sense of the Infinite Divine Excellencies , and his constant bounty and benefits , and gracious goodness to mankind , especially in our Lord Jesus Christ : which of themselves are sufficient motives to Religion : and make the same proceed from the most free , and most suitable , and noble principle that can be of affection and thankfulness to God .

§ . 13. Because an Oath is an act of Divine Worship , in which we solemnly invoke God as a witness to what we swear : It is but proper here to take notice of the Moderation of our Church in what relates to Oaths .

1. Our Church doth ( in the 39. Article of Religion ) excellently declare , and ( in the Homily against perjury ) at large prove , The lawfulness and benefits of swearing for causes necessary and honest , and for the ending of controversy , and sets forth also the sore danger of perjury .

2. Our Church doth at large testify against customary and unnecessary Swearing , and the mentioned Homily declares the danger and vanity thereof : Both these purposes of the Homily are briefly contained in the 39th Article : Thus : As we confess vain and rash Swearing is forbidden Christian men by our Lord Jesus Christ , and James his Apostle : So we judge , That Christian Religion doth not prohibite , but that a man may swear when the Magistrate requireth , in a cause of Faith and Charity ; so it be done according to the Prophets teaching , in Justice , Judgment , and Truth .

In a few lines also of the Homily , our Church seems fully to determine the whole Controversy , which our Sectaries have rais'd concerning Swearing : When Christ so earnestly forbad Swearing , it may not be understood as though he did forbid all manner of Oaths ; but he forbiddeth all vain Swearing and forswearing , both by God and by his Creatures ; as the common use of Swearing in buying and selling , and in daily Communication , to the intent every Christian mans word , should be as well regarded in such matters , as if he confirm'd his Communication with an Oath : for the truth is ( as Theophylact writeth ) no man is less trusted than he that useth much to swear .

Beside the practice of the Gentiles , to swear by Creatures , the Jews had fallen into that Custom , which gave our Saviour and St James occasion to forbid such S. Mat. 5. 34. S. James 5. 12. kind of Swearing , which also was in use among the Manichees , as St Augustine notes x x Jurabant saepissimè nulloque mentis scrupulo per Creaturas . c. Faust . 22. .

Seeing then all Swearing by the Creatures is counted by the Homily Vain-Swearing ; It can be deemed no other , to swear by the y y V. Catechism . Trident . Blessed Virgin , or by Saints ( or their reliques : ) since they have no delegated power to know our hearts , or to punish Perjury . At the solemn Inauguration of the Emperour , he saith , I swear unto God , and S. Peter , &c. When any enter into a Monastery , they say : I vow unto God , and to the Blessed Virgin , ( and to S. Dominic : or some other their particular Saint . )

3. Concerning the matter and obligation of lawful and unlawful Oaths ; we may hear our Church excellently advising and declaring : Therefore , whosoever maketh any promise , binding himself thereunto by an Oath . Let him foresee , that the thing he promiseth be good and honest , and not against the Commandment of God , and that it be in his own power to perform it justly ; and such promises must men keep evermore assuredly : But if a man at any time , shall either of ignorance , or of malice , promise and swear to do any thing , which is either against the Law of Almighty God , or not in his power to perform , let him take it for an unlawful Oath . Of an unlawful Oath , the same Homily determines in the Case of Herod , That as he took a wicked Oath , so he more wickedly performed the same . These full and just determinations of the Church , might be fitly commented on , by what Bishop Sanderson hath writ of the obligation of Oaths ; especially in his third Prelection : and may very justly also be applyed to the Case of the solemn League and Covenant : which sufficiently justifies the abjuration of the Covenant , as it is required in the Act of Uniformity .

4. Our Church lays a great charge and weight on the words of the Prophet Jeremiah : ( Ch. 4. V. 2. ) Thou shalt swear in Judgment , Truth , and Righteousness : Whosoever sweareth , let him be sure in his Conscience , That his Oath have these three conditions ; z z Homily against Perjury . which also are mentioned in the 39th Article ; and largely insisted on in the Homily . All which do sufficiently testify against the Equivocations , and mental reservations , which the Jesuits allow and defend : which is a most notorious artifice of deceit : a great profanation of the divine name , and contrary to the nature and end of Oaths .

And that we may observe how rightly our Church judgeth of the Power of the Pope , or of any other in rescinding and dispensing with lawful Oaths a a Vi. Duo brevia Pontisicis Ro. 1. dat. 1606. 2. dat. 1607. contra juram . Fidel. in R. Jac. Apologiâ . ( yea , dispensing with men aforehand , to make unlawful Oaths and Vows ; as in Marriages , within the degrees Levitical ) b b Apol. of certain Proceedings in Courts Eccles. p. 2. c. 2. p. 18. The sixth part of the Homily against wilful Rebellion , speaking of the Bishops of Rome , discharging the Subjects of the Kings of England , of their Oath of Fidelity to their Soveraign Lord ( as particularly , Innocent III. to King John ) calls it fitly , A feigned discharging of their Oath and fealty : and a vain cursing of the King . Which practices of the Popes , rely upon two Principles of the Church of Rome .

1. That the Pope hath an absolute and Oecumenical Authority over the whole World , and that all Oaths are to be taken with a reserve of his pleasure : and that he hath the sole power to declare and dispense in what relates unto them .

2. That Faith is not to be kept with Hereticks : which Doctrines are published in the Books of the Famous Romanists ; neither prohibited nor animadverted on c c Nullo modo Fides servanda Haereticis etiam Juramento firmata . Simanca . .

In interpreting Oaths , as our Church doth not encourage any loose sense , that the taker by any evasion may collude the design of the Law : so also our Church rejects such rigid interpretations , which force the words to a severe sense : but where a fair and easy construction may be made by the natural interpretation of the words , which is agreeable to truth and justice , and may secure the intention of Superiours , such a construction our Church is ready to allow of and encourage d d Vi. Q. Eliz. Admon . V. Article 37. .

5. The general Oaths enjoined or defended in our Church , are but few , and those for great causes appointed , and with great Moderation framed . As 1. The Oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy ; The necessity and Moderation of which , hath been largely expounded in the Apology of King James and others d d See the Admonition of Q. Eliz. 1559. of the Oath of Supremacy . Nunc mitius ac moderatius substitutum est . Sander . de Schism . Angl. p. 149. : since which , the Artifice of the Romanists hath had great effect on our Sectaries , in their obstinate refusing the said Oath of Supremacy , whereby they are become the more prepared for the Papacy . And that we may see how the Romanists and the Sectaries are united in their first Principles , and how both become more obstinate even the more Moderation is used to either ; Their refusing together the Oath of Allegiance is too undoubted a testimony .

Yea , Of the Moderation of his Majesties Government , and the immoderate obstinacy of the governing part of the Romish Clergy , The History of Father Walsh concerning the Loyal Formulary in Ireland , 1666. will be an eternal Monument ; which sheweth at large with what art and industry the desire of the more peaceable Romanists was opposed ( even from the Roman Cardinals and other their Superiours ) to give his Majesty but the security of their Allegiance , in a brief and very moderate Form .

2. The Oath against Simony c c Injunct . Q. Eliz. §. 26. Canon . 40. 1603. Nemo gradum sacerdotii venalitate pretii mercetur , quantum quisque meretur , non quantum dare sufficit aestimetur . Cod. Tir. de Episco . & Cleric . doth justify the integrity of our Church , and the Laws in that behalf , and that all the endeavour possible is used to prevent all guilt of Simony in the Clergy .

3. The Oath of Canonical obedience is offered unto all with that most moderate and just clause , [ In all things lawful and honest : ] which Canonical obedience is no other than is sworn in other Reformed Churches , as appears by the Form set down by D. D. Durell f f Of Reformed Churches , p. 10. .

4. In the Oath of continual residence in a Vicaridge , half the clause is for the Moderating the Oath : unless it shall be otherwise dispensed by the Diocesan .

Many object earnestly against the Oath which the Church-Wardens are oblig'd to take : Whereas such are to consider , the nature and end of their Office cannot well be procured but by obliging them in that matter . 2. Such may consider , their Presentments are of matters governed by their Superiours : in which they are but to make Presentment according to enquiries before them ; in making of which , they may be directed by the Minister .

Of other Oaths , thus the Homily against Perjury : When Judges require Oaths of the people , for declaration or opening of the truth , or for execution of Justice : Also when men make faithful promises , with calling to witness of the name of God ; to keep Covenants , honest Promises , Statutes , Laws , and good Customs ; as Christian Princes do in their Conclusions of Peace , and private persons promise their fidelity in Matrimony , &c. And all men when they do swear to keep common Laws , and local Statutes , and good Customs , for due order . When Subjects do swear to be true and faithful to their King ; and when Judges , Magistrates , and Officers , swear truly to execute their Offices , &c. All these manner of swearing , for causes necessary and honest , be lawful . By lawful Oaths common Laws are kept inviolate , Justice indifferently ministred , harmless persons are defended , mutual Society , amity , good order , is kept continually in all Communal●ies , &c.

Lastly , Of the Ceremony in taking Oaths , with laying hands on the Bible , or Testament , and Swearing by the Contents of it , and kissing the Book : we may hear what Tindal g g On 5. S. Matth. p. 208. well saith , When thou swearest by the Holy Gospel or Bible , the meaning is , that God if thou ly , shall not fulfil unto thee the promise of mercy therein written ; but contrariwise , to bring upon thee all the Curses , Plagues , and Threatnings , therein threatned to the disobedient and evil-doers . And by these Ceremonies the Civil Law tells us , an Oath is held more inviolable h h T●ctis sacr●sanctis Evangeliis . L. ●em non novam . §. Pat●●●● . de judi●iis . See our Ancient Statute , 51 H●nr . 3. .

CHAP. VIII . Of the Moderation of the Church in relation to Ceremonies .

§ . 1. In the Ceremonies of our Church which are very few , and those of great antiquity , simplicity , clear signification and use ; our Church avoids either sort of superstition . § . 2. They have constantly been declared to be in themselves indifferent and alterable : but in that our Church avoids variableness , is a further proof of its Moderation . § . 3. They are professed by the Church to be no part of Religion , much less the chief ; nor to have any supernatural effect belonging to them . § . 4. Abundant care is taken to give plain and frequent reasons and interpretations of what in this nature is enjoined to prevent mistakes . § . 5. The Moderation of our Church even in point of Ceremonies compar'd with those who have raised so great a dust in this Controversy . § . 6. Many innocent Rites and usages our Church never went about to introduce , and why . § . 7. The Obligation of our Church in this matter is very mild . § . 8. The Moderation of our Church in her appointment of Vestments . § . 9. The Benedictions of our Church are according to great Piety and Wisdom ordered . § . 10. The Moderation of our Church in her appointments of Gestures . § . 11. Of the respect which is held due to places and things distinguished to Gods Service ; our Church judgeth and practiseth according to an excellent Moderation .

§ . 1. AS in the foregoing Chapter I have not thought it necessary to stay the Reader by presenting to his consideration , the many proofs of the lawfulness , antiquity , and advantages of Liturgy in general ; or by arguing the excellence and usefulness of our publick Forms of Prayer in particular ; because any such labour hath been sufficiently saved , from the copious and unanswerable performances of so many learned and judicious men of our Communion , who have largely vindicated , and also have given the particular reasons of our Institutions :

So in this Chapter of the Ceremonies of our Church , which are only the Ecclesiastical Institutions for order and decency , I hold it ( for the same reasons mentioned ) unnecessary , by many Arguments to defend the lawful use or establishment of Ecclesiastical Rites , since the same have been abundantly proved : both from the liberty allowed to the Jewish Church ; and also from what is warranted by the Apostolical Doctrine and practice ; and is defended from the practice and judgment of the Primitive Church , and other Protestant Churches : and cannot ( without very evil Consequences , as are destructive to the interest of Religion ) be denied any Christian Church .

All which , and much more , for the Vindication of our Church , hath been fully and judiciously evinced , particularly by my Excellent Friend Mr Falkner ( in his Libertas Ecclesiastica . ) To whose solid defence also of our other Ecclesiastical appointments , and becoming gestures in the Service of God ; and also the Holy-Dayes and Festivals of our Church , as agreeable to Holy Scripture and reason , I take leave to refer the Reader ; and I presume it may satisfy my design , and sufficiently justify our Church , if unto what hath been so amply and irreproveably performed , I add the just instances and proof of our Churches Moderation .

The Ceremonies of our Church are but very few , and those of great antiquity , simplicity , decency and clear signification , hardly to be wrested to the prejudice of inward piety : wherefore they are neither unprofitable , nor burdensome ( of which they are charged in the Preface to the Directory . ) Our Church avoiding extreams on one hand of the Church of Rome a a Concil. Trid. Sess . 7. Can. 13. , whose Ceremonies are so cumbersome for their number b b Quia ad aures ipsorum totius sermè orbis justissimae querelae pervenerint de moderandâ & corrigendâ onerosâ multitudine quorundam rituum . Chemnit. Examen . ib. p. 34. , that they make no end of commanding and forbidding , till they come to the other extremity of moroseness : of which humour , St Austin c c S. Aug. Ep. 118. in express words complains : Religion which God in his mercy hath made free with few and clear . Sacraments , is made more burdensome than ever was the Jewish . Wherefore our Church is most careful , lest by any excess of Ceremonies , Religion should be any wise obscured , and by outward and sensible things , the minds of people should be diverted to the neglect of what is inward and spiritual . Therefore our Church in its Preface of Ceremonies , why some be abolished , complains , That the excessive number of Ceremonies was so great , and many of them so dark , that they did more confound and darken , than declare and set forth Christs benefits unto us . On the other hand , our Church avoids that other kind of superstition , of those that consider not the frame of men , nor the use and experience of having some Rites , for comeliness and edification d d V. Pref. to the Liturgy . ; and for exciting Piety and Devotion , in the publick worship of God . Let me for the sake of those who rather will accept such a truth from Mr Perkins e e Reformed Catholick 7. §. of Traditions . , repeat his words . We hold , that the Church of God hath power to prescribe Ordinances , Rules , or Traditions , touching time and place of Gods worship , and touching order and comliness to be used in the same ; and in this regard , Paul , 1 Cor. 11. 2. commendeth the Church of Corinth for keeping his Traditions ; and Acts 15. 29. the Council at Jerusalem decreed , that the Churches of the Gentiles should abstain from blood and from things strangled : this Decree is termed a Tradition : and this kind of Traditions , whether made by general or particular Synods , we have a care to maintain and observe ; these Caveats being remembred f f Ritus pauci numero , sine sumptu , minimè graves . Grot. in Cassand . Artic. 15. : 1. That they prescribe nothing childish or absurd to be done . 2. That they be not imposed as any part of Gods worship . 3. That they be severed from superstition or opinion of merit : Lastly , That the Church of God be not burdened with the multitude of them . And indeed a worthy instance of the prudent Moderation of the Church of England is , that in her reformation from Rome , she hath delivered her self from such an Endless g g Europae Speculum . p. 3. multitude of Superstitions and Ceremonies , enough to take up a great part of a mans life to gaze on and peruse ; a huge sort of which are so childish and unsavoury , that as they argue great silliness and rawness in their inventors , so can they naturally bring no other than disgrace and contempt to those exercises of Religion wherein they are stirring . Yet after the fashion of a modest and prudent Matron , though our Church doth not appear tawdry drest , with too great a variety of ill placed cost , yet doth she endeavour always to appear discreet and comely in her attire : On purpose retaining some Rites , in respect to the practice of the antient Church : and to vindicate her self from the imputation of moroseness ; and not to side with the other extreme of those who in the exercise of their Religion , affect carelessness and neglect of any good Form . The Church of England doth retain some Ceremonies in her Offices , thereby also to vindicate real Christian Liberty : namely , the publick liberty of Gods Church ; one part of which ( as Bucer in the beginning of the Reformation well noted ) is for the Church to chuse its own Rites , and also to vindicate the Liberty of private Christians , who by the Orders of the Church have their choice directed for their own edification , and the better order of Divine things . For Diversity of Ceremonies in divers Churches do serve to testify the Christian Liberty , and doth greatly conduce to teach the true judgment of Ceremonies , namely , that all men by this diversity may understand , That those things which are not delivered in Holy Scripture , are not necessary to Salvation , but may be altered as the time and circumstance of edification doth require h h Sprint's Necessity of Conformity in case of Deprivation . p. 115. It a Forbesius in Irenico . l. 1. c. 7. Harmon . Confess. p 194. . Which reason of them though it hath been frequently repeated , yet hath not sufficiently been taken notice of by those who pretend to be such Assertors of Christian Liberty , who fall foul into another servile and unquiet sort of Superstition .

Yet when we consider the horrid , stiff superstition of such Precisians whom the Moderation of the Church of England in point of Ceremonies doth affright , We cannot think them so moped , but others appear to have run into a greater excess of madness : when we behold the exceeding number of Ceremonies and observances , which the Roman Rubricks appoint in their Rituals , Missals , and Pontifical , &c. We may bless our selves , who within the Communion of our Church , are freed from such a bondage , more grievous than the Jewish : especially , since their Rites ( many of which are so ridiculous and trifling i i Vi. Pontificale Rom. de Ecclesiae Dedicatione . p. 237. Vi. Rituale Rom. in absolvendo excommunicatum jam mortuum , &c. ) k k Quando primò Clericis barbae tondentur , dici debet Pontifice sedente cum mitrâ , Antiphona , Sicut Ros Hermon , &c. Pontificale , p. 550. are not only approved , but required by the Council of Trent , under the pain of Anathema l l Conc. Trid. Sess . 7. Can. 13. : and that for surer notice repeated in the first page of their Ritual . Wherefore as Plutarch well saith of Religion , it hath its place between contempt of divine things on one hand , and superstition on the other : So the Moderation of our Church is excellently tempered to keep Christians from Enthusiasm in one extreme , and from what some call Rituality on the other m m D. H. Mori Ethic. c. 5. p. 105. : Of our Churches care in this last particular , Bishop Taylor thus endeavours to satisfie some Consciences , There is reason , saith he , to celebrate and honour the wisdom and prudence of the Church of England , which hath in all her Offices retained but one Ritual or Ceremony , that is not of Divine Ordinance , or Apostolical practice , and that is the Cross in Baptism , which though it be a significant Ceremony , and of no other use , yet as it is a compliance with the practice of all ancient Churches , so it is very innocent in it self , and being one and alone , is in no regard troublesome . I said , she hath only one Ceremony of her own appointment ; For the Ring in Marriage is the symbol of a civil and religious contract ; It is a pledge and custom of the Nation , not of the Religion : And other circumstances of her worship , are but determinations of time and place , and manner of a duty . They serve for other purposes , beside signification , for order and decency , for which there is an Apostolical Precept , and a natural reason ; and an evident necessity , or a great convenience n n Ductor Dub. l. ● . c. 4. R. 20. . Neither is any Ceremony used in our Church by any beside the Minister .

§ . 2. The constant Moderation of the Church from the beginning of the Reformation o o Instit. of a Christian man , p. 46. , hath always faithfully declared its Rites and particular Forms of Worship to be such things as are in their own nature indifferent and mutable , that they might be limited or revoked : Every particular national Church hath authority to ordain , change and abolish Ceremonies . ( Article of Religion 34. ) It may be lawful for just causes , to alter , change , or mitigate , or recede from Ecclesiastical Decrees : saith the Homily of Fasting : Much more to the same purpose . The Church declares , in the 20 Article , and in the Preface of the Ceremonies ; and in the Homilies , especially in the beginning of the last Preface added to the Common Prayer-Book , 1662. It hath been the wisdom of the Church of England , ever since her first compiling of her publick Liturgy , to keep the mean between the two extremes , of too much stiffness in refusing , and too much easiness in admitting variation from it . In the same Preface it is added , In which review we have endeavoured to observe the like Moderation as we find to have been used in like Cases in former times .

As this is an unquestionable proof of the Churches Moderation : So give me leave to make it a good instance also thereof , in that on the other hand , she doth wisely avoid the other extreme of variableness , being not given to change , but upon good reason thereunto moving : because of the many inconveniencies that ensue upon frequent unadvised mutations . So often as any private persons willingly and purposely recede from the appointments of the Church ; the 34th Article provides for their open rebuke .

Neither are we ignorant ( saith King James , in his Proclamation for Uniformity ) of the inconveniencies that do arise in Government , by admitting innovation in things once setled by mature deliberation : and how necessary it is to use constancy in the upholding of the publick determinations of States ; for that such is the unquietness and unstedfastness of some dispositions , affecting every year new forms of things , as , if they should be followed in their inconstancy , would make all actions of States ridiculous and contemptible . And if authority should upon all wrong apprehensions of parties make new usages ; nothing in the outward worship of God would continue , no not the very Sacraments p p Illud autem penitu● infixum esse oportet , nec tutum esse , nec ad sovendam concordiam utile , temerè desciscere ab iis quae Majorum autoritate tradita sunt , quaeque longo saeculorum usu consensuque confirmata : nec quicquam omnino novandum est , nisi hue aut cogat necessitas aut insignls invi●et utilitas . Erasmus de amabili Eccl. Concordiâ . .

§ . 3. The Moderation of the Church further appears , in that our Rites are no where made any part of Religion or Worship ; but only used in subserviency to Religion , and without them the Religion and worship of God is acknowledged entire : This is manifest from what hath been declared before of their indifferent and mutable nature : And to prevent all just occasion of exception , the Church of England doth publickly declare , that her Constitutions concerning indifferent things , are made without any opinion of worship by them , or absolute necessity of them q q Theatricum Ceremoniarum apparatum nimis rigidè & magnificè exaggerant Ceremoniarum Magistri & exactores , quasi sine illis nec veritas nec dignitas nec efficaci a Sacramentorum consistat . Chemnitii Examen . Can. 13. Sess. 7. Conc. Trid. King Edw. 6. Injunctions 1547. : yea all are admonisht to consider , that God is not appeased by them , much less is his grace by them merited , or satisfaction made for sins . In the 2d year of King Edw. 6. In the Articles of Archbishop Cranmer ; it is enquired , whether the Ministers have declared unto the people the true use of Ceremonies ; That they be no workers of Salvation , but only outward signs and tokens ( not mystical , but of clear signification : not Sacramental , but naturally and properly fit ) to put us in remembrance of things of higher perfection : Then it was also declared , That the Ceremonies are not superstitiously to be abused , as thereby to drive away Devils , &c. or by putting trust and confidence for health and salvation in the same r r See Bishop Gauden before Bishop Brownrigs Sermons , of the Cerem . in our Church . .

Thus our Church is ( God be thanked ) far from any such impious Tyranny and Vsurpation over mens Consciences , which the Pharisees of old did , and the Church of Rome at this day doth exercise , equalling , if not preferring her Constitutions to the Laws of God : having declared her self by solemn protestation , enough to satisfie any ingenuous , impartial judgment , That by requiring obedience to these Ceremonial Constitutions , she hath no other purpose than to reduce all her Children to an orderly Conformity in the outward worship of God : so far is the Church from seeking to draw any opinion , either of divine necessity upon the Constitution , or of effectual holiness upon the Ceremony s s Bi●hop Sandersons judgment in one View , p. 99. V. Bishop Morton Ep. to the Non-Conf . .

§ . 4. So great is the Moderation of our Church , that lest any should lose the benefit of her Communion , or continue uneasy in their own scruples , she hath condescended to expound such Injunctions as could be foreseen to have any objection t t Super his aliqua moderatio adhibenda est pro Conscientiarum sedatione , etiam multitudini errantium piè condescendendo aliqua declaratio facienda . Petr. de Aliaco , de reform . Eccl. Fascic . R. Expet . . In the end of the Office for the Holy Communion , lest Kneeling should by any persons , either through ignorance or malice , be misconstrued and depraved , It is declared , that thereby no Adoration is intended , or to be done , &c. ( as there may be seen more at large . ) To the same purpose is the 5. Rubrick after the Holy Communion , To take away all occasion of dissention or superstition .

In the 30th Canon , the lawful use of the Cross in Baptism is copiously and excellently explained u u See second Rubrick after publick Baptism . : For removing all scruple , and for sufficient caution against all Popish Superstition .

First , The Church of England , since the abolishing of Popery hath ever held and taught , and so doth hold and teach , that the sign of the Cross x x Nec nos p●det Crucifixi , sed in parte ubi pudori● signum est , signum Crucis habemus . S. Aug. in Psal. 30. S. Cypr. Ep. 56. used in Baptism , is no part of the substance of the Sacrament , neither doth add to the vertue or perfection of Baptism .

2. That the Infant baptized is by vertue of Baptism y y Crucis Ceremonia in baptismace reti●etur , & explicatur ( in Constitutionibus Londini , 1604. ) ●ot adhibitis cautionibus ut S. Sancti figni reverentia omnino aboleri potius quam confirmari videatur . Thuanus ( Pontificius ) ad an. 1604. ( before it be signed with the sign of the Cross ) received into the Congregation of Christs Flock , as a perfect member thereof , and not by any power ascribed to the sign of the Cross : And that no invisible grace or vertue is annexed to the sign : All Popish error and superstition being purged from the use of it , and reduced in the Church of England to the primary institution of it . For which reason also , lest any mysterious operation should be thought imputed to the sign of the Cross , King James and King Charles I. and now King Charles II. have forborn the use of that sign at the Healing z z Alliance of Divine Offices , ch. 8. ( though therewith it was used in the Reigns of King Edw. 6. and Queen Elizabeth ) So great a Moderation and condescension have the Kings of England used ( as well as the Church ) for the healing of the minds as well as the bodies of their People .

In the 18th Canon , with great wisdom and Moderation , is procured all decent , orderly , reverent , and attentive behaviour in time of Divine Service a a Erunt itaque recti moderatique gestus qui possunt servire purae Religioni Christi . Buceri Cens . c. 5. Canon 111. ; where for kneeling at Confession , Supplication , and Prayers , standing up at the Belief , paying a due , lowly Reverence , when in time of Divine Service , the Lord Jesus shall be mentioned b b Injunction Queen Elizabeth §. 52. , are added the Reasons of the Canon , viz.

Testifying by these outward Ceremonies and Gestures , their inward humility , Christian resolution , and due acknowledgment that the Lord Jesus c c Quae sanè Devotio plus afficitur erg● nomen Jesu , quia nomen ipsum significat nobis nostram salutem . Arch. Spalat. l. 7. c. 12. §. 49. de Repub. Eccl. Christ , the true and eternal Son of God , is the only Saviour of the World , in whom alone , all the mercies and promises of God to mankind , for this Life , and the Life to come , are fully and wholly comprised , &c.

d d Hooker's Eccles. Pol. l. 5. ● ▪ ●0 . Which harmless Ceremonies , as no man is constrained to use , so we know no reason any of them should withstand .

Against Infidels , Jews , and Arrians , who derogate from the honour of Jesus Christ , such Ceremonies are most profitable .

In the Canons , 1640. with all Moderation possible , the Church did declare it self concerning the scituation of the Holy Communion Table , lest any should esteem it otherwise than a figurative Altar e e See Dr. Cudworth of the true Notion of the Lords Supper . , as thereon was had a Commemoration of that full , perfect , and sufficient Sacrifice , for the sins of the whole World : Wherefore in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth , according to the advice of Bucer , it was to be so placed , that the Minister might more conveniently be heard f f Q. Eliz. Injunction f●r Tables in the Church . ●uceri censura . Inter opera Angl. ● . 457. : And because of Gods Majesty , the obeysance which was only recommended , had so great an allay of Moderation , that the Conclusion of the Canon is very memorable to our purpose . In the practice or omission of this Rite , we desire that the rule of Charity prescribed by the Apostle , may be observed , which is , That they which use this Rite , despise not them who use it not ; and that they who use it not , condemn not those that use it g g Hîc igitur nullus alium dijudicet : Vescens non insultet abstinentibus , abstinentes non condemnent vescentes . Erasm . de amabili Eccl. Concordiâ , p. 18. . The same words his Majesty King Charles II. inserted in one of his Royal Proclamations . ( So far was this from being to be counted one of the Ceremonies of the Church , as the Naked Truth calls it : ) Of this bodily Reverence of God in his Church , the Government is so moderate , ( God grant it be not loose there-while , ) That no man is constrained , no man question'd , only religiously call'd upon , O come , let us worship , kneel , and fall down , before God our Maker h h Archbishop Lauds Speech in the Star-Chamber . .

§ . 5. So that in our Church , as our worship of God is suitable to solid and rational Devotion , so in the appointments of our Church ( which refer to the Administration of the same ) our Church appears neither to affect vain gaieties , nor outward splendor , nor such luxuriant expressions , as are suited to feed the humours and boundless fancies of men : Retaining what is reverent and becoming , yet rejecting what is superstitious in sundry Consecrations , Benedictions , and Exorcisms , which are in use in the Roman Church : which mild and wise Moderation of our Church , renders their humours more unaccountably foolish and obstinate , who are so peremptory in their Non-Conformity to the Orders of our Church : Since there is no Church in the World , which hath all its Offices and Sacraments so administred , conformably to the best Precedents , in words understood , without any mixture of dangerous or superstitious encroachments ; and with that gravity , decency , and solemnity , which befits the service of God : as Dean Lingard ( whom for love and honour to his memory , I name ) in a Sermon of his before the King i i July 26. 1668. .

Yet of these men who are so impatient of Ceremonies upon publick Order , I cannot but note what hath been often observed k k See Friendly Debate , p. 221. Of the many Ceremonies ordained in the taking of the Covenant , 1646. , That many of them use two Ceremonies for one , after their own fancies ; as not only their emphatick looks , antick actions , odd postures ; but further they require of their Disciples some things of a Ceremonial nature , as special marks of admission into their parties : It is Religion with many of them not to give the Title of Saint but to their own people : And many think no Prayer acceptable unless it be very long : especially before Sermon : and that no Sermon neither , except it be in the Pulpit . As Aristotle observed of the necessity of Laws in every Society ; so the use of Ceremonies and Order , may be further proved at large ; for that all Factions , how different soever , do frame to themselves some peculiar modes and figures of practice , in which they are so strict ( although in matter of their acknowledged liberty ) that 't is pity their observance is not better placed : Even the Quakers themselves , in what they ( in abuse of the Laws ) call Marriages , use Ceremonies of joining hands , and standing , while they also declare their consent mutually in a Form : and in many other practises of opposition ; as meeting for what they call Marriage in the Afternoon : burying their people in a cross manner ; they are constant , and as formal ( where they are Antipodes to Authority ) as any Romanists can be in his Crosses and Incensings . So that if superstition l l Sensi enim dolens & gemens multas infir morum perturbationes fieri per quorundam fratrum contentiosam obstinationem & superstitiosam timiditatem . S. Aug. Ep. 118. be going beyond measures , we may conclude , that none are so superstitious as those on either hand who oppose the Moderation of our Church . And really it is a very great justification of the Moderation of our Church , That our present Anti-Ceremonial Dissenters ( though they have wanted no endeavours to the utmost of their wits and powers ) hitherto have been able to make no other exceptions against our Church , and what is therein constituted ; than what have been answered already , very often , and very fully ; to the conviction of the most learned , and the more ingenuous amongst themselves .

§ . 6. But so far is the Church of England from multiplying Ceremonies , that we know there are many innocent usages m m See Sprint's Necess. of Conform . p. 85. to 101. which have been in the Primitive Church , in sundry places , and at divers times , which our Church of England never went about to introduce , either by practice or command : as the holy Kiss , the use of the Veil ; the threefold immersion , or use of the white garment in Baptism , and many others , which since our Church passeth by their use , we do not mention : which sheweth , that Order and Edification , gives bounds ( as is meet ) to the number and use of Ceremonies in our Church ; which stops that objection in its career : Who shall determine their convenient number n n Interest of England , p. 89. ? The Church hath received just rules , and our Church hath observed the same with just Moderation . And hereunto may be added , that as our Church hath not rejected all Rites and usages , meerly because they were in use in the Roman Church ( no more than the Reformation of Hezekiah , or Josiah , rejected all things received or imitated in the corrupt worship of the Ten Tribes : ) So , many practices , which had pious and useful beginnings in the Church of Rome , and afterward were grievously corrupted , have not been admitted in our Church : partly , because she hath not been forward to multiply ritual observances ; partly , that such occasions of corruption may not be invited , when by experience it hath been seen , how easily there hath come excess : Among what had useful beginnings cannot be number'd the old wayes of superstitious purgations , by Fire and Water Ordeals , and Combates , &c. which are all abolisht among us o o V. Ridley's View , &c. l. 1. c. 5. §. 5. Reform . leg . Eccl. de purg . c. 21 ▪ .

§ . 7. Concerning the Ceremonies appointed in our Church , it must further be taken notice , That the obligation to them is very mild : for though the intent of the Church is doubtless to bind all to the preservation of regular order , yet ( as the Institution of a Christian Man hath it p p P. 47. ) Forasmuch as such things be of themselves mean and indifferent , men may upon causes reasonable well omit the same , so that it be not in case of contempt or scandal p p V. Whitgift Answ. to Admon . p. 29. V. Bishop Sanderson's judgment , &c. p. 19. And of the Church we have no reason to complain , for securing its own Orders against contempt , and for providing against scandal to those of her Communion : especially , since her Rites themselves are such as might deserve every where to be observed : But how far particular persons have to do to moderate yet further the great Moderation of the Church , we leave it to all sober Consciences , and to our Superiours to judge ; who also must judge of the true interest of the Church , how far popular exception ought to influence any change : Uniformity certainly is so excellent , that the certain purchase of it would be worth somewhat ; but the truth is , our Governours have to do with those , that are so unresolved of what they would have , that this makes their most cautious deliberation necessary : q q Bishop Bramhal to M. Militier . For as a learned Prelate observes , It is a rule in prudence , not to remove an ill custom , when it is well setled , unless it bring great prejudices , and then it is better to give one account why we have taken it away , than to be always making excuses why we do it not . Needless alteration doth diminish the venerable esteem of Religion , and lessen the credit of antient truths . Break Ice in one place , and it will crack in more .

§ . 8. It may be as proper in this place as any where , to annex the notice of our Churches Moderation in its appointments of Vestments r r Canon 24. 25. 58. 74. for Holy Ministrations ; as being herein neither undecently deficient , nor immoderately extravagant . The Vestments in use , by order among us , being very few , and those very modest and useful , for Ornament , distinction , and commonefaction ; free from all superstition and shew of luxury : of the same kind of those in use in the Reformed Churches s s D. D. Durel of Reform . Ch. Sect. 2. §. 21 , 22. . Neither are they in the Church of England Consecrated by any solemn Benediction , nor to any supernatural effects ; t t Hooker Eccl. Pol. l. 5. §. 29. As we think not our selves the holier because we use them , so neither should others think us therefore unholy . In the Injunctions of Queen Elizabeth , 1559. § . 30. u u Canon . 74. ( 1603. ) Etiam Episcoporum famuli in omni vestis genere se modestè & compositè ornabunt . V. Libr. quorundam Canonum , 1571. Her Majesty being desirous to have the Prelacy and Clergy of this Realm , to be had as well in outward reverence , as otherwise regarded for the worthiness of their Ministry , that they may receive the honour and estimation due to the special Messengers of God , willeth and commandeth them to wear such habits , &c. Not thereby meaning ( as 't is added ) to attribute any special holiness or worthiness to the said Garments , but as St Paul saith , Let all things be done decently : Wherefore in the third Part of the Homily of Idolatry , Our Church excepts against that costly and manifold furniture of Vestments in the Church of Rome , as fetcht from the Jewish usage . ( Hoopers ingenuous acknowledgment of his error about Vestments , see in Dr Durel x x Vindiciae S. Eccl. Angl. l. 16. p. 140. , a MS. Letter . )

§ . 9. The Benedictions of our Church are performed with great piety and wisdom : Notwithstanding the contempt which many entertain the same with , hath been much encreased by the extravagant practices of the Church of Rome in their Benedictions .

1. To make way for their Exorcisms antecedent to their Benedictions they seem to suppose worse of Gods Creation than they need , as if the Devil had such interest and possession in the salt and water , and what else they commonly exorcise : Sometimes they are as prodigal of their Blessings as at other times of their Curses , imprinting thereby a servile and superstitious dread upon the minds of men , whereby they suck no small advantage .

2. By their multitude of Ceremonies they seem unavoidably to confound the People , and divert their minds from the true author and cause of blessing .

How many Crossings and sprinklings with Holy-Water , Incensings , Exorcisms , variety of actions of the Bishops and Priests , frequent shifting of Vestments , many utensils and materials do they make requisite ?

Whereas the Church of England doth in a modest and solemn manner make use of that Commission it hath , to dispense by its Ministers the Divine Blessing in the name of God , because the less is blessed of the greater . ( Heb. 7. 7. )

Being 1. Very careful to make her people plainly sensible from whom the Benediction by Prayer doth proceed : 2. Our Church doth carefully declare the Divine Promises as they are made , that the people may take more effectual care , to be duly qualifyed for the Divine Blessing . 3. Our Church doth not hold any Mediator for the Divine Blessing , but what God hath appointed ; neither Saint , nor Angel , but only Jesus Christ our Lord . 4. Our Church doth rightly suppose its Ministers have authority given them , to declare and pronounce the Divine Promises of blessing , with the conditions of receiving the same : and that they have a special Commission given them to pray for Gods people and bless them : as the Priests under the Law had Commission to bless the people in the name of God , Numbers 6. 22. Deut. 10. 8. 1 Chron. 23. 13. Which practice had nothing Ceremonial in it , and peculiar to the Law . Wherefore Christ put his hands upon the little Children , and blessed them , S. Mat. 19. 13. and Commanded his Apostles and Ministers to bless his people , S. Mat. 10. 13. S. Luke 10. 5. and without all contradiction , the less is blessed of the greater , Heb. 7. 7. Wherefore for the dignity of the Episcopal Office , the Church doth especially delegate that Power and Commission to her Bishops for Confirmation , with imposition of Hands , and in Ordination of Ministers , &c. Neither do our Religious Kings in our Church , refuse the Benedictions of the Churches Ministers : either as Christians , or as Kings at their Coronations : Yea our Church indeed ascribes more to Blessing and Prayer than the Church of Rome doth : for by Blessing and Prayer , our Church holds the Bread and Wine in the Holy Eucharist to be Consecrated , which the Roman Priests do not , till those words be pronounced . [ Hoc est enim Corpus meum . ]

And here I cannot but add what the Archbishop of Spalato truly observed , of the constant and ordinary blessing at Meals in England , according to pious and Christian practice . Blessings ( saith he y y 〈◊〉 Er● . S●are●● , 〈◊〉 §. 2● . ) and thanksgivings at the Tables of the Nobility , Gentry , Clergy , and Laity ; at no time , and upon no occasion omitted ; I never saw with such Religion and Piety performed as in England .

Yea among those of the Church of England , the laudable Christian Custom is maintained of Parents blessing their Children , and of Childrens humbly asking their Parents blessing , whereby the authority of the Parent is maintained , and each are put in mind of their respective obligation : The same laudable custom is used to our Bishops .

To which may be added , that the laudable Customs , commonly in use in our Church , as they are few which are generally received , so are they such as are very suitable to this Moderation here commended : But the Church z z Canon 42. 36. 10 declares only such Customs to be laudable which are not contrary to the word of God , or the Prerogative Royal.

§ . 10. As the wisdom of our Church doth account it a reasonable service to offer up our Bodies a holy and acceptable sacrifice in the worship of God : So she requires such reverend and becoming Gestures , as are proper to betoken the awful thoughts of our minds . Wherefore at our Prayers we are injoined meekly to kneel upon our Knees ; and at the Absolution also and repeating the Ten Commandements , and at receiving imposition of hands ; because the same are accompanied with Holy Prayers : and at our receiving the Holy Supper of our Lord , the same being the most suitable posture to testify and promote our Humility , our Thankfulness , and our Reverent Worship of God .

To express also our Joy and praise of God ( as at the Psalms : ) and to witness our stedfast , and resolved , and solemn profession of our Faith ( as at the Belief , ) we use the posture of standing ; and also at the Gospels ; to express our outward Reverence to the Holy Scriptures ; especially because they generally contain the actions and words of our Blessed Saviour .

But in tender regard to the weakness and infirmity of many Christians , such is the Moderation of our Church ; she alloweth sitting at the longer Lessons and Sermons , and at the Epistles , in accommodation to the reasonable ease of people , after their long kneeling before .

§ . 11. Of that respect which is due to Churches and places , for the Divine Worship and Service ; our Church hath determined according to great Moderation and Truth : Keeping the middle way between the pomp of superstitious tyranny , and the meanness of fantastick Anarchy a a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . §. 27. : Moreover ( saith the Homily ) the Church or Temple is counted or called holy ; yet not of it self , but because Gods people resorting thereunto , are holy , and exercise themselves in holy and heavenly things . Wherefore though our Church is most religiously careful , that the incommunicable honour due unto God , be attributed unto no Creature else ; yet because the inward honour due to God , ought to express it self as well outwardly as it can ; therefore whatsoever is appropriate to the peculiar service of God , our Church requires should be used with such a difference and distinction , as may set forth our due and singular Reverence of God . It is easy to note how the extreme of superstitious curiosity hath crept into the Church of Rome ; in so much , that it may well vye with the Jewish for multitude and niceness of observances : a just Volume would not contain the curious scruples of their nice observances , in their Vestments , Consecrations , Sacramental Rites , and indeed in the whole carriage of their religious devotions : but surely I fear these are not more faulty in the one extreme , than many Christians are in the other , who place a kind of holiness in a slovenly neglect : Who are apt to higgle with the Almighty , and in a base niggardliness , pinch him in the allowances of his Service . b b Of Holy decency in the worship of God . Bishop Hall in his Remains . Wise Christians sit down in the mean , now under the Gospel , avoiding a careless and parsimonious neglect on the one side , and a superstitions slovenliness on the other : the painted looks and lascivious gaudiness of the Church upon the Hills , and the careless neglected dress of some Churches in the Vally . Far be it from me ( saith c c ● . 1. Disc. 2. Mr Mede ) to be a Patron of Idolatry or Superstition in the least degree , yet I am afraid , lest we who have reformed the worship of God from that pollution ( and blessed be his name therefore ) by bending the crooked stick too much the other way , have run too far into the contrary extreme . To observe the just mean in practice , is somewhat difficult , nevertheless , our Church in its rules doth no more favour Sacriledge than Idolatry : If the personal faults of any have caused a scandal on us for either , the Church laments the same : and that there may be the less publick temptation to Sacrilege , among us ( as it hath been in other Nations ) the immoderate bounty of exorbitant Donations is limited , as by Statute of Mortmain , lest the secular state should become impoverished : Though that which was heretofore said of those things that were given , that they were in a dead hand , may more justly be said of those things that are taken away d d View of Civ . and Eccl. Law , Part. 3. c. 4. §. 1. .

The Monuments of our Church are also full of instances of our Churches observing the mean between superstition and profaneness : The horrible abuses ( saith e e Hom. of repairing of Churches . the Homily ) and abominations , they that supply the room of Christ , have purged and cleansed the Church of England of , taking away all such fulsomness and filthiness , as through ignorance and blind devotion hath crept into the Church these many hundred years . The Homilies also condemn such sumptuousness as put people in peril of Idolatry : yet , They require all convenient cleanness and ornament , where we cannot attain to an honourable magnificence : For as the Homily saith : When Gods House is well adorned with places convenient to sit in f f Canon 83. 1603. ; with the Pulpit for the Preacher , with the Lords Table g g Canon 82. for the Ministration of the Holy Supper ; and the Font h h Canon 81. to Christen in also is kept clean , comely , and sweetly , the people are more comforted to resort thither , and tarry the whole time appointed them . i i Hom. of Idolatry , ● . Part. Thus the 85. Canon provides , That the Church be well and sufficiently repaired , and so from time to time kept and maintained : that all things be in such orderly and decent sort , without dust or any thing that may be noisome or unseemly , as becometh the House of God : That there be a terrior of Glebe Lands , and other possessions belonging to the Churches . Canon 87. That the Churches be not profaned . Canon 88. That the Bible and Common-Prayer Book , and the Book of Homilies , be had in every Church , &c. Can. 80.

Unto all this , I wish some would add the Consideration of what Mr Baxter hath writ .

Temples , Vtensils , &c. devoted & lawfully Christian Direct . p. 915. Qu. 170. separated by man , for holy uses , are holy as justly related to God by that lawful separation . Ministers are more holy than Temples , Lands , Vtensils , as being nearlier related to holy things : and things separated by God , are more holy than those justly separated by man : And so of Days , every thing should be reverenced according to the measure of its Holiness : and this expressed by such signs , gestures , actions , as are fittest to honour God , to whom they are related : and so to be uncovered in Church , and use reverent carriage and gestures there , doth tend to preserve the due reverence to God and to his worship , 1 Cor. 16. 20.

CHAP. IX . Of the Moderation of our Church , with respect to Holy-Days , namely , both the Feasts and Fasts of the Church .

§ . 1. The Feasts of the Church are few ; and those for great reason chose : with care to avoid the excesses of the Romanists . § . 2. The further behaviour of the Church in her Feasts , most useful and prudent . § . 3. We celebrate the memory of Saints , but of none whose existence or sanctity is uncertain . § . 4. The excellent ends of our Churches honour to Saints , are set down . § . 5. That they are Festivally Commemorated , not out of opinion of worship , or merit , or absolute necessity thereof to Religion . § . 6. Our Church runs not into any excess , in any Prayer to Saints . § . 7. Nor with reference to Images . § . 8. Whether our Church in any of these practices , be justly charged of Popery , by those , who Canonize among themselves those who are of uncertain sanctity . § . 9. The Moderation of our Church in its honour given to Angels . § . 10. And to the Blessed Virgin . § . 11. Our Church hath taken great care , that a special honour be had to the Lords Day ; and that the Lords Day , nor any other Festival , be abused to Luxury and Impiety . § . 12. The Moderation of the Church , with reference to its Musick and Psalmody . § . 13. The Moderation of our appointed Fasts : The Lenten or Paschal Fast , how far Religious by the Precept of the Church .

§ 1. COncerning Holy-Days in general , it may suffice here , only to repeat the words of our Bishops ( in answer to the Presbyterian Brethren 1661. N. 6. ) The observation of Saints days , is not of divine but Ecclesiastical Institution , and therefore it is not necessary that they should have any other ground in Scripture , than other Institutions of the same nature , so that they be agreeable to the Scripture in the general end , for the promoting of Piety : and the observation of them was ancient , as appears by the Rituals and Liturgies , and by the joint consent of Antiquity ; and by the ancient Translation of the Bible , as the Syriack and Aethiopick , where the Lessons appointed for Holy-Days are noted , and set down ; the former of which was made near the Apostles times . Besides , our Saviour himself kept a Feast of the Churches Institution ; viz. The Feast of Dedication , S. Jo. 12. 22. The choice end of these dayes being not Feasting , but the exercise of Holy Duties , they are fitter called Holy-Days than Festivals , and though they be all of like nature , it doth not follow that they are equal .

The exceeding number of Festivals in the Roman Church ( that they have neither mean nor measure , in making new Holy-days , as Mr Latimer saith a a Sermon to the Convocation . ) hath been the frequent complaint , not only of many Learned Protestants b b Vetus querela est de nimis magnâ festorum multitudin● . Chemn . Exam. Pars 4. p. 162. , but also of very many of the Roman Communion ( as might be instanced : ) Who have thought that the Salvation of men would have been better consulted , if there were fewer Solemnities and greater Devotion : alledging that of St Bernard c c Patriae est non exilii , frequentia haec gaudio●um ; & numerositas festivitatum Cives decet non exules . S. Bern. Ep. 174. : Such a number of Festivities , is fitter for Citizens , than for Exiles and Pilgrims : And Clemangius notes , that Moses appointed but three great Solemnities ; whereas at present the Romanists d d Quarta pars anni feratiunculis conteritur . Wicelius Meth. Conc. §. 19. Essraenis earum numerus . Centum gravam . 37. Turba festorum dierum de causis non necessariis , &c. Erasin . de amab . Concor . observe more Festivals than ever the Scribes and Pharisees did : neither had they any Feast for the Chair of Moses , as the other have for the Chair of S. Peter .

'T is true , a French Writer ( with the approbation of some Sorbon Doctors ) and others of the same Communion have thought , that many of their Festivals might be dispenst with , by the Popes leave ; or without it , according to the priviledges of the Gallican Church : but now as they write under correction of Superiours , 't is pretty to see in their pruning the luxuriant number of Feasts ; what choice some Puritan Romanists offer at , in their Schemes of Reformation c c J Bapt. Thiers de fest. dier. Imminutione , c. 48. : For , the Feast of Circumcision they would blot out , because it falls on the first of January : ( a day of Gentile superstition . ) The Feast of our Lords being presented in the Temple , or of the Purification : because C. 51. on that day the Gentiles honoured Mars or Pluto , called Februus : and the Feast of Epiphany they would have expunged , because on those days some chuse King and Queen : Yet how do they strain C. 49. at a Gnat , and swallow a Camel ? for these glorious Reformers of the Calendar , will by no means have the Feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin into Heaven , omitted f f Assumptionis celebritatem servari par est . C. 52. p. 339. : And at this day the Romanists keep for a solemnity the Immaculate Conception of the Virgin Mary : By which , as St Austin speaks of some , they love to Canonize their own Apocryphal Errors : notwithstanding among the Feast-days to be deleted , the fore-mentioned Reformers have the confidence to reckon up All Saints days , and the Feast of St Michael , and the Holy Angels , and of all the Apostles , C. 53 , 54 , 55. except S. Peter , and S. Paul .

Whereas in the Church of England ( as also in the Lutheran and other Reformed Churches g g D. D. Durell , of Ref. Ch. Sect. 2. §. 23 , 24. Chemnit. Exam. par. 4. p. 163. ) after the reformation , a moderate number of Festivals were appointed h h V. The Act for abrogation of superfluous Holy-days . Bishop Spar. Collect. p. 225. King Edw. 6. Inj. 1547. Queen Eliz. Inj. §. 46. Festos dies Protestantes , Legum praescripto , utcunque tenent eosdem omnes quos antiquitus celebravit Ecclesia , satetur Sander . de Schism . Angl. p. 171. , for the same reasons that the most sober Romanists have desired many of theirs might be rescinded .

§ . 2. Another consideration which moderates the number of Festivals in our Church , is , several of them fall in with the Lords day : and indeed most of them have Relation to our Blessed Lord , and his Apostles : so that from the very design of the Festival , the hard-handed Artizan may learn the name and meaning of some Article of his Creed , ( as Bishop Taylor speaks i i Pref. to Collection of Offices , §. 36. ) and by such anniversary remembrances of his Faith , may at once help his memory and devotion : both which among the Romanists are much overcharged with the exceeding number of Festivals ; and also by them the mean man is much hindred from maintaining his Family , and paying his dues : In the poor Mans Almanack , the number of Festivals on one side , encreasing the number of debts on the other , together confound his devotion and his estate : Whereas in our Calendar , the Festivals are set down with such choice , as Bishop Hall somewhere hath noted , that the meaner sort by skill in their Almanack , may be taught their Christian Faith k k Festorum recurrens meditatio est veluti Catecheseos Christianae inculcatio , &c. Forbes . Irenic . l. 1. c. 7. .

§ . 3. As we cannot but account it a very scandalous reproach , which some of the Romanists have used , that l l Richworth Dialogue 3. Catholicks have some Saints , Protestants none ; So they may know , we celebrate such whom the true Catholick Church always hath celebrated : and which are also Celebrated by many of the Reformed Churches m m V. Confess . Helvet . c. 24. Confess . Eccl. Bohem. & Morav . : Yea , and as we have had our Saints , so our Church hath had her Martyrs too , which are more than common Saints , who have been glorious Witnesses of the Moderation of our Church , and of the extreme rigours of our Churches Adversaries on either hand : In the Remembrance of whom ( as Bishop Cozins n n Private Dev. p. 92. hath taken notice ) Such is the wisdom and Moderation of our Church , she hath taken one solemn day of the year to magnify God for the generality of his Saints together , hereby avoiding the burden and unnecessary number of Festival days : Neither is the memory of any Saint among us celebrated , of whose sanctity , much more , of whose existence , we are uncertain o o Of the Canonization of St. Thomas a Becket , V. Consid. of present Concernment , §. 9. V. C. Baron . in Martyrol . die 29. Decembr . S. Thom. Cantuar. Macte animo , macte virtute Anglicanorum nobilissime ac gloriosissime coetus , qui tam illustri militiae nomen dedisti , ac Sacramento sanguinem spospondisti : aemulor sanè vos Dei aemulatione , cum vos Martyrii Candidatos , ac nobilissimae purpurae Martyres aspicio . Quae verba dixit vir gravissimus non solùm de his qui temporibus Elizabethae , sed etiam de his qui suo etiam tempore sub Jacobo propter similem causam passi sunt . Suarii Def. l. 6. c. 11. De veris Anglicanis Martyribus : H. Garnetto , &c. V. Sander . de Schism . Angl. ad finem . .

So far is our Church from allowing the Roman way of Apotheosis , whose Calendar affords a red Letter for some who have died for the blackest and foulest crimes .

Nor doth our Church obtrude upon those of her Communion , any Apocryphal Legends p p Ludov. Viv. l. 2. de Caus . corrup . ar. V. de Fest. imminutione , c. 50. p. 32● . or Fables of Saints : nor receives any false Revelations or Visions for the keeping new Festivals .

§ . 4. The ends propounded in our Church , why we celebrate the memory of Saints , are most just and unexceptionable , namely , that we may bless God for their gifts and graces , which have been eminent in them : which we magnify and celebrate , that we may more chearfully be enlivened to imitate q q Divos ac Divas optim● coli imitando vitam illorum . Erasm . de amab . Eccl. Concor . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . S. Chrys. To. 5. p. 625. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Euseb. Eccl. Hist. l. 4. c. 14. them , and breath after the glory they possess : there being one general Assembly of the Church Militant on Earth , and Triumphant in Heaven : Wherefore we pray on All-Saints day , That God who hath knit together his Elect , in one communion and Fellowship in the mystical body of his Son Jesus Christ our Lord , would grant us grace , so to follow his Blessed Saints , in all vertuous and godly living , that we may come to those unspeakable joyes , &c. But we are not convinced of the necessity to acknowledge , that by the Solemnities of Saints we can procure interest in their merits : or are thereby helped by their Prayers .

§ . 5. Many are the excesses which by the opinion of merits , the Church of Rome hath run into : This hath been the fund for the treasury of their Church ; and hereon hath been framed the artifice of Indulgences : Wherefore though our Church hath the greatest honour for the Saints departed that need to be , yet doth she not think that the Saints on Earth ever merited for themselves , much less for others : according to the sense of the Romanists , which is , That r r Hom. of good Works , 3. Part. De thesauro Ecclesiae superf●uentium satisfactionum B. Mariae , & aliorum Sanctorum & dispensatione per Ecclesiam , Vi. C. Bell. de Indulg . l. 1. c. 2 , 3. their Lamps always run over , able to satisfy , not only for their own , but also for all other their Benefactors , Brothers and Sisters of Religion : Keeping in divers places , Marts , or Markets of Merits , being full of holy Reliques and works of over-flowing abundance ready to be sold . Therefore we observe the wise Moderation of our Church in taking particular care , that on our Saints dayes , all our Prayers be offered , in and through the Mediation of Christ our Lord , in whose merits only we place any hope : and our Homily concerning Faith saith ; In the second of the Ephesians , the meaning of the Apostle is , not to induce us to have any affiance , or to put any confidence in our works , as by the merit or deserving s s Deus propriè nulli debitor est nisi forsita● ex gratuito promisso , quanquam & hoc ipsum ut praestemus promissi conditionem , illius est munisicentiae . Erasm . de amab . Eccl. Concor . of them , to purchase to our selves or others , remission of sin , for that were meer blasphemy against Gods mercy .

§ . 6. Very many also have been the excesses of the Church of Rome in praying to Saints departed ; wherein , beside , that their doctrine relies on what is false and uncertain ( namely that they so well know our particular conditions , and are ready at hand to hear our Prayers ; Since V. Homily of Prayer . it is none of their office to attend us ; neither have they any Commission from God to intercede for us , yet ) the Romanists often pray solemnly to Saints , for what is only proper for God to bestow ; and thereby attribute unto Creatures the incommunicable honour of the Creator t t V. Homily of the peril of Idolatry . Whereas our Church both practiseth and requires Prayer and Invocation unto God only : It no where applies the Lords Prayer , or the Psalms of David , unto the Virgin Mary , or any of the Saints : nor alloweth nuncupating of Vows , or offering Sacrifices to Saints , nor carrying about their u u Non video in multis quod sit discrimen inter eorum opinionem de Sanctis & id quod Gentiles putabant de Diis suis . Lud. Vives in S. Aug. de Civ . D. l. 8. c. 27. Images and Reliques , with theatrical pomp , as if they were inhabited Shrines of the divine blessing and favour : giving temptation to the amused people , to exhibite to them religious honour , peculiarly due to the Essential Sanctity of God : the doing of which , the Saints themselves do most of all abhorr * * V. Origen . c. Cels . p. 238. Euseb. l. 4. c. 14. Eccl. Hist . Reformed Catholick , §. 14. Conclu. 2. . For as our Homily of Prayer hath it : The Saints and Angels in Heaven , will not have us to do any honour unto them , which is due and proper unto God . If any man ( saith Mr Perkins ) can shew us the bodily relique of any true Saint , and prove it so to be , though we will not worship it , yet will we not despise it , but keep it as a Monument , if it may conveniently be done without offence .

§ . 7. The special Moderation of our Church of England , with relation to the Images of Saints , is best exprest in the Injunctions of King Edw. 6. 1547. All Ecclesiastical persons are to teach their Parishioners , that Images serve for no other purpose but to be a Remembrance , whereby men may be admonished of the Holy Lives and Conversations of them the said Images represent y y Nos unam veneramur Imaginem quae est Imago invisibilis & Omnipotentis Dei. S. Hieron . in Ezek. 16. . Where we see our Church is not for defacing of Images , so far as they are only Historical z z Et quidem zelum , ne quid manu factum adorari possit , habuisse laudavimus , sed frangere easdem imagines non debuisse judicamus : quatenus literarum nescii haberent unde scientiam historiae colligerent , & populus in picturae adoratione minimè peccarent . Gregor. Magnus l. 7. Ep. 109. Monuments , and instruments of remembrance and affection : but against the abuse of them . It follows in the Injunction , which Images , if any abuse for other intent , they commit Idolatry in the same , to the great danger of their Souls . So the Homily a a Homily of Idolatry . 2. Part. takes notice , how Image Worshippers ( as all things that be amiss ) have from a tolerable beginning , grown worse and worse , till at last they became intolerable b b Ad extremam vanitatem quam Ethnici , &c. Cassander p. 175. : as is excellently set forth in the 14th Ch. of Wisdom . The corruption of which Doctrines and practices in the Church of of Rome c c Concil. Trid. Sess. 25. is such , that they thereby give a great scandal to the Jews , and the Mahometans ; and the same is very much aggravated by their expunging out of the Fathers , sundry passages which speak most plainly against such practices d d E. g. in S. Aug. de re. Rel. p. 743. Froben . delend . Honorandi propter imitationem , non adorandi propter religionem . Ita in S. Athan. c. Arianos . delend . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . V. Ind. Expurg . . From all these instances we may observe , how steddily our Church doth mannage it self between defect and excess of honour to the Saints departed this Life in the Faith and fear of God . For the Celebration of Saints here , is not out of any opinion of worship of them , or merit by that Celebration , or any absolute necessity thereof to Religion , otherwise than that it is exceeding comely that God should be honoured in his Saints e e Vt eorum necessariam salubremque memoriam festivitas concelebrata custodiat . S. Aug. l. 32. c. Faust . c. 12. .

I may add here also what hath been observed of the Modesty of our Church reformed , Scintilla Altaris . That to avoid excess of Dedications ( wherein others are too burthensome ) she sometimes uniteth two of the Apostles at once in one Festivity ; as S. Simon and Jude : S. Philip and James .

§ . 8. The more immoderate is their reproach , who brand our reformed Church for being guilty of Popery , only because the memory of the just among us is blessed f f Co●●mus Martyres cultu dilectionis non servitutis . S. Aug. c. Faus . l. 22. . Notwithstanding those very exceptors are really like the Romanists , Canonizing and Sainting one another for being of some particular humour and faction : in this for one , that they will not keep a Festival , or remember an Apostle with honour . Indeed in the Church of Rome they have Canonized the worst of men , and let any one tell the difference , when many of those others Saint each other , and affect no other Title but of your Holiness . And here , let any equal and intelligent Christians judge , whether those who hold Communion with the Church of God ( notwithstanding sundry infirmities and failings ) ought not ( and may not more properly , according to the stile of Scripture ) to be called Saints , than those who separate from the outward Communion of Gods Church , although they usurp the name peculiarly to themselves . And here we cannot but observe the Modesty of those in Communion with the Church of England ( which is true Christian Moderation ) They never were so forward to rush suddenly ( as it were ) into the Holy of Holies , in calling themselves and one another absolute Saints : but rather ( while they are in their way and Pilgrimage ) chuse to be honoured with more modest titles : even as Pythagoras in all Ages hath been commended for his Moderation , in laying aside the great name of Wife , and chose rather to be called a Lover of Wisdom .

§ . 9. The same Moderation which our Church useth toward Saints ; she observeth likewise with respect to the Holy Angels : Yea , indeed great is the modesty and sober wisdom of our Church , in that it is no where excessively curious , nor positive in determining of the nature , actions , knowledge , number , Orders , or special Guardianship of Angels . Our Church doth not deny that there is a distinct Order of Angels , but no where takes upon her to show how those Orders are disposed . But avoiding the extreme of those who are stupidly insensible of the conduct of Holy Angels , the Church of England doth glorify God for their Creation , for their admirable order and Ministry , and affection to us : we pray to God we may imitate their readiness and chearfulness in praising and serving him , and ministring daily for the good of others ; yet our Church hath always held the Angels to be in the number of those who worship , and not of those who are worshipped : and for us to worship those who are themselves worshippers , would be such a voluntary humility as is sinful ; namely , to address our selves to such substitutes as God no where hath appointed to receive his peculiar honour g g 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Orig. c. Cels . l. 8. Neque Invocationibus Angelicis , sed 〈◊〉 , purè & manifestè Orationes dirigens ad Dominum qui omnia s●it . Iren. l. 2. c. 57. : which the Synod of Laodicea ( A. D. 364. ) calls Idolatry .

§ . 10. The like Moderation doth our Church excellently well observe , in the honour she gives to the Ever Blessed Virgin Mary , so highly favoured of God , as to be the Mother of our Lord ; whom our Church celebrates , and always humbly calls her Blessed : And as it is in the Institution of a Christian man , set forth by the Convocation , 1537. We may worthily say , she is the most blessed of all other Women h h Maria Mater Domini principatum inter Mulieres tenuit . S. Aug. Scrm. 136. Hanc ego Christi Matrem veneror — sed non illi Divae modò sed & Deae nomen tribuens . R. Jac. Apol. pro Jur. Honor Reginae judicium diligit , Virgo Regia falso non eget honore . de B. V. Mariâ , S. Bernard . Ep. 174. : and we no where doubt but she is highly graced in Heaven , as she received a most special priviledge upon Earth . But our Church doth no where believe , that she had an immaculate conception , which the Romanists celebrate with an Holy-day on purpose : Neither doth our Church believe , she was ever raised from the dead , and assumed into Heaven ; which they solemnize with another Festival . Neither did Erasmus i i Erasm . Ecclesiastes , l. 2. without cause admire how it came to pass they salute the Mother of Christ with more Religion than they invoke Christ himself , or the Holy Spirit , calling her the Fountain of all Grace : and sundry expressions they use of the like affiance in the authority and merit of the Blessed Virgin , to succour , help , and save Sinners , as may be seen in the Rosary and Psalter , and specially Litanies to the Virgin Mary k k V. Consult . Cassandr . Art . 20. p. 140. Jube Filio , &c. Cùm vix aliud in toto choro sit alienius à scripturis sanctis & quod cum Evangelio Christi atque doctrinâ Apostolicâ perditiùs pugnet . Wicelius de abusu Eccl. p. 392. . In their form of auricular Confession , they are taught thus to begin , l l Manuale Confessionum , Cap. 10. p. 128. I Confess to the Omnipotent God , to the Blessed Mary , always Virgin , &c. and when they enter into their Monasteries , they vow themselves to God and the Blessed Virgin : and in all things they are so superdevout m m 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . to the Virgin , that an Oath by her is accounted most sacred , and any of the Festivals may be sooner expunged than that of her Assumption into Heaven ; and although they prohibite the Bible , yet they freely suffer sundry Books of Devotion to the Virgin Mary in the Mother tongue .

§ . 11. Our Church hath taken great care , that a special honour be had to the Lords Day : and that neither the Lords Day , nor any other Festival , be abused to Luxury or impiety n n Haeccine solemnes dies decent quae alios non decent ? Tertull. Ita Festa moderanda ut neque nimia — neque tam flagitiosè profanentur . Bucer . Censur . c. 26. : It appears from the Offices in our Liturgy , the Rubricks , Canons , Homilies , and Statutes of the Land , and Injunctions of our Kings since the Reformation , that there hath been a first and special care taken for the Holy Celebration of Sunday or Lords Day : wherein we are equal to any Church among the Reformed o o Vi. D. Crackenthorp Defens . Eccl. Aug. c. 54. : The other Festivals being over-ruled , that in a Concurrence of Offices they may not disturb its Solemnity : the very religious observation of which , is earnestly also perswaded in our Homilies : and especially in the 13. Canon ( with which agree the Injunctions of K. Edw. 6. and Q. Eliz. ) requiring , p p Coimus in coetum ut Deum quasi manu factâ precationibus ambiamus , orantes coimus ad Divinarum literarum commemorationem , fidem sanctis vocibus pascimus , spem erigimus , fiduciam figimus , &c. Tertull . Apol. All manner of persons within this Church of England , that from henceforth they celebrate and keep the Lords Day , commonly called Sunday , and other Holy-days , according to Gods holy will and pleasure , and the Orders of the Church of England prescribed in that behalf ; that is , in hearing of the Word of God read and taught , in private and publick Prayers , in acknowledging their offences to God , and amendment of the same ; in reconciling themselves charitably to their neighbours , where displeasure hath been , in oftentimes receiving the Holy Communion of the body and blood of Christ , in visiting of the poor and sick , and using all good and sober Conversation . Much to the same purpose is largely insisted on in the Homily of place and time of Prayer .

All persons ( saith the late Statute q q Car. 2. 29. ) shall on every Lords Day apply themselves to the observation of the same , by exercising themselves in the duties of Piety and true Religion , publickly and privately ; and no Tradesman shall do or exercise any worldly labour , &c. ( Works of necessity and Charity only excepted . ) r r Cunctarum artium officia , venerabili die solis quiescant . l. 3. Cod. Tit. de Feriis . Which Statute of the Kingdom , seems to have taken its Rule of Moderation from our excellent Homilies , Which do reprove those who ride Journeys , buy and sell , and make all days alike : who profane such holy times by pride and other excesses : Albeit the same Homily declares , the Commandment of God doth not bind Christian people so straitly to observe the utter Ceremonies of the Sabbath Day , as it was given to the Jews s s Audimus apud Bohemos exoriri novum Judaeorum genus , Sabbatarios appellant , qui tantâ superstitione servant sabbatum , ut si quid eo die inciderit in c●●lum nolint eximere . Erasm . de amab . Concord . , as touching forbearing of work and labour in time of necessity : and so the Injunctions of King Edw. 6. and Queen Eliz. §. 20. conclude , Notwithstanding all Parsons , Vicars , and Curates , shall teach and declare unto their Parishioners , that they may with a safe and quiet Conscience , after Common-Prayer , in time of Harvest , labour upon the Holy and Festival Days , and save that thing which God hath sent : So by King Edw. 6. it was ordered , that the Lords of the Council should upon every Sunday attend the publick affairs of the Realm : The Church also , and the Laws of the Kingdom , have taken the same wise care to set such Holy-Dayes in every term t t Taceat apparitio , advocatio delitescat ; nihil ●odem die sibi vendicat scena theatralis . l. 3. Cod. Tit. de feriis . V. Act for abrogation of Holy-dayes , 1536. R. Hen 8. V. R. H. 8. Injunctions . Hist. of Reform . Collection of Records , l. 3. p. 161. Legum conditores festos instituerunt dies ut ad hilaritatem homines publicè cogerentur tanquam necessarium laboribus temperamentum . Sen. de Tranquill. c. 15. , that beside the ordinary Vacations , there may be some days of respite from secular businesses , and contests of Law , for the exercises of Peace , Charity , and Devotion : So careful have our Laws in Church and Kingdom been to avoid profaneness on one hand , and on the other hand all sorts of superstition : that is , either Heathenish or Jewish usages ( as such . ) For as the Homily of Prayer earnestly blames them , who abuse holy times and places with intolerable superstitions , as hath been in use in the Church of Rome ; so on the other hand , it doth not countenance those opinions which tend to establish among us such observances as were peculiar to the Jews . After the recital of the fourth Commandment in the Decalogue , our Church prays , That our hearts be inclin'd to keep that Law , therein rightly acknowledging a moral equity , that Christians should observe such a proportion of time as hath been the practice of the Church : in which time all impediments to sacred and religious duties , publick or private , are to be avoided according to the equity of the Divine Law , and the Precept of Gods Church .

The Moderation of our Church , in its judgment of the Lords Day , Bishop Bramhall hath observed , from the Homily of the Church , as concurrent with his own judgment u u Discourse of the Sabbath , or Lords Day , p. 932. : 1. That the Homily denieth not the Lords Day the name of Sabbath : That it finds no Law of the Sabbath , Gen. 23. That the Homily finds no seventh Day Sabbath before Moses his time : The Homily gives no power to the fourth Commandement , as it was given to the Jews , to oblige Christians , but only as it was , and so far as it was a Law of nature : The Homily makes the first day of the week to signify the Lords Day : The Homily makes the end of changing the Weekly Festival of the Church to have been in honour of Christs Resurrection : The Homily derives the Lords Day down from the Ascension of Christ immediately . But the Homily doth express , that p. 916. the fourth Commandment doth not bind Christians over-streightly ; Not to the external Ceremonies of the Sabbath ; not to the rigorous part of it to forbear all work . As to the question , By what authority this change was made , I find no cause to doubt ( saith the Bishop ) but that it was made by the authority of Christ ; that is , by divine authority . 'T is true , we find no express precept recorded in Holy Scripture for the setting a-part the first day of the Week for the service of God : Neither is it necessary , that there should be an express Precept for it founded in Holy Scripture , to prove it to be a divine right . The perpetual and universal practice of the Catholick Church , including all the Apostles themselves , is a sufficient proof of the divine right of it ; that at least it was an Apostolical Institution and Ordinance , not temporary , but perpetual .

§ . 12. With the Festivals it may not be improper to join the notice of the Moderation of our Church , in reference to her Musick and Psalmody ; wherein the Constitution of our Church sheweth us the true temper of Religion , which as it is the most serious , so it is the most pleasant of all performances , and is most suited to the nature , temper , and condition of man , in which joy and sorrow have a very interchangeable interest ; therefore S. James saith , Is any afflicted , let him pray ; is any merry , let him sing Psalms : ( Jam. 3. 13. ) Accordingly in our Church , Prayer and praise fill up the measures of Divine Worship ; and can there be any performance more pleasant , than to join with , and imitate the Heavenly Host in the high praises of God ? Neither doth our Church judge it enough for us to make melody in our hearts to the Lord , but doth require us to serve God also with our x x Omnes affectus spiritûs nostri pro sua diversitate habent proprios modos in voce & cantu , quorum occultâ familiaritate excitantur . S. Aug. Confess. 10. c. 33. Voices and our hearing , and our affections raised by Psalms , and Hymns , and Doxologies , and mutual incitements to praise God , and by musical instruments also , where they may be had , that we may set forth the praises of God with all our faculties ; and in the most elevated manner we are capable .

In our Church is proposed to us great variety , in which we may entertain our chearful Devotion : for Psalms , we have the divinely inspired Psalms of David , from whence every one , according to their condition , may be furnished with most excellent Forms of praise and joy in God , according to their several circumstances .

For Hymns y y 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , S. Jo. 17. of Praise , we have select Forms taken out of Holy Scripture , or in use in the ancient Church ; in the variety of which ( with Doxologies also and Hallelujahs ) we are entertained and delighted : We have also in laudable use , many excellent spiritual Songs z z Carmenque Christo quasi Deo dicere secum invicem . Plin. secundus ad Traj . Ep. of more artificial composure a a Peculiares quaedam & magis artificiosae Cantiones . Bez. in 5. Eph. 19. Ere Christianâ foret si in Ecclesiâ Cantiones ad populum intellectas ad usum pietatis permitterent Praesules : Wicelius p. 21. ; so that we may praise God according to the utmost of our abilities .

With these the Moderation of the Church doth not only call off her people from vain , obscene , and impious Songs , which do the Devils work in a sure and insensible manner , which is to debauch and vitiate the dispositions and natures of such as use them : but hereby we are furnisht also to speak to our selves , and to admonish one another ( as the Apostle exhorts ) in Psalms , and Hymns , and spiritual Songs , singing with grace , making melody in our hearts to the Lord b b Eph. 5. 19. Col. 3. 16. . In which our Church , with the Apostle , doth chiefly endeavour to promote the grace and devotion of the heart , which is most worthy to inspire our praise : The sincere elevation of the Spirit , being the life of all our Psalmody , even that half which makes the whole , without which the tongues of men and Angels ( as without Charity ) are like a sounding brass , or tinkling Cymbal . Where this grace of the heart is united with the melody of the Voice , we may entertain our selves with that joy in God , which is the most refined sort of delight we can enjoy : We join with the Church Militant on Earth , and the Church Triumphant in Heaven : We make the best use of that gift of Speech which we have given us to interpret our thoughts by articulate voice , and stir up our own and others affections to set forth the high praises of the most Excellent Majesty of God : whom it becomes us to serve not only with our nature , but our skill .

If we ought to praise God with melody , then a grave and solemn Musick , which is useful to govern the melody , and also encrease it , may be useful to the praise and worship of God : and if persons love what is costly , as well as useful , in their private Houses , why should any envy themselves or others , some comely magnificence in the holy service of God ? especially when such an instrument may make our affections as well as our singing , more regular and composed .

Neither is this help to melody ever the worse , because David us'd it in the Holy Service of God : He praised God in the most excellent manner he could , upon Harp and Organ , and such Musical Instruments as were in use for the honour of God , and called upon others very earnestly and instantly to praise God with the same : and it may be noted , that praising God by assistance of Instrumental Musick was more ancient than giving the Law in Sinai , more ancient c c Exod. 15. 20. than the Ceremonies of the Tabernacle or the Temple : Wherefore it is rather to be esteemed the effect of natural Religion , than any Ceremonial Law of Moses ; of which , the Musick David used was no part ; and being never appointed , was never abolished ; ( according to the mistake of the Geneva Notes , and of many others from them , whereas they might have been taught otherwise from Calvin d d Psalmus sit in quo concinendo adhibetur Musicum aliquod Instrumentum p●ater linguam . Calvin . in Col. 3. 16. & in Cap. 6. Amos v. 5. himself , in his Comment upon Coloss. 3. 16. Where he expoundeth a Psalm to be that , in the singing of which , some Musical Instrument is used beside the tongue : ) And in that David us'd the help of Instrumental Musick ( although there was no express Command of God for so doing ) much more among Christians e e Advers●s q●osdam ●anaticos qui cantum Ecclesiasticum ●●o Inti●hristiano 〈…〉 . Vorstius in Eph. 5. 19. ( who are not required to look for particular Commands extraordinary ) some things may be used as circumstances and helps in the worship of God , which are not required by any express Text of Scripture : So that from the example of David , we are neither bound up to a strict imitation of every thing he did ; neither doth the Church neglect his Example , where the reason remains the same ; but makes use of its Christian Liberty , as it judgeth most for edification and good order in the service of God f f Curandum est ut illa quoque Musica sit digna templo Dei. Erasmus de amab . Eccl. Concord . : where may be observed the Moderation of our Church , in that Musick is used not as of necessity , but of choice : And though the Psalmody appointed in our Church , is that which recites the divine praises as much as may be in the words of the inspired Psalmists ; although [ singing of Psalms in meter is no part of our Liturgy ] yet great is the Moderation and condescension of our Church , in permitting an accommodation in this matter to the most imperfect : as indeed the whole use also of Musick is in condescension to the imperfection of our state , because our affections are more stir'd up by the same means as our voices and melody are assisted . The Moderation of our Church may be further observed herein , in that 1. Nothing is ordered to be sung with instrumental Musick , but what is taken out of Holy Scripture g g Extra Psal nos V. T. aliquid Poeticè compositum in Ecclesia ca●ere vetatur . Conc. Bracarens . Can. 30. : 2. All is sung in the Common language : 3. The Musick only governs and moderates the Song , and encreaseth the melody : 4. Our Musick and Singing is such as S. Austin commended at Alexandria , nearer pronouncing than singing : designed wholly for edification , consistent with gravity h h Ad gravitatem att●●r . peratus cantus . Calv. Instir . l. 3. §. 20. and Christian simplicity , answering the designs of Religion ; framed not only for delighting the Ear , but affecting the Heart i i Vt per ob●ectamenta aurium animus in affectum pietatis ass●●gat . S. Aug. Confess. 10. , and raising the Devotion : wherefore as it is in the 49. Injunction of Queen Eliz. A modest and distinct Song is enjoined k k Itaque operosam Musi●am quae figurata dicitur , inf●rri placet . V. Reform . Leg. Eccl. de Div. off . c. 5. V. Vossium de viribus rythmi . , such that the sentence of the Hymn may be understood . And for Organs or other Instruments of Musick in Gods worship , they being a help , Mr Baxter's Christian Direct . p. 412. partly natural , partly artificial , to the exhilarating the spirits , for the praise of God ; I know no argument to prove them simply unlawful , but what would prove a Cup of Wine unlawful , or the tune , and metre , and melody of singing unlawful .

And now we are discoursing of Melody , the use of Bells l l Vbi pulchriores & plures & magis sonorae etiam ad modos Musicos confectae Campanae quam in Anglià ? Spal . contra Suarez . c. 2. §. 27. among us deserves our notice , since the Archbishop of Spalato hath taken particular observation , how choicely we are furnished in our Kingdom ; for Assembling the Congregation , for testimonies of publick joy , and for pious admonition of Christian people , to pray for such as are departing this life ; but among us , they are not us'd with any superstitions m m Nec Campanas superstitiosè pulsari vel in vigiliâ animarum , vel postridiè omnium Sanctorum qui dies non ita pridem geniis mortuorum sacer erat . Lib. quo Canonum , 1571. : What Cardinal Bellarmine n n C. Bell. Apologia . calls only Benediction of Bells , is not after that manner as might make it be thought they are Christned o o Centum gravam. 51. .

§ . 13. Having observed the Moderation of the Church in its Feasts , the same also is very true of its Fasts : The keeping up of the Festivals and Fasts in the Greek Church , hath been observed as a chief means of preserving the Christian Religion from sinking among them p p De Eccl. Gr. statu hodierno , p. 10. L. Canon . 72. 1603. : Our Church is neither so remiss as not to give any Counsel or Command for Fasting , nor suffers any ( not Ministers ) to appoint solemn Fasts without authority q q In observantiis afflictivis videtur providendum de aliquâ Moderatione . Pet. de Aliaco in fasc . re . exp . Jejunium Ecclesiae non debuit abrogari , licebit moderari . Wicelius in viâ Regiâ , p. 374. , neither is she immoderate in what she injoins , but observes its due measures as are most conducing to assist Meditation , Prayer , and the exercise of Repentance , and works of Piety . With Fasting we join Alms , and the Commemoration of what Christ hath done and suffered for us : And as among the Jews it was usual for them voluntarily to fast on that day yearly they buried their Parents ; so in the Christian Church , on the time that the Bridegroom was taken away , before the Paschal Festivity , the Custom hath been to fast more or less . Some few times beside are appointed as opportunities to call off the mind from the blandishments of sense : Mortification and temperance we are enjoin'd by our Christianity ; and further , it appears to all most reasonable , that there should be some seasons proper for Fasting and Mourning , which private persons may appoint to themselves r r Tantum tibi jejuniorum modum impone quantum f●●re pot●s●s si●t tibi pura , casta , simplicia , moderata & non superstitiosa jejunia . S. Hier. de vitâ cler. ad Nepotian . ; much more the publick authority of the Church , for the common good of all . In which appointed Fasts , let us well observe , that the Precepts of the Church make no difference of meats , but require such an abstinence as may best subdue the flesh to the Spirit . There are three ends of Fasting ( saith the Homily ) To chastise the flesh : That the Spirit may be more fervent to Prayer : and that our Fast may be a witness with us before God of our humble submission to His Majesty : So that the difference of meats which we observe , is accidental to the Commands of the Church , and not at all directly intended in it , but left to every ones Christian Liberty and choice s s P●● temporibus & causis uni●scu●●sque non pro imperio novae Dis●ipline . Tert. adv. Psych . Cap. 2. , so long as the purposes of Religion before-mentioned be observed , and the Commands of Governours : Thus the Moderation of the Church leaves us here as she finds us in our Christian Liberty .

But we are to consider , that it is part of the Christian liberty of publick Governours , in Cases left by God indifferent , therein to Command , especially for publick good : So that it is the Law of the Kingdom only which streightens and confines our liberty from meats at some particular times . While therefore it is the Law of the Kingdom , people must have a care of charging the Church with a superstitious difference of meats , because the Church of Rome usurps that power : The Statute indeed of Queen Eliz. provides concerning observing Lent , and also that Lent be not counted a Religious Fast : that is , by the Statute , None are to affirm , that any eating of fish , or forbearing of flesh , is of any necessity for saving the soul of man , or that it is the service of God , otherwise than as other politick Laws are : for as the Homily t t Homily of Fasting . further expounds it : The Laws of Princes are not made to put holiness in one kind of meat or drink more than another , but are grounded meerly on policy : All subjects therefore are bound in Conscience to keep these Laws : Conscience , I say , not of the thing which is in its own nature indifferent , but of our obedience we owe to Gods Minister . According to which sense also must the Laws be understood , which respect the Wednesday Fast ( called by some the Jejunium Cecilianum u u Quòd putetur Cecilii esse inventum . De Schism . Angl. p. 172. ) If any person should affirm it to be impos'd , with an intention to bind the Conscience , he should be punished like a spreader of false news ; that is , to burden the Conscience with a superstitious difference of meats : or as of necessity , to bind the Conscience by any Law equivalent to the eternal word of God : which are the words of the Advertisement of Queen Elizabeth , in her order of Ceremonies , 1554.

Thus in the Visitation Articles of King Edw. 6. The manner and kind of fasting in Lent , and other days in the year , is but a meer positive Law , and therefore all persons having just cause of sickness x x 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , Can. Ap. 69. or other necessity , or being licensed by the Kings Majesty , may moderately eat all kinds of meats without grudge or scruple of Conscience .

So careful is our Church according to the practice of the ancient Church , that the Fasts be observed with all just and equitable Moderation , lest any fall into an excess of abstinence y y 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . S. Basil . M. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . : But there is not one word in all the Liturgy , of the choice of meats .

Neither is this positive Law of the Kingdom the worse , but the better , because it may be obey'd upon a political account ; and also secondly , may be rendred useful to the spiritual ends of Fasting , namely , to bring the body under subjection to the spirit z z Vt carnalis appetitus melius compesceretur , &c. quarè universa Ecclesia in hanc jejunii Anti-Paschalis formam citò consentit . D. Beverigius : de jej . quadrag . l. 3. c. 9. , which may justly make a Fast , a Religious Fast , as it ought to be ; and thirdly , Upon a natural reason also ; the Fast of Lent happens luckily at such a time of year , namely in Spring , when most Constitutions may allow a greater Moderation in diet for health's sake : So we have been taught : But in the morning Lectures against Popery ( Serm. 25. p. 119. ) is asserted , that the Physicians have unanimously taught , we ought least of all to fast in Spring , but to eat more largely , and that flesh , and abstain from fish ; from whence would be infer'd , that those who are for a Spring Fast , are not only Anti-Christian , but Anti-Physician ; and the note of remark there is , It became the man of Perdition , not only to destroy our Souls but our bodies also : I leave it undecided , whose skill is greatest in this matter , those Physicians , or this Divine : St Chrysostom in his Sermon of Fasting saith , If we exactly search the matter , we shall find , that it is the mother of health , and of the good habit of the body , and saith he , if thou believest not my words , ask the Sons of the Physicians about it a a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . ; and for the time of the year , S. Austin b b In quâ enim parte anni congruentiùs observatio quadrage-simae constituatu ? Ad Januar. Ep. 119. asketh , In what part of the year more congruously can the observation of Lent be observed ? And the ancient Therapeutae are memorable for their fasting in Spring , not only for the health of their Souls , but their Bodies . The rest let the Physicians speak .

I only add , that the practice of the Church , in reference to Ember and Rogation Weeks , is very pious and useful , and attended with great Moderation : For the putting people in mind of the stated times of Ordination , that by Fasting and Prayer we may all beseech God for his Benediction on all that are to be ordained to his Ministery , is without exception .

So the Rogation Week is not appointed to cherish any superstitious fear of Prodigies , or inauspicious accidents approaching , but carefully to promote the designs of Piety , Justice , and Charity , in a way far from superstition . For although some kinds of Processions were put down : Yet Perambulations and Circuits of the Parish c c Q. Eliz. Inj. 18 , 19. V. Homilies for Rogation Week . are retained , and at their return they are required to make their Prayers , and to give God thanks for his benefits : and whereas in their other Processions in time of Popery , they used to sing unto many of their Saints , Ora pro nobis : ever since the Injunctions of 1541. d d V. Collec . of Records , Hist. of Ref. l. 3. p. 181. the suffrages which were advised , were rather , Spare us good Lord , Good Lord deliver us .

Since therefore the Wise man saith , There is a time to weep and a time to laugh , Eccles. 3. 4. Since the Festivals and Fasts in our Church , are enjoin'd for such excellent ends , as promoting the service of Qu. Eliz. Injunc . §. 20. Can. 13. God and religious exercises , and moderated also with all respect , to the conditions , necessities , and occasions of humane nature and life , with all cautions against excesses in practice or opinion ; it is heartily to be wished , that all sober and wise Christians would be more careful of their observance : that we may not lose all good order in this great corruption of the Age , in which so many inconsiderate people are regardless of holy times : and the Romanists frequently object , that many Protestants are never satisfied , till their reformations end in a quite opposite extreme . It is heartily also to be wished , that those who in their judgments do well allow such appointments , were not so indifferent in their observance : Happy is he that condemneth not himself in the thing which he alloweth , Rom. 14. 22. And what God said unto Moses and Aaron , ought to be imprinted on all our minds : because the reason of the command abides : Speak unto Aaron and his Sons , that they profane not my holy Name , in those things which they hallow unto me : I am the Lord .

But as for those who will not Fast nor Feast with us , If I may use the words of our Saviour ( S. Luke 7. 31. ) Whereunto shall I liken the men of this Generation ? They are like unto Children sitting in the market place .

For as when John the Baptist ( according to the infinite wisdom of God so ordering it ) appeared in all mortification and self-denial , as was most fit to prepare the way of the Lord : humble in his habit and behaviour , very abstemious and sparing in his diet and course of Life : that he might bring off the Jews from expecting a pompous Messias , which they , newly opprest by the Tyranny of the Roman power , were hugely inclined to promise themselves : and after him our Blessed Lord came more sociable and publick in his Conversation , to recommend his Doctrine and example more advantagiously unto all : Yet the men of that Generation , the Scribes and Pharisees on one hand , and the gentile Philosophers on the other , would neither conform themselves nor comply with either dispensation ; refusing to enter into the Temple , by the gate of the Bridegroom , or by the gate of the Mourners ; and instead of Piping or Dancing with their Fellows , as each reason of the time required ; they rather fill'd the Market place with loud complaints , or with their own disorders : and instead of accepting of the greatest wisdom , in accommodation to themselves ; they highly censured , one while John the Baptist for his mortification ( as v. 33. ) another while our Blessed Lord for his Freedom ( v. 34. ) wherefore our Saviour compares them to Children , peevish Children ; tossing to and fro , and never well , full nor fasting . So of the same restless and unsatisfied humour , are the common excepters against the appointments of our Church .

One while , if we observe the Rules of the Church , in our abstinence and retirements , and imitate John Baptists severity , thereby to prepare the way of the Lord : At other Seasons , if we imitate our Blessed Saviour in his blameless liberty , ( albeit with such Moderation and Religion as the Church requires ) : Yet both the Church for enjoining , and her Sons for observing those Injunctions cannot escape the dint of their keenest censures . But wisdom is justified of her Children .

CHAP. X. Of the Moderation of the Church in reference to the Holy Sacraments .

§ . 1. The Moderation of our Church raiseth no strife about words relating thereunto . § . 2. Her Moderation in what is asserted of the number of Sacraments . § . 3. In that her Orders for the Administration of the Sacraments are most suitable to the ends of their appointments . § . 4. In that our Church doth not make the benefit of the Sacraments to depend upon unrequired conditions .

In reference to Holy Baptism , § . 1. Our Church doth make nothing of the essence of Baptism , but the use of the invariable Form . § . 2. The Moderation of our Church toward Infants unbaptized . Her sound and charitable judgment of such as die after Baptism . § . 3. In some necessary cautions referring to the administration of Baptism . § . 4. Referring also to the susceptors . § . 5. In what is required of them who administer that Sacrament .

In reference to the Holy Supper of our Lord , § . 1. The same is with us celebrated in both kinds . § . 2. The Doctrine of Transubstantiation is rejected by our Church : not running to the other extreme of denying a real presence of Christ in the Sacrament . § . 3. The Moderation of our Church in complying with the necessity of the Age : but not with the Church of Rome and others , who require their people to communicate not so much as thrice a year . § . 4. Participation of the Holy Supper required after Confirmation , but not after the rigid Examinations of some , or the auricular Confessions of others : Neither is it made a private banquet . § . 5. In our Church there is not to be a Communication of the Eucharist without Communicants : The Moderation of the Church in other Rubricks referring to the Holy Communion .

§ . 1. OUR Church ( according to that Moderation in which she excels ) raiseth no needless strife or controversy about words or names a a Saepe a. Eccl. Angl. professa est , de verbo nullam litem se moturam , modo pristina sides sit restituta . Rex Jac. ad C. Perr . ( particularly relating to the Holy Sacraments . ) The name of Sacraments ( saith the Homily b b Homily of Com. Pr. and Sacram. ) may in general acception be attributed to any thing whereby a holy thing is signified : thus ( as Chilingworth c c Chilingw . Pref. §. 24. noteth ) we use the names of Priest and Altar , and yet believe neither the corporal presence , nor any proper propitiatory Sacrifice : Yea , so exceeding moderate and prudent was the Church , that in the 7. Canon 1640. it abundantly cautions , lest those words be used otherwise than in a metaphorical and improper attribution d d In Liturgiâ Anglicanâ habemus quidem Sacrificii nomen , offerendi verbum , etiam hostiae mentionem , sed nihil magis adversatur Missatico sacrificio quàm tota haec oratio . Rivet . Gro. discuss . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . p. 220. : Notwithstanding all these just and careful explications , why should our Church for the use of those words , be traduced as relishing of Popery , any more than for favouring the Sabbatarian Doctrine , because in the 70. Canon in English , the word Sabboth Day is used for the Lords day ( and dies dominicus it is in the Latin Canons : ) in the Homily also of the time and place of Prayer , 't is called Sabboth day , that is the Sunday , the Holy day of rest : and in King Henr. 8. Act of abrogation of certain days , it is said , since the Sabboth day was ordained for mans rest : and in Qu. Eliz. Injunctions , the same word is ( as in the rest ) used in a general accommodation to the improper use of the vulgar : which clauses mentioned are known to have been before this word ( among some others ) hath been set apart as one of the Shiboleths of a party : Whereas , rather the Moderation of the Church should be taken notice of , which insists not so much on the nicety of the word , as on the integrity of its sense .

§ . 2. Our Church receives none as proper Sacraments ( generally necessary to salvation ) but such as are so : Which said expression contains a great deal of Moderation ( notwithstanding it hath been much cavill'd at by some of rigid principles ) for our Church doth no where assert the receiving so much as the true Sacraments to be always to every one particularly and absolutely necessary to Salvation . Our Church ( saith Bishop Branthal e e To M. Militier ) receives not the Septenary number of Sacraments , being never so much as mentioned in any Scripture , or Council , or Creed , or Father , or ancient Author , first devised by Peter Lombard , 1439. First Decreed by Eugenius the 4th 1528. First confirmed in the Provincial Council of Senes , 1547. and after in the Council of Trent . The word Sacrament is taken largely , and then washing the Disciples feet is called a Sacrament , then the sprinkling of ashes on a Christians head is called a Sacrament , then there are God knows how many Sacraments more than 7. Or else it is taken for a visible sign instituted by Christ , to convey and confirm invisible grace , to all such partakers thereof , as do not set a bar against themselves , according to the analogy between the sign , or the thing signified : and in this sense , the proper and the certain Sacraments of the Christian Church , common to all , or in the words of the Church , generally necessary to Salvation , are but two , Baptism and the Supper of the Lord : more than these S. Ambrose writes not of in his Book ( de Sacramentis ) because he did not know them . And here it may not be improper to add those memorable words of S. Austin f f S. Aug. Ep. ad Januar. 118. which were recited in the Articles of Religion , 1552. published by King Edw. 6. and are cited also in our Homily of Sacraments : Our Lord Jesus Christ hath knit together a Company of new people , that is , Christians , with Sacraments most few in number , most easy to be kept , most excellent in signification , as are Baptism and the Lords Supper : beside which two Sacraments of the New Testament , our Church appointeth no other way of solemn engagement to Christianity .

§ . 3. The Holy Sacraments among us are administred in such order prescribed as is suitable to the end of their appointment : Our Church most strictly holding to what is of Divine Institution , and adding nothing which is humane to the Sacraments themselves : nevertheless , the Prayers , and Blessings , and Exhortations , and what is enjoin'd , promote the true design of the administration : In which the Moderation of our Church holds a just mean between those who deny the Church any use of its Christian Liberty , and between the intolerable excesses of the Church of Rome : yet so very moderate is our Church in this particular , that the Lutheran Churches cannot compare themselves with her for Moderation : for they retain Exorcism and other Ceremonies in use with their Sacraments ; beside their peculiar doctrines and usages referring to the Holy Supper .

§ . 4. Our Church doth not make the efficacy of the Sacraments to depend upon the bare administration , whether the mind be well prepared or no : I dare not say that most Romanists generally mean so by the Opus Operatum in the Council of Trent g g Concil. Trid. Sess . 7. Can. 8. , but the Explanations of several come to no less .

In our Church , although the due qualification of the receiver be required , and the Authority of him who administers : yet the effect of the Sacraments is not made to rely upon the present intention h h C. Tr. Sess . 7. Can. 11. of the Minister , or his own inherent worthiness : The Sacraments being effectual by virtue of Christs Institution and promise , though they are ministred by evil men i i Article of Rel. 26. .

More particularly in reference to the Sacrament of Holy Baptism .

§ . 1. The Moderation of our Church judgeth nothing to be of the Essence of that Sacrament , but the invariable form of Baptism : Neither the sign of the Cross ( Canon 30. ) nor any words , Prayers , or usages : nor the intention of the Minister : neither is the Consecration of Water used in our Church as of necessity , but in reverence to the Sacrament .

§ . 2. Such is the Moderation of our Church , it doth not censure , nor pass any judgment on the condition of Infants who die unbaptized ; however their condition be worse : so in our Subscription for Vniversity Preachers at Cambidge , We testify that we will not enter into judgment of such as die without Baptism , when it cannot conveniently be used : for according to the good pleasure of God , his extraordinary help is often found , when the help of man doth fail : ( and the great danger justly supposed by us , is upon the contempt of Gods Ordinance , and Holy Institution : but when the failure is of unavoidable necessity , our Church charitably teacheth us to refer such to the sure mercies of God : ) k k Bishop Bramhals Discourse of Persons dying before Baptism , fol. p. 981. which makes more strongly against the Romish Limbus Infantum .

But of Infants who are baptized , and die before the Commission of actual sin , our Church doth pass a judgment of Charity for the comfort of Christian Parents , and for the due honour of the Divine Sacraments , which is this : l l Articl . 27. Rubrick after Bapt. Ch. Cat. Homily of Salv. 1 Part. Libertas Ecclesiastica , l. 1. ch. 5. It is certain by Gods word that Children which are baptized before they commit actual sin are undoubtedly saved .

§ . 3. Our Church according to great Moderation and care doth caution that dipping or immersion , be very discreetly and warily performed : and because of the Clime , our Church doth admit of pouring or sprinkling water upon the Child . ( See the Rubrick immediately before Baptism ) And although publick Baptism be expresly required where it can be had , yet in case of necessity , our Church doth moderately admit of private Baptism m m Canon . 69. 1603. , in any decent place and time n n Sedulò legibus Eccl. provisum est , ut quovis tempore & loco baptizandi infantes esset fa●ultas . Rex Jac. ad C. P. : for which there is a special Office : Requiring nevertheless , that people be admonished , that it be not done but upon great cause and necessity compelling : and that it is expedient that the Child be brought to the Church : whereas the Directory did forbid very uncharitably all private Baptisms : notwithstanding most of its followers now adays , admit only private Baptisms . Nor can I see ( saith Bishop Sparrow o o Rationale , p. 302. ) what can be reasonably objected against this tender and motherly love of the Church to her Children , who chuseth rather to omit solemnities than hazard Souls . Which indulgence of her cannot be interpreted any irreverence or contempt of that venerable Sacrament , but a yielding to a just necessity .

Yea , such is the Moderation of our Church , as she hath made sundry alterations in accommodation to the time , so she hath when occasion required , made some additions in its Offices : particularly , because of the growth of Anabaptism , through the prevailing licentiousness of the times , our Church p p V. Preface to the Liturgy , and the Office of Bapti●m , &c. hath compiled a peculiar Office for Baptizing such as are of riper years , which is also useful for the baptizing of Natives in our Plantations , and others converted to the Faith . Wherein the care of the Church is also to be noted in requiring Sponsors , whom the Office calls their chosen Witnesses , who are to call upon the persons baptized , to use all diligence to be rightly instructed , &c. So that no burden lyeth upon the Sureties , but what may be reasonably complyed with : Neither is the use of Sureties , nor their promise in the name of the persons baptized , made by our Church any necessary condition of Baptism .

§ . 4. In our Church , those who are not secular persons , are not forbid to be God-fathers ( as in the Church of Rome q q V. Rituale Ro. de Bapt. ) nor are any susceptors supposed to contract any affinity , as that such an undertaking should hinder marriage between the Sponsors and the persons baptized ( if otherwise it be lawful . )

§ . 5. Although in our first Rubricks , in Case of necessity , great liberty was allowed for baptizing , when a Minister could not be at hand : yet the said Permission , Dr Abbot in his Prelections 1598. r r V. Archbishop Whitgift , c. T. C. tract . 9. c. 3. assures us , was only in accommodation to the time ; and that the Governours of the Church did design from the first , the reformation thereof by little and little : which right administration of this Sacrament is at length vindicated to the Ministers of Gods Church : without that wondrous number of Ceremonies ( in Exorcism , Exsufflation , use of salt spittle , inunction , &c. ) in the Church of Rome required ; unless in danger of dying , and then the Church of Rome allows any Woman , or Lay Person , or Heathen , or Heretic , to baptize the Infant ( in some cases before it be born s s Si Infans ex utero caput emiserit baptiz●tur in capite . V. Rituale Ro. de Bapt. ) from all which instances may be observed the just Moderation of our Church between the extreme Sects of the Papists and the Anabaptists .

In reference to the Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist .

§ . 1. The Moderation of the Church appears , in that the same is reverently celebrated in both kinds , both according to the ancient practice of the Church for 1300. years , and according to the express command of our Lord to his Disciples , Matt. 26. 27. Drink ye all of this Cup , &c. t t 1 Cor. 10. 17. V. Vulg. Transl . although ( with a Proviso to the contrary notwithstanding u u Licèt Christus Dominus sub utrâque specie &c. Hoc non obstante . Syn. Constantiense , Can. 13. ) the Church of Rome remands the Cup from the Laity .

Now for a specimen and admirable sample of the Moderation of the Roman Church : ( At the instance of some Princes for the Concession of the Cup ) : the Council of Trent sets forth a Test , which is called the conditions on which the use of the Cup is granted x x V. Conc. Trid. Sess . 22. V. Chemn . Exam. de concess. Cal. , namely , That such as would Communicate in both kinds , do in all other matters , referring to that Sacrament , and all the other five Sacraments , ( also in every thing referring to Faith , and Doctrine , and Rites ) agree in heart and confession of mouth with all things received in the Roman Church , and all the decrees of that Council made or to be made : exhibiting all duty to the Pope as the universal Bishop of the Church , &c. Such gainful and advantageous bargains will they be sure to make for themselves , and the keeping up their usurpations , before they will allow any concession , or mitigate any extreme rigour , in their most unwarrantable practises , or they will not fail to annex such conditions as shall render their concessions ineffectual .

§ . 2. The Doctrine of Transubstantiation , which the Church of Rome receives as an Article of Faith , absolutely and simply necessary to Salvation , and propounds it to be received by all under a terrible Anathema y y Conc. Trid. Sess . 13. Can. 2. , is by our Church plainly denied , as contrary both to Holy Scriptures , and all testimonies of venerable antiquity ; and as a doctrine liable to grievous consequences z z V. Hist. Transubst . à Jo. Dunelmensi . : which judgment of our Church may appear to them that peruse our Articles ( 28 , 29. ) Order of Communion , Rubricks , Homilies ; several Statutes of the Land : particularly the late Statute , wherein is provided , that all that are in office , do declare , that they do believe , that there is not any Transubstantiation in the Sacrament of the Lords Supper , or in the Elements of Bread and Wine ; at or after the Consecration thereof by any person whatsoever : yet such is the accurate Moderation of the Church of England , in avoiding one error , it runs not into other extremes ; for in the Office of the Holy Communion , in the Church Catechism , in the Apology for the Church of England , is asserted , the real presence a a Archbishop Vsher's Serm. 18 Febr. 1620. of Christ in the Sacrament , according to Scripture , and the judgment b b Patres dehortantur à quaestione 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ▪ Hâc piâ Moderatione si Rex & Eccl. Angl. utuntur , quae invidia ? R. Jac. ad C. Per. of the Church of God : but the particular mode and manner thereof ( any otherwise than that it is spiritual , mystical , and sacramental ) the Church of England , according to the same Rule and practice of the Catholick Church , doth not too curiously pry into or search . ( See Ch. 5. §. 6. )

§ . 3. As the Church of England doth earnestly and passionately invite , and expostulates with those of her Communion to frequent the Holy Sacrament : as in the exhortations before the Holy Communion ; in the Conclusion of the Homily of the place and time of Prayer : and in Q. Eliz. Articles for Doctrine and Preaching , all Ministers are required to excite the people to often and devout receiving the Holy Communion c c V. Librum quorundam Canonum 1571. Jam vero singulis mensibus coenam celebrari maximè nobis placeret . Calvin . Ep. p. 452. ; and in Colleges and Collegiate Churches , the Holy Communion is required to be administred every Sunday , unless there be reasonable cause to the contrary d d V. Rubr. 4. after H. C. Canon . 23. V. Rubr. 8. after H. C. Canon . 21. 1003. Rubr. 8. after H. C. : and on the first or second Sunday of every month : So also the Church of England doth lay its general Command , according to great Moderation , in requiring every one thrice at least every year to Communicate e e Qui in nataii D. Paschate & Pentecosle non Communicant , Catholici non credantur . Conc. Agath . Can. 18. : well tempering her Injunction , in accommodation to the necessity of the Age , between the earnest practice of devotion which was in the Primitive Church f f Quando Domini nostri adhuc calebat cruor , & fervebat recens in credentibus fides . S. Hieron . ad Demetr. Ep. 8. ( when they commonly Communicated at least every Lords Day and Festival : ) and between the remissness of the Church of Rome g g Dolemus tantam Christianorum incuriam ut semel tantùm in anno sumant , &c. Concil. Rhem. 1583. , which expresly requires all of her Communion , to celebrate but once every Year h h In Pentecoste rarior est Communio ; & ideo fortasse Concilium Tridentinum hoc tempore nuptias solennes fieri permisit . C. Bellarm. de Matrim . Sacram. l. 1. c. 31. , and the followers of the Directory , who for many years together lamentably neglected the administration and participation of the Eucharist i i V. Coena q. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . V. S. Eccl. Angl. Vindic. c. 3. as ( beside our own memory ) Mr Prin often testifies : and the History of the Times soon after the Reformation , tell us of some who from adoring the Elements fell to contemn them , wherefore there issued out a Proclamation k k Fuller's Eccl. His . P. 387. concerning the irreverent talking of the Sacrament .

§ . 4. As our Church offers the Holy Eucharist only to those who have given due testimony of their knowledge and Christian belief , in having been confirmed by the Bishop l l V. Rubr. after Confirm . Injunctions of King Edw. 6. Canon 29. : So it requires that none be admitted Godfathers or Godmothers , at Christening or Confirmation , but such as have received the Holy Communion . Yet because S. Paul remits every particular Christian to a Self-examination , without any order , either to Minister or Lay-Elder , to exclude any from the Holy Communion , upon their Examination : therefore the Moderation of our Church is such , it doth not depress adult Christians below the order of persons first to be Catechiz'd , requiring them to such rigid Examinations as have been sometime used ( like the auricular Confessions of the Romanists : ) among which Examiners of the adult Professors , the being of a party hath been too often the note of preparation for their Church Communion : Neither doth our most moderate Church , judge any uncapable of the Sacraments , whom she judgeth not unworthy of her Communion m m Homily of the Sacrament . : We must take heed , saith the Homily , lest of the Memory it be made a Sacrifice : lest of a Communion it be made a private eating . Wherefore as the redemption of our Lord is offered to all that do not wilfully reject so great grace , so is the Holy Communion in our Church , to all that are not unfit to receive it : And such as are , the Church is not wanting to admonish and forewarn n n V. Exhorta . and Admon . before the H. C. ; and takes all due care to provide against their intrusion : ( as the general corruption of mankind now doth admit ) according to the Rubrick and Canon o o Canon 26. , concerning Notorious Offenders : On which Bishop Andrews his note was , Our Law will not suffer the Minister to judge any man a notorious offender , but him who is so convinced by some legal sentence .

§ . 5. Our Church of England doth not admit any private Masses p p Conc. Trid. Sess . 22. Can. 8. 39 Artic. 31. Hom. of Sacr. , which in the Church of Rome are multiply'd , without Communicants , out of which they suck no small advantage q q Minuatur ingens turba quotidiè missantium propter saginandum aqualiculum duntaxat . Wicelii Meth. Concord . c. 5. ; whereas our Church in great Moderation appoints the Sacraments to be freely administred , without any charge for their ministration , and also at every Celebration there is required a convenient number of Communicants r r 2d Rubr. after H. C. Rubr. before Com. for sick . Last Rubr. after H. Com. for the sick . , as in the Communion for the sick s s 2d Rubr. after the H. C. for the sick . Canon 71. 1603. , there are always to be three or two at the least ; except in case of contagion : And in case that those who sincerely desire to Communicate are lawfully hindred ; the Moderation and wisdom of our Church hath prescribed a most pious instruction for the sick person , such as may at once most exceedingly satisfy and comfort .

CHAP. XI . Of the Moderation of the Church in reference to other Rites and Usages .

§ . 1. The Moderation of the Church in its Judgment and use of Confirmation .

§ . 2. Concerning Matrimony , allowing her Clergy to marry : affording opportunity of voluntary celibacy in our Vniversities , according to a commendable moderation . Vndue degrees of Marriages , and some particular Times forbid , &c.

§ . 3. In reference to Holy Orders . 1. The Moderation of the Church in her Consecrating Ministers . 2. In taking care to have them be as they ought to be , both before and after Ordination , with good effect . 3. Yet if not so great as is desired , why the Church ought not to be accused . 4. In retaining such Orders of Ministers in the Church as are Primitive . 5. The Moderate Judgment of the Church concerning such as have been ordain'd in the Church of Rome , and elsewhere . 6. Our Church endeavours to preserve all due regard to what-ever is consecrated to God . 7. The Power of the Keys asserted in our Church with due moderation .

§ . 4. Of Penance . 1. The Moderation of our Church , between those who sleight Penance , and those who explain it extravagantly . 2. The Confession of our Church which is required , is suitable to the design of Repentance . 3. The Seal of Confession in our Church is as sacred as it ought to be . 4. The use of External Penance in our Church , according to due Moderation . 5. The use of Absolution in our Church maintained according to a just temper .

§ . 5. For Visitation of the Sick . 1. The worthy care of the Church therein , and some Instances of its Moderation referring thereunto . 2. Our Churches care for preparing those who are of her Communion for Death , without extreme Vnction in use in the Church of Rome . 3. Many Instances of the Moderation of the Church , referring to the Burial of the Dead .

§ . 1. OUr Church in its judgment and use of Confirmation , holds a just Moderation , between those who reject the use of it , and others who make it a proper * * Conc. Tri. Sess . 7. Can. 1. de Confir . Sacrament : It being received as a holy and useful Rite perpetually expedient , tho not of necessity to * * V. Instit. of a Christian Man . Salvation : With which our Church doth not join Chrism or Unction ; as in Baptism also we use not Oil , ( there being no mention of either in Scripture , or in Primitive Antiquity for such purposes ) .

Neither is the baptized Person brought Hic mos fuit ut Christianorum puert-coram Episcopo sisterentur Calvin . Inst. l. 4. c. 19 § 4. Laudo : & restitutam in purum usum velim . ib. V. Bez. in Hebr. c. 6. to Confirmation , till every such a one be of competent years of understanding , solemnly to take upon him the obligation entred into in Baptism ; which being duly performed , the Bishop doth impose his Hands on every of them , with Prayer and Blessing : Which is the order of our Church , for the honour and dignity of Episcopacy , according to primitive and ancient † † Qui in Ecclesiis baptizantur praeposito Ecclesiae offeruntur . S. Cypr. ad Jovin . practice : Altho such is the moderation of our Church , that its Presbyters are taken into some society with the Bishop generally in those Ministeries .

Neither is any in our Professio baptizatorum infantium per susceptores facta , in puberibus unà congregatis solemni ritis renovetur . Wicelii Meth. Concord . c. 4. Canon . 60. & 61. 1603. Church to be admitted to the Holy Communion until such time as they are confirmed , or be ready and desirous to be confirmed : So wisely moderate is our Church to accept of a true preparation , and sincere desire of Confirmation , when in some cases it cannot be had , either through the lamentable neglect of those who ought to * * Si in hoc E●iscoporum negligentia peccatum est hactenus , negligentia damnetur , n●n id quod per se bonum est . Wicelii Meth. Concord . c. 8. perform it , or those who should desire it be performed : It was a discipline of the Helvetians to forbid the Bannes of Marriage to such as could not give a good account of their Catechism : which soon made all who had a mind to Marriage , to be very diligent in learning their Lessons by heart : And by a Canon of a * * Conc. Bituricens. 1584. Council in France , None were to be admitted to the Eucharist or † † Nec enim alia adversus foediss . ignorantiam via restabat , nisi Maritalis tori sit is in subsidium Vocaretur . Hammondus de Confirm . c. 2. §. 11. Matrimony , but such who had been Confirmed : The same , if well lookt into , is indeed a Canon also of our ¶ ¶ A Book of certain Canons . 1571. English Church . Especially they shall warn young Folks , not only Men , but also Women , that it is provided by the Laws , That none of them may either receive the Holy Communion , or be married , or undertake for a Child in Baptism , except they before have learned the Principles of Christian Religion , and can fitly and aptly answer to all the parts of the Catechism .

Neither is this Rite among us degenerated into a practice of meer Gain and Covetousness , as Spalatensis complain'd of the Church of * * De Rep. Eccl. l. 5. c. 12. Rome : ( where Confirmation with Chrism is made such a Sacrament as they think confers a greater Grace than the true Sacrament of † † V. Chem. Exam. de Confirm . p. 69. Baptism : ) But the Moderation of the Church hath restored the Ancient Primitive Rite of Imposition of Hands , which for many hundred years hath been extruded from the Romish Confirmation by other superstitious ¶ ¶ Libertas Eccles. l. 2. c. 4. §. 3. Ceremonies .

§ . 2. The Moderation of the Church of England , in what relates to Marriage , chiefly appears in that it esteems Matrimony honourable in * * Dei Ordinationem nulla lex humana , nullum votum . potest tollere . Conf. Aug. all ; and particularly also in Priests and Ministers of the Church : and to make Vows of perpetual Virginity , our Church doth rightly judg there is no Obligation : Our 32 Article thus declares ; Bishops , Priests , and Deacons are not commanded by God's Law , either to vow the state of single Life , or to abstain from Marriage ; therefore it is lawful also for them , as for all other Christian Men to marry at their own discretion , as they shall judg the same to serve better to Godliness . To the same purpose is the Injunction of Q. Elizah . 1559. In all which our Church followeth the Judgment and Practice of the Apostles * * Christus Apostolos non Virgines eleg●t nisi unicum Joannem . Spalatens . l. 2. c. 10. who were most of them married Men , as S. Ignatius † † 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . S. Ign. Ep. ad Philad . and S. Chrysostom ¶ ¶ S. Chrys. Hom. in Tit. ( a ) 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Can. 5. Apost. V. Zoran . & Balsam . and other of the Ancients deliver : And also the Apostolical ( a ) Canons , and sundry General Councils of greatest Authority . Very many of the Roman Communion also having largely confessed the same . Tho the contrary was introduced by the worst of Popes , ( Hildebrand * * Hoc Insuave jugum nostris imponere Christus Nolu●● : i st ●d onus quod adhuc quam — plurima monstrae Fecit , ab a●daei dicunt pietate repertum . Mantuan l. 1. ) thereby to secure the worldly Interest of the Roman See , as if , for the good of the Church , Man could be wiser than God : Wherefore nothing hath been more lamentably notorious than the horrid impurities and tumults ¶ ¶ Quare ex nimis rigidà exactione , &c. gravissima scandala . Cassand . de Caelib . S ●●rd . which the different imposition hath caused in sundry places , particularly in this Realm , ( in and soon after the times of Anselm Arch-Bishop of Canterbury . )

And to make the Moderation of our Church the more confessed in this Matter ; It is manifest that what was anciently commendable in the Monastic * * S. Augustini tempore Monasteria ●rant libera Collegia : postea corruptà disciplinâ ubique addita sunt vota caeteraeque impiae . Opiniones . Conf. August . Life , may conveniently be practised , by such a voluntary and useful celibacy as may be enjoyed in either of our famous Vniversities in this Kingdom .

§ . 2. The degrees of forbidden Marriages are determin'd by the Ecclesiastical Laws of England according to an Excellent * * V. Articles of Q. Eliz. 1564 V. Libr. quoque Canonum . Can. 99. 1603. Moderation : As appears from the Table of Matthew Lord Arch-Bishop of Canterbury 1563. confirmed by sundry Statutes and Acts of Parliament , and by the 99 Canon 1603. commanded to be set up in our Churches . Wherein the forbidden degrees are interpreted according to such just Rules as are common to both Sexes equally .

2. The same effect ( for making any degrees unlawful ) is attributed to Affinity as to Consanguinity : because the Husband and Wife are one flesh , Gen. 2. 24.

Neither is any degree forbid by our Canon , but what was forbid in the 18th and 20th Chapters of Leviticus , by the Law of God : either in express terms , or ( which is all one ) by divers necessary Consequences , from Likeness , Parity , or Majority of Reason : The same was provided by that Clause of the Statute , 32. Hen. 8. cap. 38. which is chiefly insisted on by way of Exception . Viz.

That no reservation or prohibition , God's Law except , shall trouble or impeach any Marriage without the Levitical Degrees : Which plainly imports , that all Marriages within the Levitical Degrees , shall be troubled and * * V. Table of Incestuous Marriages . Printed 1677/8. impeached , tho there were no exception against them by any other Law of God .

Even within these degrees of incestuous Marriages , the Bishop of Rome takes upon him to dispense , to the great enlargement of his Authority and † † V. Reform . Leg. Eccl. de gradibus in Matri . prohib . c. 3. &c. 7. Revenue : and to make way for his Dispensations , he remits where God hath confin'd , and binds up where God hath enlarged , making such Spiritual Cognations ¶ ¶ V. Centum gravamina Germ. to the hinderance of Marriage , as have no foundation in Holy Scripture or Reason : as between the Susceptors in Baptism and Confirmation , and the Persons they answer for : Not to aggravate the severity of the Canon in the Council of * * Conc. Trid. Sess. Can. 7. Neque n. usque adeo debet integra persona crimine alieno pr●mi . Trent , toward the Innocent Person after divorce in case of † † Reform . Log. Eccl. de Adulteriis & Divortiis , c. 5. Adultery .

§ . 3. The prohibited Times of Marriage are also with much liberty declared : and the Dispensations also from the general Rule , are with great Moderation allow'd : There is also a particular Canon , whereby a Moderation of those Licenses is provided , and the Celebration of Matrimony is indulged , without the three dayes publishing of * * Can 62 , 63 , & 101. 1603. Has cautionis leges non improbamus . Altare Damasc p. 88 the Bannes .

§ . 4. Matrimony , tho it be owned a Rite , in which the Civil Societies of Men are naturally interested ; yet because it is for the supply of the Church , as well as for enlarging the Civil Polities of Men , the solemnity of Marriage is only to be performed by the Ministers of God's Church * * Ipsum conjugium benedictione sacerdotali sanctificari oporteat . S. Ambros . Ep. 70. ( among us ) both for the more venerable Solemnity , and for the blessing of the Church , as hath been the constant practice of the Church , and of * * Sponsus & sponsa cum benedicendi sunt a sacerdote offerantur in Ecclesiâ . Conc. Carthag. 4. c. 13. Christian Kingdoms : and L'estrange ( in the Alliance of Divine Offices ) highly extols the admirable Piety and Wisdom of our Church in appointing the Wife to be received from the hand of the Priest . The Minister ( saith the Rubric ) receiving the Woman at her Fathers or Friends hand , shall cause , &c. which excellent mode he thinks proper to signify how a good Wife is from the Lord . In all Reformed Churches ( saith D. Durell * * Sect. 2. §. 57. ) Matrimony is celebrated in the public Congregation , and by the Minister .

§ . 3. In reference to Holy Orders , our Church observes an excellent Moderation .

1. Our Church always maintains a separate visible Order of Men , as not only comly and convenient , but necessary for the Function of the Ministry . It is not lawful ( saith the 32 Article ) for any Man to take upon him the Office of public preaching , or ministring the Sacraments in the Congregation , before he be lawfully called and sent to execute the same , &c.

2. We must take notice of the excellent design of our Church ( which is in a high measure attained ) to have such Persons ordered and separated for that Office , who are duly qualified for their Learning , Piety , and sound Doctrine : The excellent design , and extraordinary care of the Church , appears in her wise and prudent Canons in that behalf , and the strict enquities and admonitions of the Church , of which her Ordinals most particularly give an account . After their Ordination also , Of the Exemplary behaviour of the Clergy , our Church hath taken all the care that may be : see we for instance that excellent Canon .

No Ecclesiastical Person shall at any Canon . 75. time , other than for their honest necessities , resort to any Taverns or Ale-houses , neither shall they board or lodg in any such places : Furthermore , they shall not give themselves to any base or servile labour , or to drinking or riot , spending their time idly by day or by night , playing at Dice , Cards , or Tables , or any other unlawful Game ; but at all times convenient they shall hear or read somewhat of Holy Scriptures , or shall occupy themselves with some other honest study or exercise , always doing the things which appertain to honesty , and endeavouring to profit the Church of God , having always in mind , that they ought to excel all others in purity of Life , and should be examples to the People to live well and Christianly , under pain of Ecclesiastical Censures to be inflicted with Quomodo inquiritur in excessus & defectus Ministrorum Verbi . V. de Polit. Eccl. Anglic. c. 6. p. 322. severity , according to the quality of their Offences , whether it be to suspension , deprivation , deposition , or other greater censures , as is the demerit . To the same purpose have been sundry Articles , and Injunctions , and Laws of the Land , and Rules of the Church * * V. Librum 9. Canonum : V. Articulos pro clero . Canon . 33 , 34 , 35. 1603. 39 Article 26. very express . At the Ordination of Ministers , 't is asked them , Whether they will be diligent to frame and fashion themselves and their Families according to the Doctrine of Christ , and to make both themselves and them , as much as in them lieth , wholsom Examples and Spectacles to the Flock of Christ . Lastly ; All Promotions of the Church are distributed so equally , that any Son of a Layman in the Kingdom otherwise fitted , is capable of the highest Eminence in the Church . In her Canons , restraint is made of Plurality of Benefices , ( Canon V. Articulos proclero . 41. ) with indulgence only in cases extraordinary ; requiring * also convenient V. Bishop Sparrows Collections . residence and hospitality , and every one's discharge of their Functions . In case of lawful absence , that a just and conscientious supply be provided : Always letting the People see , that they do not seek their own Profit , Promotion , or Advantage , more than the profit of the V. K. Ed. 6. Injunction . Souls they have under their Cure , or the Glory of God .

Of the Effects of these Orders , if any enquire : Beside the judgments of other Churches , ( that the Clergy may not be the only Judges in this case ) such may consider what the great Verulam hath witnessed ; That scarce any Church since the Primitive Times , hath yielded in like manner of years , a greater number of famous Writers , excellent Preachers , grave Governours , and the most and chiefest of them of holy and good Life . And the famous University of Oxford , in answer to the Petition of the N. C. 1603. replied :

To stop the Mouths of those that traduce us for a dumb Idol-Ministry , There are at this day more Learne● Men in this Kingdom , than are to be found in all Europe : Which must not be imputed for Vanity , since the Apostle , when his Ministry was reproached , defended his godly boasting . Which premised , Bishop Hall may be allowed to speak for the Clergy of the Church of England ; What Christian Church under Heaven ( saith he ) in so short a time , yielded so many glorious Lights of the Gospel , so many able and prevalent Adversaries of Schism and Antichristianism ; so many eminent Authors of learned Works , which shall out-bid time it self ? Let Envy grind her teeth , and eat her heart ; The memory of these worthy Prelates shall ever be sweet and blessed .

3. If all this care of the Church hath not its absolute and entire effect , ( which when it hath not , is much lamented ) according to the sincere desire and intent of the Church : As also Nec hac Culpae est Christiani nominis , si simulator religionis in vitio sit . S. Hier. Ep. 4. that the Laws of Christ have not that effect upon all Christians as they ought . Our Church in the mean while must be acquitted , while according to the condition of the things , she hath used her best care and endeavour ; and if the practices of Men always cannot , her Laws must bear her out * * Delictum personae in detrimentum Ecclesia non debet redundare . Reg Ju. . Wherefore very reasonable was the Injunction of Queen Elizabeth , That for defaults which people find in Ecclesiastical Persons , They are not to detain their Dues , §. 15. 1559 to requite one wrong with another , but to call for reformation thereof at their Ordinaries and other Superiors ; who upon complaint , and due proof thereof , shall reform the same accordingly . Now of thousands who are apt to complain of the Clergy , how few take the right course to rectify any thing ? If any are vitious among us , we protest against their practices , and are Advocates for none in what is evil ; but leave them to answer for themselves before proper Judges .

Being sure it would be a happy World , if right Principles in the understanding , and a conformable practice could always go together : but it is an ordinary practice , whose Doctrine they cannot confute , their Life endeavour to bring into hatred * * Cum Viderint Doctrinam nostram non posse rectè accusari , malu●run● in mores nostros in vehere . Apol. Eccl. Angl. § 53. .

It may be added , According to an excellent Moderation are also the Ages appointed of them who are to enter into holy Orders † † V. Preface to the Ordinal . Canon 33. Artic. proclero . .

§ . 3. Our Church maintains and preserves those Orders of Ministers in the Church , ( Bishops , Priests , Deacons ) 39. Articl. 36. which are truly Primitive : without the additional Train which the Church of Rome makes necessary , ( even seven kind of Orders suitable to their number of Sacraments ) and with much the like necessity , that the followers of the Geneva Government appoint their Lay-Elders .

The power of Orders consisteth partly in preaching the Word , and other Offices of Public Worship , common to Bishops , with other Ministers ; partly in ordaining Priests and Deacons , admitting them to particular Cures , and other things of that nature proper to them alone . The Power of Jurisdiction is either internal , in retaining and remitting sins ( in the Hoc malè habet quosdam immoderatiores , reddi jurisdectionem , restitui politiam Ecclesiasticam . Ph. Melanct. ad Camera . Court of Conscience ) common to them also , ( for the substance of the Authority , tho with some difference in the Degree ) with other * * Of Episcopacy and Regal Power . Bishop Sanderson , p. 33 , 34. Ministers . Or External , for the outward Government of the Church in some parts thereof peculiar to them alone . The Government of the Church ( according to these Orders ) in its own Constitution , hath an excellent temper , between an Ecclesiastical Monarchy ( which the Church of Rome asserts , in making it self the Mother and Mistress of other Churches , and its Bishop Supreme Monarch over all the Bishops and Churches : ) and between such Democracy and Populacy as is held in the Independent and Presbyterian parity . * * Reti●emu● ex singulis regiminibus exquisitam temperaturam . J. A. Comenius Moravus de ord. Eccl. apud Bohemos .

In our Government by Bishops succeeding the Apostles ( which also was Aristocratical , they having all a fulness of Order and Power among themselves ) ¶ ¶ Omnes Episcopi ejusdem meriti , ejusdem sacerdotii . S. Hier. ad Evagr. a succession of Pastours our Church doth not refuse , because derived for a time in the same Chanel with the Roman Bishops : After the same manner ( saith Bishop Jewel ) we are chosen , invested , confirmed , admitted : if they were deceived in any thing , we succeeded in their Place , not in their Error .

Of the real Moderation of our Episcopacy , Mounsieur Amyrald may speak for us , because of many he may more readily be heard : The Bishops of the Amyraldi Irenic . p. 196. Church of England , because they neither acknowledg the Authority of the Roman Pontif , nor do they assume to themselves any right or power over the Consciences of Men , nor over the Truth of Christ , and in all other things they most earnestly maintain the same Doctrine with us against the Errors of the Papists , Cavendum ne Scyllae fugâ , in Carybdi incidamus : Neve rigor nimius & Vatinianum in Episcopos odium , eò imprudentes adigat ut veters Ecclesiae dicam scribanius . Sam. Bochart . Ep. 8. ad Episc . Winton . Anabaptists , Socinians , and others ; We think therefore in somethings they are to be born with , if there be any thing in that Order which doth not altogether suit to our Humour .

§ . 4. As our Church doth not approve of the Roman Tonsures , Rasures , Vnctions in the imitation of the Jews ; so she hath cast out of its form of Ordination , all those superstitious Rites used in the Church of Rome . Neither hath any of her Consecrations * * Instit. of a Chri. Man . 1537. , any thing that is of it self Superstitious , or Vngodly ¶ ¶ 39. Articles . 36. .

Yet so moderate is our Church toward the Church of Rome , That , 1. It allows it to have not only the Essentials of a true Church , but of Ordination also .

2. Although it hath only the Ancient and Apostolical Rites of Imposition of Hands and Prayer ; and accepts of the form of Ordination used by our Lord as most suitable , and best : Nevertheless it doth not hold all those Ordinations void , which have been made in some other form of Words .

3. It imitates the Moderation of the whole Catholic Church , in being against the Rebaptizing of any , who have had the Essentials of Baptism : And also against the Re-ordination of those who keep the Essentials of Ordination ; and of such Churches where Bishops cannot be had , we use all Moderation of Judgment * * Bishop Bramhal's Vindicat. p. 29 , 31. . Yet where our Constitution requires Ordination by Bishops , it is at liberty not to make use of their Ministry , who peremptorily refuse the Ordination of our Bishops : ¶ ¶ Non opus est Re●pub . Eocive qui parere nescit . M. Curius . Valer. Max. l. 6. c. 3. Neque Ecclesia opus est iis qui spretis Episcopis suis , &c. V. Vindic. S. Eccl. Angl. c. 6. Or who would in a settled Church and Kingdom , set up a Church Government in opposition to the Bishops who ordained them before .

§ . 5. Our Church doth endeavour to preserve to its Bishops , Priests , and Deacons , all due Honour and regard sutable to their several Ministries and Orders : Having the right of a Revenue , which is for the most part a convenient provision for its Clergy , above some others of the Reformation : Yet , not only below the Pompousness of the Roman Church , but much inferiour in proportion to the Provision God made the Priests and Levites among the Jews : As our Church observes an excellent Moderation in reference to things peculiarly devoted unto God , equally abhorring Idols and Sacrilege : And whatsoever is sanctified to the peculiar Service of God , our Church Orders should be used in a sutable manner : So in reference to Persons consecrated to the holy Service of God , a worthy care is taken by the very constitution of our Government in Kingdom * * 1 R. Eliz. c. 2. ¶ ¶ 8 R. Eliz. c. 1. and Church , to secure their Office and Persons from such contempt as might render their Religious Performances more useless and unprofitable to the Church , and might discourage the worthy industry of those , who should devote themselves entirely to a Function so honourable in it self . King Edward the 6th , and Queen Elizabeth , enjoyn'd , that Whereas many indiscreet Q Eliz. Injunction §. 28. Persons do at this Day uncharitably contemn and abuse Priest and Ministers of the Church , yet for as much as their Office and Function is appointed of God : The King's Majesty willeth and chargeth all his loving Subjects , that they use them charitably and reverently for their Office and Administration sake , especially such as labour in setting forth God's holy Word . And for the more remarkableness of the Moderation of our entire Constitution , may be considered what Dr. Heylin makes out at large in his Treatise for undeceiving the People in point of Tithes , 1657. Never was any Clergy maintained with less Charge to the Subject , than the established Clergy of the Church of England : No Man paying any thing of his own toward the Maintenance of his Parish-Minister , but his Easter-Offering .

§ . 6. Because our Church asserts to its Ministry all just Effect . ( See Art. 33. ) It makes the power of the Keys not only Declarative and Doctrinal , but Authoritative , ( of which more in the next Section of this Chapter ) .

Yet our Churchmen do not boast , as some of the Church of Rome do often , of a Power Ascendant over the awful Presence of God , and the glorified Body of Christ in Heaven , as if they made him corporally and immediately present in the Eucharist upon their secret pronouncing of Hoc est enim Corpus meum * * V. Missale Rom. .

Neither doth our Church of England ascribe to the power of Priests , the bringing Spirits out of Purgatory in their Suffrages for the Dead .

Nor doth our Church hold any true Propitiatory Sacrifice for Dead , or Living , to be offered up in the Mass ; because that would derogate from the sufficiency of Christ's Priesthood : Neither De Sacram . ord. can . 1. doth it define its Priesthood by the action only of such a Sacrifice , as doth the Council of Trent .

§ . 4. Our Church behaves it most moderately between the two extremes of those who slight all due Penance , and of those who explain it differently from the true nature of it .

The Council of Trent declares it of necessity by Divine Right for every one of both Sexes , once a Year to confess to a Priest ( as his Judge next to God ) all and singular their Mortal Sins which they can possibly recollect , even the most secret with all their Circumstances , or else they had as good do nothing ( as the Council saith * * Qui verò secus saciunt nihil Divinae bon●tati p●r Sacerdo●em remittendum propo●unt . Conc. Trid. de Confes . c. 5. ) which Confession with Contrition and Satisfaction , are ( with them ) the matter of Penance ; and the form is the word of Absolution from the Priest , which make up their entire Sacrament : Whereas our Anxietate Circumstantiarum & tortur● conscientiarum sublata — Wicel . Method . Concord . c. 6. Church doth suppose the nature of true Penitence doth consist in true change Quam conscientiae carnisicinam nemo moderatus approbat . Cassander ad Artic. 11. 28 H. 8. of Mind , and effectual amendment of Life , which when it is sincere , there will be so much of the rest as In confessione sacerdotali catholici quoque Moderationem aliquam postulant . Wicelius , in viâ Regia . p. 360. is useful . In the Convocation , 1536 , at the first dawning of the Reformation , it was determined , That perfect Penance which Christ required , consisteth of three parts , Contrition , Confession , and Amendment of former Life , and a new obedient Reconciliation to the Laws and Will of God : The same is earnestly enforced in our Homilies .

Bishop Bramhal very compendiously enumerated the Romanists abuses of Confession , In tricking it up in the Robes of a Sacrament ; by obtruding a particular and plenary enumeration of all Sins to Man , as absolutely necessary to Salvation , by Divine Institution ; by making it ( with their Commutations ) a remedy rather for the Confessor's Purse than the Confitent's Soul : As Chaucer observed , He knew how to impose an easie Penance , where he could look for a good Pittance ; by making it a Picklock to know the secrets of States and Families : By absolving , before they enjoyn Ecclesiastical satisfaction ; by reducing it to a customary Formality , as it were but the Pag. 975. fol. concluding an old Score to begin a new .

§ . 2. Our Church doth declare the necessity of such a Confession as is useful to the purposes of true Repentance : That is , when Confession to the Minister of God may be useful for Spiritual Advice , and for the quieting of any ones Conscience in order to a good Life , or happy Death : And particularly in order to the fruitful receiving the holy Communion * * V. Exhortation to the H. C. . In K. Edward 6. time , in the order of the Communion , the Exhortation was thus : And if there be any of you whose Conscience is troubled and grieved at any time , lacking Comfort and Counsel , let him come unto me , or to some other discreet and learned Priest taught in the Law of God , and confess his open Sin and Grief secretly , that he may receive such Ghostly Counsel , that his Conscience may be relieved † † Liberum 〈◊〉 administrum habeat & ab illo levationem aegritudinis accipiat . Reform . leg . E●cl . de div . Off. c. 7. , and that of us as a Minister of God and of his Church , he may receive Comfort and Absolution to the satisfaction of his Mind , and avoiding all scruple and doubtfulness : Requiring such as shall be satisfi'd with a general Confession , not to be offended with them that do use , to their further satisfying , the auricular and secret Confession to the Priest ; nor those also which think needful or convenient for the quietness of their own Consciences , particularly to open their sins unto God , and the general Confession to the Church : But in all these things to follow and keep the Rule of Charity , and every Man to be satisfi'd with his own Conscience , not judging other Mens Minds or Acts , whereas he hath no warrant of God's Word for the same . So much the Spirit of Moderation did move in our Church , from the first of the Reformation , and was perfected in what after was ordered * * Absit repetendi Confessionem superstitio , absit anxietas enumerandi commissa & circumstantias . Erasm . de amab . Eccl. Concord . Homily of . Rep. 2. part . . If any Men do find themselves troubled ( saith the Homily ) they may repair to some godly learned Man , &c. But it is against true Liberty , that any Man should be bound to the numbring of his Sins , as has been used heretofore in the time of Ignorance .

In the mean while , how slanderously are we reported by the Romanists , in the Recantation some of them made for Anton. de Dom. §. 25. thus speaking of the Men of the Church of England ? Amongst them scant ever saw I any Reformation : For the most part , all care of Conscience is cast away : They are not ( except some few ) troubled with any scruples for Adulteries , Robberies , or Deceiving their Neighbours : For they have wickedly abolisht Auricular Confession .

Indeed such Auricular Confession as is in practice in the Roman Church † † Scire volunt secreta domus atque inde timeri . , the Church of England hath utterly rejected , it being devised to pry into the secrets of Governments , and such private Circumstances of Actions , which to unvail is neither the Interest of private Persons nor of Priests . It is more plain ( * * Homily of Rep. 2. p. saith our Homily ) that this Auricular Confession , hath not its warrant of God's Word , else it had not been lawful for Nectarius Bishop of Constantinople ¶ ¶ Sozomen Eccl. Hist . l. 7. c. 16. upon just occasion to have put it down . Yet the same Homily earnestly commends to us , Confession of our Sins before God , and one to another for reconciliation of Offences , and to the Minister of God , for his Ghostly Counsel and Absolution , and publickly in case of publick Scandal .

§ . 3. Whereunto may be added for the Honour of our Church's Moderation , that it observes the Seal of Confession , as sacredly as Reason or Religion can possibly permit , yet forbids not the disclosure in case of Murder or Treason , but in those particulars , leaves us entire in our Obedience to the Common Laws of the Kingdom : Of which , see we what our Church delivers in its 113. Canon . If any Man confess his secret and hidden Sins to the Minister for the unburthening of his Conscience , and to receive Spiritual Consolation , and ease of Mind from him : We do straightly charge and admonish the said Minister , that he do not at any time reveal and make known to any Person whatsoever any Crime or Offence so committed to his trust and secrecy * * Cujus rigidam necessitatem qud apud vos obtinet Eccl. Aug. molliendam putavit : Rem ipsam neque sustulit , &c. IS . Casaub . ad Frontod . p. 129. , ( except they be such Crimes , as by the Law of this Realm , his own Life may be called in question ) under pain of Irregularity . For as H. Garnet ( whom the Romanists will have a Martyr for their Sacrament of Confession ) confessed himself , It is not fitting that the Lives of Princes should depend upon the private Nicety of any Man's Conscience * * V. Proceedings against the Traytors . .

And yet Suarius ¶ ¶ Suarius de poen . disp . 33. §. 1. determins , That in no case , for no end , though it was to save a whole Commonwealth from a great Evil , Temporal or Spiritual , may it be lawful to violate Confession . Ja. Binet † † I S. Casaub . ad Frontod . p. 140. went higher , It was better all Kings should perish , than even once the Seal of Confession should be violated .

The Catholic Apologist goes higher yet , Pag. 426. The Sacrament of Confession is of such Reverence among us , that we cannot lawfully disclose a secret known by it , tho it were to save Christianity it self . Nay , the Apologie for Garnet * * Eud. Jo. Apol. pro Garnetto p. 327. , hath a notable fetch to bring in all the Gun-powder Conspirators as Martyrs , for saith he , It is the common opinion of Catholicks , That all who receive the Matter from the Confessor ( by the consent of the Penitent ) are bound by Religion of Secrecy . But what abuse of Confession is this , to hold those Martyrs , who confessed a Wickedness they were resolved to commit : And their Priests absolved them from a Treason , they were then sworn to undertake .

§ . 4. The Discipline of our Church doth by no means exclude the use of External Penance : And in its judgment is more right than the Church of Rome . To inforce both inward and outward Penance , our Church hath a special Office of Commination upon solemn occasion to be used . And for some scandalous Sins ( when Notorious ) solemn Penance is by a special Canon required , for the Humiliation and Compunction of the Sinner , for the Example of others , and for the Edification of the Church * * V. Artic. proclero . : The Commutation of which ( for very good Reasons requiring ) the Church hath taken care sometime to moderate : But the Commutations allowed by our Commutationem a. injunctae poenitentiae nec Cancellarius faciet nec Archidiac . nec Officialis , nec Commissarius . Ea potestas multis gravibus de causis Episcopo soli reservabitur . V. Libr. qu. Canonum . 1571. Church are sincerely designed for the ends of Charity and Religion , and the consideration of Piety , but are not taxed in a penitentiary Table , as it were to invite Men to sin . The De Polit. Eccl. Angl. c. 6. p. 328. godly Discipline of the Primitive Church of open Penance for the Conviction of V. Office of Commination . Notorious Offenders , the Church of England wisheth may be restored again : But , The satisfaction that God requires of us ( saith the Homily of Repentance ) is that we cease from evil , and do good ; and if we have done any Man wrong , to endeavour our selves to make him true amends to the uttermost of our power , following in this the example of Zacheus , &c.

Nevertheless the Penances in the Church of Rome , which there are called Satisfactions , and are counted Deletory of Sin , and Meritorious of Pardon , our Church doth account no otherwise than Superstitious .

§ . 5. The Absolution of the Priest hath its due honour and use in our Church , altho it be made no part of any Sacrament of Penance . And that the Moderation of our Church may be more perceived , observe , 1. That our Church ascribeth not the power of Remission of Sin to any but to God only .

2. It constantly holds , That Faith and true Repentance , are the necessary conditions of receiving the benefit of Remission of Sin .

3. It asserts what is most true , that the Ministers of the Church have a special Power and Commission , which other Believers have not , authoritatively to declare this Absolution and Remission of Sin , for the benefit and consolation of true Penitency , which if duly dispensed , cannot but have a real effect from the very promise of Christ . ( S. Jo. 20. 23. ) Vid. S. Chrys. Hom. 5. in Esaiam .

4. This Penitence our Church makes not a new Sacrament ( as doth the Church of Rome ) but a means of returning to the Grace of God bestowed in Baptism : They which in act or deed sin after Baptism ( saith our Homily ) when they turn to God unfeignedly , they are likewise washed by this Sacrifice from their Sins . Poenitentia nihil aliud est quam reditus ad promissionem gratiae Baptismi . Chemn . exam. de paenit . p. 199.

The rare temper and proportion , which the Church of England useth in Commensurating the Forms of Absolution to the degrees of Preparation and Necessity , is to be observed , That at the beginning of Morning and Evening Prayer after a general Confession , the Form of Absolution is in general Declarative , and by way of Proposition : In the Office of Communion , it is by way of Intercession . In the Visitation of the Sick , when it is supposed and enjoyned that the Penitent shall disburthen himself of the clamorous loads on his Conscience , the Church prescribes a Medicinal Form by way of delegate Authority : Therefore saith the Bishop of Down , It is the excellent Temper of the Church , so to prescribe her Forms of Absolution , as to shew them to be the results of the whole Priestly Office . All which Forms V. Bishop Sparrow's Rationale . p. 23. in Sence and Vertue are the same .

5. For Visitation of the Sick , such is the care of our Church that by its Canon , When any Person is dangerously Sick Can. 67. 1603. in any Parish , the Minister or Curate ( having knowledg thereof ) shall resort unto him or her ( if the Disease be not known , or probably suspected to be Infectious ) to instruct and comfort them in their Distress , according to the Order of the Common-Prayer-Book ( if he be no Preacher ) ; or if he be a Preacher , then as he shall think most needful and convenient . And so in the Rubric it is said , The Minister may use that , or the like Exhortation . From both which passages ( altho we are not greedy of Liberty ) yet for good Reasons and the occasional Necessity of accommodating our addresses in that kind to the particular cases of Persons , we observe the Moderation of our Church , in complying accurately with all the Necessities of her People . And further we note from that Canon ,

That altho in Prudence , and Kindness , and Christian Duty , the Minister may and ought in many cases to go of his own accord to visit his Charge especially ; yet we cannot say that the Church doth bind always her Minister thereunto , till he be certified : According to the words of St. James ( Chap. 5 ver. 14. ) Is any sick among you ? let him call for the Elders of the Church , &c. Yet because in a matter of such concern the Church would not have its Ministers use such a Capricio , as to stand upon their Niceties in so serious and momentous a Matter , nor the People so forgetful of their own Interest as to neglect their part therein , therefore ( so punctual is our Church , and moderate according to Reason ) the Canon only saith , The Minister having knowledg thereof , shall resort , &c.

Excellent was the Injunction of King Edward the 6th , 1547. and Q. Elizabeth , §. 17. 1559. That the damnable vice of Despair may clearly be taken away , and firm belief and stedfast hope surely conceived of all their Parishioners being in any danger , the Parsons , Vicars , and Curats , shall learn , and have in readiness , such comfortable places and sentences of Scripture , as do set forth the Mercy and Goodness of Almighty God toward all penitent and believing Persons , that they may at all times ( when necessity requires ) promptly comfort their Flock with the lively Word of God , which is the only stay of Man's Conscience . Wherefore certainly it ought to be the special study of every Minister of God to provide himself , that he may be ready and dexterous to assist such as desire a Spiritual Guide and Counsellor at so needful a time .

§ . 2. The Order of the Church for the Visitation of the Sick , and preparing those of her Communion for Death , is the same with that of the Church ever since the Primitive Times , which was Prayer and Absolution , and the Holy Viaticum of the Body and Blood of Christ , which we retain : And I pray C. 8. §. 5. ( saith Spalatensis ) what proper and peculiar effect can Extreme Vnction have on any faithful Man for the occasion of passing from this Mortal Life to a glorious Immortality , which may not be entirely obtained by Faith and Repentance , and the Holy Eucharist , and Alms , and Prayer , especially the public Prayer and Absolution of the Church ? These and no other the Ancient Fathers and Councils mention , as having the common and abiding Promise of God , which extreme Unction hath not ; and as it was used in and about the time that S. James speaks of Anointing the Sick with Oyl in the Name of the Lord , was a miraculous Gift of healing , the Effect of which was their recovery , as it follows ; and the Lord shall raise him up . Different from which also is the practice of the Church of Rome , never or rarely aneling any with exorces'd Oyl on the five Organs of their Senses , till they are past all hopes of recovery .

From which practice the People of this Nation was brought off by degrees : For in the first Book of King Edward the 6th , the Rubric was thus ; If the sick Person desire to be Anointed , then shall the Priest anoint them on the Fore-head or Brest , only making the sign of the Cross , saying , As with this visible Oyl thy Body outwardly is Anointed , so God grant that thy Soul , &c. * * V. Alliance of D. Offices ▪ p. 182.

Unto which Ceremonies of Crism in Baptism and Extreme Vnction ( as it was then here in Use ) those repeated words of Calvin may appear particularly to refer , and not generally to other Constitutions among us : In the English Liturgy ( saith he ) I see there hath been many tollerable trifles † † In Anglic. Liturgiâ qualem describitis multas video fuisse tolerabiles in eptias-his duobus verbis experimo non fuisse eam puritatem , &c. Ep. 200. Anglis Francofur . : Which two words , as conscious that they were very brigose and severe ( if too generally taken , therefore ) he softens them in the next immediate words by an Apology ; By which ( saith he ) I mean , there hath not been that Purity which might be wished . What he particularly meant , I suppose is exprest in another Epistle to the English Protector : There are other things ( saith he ¶ ¶ Sunt & alia non proinde damnanda fortasse , sed tamen ejusmodi ut excusari non possunt , viz. Crisma & Vnctionis Ceremonia . Prot. Angl. Ep. 8● . ) perhaps not presently to be condemned , but yet of that sort . as cannot be excused , viz Crism in Baptism , and the Ceremony of Unction : Which only if he referr'd to , How often have his severer Followers been mistaken ?

§ . 3. In reference to the Burial of the Dead , the Moderation of the Church is such , it concerns it self but as far as Christian Religion doth .

* * Can. 48. 1603. De Donatistis qui Catholicorum corpora sepel●ri verabant . V. Optat. Mile● . l. 6. 1. Confirming all Natural and Civil Law herein : Providing that Christian Scpulture be Decent , Honourable , and Religious , as Quibus constat quod semel in anno non susce●erint Sacramenta confessionis Eccles. Scpultura negatur . Rit . Rom. de Exeq. becomes a Church in which the Resurrection of the Body is asserted : Our Church well remembring that the Christian Religion did obtain by no means more than by the care the Primitive Christians had of the Burial of their Dead .

Wherefore Julian ¶ ¶ 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Juliani Imp. ad Arsaicum Pontif. Ep. 49. , who was a great Bigot to Gentilism , in an Epistle to his Gentile High Priest , recommends the practice of the same things amongst them , by which the Christian Religion got so much ground : Which was by the gravity of the Christians Deportment , by their kindness to Strangers , and by their care of Burial . And tho indeed the Ecclesiastical Solemnity by the use of the Liturgy is forbid at the Burial of such as die Unbaptized † † V. Rubric . , or Excommunicated , or have laid violent Hands on themselves , the same is but in pursuance of the chief design of the Burial Office , viz. The benefit of the Living * * Vt hoc pacto à peccato retrahantur . Grot. de jure b. c. 19. , that all may avoid whatsoever may deprive them of such an honourable sign of being esteemed to have died in Communion with the Church .

In our Church Christian Burial is not such a dumb shew , as is the practice of a shameful company of People in this Realm , who have Excommunicated themselves while they live , and therefore it is the less matter tho they keep by themselves when they are Dead . In our Burial Office , Christian People may be at once Comforted and Admonished . And because the whole Church , Militant and Triumphant , is united in one Society , under one Supreme Head ; Because also at Death the happiness of the best is but incomplete : Therefore in our Church , we beseech God of his great Goodness shortly to accomplish the number of his Elect , and to hasten his Kingdom , that we with all those , &c. may have our perfect Consummation and Bliss , &c. Here the Moderation of our Church stops , and leaves the Romanists in their extremes . Altho the Bodies of the Dead are often laid up in our Churches according to the Custom of the Country , it is without any Superstition required , or allowed : The Bodies and Coffins of the Dead are not sprinkled with Holy Water * * Parochus antequam Calaver efferatur illud aspergit aq ● benedictâ . Rit . Ro. de exeq . ( as if it was to keep the evil Spirits from interrupting the Worms ) . We attribute no effect to the Garments we are buried in , which those Friars do , who persuade People to die and be buried in their Habits , for the redemption of their Souls out of Purgatory . There are not among us any Masses for the Dead , Vigils , Trentals , adoring the Bones of Saints , worshipping their Reliques : Which ( with the like ) the Articles of K. Edward 6. call Blind Devotion : There is not consecrating and reconciling Church-Yards with so many Ceremonies and opinion of Efficacy and Necessity ( as in the Church of Rome . ¶ ¶ V Form of Consecration of Churches . Bishop Sparr . Collect. 1675. )

The Bells which sound at Funerals among us , are not appointed for any Superstition † † Centum gravam. 50. , or to drive away Spirits from the Grave : And because by Death all are made equal , therefore all have the same Office for Burial , All amongst us are deposited in the same general place of the Earth * * Redditur Terrae Corpus & ita locatum quasi operimento Matris obdusitur . Cic. de leg . l. 2. : In other Circumstances Respect and Distinction is permitted , according to the Custom of the Country , and the condition of the Person deceased .

The Moderation of our Church is the same with that of the Christian Religion , as it also leaves all Nations to their proper Usages , and doth not oppose any Civil Laws , or indifferent Customs of this , or of any other Kingdom .

As it is observable , That God himself ( tho he forbid the People of Israel ¶ ¶ Lev. 19. 28. Deut. 14. 1. to cut themselves , or make any baldness upon themselves for the Dead , or printing any Marks upon themselves , which were the practices of that Idolatrous Nation : Yet ) in such ancient Customes they had those which were Innocent , referring to the manner of their Burial , were permitted the same , notwithstanding they had them from the Egyptians and other Heathen Nations : Whereunto even also the Burial of our Blessed Lord Jesus was Conformable , of which it is Recorded , † † John 19 4● . They took the Body of Jesus and wound it in Linnen with the Spices , as the manner of the Jews is to Bury : Among whom ( as hath been noted * * Bishop ●earson on the Creed , notes on Expos. Art. 4. ) there was a kind of Law , that they should use no other Grave-clothes . Notwithstanding it is all one ¶ ¶ — Tabésne Cadavera solvat , Aut rogus aut refert . — Capit omnia tellus Quae genuit , coelo tegitur qui non habit urnam . to our Bodies , whether they are deposited in Linnen or in Woollen , with Spices , or without , in the Earth , or in any other Element ; whether we lie in S. Innocent's Church-yard , where the Bodies soon consume , or in the Sands of Egypt , where they last longer , or under the Moles of Adrianus . And if the Minds of some seem uneasie in relation to one way of Burial more than another , it convinceth us how great Tyrants Custom and Imagination are ; and perhaps in no Instance can it be confirmed more , than in the late alteration referring to Burial : Concerning which , St. Austin's Comment might be of use : † † S. Aug. de Doct. Chr. l. 3. V. de civita . Dei . l. 1. c. 13. The Evangelist ( saith he ) doth seem to me not in vain to have said , [ As the manner of the Jews is to Bury ] for so ( unless I am deceived ) he admonisheth in such offices of Piety which are exhibited to the Dead , The Custom of every Nation is to be observed .

Wherefore our Church of England always leaves the Government of the Kingdom to have its Reasons to it self in what it appoints : Instructing her Sons also how little soever the Matters are , from thence to receive the greater honour of Obedience .

And because at so solemn a Providence as is the death of our Friends , if some well-disposed Persons finding their Minds then more lifted up to the desires of Heaven , and become more mortified to the World , would take an opportunity of seriously commemorating the Death of our Lord , who by Death overcame Death , and opened the Gate of Heaven unto all Believers .

Therefore there is a brief peculiar appointment for the Celebration of the Holy Supper of the Lord at Funerals * * Peculiaria quaedam in funeribus , &c. R. Eliz. V. Bishop Sparows Collections . appointed 1560 , with a Collect , Epistle and Gospel , which bears a part of the Reformed Liturgy , which here is taken notice of , as a proof how refined every part thereof is from Romish Superstition .

The like Instance of Inoffensive Moderation , may be the public Office appointed by Q. Elizabeth , for the Commemoration of Benefactors , which is used in our Colleges and Vniversities , which doth testify what worthy care we have of the memory of the deserving , tho deceased ; and also doth shew how much purged these honourable Offices are from Superstition .

CHAP. XII . Of the Moderation of our Church , in what concerns the Power of the Church .

§ . 1. The Moderation of our Church , owns the Power of the Church to be only Spiritual . § . 2. All other Power which Ecclesiastical Persons receive , is readily acknowledged entirely depending on the favour of our Kings . § . 3. The Interests of the Kingdom and the Church , are excellently accommodated in our Constitutions , which is not done in other Models . § . 4. The pious Moderation of our King 's preserving their own rightful Supremacy , and leaving to the Church the exercise of their Spiritual Power , acknowledged by our Church . § . 5. The just Right of Kings shamefully invaded by other Sects pretending Divine Right : Concerning which Claim , the Moderation of our Church observed . § . 6. The dutiful Moderation of our Church in asserting Monarchy : The first Canon , 1640. justified . § . 7. All Interests of Humane Society , especially of Subjects Allegiance in our Church abundantly secured , which is not done by those in separation from her . § . 8. The Ordinances of our Church , are framed with great Mildness and Moderation . § . 9. The same compared with the mild Obligation which Cardinal Bellarmine pretends the Church of Rome lays upon those of her Communion . § . 10. Sundry Instances of our Church's great regard to Equity ,

§ . 1. THe Church of England always hath confessed , That the Power of the Church is only Spiritual , and Ministerial ( for the Head , the Authority , the Conversation of the Church is in Heaven ) : Hence it is that the Appointments of the Church are not called Laws , but Canons , or Rules ; by which the Moderation of the Church rather leads than compels : Yea , In matter of Canons , the Bishops and Clergy do but propound such Constitutions as they think useful , and when they have done , send them to his Majesty , who perusing and approving them , puts Life into them , and of dead Propositions makes them Canons ; so are they the King's Canons , not the Clergies * * Bishop Hall's Remains . p. 430. . And the Inflictions Ecclesiastical , the Church her self doth not call Punishments but Censures ; for Temporal Punishments are for Vengeance , Spiritual for Discipline ¶ ¶ Bishop Lany , on 1 Thess. 4. 11. : The Temporal Judg ( except he be Supreme ) in many things cannot pardon , the Ecclesiastical Judg cannot but pardon upon Repentance ; as our Church doth express it self in the Canons , if the Offender revoke that his wicked Error . To this purpose St. Chrysostom † † St. Chrys. Homil. 4. in Isaiam . speaks , The King remits the guilt of Bodies , the Bishop remits the guilt of Sins ; the Prince compels , the Bishop exhorts ; he governs by Necessity , but we by Counsel . So it is in the Injunction of King Edward the 6th , 1547. unto those who have the Cure of Souls : They ever gently and charitably Exhorting , — and in his Majesties Name strictly charging and Commanding , &c. So in the 3 d. Canon , 1640. the sacred Synod earnestly intreats and exhorts the Reverend Judges , &c.

§ . 2. As our Church doth lawfully assert her own Spiritual Power entire and inherent in the Church , so she hath always exercised her power in all Subordination to the Right of Princes * * V. Institution of a Christian Man . p. 49. V. Homily of Obedience . : And constantly acknowledging , that whatsoever Power beside Spiritual , the Church or its Church-Men have , she receives the same entirely from the favour of our Kings , wherefore our Bishops have exercised no Jurisdiction ( in foro Externo ) within this Realm , but such as hath been granted unto them by the Successive Kings of England ; Neither have challenged † † Non enim dominandi cupidine imperant sed Officio consulendi nec principandi superbiâ sed providendi misericerdia . S. Aug. de Civ . D. c. 14. any such Jurisdiction belonging to them by any inherent right or title in their Persons , or Callings , but only by emanation and derivation from the Royal Authority : Now the regular exercise of a derived Power is so far from destroying , or any way diminishing that Original Power from whence it is derived , as that it rather confirmeth and establisheth the same ¶ ¶ Bishop Sanderson of Episc. not prejudic . to Regal Power . : Wherefore ( the Institution of a Christian Man ) calls The Power of Orders a Moderate Power , subject , determined and restrained .

§ . 3. As the Interests of the Kingdom and Church are excellently accommodated in our Constitution ( of Civil and Ecclesiastical Laws ) under one Supreme Governour ; so the Moderation of the Church hath tempered her self very justly between those pretences on one hand , who have insisted on their Pleas of Spiritual Right to the real diminution of Soveraign Power : And those on the other hand , who resolve the exercise of all the inward Power of the Church into the sole will and arbitrary power of the Civil Magistrates , according to Erastus , and the Leviathan-Author , who thus delivers himself : The Monarch hath authority not only to Preach Pag. 297. ( which perhaps no Man will deny ) but also to Baptize and Administer the Sacraments of the Lord's Supper , and to consecrate both Temples and Pastours to God's Service . Wherefore our 37 Article declares : We give not our Princes V. Canon 1. 2 , 36. V. Q Eliz. Admonition . the Ministring either of God's Word , or of the Sacraments ( which thing the Injunctions set forth by Elizabeth our Queen , do most plainly testifie ) but that only Prerogative which we see to have been given always to all godly Princes in Holy Scriptures by God himself , that is , that they rule all Estates and Degrees committed to their charge by God , whether they be Ecclesiastical or Temporal . Which Article of our Church is agreeable also to the judgment of some Bishops concerning the King's Supremacy , in the Raign of King Henry the 8th . Other places of Scripture declare the highness and excellency of Christian Princes Authority and Power : The which of a truth is most high , for he hath Power and Charge generally over all , as well Bishops , as Priests , as other : The Bishops and Priests have charge over Souls within their own Cures ; power to minister Sacraments , and to teach the Word of God : To the which Word of God Christian Princes knowledg themselves subject ; and in case the Bishops be negligent , it is the Christian Princes office to see them do their duty . Which sheweth Ex MSS. Dr. Stilling-fleet V. Collect. of Rec. Hist. of Reform . l. 3. p. 177. that Objection against the Oath of Supremacy is groundless , which supposeth that the King is therein made not more a Political than a Spiritual Head of the Church * * V. Camdens Eliz. p. 26. 39. Bishop Bramhal to M. Militier . p. 37. V. Instit. of Chri. Man . p. 50. : Which the Kings of England have constantly and openly disavowed to the whole World , renouncing all claim to such Power and Authority : Tho the regulating and ordering that Power in sundry Circumstances concerning the outward exercise thereof ( in foro externo ) the godly Kings of England have thought to belong to them as in the right of their Crown , and have accordingly made Laws concerning the same , even as they have done also concerning other Matters appertaining to the Religion and Worship of God .

§ . 4. Which being well considered , we have great reason to observe and extol the excellent and pious Moderation of our Kings of England , who never challenged to themselves the exercise of the pure Spiritual Power of the Church , but left it entirely to the Bishops , as the lawful Successors of the Apostles . Which more fully appears from the Proclamation , in the 13th Year of King Charles the First of blessed Memory , according to the Certificate of the Right Reverend Judges under their Hands , July 1. 1637. Wherein it was declared , That , Processes may issue out of the Ecclesiastical Courts in the name of the Bishops , &c. ( The Censures also of the Church are confirmed by the Law of the Kingdom . * * 1 R. Ellz. c. 2. )

And the behaviour of the Church to the King , sheweth the same Exemplary Moderation : For the Ecclesiastical Censures are with all due subordination to the Supreme Power secular used : Because all external jurisdiction coercive is by Law declared , and by the Clergy acknowledged to be wholly and entirely derived from the King , as the sole fountain of all Authority of external jurisdiction , whether Spiritual , or Temporal , within this Realm : In other Matters , tho the substance of the Power it self be immediately from God , and not from the King , ( as those of Preaching , Ordaining , Absolving , &c. ) Yet are they so subject to be inhibited , limited , or otherwise regulated in the outward exercises of that Power by the Laws and Customs of the Land , as that the whole execution thereof still depends on the Regal Authority . * * Bishop Sanderson l. praedict. p. 32 , 33. Altho then the Church knoweth it self to be a Society in its own nature distinct , ( unto which the 19 Article most properly refers ) yet ( as very often now it is the unspeakable happiness of the Church to be entertain'd within the Protection of Supreme Powers secular , so ) however the Church of England very justly declares for the Right of Kings to be preserved Inviolable , as well as the just Power of the Church , and the real Interest of the People : Yea , all these Interests with that of Religion in the first place , our Church with great Moderation and Wisdom preserves entire and distinct : All which among the Romanists and other Modellers , are miserably confounded or destroyed .

§ . 5. Other Sects among us do some way or other deny the King's Supremacy in Matters Ecclesiastical : either claiming a power of Jurisdiction over him , or pleading a privilege of Exemption from under him : The Papists do it both ways in their several Doctrines of the Pope's Supremacy , and of the exemption of the Clergy : The Presbyterians claiming to Ibid. p. 42 , 43. their Consistories as full and absolute Spiritual Jurisdiction over Princes ( with power even to Excommunicate them , if they shall see cause for it ) as the Papists challenge to belong to the Pope : And the Independents exempting their Congregations from all Ecclesiastical subjection to them , in as ample a manner as the Papists do their Clergy : whereas the English Protestant Bishops and Regular Clergy , as becometh good Christians and good Subjects , do neither pretend to any Jurisdiction over the Kings of England , nor withdraw their subjection from them , but acknowledg them to have Soveraign power over Can. 1. 1640. them , as well as over their other Subjects , and in all matters Ecclesiastical as well as Temporal : Which considerations verifie what hath been often formerly declared : Namely , That whereas now we are governed by Canon and Civil Laws , dispensed here by 26 Ordinaries , easily responsible for any deviation from the Rule of Laws ; conceive , should we be exposed to the meer Arbitrary Government of a numerous Presbytery , who together with their Ruling Elders , will arise to near forty thousand Church-Governors among us , they with their adherents must needs bear so great a sway , that they will not easily be reducible , and not consistent with Monarchy .

And for the Title of Divine Right , those of the Episcopacy rather purposely decline the mentioning of it , as a term subject to mis-construction : Or else so interpret it , as not of necessity to import any more than an Apostolical Institution : and is pleaded by them with more calmness and moderation , and with less derogation from Regal Dignity , than by any other of the three .

§ . 6. As the most excellent form of Government in our Kingdom most graciously and bountifully protects the Church , so the Church doth all she can to acknowledg the favour by asserting our Monarchy ; which is but truly performed in Canon 1. 1640. if we throughly consider the same . Since then there hath been spread abroad an Insinuation , that the said Canon did immoderately extol the Divine Right of Kings , as if no other Form but Monarchy could in other States be lawful , or of God's Ordinance , because the Canon saith , The most High and sacred Order of Kings is of Divine Right : I may have leave to vindicate the same with all submission where it is due .

Where I conceive the words , the most High and sacred Order of Kings , may be justly and reasonably interpreted , First , and especially of Monarchies , and also of All those Supreme Powers under what Form or Name soever they are called , in such places as they are lawfully Constituted ; Which , doubtless are , as the Canon proceeds , The Ordinance of God founded in the Primitive Laws of Nature ; which Supreme Rulers are often exprest by the general Name of Kings : And because of the Pre-eminence and Excellence of Monarchy , above all other Forms , the Denomination of the Order of Supreme Powers may not improperly follow the more noble and excellent part : Especially in a Kingdom where that is our only lawful Form , it is properly and truly so affirmed , that the High and sacred Order of Kings is of Divine Right : as being ordained of God Himself ; which just interpretation of the Canon , is according to our Homily * * V. Homily of Obedience . : Take away Kings , Princes , Rulers and Magistrates , Judges , and such Estates of God's Order , and no Man shall ride or go by the way unrobbed : — Blessed be God that we in this Realm of England feel not the horrible Calamities which they undoubtedly suffer that lack this godly Order , &c. Which the same Homily expresseth by the Name of Kings or other Supreme Officers , that is , the Higher Powers , as ordained of God : And that the Canon means no other by the Denominations of Kings , may be fairly gathered out of the following words of the Canon wherein ¶ ¶ V. 39 Articles 37. ( with excellent Moderation in opposition to the Usurpations of the Church of Rome , and other Sectaries ) what is there set down is most true of all Rightful Supreme Powers secular .

§ . 7. The Moderation of our Church doth not favour any Doctrines or Practices which are prejudicial to the safety of Humane Society in general , or this or any other Rightful State or Kingdom in particular : It doth no where pretend to remit the Divine Laws , or dispense with Oaths , or transfer the Right of Kingdoms , but leaves them without any imminution or change as it finds them * * Apol. Eccl. Anglic. §. 67. : But ¶ ¶ Homily of wilful Rebellion . 5 part . p. 374. after that ambition and desire of Dominion entred once into Ecclesiastical Ministers , and that the Bishop of Rome ( being by the Order of God's Word , none other than the Bishop of that one See and Diocess , and never yet well able to govern the same ) did by intollerable ambition challenge , not only to be the Head of all the Church dispersed through the World , but also to be Lord of all the Kingdoms of the World , he became at once the Spoiler and Destroyer both of the Church , and of the Christian Empire , and all Christian Kingdoms , as an Vniversal Tyrant over all . In so much that * * Pag. 380. There is no Country in Christendom which hath not been over-sprinkled with the blood of Subjects by rebellion against their natural Soveraigns , stirred up by the same Bishops of Rome : ¶ ¶ Pag. 383. Would to God we might only reade and hear out of the Histories of old , and not also see and feel these new and present Oppressions of Christians , rebellion of Subjects , &c. being procured in these our Days , as in times past , by the Bishop of Rome and its Ministers : † † Pag. 382. by the ministery of his disguised Chaplains creeping into Houses , &c. * * Pag. 361. What a Religion is this that such Men by such means would restore , may easily be judged .

Contrariwise , our Church of England requires all of its Communion , to give the King such security of their Allegiance and Fealty , as may be a sufficient security to his Government : Which security V. Homily of Obed. part 2. is with great Moderation exacted in our Realm .

Nevertheless , Pope Vrban 8 , in the Year 1626 , by his Bull bearing date May 30. forbad all Roman Catholics to take the Oath of Allegiance : And since the happy Restauration of his Majesty , when several of his Subjects of the Papal profession , offered by Oaths ( wherein the Supremacy is wholly wav'd ) to assure their Duty and Obedience : the Pope and his Agents look'd upon this Overture as an Apostacy from him , that is , from the Christian Faith , and persecuted all those who were concerned in the Proposal * * Diff. between the Church and Court of Rome . p. 30. , of which see the Controversial Letters , and the late History of the Irish Affairs . Which most remarkable Story is a strange proof of the dangerous influence on Kingdoms , which is to be expected from the propagation of the Roman Faith : and is also a great Instance of the Moderation of our Governments , and how ineffectual the same is on such .

§ . 8. The Rules and Orders of our Church are mildly and moderately framed : Our Church being ever most remov'd from the guilt or humour of Domineering over the Consciences of any : She teacheth and enforceth the Divine Commands , and useth her Liberty in those things which are left undetermin'd , and are within her own just Compass ; The Precepts of the Church , which are very few , are justly affirmed to bind by virtue of the Command of God ; yet their Obligation ( which is declared not to be Universal , only to her Sons , and that but so long as she judgeth expedient ) is intended or remitted , as just reason of the Case requires .

No Councils Evangelical are any where made into Laws in our Church ; or set up as a Fund for Merit and Supererogation , but are left free for our further exercise and endeavour after Christian Perfection : Which because it cannot be thorowly attained in this imperfect state , therefore the Moderation of our Church no where pretends to this perfection either of Knowledg or of Grace : So K. James affirmed to the Cardinal ; He never should boast of this Church as being perfectly without spot or wrinkle .

§ . 9. For Illustration sake , if we would compare the moderation of our Laws , with the Laws of the Roman Church , we cannot better do it than by taking into Consideration a Chapter of Card. Bellarmine's * * C. Bellarm. l. de Pontif. Ro. cap. de comparatione Legum . , wherein he useth very neat Sleights to elevate the heaviness and number of the Pontifical Laws , and to make them fewer and lighter than were the Ordinances among the Jews : For ( saith he ) the Laws absolutely impos'd upon all Christians by our Church , are scarce found any more than four : viz. To observe the Feasts of the Church : And the Fasts : and to Confess once a Year : and to Communicate at Easter . Indeed the Men of that generation are so wise , that until any be a through Proselyte , there is all shew of Moderation that may be to entice them into their Communion : But first , what Bondage was there ever among the Jews comparable to that one Obligation among the Romanists , to believe the Church and Pope of Rome infallible ? with the Consequences of that in practice , which are heavier than all the Jewish Observances set together . 2ly . On the Supposition that there were only those four general Precepts of the Church , we may consider how great Burdens any one of them singly do contain : 1. In that their Feasts are so excessive in their number , and the observation of them have so many Superstitions , ( V. Ch. 9. ) . The same 2. is to be said of their Fasts . 3. In that Auricular Confession of all Mortal Sins , with all their Circumstances , is enjoyn'd as by Divine Right ( V. Ch. 11. ) . 4. The slightest Precept of the four is the last , of Communicating at Easter : But considering therewith the round belief of Transubstantiation , which all are required to have , we may truly say with our Bishop Hall , * * Remains . p. 30. The Pope's little Finger is heavier than Moses 's Loins .

But perhaps one reason why the Cardinal saith , there are so few Precepts of the Church , is because he will say that many of the rest are Divine Commands , as Extreme Unction , &c.

The rest ( saith he ) of which the Tomes of Councils and Books of Canon Law are so full , are not Laws , but Admonitions only , or pious Institutions without obligation to Fault . However , there are great store of them , of a great Bulk : But it is strange that so many Canons of Councils , and other Laws enforced with Anathema , should have no intended obligation to a Fault in case of Transgression : Why were such Laws made , or why were such Anathemaes annexed ? Or ( saith he ) They are Conditional Laws , as of Celibacy , in case any enter into sacred Orders , which are not to be accounted burdensome , because the Law leaves them to their choice ; as also in case of Vows .

How many and how strict observances are contained under such conditional Obligations , is too well known to be largely insisted on . The Purifications , the choice of Meats among the Jews , had not all of them comparably so many Rites , and Orders , and Laws , as the Pontifical Oeconomy hath . But to make the Precepts of the Church show very light and easie indeed , The four Laws of the Church ( saith Bellarmin ) are rather a determination of the Divine Law , than any new Law ; for by the Divine Law , we are bound to dedicate some time to the Worship of God ; sometimes to Fast , to Confess , to Communicate . True indeed : But then the general Rules of Scripture , the edification of Christian People , the practice of the Primitive Church , the ends of Religious Actions themselves , ought to give measure to Laws , ( as in the Church of England is practised ) and not to let their Commands run out into such lavish extremity , where God hath left us at so large and safe freedom . Lastly , he saith , The Commands of the Church have a most moderate Obligation : for in their Fasts those who are Sick and Aged are accepted : And for Festivals , their observation also is dispensed with upon a just Cause .

So that in conclusion the Church of Rome is the most moderate Governour that ever was , for there it is the easiest matter to get off from the strictest Precepts that are , if you have Money , but the Poor cannot be comforted * * Nota diligenter quod hujusmodi gratia & dispensationes non conceduntur pauperibus , quia non sunt , & ideo non possunt consolari . Taxa . Cancel . Apostol. : So great is the moderation of the Church of Rome , so large are her Indulgences , whether for Commission of Sin , or for Omission of Duty .

§ . 10. Having mentioned the mildness of the Churche's Power , It is meet for the further shewing her Moderation , to note , That our Church in the Government of her Ecclesiastical Courts , in their manner of Process , Sentence , Appeals , doth make use of the Law of Equity : moderating even the practice of that also with all due Subordination to other Superiour Laws : According to Equity , our Church desires all its Laws may be interpreted ¶ ¶ Benignius leges interpretandae sunt quo voluntas earum conservetur . Capienda est occasio quae praebet benignius responsum . : She admits of a mitigation of a rigid Sentence : She doth sometimes dispense with her General Rules upon the exception of a particular Case : Just reason requiring , she admits a commutation of her Censures . When there is sufficient Cause , she is ready to abrogate any such Laws as are found inexpedient and inconvenient : The reason of her Laws ceasing , they are made to cease also : And to take cognizance of their desires who ask a relaxation of strict or rigid Law , there is a Court of Faculties constituted on purpose , to grant in many Cases ( not repugnant to the Law of God * * Camden . Britan. p. 110. ) a Dispensation of some Canons : And if the Ecclesiastical Senate among the Disciplinarians , might for the greater good of the Church dispence with a Rigid Law , why Altare Damasc . p. 85. may not the same be done in a Christian Kingdom by such Authority as the King and the Laws have constituted ? And we count it a great Moderation in our Establishment , that there is amongst us a right of Appeal allowed in case of unjust Censure . And the Moderation of our Public Government hath been such , that Permissions which have been sometime known upon occasion , were never allowed to make void the Laws of the Kingdom or the Church .

It may be added that in the separation and division of Causes , which is made between our Ecclesiastical and Civil Courts , as excellent Proportions and Measures are observable , so instead of all is , that the Rules of Ecclesiastical Practice are with all reserve and subordination to the Laws of the Kingdom . For our Church useth no other voluntary Jurisdiction than what is established or confirmed and limited by the Statute or Municipal Law : For the execution of which , and to correct the Excesses and Defects which shall be found among the Ministers or People ; and to promote Piety , Righteousness , and Sobriety of Life and Conversation , there are among us frequent Visitations appointed and practised by the Bishops and Arch-Deacons .

CHAP. XIII . Of the Moderation of the Church and Kingdom , referring to the Administration of Public Laws towards Offenders .

§ . 1. The occasion of that Mistake which is concerning the unlawfulness of Coercion in cases which concern Religion . § . 2. It may be very well consistent with the Moderation of the Church ( besides her own Censures ) to approve and sometimes desire such Coercion . § . 3. The Vse thereof in many Cases relating to Religion , the undeniable Right of the Christian Magistrate . § . 4. Some of the chief Objections hereunto Answered . § . 5. Sundry proper Instances of the great Gentleness and most indulgent Care of our Church toward all its Members . § . 6. The Moderation of the Church and Kingdom not without their requisite and just Bounds . § . 7. The Recourse which our Church desires may be made to the Secular Arm , is not but upon urgent and good Occasion . § . 8. Our Government defended from unjust Clamours of Persecution , of the Romanists on one side , and the Separatists on the other . § . 9. The Kings of England since the Reformation , and especially his present Majesty , Glorious Examples of this Moderation . The effect of this Moderation yet much desired and wanted .

§ . 1. AS the nature of Moderation hath been Explained . ( Ch. 1. ) The most proper Instances thereof are such , as shew the Gentleness and Mildness of the Church , with reference to such Censures and Punishments as are used and approved by Her : Which is most necessary to be observed , because the most general ( but groundless ) Objection against the Moderation of our Church hath been upon this Occasion : Which if we truly consider , ariseth either from a mistake in Judgment , that all Coercion in matter of Religion is unlawful , or else from an Impression , which ( on the Phancy and Affection of easie and soft Dispositions ) hath been made , from the Complaints of several ; to whom whatever looks like Penalty , is commonly irksome and very unpleasing , ( especially if it happens that they are guilty of the same ) wherefore they seem in haste to fly unto Religion as their Sanctuary against Punishment ; as if God's Religion , and His Church had different Altars among us ; therefore I doubt not but when the Prejudice against the former Mistake is taken off , Religion and the Church will appear to have the same Interest , and the Moderation of the Church may be fairly acknowledged .

§ . 2. For the distinct understanding what is right in this Case , we may first Consider how far toward this Coercion , the Church can move of it self .

1. We cannot but acknowledg the Church as a Society established by our Lord Christ , and ( which was necessary to the being of a Church ) had Rulers therein appointed , with Authority and Power to effect the necessary Ends of Government : Which could not be without a power of Discipline , to Rebuke Article 33 and Censure , and Exclude from such a Society , those who will not observe its just Laws : Which proceeding was suitable to the Apostolical Practice and Command with relation to Offenders ; and agreable to what was practised among the Jews in their Synagogues ; the common Reasons of which are perpetually the same : Namely , that such a Community and Fellowship as the Church is , be maintained in Unity , Peace , and Purity ( since without these no such Society can subsist ) and that such Offenders may ( if possible ) be reduced and amended ; who are bound to submit to such Censures , by virtue of their own first Consent ; which was the Condition of being admitted to partake of the Privileges of such a Communion . But in that general Contempt which is cast on Sacred things ( through the grievous Corruption of the Age ) since many are insensible of their Duty and Relation to the Church as Members ; and also are apt to despise the Church and her Spiritual Discipline : Therefore the Church in a Christian Kingdom being in other Circumstances than considered alone by it self , receiving thereby Defence in the exercise of its Power , so far , that many times the Christian Magistrate is pleased to add ( to the Spiritual Censures of the Church , if need be ) such outward and sensible Punishments , as may touch the Bodies , or Goods , or Temporal Interests of such Delinquents : In such a case the Church hath reason to accept of such Defence , and to approve also and defend the same civil Animadversions on Offenders , since they are very lawful and useful , and worthy a Christian Magistrate .

§ . 3. He being appointed of God for the punishment of Evil-doers , and to execute Wrath on them : Since they on whom the Church rightly inflicts her Censures are Evil-doers , therefore such also the more they undervalue the Censures of the Church , the more justly are they the subjects of the Civil Magistrates Punishment .

And since Offences which affront the Majesty of Heaven are of the highest Nature , the more Religious a Magistrate is , the more care he will take to see such Punished . And since Christian Magistrates owe that duty to God ( from whom alone they receive their Power and Soveraignty ) they are therefore especially to take care of Religion ; and Common Reason and Experience instructs us , This cannot be done unless such Laws are guarded with Sanctions of Punishments ; that so They may be indeed a Terror to those who will break the Peace and Order of the Church : Especially when the Peace of the Church hath so great an Influence on the Peace of the Public State , or Kingdom : Which , when it is Christian , the Religion of the Kingdom is the chief part of its Laws .

This is the use of no other Power than what the Kings of Israel and Judah had : And in Christian Kingdoms * * Cod. l. 1. Tit. 1. hath been used , ever since any Kings have become Christian , for the real good of the Church , whose Members with all thankful acknowledgment have approved the same : As hath often appeared from sundry Testimonies of the Ancients , which need not be repeated , since the several Sects which oppose our Church , in this Matter make use of the same Power to the utmost , when they can come to it : As , ¶ ¶ Thorndike . Forbear . of Penal . ch. 29. The Independent Congregations in New-England , have not only Banished the Antinomians , and put Quakers to Death , but have imposed a Penalty of Five Shillings a day upon all that come not to hear their Sermons .

And as the Synod of Dort said , There is no Order , no Peace in the Church , where it may not be lawful to the Church to judg of its own Members , and retain within due bounds their Licentious Humours . * * Vt vaga ingenia coerceat intra debitos limites .

We know God commended Abraham , because he would command his Children and his Houshold after him , to keep the Way of the Lord , ( Gen. 18. 19. )

And People of different Persuasions , do not question but it is reasonable for Parents to correct their Children when they absent themselves from such Teaching as they order them , and when they refuse to reade , or hear what concerns Divine Matters , in the way they judge fitting : And shall not the Power of the Supreme Magistrate have the like effect for the good Order of the Church ?

§ . 4. But many Object . First , Nothing ought to be so voluntary as Religion : And indeed Religion ought to be most free , even the choice of our Mind , otherwise it cannot be our reasonable and acceptable Service : But Penalties ( say they ) make that to be Servile , which ought to be most Free : To which may be Answered . That all Acts of Vertue are to be free likewise , and it is indeed more Noble to observe good Laws for the love of Goodness , than the fear of Punishment ; But sometime Fear is the beginning of Wisdom , and if Men will not willingly observe such good Laws , the suffering Punishment is a less bondage than the slavery of Sin .

All Christian Duty ought to be free and voluntary , but if Men are voluntarily Vitious , Heretical , and Schismatical , the Christian Magistrate may Act religiously voluntarily to Punish them , even because they wilfully do what is evil , when they might have freely Acted what was good : Which offence is the more aggravated in Matters of Religion , therefore for any to make Religion their excuse for irregular practices , is to turn Religion and the Church into a Sanctuary of Wickedness : Irreligion and Heresies have their sensual baits and temptations , which fear of punishment wholsomely prevents , and usefully takes away .

2. Others Object , That no Man can be compelled to believe ; for Belief must follow the evidence of things to the Understanding .

T is true , The Rules of the Christian Church do not allow Force as a means to bring any to believe * * Sed nec Religionis est cogere Religionem , quaeisuscipi spon●e debet non vs . Tertul. ad Scapulam . : But those who have professed that they do believe , and thereby have become Members of the Christian Society within a Christian Kingdom , and so ought to be Obedient to the Laws and Orders thereof : If such by their speeches and behaviour say and do what tends to destroy that Society , and disturb its Peace and Order , when by the execution of good Laws , the pravity of their Minds , as it betrays it self by disorderly speeches and actions , is corrected ; it may be a proper means to reduce such to a better Mind , which may be the more thereby prepared to entertain a sound belief : When speculative Errors become voluntary , they become sinful , and are springs of Vice ; and therefore as the interest of the Public may be concerned , so they properly may come under the animadversion of Laws . Yet we may take notice that the case is quite different between either Infidels or weak Christians , and those who have been taught the Christian Religion :

Who call themselves Christians , and profess themselves of the Society of Believers : Who presume of themselves , that they are far above the rank of Ignorant or weak People : When these disturb the common Peace of the Church , and are in danger to infect others : When the same disorder in the Church hath a dangerous influence on the Peace of the Kingdom : Such from the Nature and Laws of Christian Society , deservedly come under the Censure of the Church , and the Punishment of the Civil Laws , especially in a Christian Kingdom . And it is a great Blessing if such can by any means be reduced : It is but what is necessary , and what is a great work of Charity ( as our Homily hath it . )

3. Others pretend they ought not to be punished while they follow their Conscience .

But ( in answer ) What if such a Conscience shall cast off all Subjection , must therefore all Execution of Laws be unlawful ? ( And they may so do , if they will , by the same Reason ) . Again , What if any call that , by the awful name of Conscience , which is their Prejudice , their false Judgment of things , caused by the irregular inclination of their wills ? Shall that excuse them from their manifest Christian Duty ? When they ought to inform their Consciences right : And also ( as of necessity ) be obedient for Conscience sake : The Conscience therefore of any who are punished for their Disobedience , cannot render that Punishment unjust , when the Laws themselves are good , and the execution of those Punishments upon them , are according to those Laws .

4. Many will say , That Counsels and gentle Instructions , are a surer and better way to prevail . And it is very true : and God forbid but they should be in their due place used : But if they will not prevail , they are left the more inexcusable , who notwithstanding are captious of exceptions against their Governours , to justifie their own Schism . Others frequently appeal to experience of the inefficacy of Punishments to these ends ; and that they rather confirm than root out the persuasions they strike at . And this also may be very true , when such Penalties are either executed very unconstantly , or in excess , either to a degree of Injustice or Cruelty : And when the due ends and measures of Punishments are not observed : whereas moderate and sober Punishments are justly thought proper , to awaken the minds of Offenders into due consideration and regard of their Duty : But none can ever reasonably think , that it will conduce to the peace of the World for any to do as they list . And whereas it is frequently objected : That the omissions of Forms and Ceremonies is more severely punished than greater Faults . How greater ? ( said Bishop Lany before the King . ) Our Earthly Tribunals are not erected to anticipate the Day of Judgment , to try Men according to the proper measure of their Guilt , but for a particular End and Vse ; therefore in some cases such Omissions are pursued with more care and strictness , because they destroy the very end for which the Power is given the Church to punish , which is the preservation of Peace and Vnity .

§ . 5. Wherefore now it remains for us to observe the excellent measures of the Moderation of our Church , in that Gentleness and Benignity , which is shewed in the Administration of her Laws .

1. Religion is no where allowed or desired to be more voluntary than among us : And no where are any more required by their own choice , and free use of their own understandings , to take upon them the profession of their Religion .

2. None by our Church were ever compelled to the Faith : When did ever our Church encourage any Christian King to send his Arms to compel any Pagans or Infidels to the Faith ?

3. Let it be remembred : None in our Church are punished only for their Opinion : Even The Liberty of Prophesying , saith , Opinion may accidentally disturb Sect. 16. Num. 4. the public Peace through the overactiveness of the Person , and the confidence of their Belief , and the opinion of its appendant necessity , and therefore Toleration of differing Persuasions in these cases is to be considered upon Political Grounds , and is just to be admitted or denied as the Opinions or Tolerations of them may consist with the public and necessary ends of Government .

Let it also be remembred , that our Church and Laws do allow a Liberty of Conscience , and which is more , a Liberty of Practice , to such a degree as the Laws of the Kingdom and the Church judge safe for the Public Interest . 'T is evident that they already allow a large and real Toleration , within such bounds as They have judged the Public Peace may be secured : which large Liberties all are not sensible of , who enjoy them , because they compare not the effects of that Spirit of Meekness in our Church , with the Cuts of those Rods ( and Axes too I may say ) which have been prepared both by the Romish Communion , and by other Disciplinarians .

And by the few things which our Church hath determin'd , since there is so great a liberty left for Mutual Toleration , It is evident that the Divine Moderation of our Church considers the frame of Man ; and the uncertainty , difficulty , and imperfection of Humane Knowledg , the weakness and variety of Humane Understandings : She alloweth much to the force of Prejudice , Education , and the power and artifice of Seducers : Our Church makes a great reserve of Dispensation to Persons of modest , humble , docible , and peaceful Spirits ; and proportions its Censures to the degrees of Malice , and the Unchristian Temper which appears in Offenders ; and chiefly designs securing Peace , and the true ends of Government , and the common interest of her Communion .

4. All Christian care is used to inform and instruct the Ignorant , and those who are in Error , with all Meekness and Patience : * * Blandâ pietate portandi sunt , qui increpari pro suâ infirmitate non possunt . Prosper de vitâ Contempl. c. 5. Counsels , Debates , Persuasions , Concessions , Indulgences , from time to time have been used , sufficient to justifie our Church , and leave her obstinate Adversaries the more Inexcusable : The Infirm and ¶ ¶ Veluti pueris absinthia tetra Cum dare conantur , pri●● or as pocula circum . Lucret. l. 4. Weak our Church receives with an Apostolic Care : and earnestly provides , they be not led into doubtful Disputations . It doth not only pray that all such as have Erred and are Deceived , may be led into the Way of Truth , but requires her Ministers to use all private Conferences and means that may be , to reduce the Dissenting Brother : Which Method at large is prescribed in the 3 d Canon , 1640. for the suppressing the growth of Popery , and is also provided for in the 66 Canon , 1603. It is not my purpose ( said King James † † Confer . at Hampt . Court . ) and I dare say it is not the Bishops intent , presently and out of hand to enforce these things without Fatherly Admonitions , Conferences , V. Refor . Leg. Eccl. de jud. contr. har. c. 3. and Persuasions .

Wherefore the Rules of our Church require in the exercise of her Authority , great Gravity , Temper , and Wariness : There being no Earthly Providence so likely to secure the Obedience of Children , as that of Parents not provoking them , and the difference being not great ( and the danger equal ) whether that be done by too great severity of Punishments , or levity of Commands , the one abating the Love , the other the Reverence due to the Parents * * Dr. Ham. of resolv . Controversies . . Our Church therefore maintains the Reverence due to her , by laying greatest stress on the weightest matters of the Law : and declares the keeping or omitting of a Ceremony in it self considered , is but a small thing ( setting aside Wilfulness and Contempt ) ¶ ¶ Pref. of Cerem . , and which might ( in reason ) gain Love to our Church , her Punishments are as mild as her Commands are reasonable .

5. The Punishments for any Errors , yea , Heresy it self , which by our Laws are allowed , or by our Church are approved , are so moderate , as thereby may appear , their design is not Destruction , but Amendment and Edification : As our Church doth earnestly commend Gentleness , so it practiseth the same , for as our Church saith , † † Homily of the state of Matrimony . Honest Natures will sooner be retained in their Duties by gentle words than by extremity and severity , and frowardness is not mended with frowardness , but with softness : Wherefore the Institution of a Christian Man saith , The Bishops are not bound so precisely , but they may attemper and forbear the Execution of their Jurisdiction , when by so doing the Cure of the Offenders , and the Tranquillity of the Church , may be furthered : Our Church being of the same Judgment with those Fathers of the Church , who when the Donatists were intolerable , they consented to some lesser Penalty , but constantly condemned taking away their Lives . * * Semper tamen Augustinus excipit supplicium Mortis , non quod illos hoc non mereri putaret , sed tùm quia hoc decere Ecclesiae Mansuetudinem putaret . C. Bellarm. de Laicis , Tom. 2. l. 3. c. 21. At other times our Church moderates her Censures in proportion to the Offence , for the reducing the Transgressor ; using a Medicinal Censure , before a Precisive : a less , to prevent a greater Excommunication ¶ ¶ Canon 48. 88. 109. 115. : This , she resorts to as the last Remedy † † Monitio omnes ferè Censuras Ecclesiasticas pracedit . De Polit. Eccl. Anglic . p. 315. ; and so also , that the Church hath her Bosom open to any who return and repent of their wicked Errors and Practices : and upon Repentance , our Church is more ready to Absolve than otherwise to Bind ; and delights to give her Sons to God , but very unwillingly * * Form . Senten . Excommunic . delivers them over to Satan ¶ ¶ Sic Episcopi affectus boni est — postremò quod sanari non potest , cum dolore abscindere . S. Ambros . Offic. l. 2. c. 27. .

Wherefore those who in the execution of the Church-Discipline , abuse the most excellent Temper of the Church in the Constitution of her Laws , under the pretence of Ecclesiastical Authority , verily , they most of all deserve the Churches Rod , and the dire point of her Anathema : Let it be considered ( said Bishop Taylor † † Ductor Dub. l. 3. p. 259. ) how great a reproach it is to Ecclesiastical Discipline , if it be made to minister to Covetousness , and to the need of Proctors and Advocates : The more shame for the over-easie denouncers of that Censure , that inflict it for every trivial commission , without consideration whether or no repented of ; or that use this soveraign Recipe unadvisedly , for any other end than reforming of the Prophane ¶ ¶ Doctor Hammond of the Keys c. 5. §. 18. . Where this Discipline is duly exercised , if it hath not that effect as it might , and ought , much may be imputed to the immoderate refractoriness of the Recusants among us , who are so devoted to their Wills , that they have rendred our Discipline more useless than it would be : Yet sundry abuses referring hereunto , our Canons have endeavoured to redress .

§ . 6. But there is a Moderation in Moderation it self ¶ ¶ — Solertèr cavendum , ne dum moderatius custoditur virtus humilitatis , solvantur jura regiminis . S. Greg. M. pastor , cur . par. 2. c. 6. : Wherefore it is one great Commendation of the Moderation of the Church of England , and her Supreme Governours , when the Case hath required , their Moderation hath been necessarily and conveniently governed , because of the danger thereof otherwise : For God used Samuel , as a Messenger against Eli , for his excess of Indulgence to his Sons , 1 Sam. 3. 13. And yet Samuel himself seems scarce free from the very same fault concerning his Sons , 1 Sam. 8. 3 , 15. And this Indulgence occasioned the change of the Civil Government , as the former was the loss of the Priesthood * * Iram benignitas mitiget , benignitatem zelus exacuat , & ita alterum condiatur ex altero , ut nec immoderata ultio , plasquam opert●t affligat ; nec iterum frangat rectitudinem Disciplinae remissio , Greg. M. l. 4. Epist. 55. .

Moderation is confessed an excellent Vertue and much to be desired , but then it is in a subject capable of it , wherein there are extremes and excesses to be moderated , as certainly there is in all our passions , there it is proper ; Only this Caution Bishop Lany ●n 1 Thess 4. 11. is to be observed in Lenity , that it be such as may win Men into the Church , not such as may secure and encourage them to stay without ; Yet Lenity and Gentleness is so good a Vertue , that I am loth to cast Water upon it , or seem to temper it : But for Men of moderate Opinions , I am at a loss to know what they should be ; for Moderation there cannot be but between Extremes : Now what extremes are there of Opinions in a settled Church , unless the Church be one Extreme , and the Schismatick another ? And then , the Man of moderate Opinions is he that is part Church-man and part Schismatick .

— Possibly they may bestow that good word Moderation upon such as care little to observe the Law themselves , or to require it of others : But if the Law it self be too rigorous , in God's Name let it be amended , and not left to the arbitrary power of others to do it , for that is known to be a remedy ten times worse than the disease .

* * Bishop Ward , Nov. 5. 1661. Praestat vivere ubi nihil licet , quàm ubi omnia . There is no Cruelty so great as that of Laxness of Government , nor any Tyranny in the World like the rage of Subjects let loose ; and the little finger of Licentiousness is harder than the Loins of the severest Laws , and strictest Government .

§ . 7. Yet our Church hath not recourse to the Secular Arm , but upon urgent and good occasion : When the Spiritual Power of the Church , cannot have all the effect which it ought , to keep Men in order for their own good , and the common peace of the Kingdom and the Church , the supreme political Governour hath right to restrain and animadvert on Hereticks and Schismaticks , that the Contagion may not spread as doth a Cancer , and that the disorder in the Church may not influence the disturbance of the Kingdom : therefore when great Reason moves , the Church is glad when the Civil Power will be friend it so far as to defend and protect it in its Office , and sometime to render the same effectual , to enforce a common and public Order even by the Laws of the Land :

For , * * Institu . of a Christian-man . p. 46. It is out of all doubt that the Bishops and Priests never had any Authority by the Gospel to punish any Man by Corporal Punishments , and therefore they were oftentimes moved of necessity to require Christian Princes to interpose their Authority , and by the same to reduce the Inobedient to the good Order of the Church .

§ . 8. Wherefore it is not improper here to take notice of the wrong notion which the Romanists and other Separatists have entertain'd , not only of Moderation but of Persecution : As if every Spiritual Censure of the Church , or Punishment of the Magistrate , for the greatest inconformity and disorder and breach of the Peace of the Church , and the Ecclesiastical Orders of the Kingdom , was Persecution : when indeed it is but defending the Faith , and the society of the Faithful , that is , the Church : Which is the noblest Privilege of Christian Princes , and the most worthy execution of their Power . Yet herein the immoderate Calumnies of our Adversaries appear more grievous , that upon any execution of this Power , the Offenders instead of accusing themselves , and being reconciled to the Lenity of the Church , and the Preserver of its Laws , They accuse at one blow the whole frame of Government , of direful Persecution , as if they had erected some terrible Tribunal of Inquisitors , which our Church doth most of all abhor ; and doth declare against punishing even Heretics ( as such only ) with Death , much less those who are falsely branded with that name ( which is the cruelty of the Romish Inquisition ) : And the Moderation of our Church hath no other Punishments but what are just and proper to convince such , and reduce them , and secure their own ; but indeed if Heretical and Erroneous Persons cause a Schism and Division , and make a breach upon the Churche's Peace ; If the Christian Magistrate restrain or punish such , they do but as in the Ancient Church the Christian Emperours have done , as when St. Austin * * Insectamur vipotestatis secularis Haereticos , non quia fidem deseruerunt , sed quia illi Catholicos usque ad necem persequuntur . St. Aug. Ep. 50. was forc'd to call upon the Imperial Arm for defence of the Church , against those kind of Donatists call'd the Circumcelliones .

1. The Romanists set up this cry of Persecution , and the other Separatists second the loud Clamour ¶ ¶ Quid juvant leges aequissimae , ubi dominantur Domini , dixissem Tyranni , legum administri & executores ? Altar . Damas . P. 579. . Notwithstanding , Our Edicts and Statutes made for their restraint , are such as serve only to awake them , and cause them to consider the innocence of that Cause , for refusal of Communion in which they endure , as they suppose , great Losses : Those who are sent over by them either for the retaining the already perverted , or perverting others , are either returned by us back again to them who dispatch them to us , or without any wrong unto their Persons , or danger to their Lives , suffer an easie restraint , which only hinders them from dispersing their Poyson they brought , and had they not been stickling in our State Businesses , and medling with our Prince's Crown , there had not a drop of their Blood fallen to the Ground * * T●t conjurationes & machinationes & rebelliores publicae in illo Regno ortae sunt , ut illae non solum fuerint justae , sed etiam Moderatae poenae delin quentium . Ad R. Eliz. Rex Jac. in Apologià . Quod me de Catholicorum persecutione calumniàntur , nunquam probari potest , quenquam Conscientiae causà & Religionis ergo , me regnante , hactenus vel morte mulctatum fuisse , vel in mortis periculo versari . Rex Jacobus . ibid. .

Yet they traduce our Judiciary Proceedings against them for sanguinary and violent , striving to persuade other Nations , that such as have suffered by Course of public Justice , for Religion sake only , and not for Treason , have Died ¶ ¶ M. Hales of dealing with erring Christians . . — And the less wonder that these Penal Laws are not taken away , until those Principles be fully renounced which gave occasion to them : Yet this may be noted of the Moderation of our Government , in not suffering the Course of our Law to proceed , but when the apprehension of danger hath been great .

2. As to most of our other Separatists : Who seeth not their Hypocrisie , who would make the World believe they are persecuted , when with too much Lenity they are punished for their intolerable contempt of good Laws : It is to be doubted what these Men will do when Persecution cometh indeed , who make now so much of nothing ¶ ¶ Arch-Bishop Whitgift answer to Admon . 1572. .

The Moderation of our Church in this matter , Bishop Sanderson † † Bishop Sanderson's judgment in one View . thus also defends : Our Church , it is well known , hath not always used that Rigour she might have done : Where she hath been forced to proceed as far as Deprivation , she hath ordinarily by her fair , slow , and compassionate proceeding therein , sufficiently manifested her unwillingness thereunto , and declared her self a Mother every way indulgent enough to such ill nurtured Children as will not be ruled by Her . 2. Those that are suspended or deprived , suffer it but justly for their obstinacy and contempt : For however they would bear the World in hand that they are the only Persecuted ones , and that they suffer for their Consciences , yet in truth they do but abuse the Credulity of the simple therein : And herein ( as in many other things ) jump with the Papists , whom they would seem above all others most abhorrent from : For as Seminary Priests and Jesuits give it out they suffer for Religion , when the truth is , they are justly executed for their prodigious Treasons , and felonious or treacherous Practices against lawful Princes and States : So the Brethren pretend they are persecuted for their Consciences , when they are indeed but justly censured for their obstinate and pertinacious contempt of lawful Authority .

'T is well known the Quakers were hanged in New-England : Yet

To these , who so much cry out Persecution , saith the Friendly Debate : Are Pag. 218. Part. 1. you not allowed to worship God just as you please in your own Families ? May not some of your Neighbours joyn with you ? For shame do not complain of Persecution who are so kindly used * * Si ea quae per misericordissimam disciplinam patiuntur , comparentur sactis quae furi●sa temeritate committunt , quis non videat qui magis Persecutores vocandi sunt . S. Aug. Ep. 167. , who endeavour'd in such a manner to oppose others : The Common Prayer was never imposed with such Rigour as the Directory was .

* * M. Dryden's Ep. Ded. 1678. We have already all the Liberty which Free-born Subjects can enjoy , and all beyond is but License : But if it be Liberty of Conscience which they pretend , the Moderation of our Church is such that its Practice extends not to the severity of Persecution , and its Discipline is withal so easie that it allows more freedom to dissent then any of the Sects would allow it : In the mean while what right can be pretended by these Men to attempt Innovations in Church or State ? Who made them Trustees , or to speak in their own Language , the Keepers of the Liberties of England ?

Wherefore if a perfect pattern of dealing with Erring Christians were to be sought , there were not any like unto this of ours , which as it takes not to it self liberty of Cruelty , so it leaves not any the liberty of destroying their own Souls in the error of their Lives ¶ ¶ M. Hales of Erring Christians . .

§ . 9. Here humble thankfulness and duty binds us to make mention of the most glorious examples of Princely Moderation which the Christian World ever hath exhibited , namely the Moderation of our Kings which have been since the Reformation : which gives a great Lustre to the subject here treated of : Of whom those have been most fortunate to whom belongs that Character , which was given of Marcus Aurelius Antoninus , * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Mar. Anton. l. 1. §. 16. He had skill and knowledg when Rigour and Extremity , and when Remisness and Moderation Neque multâ asperitate exulcerentur subditi , nec nimiâ benignitate solvantur . Gregor. M. de Curà Pastor . was in season : ( Or as King James's Phrase to the Parliament , 1622. was ) when the Spur and when the Bridle was to be used . The very Enemies of Q. Elizabeth , among the Romish Faction , could not but confess , that Her Laws and Procedings were very mild and merciful ¶ ¶ Watson's Quodlibets . p. 303. V. Fowlis Hist. of Popish Treasons l. 7. c. 2. &c. : And yet how very often did they Treasonably attempt against her Life ? Neither did her Indulgence sufficiently prevail with the other sort of Recusants to conform , as the Queen by all means did desire . That wise King James ( in his Basilicon † † Pag. 31. ) earnestly from our dear-bought Experience , warned his Son , that his Mildness and Lenity found ( in Scotland ) little effect : and the loss of his thanks was all his reward . And in his Raign , of the Romanists in England , Isaac Casaubon asked Fronto Ducaeus , * * An illa divina in negotio Religionis Moderatio quicqam apud vestros profuit ? p. 73. Whether the King 's Divine Moderation in business of Religion , had prevailed one whit among them ?

K. Charles the First was so great an example of Moderation in Judgment and Practice , that ( as his Character is in his Life ) He pursued Moderation in spite of the Malignity of the Times : Yet he was made a Royal Martyr , rather than he would betray the Church to either of its Enemies on either extreme . The Moderation and Clemency of his present Majesty hath appeared to all the World as the most radiant Lustre of his Crown : And yet it may be an astonishment to the most moderate Men to consider , how unaccountable the rage of the Jesuits , and some other Romanists have been toward a Prince of such Divine Clemency and wonderful Grace , even to those of their Communion : And how little the more peaceable and orderly and complying the greatest part of our other Dissenters have been , notwithstanding all that Forgiveness and Moderation and Favour , wherewith he hath crowned both sorts of Enemies , by heaping of Coals of Fire on their Heads ; Where do we see either of them generally the more melted down into greater Humility and Observance ? Or the more inflamed in a passionate sense of the excellency of that Moderation which from the King and the Church they have so much experienced * * Ne Regum quidem mansuetudine abuti consultum est , non ignorant illi vires suas . Erasm . de amab . Eccl. Concord . ? What Re-condescention hath been made by them for all the Indulgences of his Majesty from first to last ?

Julian the Apostate was honoured as a wondrous Moderate Prince , because he permitted the Sectaries then their Liberty in Religion : And Valentinian ¶ ¶ Valentinianus hoc Moderamine principatus inclaruit , q●ò● inter Religionum diversitates Medius ste●it : neque ut hoc coleretur imperavit aut illud . Am Marcellinus . the Emperour was in those days counted Moderate , because he stood middle and indifferent ( as we may say , between God and Baal , that is ) to any sort of Worship .

But the Christian Moderation of our Kings hath been so well temper'd , I cannot express it but in some of their own words . To any number of our Loving Subjects we very willingly Comply , with the advice of the Parliament , that some Law be made for the exemption of tender Consciences . Provided that this Ease be attempted and pursued with that Modesty , Temper , and Submission , that in the mean time the peace and quiet of the Kingdom be not disturbed ; The decency and comliness of God's Service discountenanced , nor the pious , sober , and devout Actions of those Reverend Persons who were the first Labourers in the blessed Reformation be scandal'd and defam'd * * His Majest. Declaration , 1641. .

So cool a Moderation methinks should have tempered and prevented the growing Flame : Or since , it might have been extinguished by that Act of Grace , among many others , which connived at their private Meetings to the number of Five , &c. which if only Conscience rightly so called was the reason in the Case , might have contented any sober Dissenters : But , in that , unhappy was Alexander the Great , ¶ ¶ Aestuat Infelix angusto limite mundi . He swelled the more for being Confin'd .

Nevertheless , what Thuanus said in his Epistle to K. Henry 4th of France , hath been much more true in our Case among us . You , Sir , have graciously restored them to their Houses and Goods , and most of them you have adorn'd with Primary Dignities , supposing that by degrees their Hatreds being assuaged , and that Concord which you have decreed being more conveniently established among those that were at Enmity , thereby chearfulness being returned to their Minds , what in Religion is best , and what is most ancient may be discern'd , * * Vt ex eorum quiete , aliorum adhuc in Schismate positorum Corda flectantur . Greg. M. l. 7. Ep. 97. &c. Yet notwithstanding all the Moderations which have been used , the Romanists have gone on in their Serpentine way of Insidiousness : And the Sectaries also have been like the deaf Adder which will not hear the voice of the Charmer , charm he never so wisely : But we may not wonder if the favours and bounties of Princes cannot make them be thought so much as Moderate , with some sorts of Romanists such as are of Suarius's † † Praetered favores & beneficia quae Catholic●s se contulisserefert , & parvi momenti sunt ad excusandam Persecutionem : non enim Religionis causâ illis fave●e , vel potius cum illis dissimulare incepit , sed obrationes politicas ut in principio Regni sui omnes sibi aliquo modo conciliaret . — Et fortasse illis blanditiis & honoribus eorum animos lu●rari cupiebat , — Quod si ita est id non excusatio sed po●ius pars & augmentum Persecutionis censenda est , Suarii Def. l. 6. c. 10. de Persecutione Anglic. mind ; who treating of the English Persecution under King James , argueth very Scholastically ; His pursuing them with Favours and Benefits to be even one great part and aggravation of their Persecution : That being only a politic kind of dissimulation , by blandishments and honours to gain upon their minds : O the favours of good Princes sometimes ill-placed , thus to be commented on , and requited !

CHAP. XIV . Of the general Moderation of our Church toward all that differ from her , and are in error .

§ . 1. Our Church takes an universal care to satisfy and reconcile those who differ from her : Particularly our Domestic Dissenters , to whom sundry Concessions have been made . § . 2. Our Church is not forward to denounce Curses against those who are not of the same Judgment with her . § . 3. Our Church doth not judg all according to the Consequences of their Doctrines . § . 4. In refusing an adverse Party , Our Church gives an excellent Example , not to use odious Names . § . 5. Our Church useth great care to preserve and restore peace . § . 6. The Moderation of the Church gives it a singular advantage to convince Dissenters upon right and proper Principles . § . 7. The Moderation of our Church doth incomparably qualify Her to arbitrate and reconcile the present differences of the Christian Churches . § . 8. A Supposition laid down of the most possible means of Reconciling a Protestant , and such a Romanist as lays aside Infallibility : and that the Church of England hath done her part , in what was fit , toward any just Reconciliation . § . 9. An Answer to that common Calumny of the Separatists , that our Governors in the Church of England have more peace and reconciliation for Papists , than for the most moderate Protestant Dissenters .

§ . 1. ALthough the lenity and benignity of our Church , toward those who differ from her , even toward Offenders , hath sufficiently appeared from what hath bin already delivered : Yet moreover , in an universal care to satisfy all who differ from Her , and to reconcile them to Truth , and to Her self ; Our Church hath been always ready to give an Apology and Reason of Her Faith and Practice .

Particularly , Our Domestic Dissenters have less reason to except , because Our Church hath wisely and faithfully provided , what-ever is necessary or expedient for those who are , or ought to be within Her Communion ; As becomes a good Steward of the Family of Christ , there is in her House ( the Church of the Living God ) whatsoever is requisite to promote the true Worship of God , the Communion of Saints , the Kingdom of Christ , the Emendation and Edification of all in brotherly Love , and Faith , and Godliness , as appears from the excellent Monuments of the Churches Piety , Her Articles , Liturgy , Canons , and whatsoever else belongs to Her Constitution : The Church Doors are open , we have the Holy Scriptures in our Mother-Tongue frequently read and expounded in Preaching and Chatechism ; We have the excellent Prayers generally accommodated to all public Occasions , and the Holy Sacraments ritely administred , and all Spiritual Means necessary to prevent Heresy and Schism ; Over and above , we have Our Prince , the professed Defender of our Faith ; and the assistance of the Ministry of God for all particular occasions , public and private , which humane fore-sight generally can procure ; ( of these things we have a large Confession in the Morning Exercise against * * Serm. 9. p. 209. Popery . ) Our dissenting Friends should therefore consider that the Case is quite different from the condition of the Church , when it was forced to assemble together in † † Homily of Idol . 3 part . low and poor Conventicles , simple Oratories , and Caves under-ground , called Cryptae , for fear of persecution . Since these things are so , A wild humour possesseth too many who run into dangerous and forbidden Conventicles , scandalously insinuating , that our Church and Kingdom , rather persecute than encourage Christianity .

But because nothing in this World is so perfect , but may have its exceptions framed against it , especially when fair Constructions are not allowed : therefore for the sake of Peace , and in hope , by the Church's Condescention and endeavour to remove even all suspicion of what is blame-worthy , there have from time to time bin many Concessions made , for the utmost satisfaction of all , in what hath been thought expedient : Our Church being of the mind of Father Nazianzen * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . ; who in his Oration of Peace , said , Come , let us give way , that so we may over-come ; let us grant a little , that so we may gain a great deal , even Peace . Not only in Queen Elizabeth's time some things were changed , ( then being taken into advice , many Learned and Moderate Divines * * Camdens Hist. of Q. Eliz. ) but even since our Reformation , there have bin Concessions made in accommodation to Dissenters : Our Church still holding the mean , between too much moroseness , and too much easiness in admitting Variations † † Pref. to the Lit. . There are two sorts of Popularity , ( said Calvin to Farellus ) one , when with Ambition and Lust to ingratiate our selves , we hawk after the popular Air ; the other , when by Moderation and Equity , we endeavour to engage the affection of Men , only to render them more docible . This latter practice belongs to Our Church : which hath wisely accommodated Her self to all , to gain * * Submittendo nos ad mensuram discentis , & manum dando & gradum nostrum minuendo . Quintil. some . Our Church being of the temper of those whom Tully calls Courteous and Sweet , who gently shew those that err the way , which is the true Christian disposition , different from what Juvenal * * Non monstrare vias eadem nisi Sacra colenti . described in the Jews . Yea , one of the great perfections of the Christian Practice , ( which is an Universal Charity to all , even Enemies ) may be much promoted by our Church's Prayers , where we pray for all Men , and for Enemies , and for Persecutors and Slanderers : Yea , such is the Charity of Our Church , that in it every one is presumed good , and orderly , and willing to be of Her Communion , until it appear lawfully to the contrary .

§ . 2. Whereas of the Extreams of the Separation on either hand from Our Church , 't is too well known how generally they give out themselves as the only Children of God's Church , the only Beloved of God , and scarce admit any else to have any portion with their Saints : Nevertheless for such matters as they contend , Our Church is not busy to send Men presently to Hell * * Quod eo consilio invectum ut terrore mortis credulos in obsequium trahant . D. An. Sall. Votum pro Pace . with an Anathema in their Ear , crying out against them , Go ye Cursed : Yea , very moderate she is in her Judgment of the final condition of any without good and sufficient grounds , because of the unsearchableness of the Divine Providence in his Government of the World , and of particular Men : Yet the Moderation of our Church is not of such a Latitude to hold , That every Man may be saved by the Law or Sect which he professeth , so that he be diligent to frame his life according to the Law and Light of Nature ; for Holy Scripture doth set out unto us only the Name of Jesus Christ , whereby Men must be saved* : 39. Articl. 18. Wherefore in giving account of the remission of such Punishments as are declared by the Divine Laws , Our Church doth not think fit any should be wiser than those Laws themselves , and the Divine Revelation . The Church of England ( said Arch-Bishop Laud ) is not such a shrew to her Children , as to deny her Blessing , or denounce an Anathema against them , if some peaceably dissent in some particulars remoter from the foundation † † Dissentio de minimis & de opinionibus non repugnat paci imperfectae quae est in viâ . D. Tho. 22. q. 29. a. 3. .

§ . 3. Neither is our Church so severe , as to judg of all * * Maximè cum sciat eos fac●re quae nesciunt , nostros autem negligere quae credunt . Salvian . de gub . Dei . Erroneous Persons according to all the Consequences of their Doctrines : Which we presume in many Cases are beyond the comprehension and knowledg of the Party so erring : Much less is our Church at any time busy to exulcerate the minds of any , by attributing to them such Consequences as their Assertions will not bear .

§ . 4. In refuting the Objections of an adverse Party , Our Church gives an excellent Example to her Sons to abstain from odious Names . Most wholsome to this purpose was the Injunction of Queen Elizabeth ; That the Knot of all Christian Inj. §. 50. 1559. Society ( which is Charity ) be not loosed , the Queen's Majesty straightly commandeth all her Subjects to forbear all vain Contentions and Disputations in Matters of Religion , and not to use , in despite or rebuke of any Persons , these convitious words , Papist or Heretic , Schismatic or Sacramentary . So King James said , He would not have Pulpits made Pasquils * * Confer . at Hamp . Court . ; and in his † † Aug. 4. 1623. Letter to the Arch-Bishop , requires , That no Preacher , of any denomination whatsoever , presume to fall into indecent railings against the Persons of Papists or Puritans . So in our Subscription for University Preachers , we promise , We will preach without odious invectives , and indiscreet discourses by name , or plain Circumstances ; we will not defame any Man .

Much to this purpose is set forth in our Homilies , * * Homily against Contention . That by being soft , meek , and gentle in answering , we may overcome our Adversary with gentleness ; especially in Matters of Religion and God's Word , which should be used with all modesty , soberness , and chastity : For it is better to give place meekly , than to win the Victory with breach of Charity : Of such an Apostolical Spirit is our Church ! * * ●ius & simplex affectus , interdum tolerandu● est , etiamsi cum aliquo conjunctus est Errore . Erasm . de amab . Eccl. Concor . So S. Austin call'd the Pelagians , and Optatus of Milevis , his Contempory , call'd the Donatists Brethren : and before them S. Cyprian wisheth and persuadeth that none of the Brethren might perish : So our Church calls , and treats the Dissenters as Brethren . In confuting Opinions , Our Church always spares the Persons , how severe soever she is upon the Error : because in the Divisions of hearts that are in the World , it is certain some good may dissent * * Duct . Dub. l. 3. c. 4. . So moderate also and just is our Church , she is far from deterring others from her Communion , by branding any with the note of Heresy , unless upon just reason and cause : distinguishing also between a Heretic , and those who are by Heretics seduced * * ( Quidam Schismatum Duces ) caeteri tamen vel simplicitate capti , vel errore inducti , vel aliquâ fallentis astutiae calliditate decepti , à fallaciae laqueis vos solvite . S. Cypr. de unit . Eccl. . Yea , where there might be just cause , Our Church rather chuseth to imitate St. Paul 's demeanour at Athens , where finding the City full of Idols , or wholly given to Idolatry ; He doth not fall foul upon Bishop Sanderson's Preface to his Serm. §. 16. them , nor exclaim against them in any reproachful manner ; no nor so much as call them Idolaters , though they were such , and that in a very high degree ; but tempering his speech with lenity and condescention , he telleth them only of their Superstition ; and that in the calmest manner , ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) [ ye are somewhat Act. 17. 23 too superstitious , ] ( the comparative degree in such kind of speaking being usually taken for a diminuent term . )

§ . 5. In reference to Peace and Charity , ( which is the excellent Bond of Ecclesiastical Society ) the Moderation of the Church appears from its most earnest and frequent Precepts , and Desires , and Declarations for Peace : It being that quiet condition of Being , in which any thing may exercise its proper and suitable Actions , in order to its good and perfection : Wherefore because the proper Actions of the Church regularly tend to the perfection of Truth and Goodness : and these most obtain , when Peace bestows upon them Ornament , Strength , and Blessing ; Therefore our Church hath done so much to procure , to keep , to restore this Peace every where , especially among the Churches * * See the Questions in the Ordination of Bishops , Priests , and Deacons . K Edw. 6. and Q. Eliz. Injunc . §. 21. Homily of Charity . Hom. against Contention . .

§ . 6. The Moderation of our Church gives it a singular advantage to convince Dissenters upon right and proper Principles : in defect of which , in disputation with the Romanists , Bishop Sanderson and others have observed , many have disserved their Cause , either mistaking the Question , or mingling some of their own false Principles with their Argument ; either over-shooting , or coming short of the Mark : Wherefore those of our Separatists are very injurious to the Protestant Cause , who take so much pains to elevate and depreciate the Labours of our Conformable Clergy , which so sensibly have prest the Romanists , because they have manag'd those Controversies upon the only right Principles : Which requires greater variety and depth of true Learning , than seems to be well consisting with the Principles of a rigid Separation .

§ . 7. Because of the excellent Moderation of our Church , it hath bin judged by the most Learned , and the most equal Judges of things , so well pitcht in Her Principles , and of so rare a temper in her Constitution , that it is rightly resolved to be the best and most proper for * * Accepi perniciosam esse in omni arte vel Doctrinâ assertionem audacem & extremam . Gerson . de vitâ Sp. Arbitrating and reconciling the present Differences of Christendom . Wholsom indeed was the Advice which King James gave his Divines which were to be at Dort :

In case of main opposition between any over-much addicted to their own Opinions , your endeavours shall be , that certain Propositions be moderately laid down , which may tend for the mitigation of heat on both sides . The same is already performed in our Constitution for a general Accommodation of Controversy : Neither will any , I hope , have the worse Opinion of our Church , because Grotius thought the Church of England , a right Medium of * * V. Bp. Bramhalls Vind. p. 23. Reconciliation : Whose Pacificatory Design Mr. Baxter took to be one of the most blessed noble Works that any Man Ib. p. 22. can be imploied in . And certainly Peace without the loss of Truth , is a most valuable acquist : Yet Mens fingers do Vià Media . Bp. Halls Remains . p. 387. so itch after the maintenance of their Opinions , that they can hardly contain themselves from flying upon the fairest Moderation of any Vmpire . Wherefore no wonder if the Church of England hath the fortune of other wise and good Arbitrators , not to please both Parties ; † † Hic accidit , quod usu veniri solet iis qui contrarias Opiniones student reconciliare : ut utrique in Mediâ Opinione oppugnandâ vires suas consocient , ipsi interim in opinione suâ multò quàm antè obfirmatiores . In Hist. Concil. Trid. l. 3. p. 239. Therefore our Church hath this left her , ( as such have ) to be satisfied in her own integrity . But however in this Matter Our Church cannot ( I conceive ) so properly be termed an Arbitrator or Umpire of the Differences of the Church ( how fitly soever she is qualified to be ) as she hath determined for her self , ( which she hath right to do ) according to the Word of God , and the practice of the Universal Church : Yet in this Our Church hath performed so much as might be made use of , in order to a due Reconciliation .

For suppose a Kingdom or State well setled , ( as was the Primitive Church by Christ ) and there happens a Rebellion or Division , the means of Reconciliation are the Laws ; to attempt a Reconciliation further , is in no hand of right but theirs who have Power of the Law : Any design further is but a Speculation ; and so in the Church to speak of Reconciliation , otherwise than upon the foundation of its establishment , is neither safe nor obtainable . What is removed from the foundation , is the proper Matter of Charity and mutual forbearance : But as the different Judgments and Interests of the divided World are now , a Reconciliation is thought impossible , and generally impracticable ; but because the very speculation of Peace is delightful , we make in the Idea this Supposition .

§ . 8. Admit ( which is a case possible ) some few Families of well-bred , and better disposed Persons , but of as different Persuasions in the Extreams as any are among us , were to settle together in some remote Island , and had a singular inclination to compass a Communion with each other , in what they might in Spiritual Matters : The means to bring this about , one would think , must be the same which all wise Persons would take to convince another of a different Persuasion ; namely , by moving upon such Principles as both agree in ; which being improv'd to the utmost they are capable of , must be between them the common foundation of a possibility of agreement : Suppose then upon this score a Romanist , and an extream Dissenter should yet agree in the most Fundamental Articles of Faith , ( contained in the received Creeds ) and in acknowledging the Holy Scriptures in their Original ; or admitting the Vulgar Version ( or the like ) ; and if they admit the four first General Councils so much the better : Upon this Stock an accommodation must be negotiated amongst them .

1. Neither pretending to be Dictators one to the other , ( for that will spoil all ) but to acquiesce as these Principles and their best Reasons shall govern them to a fair entercourse in common . For Union in Practice , 2. No unjust condition of Communion must be enjoyned on either hand : Nor any thing but what is very necessary and clear , ( as well as they can ) agreed on according to those first Rules . 3. Both must sincerely bear with one another , in what they appear to differ , and to forbear all occasions of giving mutual distast that may be . 4. Sufficient security must be mutually given against such Principles , the professing and pursuing of which necessarily destroys all Civil and Spiritual Communion : As for Instance , That Faith is not to be kept with those whom one part calls Hereticks : Or that right of Dominion one over the other is founded in Saint-ship , &c. 5. For accommodation in Peace-sake , if these and the like Principles and Doctrines be publickly and sufficiently renounced , then they must mutually take care , that the evil Consequence of either shall not be imputed to those particular Persons who do detest them and acknowledg them most impious .

This being the proper Foundation for Communion together in Doctrine , Sacraments , and Discipline ; the consequent business is to convince such as will admit of the Debate , That those Doctrines and Practices which are received , above and beside what are mutually agreed in ; do really contradict the clear Contents of the Scripture , or the Judgment of the Universal Church , and are not of safe influence on the Christian Religion : It may do well to be shewn by Instances of Fact ; and the light of concurrent Tradition , when the particular Innovations entred in , by what occasions and degrees , and the evil Consequences of them all : Which will more effectually be performed , if it can be demonstrated , That most of this is acknowledged by the many of the sincere amongst themselves , ( at quiet Intervals . ) And if they can , distinguish between what might be of Original good intent , or had at least a plausible pretence ; and what is of manifest corruption .

So much of all this as was proper and belonging to the Church of England to perform , that She may acquit her self from the Imputations of those who deny her Communion , let the whole Church of God judg how carefully , and how peaceably She hath done her part . But those of the Church of Rome , who have appeared desirous of Reconciliation , have done it either for civility of Conversation , or out of Design , or without leave of their Superiors : For , admit Protestants could open a Door to the Peace of Christendom , the Romanists * * Num verò spem aliquam ostendunt ( Pontificii ) Moderationis le●ationis & emendationis ? nihil profecto minùs , quin execrandum Anathema dicunt , &c. Chemn . ex . Cone . Trid. Sess. 7. Can. 13. set a Bolt on their side by their Doctrine of Infallibility , ( however they place it ) whereby they seem to think it unlawful to correct themselves of such Errors as most grievously divide the Church : Therefore ( as the case stands ) the Learned Thorndike † † Forbearance of Penalties . Ch. 8. p. 38. professeth himself freely , to be without any manner of hope , that ever the See of Rome will abate any thing of their Rigour : tho the Reformation should content themselves with these terms : for I find , by the proceeding of former Times , that it is their Maxim , To stand to that which they have once done : And to mark those Popes to posterity that have abated any thing from the rigour of their Predecessors . For , being arrived at this greatness , by this rigour and obstinacy in all pretences , right or wrong , they will always think themselves obliged in reason of State , not to yeeld so much as the Cup in the Eucharist : Not considering all this while that this rigour is the cause of Division .

The Remedy therefore must begin from those Parties which have given cause of the breach ; if they shall remit of their undue height and rigour , and be content with those moderate bounds , which God hath set them , both for Doctrine and Government , and yield themselves but capable of Error , there may be a possibility of Vnion and Peace : but while they persist to challeng an Infallibility of Judgment , and uncontroulableness of Practice , they do wilfully block up the way to all Reconciliation and Concord , and stand guilty of all that grievous Schism , under which the Church of God thus long and miserably suffers * * Bp. Halls Remains , p. 410. . † † Casaubon of Reformation , p. 147. But This is the grand Mystery of Jesuitism and Politic Popery at this day , to look upon all moderate Counsels as pernicious and destructive .

§ . 9. The design of Peace is generally applauded by all : and indeed it is so excellent an undertaking , it seems a great pity that any endeavours for it should at any time be blasted with suspicion , misconstruction , and ill success . And whereas some have Objected against us , that we are ready to chuse Pacisication with the Romish rather than with the Protestant Dissenter . We Answer , 1. in general , with respect to both : That true Christianity requires us to be Enemies to no one ; If any will be to us , and to Truth , the blame must lie at their Door who give the just cause . If any require plainly sinful conditions , indispensable to hold Communion with them , in such a case the Command holds good , Come out from among them , and be ye separate . The reason why , in Disputation , Reconciliation with the Romanists hath upon such terms mentioned , bin spoken of , is because ; They are they who have laid the Obstruction to all Union by their enormous Corruptions , and it lies upon them to remove the Obstruction ; and no wonder if they be called on so to do : And who will not consent to that ( however hopeless ) desire ; if they will lay aside their Corruptions , we may be all one Sheepfold under one Shephard , Christ Jesus ? Concerning such Projects of Reconciliation with the Church of Rome , which have been made long since by some of the most moderate of their own Communion , and some other Learned Men amongst Protestants : Of which Cassander's Consultation * * Ergo istipii & pacifici viri sunt omnes ficti & simulati . C. Bellarm. Tom. 2. l. 3. c. 19. , with Grotius's Annotations also thereon , are most common and famous : Of these this may safely be said , ( whether and to what degrees their Designs be approved or condemned , however ) they have given abundant Proofs , wherein the Church of Rome at present appears the more irreconcileable , the more she is opposite to all such terms of Reconciliation which they have discoursed . If some other Discourses have bin at any time made by any of our Communion , referring to such Reconciliation with some Romanists , they may be lookt upon only as such Suppositions as have bin among Learned Men generally discoursed , thereby the more clearly to show the unreasonableness of the Romish Rigours . But what-ever may be proposed as a meer Speculation ; the vanity of concluding upon any such Union as likely may appear from the Principles of the Church of Rome ; which are such , if we take away her Corruptions , we take away Popery it self . Yet it must be acknowledged , the Art of the Romanist , even in such seeming Concessions , is very notorious , to gain such Points for themselves , as may serve their present turns , and may make afterwarward for the confirmation of their own Rigours . But , ( whatsoever some few among them promise ) what should be consented to by them , is like an Agreement made by a Minor , which is void , as the Tutor and Governour shall please : for we know , not only what the nature of their Gifts are , but also how they receive and return Concessions and Indulgences : Wherefore such Proposals from any of our Communion are the more needless ; because the Principles of our Reformation are already so prudent and moderate .

As to some who have suspected an inclination in those of our Communion , to pacification rather with the Romanists than with them : We Answer ,

1. This is the nature of Aemulous Parties to be always thus jealous of any sorts of Communication with their Adversaries ; but so long as the Romanists and Sectaries have had the same kind of jealousy of the same sorts of Persons , it is but a good proof of the real Moderation of our Church , and of those of her Communion , in opposition to all undue extreams . Neither ought it to be interpreted Indifference , Neutrality and Lukewarmness , but impartial constancy to such Truth as is espoused for her own sake . Sometime that jealousy hath bin raised of design to make the indiscreet sort of Men among us , the more out of charity with our Church : Notwithstanding it will be made out , ( Ch. 17. §. 7. ) that those who conform to the Church of England , do not agree with the Papists so really as our Dissenters do . Our dissenting Brethren often forget what hath bin performed by our Church in opposition to the Romish Corruptions and Errors , and also for the sake of themselves : They forget how often their Jealousies have proved groundless and untrue : And it would do well , for the time to come , if the sincere among them would set down , in some place by it self , such jealousies of theirs ; and in the next Column ( over against ) would remark their own frequent mistakes . Such forget also , or seem never to have known , how our Reformation hath bin approved of by the best Protestants : And whereas they seem to pity the first Reformers , as Men but half so much enlightned as themselves , who look upon the Moderation of our Church , but proportionable to the first crepuscular and duskish Light of those Times ; in this Matter they speak like those who have received some Traditions at second-hand from Cartwright , but never compar'd his Writings with Arch-Bishop Whitgift : and as they do not seem to consider the full knowledg and consideration which our Reformers had of the Principles and Abuses of Popery : and the diligent eye they had also to such other Reformations , as before ours had their perfection ; so they do not consider that our present Establishment was constituted with respect to our Protestants of the greatest aversation from Rome .

It is much to be feared , that those that clamour most of us for pacification with the Romanists so little understand what they would have , that because the Romanists hold ( as Mr. Perkins sheweth ) Reformed Catholic . the same necessary Heads of Religion with us , they seem willing and contented we should renounce sundry Articles of our Creed , that we may be sure not to agree with them . And this is spoken upon good grounds , for many of our Protestant Dissenters , as they are called , do ( as it is too well known ) not by Consequence only , but in direct terms , deny many , ( I may say of these few ) first Fundamental Verities of Common Christianity ( as , 't is a sad thing to say it may be shewn at large ) ; and yet nevertheless , what kindness ! what friendship ! what Correspondence is practised and encouraged by them daily with these Friends ? who are less suspected or reviled , than the true and firm Protestants of the Church of England .

And whereas they commonly say , That the Church of England , and the chief of Her Communion , are unwilling to allow any Pacification with , or Concessions to Protestant Dissenters , as may be reasonable for public Concord . We Answer ;

1. They are utterly mistaken in saying so ; for beside that , the conditions of Communion with our Church are very equal and just . We may presume to say also , from what our Church hath done , and hath declared She is willing to do ; and from the disposition of Her Communion , there is no doubt but our Church would gladly ( in such things as she might ) remit of what she judgeth otherwise expedient ; for the ends of Peace and Universal Concord , if she could be assured any reasonable Concessions should have that effect , as might suit with the true Honour of God , and the real good of the Church .

Uniformity in Religious and Ecclesiastical Matters sure is so excellent and desirable a gain , that certainly an establishment somewhat less perfect ; with being of the same mind so far as we have attained , and with a regular and effectual observation of good Laws , is more expetible , than an appointment in some Circumstances more perfect , without the same uniform order and peace therewith : But how unequal is it , that they should be the only Arbiters and Judges of Union , who not only are great Authors of our Dissention , but are at such great disagreements among themselves , ( V. Ch. 18. § . 2. Rule 10. ) and are so imperious and tyrannical in their disobedience , as some of them are ?

CHAP. XV. Of the Moderation of the Church toward other Churches and Professions of Men.

§ . 1. In that Vniversal Concord which our Church hath maintained with all , so far as lawfully and usefully it may . § . 2. Her protesting against unsufferable Abuses , well consisting with her Moderation and Charity . § . 3. Our Church leaveth other Churches to the use of their liberty , and vindicateth that use mutually . § . 4. Her especial Moderation and Charity toward the Greek Church . § . 5. Our Church's Modesty and well-becoming Behaviour toward other Churches ; and their mutual affection unto Ours .

§ . 1. THe excellent temper of our Church is abundantly justified in that Universal Concord and Friendship it desires to maintain with all , so far as may be done lawfully . Our Church separates indeed as far as is possible , from all that is vile and impure , making her self ( as is the Church ) a Society distinct from Jews and Gentiles ; and by her Censures doth separate from those that are inordinate : and in her own defence keeps her self from complying with sinful and unjust conditions of Communion : Yet with the whole Church throughout the World , and every part thereof , ( to whom her Communion is not displeasing ) Our Church in desire and endeavour , doth maintain all inward and outward agreement she can * * Odia restringi , favores convenit ampliari . Reg. juris . ; in affections and behaviour also so approving her self , that it is manifest she unwillingly differs from any , and no more than needs must . Thus the 30 Canon of our Church ; Nay so far was it from the purpose of the Church of England , to forsake & reject the Church of Italy , France , Spain , Germany , or any such-like Churches in all things which they held and practised ; that as the Apologie of the Church of England confesseth , it doth with reverence retain those Ceremonies , which do neither endamage the Church of God , nor offend the minds of sober Men ; and only departed from them in those points wherein they were fallen , both from themselves in their Ancient Integrity , and from the Apostolical Churches , which were their first Founders .

Episcopal Divines ( saith Bishop Bramhall * * Vindication , p. 30. ) do not deny those to be true Churches where Salvation may be had .

§ . 2. Neither did our Church of England ever yet oppose it self to any lawful Ecclesiastical Authority , which yet is inseparably of the Essence of Schism ; but on the contrary , according to a singular Moderation * * Ecclesia Britannica , quâ est perpetuò in omnes Christianos singulari moderatione & Christianâ dilectiene , &c. De Antiq. lib. Eccl. Brit. Thes. 4. , and Charity , it doth open its Bosom to every genuine Son of the true Catholic Church , of what denomination soever . For it is one thing for any to frame to themselves a diverse Congregation and Religion , separate from , and opposite to the Universal Church , as anciently did the Donatists , and another thing not to communicate with some particular Persons and Places in some unwarrantable usages , and that under express protestation , ( from whence was occasion'd the moderate and innocent Title of Protestants † † V. Cluverium , & Calvisii Chron. ad An. 1529. ; for protesting against the Edict at Worms , which was for restoring all things as they were without Reformation . ) By which Protestation , all scandal of Schism is taken away , and desire of reconciliation is publicly testify'd , not as of absolute necessity , but for the sake of Catholic Unity : by which Protestation , a right is vindicated from the usurpation of the Church of Rome , who fondly calls her self , not only Catholic , but the Mother and Mistress of all other Churches , by which she makes her self a public invader of common Ecclesiastical Right .

§ . 3. In Matters of Ecclesiastical Freedom , The Church of England leaves always other Churches to their liberty , and vindicates their right to the same * * V. D Durell's View of the Reformed Churches . : As other Reformed Churches leave us to our liberty , and vindicate the same . ( Article 34. ) It is not necessary that Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one V. Homily of Fasting . or utterly like ; for at all times they have bin diverse , and may be changed according to the diversities of Countries , * * Distant inter se linguae , sed linguarum distantiae non sunt Schismata , omnes linguâ ad u●am fidem . S. Aug. in Joan. Times , and Manners . — Every particular National Church , hath Authority to ordain , change , and abolish Ceremonies or Rites † † Pref. of of the Church . the Cerem . In these our doings , we condemn no other Nations , nor prescribe any thing but to our own People only . According to the practice of S. Cyprian , ( clearing himself to the African Bishops ) Judging none , nor removing any from the right of Communion , if they think somewhat diverse from us . For which S. Austin * * Cujus charitas non sol●nt illius temporis Christianis sed etiam posteris ad medicinalem notitiam signatur . S. Aug. de bapt. l. 1. c. 18. commends S. Cyprian : And as Tully † † Ita dissensi ab illo ut in disjunctione sententiae , conjuncti tamen amicitiâ maneremus . Orat. pro provinc . Consul . spake of himself , with relation to Caesar ; I so dissented from him , that in the difference of our Opinion , however we remained entire in our Friendship .

Of this mind also was St. Austin , in matters of different Observances , as to Times of Fasting , and Days of Communicating ; All this ( saith he ) is matter of liberty ; and no practice is more worthy a grave and prudent Christian , than to act so as he sees the Church doth , unto which it happens he comes ; and as the Society doth in which he lives * * S. Aug. Ep. 118. & Ep. 86. : And in these Matters , of which the Holy Scripture appoints nothing expresly ; the Custom of the People of God , and the Institutes of our Superiors are to be held for a Law : Of which if we have a list to dispute , and to disprove others for their different Custom , there will arise endless Contests . M. Amyrald * * Galli — Anglorum c●tibu● libentissimè intersunt & Eucharistiam ex eorum more participant , & Episcopis sese subjiciunt . Angli pariter — &c. Amyraldi Irenicum , p. 351. well observes the friendly moderation of the English and French Protestants , when they are in each other Countries , they readily join themselves with the Communion of the Churches they are in .

Yet such is the abundant Moderation of our Church , That to Merchants and Strangers of other Churches , are permitmitted their several Congregations and Churches : And all Aliens of the Reformation have , by Act of Uniformity , an express provision made for their enjoyment of their own way of worship , at the pleasure of his Majesty : which is real proof that Conformity doth not prejudice Trade * * V. Mod. Pleas for Comprehen . answerd . p. 210. . ¶ ¶ Omnibus notum est quàm elementèr patiantur peregrinorum Ecclesias Ceremoniis & ritibus uti diversis ab Anglicanâ Ecclesiâ . Saravia . de div . grad. Min. c. 24. And this tender care of other Churches Liberty , which the Church of England with great Moderation doth profess , other reformed Churches generally return to us . Which the 30 Canon refers to , where it saith , This Resolution and Practice of our Church , namely , not to forsake and reject other Churches , ( only as they depart from the Apostolical Churches ) particularly with relation to the use of the Cross in Baptism , hath bin allowed and approved by the Censure on the Common-Prayer-Book in King Edw. 6. days , and by the Harmony of Confessions of later years . And it was King James his advice to his Divines , to hold a good correspendence with the Neighbour Reformed Churches : but , saith the King , * * V. in Apol. Ep. Lectori . Non est mihi ingenium in alienâ Rep. curiosum . I am resolved to leave other Churches to their liberty . And so also K. Charles I. † † His Majesty's third Paper to Mr. Henderson . As I am no Judg over the Reformed Churches , so neither do I censure them .

§ . 4. As a special note of our Churche's Moderation , we must not forbear to instance her excellent Behaviour and Charity toward the afflicted Greek Church ; to whom , as she hath opportunity , she hath testified a great commiseration , a most pious affection , and a great esteem : See the Homily against the peril of Idolatry , wherein our Church doth frequently deplore the thraldom of the noble Empire of Greece to the Turk . I must needs profess ( said Arch-Bishop Laud ) * * § 9. p. 26. ] Vt videant hi qui facilè de haeresi pronuntiant , quàm facilè etiam ipsi errent ; & intelligant , non esse tam leviter de haeresi pronuntiandum . Alph. à Castro . Contr. Haer. l. 3. f. 93. that I wish heartily , as well as others , that those distressed Men , had bin more moderately dealt with , ( tho they think diversly from us ) than they have bin by the Church of Rome . C. Bellarmine having delivered that three of their Councils have declared her guilty of Heresy . Let the Church of Rome answer for her self if she can , for her trampling upon the poor Greek Church , as she lies in the Dust ; and branding her with Heresy for her Doctrine of Procession , as cruelly as her Turkish Masters burn their half Moons on the Bodies of those whom they enslave : But our Church is not so uncharitable as to define it a Heresy for any to maintain , That the Holy Ghost proceeds from the Father by the Son , tho we maintain as great a Truth , that the Holy Ghost proceeds from the Father and the Son ; but this makes no breach of Communion among us , the difference only arising from inadequation of Languages , which notwithstanding we agree in the main of this Article * * Animadversions on Naked Truth . p. 7. . Such lastly is the moderation of our Church toward the Greek Church , that some of the Greek Bishops and Priests , are allowed among us the celebrating Holy Mysteries according to their own Rites * * In unâ fide nihil officit Sanctae Ecclesiae Consuetudo diversa . Greg. 1. Ep. 41. .

§ . 5. Other Churches have not bin by the Church of England despised , if in sundry Instances they have not arrived unto her perfection in purity of Doctrine , and order of Discipline . With other Churches she doth not contend for Title , or understanding of Mysteries ; nor boasts of the Spirit : nor calls her self ( in distinction from other true Churches ) the Catholic Church ( as of old the Arians did ) . Lastly , The Guides of our Church never challenged to themselves Infallibility .

Altho our Church of England hath had the peculiar happiness of a Monarchical Reformation , and retains the blessing of Episcopal Government , yet such is the Moderation of our Church , she imputes the want of the same , in other Reformed Churches , not so much to any fault of those Churches themselves , but rather attributes it to the Injury of the Times * * Non culpâ vestrâ abesse Episcopatum sed injuria temporum . Ep. Winton . Ep. 3. Molinaeo . Eos coegerit dura necessitas . Saravia . .

Our Church also thankfully commemorates those Acknowledgments which the Reformed Churches have frequently made of our Moderation and happy Constitution .

And altho we remember , when it was commonly objected to us , That the Pastors of the Reformed Churches abroad , took our Conformity to be a Sin : Sure , the useful labour of D. Jo. Durell , hath for ever silenced that vain reproach : Who to the whole World , in plain and open Testimonies hath now long since * * 1662. illustrated the Conformity of the Reformed Churches abroad , to our Church of England : In matters of Ceremony ; subordination of Pastors ; use of set Forms and Liturgie , Holy-Days , set Times of Fasting , magnificent Churches , Organs , Surplice , Church-Ornaments , Cross in Baptism , receiving the Communion kneeling , &c.

Who hath also proved by Testimonies , the practice of those of the Reformed Churches joining with us , in our Publick Worship , by the advice of their Pastors ; either when they come over into England , or in such of our Congregations as are in their Countries .

If it happens that any Member of the Reformed Churches speak against the Reformed Church of England , he is censured for it by their Synod .

The Ministers of the Reformed Churches abroad , blame those that refuse to Conform to the Church of England , when occasion is offered , and hold them for Schismatics , and are scandalized at them .

Those few Reformed Churches which want Subordination of Ministers , approve the Episcopacy of the Church of England * * Certu● est mihi 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Anglicanam , item morem imponendi adolescentibus in memoriam Baptismi , a●toritatem Episcoporum , Presbyteria ex soles Pastoribus comp●si●a , mul●àque alia ejusmodi satis congruere institutis ve●ust●oris Ecclesiae ; à quibus in Gallià & Belgio recessum negare non possumus . Grotius . E● . ad Bo●t . ; and wish they had the same , and would esteem it a singular felicity .

All which sheweth the amity and good correspondence and concord that is between our Church of England , and other Protestant Churches : and also justifies exceedingly the excellent Moderation of our Church .

Indeed our Church of England deserves better the name of Catholic , both for her Catholic Charity , and especially for that she maintains her Communion upon the Foundations and Principles of Christian Religion , both with the Western and Eastern Churches ; whom the Church of Rome excommunicates from the society of the Mystical Body of Christ , limiting the Church to Rome , and such places as depend upon it . As the Donatists did of old to Afric : — separating her self also from the Communion of the Churches of Graecia , Russia , Armenia , and all the Protestant Churches — Much greater is her Schism , for refusing to be a fellow-Member with other Churches , in the Vniversal Church of Christ ; and challenging to be the Head , the Root , the Fountain of all other Churches * * Bishop Bramhals Works , p. 990. . ¶ ¶ Necessity of Reformation , p. 145 : Yet because they still keep to the main Fundamentals , we do not exclude them from the Catholic Church , tho by their hard and rigid Censures , and Excommunication of us and others , that do not hold with them , they do very much hazard their right and title to the said Catholic Church , as much as by any thing .

CHAP. XVI . Of the Moderation of the Church of England in her Reformation .

§ . 1. The Reformation of our Church , as it had just grounds , and was by just Authority , so it was managed with due Moderation ; the Idea of our Reformation having bin impartial . § . 2. The whole manner of it ( so far as concerned our Church ) was with great temper . § . 3. She separated from the Romish Errors , not from their Persons any more than needs must . § . 4. Our Charity exceeds that of the Church of Rome , which denys Salvation to all who are not of her Communion . § . 5. The Preparation of our Church to submit to the Church Vniversal , saves us from Schism . § . 6. The Reformation of our Church was the more Christian , because not fierce , but well governed . § . 7. Albeit the Moderation of our Church seems to have enraged her Adversaries ; yet because of this Moderation , our Church is the better prepared to survive Persecution . § . 8. The Moderation of our Church in her Reformation , was founded on Rules of absolute Justice , as in sundry great Instances is made to appear .

§ . 1. THe moderate and orderly Reformation of the Church of England , Bishop Bramhall well calls the Terror and Eye-sore of Rome * * Answer to the Bp. of Chalcedon , p. 244. , because of 3 Conditions of a lawful Reformation well agreeing thereto ; viz. Just Grounds ; Sufficient Authority ; Due Moderation .

1. Just Grounds ; Under which head I shall not take too large a compass to illustrate the Moderation of our Reformation , either from the manifold Usurpations and Corruptions of the Church of Rome at that time ; nor from the invidious task of looking into the extreme Rigors of any other Models of Reformation : Neither is it here necessary to reflect more particularly on Matters of Fact historically relating hereunto , which have bin copiously set forth by a multitude of Writers , both Ecclesiastical and Civil , which abundantly justify this Reformation both in its Causes and Proceedings , clearly manifesting how this Church was justified therein , from the unjust conditions of Communion , which the Church of Rome peremptorily insisted upon .

2. That it might have Just Authority , the said Reformation was manag'd by the Guides and Governors of the Church ; and was confirmed by Supream Authority , and so in every particular was as legal as any Reformation could or ought to be ; as doth sufficiently appear from Matter of Fact recounted in the Histories and Monuments thereof ; Wherein the Princes acted their parts , and the Clergie theirs ; they calling together the Bishops and others of the Clergie to consider of what might seem worthy Reformation ; and the Clergie did their part ; for being called together by Regal Power , they met in a National Synod of 62 , and the Articles were agreed on , and were afterward confirmed by Acts of State , and Royal Assent * * Arch-Bp Laud , §. 24. .

Any Reformation otherwise than Regular , is as much against the Principles of our Church as any one can wish ; and had the Doctrine of our Homilies bin well regarded , it might have prevented much mischief consequent on later Reformations : Lest any Persons , upon colour of destroying Images , make any stir or disturbance in the Common-Wealth , it must always be remembred , that the redress of such public Enormities pertaineth to the Magistrates , and such as are in Authority , and not to private Persons .

In the Homilies against wilful Rebellion , is set forth at large the sufficient reason of our Church's Reformation , viz. the Intolerable Usurpations of the Bishop of Rome . To the same purpose * * Angli , necessitate dirâ cogente , secessionem fecerunt . Casaub . ad . C. Per. the Apologie of the Church of England , doth express it self more largely than need be repeated ; We did nothing rashly or insolently , for the sake of any worldly pleasure or advantage , but upon great advice and deliberation we shook off a Yoke which we had no obligation to endure † † Postermò ab illo decessimus cui obstrecti non eramus : ejusque jugum ac tyrannidem excussimus . Apol. Eccl. Angl. §. 150 , 159 , 160 , &c. . The Church of England did but behave her self as became a free Church , enjoying the Rights of a Patriarchal See ; according to the Rules of the Universal Church it reformed it self , when it had high need : For as King Henry the 8th said , in his last Letter to the Pope , Better is it in the middle way to return , than always to run forth head-long and do ill .

3. The Due Moderation of our Reformation will appear , if we consider ; 1. The Idea or Form of our Reformatation , was neither taken from Luther nor Calvin ( as the Romanists love to speak of us * * Impia mysteria & instituta ad Cal●ini praescriptum . Bulla Pii 5. contra R. Elizab. Calvinicas aliquot deprecationes substituit . De Schism . Angl. p. 165. In illis Angliae legi●us , quae alios actus Sacrilegos ut Participationem Calvinianae coenae , & similes Communicationes in eorum ritibus praecipiunt . — Suraii . Def. l. 6. c. 11. ) nor from any other , but from the Holy Scriptures , according to the use of the Primitive Church ; which were only its measures ; according to which our Church practis'd the part of the Elective Philosopher , and chose what she thought most agreeable : among the rest she seemeth to come nearest the Augustan Confession and the Consultation of Herman Arch-Bishop of Colon ; which was also set forth in English , 1548.

Among others that have reformed their Churches , I have often ( saith Saravia ) admired the wisdom of those who restored the true Worship of God to the Church of England , who so temper'd themselves , that they cannot be reproved for having departed from the Ancient and Primitive Custom of the Church of God , and that Moderation they have used , that by their Example they have invited others to reform , and deterred none * * Sarav . Desins . Praef. .

* * Ea omnia sublata sunt quae nimium onerosa & operosa sunt . Lud Capel . inter Thes. Salmur . 6. Between those who were loth to bid adieu to their Ceremonies , and others whose Reformation had no bounds , our Godly Reformers compiled the excellent Model of our Liturgie in so moderate and well-temper'd a Mode , as neither part had Alliance of D. off . c. 1. just cause to think themselves agrieved † .

So that the Church of England appears faithfully to have practised the same counsel which P. Gregory the Great gave unto Austin the Monk , when he was sent over into England . From all Churches , chuse whatsoever things are Pious and Religious , whatsoever things are Right ; and being gathered into one bundle , commend them to the Minds of the English for their use ¶ ¶ B. Greg. Epistol. ex registro . l. 12. indic. 7. .

For having laid their Ground , that Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to Salvation , ( Artic. 6. ) They do upon that * * Huic Basi Reformationem Britannicam niti voluerit ; ut Scripturis primae , deinde primorum soeculorum Episcopis , Mart●ribus , Scriptoribus Ecclesiasti●is secundae deferrentur . Dissert. cont . Blondel . c. 14. § 13. Basis establish the Doctrine of the three Creeds : † † V. Hist. of Reform . l. 3. p. 218. Twisden . Hist. Vind. c. 9. and that the Romish Doctrine of Purgatory , Pardons , worshipping and adoration of Relics , Invocation of Saints , &c. is not warranted by Scripture . ( Artic. 22. ) and then proceed to settle such other things as are of positive right , with so just a Moderation , as is hardly elsewhere to be found ; changing nothing for the general , but where the practice of their own Ancestors did justify their doings , without at all extending themselves to any thing where they had not Antiquity their Warrant * * Quod si ▪ me conjectura non fallit , totius reformationis pars integerrima est in Angliâ , ubi cum studio veritatis viget studium antiquitatis . If Casaub . Ep ad Salmas . — Anglicanam intelligo omnium reformatorum reformatissimam . Forbes . Consid. Mod●st . Pref.

Can we chuse ( saith Bishop Hall ) but observe the blessing of Monarchical Reformation amongst us , beyond that popular and tumultuous reformation amongst our Neighbours ? Our's a Counsel , their 's an Vproar : Our's beginning from the Head , their 's from the Feet : Ours proceeding in due Order , theirs with Confusion : Ours countenancing and encouraging the converted Governors of the Church , theirs extremely over-awed with averse Power , or totally over-born with foul Sacrilege : in a word , Ours yeelding what the true and happy condition of a Church required , theirs hand-over-head taking what they could get for the present † † Of Episcopacy . §. 5. p. 21. .

§ . 2. The manner of our Reformation was such , as might reasonably both justify our Church , and leave the Church of Rome most inexcusable in the judgment of the whole Catholic Church of Christ ; our Church condemning those she left no more than needs must : And ( as Dr. More saith ) courting the Adverse Party to all lawful accommodations , if by any means she may gain some .

Attempering her self to the occasion of the time * * Homily for Rogation W. 3. part . , ( as our Church's Phrase is in her Homily . )

† † V. Cromwell's Letter to the Bishop of Landaff , directing him how to proceed in the Reformation . Collect. of Records . Hist. of Ref. l. 3. p. 183. From whence was manifest our Church's freedom from Prejudice and Passion , and the humour of Innovation , or the Spirit of Contradiction ; our Church not dividing but upon necessity , and then using all lawful and good means to procure such an agreement only , as might consist with the good Consciences of her People : Wherefore that the Breach might seem no greater than indeed it is , and that all probable pretences of Offence ( as they call it ) might be taken away , was omitted that Suffrage in the Litany , From the tyranny of the Bishop of Rome , and all his detestible Enormities , good Lord deliver us . Which Moderations in our Church , ( and in other Reformed Churches the like * * V. D. Durell's view of Ref. Ch. p. 180. ) have left the Romanists the more inexcusable in their dissent ; especially since , as Camden and others relate , in the beginning of Queen Elizabeth , for about ten years , ( for at least eighteen years saith the Lord Cook ) few of the Popish Recusants absented themselves from our Churches , till Pope Pius the 5th , by his Interdictory Bull , would have all Communion with us renounced : For as long as Schismaticks are not hardned into obstinacy , there is a prudential Latitude allowed by the Church , delaying her Censures as long as possibly she can , without wronging her Government , ( as was , de facto , practised in England till the tenth year of Queen Elizabeth † † Schism guarded . p. 396. ) . And admit that P. Paul . 4. in his private Letters to Q. Elizabeth , did offer to confirm our Liturgy , if she would acknowledg his Primacy , and the Reformation derived from him ; and that the same Proposal was confirmed by his Successor Pius 4. ( tho it had caused sundry ignorant and peevish complaints ) it ought to be no imputation to us , since our Reformation , blessed be God , is so good and justifiable : Insomuch that the Presbyterian Brethren acknowledged * * Grand Debate . p. 3. ; Our first Reformers , in great wisdom , did at that time so compose the Liturgie , as to win upon the Papists . What was reformed and composed in such great wisdom then , is the same still . The Inference therefore which may be made , is what Bishop Davenant resolved : The Papists are bound to be present at the English Divine Service , because nothing occurs therein that can be by themselves reproved . And if Papists , much more Protestants . And we rather suppose it the great Glory and excellent Commendation of our Reformation , that it is at once so compleat , and also so moderate ; considering how difficult a thing it is , especially in matter of Reforming , to pare off the Excess , and not to cut to the quick ; to stay at the right point and not over-do , because of the lyableness in such cases , in declining one extreame to fall into another † † 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . S. Basil . , which usually is the fault of the unwise , and the inconsiderate : For as the Matters in Religion , in which our utmost Zeal is required , are unquestionably evident to every Christian Man's notice , so the cases in which Moderation is to be exercised , are almost infinite , and often very intricate : Wherefore the use of this Vertue is so universal , that as the truest Fortitude is governed by Temperance , so where there is most Moderation , there is the truest Zeal ; and ( which is a better effect than usually is of suddain Calentures ) by Moderation the Mind is best prepared to find out and determine those Proportions and Measures which are to be observed for the right conduct of our selves and others , in our moral and religious Concerns : Such Operations suppose also a peculiar power and ability of the understanding , and a most excellent prudence : Wherefore the wise King said , A Man of Vnderstanding is of an excellent Spirit , Prov. 17. 27. where the Hebrew phrase is observed to signify also a cool Spirit or temper , that being the most excellent disposition to Wisdom . Thus in the Life of Pomponius Atticus , it was said of him , His Moderation gave him great security in troublesome Times , procured him Friends , kept him considerate and circumspect in all he did , that he never over-shot himself with folly , passion , and precipitancy in Words and Action . The like Vertue hath bin the great happiness of our Church of England , especially conspicuous in her first Reformation ; and thus according to an excellent Moderation our Church doth express it self . And for this ought we greatly to praise God , for that such superstitious and idolatrous Manners as were utterly nought , and defaced God's Glory , are utterly abolished , as they most justly deserved ; and yet those things that either God was honoured with , or his People edified by , are decently reteined , and in our Church comely practised * * Homily of Place and Time of Prayer , 2 Part. .

And certainly were that Spirit of Charity stirring among them ( the Romanists ) which ought to be , they would love and honour us for the resemblance of that ( Primitive ) Church , the beauty of which they so much admire † † Mr. Hales Sermon of Erring Christians . .

§ . 3. It is evident that our Church hath separated from their Errors , and not from their Persons * * Noli propter hominem diligere vitia , nec propter vitium odisse homines . S. Aug. Serm. de temp . , any more than needs must , ( such Errors , I mean , the belief of which the Church of Rome hath made necessary to Salvation ) : In consideration of which Mr. Hales ( in his Sermon of dealing with Erring Christians ) saith , He may not pass by that singular Moderation of this Church of ours , which she hath most christianly exprest toward her Adversaries of Rome , here at home in her Bosom , above all the Reformed Churches I have read of , ( and so forth at large ) . In which Communication , what if the Protestants call the Romanists sometimes Catholics , because they call themselves so ? ( for as it is in the answer to the Bishop of Condom , These Gentlemen do herein like Princes , who alwayes retain the Title to Countries which they have lost several Ages past ) since our Saviour call'd the Scribes and Pharisees Builders , upon the same Reason , when he saith , The Stone which the Builders refused . S. Matth. 21. 42.

§ . 4. Such is the Moderation of those of our Communion , we think not our selves oblig'd to deny a possibility of Salvation to such as are sincere , and otherwise good of the Church of Rome : Notwithstanding they are so uncharitable to deny Heaven to any of us who hold stedfast Communion with the Church of England ; for which we are accounted no others than damned Hereticks ; and therefore once a year , every Maunday Thursday , the Pope curseth all whom he hath denounced Heretics ; and that his Christianity therein may be the more known , the form by which we are Excommunicated , is known by the name of The Bull of the Supper of the Lord . Even so Justin Martyr tells us the Jews * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Dial. cum Tryph. used to curse in their Synagogues all Christians . Yea , the very from of the Bishop's Oath at their Consecration in the Romish Church — obligeth them expresly to persecute whom they account Heretics † † Haereticos , Schismaticos & rebelles eidem Domino nostro vel successoribus praedictis proposse persequar , &c. . Were there nothing else objected to Papists , but this one thing , their uncharitable proscribing , and excommunicating all Christians , in all parts of the World , who are not of their Communion ; and obliging all that adhere unto them to profess the same , I should think that one thing a just ground of separation , or forsaking of their Communion ¶ ¶ Casaubon's Necess. of Reformation p. 142. . Nevertheless at the same time we pray most solemnly for all that persecute and slander us , yea for all that have * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Just. Mart. Dial. cum Tryph. erred , and are deceived , that they may be led into the way of Truth . Yet such is the Moderation of our Church , she doth not in the Good Friday prayer join the Papists with Jews , Turks , Infidels , and Heretics : but prayeth for the whole Family for whom Christ died ; for all estates of God's Church every where ; and that we may be made one Fold under one Shepherd , Jesus Christ our Lord . And altho the Romanists say we cannot be saved , we Protestants say , they may ( for we know not the possibility of their Repentance , or the extents of the Mercies of God ) ; but from thence to argue that theirs is the safest Religion , is so slight an Argument ( drawn only from the greater want of Charity in them ) that I wonder so many of our Protestant Writers of great Name , do it so much honour to answer it : but only , that the slightest Arguments prevail most with those that use most slight Consideration .

§ . 5. That which saves us from all danger of Schism , is , We profess such a preparation of Mind , always to believe and do , whatever the true Catholic Church of God believes , and judgeth requisite to be done by Christian Men : As King James answered for the Church of England ; That she hath not departed from the Faith of the Ancient Church , which she honours and embraceth ; Neither hath she divided so much as from the Faith of the Roman Church , so far forth as that agrees with the Primitive Church . Thus the moderate and peaceable Bishop Hall * * Remains p. 309. Ep. to Mr. Struthers . professeth ; That since for order-sake we acknowledged the Primacy of the Western Church , We never departed one inch from the Roman , save where she is perfidiously gone from God and her self . And I doubt not but all sober Men of the Church of England will profess as Zanchy † † Zanch. Confess . Art. 89. did , ( like a true Reformed Catholic ) ; We have not divided from the Church of Rome simply in all things , but in those things only , in which it hath separated from the Apostolical Church ; and indeed from it self as it was ancient and pure : Neither have we departed with any other purpose , than if she will return amended to its Primitive Form , we also will return to her that we may have communion with her in her Assemblies : which that once it may be with all our hearts we beseech Christ Jesus .

I Hierom Zanchy , aged 70 years , with all my Family , have this testified to the whole Church of Christ to all Eternity .

For we left them as one should leave his Fathers House when it is infected , with a hearty desire to return again , so soon as it is cleansed ; which Charity is a great proof Schism guarded , fol. p. 399. of our Moderation* .

Unto which I add the Reverend Hooker's words † † Eccl. Pol. l. 3. §. 1. ; With Rome we do not communicate concerning sundry her gross and grievous abominations ; Yet touching those main parts of Christian Truths , wherein they constantly still persist , we gladly acknowledg them to be of the Family of Jesus Christ : And our hearty Prayer to Almighty God is , That being conjoyn'd so far forth with them , they may at length ( if it be his Will ) so yield and reform themselves , that no distraction remain in any thing , but that we may all with one heart and voice glorify God the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ , whose Church we are .

Hear we once more King James † † S●ow's Chron. p. 84. Anno 1603. ;

I could wish from my Heart it would please God to make me one of the Members of such a general Christian Vnion in Religion , as laying wilfulness aside on both hands , we might meet in the midst , which is the center and perfection of all things ; For if they of the Roman Church , would leave and be ashamed of such new and gross corruptions of theirs , as they themselves cannot maintain , nor deny to be worthy Reformation , I would , for my own part , be content to meet them in the mid-way , so that all Novelties might be renounced on either side . Which passage I find cited by Cressie's Answer to Dr. Pierce , adding thus , See the condescence of this great King . The want of such Moderation makes the Church of Rome so irreconcilable as it is . ( V. Ch. 13. §. 7. )

§ . 6. It was the Speech of a wise Bishop , concerning too suddain a Convert , I do not well like a Man , that tells me so presently , he hath changed a whole Religion at once : even so our Reformation was perfected by just degrees ; and being more moderate , 't is hoped it is the more durable . Dr. Hammond hath largely vindicated the honest policy of the Church of England , for compliance only so far as was innocent ; I cannot imagine ( saith he ) but Liturgie , Moderation and Charity may be able to bring in as fair a shole of Proselytes , to convert as many Papists to us , or at least confirm Protestants , as an Ordinance for sequestration of all their Goods , and Halter , and Directory will be able to do . I know what we justly call Moderation , there are some will stile a halting between God and Baal * * Altare Damas . P. 558. ; a Laodicean luke-warmness of Reformation , as hath bin ( they say ) matter of continual complaint to the Godly of this Nation * * Mr. Henderson to K. Ch. I. . Whereas certainly a fierceness and extremity in Reformation is as great reason of complaint ; for as Dr. Pierce hath it ; The Tepida quaedam temperatura . Parker de Pol. Eccl. l. 1. c. 25. way to convince a Papist , is to accuse them in measure of their Corruptions , ( a Puritanical opposition confirms a Papist , and makes him conclude he is Orthodox because he conquers ) . Thus Bishop Sanderson ¶ ¶ V. Pref. to his Sermons . observed , that some promote the Interest of Rome , and betray the Protestant Cause , by mistaking the Question . Wherefore let it be always remembred , that our Church hath admirably imitated our blessed Saviour's Reformation , which was a quiet , and peaceable , and orderly Reformation : He did not pull down before he had another frame of Order instituted : He did not destroy all before him , as some Reformers do , who love to run to the other extreme ; sundry Instances are often * * Dr. Ham. view of the Director . §. 43. given , that our Lord made no more alteration than was necessary ; neither was his Reformation wrought by force of Arms , with great noise and violence , but it was gentle and according to great ( 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ) Moderation , as became the Prince of Peace , and the great Law-giver of his Church .

Somewhat the like Apology was made at the beginning of the Reformation ; It was said , that as our Saviour did not reveal all things to his Disciples , till they were able to bear them ; and as the Apostles did not of a suddain abolish all the Rites of Judaism , but for some time to gain the Jews complyed with them , and went to the Temple and offered Sacrifices ; So the People were not to be driven in this change . The Clergie must be brought out of their Ignorance by degrees ; but to drive furiously , and to do all at once , might have spoiled the whole Design — Therefore these slow steps were thought the surer and better Method * * Hist. of Reform . l. 3. p. 219 . But soon after the excellent frame of our Constitution was made more perfect : considering which Doctor Cressy may be thought to owe a Penance for his Exomologesis , where he saith of the English Church — By the just judgment of God she had only power given her to destroy the Temple of God , but not so much as to lay one stone towards the raising up another in the place of it † † C. 55. §. ● . .

§ . 7. This Moderation of our Church hath made it the great envy of the Church of Rome , and the chiefest Object of its despite — But of all places ( said a wise Writer * * Europa Speculum . Quarto . p. 214 , 215. ) their Desires and Attempts to recover England have bin always , and still are the strongest ; which altho in their more sober Moods , sundry of them will acknowledg to have bin the only Nation , that took the right way of justifiable Reformation , in comparison of other who have run head-long rather to a tumultuous Innovation , ( so they conceive it ) ; whereas that alteration which hath bin in England , was brought in with peaceable and orderly proceeding , by general consent of the Realm representatively assembled in Parliament ; a great part of their own Clergie according and conforming themselves thereunto ; no Luther , no Calvin , the square of our Faith . The succession of Bishops , and vocation of Ministers continued , the Dignity and State of the Clergie preserved , the more ancient usages of the Church not cancelled : In sum , no humour of affecting Contrariety , but a charitable endeavour rather of Conformity with the Church of Rome , in whatsoever they might , not gain-saying to the express Law of God , which is the only way of meet Reformations , thereby the fitter to be an Vmpire to the rest . Of all places in the World , they desire most to recover this , making full account that the rest would soon follow .

But to as high a Tide as they are risen in their desires thereof , to as low an Ebb are they fallen in their Hopes , being less now , I perceive , than ever ; having seen her Majesty so often and miraculously preserved , their Treasons discovered , their Excommunications vanished , their Armies defeated , their Books answered , their chief Champions discouraged .

And we hope this Moderation of our Church may still , with God's wonderful Providence , preserve her * * Vis consilii expers mole ruit suâ . Vim temperatam Dii provehunt in majus . ; and it hath not bin thought improbable , that their immoderate asserting of the Authority of the Pope , and their Severities to such as differ from them , will some time or other awaken ( if not themselves , yet ) such an understanding in others as may prove a truer Mother of Devotion , than the Ignorance they cherish . Bishop Bramhall therefore had good reason to say of the Romanists ; They fear our Moderation more than the violent opposition of others ¶ ¶ Fol. p. 957. .

§ . 8. This Moderation being the great praise of our Reformation , I cannot but compare the effects of this Moderation in our Reformation by some of the Rules and Measures of Justice , which a right Moderation always supposeth : Which Justice also is considered as due to God and his Truth ; and hath appeared in the sincere endeavours of our Church for the advancing the true honour of Almighty God , the suppression of Superstition * * Pref. to Injunctions . , ( yet ) procuring of Reverence to God's Holy Mysteries and Sacraments † † Pref. to the Liturgy . : Avoiding diversities of Opinions , and establishing consent about true Religion ¶ ¶ Title of the Articles . . Preventing Factions and Schisms a a Act for Uniform . Preface . . How much Primitive simplicity , and most discernable intent at the Glory of God , and Edification of Men , and establishing Truth and Peace with all freedom from prejudice and passion , hath appeared throughout the whole frame of our Liturgy , Articles , and Homilies , and Constitutions , and Versions we have of Holy Scripture , any who are sincere themselves may easily acknowledg , if they will truly consider the same . For ( as our Homily of Holy Scripture saith ) Without a single Eye , pure Intent , and good Mind , nothing is allowed before God . And in the Homily of Prayer , earnest complaint is made of such as would deface the plain and simple Religion of Christ .

In pursuance of these sincere designs of Piety , Truth , Peace , and Order , the Moderation of our Church in her Reformation , will the more certainly appear founded in Justice . If we consider ;

1. Our Church hath not made Truth to submit to her Authority , but hath chearfully and sincerely submitted her self to Truth : She hath not had a weight and a weight , to buy the Truth by one , and to sell it by another ; but hath judged of all Truth , and the degrees of its necessity , by the Standard which God hath given his Church , namely , the Holy Scriptures , the only Rule of her Faith : So in rejection of Error , our Church hath bin impartial to either extreme .

2. Our Church holds no such Doctrines as necessarily or by consequence overthrow a good Life , and the practice of Devotion : For this we must say for the Constitution of our Church , The Vices among us are in no wise the Consequences of our Doctrines : Neither have we any such Moderation among us , to reconcile the pleasures and profits of Sin , with the hope of happiness hereafter , subjecting the most divine things , to most vile purposes ; which tends to make the World believe , that Christian Religion is a cheat , and its Priests the most vile Imposters of any . Whatever the scandalous opinions and practices of the Adversaries of our Church have done , to the great hindrance of the conversion of many , and the injury of Christianity ; Our Church of England gives no offence to Jew or Greek , Mahumetan or Heathen .

3. Our Church hath not squared the frame of its Ecclesiastical Policy , by the ends of Secular Grandure , or external Pomp , as if she could put off Christianity to put on worldly Glory : and as if we believed in such a Messias as the Jews expected , rather than in the crucified Jesus , whose Kingdom is not of this World . And here , rather than stay the Reader too long , I commit to his reflection , how the peculiar Doctrines of the Roman Church , tend to the encrease of their Power , or their Patrimony , * * Non est amplius Ecclesia , sed Respublica quaedam humana , sub Papa Monarchiâ temporali . Spalatensis in . profect . Consil . rather than that Interest of the Christian Religion , which the whole constitution of our Church is framed first to regard .

Here might properly be considered , the intolerable Charge which the Moderation of our Church justly saves us , in that expence which unjustly follows Popery . The one Doctrine of Purgatory , will cost any one very dear upon the belief of it . How many Indulgences , Masses , Jubilees , &c. must be paid for ? ¶ ¶ V. Fullers Eccl. hist. ad an . H. 8. 27. V. Romish Horse-leach . V. Brutum fulmen . Tanti videlicet nobis constitit âmicitia urbis Romae . Apol. Eccl. Angl. § 160.

4. Our Church by its Moderation , hath been far from driving on any corrupt designs . Whereas the Moderation of the Romish Church , hath been always noted very artificial . Whence they have moderate explications for the doubtful Indulgences , for the soft Austerities , for the soure Legends , for the credulous Visions , for the Enthusiast , fair interpretations for what may seem harsh ; a mild sence for their turn , and a strict sense also to keep up the Authority of their Church ; fair and goodly Baits to entangle Proselytes , but when they are engaged , they may find themselves caught with a bearded Hook . Even such sometime is the seeming Moderation and Self-denial which is cherished in our Sectaries , by those who actuate them : that so they may more effectually divide , and propagate such Division . Whereas , those who are truly principled , according to the Moderation of our Church , are made to be more constant and consistent to themselves , and to Truth ; not to turn to one hand of Popery , nor to the other hand of Enthusiasm , in any sinful compliance ; which rather than admit ( if the case requires ) they can suffer Martyrdom , as did sundry of the first Compilers of our Common-prayer-book , and many since ( even in the late times ) , and all kinds of Sufferings beside .

5. The Moderation also of our Church in its Reformation thus founded in Justice , hath caused her to avoid such Corruptions , as render the Sincerity of others very doubtful . We have not by Arts and devised Subtilties , gone about to palliate , nor by Power and Authority to uphold any Errors whatsoever ; nor promoted Ecclesiastical Policy , by gratifying the corrupt inclinations of Men : Neither the Doctrines nor Policy of our Church are kept up by pious or impious Frauds , equivocations of Oaths , false Miracles , pretended Revelations , counterfeit Reliques , Forgeries and Expurgation of Books , devotional Ignorance , exquisite Arts of defaming our Adversaries , and sometime extream Cruelty : This Justice in which the Moderation of our Church is founded , makes those of our Church careful to take , and heedful to keep our Oaths and Vows , whereas among the Romanists easy dispensations dissolve those sacred Bands of Society . What think we ( saith our Homily of good works ) ¶ ¶ ●2 Part. of those that vow Chastity , and yet ( as is very moderately expressed ) how their Vows are kept , it is more honest to pass over in silence . They vow Poverty , and yet their Possessions and Riches are equal to those of Princes ; under pretence of Obedience to their Fathers in Religion , by their Rules and Canons they are made free from the Obedience of their natural Father and Mother .

According to the same principle of Justice governing our Church , the forms and practices of our Church do not contradict our general Rules of Faith ; because we believe in the Holy Trinity , therefore we do not worship Saints and Angels ; because we believe the Holy Catholic Church , therefore we believe not in the Church of Rome .

6. The same Moderation of the Church founded in Justice , hath governed her Reformation in using or rejecting things indifferent which have bin abused . The Wisdom and Moderation of our Church , having bin far from judging that things which have been abused to ill purposes can never be lawfully or profitably used ; which principle might lay waste all Ecclesiastical or Civil Societies , of any good Orders and Appointments ; for there is nothing so good , but either hath bin , or is capable to be abused ( very grosly . ) Wherefore our Church , doth well distinguish between what is abused by the fault of ill Men ; * * Si quid vitil access●t vitium tellatur , r●s verò restituat●r , & concordia ●latur . Wicelii Meth. Concord . c. 5. and what in the nature of the thing it self , tends to promote such an abuse , as is evident from the Preface to the Liturgy concerning Ceremonies . Wherein our Church gives account why some Ceremonies were put away , namely because , so far abused by the Superstition of some , and Avarice of others ; others were retained which ( our Church judged ) were not like in time to come to be abused as the others have bin . † † Preface concerning Ceremonies . And as our 30 Canon hath it : The abuse of a thing , doth not take away the lawful use of it : Wherefore the design of our Church in its excellent Reformation , was sincerely to remove , what did in its own nature tend to corruption , and to retain what might be useful , when corrected and reformed from the abuse . Thus Zanchy did lay down , The true way of reforming , was not to root out every thing that was found in the Church of Rome , but to reject what was fit to be rejected , and to preserve what was fit to be preserved .

7. The same Justice governing our Moderation , sheweth it self to the Church of Rome also , not denying what is true of Her ; that she professeth a true Faith in the form of Baptism , and the three Creeds which she receiveth , and professeth to own the Holy Scriptures , and to hold to the four first general Councils , and the ancient Fathers . Many things in Order and Government she hath very excellent , and likewise in some of their Devotions . But , how much she hath in her superfluous Additionals built upon good Foundations , Gold , Silver , Hay , Stubble , and the like , is no where better distinguished , than in what our Church of England hath rejected , and in what she hath retained ; and how far the peculiar Doctrines and Practices of the Roman Church do contradict the other part of what they retain in common with us , and tend to destroy the same , hath bin frequently also shewed , in such Writings , as are approved by our Church .

A signal instance of this Moderation of our Church of England is , * * V. Canon . 30. 1603. it never denied that a true Church might be found in the Romish Communion ( however corrupted and unsound ) which Moderation the learned Mede † † Mede . Ep. 77. hath noted peculiar to the Church of England ; namely , To maintain that the Roman Church , much more the Greek Church , erreth not in the Articles we account Fundamental , because explicitely they profess them , however in their Assumenta they implicitely and by consequent subvert them : for which ( as Bishop Bramhal saith ¶ ¶ Answer to Bishop of Chalc. p. 364. ) our Charity frees us from Schism : ( But a Church that holds the Foundation , may grosly and dangerously erre in their Exposition , which is the condition of the Church of Rome * * Arch-B . Laud against Fisher . p. 320. ) : Yet we do not declare , that we have any new Faith , or new Religion , but the same only necessarily and well reformed from those superfluous Additions and Luxuriances , which might have endangered our Religion , if they had not bin corrected , which was performed wisely in our Reformation , without destroying all root and branch ; namely , by reserving such things as are good , and only lopping off such excrescencies , as might , and ought to be spared : and in our censures of them , our Church doth wisely distinguish , between what was appointed of sincere intention at first , and what hath bin since of manifest corruption : neither are we altogether ignorant , when most of those innovations and corruptions were introduced , and ( generally ) by what degrees and occasions they encreased ( tho we may very well judg of errors and corruptions , albeit we could not fix the time of their creeping into the Church ) which to speak more particularly of , requires a very mature consideration . Yet notwithstanding , Casaubon had good reason to say , The denying the Church of Rome Necessity of Reformation . p. 145. the being of a Church , ( which some Protestants rashly and ignorantly , rigidly and uncharitably have done ) hath been a great hinderance of Reformation : and I verily believe the opinion most Papists are kept in , that the Religion of Protestants is a new Religion , is not of little force to make them averse from it to this day .

CHAP. XVII . Of the Moderation of our Church in avoiding all undue Compliances with Popery , and other sorts of Phanaticism among us .

§ . 1. Notwithstanding our Reformation is the most of any opposite to Popery , how it hath bin the craft of the Roman Agents , to raise of it such a suspicion of Popery , as hath bin artificially made a very unhappy Instrument of the Divisions which are from our Church . § . 2. How the great Labours of our Bishops , and our Clergie , remaining the most impregnable defence of the Reformation , hath stir'd up the more earnest opposition of the Church of Rome to our Church . § . 3. The vain and ungrateful jealousies of our Separatists and Enthusiasts , are the more unjust , because they have appeared really acted by that Interest , ( not in intention , but in event ) . § . 4. Therefore it is a most seasonable work at this time to cast open those Masquerades . § . 5. Some Moderate Cautions here inserted to prevent any unkind Mistakes . § . 6. Some Objection to such an undertaking here answered . § . 7. That our Separatists and Enthusiasts generally ( more or less ) do conspire ( in fact , albeit not in intent ) with the Romanists ; instanced as a Specimen , in twenty Particulars . § . 8. Particularly how the Quakers are one with the Papists ( how ignorantly soever ) in sundry Instances . § . 9. By what steps and degrees these Progresses commonly are made toward Popery by such as separate from Communion with our Church . § . 10. What hath bin said , confirmed by other rational Proofs . § . 11. Some further Reasons why the Clergie , and faithful Sons of our Church , cannot be thought thus concerned , in so much as an Eventual Conspiracy . § . 12. An easy Divination of the Consequences of these things , if a due sense of these Matters be rejected , when so fairly and often recommended to the common notice of all , with a sincere and affectionate close to such as this Address most doth concern .

§ . 1. NOtwithstanding our Church of England hath bin by the most wise and Learned Men , Foreign and Domestic , acknowledged the very excellent part of the Reformation ; yet how often hath she bin reproached with most unjust Censures of undue compliance with Popery ? It being one of the known Policies of the Romish Factors , to cause their Agents among our selves ( whom they use for the overthrow of our Church ) to cry out Popery , at the same time they most of all serve the Papal Interest themselves . Wherefore that the Romanists may use the Separatists with the more unperceivable disguise and success , to undermine our Constitution , these also have bin inspired to blast with the Name of Popery , what is rightly established in our Church . Hence is it , that the Writings and private Insinuations of Dissenters are full of this Charge , in a joint design to disgrace our Communion , and to exasperate other Protestants against us : Some of those Exceptors running to such an excess of Rigour , as to count Churches , Bells , God-fathers , Churching of Women , Burial-Service , the Gloria Patri , to come under the name of Popery : Altho by no Instance was it ever made to appear , That our Church agrees with the Romanist in any thing contrary to Scripture , and the practice of the Primitive Church : As she is truly also most remov'd from Fanaticism ; neither using nor encouraging any Enthusiastic way of Religion ; nor allowing any resisting of Authority under any Religious Pretences whatsoever . Any one may be convinced , that no formed Church in the Christian World is more truly Protestant than is the Church of England , nor any which ( all things compared ) less compromiseth with Rome . If they will but consider in our Articles , Liturgy , Canons , Constitutions , Practice , Oaths of Supremacy , &c. how firmly our Church preserves and enforceth the Reformation : Yea , the Canons of 1640 , did excellently take care for the suppressing the growth of Popery , ( Canon . 3. 6. ) and also of Socinianism , Canon 4. Which Seeds of Socinianism have bin scattered amongst our Sectaries , and have of late had great growth amongst them : Yet nevertheless if such Friends as they should slip into greater Heresy , so long as they are with them in the Schism , there is a special respect due to them , rather than to the close adherents of the Church of England ; who because they run not into the madness of their extremes , and are not outragious too in that madness , they are forward to clamour against our Church it self as Popish , and turn their own silly Surmises into powerful Calumnies . Neither do those who reproach our Constitution , sufficiently call to mind what hath bin done all along since the Reformation , by our Kings of England , and the great Councils of the Kingdom , and the Orders of the Church , and the Industry of our Bishops , for the suppression of the growth of Popery .

§ . 2. But as a sufficient Evidence that our Church ( according to its establishment ) doth in no sort favour Popery ; They must be very disingenuous and wanting to Truth , who will not readily acknowledg that the Labours of our Bishops , and our Conformable Clergy , remain the most impregnable defence of the Reformation .

For who , I pray , have more strenuously and constantly opposed the Innovations and immoderate Extravagancies of the Church of Rome than our Bishops , and the Learned Men in firm Communion with our Church , even since Queen Mary's days , ( when some were Martyrs and Confessors ) and whose Writings but theirs , who have held firm Communion with our Church , remain as the constant Bullwark of our Protestant Reformation ? Wherefore the Romanists keenest displeasure * * Immortale odium & nunquam sanabile vulnus Ardet adhuc Combos & Tentyra . Juven. Sat. 15. and jealousie hath bin always against the Church of England , because from Her they have always received as forcible repulses as any . As nothing doth more stir up the anger of a Zealous Enemy , than the equal behaviour of those they malign , and a moderate carriage doth sometime provoke their sharpest hatred : So certainly nothing hath more stir'd up the jealousy of the Romanists , than the excellent temper which is observed in our Churche's Constitution . 'T is for the sake of this poor Church alone ( said our most noble Lord Chancellor † ) that the March 6. 1678. State hath bin so much disturbed : It is her Truth and Peace , her Decency and Order , which they labour to undermine and pursue with so restless a malice : And since they do so , it will be necessary for us to distinguish between Popish and other Recusants ; between them that would destroy the whole Flock , and them that only wander from it .

As for those of our Separatists who have sometimes menaged Debates with the Romanists , the cunning Adversary commonly lets them alone : for how seldom do we see a Romanist write against or oppose a Nonconformist , and be in much earnest against him ? Not merely because he thinks such inconsiderable , but because these are doing their Work for them as fast as they can * * Hoc Ithacu● velit & Magno mercentur Atrida . ; Whereas those Contests which have bin menaged upon the Principles of our Church's Reformation , have given the Romanists greatest awe , and have always exercised their utmost strength .

§ . 3. Wherefore those of the Separation who have bin concerned in these Clamours and Surmises of our Church favouring Popery , have acted , therein as appears , first , very falsly , and then very imprudently , in reproaching so excellent a Reformation , and by joining , with them in their opposing our Church , they strengthen the hands of the Romanists whom they pretend to oppose , to the great scandal of the Christian Religion , and great mischief to the true Protestant Interest : Which caused Bishop Morton ( in his Epistle to the Nonconformists ) to tell them ( Beside their notorious Scandals given to the Church of God it self ) of their breaking the Hedg of Peace , and opening the Gap for the wild Bore out of the Romish Forest to enter in , and root out that goodly Vine which many Pauls ( industrious Bishops ) many Apollo's ( faithful Martyrs ) have planted and watered . Even as Josephus * notes the Divisions of the Jews laid † Prol. ad bel . Jud. them open to their overthrow . And by their several Divisions which they help to propagate among us , they join with the Romanists in endeavouring to overthrow and destroy our Constitution ; While they are crumbling into Factions , biting and devouring one another , a vigilant Adversary , who is intent upon his advantage and opportunities , may , when he spieth his time , over-master them with much more ease , and less resistance † † Bishop Sanderson's Preface to his Sermons . Ad rerum momenta cliens , seseque daturus Victori — . And the more unreasonable and vehement they are in their clamours , the more they help the Roman Engineer to confound and overturn . Therefore Arch-Bishop Whitgift ¶ ¶ Arch-Bp . Whitgift Answ. to the Admon . p. 55. See his Letter to Q. Eliz. Fuller's Hist. l. 9. , now above a hundred years since said , I am persuaded you and they do the Pope great good Service , and he would not miss you for any thing ; For what is his desire , but to have this Church of England ( which he hath cursed ) utterly defaced , and discredited , to have it by any means over-thrown , if not by Foreign Enemies , yet by Domestic Dissention ; And what apter Instruments could he have for that purpose than you , who under pretended Zeal , overthrow what others have built , under colour of Purity , seek to bring in Deformity , under clo●e of Equality , would usurp as great Tyranny and Lofty lordliness over your Parishes , as ever the Pope of Rome over the whole Church . Which also was the judgment of the University of Oxford , 1603. Verily these Men are like Sampson 's Foxes , they have their heads severed indeed , the one sort looking toward the Papacy , the other to the Presbytery ; but they are tied together by the Tails with Fire-brands between them , to the injury of the Church .

Who would ever have thought ( said Bishop Bancroft , 1588 , in a Sermon at St. Pauls ) that we should ever have lived to have heard any Protestants reprove our Religion : It must be confessed we have escaped the Lion's Mouth , but have fallen into a Den of Dragons ; our Enemies are those of our own house .

§ . 4. Wherefore according to a most sober Judgment , it may be thought a proper means to awaken such to see their Error , in the evil Consequences of their Separation , if some of the most earnest among them would please sincerely and faithfully to consider now , how oft they have bin made use of as meer Tools and Instruments to Purposes , the utmost reaches of which they did not know , but may now , if they will but reflect : And it might reasonably be hoped , that many would repent of their vain and scandalous Jealousies , and may for the time to come , refrain such false and foolish Accusations of our Church , if they please but impartially to consider , how many Sectaries among us , which seem with greatest Zeal , and least Knowledg , to run into the furthest extreme from Popery , have not only serv'd the Design of what they appear averse from , but indeed have still a very great sympathy with them in their Principles and Practices ; and do but charge us with what they are most guilty of in Fact themselves .

§ . 5. But before we enter upon this undertaking , to shew how those who are in separation from our Church do really conspire with the Romanists . To prevent any mistake , let it be remembred ;

First , That we do not deny that most of our Dissenters do openly demonstrate a very zealous and undoubted abhorrence of Popery ; their real purpose in which is not here questioned , but believed : * * Sunt alii qui etiamsi non spiritu Aegyptiaco & dolo moliuntur reditum ad Papismum , at incuriae & latae culpae reatum tamen incurrunt . Alt. Damasc . p. 558. For such is our Charity for those who are generally seduced ; we count it indeed the unhappiness of their Error , that many of them do entertain such Principles as are agreeing with Popery , but we do not charge upon them the knowledg of , or consent to the Consequences of their own Principles ; but conclude they are sown in their minds ( not by their own direct choice , so much as ) by the slight of Men , and cunning craftiness whereby they lie in wait to deceive .

2ly ; Among the diversities of Sects thus influenced , we acknowledg it most manifest , that some are more acted than others , by far : * * — hâc in re scilicet unâ multùm dissimiles : ad caetera penè gemellî . Horat. l. 1. Ep. 10. Nevertheless all that are in separation from our Church , in that their very division from us , do actually joyn with the Romanists , to strengthen their hands , and weaken the Interest of our established Reformation , ( more or less ) .

And I suppose it may be taken for granted , that generally they who raise most clamour against our Church as guilty of Popery , they most of all others will appear most actuated by the Roman interest .

3ly ; And since of late especially some of the worst Principles of Popery , have appeared among us most manifest , from such most notorious practices , as are the very proper Consequences of their generally approved Doctrines ; It may be judged most seasonable , even at this time , that all sincere Persons be awakened to see whither those Divisions naturally lead , in which so many have bin engaged ; whose interest they serve ; whom they join with , and are acted by , ( how ignorant soever they are thereof ) .

Especially since of late there hath bin so much discovery made , that the overthrow of the Church of England hath bin all along one of the principal aims of the Conspiracies of our Adversaries ; and that they have endeavoured to effect the same by what our Separatists call Liberty of Conscience , ( tho God preserve our Liberty and our Conscience from such Snares , so artificially laid by the Romanists : who have made most use of the Dissatisfactions and Oppositions of our Domestic Dissenters to compass their intended Designs ) . Thus Thuanus , tho of the Roman Communion , declares , in his History of the Gun-Powder Treason here in England ; * * Rejecto libello supplice pro Libertate Conscientiae oblato . The first design of their Conspiracy began , upon the Papists Petition for Liberty of Conscience being rejected .

§ . 6. But ( because many are huge concern'd to shift off the conviction of this great Truth ) if any say , — Oh , now is the time for Protestants to be united against the Common Adversary : and why is such a distinction kept up between Church-men and Separatists ? Very true ; why is there ? who hath made and continued the difference ?

Wherefore the proper means for consolidation of such an Union among all true Protestants among us , which is most earnestly desired by us , is for our Separatists to come off from such their Divisions as are still designed for the overthrow of our Church ; especially since the Presbyterian Brethren well observed , That a more firm union and consent of all Grand Debate . p. 3. 1661. such , as well in Worship as in Doctrine , would greatly strengthen the Protestant Interest against all those Dangers and Temptations which our Intestine Divisions and Animosities do expose us unto from the Common Adversary .

2. For them also to forsake such Principles and Behaviours as serve the Interest of the Roman Church ; and peaceably to return into Communion with our most moderate Church , which is ready to over-look what is past , if it may be secure of their Communion for the time to come : But never let it be thought that our Church will ever come into their Schism , or that we will go about to sail to Rome by a side-wind of Separation .

§ . 7. And now to prove the forementioned Proposition : That our Separatists ( I do not say , all alike , nor that any sort agree in all these Instances following , but ) more or less do conspire in Fact ( however not in intent ) with the Romanists ; One single proof of the whole might be sufficient , namely , from their separating and dividing from such a Church as ours is , ( which Division is the main Art , and Counsel , and Design of the Roman Engineer * * V●que facilius Catholici Sectarios opprimere possint , variis obductis causis & artibus alios ab aliis ut divellant occasiones captandae . Jo. Paul . Windeck de extirp . Haeres . Antidoto . ; ) and from their constant and common business , which is by Reproaches ( much alike ) to vilify and deprave our Church in all its Constitutions and Offices : and especially they jointly labour to vilify our Clergy , calling them Ministers of Satan , † † Clero Anglicano nihil putidius . Campianus Jesuita . and Baal's Priests , &c. Which beside that , it is a cursed , unjust , and ingrateful practice ; so a more acceptable Work our Separatists could never do for the Church of Rome .

2. As they serve the Romanists now by their Practices , so may they more hereafter by their Opinions ; for so many Points as they are off from our ¶ ¶ See the 8 & 9 , Parag. of this Chap. Church , so much the nearer are they coming to them , ( sundry ways ) as in opposite Errors the Causes may be commonly the same . Thus Arch-Bishop Laud * * Pref. of the Conference . against Fisher observed ; The Rigid Professors on either side have quite leaped over the Mean , and have bin rigid the other way , as Extremity it self — and is a very natural motion . For a Man is apt to think he can never run far enough from that which he once begins to hate . Of which sort the several Factions and Interests among us have bin continually like the Friars at the Council of Trent , who were always watchful and zealous to maintain their peculiar Doctrines : among which extremes , our Church ( if she might be listened to ) would reduce all to a due temper , upon surer and more reasonable Foundations , than the Bishops at that Council laboured to do .

3. As our Laws by one name call both sorts of Separatists , Recusants ; so our Romanists and Sectaries behave themselves much alike : The one have their private Masses , the other their Conventicles , both contrary to the Laws of our Kingdom and our Church : Both the Romanists and the Separatists join in requiring a License for the Exercise of their Religion in private Houses .

4. Both our Romanists and Sectaries by encreasing our Divisions , help with joint force to make a general Toleration necessary , which would give the Romanists the greatest advantage they can desire .

They both supplicate with equal earnestness to be tolerated , whereas the Principles of each lead them not to tolerate others .

5. Their pretences to all mildness and gentleness , are equally supple and assuring : but how mild they are when they are uppermost , odious experience testifies , so that Instances of their extreme Rigors , which are most known , need not be enumerated . We need not call on the Inquisition to testify to the Rigors of the Romanists , nor look into all the Severities of the Disciplinarians , who have bin known to inflict Censures for a suspicion of Covetousness , a superfluity in Raiment , for dancing at a Wedding , for using their Liberty in their Recreations ; and have kept others ( as well as themselves ) from the Sacrament of the Lord's Supper upon uncharitable Accounts . It hath bin observed , where the Discipline in Scotland was established , the People had a high Commission in every Parish , and groan'd under the Arbitrary Decrees of Ignorant Governors : If there arose a private Jar between the Parent and the Child , the Husband and the Wife , these Domestical Judges must know it . Formerly and lately among some , they have bin scarce allowed in Conscience to marry without the consent of the Teacher : or when they have , it hath bin matter of complaint .

6. It hath bin already observed at large , ( Chap. 13. §. 58. ) how both the Romanists and the Separatists agree in their groundless and unjust accusing the Government of Persecution : like the Donatists of old , who cried out Persecution , when they most of all had afflicted the Catholics .

The Romanists have their dire Anathema's and heavy Censures ; the Separatists their cruel Maranatha's ; and preach Damnation most of all against them that differ from them , especially if they be of the Church's side .

7. Nevertheless both sorts can very easily give out Indulgences to their own Parties . God sees no sin in his Children , say some Sectaries : Which is a greater Bribe to be of their Party , than any can be found in the Penitentiary Tax , for Sins as they are sold at Rome .

8. When the Papists and the Separatists have bin at a loss , that they cannot justify their Proceedings by the Laws of God or Man , then they meet in one common Sanctuary , whereby they are bold to sanctify the most extravagant Practices ; pretending Providence for their Warrant . Thus Pope Pius 5. in his Speech in the Consistory of Cardinals at Rome , after the murder of King Hen. 3. of France , sundry times , in one Oration , he magnifies the Exploit of that wretched Zealot , as brought about by the special Providence of God * * Non nisi Dei opt . Max. particulari Providentiâ & dispositione perpetratum . . The same impudence or ignorance others have used to defend such Practices as no Laws , Divine or Humane , could justify , sheltring them under the wide pretence of Providence ; which hath bin well call'd , † † Answer to Mr. Jenkins p. 16. Regiment politicum fundatur in extraordinarià Dei Providentiâ . Ibid. p. 15. A fine pliable Principle , it will lap about your finger like Barbary Gold .

9. The Romanists enlarge their Creed in sundry Articles , ( without belief of which there is no Salvation ) and very many Separatists deliver their peculiar Doctrines as absolutely necessary to a state of Salvation , ( tho among the divided Sects many of them are contrary one to another . )

They both often stuff their Prayers and their Chatechisms with Matters of doubtful Controversy ; and in maintaining the same , they are alike too dogmatical .

10. We need not here prove what is so well known , namely , the mean Opinion which the Romanists have of Holy Scriptures , supposing they receive their Authority from the Pope , yet receiving their own Traditions with equal affection and reverence . The Separatists , by casting off ( to another extreme ) the real Authority and Testimony of God's Church ( which hath bin all along the Keeper , the Witness , the Defender , the Interpreter of Holy Scriptures ) by degrees many of our Separatists have come to throw off the Holy Scriptures as a Rule of Faith and Manners . The Romanists they add their own Traditions to the Word of God ; and many Sectaries call their Teaching , and their Impulses , the Word of God , which often is quite contrary thereunto .

The Romanists set up the Pope for an Infallible Interpreter ; many of the Separatists account the Private Spirit an Infallible Interpreter . V. Ch. 4. §. 3.

11. The Romanists pretend that Miracles and extraordinary Gifts have not ceased , but are still necessary Signs of a true Church . It is also the very height of Enthusiam to hold as many of our Separatists do , That Immediate Revelations from God , and extraordinary Illapses from the Holy Spirit , are necessary and common among all the Faithful .

Which Pretences lying obvious to an easy Confidence , cannot easily be wrested from such as will hold them to their own destruction .

12. The Romanists assert an implicit Faith which is determinately resolved into the authority of their Leaders : Whether the like is ever required by the Leaders generally of Factions among us , I do not now enquire : But however that the same is granted by their Followers appears most evident ; For when many can give no reason for what they hold , they keep close to their Ring-leaders , and move and change with them generally ; and how much the Authority of the Persons they have in admiration , governs them , more than any sway of Argument , is daily experienced . And whereas a due regard on this side , the implicit Faith of the Romanists is due to Governors , V. Ch. 6. §. 9 , 10. toward such , how scrupulous , delicate , and wary are they , ( not to say disregardful ) ; but in following their Masters of Factions , how prone are they , and sequacious .

13. Both the Romanists and Sectaries ( to serve their turn upon occasion ) cast off the use of Reason , wherein God hath made it a Guide : Therefore they both reproach our Faith as a humane , probable , natural , fallible Faith ; the one because we will not receive Oral Tradition , and the like Uncertainties ; the other , because we do not think an immediate extraordinary testimony of the Spirit necessary to assure us of the certainty we have of our Faith , of the Truth of Holy Scriptures ; to afford us also our words in Prayer , and the assurance of our Salvation .

14. The Superstitions of the Papists are notorious , and also of our Sectaries ; and so many , they are not here to be numbred . If Superstition be going beyond all measure , their humour is to keep no Measure nor order , but to heap one superfluous thing upon another ; and then they think God is pleased , because they are : Many of them account it a sign of Grace , and the favour of God , and matter of greatest Conscience , not to hear or use Common Prayers , nor any decent Rite or Practice required by the Church .

The Romanists invoke Saints of uncertain Sanctity : Many of the Separatists call those of their own Party the only Saints , and judg them to have the right to judg the World , and in the mean time to rule it ; if they cannot do that , they must censure what is done by others .

15. The Romanists and our Enthusiasts are very much the same in their Pharisaical Humour , ( described at large , and reprehended by our Saviour , Mat. 23. 4. ) To name only , Their binding heavy Burdens and grievous to be born , and laying them on Mens shoulders . As the Romanists add twelve Articles to their Creed ; a wondrous number of Ceremonies to their seven Sacraments : Not to mention more of their loads of Injunctions ; their Festivals ; their Auricular Confession ; their Vows ; their Scourgings , and Fastings , and Penances which they lay upon the Poor ; when the Imposers do not touch them with one of their fingers , or with wetting the least of them , they can get themselves an easy Dispensation . Doth not the same Pharisaical Spirit possess many , who make the Peace of the World , and the Church , depend upon their peculiar Doctrines ? Who make all they can , think it a sin to come to Common-Prayer ; to kneel at the Sacrament ; to be Baptized according to Order of the Church ; to pray in a Form ; to wear a Surplice : Instead of making broad their Philacteries , and enlarging the Fringes of their Garments , they have had another sort of Superstition , in wearing their Hair in a precise cut , ( somewhat like the tonsures of the Romanists ) ; some will not wear a Riband : Others not Starch in their Bands , nor pull off their Hat .

16. The Council of Trent makes the Intention of the Priest necessary to the Sacraments : Many of the Separation make the Spiritual Grace of the Minister absolutely necessary for the Peoples receiving benefit from the same .

17. Both the Romanists and the Separatists use much the same kind of Arts to blast their Adversaries : The Romanists have their Legends and Fables ; just so our Separatists love to pick up Stories of Bishops and the Clergy , and to patch them together in enmity to our Church ; with these they keep up the humour of the People who entertain them with good things . I wish such would remember what in Levit. 19. 16. the command is , Thou shalt not go up and down a Tale-bearer among thy People : which the Ghaldee Paraphrase interprets , ( Non comedes Placentas in Populo tuo ) Thou shalt not go up and down among the People pacifying thy Appetite , eating of their Delicates , and to please them again , tell tales of Governors * * Apud Anglos est simile genus Hominum quoscirculatores Itali vocant , qui irrumpunt in Convivia , &c. Erasm . Eccles. l. 3. .

18. Most of our * * Ineptè nobis tribuis Catharorum nomen , cùm Cathari suos habuerint Episcopos , quos nos omnes sublatos ex omnibus Ecclesiis optamus . Altar . Damasc . p. 367. Separatists are highly against the Government in the Church by Bishops : and in the Covenant the same is ranked with Superstition , Heresy and Schism : Even so the Jesuits , who are the great Exalters of the Pope's Supremacy , declare commonly against Bishops , as if the source of all Disorders came from Bishops contending for their Jurisdiction ; which ( say they ) makes so many small Popes , ( thus the Jesuits argue † † V. C. Palavicini Hist. Conc. Trid. l. 1. c. 25. ) : Then it will follow that the Pope cannot dispose of things belonging to their Jurisdictions ; and then the Pope may be opposed by these Bishops , which may be a ready way to overthrow the Papacy . So that the Controversy , who hath the Jurisdiction which belongs to Bishops in common , nay , who have such Jurisdiction by Divine Right , is driven between the Court of Rome , who challeng it to the Pope , and other Consistories among us in Division from our Church .

Wherefore in opposition to Bishops , the highest Papalins talk most of the Sovereign Power of the People , because they hold the Interest of the Pope to be upheld by their veneration . And by the Interest of the Jesuits for many years of late , the Popish Faction in England have bin with-held from having any Titular Bishops . And most of our Separatists would be glad there were no other ; thus in their opposition to Bishops they agree .

19. Both the Romanists and Separatists extreamly agree in their Principles against the Civil Magistrate . According to that of Bishop Lany * * Serm. on 1 Thess. 4. 11. ; The Papists and Presbyterians hunt in couples against the King's Power and Supremacy . 'T is admirable to see how the Common-Wealths Men , in the times of the late Rebellion , received their Principles from the Ancient and Modern Writers of the Jesuits , and other Papists ; and still agree with them in most of the Republican Doctrines , and Tendencies of them to the like Practices . Both the Papists and the others infringe the Authority of the King in Ecclesiastical Matters within his own Dominions : Both deny the Right of Kings to call Synods and Ecclesiastical Convocations : Both hold that Kings may be put out of all Ecclesiastical Communion : Both deny the Supremacy of the King ; one attributes it to the Pope originally , the other to the People . And the same Arguments which the Pope useth for his Supremacy over Kings ; the Disciplinarians use for establishing their Soveraignty : the one exempts all the Clergy from the Jurisdiction of the Supreme Magistrate : and the other Disciplinarians in Scotland have now a long time endeavoured to have their Ministers exempted from the Punishments of the Civil Governour . The pretence of the King's Authority against his Person , was hatched under the Roman Territories , and was made use of in the Holy League of France * * Chr. Loyalty , l. 2. c. 1. V. Fowlis of Pop. Treason● &c. . The Rules for making a King become a Tyrant , and then ceasing to be a King , that it may be lawful to attempt any thing against his Person and Life , are so much the same that they cannot be more : if we compare Lessius , Suarez , Bellarmine , and many other Jesuits , and Mr. White of Obedience and Government , with Knox and Buchanan , and many other Republicans since ; wherein both sorts , as Rivals , seem to deal with the People , as some Gallants do by foolish Women , flatter them so long into a pride and conceit of themselves so great , that at length they become intolerable and ungovernable : Of this sort were the Discourses in the Council of Basil , related by Aeneas Sylvius , ( afterward Pope ) who could not contain from highly commending * * Quem Sermonem sic doctè , sie verificè , sic suaviter disputarit . Commentar. de gestis Concil. Bas . in Fascic . rer. expe● . fol 4. the Bishop of Burgen for his admirably vilifying the Power of Kings . Thus the worst of our Enthusiasts , and of the Romanists , agree in that Character of the Pharisees ; They mightily employed their Powers to oppose Kings † † Jos. Antiq. l 17. c. 3. . So true is the observation of King Charles the First , ¶ ¶ 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . §. 15. of some Protestants ; They seem to have learned , and to practise the worst Principles of the Papists . And of both , the Lord Bishop of Salisbury ; The Bigot and Jesuited Romanist , the frighted and transported Reformist , have bin Authors of the most horrible Treasons and Rebellions .

20. I need not here particularly relate how many Doctrines of the Romanists tend to dissolve the very Bonds of Relative Duty one toward another ; as in their Monastical Vows ; absolving People from their Oaths and Allegiance , and Faith with Hereticks , &c. How do many Principles of our Enthusiasts and Separatists , tend to destroy the Relation of King and Subject , Bishop and People ? Their very Divisions , how do they alienate the minds of Christians one from another ? Tho they ought to belong to the same moderate Church , are Subjects of the same most Gracious King , are of the same Protestant and Reformed Interest , beside the danger they bring to themselves and their Families , by their pernicious and destructive Separation , so many and more might be the Instances of their loosing the Bonds of Relative Duty .

§ . 8. Among other Sects , it would grieve any one to behold so many seduced into the silly Herd of Quakers ; a Sect into which the very dregs of Heresy and Schism seem to have bin drein'd , as it were , into one Common Shore : In the inventing and propagating which , even Satan and the Jesuit seem to have club'd their utmost Art ; possessing them with an evil Spirit of Delusion , which they call the Light within them ; according to which , what is most contrary to Holy Scriptures , and Right Reason ; and the testimony and judgment of the whole Church , and the prudent command of Governors , and the sence and custom of wise and pious Men , must pass for an extraordinary illumination from God , merely on the credit of their own saying so .

This one Enthusiastical Conceit of the Light within , and Opinion of such Revelation from God , is the most unhappy contrivance and suggestion that can be , to lift up silly People above a possibility of being contradicted , by any sober Principles of Scripture , or Reason , or regular Authority ; fitted to possess such with a lusty pride , and bewitched conceit of themselves ; an incorrigible moroseness , and obstinacy ; an intolerable censoriousness , a sordid scorn of whatever is in just place above them : and wonderfully disposeth such for Popery ; for when once they are sufficiently divided from our Church , the Work is sufficiently done . Then if any arch-Emissary from Rome , will come with Visions and Revelations , and a shew of extreme Authority ; and humor this People still in their outragious clamours against our Church : especially if they will fall a quaking and groaning intolerably , and appear in the Streets , as some have done , soundly be-dunged with Calumny and Filth , such may make some People believe any Romish Tenets as Revelations from God .

That they have bin wrought and acted unto this by the common Authors of our Divisions , is such plain attested matter of Fact , that I suppose few considering Persons question it . Some long since took notice , that in the Northern Parts ( where there abounded most Popish Priests and Recusants ) there this upstart Sect of Quakers first sprung up ; sending thence their Emissaries two by two into other quarters of the Kingdom , ( as the unclean Beasts entred the Ark by Couples ) : beside which , many Reasons confirm the same .

1. The effect in that Spirit of Division and Delusion , which so succesfully obtains among them ; to break in pieces the Peace and Order of the Church , unto which of all Sects these are the most Antipodes to .

2. There are none whose Tenets more tend to destroy the Holy Scripture as a perfect Rule of Faith and Manners : instead of which , and in opposition to the same , they set up the Suggestions of their Light within them , which they call the Word , the only Guide unto Perfection * * Perfectos se appellantes & semina electionis . De Valentinianis . Iren. l. 1. ; which they and the Romanists pretend : the one even unto supererogation of Merits ; the other to be above all need of confession of sin .

3. None come so near the Papists in the matter of an infallible Judg of Doctrines .

4. The Light within them is very much like the Enthusiasms of the Romanists ; as Dean Stillingfleet hath set them forth in the Fanaticism of the Church of Rome .

5. They join with the severest Romanists , in their reproaching the Offices and Orders of our Church , and especially villfying her Clergy ; whom they would have by all means to vow wilful Poverty .

6. By refusing all Oaths , their Allegiance is left uncertain to the King , which is the main thing such Papists would have .

7. The King's Supremacy is left unacknowledged , which is another principal preparation for the owning of the Pope's Supremacy .

8. In that they refuse to assist their Prince in his Wars , and pretend they hold it unlawful for any to fight : By that Principle they not only take away the Power and Sword of the Magistrate , and leave the King and Country undefended , that none can live in peace and safety , and consequently that Opinion leads to overthrow the very being of the whole Kingdom .

But the Pope also serves his Design by them , being sure that so many as there are of that Sect , so many will never oppose him by Arms : Whereas they who bind , can also loose ; and the same Agent can be able to stir up their Spirit of Zeal also , ( which the longer it hath bin contained , will be the more furious ) a Specimen and taste of which fury , we experience in the keen violence of their Tongues , which are as a very sharp Sword , upon sundry slight occasions .

And when once they shall be assured that the Lord hath delivered a People to slaughter , then Down Dagon ; then they will pretend they must be the Sampsons ; and like Pope Pius 5. ( in his Bull against Queen Elizabeth ) they will cry out , God hath set them over all Princes and Nations , to pluck up , and destroy , and to scatter , to plant and to build : They will presently be for binding Kings in Chains , and our Nobles in Fetters of Iron ; that the Saints may rule , and that the mountain of his Holiness may be exalted .

9. In the mean while they have among them such a political and artificial dependence on their principal Leaders , and the administration of their Body is cast into such a method for communication of News , and * * Tantum vaferrimi veteratores ex solâ correspondentiâ utilitatem ad unio●em tuendam sentiunt — Hospin . de Jesuitis . l. 4. intelligence of their Affairs and Interests , as we may be sure is contrived and menaged , and directed by more subtil Wits than their own ; being so very like the same method which the Agents of Rome use themselves for the propagation and disposition of their Matters . To mention nothing now further of their Agreements with the severest Emissaries of Rome in their pretences to all mortification of Spirit and mildness . In their pretences to extraordinary and miraculous Gifts ; in their many kinds of Superstitions , and Pharisaicalness ; in their clamours also of Persecution ; in their grievous Anathema's and Curses they use against us , too like the Roman Curses , by Bell , Book , and Candle ; which sheweth what is the Light within them .

§ . 9. It might be no difficult thing to shew some of those steps and degrees by which some commonly advance to Popery , who separate from Communion with our Church .

The first step to Division is , When what is amiss in Government and Governours , ( in Church or State ) is set forth to the full advantage of dissatisfaction , as may make withal the most lamentable out-cry that may be : unto which there shall never be wanting arch and cunning Instruments , who by all plausible means shall stir up the humour , and Passions , and Zeal of the People under such pretences , as shall most inflame and excite them .

Then in the next place are made such immoderate pretences to Purity , and profession of Saintship , as when poor simple People experience upon trial the same to be false , and not to answer their expectation , they run and seek from one Sect to another , till they come to be Quakers , and so ( as we see ) in the next preparation to Popery .

3. Having thus cast off all Forms as dangerous and unlawful , being raised to expect every-where the effects of a Spirit extraordinary , they are made so Enthusiastical , 't is hard to contain them within ordinary bounds , till they arrive at the perfection of Enthusiasm , the Light within .

4. By the way we must note , there is no one Principle which hath bin the Original of all this Enthusiasm and Division , more than that , Nothing is lawful to be done , but for which there is an express Example or Precept in the Scripture .

Which attributing to the Holy Scriptures that Perfection which is beside the end of them , doth tend , by consequence , to take away the true perfection of them which they have , ( which hath bin considered in the 4th Chapter ) which hath bin found true : for all these sub-divisions of Sects , have tended in the conclusion to cast off Holy Scripture as a Rule . By the consequences of this Principle , is come to pass what Arch-Bishop Whitgift , and Hooker , and others foretold ; If Puritanism should prevail , it would soon draw in Anabaptism . From them we have had Quakers and Seekers , and other Sects , which divide us , and are ready to destroy us , and to bring in Popery , as it were , at the back door : I may not dissemble my own fears , ( saith Bishop Sanderson * * Pref. to his Serm V. Arch. Bp. Laud's dying Speech . ) if things still go on as they have hitherto proceeded , the application that some have made of that passage , John 11. 48. The Romans will come and take away both our Place and Nation ; will prove but a true Prophecy , and Popery will over-run all at the last .

5. But when they are run out of all possibility of pretending any Scripture to justify their Actions , they then warrant them by Providence , and such a necessity as God hath called them unto by extraordinary Revelations , and Impulses , which in the next remove comes to be Light within them .

6. And when once they are off from our legal Establishments , what can stop the Divisions of several Sects from ending in confusion , and being made a prey of by designing Men , whose business is , when the Public is on fire , to make out their Spoils ? And who think we are most cunning and industrious to make the advantage by all this , but they whose greatest Business , and industrious Design , is to have our Church ruined ? Who make use of our Divisions to cry up also the necessity of an Infallible Judg of Controversy .

The Infallible private Spirit , is a fair preparation thereunto : and when they have broken and discredited the Authority of our Church , they have that taken away , which gives them most hinderance and opposition .

§ . 10. What hath bin in so many Instances proved , is most agreeable ;

1. To the Art , Industry , and Design of the Romanists , to make use of the Prejudices and Passions , the divided Principles and Interests of Men , to serve their purposes ; which are , by any means whatsoever to multiply Proselytes , and enlarge their Party : Wherefore the Thesis of Bishop Bramhall out of Nilus , was worthy such an Assertor ; That the Papacy as it was challenged and usurped in many places , and as it hath bin usurped in our Native Country , was either the Procreant or Conservant Cause , or both Procreant and Conservant of all the Ecclesiastical Controversies in the Christian World * * Bp. Br. Gro. Rel. p. 74. .

2. This is no more than what is agreeable to most common experience since the Reformation , and hath bin noted with great authority and remark . In the Preamble of the Act of Parliament , 27. Hen. 8. 1536. The Public Authority of the Kingdom took notice , how many of the Pope's Emissaries were practising up and down the Kingdom , and persuading the People to acknowledg his pretended Authority .

In the Homily against Rebellion , it is observed , That the Bishops of Rome , by the Ministry of their disguised Chaplains creep into Houses in Laymens Apparel , and raise Rebellion . The same Comenius relates was practised by them in the Bohemian Church † † Admiscebant se personati quidam , qui Papa causam promoturi dissentines mutuas promovebant . Histor. §. 36. .

Our English History tells us of sundry seditious Motions , soon after and about the time of the Reformation , which received their Impressions and Continuance from the influence of Romish Agents , as * * V. Acts and Monuments . p. 1086. 1087 , 1306. in the Lincolnshire , and Yorkshire , and Devonshire Commotions and Rebellions , which were actuated by Monks , Priests , and Papists . And how the like Game hath bin played ever since ( especially from the beginning of our Troubles ) in England , Scotland , Ireland , &c. Mr. Fowlis gives sundry proofs in his History of Pretended Saints , ( Ch. 3. ) which other observable Testimonies notoriously do verify . Arch-Bishop Whitgift frequently traced their footsteps in the dust they themselves raised ; I am persuaded ( saith he † † Def. of Answ. to the Admon . p 349 ) that Antichrist worketh effectually at this day , by your Stirs and Contentions , whereby he hath and will more prevail against this Church of England , than by any other means whatsoever .

These Divisions ( the Character of a Carnal and Unspiritual Temper ) the Learned Mede ¶ ¶ V. Medes Life . §. 44. p. 30. rightly judged , At once weaken and dishonour the Protestant Cause , and occasion the grand Enemy to triumph ; who seeing much of his Work done for him , by those who would seem most averse from him , while they bite and devour one another , claps his hands , saying , Aha , Aha , our Eye hath seen it , so would we have it .

The Lord-keeper Puckering spake of the unquiet Puritans in Queen Elizabeth's time , who pretended to be at War with the Jesuits ; yet by their separation they did join and concur with the Jesuits , in opening the door , and preparing the way to the Spanish Invasion . King James in his Letter to the Assembly of Perth * * Dat. Aug. 25. 1617. , took notice how many of the Discipline shook hands with the upholders of Popery . King Charles I. of blessed memory , declared truly , It is possible that a Papacy in a multitude , may be as dangerous as in one .

Bishop Sanderson , in his excellent Preface to his Sermons , saith , It hath bin observed , that where the Jesuits have bin most busy , other Factions have bin most Insolent ; and that those who have lived in those Countries where there are the most rigid Presbyterians , there are the most zealous Romanists ; for ( saith he ) they help together to pull down the same form of Government .

Our present Lord Bishop of Lincoln † † Popish Principles , &c. p. 78. takes notice of the favour the Papists had under Oliver Cromwel , and the freedom from the punishment of the Penal Laws , more than ever they had before , ( under King Charles the Martyr ) . No Oath of Allegiance and Supremacy was pressed upon them ; our Liturgie and Common-Prayer were taken away , so that there was no way then to discover or legally convict a Popish Recusant . Notwithstanding the same Oliver ( in a Speech to one of his Parliaments , 1654. Sept. 4. * * V. Mr. Fowlis Hist. of pretended Saints . p. 13. ) profest that he could prove by witness , that they had a Consistory and Council that ruled all the Affairs in England . And in the Year 1647 , when the King's Cause was at the lowest ebb , then the Romanists , by approbation of the Sorbon Doctors , were ready to give such full satisfaction and assurances of their fidelity to the Civil and Political Government in the Kingdom , whatsoever it shall be † † P. Walsh . p. 522. : Which they refused to do , when by the Moderation of the Government , they had a Convocation permitted them for that purpose at Dublin since the re-return of his Majesty . Then the Roman Leviathan had a fine time to play his Game , and to sport among the People , which are like many Waters : Then they laid their fruitful Spawn of Divisions in the Church , as well as Dissention in our Kingdom : As Arch-Bishop Laud most truly on the Scaffold declared ; The Pope never had such an Harvest in England since the Reformation , as he hath now upon the Sects and Divisions that are amongst us .

3. The same experience which our Church and Nation hath had of the Conspiracy of the Sectaries and the Romanists ( at least ) in event ; other Churches and Nations have also observed * * V. Lib. Ecclesiast . p. 10 , 11. :

As in Switzerland the Anabaptists were animated by the Papists : And in Bohemia some furious Divines carried on the Pope's Interest . A Jesuit who suffered at Strasburg , confest that he was one of the thirty Jesuits who was employed to be Agents for the Roman Cause in the late German Wars † † V. Mr. Fowlis Hist. of our pretended Saints . p. 12. .

And Crucius ¶ ¶ De Doctr. Jesuit . l. 4 in his Speech , as we have it in Hospinian , saith , We are sent into Germany , not only or chiefly that we might be Teachers , and Preachers , and Schoolmasters in the Schools and Churches , but that we use all means that the Protestants do not encrease ; that we may join our mutual Endeavours , Strength , and Arms , that more easily we may root them out . And for our overthrow , if they are our Incendiaries , as it is believed , we may say with reference to them , what Pliny in his Natural Philosophy speaks of the nature of things ; considering their Principles , and the Fires which break forth out of the Caverns of the Earth ; It is the greatest wonder of all , that every day , All things are not in a conflagration * * Excedit profecto omnia miracula ullum diem fuisse , in quo non cuncta conflagrarent Plin. Hist. Nat. l. 2. c. 107. .

4. That sundry of our Separation have bin thus acted , hath bin often among us in fact deprehended , together with the Confessions of those who have bin both Actors , and acted by them : Which is matter of such known discovery , that it needs no repetition here : Yea , of this sometime they have suspected one another ; for one of the Independent * * P. Sterry , 5 Nov. 1650. Brethren said ,

The same Spirit , saith he , which dwells in the Papacy , when it enters into the purer form of Presbytery , as fuller of Mystery , so is fuller of despite and danger . † † Inter finitimos vetus atque antiqua simultas . Juven. Satyr. 15. .

In the late Morning Exercise against Popery , one saith ¶ ¶ Serm. 4. p. 103. , The Papacy , together with their Religion , have had a Party , and kept up an Interest among the Protestant Churches . But because the Dissenters love to have it thought , that those of our Church are more guilty herein ; as there seems to be insinuated : Therefore ,

§ . 11. Unto all this , if any object , and tell us of the Advice of Cardinal Allen to the Persons who undertook to reduce Ireland again to Popery : — Among other things they should apply themselves to the Conformists , and possess them with the Factiousness , Disobedience , and Disorders of the Nonconformists , that so they might be provoked to spend their fury on each other to their mutual ruin .

We answer ; We hope that the Church of England , and her right conformable Clergy , have bin so setled by the establishment of our Church , as not to have had their Principles corrupted by Popish Influence :

As appears , 1. from the constant and stout opposition which Popery hath had from the Fathers and Sons of our Church .

And , 2. in that the many surmises of the contrary , have proved , upon the test , very notoriously foolish and false . Let any of them prove our Principles and Practices such , as we are able to do theirs , to serve the real Interest of Rome .

3. Let them know , that those who have bin most violently slandred as favourers of Popery , are known to have done more real and faithful service to the Protestant Cause , than all those that have entertained and promoted that rumour , have bin able to do . I will at present only mention Arch-Bishop Laud , ( whose Labours against Popery , and the other Separation were equally vigilant ) .

Of whom the Letter of Discovery ( of the Treason against the King and Kingdom , and the Protestant Religion , Octob. 1640. ) thus speaks ; Yet notwithstanding there remained on the King's part a knot hard to be untied ; for the Lord Arch-Bishop by his constancy , interposed himself as a hard Rock . And yet it was a lamentable hard case , that at the very same time the Reproaches and Seditions of the People were inflamed against King Charles I. of blessed memory , and Arch-Bishop Laud , under suspicions of their favouring Popery ; at the very same time the Jesuits were conspiring the killing of King Charles I. and also Arch-Bishop Laud , and the Convulsion of the Kingdom , and the Ruin of the Protestant Religion , and introducing of Popery , ( as appears by the Discovery to Sir William Boswell at the Hague , 1640 , and sent over by him to the King and the Arch-Bishop ) .

Even thus hath bin the practice of the Romanists , to slander Princes also for being Papists , and then to assassinate them for being too zealous Protestants * * The Lord Chancellors speech March 6. 1678. .

4. Whereas our Enthusiastical Friends are ready to object unto us , That the Church of England is either Popish , or in some degree prepared to be so , namely , because she hath Bishops , a Liturgy , and Ceremonies .

Such might know , if they rightly understood things , even what they object , that these things do most of all oppose Popery ; and help to secure us from it .

For , 1. Episcopacy asserted in our Church , is the greatest opposition to Popery that is ; for the very formality of Popery , is the Pope's Jurisdiction over all other Bishops and Churches ; which Authority of the Pope is no where so much contradicted , as by our Episcopacy . To say nothing what our Bishops undeniably and unanswerably have performed against Popery ; It is very well known what rejoicing that Vote for pulling down Episcopacy brought to the Romish Party ; how in Rome it self they sang their Io Paeans upon the tidings thereof , and said , triumphantly , The day is ours * * Bp. San derson's Pre●ace . §. 17. .

2. A Reformed Liturgy as ours is , ( separated from all Popish Soyl and Corruption ) must needs be it self the greatest security from Popery ; since the want of it tends to bring in the worst part of Popery , which is Enthusiasm , and Phanatical pretences to Revelation , and an Infallible Spirit , ( as hath bin abundantly experienced ) .

3. Our Ceremonies reformed from all Popish Reasons and Ends of their Institution , are useful to defend Christianity from Superstition ; using People to apprehend , that Christian Religion consists , neither in their necessary use , nor in their being necessarily refused ; either of which is an equal infringing of Christian Liberty .

Much more might be added in defence of what is appointed in our Church , as the Marks and Bounds of a moderate Reformation ; and do afford a better Apology and Defence against the Romanists , in the Judgment of the General Church , than they can have who fix upon false Principles , and therefore may the more easily be turned unto the opposite extreme : Whereas the true Moderation of our Church gives her establishment against each opposite Errors . Yea , it is manifest that our Church of England thus reteining Episcopal Government , and a well-reformed Liturgy , and while it observes Christian Festivals , and a moderate outward decency in the Church of God , ( as did the Churches of Christ in the Primitive Times ) hath a fairer Plea and foundation of Argument , to invite and perswade any from Romish Corruption , than a Dissenter who will tell such a one , That all that is Popery : which account of things may presently beat him back , and make him conclude , that Protestants call that Popery , which in the purest and most Primitive Times , was practised in all Christian Churches in the World . Whereas how easy a thing is it for a Popish Priest to turn himself into a Gifted Brother : And what Opinion is there of the Romanists , which may not come forth as a New Light ? So that it was no ill Character of a Schismatic , He is a Papist turned wrong side outward .

§ . 12. Wherefore an easy Prudence ( which is a perpetual kind of Divination ) * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Proverbialis senarius , qui sic apud Ciceronem redditur , Benè qui conjici● , hunc vatem perhibeto optimum . may readily foresee how soon , if occasion present , those Parties so seemingly opposite will close , even more certainly than they themselves are aware of : for Men of wrong Principles know not where to find themselves after a while , especially in changeable Times , because they know not where their Principles will lead them : In the mean while such as hold a stedfast Communion with our Church , must needs be the most firm Protestants of any ; because they follow the Moderation of the Church it self : For Truth is ever found among the modest , who never affect utmost extremes , which the Vulgar ( of which our Dissenters consist ) so passionately and hastily run into . Wherefore among the Considerations touching the true way to suppress Popery in this Kingdom* , it was well laid down , The best way P. 132. for the suppressing of Popery in this Kingdom , is to get our Church to be better understood . And indeed if all who call themselves Protestants , of what denomination soever , understood their own Interest , they must needs be for upholding our Church of England . For if it be overthrown , it must either be by Divisions , ( and certainly the watchful Adversaries of Rome will chiefly make their Game by them , whose business is to promote them ) If our Divisions prevail , the Romanists will prevail also * * Thorndike . Forb . of Pen. p. 37. .

Or , 2ly , by Toleration ; by which the same Romanists will obtain but an opportunity openly , and , as it were , by Authority to divide and work their Wills , which without a Toleration they only dare attempt secretly .

Or , 3ly , by setting one of the Dissenting Parties uppermost .

But they all have given such proof of their Rigour already , that all other Parties will think themselves equally grieved then ; and the cry for Toleration will continue to be as loud : and they can never expect from any Constitution , more Moderation than what our present Establishment affords .

Therefore all that love Moderation , and are afraid of Popery , ought to be solicitous for the welfare of the Church of England , as it is now setled .

And now I have said thus much , ( and more may be said on this Head , if this be not enough , to convince any who are sincerely dispassionate ) I may appeal to all the World of the truth of what hath bin said , with no design to reproach any ones Persons , or incense any one's Spirit , but in the real Spirit of Meekness , and most affectionate regard to such who are wrought upon to be of another mind ; most heartily wishing and praying , That all who are sincere in this Nation , would at length be awakened , to see from whence our Divisions generally proceed ; who they are who have nourished , and cherished , and encreased our Flames , and cast their Wild-fires among us : By whom our Dissenters have bin acted , and menaged , and chiefly made to be what they are : That thus far may suffice them to have bin gulled to other purposes than they themselves have known ; that those who are honest-hearted , may be truly ashamed and convinced , and see their Error , and may repent and return into Reconciliation to an excellent Church , whom they have forsaken , and endeavoured , with common Enemies , to destroy . Oh that at length they may see their folly , and their imprudence , & may make some amends , by continuing hereafter more stedfast to our Communion , for the sake of no less than the Christian Religion ; unto which hath bin given so great a scandal ; and for the honour of our excellent Reformation ; which , because of its Moderation , and excellent Temper , is really the Terror of the Roman Church : and God grant it may long , long so continue !

CHAP. XVIII . Of the Moderation of our Church , as it may influence Christian Practice , and especially our Union .

§ . 1. Some proper Inferences from what hath bin insisted on at large . § . 2. Sundry general Rules agreeable to Reason and Christianity ; by which the Moderation of private Persons may be measured and directed , particularly of our Dissenting Brethren . § . 3. Some proper means to reduce Dissenters into Vnion with the Church , with all Moderation proposed . § . 4. The hearty Profession of the moderate and sincere purposes of the Writer . § . 5. One or two Caveats entred , to prevent mistake ; and for the Caution of such as will attempt to disprove the main Proposition here designed to be evinced . § . 6. Some good Wishes to the Adversaries of our Church on both sides , such as are fit to conclude a Treatise of the Moderation of our Church .

§ . 1. AS from the very being of Moderation and Equity , we are certain that the nature of absolute Good and Evil , Just and Unjust , doth not depend upon the Arbitrary Power of any , but is founded in the nature of Things and Circumstances , ( or else the Assertion of Equity would be very ridiculous ) ; so we are sure , from what hath bin largely declared , ( especially by comparing other Extremes ) That our Church of England is far from designing to use or encourage any arbitrary or rigorous way of Administration , which is contrary to the measures of natural Justice or Christianity .

2. As from the nature of Moderation it hath appeared , that Benevolence is the true Fountain of Equity , and answers the most general Law of Nature , giving the best end and measure to all Actions , ( especially which have any influence on the Public ) ; which causeth Laws themselves to bend , by all gentleness and benignity , to the general design of all public and private Endeavours , which ought to be the Glory of God , and peace and good-will to Men : So we hope from the fore-going Instances , it appears also , that a benevolous inclination is implanted into the very frame and temper of our Church's Constitution : and that from such a Principle it persues the excellent ends mentioned ; not only according to the Rules of Natural Justice , but the most fair and equal Measures of Gentleness also and Benignity . Wherefore it concerns us all , who live where the Laws of the Kingdom and the Church are framed and interpreted according to this equity , to acknowledg so great a Blessing . The same Consideration aggravates the unreasonableness of those who persue their own Prejudices , contrary to what is appointed even so equitably and moderately . And it is heartily to be wished , that the Opposers of our Church could give any such testimonies of their Moderation as our Church hath done . Let any if they can , Romanist or Separatist , ( of any particular denomination whatsoever , as they are generally known among us ) shew as much proof and instance of their Moderation , as I have done of our Church .

§ . 2. But as in our first Chapter we laid down some general Rules , which are agreeable to natural Justice and Goodness , and also unto Christianity , by which we are directed to judg the more truly of the Moderation * * Nihil est tam praeclarum aut tam magnificum quod non Moderatione temperari desideret . Valer Max. de animi Moder . l. 4. c. 1. of our Church : So I conceive there are some such Rules also alike agreeable to the same Principles , by which the Moderation of private Persons may very equitably be judged .

1. It may be supposed very agreeable to the Rule of Moderation , not to expect or require of an Establishment , what is utterly impossible in this World ; namely , Absolute Perfection : And for any to withhold their Obedience , so long as they conceive some things may be better , cannot but be concluded very unreasonable .

Here it is but just to note of our Church : 1. That she never pretended of her self ( nor any I know of , for her ) that she was , or is , so perfect as to be without spot or * * Vltra etiam progreditur eorum morositas & fastus , quia Ecclesiam non agnoscunt nisi minimis quibusque naevis puram . Calv. Inst. l. 4. c. 1. wrinkle ; as the Brethren in their Morning Lecture against Popery deliver : There is no Church under Heaven perfectly beautiful ; that remains for glory † † Serm. 25. p. 870. . Altho we say our Church hath a most excellent temper , it is not necessary we attribute to her what some call ( Temperamentum ad pondus ) such a Temperament , that no Scruple , one way or other , can alter her poise . 2. I hope from what hath bin shewed , it may appear that the possible Imperfections are in no wise so great as sundry would suppose . 3. However , not in Matters of any principal Moment or Concern to Religion .

2. It is but very agreeable to the Rules of Moderation , that such as require Moderation so desirously , should give very good example of their own Moderation themselves : and should also lay aside their own Rigours , in unjust and severe Thoughts , harsh Words , and immoderate Actings ; and not make those Rules the measure of their Moderation , which are just proofs of their Rigour : For I suppose the Observation of King Charles I. is a famous Truth ; I see no Men so prone to be greater Tyrants , and more rigorous Exacters upon others to conform to their illegal Novelties , than such , whose Pride was formerly least disposed to the obedience of lawful Constitutions * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Med. 16. . And even in the Liberty of Prophecying , the Libertines themselves are most truly described ; † † Sect. 17. They who were perpetually clamorous , that the severity of the Laws should slacken as to their particular , and in matter adiaphorous ( in which if the Church have any Authority , she hath power to make such Laws ) to indulge a leave to them to do as they list : Yet , were the most imperious among Men , most decretory in their Sentences , and most impatient of any disagreeing from them , tho in the least minute and particular .

3. If any do conceive the Church defective in some particular , ( especially when few will deny but the principal and substantial Things are not wanting ) Christian Moderation requires all to supply any such supposed Defects as much as they can by such a Christian Charity ¶ ¶ Pii & placidi homines misericorditèr corripiant quod possunt ; quod non possunt patientèr ferant , & cum dilectione gemant atque lugeant , donec aut emendet Deus , aut in messe eradicet zizania . S. Aug. l. 3. contr. Parm. c. 1. as thinketh , hopeth , believeth the best : especially of their Governours , and renders all Persons suspicious of their own Judgments , and docible and humble in disposition and behaviour .

And while they charge the Church with being in some things deficient , in others superfluous ; they ought to have the more care not to add thereunto their own faults in the same kind , as being deficient in their Duty , or superfluous in such exceptions as generally are so frivolous .

4. It is most agreeable to the Rules of Moderation , that those who are so earnest to have still more Moderation allowed them , should first acknowledg such Moderation and Indulgence as they have received ; and also should take care that the same miss not of its desired and promised Effects from them . Wherefore what the Bishops told the Presbyterian Brethren , was but a very moderate admonition ; We conceive the most real expression of their thankfulness for his Majesties most Princely Condescention , had bin a hearty compliance with his Majesties most earnest and passionate request for the use of the present Liturgie , at least so much of it as they acknowledg by these Papers to be lawful .

Such also should readily and thankfully own whatsoever is good in the establishment which is over them , and the real benefits and blessings which all do and may enjoy .

And since there are such Instances and Proofs of the Moderation of our Church , Christian Moderation will also govern any , who are concerned in this Matter , well to understand and consider such Proofs , and acknowledg what is true in them .

5. It is but according to Christian Moderation , that a special respect and regard be had to a reformed setled Establishment as Ours is , which is in possession * * In pari causâ possessor potior haberi debet . Reg. jur. of its Authority .

( 1. ) Christian Moderation will dispose such well to consider how far they ought to bear against their own Inclination , before they offer at the Violation of the Sacred Peace of God's Church .

( 2. ) Christian Moderation will instruct any one , that exemption from Obedience ought to be as clear as the Command to Obey † † Infirmae prorsus voluntatis est indicium Statuta Seniorum studiosiùs disquirere , haerere ad singula quae injunguntur , exigere de quibusque rationem , & malè suspicari de omni praecepto , cujus causa latuerit , nec unquam libenter obedire . S. Bern. de praec . & dispens . .

( 3. ) Such ought moderately to consider of the danger they threaten all Government , ( Civil and Ecclesiastical ) and also the Interest especially of the Reformation , who are so industrious to overthrow such an Establishment as ours is , upon these kind of Dissatisfactions .

6. Christian Moderation doth certainly govern all to use the same measures of practice for themselves and others , ( that is , to do as they would be done by * * Non debet alteri per alterum iniquae conditio inferri . Reg. juris . ) : Suppose therefore that any Plat-form , the Exceptors against our Church propose , was setled according to their own phancy ; They ought to consider , whether they would endure to be reproached , resisted , disobeyed after such an establishment was made . They who have used sundry significant Ceremonies themselves , ( as were used in taking the Covenant ) should not be so violent against all Ceremony . They who are against all Jewish Usages , ought to have a care of Judaizing . They who are zealous against Popery , ought to have a care themselves both lest they run into Popery , and lest they be carried thereinto , ( however imprudently and unwarily ) . They who could be forward to appoint Fasting-days , and days of Thanksgiving , upon accounts not so justifiable , ought not to be against all our lawful and appointed Fasts and Festivals . They who have made it the chief of their Exception against our Monarchy formerly , that it made void Acts of Parliament by Prerogative ( when it did not ) should not be so earnest , that the same be done for the sake of Papists and themselves . They who would not have the miscarriages of some particular Brethren charged on their Party , or themselves ; ought , by the same Rule , to have a care that they never charge our Church with the Faults of some particular Persons of our Communion ; making those the Vices of our Constitution , which are only the Faults of some Persons , which will be in the World so long as there are Men ; happy is it , where there are fewest . The same equity also which our Church sheweth unto others , she may justly expect to receive : Namely ; To be allowed such just and favourable Construction , as in Preface to the Liturgy . common equity ought to be allowed to all humane Writings , especially such as are set forth by Authority .

7. Christian Moderation will govern any , when they have experienced an Evil , not to run into the same again ; They therefore who have seen that the Consequences of their own Principles have proved worse than before they apprehended ; and that such immoderate Zeal as their own , hath bin made use of to other purposes than they were aware , and have seen and felt the horrid Effects of Confusion , occasion'd from such Exceptions as these , which are so busy now against our Church ; by the Rules of true Moderation , ought to acknowledg the same constantly , and to have a diligent care lest they split again upon the same Rocks . This Christian Moderation will help any for avoiding one extreme from running unto another : because they detest In vitium ducit culpae fuga , si caret arte . Horat. Papal Tyranny , they will not therefore reject Episcopacy ; because of some defect in Discipline , they will not therefore run into a culpable Separation : because some are careless in their Prayers , they will not therefore reject all Forms as unlawful : Because of the Imperfection of all Forms of Government , therefore they will not conclude Monarchy sinful : Because some set up the Doctrine of Merit , they will not therefore think good Works needless to Salvation : Because too many neglect the Vow they made in their Baptism , therefore they will not deny Infant Baptism : Because in Popery there are such heaps of Fopperies , therefore what was really good among them , must not for their sakes be condemned : Because what was typical of Christ under the Old Testament is abolished by our Christianity , therefore other moral and useful Usages which were among the Jews are not to be thought unlawful .

For many are forward to cry out of sundry Appointments among us as Jewish : As the use of Churches ; Music , separate Persons , Places , and Things for the Holy Service of God ; Churching of Women ; Tythes ; Holy-days and Times ; decent Vestments , &c. wherein our Church useth its Christian Liberty to take or leave such Institutions as are free for us , the Reason remaining generally the same to us , and them , and others .

Yet ( which is contrary to the Rule of right Reason and due Moderation ) the very same Persons ( where the Reason remains not the same to Jews and Christians , but quite contrary ) are apt to Judaise in practice properly Mosaical , and which were shadows of good things to come * * V. Compassionate enquiry . p. 69. .

8. Because the Precepts we meet with in the New Testament concerning Moderation , Condescention , bearing Infirmities , are plainly given to private Persons , and many times in relation to their own Passions , and with a clear reference to their having not as yet time or opportunity of being sufficiently instructed . Therefore all good Christians are to have a care lest any indisposition or ill-temper of Mind or Phancy prevail with them against a positive and certain Duty ; which is a Rule of true Moderation .

9. As Christian Moderation guides and inclines us , with all compassion and affection , to pity the Seduced , whose Education and Company , and the Authority of those they admire ( too blameably notwithstanding ) governs their weakness , into dislike of what is publicly ordered : however with meekness we desire to instruct such who oppose themselves , if God peradventure will give them repentance to acknowledgment of the Truth .

So for such who are driven aside by Interest , Love of Faction , or other corrupt Designs : Albeit we grieve for them , and pray for their better mind : Yet it is no breach of Christian Moderation , if ( for the Peace of the Church , for the Honour of the Laws , for the Safety of Others , and that all their Souls may be saved in the Day of the Lord ) we do wish the Gensures of the Church in full force and vigour , for their seasonable reducement and emendation .

10. True Moderation which governs it self according to Truth , will not suffer any to pretend to that Union among themselves , which really they know they have not : I think nothing might help some to a sense of their unreasonable opposition to the Church of England , and their unadvisedness therein , more than if they themselves would please to reflect on the Variety and Contradiction which is among themselves one to another * * Inde furor vulgo , quod numina vicinorum Odit uterque locus , quûm solos credat habendos Esse Deos , quos ipse colit — Juven . Sat. 15. : However all Dissenters would seem to be united in the great numbers every Party boasts of .

But because it is impossible to comprehend the variety of all Sects ; look we for Instance but upon the Presbyterian Brethren ; and see among them the mild and the rigid ; and the subdivision of these into sundry Classes and Forms of them .

Some have professed they adhere to the Scripture , and the Catholic consent of Antiquity , Grand Debate , p. 61. as described by Vincentius Lirinensis . Whether others prefer the judgment of one of the Masters of their Assemblies equal to most of the Ancient Fathers , I should not offend many of them to declare . Some take it for granted there is a firm agreement between us in 1. Paper to his Majesty . Doctrinal Truths of the Reformed Religion expressed in the Articles & Homilies . Others contend for a necessity of Reformation , even of the Doctrine of the Church of England . Some among them hold our Liturgy Unlawful ; others only Inexpedient : Some not inexpedient in some Offices , but in others . Others can join with all our Forms of Liturgy , but cannot use them . Some could use them , if Grand Debate , p. 61. there was a convenient conjunction of the Liturgie mixt with their own Conceptions interposed , which they have thought would be a well-temper'd means , to the common constitution of most . Some can use them , but not subscribe them ; others can subscribe to the use , but not assent and consent to the use of them . Some who will not themselves consent , are content their Sons should be brought up to be wiser . Others when they advise or give leave to any to conform , gravely desire them to do it as their Burden . Some Brethren of the same denomination among themselves , disapprove of those very Offices and Constitutions which others of them allow , and yet like others better . In so much that we may count those who are satisfied , to oppose the dissatisfied ( in many things ) among themselves .

So concerning Ceremonies , the Presbyterian Brethren , ( while they do not deny their practice to be lawful ) they declare of others , Some think them flatly 2. Paper to his Majesty . unlawful , some inconvenient ; some think them unlawful in themselves , and others but inconvenient . Thus in the Nosotrophium of the old Philosopher , who undertook to ●ure all Calentures , by bathing Patients under Water ; some were up to the Chin , some to the Middle , some to the Knees . So it is amongst the Enemies of the Sacred Order of Episcopacy ; some endure not the Name , and they indeed deserve to be over head and ears . Some will have them all one in Office with Presbyters , as they first were in Name , and they had need bath up to the Chin : but some stand shallower , and grant a litle distinction , a precedency perhaps for Order-sake , but no preheminence in Regiment , no superiority of Jurisdiction . Others by all means would be thought to be quite through in behalf of Bishops Order , and Power , such as it is , but call for a reduction to the Primitive State , and would have all Bishops like the Primitive ; but because by this means they think to impair their Power , they may endure to be up to the Ankles . Their Error indeed is less , and their Pretence fairer , but the use they make of it of very ill consequence . Thus those who are for Parity in the Church , have great disparities , and very disproportionate Measures in their own immoderations , in many other Matters as well as these mentioned . You may as Grand Debate , p. 91. well think to make a Coat for the Moon , ( as was the Phrase of the Presbyterian Brethren ) as reconcile most of them one to another . Who since they are so inconsistent among themselves , are less to be credited against the Church . And here it might also be proved at large , how the most of the Dissenting Brethren of the same denomination , often change many of their Principles within a few years : especially the Dissenters of the former times seem'd to have a greater sense of the Moderation of our Church , and used a fairer compliance , than many have done since under greater Indulgence , for they came generally to our Common-Prayers , and Holy Sacraments . To say nothing of other Differences , which will not please our Brethren to mention , as well as they love the old Nonconformists . As to those among us who are most moderate , it may be wisht they will afford their own Example in what they allow in Discourse ; and that they would labour as effectually to prevail on those who depend on their Judgments and Example .

§ . 3. Whereas many of our Dissenting Brethren profess they desire the Interest of Jesus Christ may be promoted , and that sanctity of Life , and the pure Worship of God , and the Communion of Saints , and the Edification of the Church , and the Reformed Protestant Religion may be maintained and encreased ; and in all Debates they appeal to the Holy Scriptures ; and many of them say , they are desirous to rectify Mistakes , and to lay aside all prejudice , and passion , and partiality , and profess they desire their Judgments and Practices may be guided in the ways of Truth and Peace . Supposing all this , if we meet with such as will admit what follows into fair consideration , I should think it the most proper means by some such degrees as follow to bring them , if it be possible , to understand the good Constitution of things among us .

1. By letting such , by clear Instances , see how unmoveably we hold the Faith and Doctrine of Christ delivered in Holy Scripture ; which together with the whole Church of God , the Church of England doth keep inviolably , witness unto them faithfully , and so constantly appeal to , as the only perfect Rule of Faith and Manners . ( V. Ch. 4. )

2. Since the best and most useful sort of Moderation , is that which governs us as we ought , in the real Practice of Vertue and Goodness , whereunto tend all the Moderation of the Laws , and the Doctrine and Discipline of God's Church ; yet ( which is a lamentable thing to consider ) this is most silently past over , and scarce known by the Name at that same time , that a huge clamour is rais'd among us for Moderation in Religion : in which , all that are concerned may know and understand , that the great Design and Desire of our Church is to promote holiness of Life . Among us , all may not only be as holy as they will , but that they may be so , they are assisted and encouraged most earnestly , by the Laws , and Constitutions , and Offices , and Councils of our Church , ( which if they were rightly understood , would be known uniformly to tend to no less ) .

3. Such may consider that all the appointed means of Grace and Salvation , are by our Church publicly and amply taken care of , as duly and effectually as may be .

4. In a Church where substantial Piety is so truly procured throughout the whole Constitution ; it might at least mitigate the great offence taken to consider ( what is more largely shewed Ch. 8. ) That our Church never did own her very few Ceremonies , any other than accidental and mutable Circumstances , for Order and Comeliness-sake ; but never asserted them any essential or necessary part of God's Worship . Such may also consider the Rules of reasonable behaviour and submission to the Church ; as are moderately laid down Chap. 6. §. 10.

5. Because our Dissenters , by their dividing from us , seem to endanger very much the Interest of the Reformed Religion , which they appear so zealous to uphold ; Let them be pleased to consider the real danger of their being acted by Romish Agents and Incendiaries , while they take the second direct course to destroy this reformed Establishment among us ; as is more particularly considered in Chap. 17.

6. Such may do well to consider truly , those easy and proper Consequences which follow the Consideration of the Church being a Society , with relation to a Christian Kingdom as ours is ; from whence sundry special Obligations may be inferred , to bind every one who calls himself Christian , to maintain the Peace and union of such a Society ; especially if we look on the Church as a Society , formed by God himself ; and therefore common Christians are not to look upon themselves as Spiritual Governors ; as if they had any power in themselves to constitute new Bounds , or new Extents , to its Being or Authority ; but are to think they have an easier and safer task , quietly to accept and obey that which is constituted by lawful Authority , in all things not repugnant to the revealed Will of God .

And since every one's being of the Church doth suppose their duty to communicate in those Sacraments and Holy Offices , which are appointed as a public Sign before God and Man , that we do confess Christ Jesus ; and is an evidence of our holding communion with God's Church , and that we are obedient to the Laws of this Society , and the Government thereof , in that fixed part of the Church we live in ; it follows that we are obliged unto the Peace of this Church by the intent of our Baptismal Vow , when we were incorporated as Members of Christ's Body , the Church : And we are bound to maintain the same Peace of this Society of the Church , as we live in a Christian Kingdom , where the Religion of the Kingdom is so great a part of its Laws . Upon which account Schism renders the safety of Kingdoms very hazardous : beside that it looseth the Bands of all Friendship , Sacred and Civil , and breeds enmity among nearest Relations and Neighbours : It tends exceedingly to the dishonour of the Public Laws , and opens a gap to the most dissolute , making void the exercise and effect of the Discipline of the Church upon the scandalous ; which otherwise to the prophane World would prove terrible , as an Army with Banners : It is the only way any can take , to destroy all being of a Visible Church ; to corrupt her Doctrine , and destroy her Power , and is so great a sin as Martyrdom it self cannot expiate it : Such do as much as they can , make void the Design of our Blessed Saviour ; Who died , that be might gather into one the Children of God that are scattered abroad , 11 S. John 52. the night before our Lord was betrayed , when he instituted the Sacrament of Unity ; How fervently did he pray for the Peace of the Church ! 17 S. John 11. Holy Father , keep through thy own Name , those whom thou hast given me , that they may be one , as I am one . ( V. 21. ) That they also may be one in us , that the World may believe that thou hast sent me . Whereas these Schisms which we have , tend to weaken or take away the greatest outward Witness we have of the truth of Holy Scriptures , and of our very Christianity ; namely , the Testimony of God's Church from the beginning ; and do expose our most excellent Religion , to the contempt and entertainment of Atheists . The sad account for which let them beware of , who make it their idle business , to defame the Church in her Holy Offices , and alienate all whom they can from her Communion .

Let them pretend what they will in the mean time to intimate Communion with God , they indeed take away the Unity of the Church as much as in them lies , but in effect they take it away from themselves ; and they cut themselves off from Communion with the rest of the Body ; and by being dissevered from the Body , how it is possible they should retain Communion with the Head of that Body , God only knows , to whose infinite Mercy we leave them .

It is seriously and heartily to be wished , that the Duty and Benefits of Communion with the Church , were duly considered by all : and the many more grievous Mischiefs of Schism than have bin here mentioned : and in reference to our Church of England in particular , as certainly her Moderation is a great aggravation of the Schisms which are ; so I suppose it a most true observation , and deserves the common consent of all , That the only Reason why our Church is not more generally embraced and admired , is , because the Purity of its Doctrine , the Sobriety of its Devotion , the Moderation of its Discipline , the largeness of its Charity , are not impartially and calmly examin'd , and more generally understood .

Wherefore we wish that by God's Grace working love in all the hearts of those who do not understand & consider so much : they would yet consent to what the Peaceful and Holy Nazianzen declares in one of his Orations of Peace ; Thus ( saith he ) I resolve , it is not good to be more indifferent than is meet , nor too hot ; either through levity to be carried about with every one , nor by disorder to separate from all : when the manifest things of wickedness require our compliance , then we are to contest with Fire and Sword , rather than partake of their Leven : But when only a suspicion of evil seizeth on our minds , then Moderation and Condescention are more advisable , rather than make a separation from others we relate unto as Members . Wherefore let us embrace each other , and be sincerely one , and imitate our Blessed Mediatour , who by his Blood hath reconciled all things , and made peace : Let us say to our Common Father , Behold thy Sons gathered into One. Unto which I must add what the same Father from those Dissentions which were in the Church did conceive , namely , a great dread , lest thereby Antichrist * * 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 — should come upon them on suddain , taking advantages of their Discord .

It would be well if modest and quiet Persons could at length be convinced of the happiness of having and holding to a Rule † † Pulchrum est tenere mensuram officii . S Ambros . offic. l. 1. c. 10. : And what a blessing it is , to have every thing for their Spiritual use so readily , and so well prepared to their hand : and admit ( which we are in no wise forced here to affirm ) that sundry Orders might be much better ; Nevertheless whereunto we have already attained , let us walk by the same Rule , let us mind the same Thing . ( 3 Phil. 13. ) In Matters of Indifferency , the best way of cementing the ¶ ¶ Fracturam verò ligamen astringit , cum culpam disciplina deprimit : sed gravius scissuram sentiat , si hanc immoderatiùs ligamenta constringant : inter haec solicit a circumspectione providendum , ne aut districtio rigida , aut pietas sit remissa . Greg. Mag. de cura past . in part . 2. c. 5. Fractions , is , unite the Parts in the Authority ; for then the Question is but one , namely , Whether the Authority shall be obeyed or not * * Lib. of Prophec . §. 17. ?

Me thinks the Interest of the Christian Religion , ( to free it from so great a scandal ) the Honour of the Kingdom , and their Native Country , and the Laws , and the private Interest of themselves and their Families ( where greater Interest and Engagement with a Party and Prejudices do not hinder ) should prevail at length with more to embrace the Reconciliation of the Church : which the best and wisest every-where have done , ( convinced of the Moderation of our Church ) and the rest remain so divided and shattered among themselves , only united by their common prejudice against the Church ; having had their mouths over and over stopt by solid Arguments , and a palpable demonstration of their falsities and incongruities , ( which have bin posted up to the World to their unanswerable conviction ) ; or else they have bin laught out of their ridiculous follies , by them who have had a laudable art in so doing * * Ingenuo culpam defigere ludo . Persius . Sat. 5. .

§ . 4. And indeed since the Church of England suffers so exceedingly , between such extreme Adversaries , ( which hath bin a great proof of her great Moderation ) no wonder if such as desire to maintain the even tenour of uniform Principles , partake of the same hard measure with our Church † † 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Thucyd. : Wherefore for our calmly defending what is real Moderation , we may surely expect to be accused as immoderate , and to be suspected by either extreme of the number of their opposite Adversaries , against which chance perhaps there is no Remedy : Wherefore the sincerity of our Purpose , and the goodness of our Cause , we hope will support us ; For it is enough for the Disciple , that he be as his Master , and the Servant as his Lord : Blessed be God we have yet the advantage of so excellent a Reformed Church on our side . So the worthy Translators of the English Bible , in their Epistle to King James , comforted themselves ; If on the one side we shall be traduced by Popish Persons , or if on the other side we shall be maligned by self-conceited Brethren , who run th●ir own ways , and give liking unto nothing but what is framed by themselves , and hammered on their Anvil , we may rest secure , supported by the truth and innocency of a good Conscience .

For my own part , I profess my self a lover and admirer of true Moderation ; and I hope I have observed the due measures of it * * Moderatus sum Ipse mihi , quant●●● lic●it , & non quod Ip●● de ●o●is ●erue●in● , sed quid nostros Homines deced● , spectavi . Su●liv . pref. de Monach. , in what I have writ , with relation to either extreme . And h●re I crave leave to repeat the dying words of the right Reverend Bishop Sanderson , and to use them solemnly as my own ; As I do profess that I have lived , so I desire , and by the Grace of God , resolve to die , in the Communion of the Catholic Church of Christ , and a true Son of the Church of England , which as it stands by Law established , to be both in Doctrine and Worship agreeable to the Word of God ; and in the most material Points of both , conformable to the Faith and Practice of the Godly Church of Christ in the Primitive and purer times , I do firmly believe : Led so to do , not so much from the force of Custom and Education , ( to which the greatest part of Mankind owe their particular different Persuasions in Religion ) as upon the clear evidence of Truth and Reason , after a serious and unpartial examination of the Grounds , as well of Popery as Puritanism , according to that measure of understanding , and those opportunities which God hath afforded me ; and herein I am abundantly satisfied , that the Schism which the Papists on one hand , and V. Bishop Sanderson's last Will . Walton in his Life . the Superstition which the Puritan on the other hand lay to our charge , are very justly chargeable on themselves respectively .

It is the Church of England in its legal Constitution , which I defend , and not the Assertions and Practices of particular Persons : Neither have I undertaken to commend the Church in all her equal Constitutions , nor shewn all the Proportions and Instances of her Moderation ; neither have I illustrated the same from all the extremes and immoderate extravagances of other Professions in Religion , which would have bin a boundless and an infinite task : But if I have made out this excellent Vertue to be truly conspicuous in our Church : If I have fairly wrested out of our Adversary's hands that glorious Calumny , in which so many have cheared and vaunted themselves , in their fond Hopes , strange Demands , and very dismantled Confidences , That our Church is devoy'd of all true Moderation ; I am sure I have done reason to our most indulgent Mother to defend her from the imputation of unjust Rigour ; which our Church justly disdains , as in her 8th Canon ; Whosoever shall affirm that their pretended ( Schismatical ) Church hath a long time groaned under the burden of certain Grievances imposed upon them by the Church of England , let them be Excommunicate . —

§ . 5. But whereas some forward to censure , will be apt to judg of our justifying the Moderation of the Church as an endeavour to prevent any Reformation or Union ; such may consider , That admit our Superiors should think fit to remit , or at any time change any thing in our present Order ; The so doing doth not necessarily infer that our Constitution is not very moderate as it is : For Concessions which are for the future , ought not to be an accusation of the Church in what is past . But may our sins never bring upon us such a wretched condition of the Church , when every one shall judg he hath a right to think and speak in Religion what he pleaseth * * In liberâ Repub. unicuique & sentire quae velit & quae sentiat liberè dicere . Tractat. Theologo . Pol. . Unto this state of things , or unto Popery , those hasten us , ( whether they know it or no ) who are in no wise satisfyed with the Moderation of our Church . How far our present establishment may be any way moderated to compass a more general and lasting uniformity , we hope if ever there should be occasion , God will guide our Governors to determin ; but I am sure , as the present Moderation of the Church is most justifiable , so I suppose the change may more easily be allow'd , when ever the generality of Dissenters shall be agreed and resolv'd of their own Reasons among themselves .

In the mean while if any will undertake to disprove the Proposition which this Treatise principally doth ovince , Namely ,

That the great Moderation of the Church of England doth rightly argue those who are in separation from the same , to be the more unjust and guilty in their Schism .

* * Et refellere sine pert●nac●â , & refelli sine iracun●iá para●i sumus . Tuscul. 9. l. 2. I hope such will menage their Exceptions with respect to the Rules of Moderation , ( especially as they have bin laid down in the second paragraph of this Chapter ) .

Neither I conceive is it enough to excuse their Schism , nor to render our Church so immoderate , as not to be communicated with , for any to give some Instances , which according to some Judgments they would have otherwise ; since it is most impossible to have any constitution of things free from all manner of exception ; and also against the most perfect things , great enmities may be raised , for want of equally considering the Principles , Rules , and Ends for which those things were established . Neither is it enough to except against what is faulty in particular Persons , when the same is no vice of the public Constitution . Sure then it may be judged a very unreasonable manner of sundry sorts of Men answering such Discourses as pinch them , namely by catching at some little scattered parts , of the Skirts and Margent of the Cause : Or when they cannot by unbiassed Reasons have victory in their Contest , then they readily fall off to Personal Matters , which in no sort tend to the Merits of any Cause : and by these methods they hope to buoy up the Party , which is the main thing they generally aim at .

§ . 6. Such was the Moderation of our Church when she had any hopes to reduce any of the Romish Profession unto our Communion , she left out of the Public Litany that Clause ; From the Tyranny of the Bishop of Rome , and all his detestible Enormities , Good Lord deliver us .

Yet it may be very proper now to make the same our Petition ( here ) ; adjoining thereunto another seasonable Prayer of Isaac Casaubon's ; O Lord Jesu preserve this Church of England , and give a sound mind to those Nonconformists who deride the Rites and Ceremonies of it * * Faxit Deus ut ad san●orem mentem redeant , Amen . Lud. Capellus . Thes. 51. Salmur . de moresis in Angliâ . .

And since I have named the Learned Casaubon , 't is most suitable here also to add some of his words to King James * * Exercit. in Baron . Ep. D●d . ; Sir , You have a Church in these Kingdoms , partly so framed of old , and partly by great labours of late so restored , that now no Church whatsoever comes nearer than yours to the form of the Primitive flourishing Church , having taken just the middle way between those that offended in excess and defect : In which Moderation the Church of England hath obtein'd this first of all , that those very Persons who envyed her happiness , yet by comparing one with the other , have bin compelled to praise Her .

As for any of those who think it their Interest to decry the Moderation of our Church : We wish first that the Roman Church would once take advice of her own Cassander * * De nimio ●●origore aliquid rem●●●ant , & Ecclesiae paci aliquid concedant . Consult . ad Artic. 7. ; To remit of their immoderate rigour ; and hearkning to the Admonitions of Pious Men , would set themselves to correct manifest abuses , according to the Rule of Divine Scripture , and of the Primitive Church , from which they have swerved .

And that those of the other extreme would practise the Counsel which * * Vt vos ultra modum rigidos esse nolim , ita rursus altos monitos esse cupio , ne sibi in suâ inscitiá nimis placeant . Ep. 200. Calvin gave the English Brethren at Frank fort ; As I would not ( saith he ) have you beyond measure rigid , so again , the rest I desire , they will be advised not to please themselves too excessively in their own ignorance * * Off●●sions suae modum statuere nesciunt ; nam ubi Dominus clementiam exigit , omissâ illâ , totos se immoderatae severitati tradunt . Calv. Inst. l. 4. c. 1. .

For I suppose , that according to the best Reason it may be made out very probable ; that as the overthrow of Popery may as probably be wrought by the growth of its own rigour and immoderate claims , as any way we can imagin † † Inde exitium imminere Pontifici● imperio . A. Sall. votum pr●pace . ; so if any thing in the mean while endanger the Protestant Reformed Interest , it will be the immoderate behaviour of those of the Separation in their Schism against our Church . Between both taking auspicious hopes from the Moderation of our Church : We trust its Constitution being most Primitive , will be also most lasting ¶ ¶ E● demùm tuta est potentia quae viribus suis modum impon●t . Val. Max. de Animi Moder . l. 4. c. 1. in the esteem of the Church Universal , and in the approbation of wise and good Christians .

And while our Church continues thus moderate , it must needs argue the Separation which is from it , to be the more unequal and sinful : For the same Moderation which exonerates the Church of England from the guilt of Schism , with respect to the Romanists , doth aggravate also the Schism of other Separatists ; and however some dissenting Brethren ( while they remain drencht in their Tinctures ) will not be forward to acknowledg the Moderation of our Church , yet we are assured that nothing would more tend to bring People in love with happy Peace and blessed Order ; nothing would contribute more to the quieting Mens Minds , to reconcile all Parties , and to accommodate the most and greatest differences which are among us , than a right and full persuasion of the excellent Temper and Constitution of our Church .

I cannot close a Treatise of the Moderation of the Church of England more properly than with some of the mild and pathetical Soliloquies of our late Blessed Martyr King Charles I. Most merciful God , stir up all Parties pious 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . §. 19. & 16. Ambitions , to overcome each other with Reason , Moderation , and such self-denial as becomes those who consider , that our mutual Divisions are our common Distractions , and the Vnion of all is every Man's chiefest Interest .

Keep Men in a pious Moderation of their Judgments in Matters of Religion .

Give us wisdom to amend what is amiss within us , and there will be less to mend without us .

Evermore defend and deliver thy Church from the Effects of blind Zeal , and over-bold Devotion .

Glory to God in the highest , on Earth Peace , Good Will toward Men.

FINIS .