Ladensium autokatakrisis, the Canterburians self-conviction Or an evident demonstration of the avowed Arminianisme, poperie, and tyrannie of that faction, by their owne confessions. With a post-script to the personate Iesuite Lysimachus Nicanor, a prime Canterburian.

THE MAINE SCOPE And Delineation of the subsequent TREATISE .

CHAP. I.

OUR Adversaries Our Adversaries decline to answer our greatest challenge . are very unwilling to suffer to appeare , that there is any further debait betwixt them and us , but what is proper unto our Church , and doe arise from the Service-Book , Canons , and Episcopacie , which they have pressed upon us with violence , against all order Ecclesiasticall and Civill ; In the meane , least they become the sacrifices of the publick hatred of others in a subtile Sophisticatiō , they labour to hide the notable wrongs and effronts which they have done openly to the Reformed Religion , to the Churches of England , and all the Reformed Churches in the main and most materiall questions debated against the Papists ever since the Reformation ; for such as professe themselves our enemies , and are most busie to stirre up our gracious Prince to armes against us , doe wilfully dissemble their knowledge of any other controversie betweene them and us , but that which properly concerneth us , and rubbeth not upon any other Church .

In this their doing the Judicious may perceive their manifold deceit , whereby they would delude the simple , and many wittie worldlings doe deceive themselves .

First , they would have the world to thinke that we obstinately refuse to obey the Magistrate , in the point of things indifferent : And therefore unnecessarily , and in a foolish precisenesse draw upon our selves the wrath of the King .

Secondly , when in our late Assemblies the order of our Church is made knowne , and the seeds of superstition , heresie , idolatrie , and antichristian tyrannie are discovered in the Service-Booke and Canons , they wipe their mouth , they say : No such thing is meant ; and that we may upon the like occasion blame the Service-Booke of England .

Thirdly , when by the occasion of the former quarrellings , their palpable Poperie and Arminianisme are set before their eyes , and their perverse intentions , desires , and endeavours of the change of Religon and Lawes , are upon other grounds then upon the Service-Booke and Canons objected against them : they stopp their eares , or at last shut their mouthes , and answer nothing . This Challenge they still decline and misken ; they will not let it be heard , let be to answer to it ; And for to make out their tergiversation , and to dash away utterly this our processe , they have beene long plying their great engine ; and at last have wrought their yond most myne to that perfection , that it is now readie to spring under our wals . By their flattering calumnies they have drawn the Prince againe to arms , for the overthrow of us their challengers , and for the affrighting by the terrour of armies on foot of all others elsewhere , from commencing any such action against them .

As for us , The scope of the Treatise . truely it were the greatest happinesse wee doe wish for out of Heaven , to live peaceably in all submission and obedience under the wings of our gracious Soveraigne , and it is to us a bitternesse as gall , as wormwood , as death to be necessitated to any contest , to any contradictorie tearmes , let bee an armed defence , against any whom he is pleased to defend ; Yea certainly it were the great joy of our heart , to receive these very men , our mortall enemies , into the armes of our affection , upon any probable signes in them , of their sincere griefe , for the hudge wrongs they have intended , and done to their Mother-Church and Countrie . But when this felicitie is denyed , and nothing in them , doeth yet appeare but induration , and a malicious obstinacie , going on madly through a desperate desire of revenge , to move a very sweete Prince for their cause to shed his owne blood , to rent his owne bowels , to cut off his owne members , what shall wee doe but complaine to GOD , and offer to the worlds eyes the true cause of our sufferings , the true grounds of this Episcopall warre , or rather not Episcopall , but Canterburian broyle : for we judge sundrie Bishops in the yle to be very free of these mischiefes , and beleeve that divers of them would gladly demonstrate their innocencie , if so bee my Lord of Canterburie and his dependants , were in any way to receive from the Kings justice some part of their deservings .

Howsoever , that wee may give a testimonie to the truth of God , which wee are like at once to seale with our blood , wee will offer to the view of all Reformed Churches , and above the rest to our acer●st and sibbest sister of England , as it were in a table , divers of these errours , which our partie first by craft and subtilitie , but now by extreame violence of fire and Sword , are labouring to bring upon us ; to the end that our deare Brethren , understanding our sufferings in the defence of such a cause , may bee the more willing at this time to contribute for our assistance from God , the helpe of their earnest Prayers , and for ever hereafter to condole with the more hearty compassion , any misery which possibly may befall us , in such a quarrell .

All our plea is but one cleare syllogisme . Albeit truely our hopes are yet greater then our feares , if we could become so happie as once to get our plea but entered before our Prince ; for we can hardlie conceave what in reason should hinder our full assurance of a favorable decision from that Sacred mouth , whose naturall equitie the World knowes in all causes whereof hee is impartially informed , since our whole action is ● u●ht but one formall argument , whereof the M●j r is ●he verdict of our judge , the Minor shal be the open and ●●●w●d Testimonie of our partie , need we feare th●● either our judge or partie will bee so irrationall as to v●nture upon the denyall of a conclusion , whereof both the premisses is their owne open profession .

Our Major is this : The Major thereof . Who ever in the Kings Dominions spreads abroad Poperie , or any Doctrine opposite to the Religion , and Lawes of the Land , now established , ought not to bee countenanced , but severely punished by the King . This Major the King hath made certaine t● us in his frequent most solemne asseverations , not onely at his coronation both here and in England , in his proclamations both here and there , (a) (a) Neither shall we ever give way to the authorizing of any t●●ng , wherby any innovation many steal or creep into the Church but shall preserve that unitie of doctrine & disc●pline , established ●n Q. Elizabeths reign , wherby the Church of England have stood & flou● s●ed since . Proclam . dissolving the Parl of England , 1628. and therefore o●ce for all we have thought fit to declare , and hereby to assure all our good people , that we neit●er were , are , nor ever ( by the grace of God ) shall bee slained with popish superstition , but by the con●tarie , are resolved to maintain the true Protestant Christian religion , already professed within this our ancient Kingdom . We neither intend innovation in religion or lawes , proclam . ●une 8. 1638. to free al our good subjects of t●e least su●pition of any intent on in us , to innovate any thing , either in religion or lawes , and to sati fie not onely their desires , but even their doubts . We have discharged , &c. proclam : Septemb 22. 1638. and to give all his Maj. people full assurance , that he never intended to admit any al●eration or change in the true religō , pofessed wi●●in this kingdome , and that they may be truely and fully satisfied of the realitie of his intentions , and integritie of the same , his Maj. hath been pleased to require & command all his good Subjects , to subscribe the confession of Faith , formerly signed by his dear Father , in anno 1580. and it is his Maj will , that this be insert and registrat in the books of Assembly , as a testimony to p●steritie , not only of the sinceritie of his intentions to the said true religion , but also of his resolution to maintaine and defend the same , and his Subjects in the pro●ession thereof , proclam . Decemb. 18. 1638. but also in his late large declaration , oftimes giving out his resolution to live and die in the reformed protestant religion , opposite to all Poperie ; to maintaine his established lawes ; and in nothing to permitt the enervating of them : Yea , this resolution of the king is so peremptor , & publickly avowed , th●t Canterburie himselfe dare not but applaud thereto ; (b) (b) If any Prelate would labour to bring in the superstitions of the Church of Rome , I doe not onely leave him to Gods judgement , but if his irreligious falshood can bee discovered , also to shame and severe punishment from the State , and in any just way , no mans hands should bee sooner against him then mine . in his Starre chamber speech , who can seeme more foreward then he for the great equitie , to punish condignlie all who would but mind to bring in any Poperie in this Isle , or assay to make any innovation in Religion or Lawes .

Wee beleeve indeed that my Lord Canterburie doth but juggle with the world in his fair ambiguous generalities , being content to invegh as much against poperie and innovation as we could wish , upon hopes ever when it comes to any particular of the grossest poperie we can name , by his subtile distinctions and disputations to slide out of our hands : But wee are perswaded what ever may be the jugling of sophisticating Bishops , yet the magnanimous ingenuitie , the royall integritie of our gracious Soveraigne is not compatible with such fraudulent equivocations , as to proclaime his detestation of poperie in generals , and not thereby to give us a full assurance of his abhorring every particular , which all the orthodox Preachers of this Isle since the reformation by Queene Elizabeth and King Iames allowance hath ever condemned as popish errours . Our Major then wee trust may be past as unquestionable .

Wee subjoyne our Minor ; The Minor . But so it is that Canterburie and his dependars , men raised , and yet maintained by him , have openly in their printed bookes , without any recantation or punishment to this day spread abroad in all the Kings Dominions , doctrines , opposite to our Religion and Lawes , especially the most points of the grossest poperie . In reason all our bickering ought to be here alone . This Minor I offer to instruct , and that by no other middes then the testimonie of their owne pens . If J doe so to the full satisfaction of all , who know what are the particular heads of the reformed Religion , and what the Tenets of Poperie ●pposite thereto ; what are the Lawes standing in all the thr●e Dominions , and what the contrarie maximes of the Turkish Empire , wherewith Matchivelists this day every where are labouring to poyson the eares of all Christian Princes , for enervating the Lawes and Liberties of their Kingdomes : I hope that reason and justice which stand night and day attending on either side of King Charles Throne , will not faile to perswade the chearfull embracement of the conclusion , The conclusion . which followes by a cleare and naturall necessitie , from the forenamed premisses , to witt , that Canterburie and his dependars in all the three Dominions ought not to be countenanced by the King , but severally punished : Let be that for their pastime a bloodie & hazardous warre , should be raised in so unseasonable a time , for the undoing of that countrie , and church , which God hath honoured with the birth , and baptisme , both of his Majesties owne person , and of his renowned Father , and to the which both of them as all their hundreth and six glorious Predecessours , are endebted before God and the World , all their Prerogatives both of nature , grace and estate , so much as any Princes were ever to their mother church , & native Countrie .

CHAP. II. The Canterburians avowed Arminianisme .

ARminianisme how great and dangerous an inn●●ation of the Reformed Religion it is , Arminianisme ● great and dangerous innovation o● Religion . wee m y learne by the late experiences of our neigh●ours , when that weed began to spread among 〈◊〉 . The States of Holland have declared in many p●ssages of their Dordracen Synod , that they found it a more readie meane to overthrow both their Church and State , then all the engines , Policies , armes which the Pope , and Spaniard , in any bygan time had used ●gainst them .

The Church of France the other yeare , when Amir●t , and Testard , and some few of their Divines , were but surmised to incline a little towards some small twigs of one article of Arminius , was so affrighted , that they rested not till in a generall assembly at Paris , they did runne together for the extinguishing of the first sparkes , as it were of a common fire .

When Barrow in Cambridge began to run a little on this rock , how careful was my Lord of Canterburie and the Bishops than in the meeting at Lambeth , for the crushing of that Cokatrice in the egge ; when that Serpent againe in the same place began , to sett up the nose in the writtes of Thomson , how carefull were the Bishops then by the hand of their brother of Salisburie Doctor Abbots to cutt off the head of that monster .

But what speake wee of the Churches Reformed ? The very Synagogue of Rome , whose conscience is enlarged as the Hell to swallow downe the vile●● morsels of the most lewd errours that Antichrist can present , yet did they stick much at this bone , when the Iesuite Molina began to draw out these dreggs of Pelagianisme from the long neglected pitts of some obscure Schoolemen , what clamours were raised there , not onely by Alvarez and his followers but ulso by numbers of Prelates and some great Princes , till the credit of the Iesuites in the Court of Rome , and the wisedome of the Consistorie prognosticating a new Rent in their Church , did procure from the Pope a peremptorie injunction of silence to both sides , on all highest paines : hoping if the Dominicans mouthes were once stopped , that the Iesuites by their familiar arts , and silent Policies , would at last worke out their intended point , which indeed since that time , they have well neare by fully gained .

But to King Charles eye no evidence useth to bee so demonstrative as that which commeth from the learned hand of his blessed Father . Would wee know how gracious a Plant Arminianisme and the dressers of it will prove in England , or any where else , advise with King Iames , King Iames judgement of Arminianisme . who after full triall and long consultation about this emergent , with the Divines of his Court , especially the late archbishop Abbots gave out at last his Decreet in print , and that in Latine , not onely for a present declaration to the States of Holland of his minde against Vorstius , and a cleare Confession of his Faith in those points to the Christian World , but above all to remaine a perpetuall Register for his heirs and successours , of his faithfull advise , if after his death their Kingdomes should be ever in danger to bee pestered with that wicked seed .

In that treatise , his Majestie doth first (a) (a) Declarat . contr. Vorst . pag. 15. Non erubescit ita crasse mentiri , ut affirmet haereses libro suo expressas á professione Ecclesiae Anglicanae non dissentire . avow all them to be grosse lyers , who doe not blush to affirme that any of the Arminian articles , even that most plausable one of the Saints apostasie are consonant with the Doctrine or articles of the Church of England . (b) (b) Ibid. pag. 12. Gnaviter impudens & ferreioris . Hee stileth Bertius for such a slander , a very impudent and brazen faced man . 2. (c) (c) Ibid. pag. 18 Detestandae haereses novitor , exortae maturè exstinguēdae , & ad usque inferos unde manarunt relegandae . He pronounceth these Doctrines of Arminius to be heresies lately revived and damnable to the hells , from whence they come . 3. (d) (d) Ibid. pag 12. Sola inscriptio clamat igni damnandum . That Bertius for the very title of his booke , The Saints apostacie , deserved burning . 4. (e) (e) Ibid. pag. 14. Inimicus Deo Arminius ▪ cujus discipuli pestes , arrogantes , haeritici , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 sectarij . That A●minius and his Schollers were to be reputed pests , enemies to God , proud , schismaticall , hereticall , Atheists . 5. (f) (f)

Ibid. pag. 15. A Deo maledictionem , apud . Ecclesias omnes infamiam , in Republicam perpetuam , distractionem .

The great increase of Arminians in Scotland by Canterburies meanes .

Hee affirmeth that their tolleration would not faile to bring upon the heads of their toleraters let be favourers , Gods malediction , an evill report , slander and infamie with all the Churches abroad , and certaine Schisme , division and tumults at home .

Shall wee then make any doubt of King Charles full contentment that we avow Arminianisme to bee such a dangerous innovation in our Religion as the Reformed Churches abroad , and his Father at home hath taught us to count it where ever it is found .

Notwithstanding this bitter roote amongst us was setting up the head of late very boldly in all the prime pl●ces of our Kingdome ; wee have had since the reformation many bickerings about the Church government and Ceremonies , but in matters of Doctrine never any controversie was knowne , till some yeares agoe a favourable aire from the mouth of Doctor Laud at Court began to blow upon these unhappie seeds of Arminius . No sooner was those south-winds sensible in our climate , but at once in S. Andrews , Edinburgh , Aberdeen , and about Glasgow that weed began to spring amaine .

Doctour Wederburne in the new Colledge of S. Andrews did stuffe his dictates to the younge Students in Divinitie with these errours . This man upon the feares of our Churches censure , having fled the Countrie , was very tenderly embraced by his Grace at Court , and well rewarded with a faire Benefice in England for his labours ; But to the end his talents should not lye hid , although a man very unmeete either for preaching or government , hee was at once sent downe to us , without knowledge of our Kirk , by Canterburies onely favour to be Bishop of Dumblane , for this purpose mainly that in the Royall Chappell , whereof that Bishop is alwayes Dean , hee might in despite of all our Presbyteries weive out the webbe hee had begun in S. Andrews . So at once there was erected a society of twentie foure Royall Chapplains , who were thought fittest of the whole Cleargie of the Kingdome , to be allured with hopes of favour from Court , to preach to the State , the Deans Armiminian tenets .

In Edinburgh M. Sydserfe did partly play his part , and for the reward of his boldnesse , had cast in his lap in a trace the Deanrie of Edinburgh , the Bishoprick of Brechan , and last of Galloway , with full hopes in a short time of an Archbishops cloake .

In the North , Doctour Forbes the onely Father of the most of those who fell away from the doctrine of our Church , came to good speed in his evill labours and for his paines was honoured with the first seate in the new erected chayre of our principall citty .

Others about Glasgow made their preaching of the Arminian errours the pathway to their assured advancement .

In our generall Assembly we found that this cockle was comming up apace in verie manie furrowes of our field ; Some of it we were forced , albeit to our great griefe , to draw up & cast over the dike , which at once was received and replanted in England in too good a soyle .

We confesse that it happened not much beside our expectation , that our Arminians The Kings names stolen by Canterburie to the defēce of Arminians . after the censure of our Church should at Court have beene to graciously received and sheltered in the sanctuarie of his Grace at Lambeth ; But this indeed did and doth astonish us all , that any should have beene so bold as to have stolen King Charles name to a printed Declaration , wherein not onely our generall Assembly is condemned for using any censure at all against any for the crime of Arminianisme ; (g) (g) Large declar . pag. 74. According to their weake and poore power they did determine controversies concerning predestination , universal grace irresistibilitie of grace , concurrance in grace , and other such like intricate points , that some men would be loath to live so long as they could make them understand them . But also Arminius articles are all utterly slighted and pronounced to be of so obscure and intricate a nature , that both our Assembly was to peart to make any determination about them , and that many of our number were altogether unable by any teaching ever to winne so much as to the understanding of the very questions : (h) (h) Some Mininisters were dedepr●ved for Armini●●isme , a course never heard off ●n any p●ace where any rule of justice was observed , that a Min ster should bee deprived for holding any Tenet , which is not against t●e doctri e of that Church wherin he liveth , and that before it be prohibited & condemned by that Church . Now there is nothing in the confession of that Church against these Tenets . Yea , those articles are avowed to be consonant , and in nothing to bee opposite to the Confession of our Church , and are freely absolved of all Poperie .

(i) (i) Pag. 303. They could no answer when it was told them th se Tenets , could not b●e counted Popish , concerning which , or the chiefe of which as learned Papists as any in the world , the Dominicans & Iesuites did differ as much as th● Pro●estants , and tha● those which doe adhere to the Augustin confession , did hold hat side of ●hose Tenets . w●ich the Arminians did hold , and yet they were very far rom beeing Papists , beeing the first Pro●estants , and there ore it was a●ainst all sen●e ●o condemne that for P perie wh c● was held by many Pro●ella●ts Churches , and reject by many learned Papists . Because indeed ( for this is the onely reason ) some learned Papists finde divers of Arminius points to be so absurd , that their stomackes cannot away with them , and some of the Lutherian divines agree with the Arminians in certaine parcels of some of their articles . They must be strangers in these questions , who are ignorant in how many things the Dominicans and all Papists agree with Arminius , and in how many the Lutherans disagree from him . However wee were and are amazed to see Canterburie so malapeart , as to proclame in the Kings name , beside many other strange things , the articles of Arminius , to bee so farre above the capacitie of our generall Assembly , that it deserves a Royall reproofe for minting to determine any thing in them , and that they are no wayes contrary to the doctrine of our Church , neither any wayes Popish , and that for a reason , which will exeeme from the note of Poperie every errour which is so grosly absurd , that some learned Papists are forced to contradict it , or some grosse Lutheran can gett his throat extended to swallow it downe .

This boldnesse can not in any reason bee imputed to our gracious Soveraigne ; For how is it possible that hee upon any tollerable information , should ever have suffered himselfe to be induced to write or speake in such a straine of these things which so lately by his learned Father was declared in print , and that in Latine to be no lesse then heresies , worthie of burning ; yea , damnable to the very infernall pitt ; whence as he sayes , they did first come up . Neither is it like that these Sentences come from the heart of D. Balcanquell the penman of them ; For hee was a member of Do●t Synod , and brought up in the Church of Scotland , the man is not unseene in the Popish Tenets ; How is it p●ssible that his conscience should absolve the Arminian errours of all Poperie , and all contrarietie to the Scotish confession .

May any be so uncharitable , as to suspect his late promotion in Durhame , hath altered so soone his minde ? Sure not long since , both in England and Scotland , he did desire to be esteemed by his friends , one of those whom Canterburie did maligne , and hold downe for his certaine and knowne resolutions , and reputed abilitie to oppose his Graces Arminian , and Popish innovations .

His Majestie being certainly cleare of this imputation , and readily also Balcanquell , the amanuense , on whom can the fault lye but Canterburie , the directors back ? For the world knowes , that on his shoulders for common alone , the King doth devolve the trust of all Bookish and Ecclesiasticall affaires that concernes him , that at his commandement hee hath written in the Kings name that part at the least of the declination , which patronizeth the Arminians persons and cause , we doe not conjecture , but demonstrate by the constant & avowed course of his Graces carriage , in advancing Arminianisme at all occasions , in all the Kings Dominions .

That this may appeare , consider his practises , not so much among us , as in the Irish Church , The Irish Church infected with Arminianisme by Canterburie . where yet his hand is very nimble , to set these ungratious plants , and to nippe off all the overspreading branches of any tree that may overtop them ; For who else in a moment , hath advanced D. Bramble , not onely to the Sea of Derrie , but to be the Kings Vicar Generall ?

Who sent D. Chappell first to the Universitie of Dubline , and then to his Episcopall Chaire ?

Who holds downe the head of that Orthodox P●imat , and of all who have any zeale there to the truth of God ?

Who caused not onely refuse the confirmation of these Antiarminian articles of Ireland , in the last Parliament , but threatned also to burne them by the hand of the hang-man ? Whose invention are these privie articles , which his Creature my Lord of Derry presents to diverse who take Orders from his holy hands ?

We will passe these and such other effects , which the remote rayes of his Graces countenance doe produce in so great a distance ; Onely behold ! How great an increase that unhappie plant hath made there in England , where his eye is neerer to view , and his hand to water it . The Canterburians in England teach the first and second article of Arminianisme .

In the 25. yeare , at the very instant of King James death , D. Montagu , with D. Whites approbation , did put to the presse all the articles of Arminius in the same fearmes , with the same arguments and most injurious calumniations of the Orthodox doctrine , as Spalato and the Remonstrants had done a little before , but with this difference , that where those had dipped their pennes in inke , D. Montagu doth write with venegar & gall , in every other line , casting out the venome of his bitter Spirit , on all that cometh in his way , except they be fowles of his own feather ; for oft when he speakes of Iesuites , Cardinals , Popes , hee annoynts his lips with the sweetest honey , and perfumes his breath with the most cordiall tablets . If any doe doubt of his full Arminianisme , let them cast up his Appeale , and see it clearly , (k) (k) Appeal , p. 60. I professe my through & sincere dissent from the faction of novellizing Puritans , but in no point more them in the doctrine of desperate predestination . Ibid. p. 70. I see no reason why any of the divines of our Church present at the Synod of Dort , should take any offence at my dissenting , who had no authoritie that J know of to conclude me , more then I doe at them , for d●ffering from me in their judgment , quisque abundet in suo sensu . Ibid. pag. 71. I am sure the Church of England never so determined in her doctrine . Ibid. pag. 72 , at the conference of Hamptoun-court , before his Majestie , by D. Bancroft , that doctrine of irrespective predestination was stiled against the articles of Lambeth , then urged by the Pur●tans , a desperate doctrine , without reproof or taxation of any . Ibid. pag. 50 , your absolute , necessarie , determined , irresistible , irrespective decree of God , to call , save , and glorifie S. Peter , for instance infalliblie , without any consideration had off , or regard unto his faith , obedience , repentance : J say it truely , it is the fancie of some particular men . in the first and second Article of Election and Redemption , he avoweth his aversnesse from the Doctrine of Lambeth and Dort , which teacheth , that God from eternitie did elect us to grace & salvation , not for any consideration of our faith , workes , or any thing in us as causes , respects , or conditions , antecedent to that decree , but onely of his meere mercy ; And that from this Election all our faith , workes , and perseverance doe flow as effects . Hee calleth this the private fansie of the Divines of Dort , opposite to the Doctrine of the Church of England ; For this assertion he slandereth the Synod of L●mbeth , as teachers of desperate doctrine , and would father this foule imputation , but very falsly on the Conference at Hamptoun Court .

(l) (l) Ibid. pag. 61 , 64. I shall as I can briefly set downe what I conceive of this of Gods decree of predestination , se●ting by all execution of purpose : this farre we have gone , and no word yet of predestination , for how could it be in a paritie ? T●ere must ●e first conceived a disproportion , before there can be conceived an Election or dereliction : God had compassion of men in the masse of perdition , upon singulos generum , & genera singulorum , and out of his love , motu mero , no o●herwise stretched out to them deliverance , in a Mediator the Man Iesus Christ , and drew them out that tooke hold of mercie , leaveing them there that would none of him . Againe he avoweth positively , that faith goeth before Election , and that to all the lost race of Adam alike , Gods mercie in Christ is propounded till the parties free-will , by beleeving or mis-beleeving , make the disproportion antecedent to any divine either election , or reprobation .

One of the reasons why King Iames stiled Arminius disciples A●heists , Why King Iames stiled them Atheists . was , because their first article of condi●ionall Election did draw them by an inevitable necessitie to the maintenance of Vorstian impiety ; For make me once Gods eternall decree posterior and dependant from faith , repentance , perseverance , and such works , which they make flow from the free-will of changeable men ; that decree of God will bee changeable , it will be a separable accident in him ; God will be a composed substance of subject , & true accidents , no more an absolute simple essence , and so no more God . Vorstius ingenuitie in professing this composition is not misliked by the most learned of the Belgick Arminians , who use not as many of the English , to deny the clear consequēces of their doctrine , if they be necessary , though never so absurd . However in this very place Montagu maintaines very Vorstian Atheisme , as expresly as any can doe , making the divine essence to be finite , his omnipresence not to bee in substance , but in providence , (m) (m) Appeale p. 49. the Stoicks among others held that paradox of old , Deum ire per omne terras tractusmaris , coelumque profundum . They meant it subst●ntially , and so impiously . Christians doe hold it too , but disposively in his providence . and so making God to be no G●d . This , though long agoe by learned Featlie , objected in print to Montagu , lyes still upon him without any clearing . Certainly our Arminians in Scotland were begun both in word and writt to undertake the dispute ; for all that Vorstius had printed ; I speake what I know , and have felt oft to my great paines .

Arminianisme is a chaine , any one linck wherof , but specially the first will draw all the rest , yet see the other also expressed by Montagu . In the articles of grace and freewill , They teach the third and fourth article . not onelie he goes cleare with the Arminians , teaching that mans will hath ever a facultie to resist , and oftimes according to the Doctrine of the Church of England , actually doth resist , reject , frustrate , and overcoms the most powerfull acts of the spirit and grace of God , even those which are employed about regeneration , sanctification , justification , perseverance . (n) (n) Appeal . p. 89. S. Steven in terminis hath the very word 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , you resist , nay , fall crosse with the holy Ghost , not suffering him to worke grace in you . If the Counsell meaned it de gratia excitante , praeveniente operante ; I think no man will deny it de gratia adiuvante , subsequente , cooperante ; there is without question in the naturall will of a regenerate man so much carnal concupiscence , as may make him resist and rebell against the Law of the Spirit . And if a man justified may fall away from grace , which is the doctrine of the Church of England , then without question your selves being judges , he may resist the grace of God offered . Not onely doeth he thus farre proceed , but also he avowes , that all the difference which is betwixt the Church of England & Rome , in this head of freewill , to be in nothing materiall , ( a ) & reallie long agoe to be ended and agreed amongst the most judicious and sober of both the sides . (o) (o) Ibid. p. 95. Thus having with as great diligence as I could examined this question inter partes of free-will , I doe ingenuously confesse , that I can not finde any such materiall difference betweene the Pontificians , at least of better temper , and our Church .

For the fifth Also the fifth . of perseverance , he is as grosse as any other Remonstrant or Molinean Iesuite , professing , that no man in this life can have more assurance not to fall away both totally and finally from all the grace he gets , then the divels (p) (p) Antigag . p. 161. Man is not likely in the State of grace to be of an higher alloy then angels were in the state of glory , then Adam was in the state of innocencie . Now if Adam in paradise , and Lucifer in heaven did fall and losse their originall estate , the one totally , & the other eternally , what greater assurance hath any man in the state of proficiencie , not of consumatiō had once in heaven , and Adam once in paradise .

Behold the Arminian ensigne fairly now displayed in England by the the hands of Montagu and White , under the conduct of D. Laud , Bishop of S. Davids , even then the President and chiefe of Ecclesiasticall affaires , of the Duke of Buckinghames secret Counsel . At the first sight of this black banner , a number of brave Champions got to their armes ; pulpits over all England rang , presses swat against the boldnesse of that , but small hand full then of courtizing Divines . Their craftie leader seeing the spight of opposition , and finding it meet for a little to hold in , and fold up his displayed colours , did by the Duke his Patron perswade the expediency of that pollicie , which the Iesuites had immediately before , for that same very designe moved the Roman consistorie to practise . He obtained a Proclamation , commanding silence to both sides , Silence by proclamation injoyned to both sides . discharging all preaching , all printing in these controversies , a stricting to the cleare , plaine and very grammaticall sense of the articles of England in these points , without all further deductions . By this means his intentiōs were much promoved , open avowers of Arminianisme were by publicke authority so ex●emed from any censure , a reall Libertie was thus proclaimed over all the Land , for any who pleased to embrace Arminianisme without opposition .

Hereby in two or three yeares the infection spread so farre and broad , that the Parliament was forced in the 28. to make the encrease of Arminianisme The Arminians in England advanced . their chiefe grievance to his Majestie ; But at that time D. Laud was growne greater . He had mounted up from the Bath to London , and to make a shew there in Parliament of his power , in the eye of all the complainers , hee raised up Montagu to the Episcopall Chaire of his owne Diocesan , D. Carletoun , who had lately chastised him in print for his Arminian appeal . D. White his other chiftane , that all great spirits might be encouraged to run the wayes which D. Laud pointed out to them , in despight of these Parliamentarie Remonstrants , was advanced from Bishoprick to Bishoprick , till death at the step of Elie did interrupt the course of his promotion , that to Wren a third violent follower of his Arminian Tenets , way might be made for to climb up the remaining steps of the Ladder of his Honours .

Now to the end that the world may know , that my lord of Canterburie doth nothing blush at the advancement of such men , heare what a publicke Testimony of huge worth and deserving , hee caused his Herauld Peter Heylen to proclaime to that Triumvirat , not onely at his owne directions , ( for that moderate answer of Heylens is the Iusto volumine , which his G. did promise to the World in his Starre Chamber-speach ) but also in name of Authoritie ; If Heylen lye not , who sayes : Hee writes that booke at the commandement of the state : There after the cryasse of Canterburies owne extraordinarie praises (q) (q) A moderate answer , pag. 78. you will be troubled to finde Canterburies equall in our Church , since K. Edwards reformation , whether yee look to his publick or pr●vate demeanours . the renown of his three underleaders , is loudly sounded as of plaine non-suches . (r) (r) Ibid. pag 84. White , Montagu , and Wren , whom you so abuse , are such , who for their endeavours for this Churches honour , fidelitie in their service to the King , full abilities in learning , have had no equals in this Church , since the Reformation .

All these his Graces favours to his followers , Their opposites disgraced and persecuted . would have beene the more tolerable if hee would have permitted his orthodox opposites to have had some share in their Princes affection , or at least have lived in peace in their owne places . But behold , all that crosses his way must downe , were they the greatest Bishops in the Dominions . For who else wrought the late Arch-bishop so farre out of the Kings grace , that he remained some yeares before his death well near confined to his house at Lambeth ? Who hath caused to be caged up in the tower that great & learned Bishop of Lincolne ? what ever else may bee in the man . What fray makes that worthie Primate Vsher to foretell oft to his friends his expectation , to bee sent over Sea , to dye a pedant teaching boyes for his bread , by the persecution of this faction , whose wayes he avowes to many , doth tend to manifest Arminianisme and Poperie . This their resolution to persecute with all extremitie , every one who shall mint to print or preach any thing against Arminianisme , they avow it openly , not onely by deeds ( for why else was poore Butter cast by Canterburie in the Fleet for printing of B. Davenants letter to B. Hall against some passage of A●minianisme at the Authours direction as we see it set downe by Huntly in his Breviate ) but even in open print , for when Burton complaines to the King that he was silenced by Canterburie for expounding of his ordinary text Rom. 8 : Whom God had predestinate those he hath called , and applying it to the present Pelagianisme and Poperie of the Arminians , Christopher Dow (s) (s) Chr. Dow. Answer to Burton . Mr. Burton did preach on the highest point of predestination in a controverted way with disputes and clamarous invectives against those who dissented from him in opinion , his questioning & suspending for this cause , was nothing contrary to his Majesties declarations . Ibid. pag. 40. Bee it so that the doctrine of election , effectuall vocation , assurance o● perseverance , are by the Kings declaration suppress●d , rather then the peace of the Church should be disturbed , we might truely say of that time when his Majesties declaration was published , that men were uncapable of these doctrines , when men began to chyde , and to count each other Anathema , as it was with our neighbours , it began to be with us , was it not time to enjoyne both sides silence ? By this meanes you say , there is no Minister , not one among thousand that dare clearely preach of these most comfortable doctrines , and so soundly confute the Arminian heresie . Blessed be God that there are so few who dare , and I wish those few who dare , had shewed more obedience to his Majestie . approven by Canterburies Chaplane , & P. Helen directed to speake for Canterburie himselfe doth not stand to affirme , that this was a cause well deserving all the sufferings he complained off .

Canterburie & his followers contrary to the proclamation , goe on still to print , let be to preach their Tenets . Could any here but expect of his Graces wisdome and loyaltie , when his sollicitude appeareth to disgrace and punish without respect of persons all who in contempt , as hee saith , of the Kings proclamation will not desist from the publick oppugning of Arminianisme , that on the other hand the preachers & printers for Arminianisme according to that same proclamation should be put to some order ; yet this is so far neglected , that all who are so affected , Cousins , Colin●s , Beel in Cambridge , Potter and Iackson in Oxfoord , and many more prime Doctours in both Universities in the cittie , in the Court , and over all the Land , boldly give out their minde to all they meete with , for the advancement of the new way , yea boldnesse in running those pathes hath beene knowne to have beene the high way in all the three Dominions these yeares bygone to certaine promotion in many men who to the worlds eyes had no other singular eminencie of any good parts .

But that his Graces tramping upon the Kings Proclamation may be yet the more evident , behold how he doth dayly dispense both with his owne pen and those also of his friends to write and print for Arminianisme what they please .

White being taxed by Burtoun for his subscription to Montagous appeal , is so far from the least retractation , that the fift article of Apostacie & uncertaintie of salvation , which Burton did single out of all Montagous errours , as most opposite to Christian comfort , he maintaines it in his owne answer to the Dialogue ; but as the custome now is under the covert of some Fathers name , at great length with much bitternesse , and casts out without provocation in his Treatise of the Sabboth , the first and second article (t) (t) P. 82. The benefitt of redemption , by the antecedent will of Christ is intended to all men living , though all men by reason of their own demerits doe not actually receive the Fruit of it . Voluntas antecedens est voluntas primaria & beneplacitum Dei ex eius nativa propensione existens , nullamque sumans occasionem ex nobis . Mr. Dow and Schelfoord use the same plainesse . Yea , in the 31. yeare that faction was so malapeart , as to set out the historicall narration , by one M. A. Ileward , wherein all the Articles of Arminius at length , with these false and bitter calumniations of our doctrine ; Which are usually chanted and rechanted by the Remonstrants , are not onely sett downe as truths , but also fathered upon the first reformers & Martyrs of England .

That booke when it had beene out a while , was called in , not because the Doctrines were false , not because the storie was forged , as that learned Knight S. Vmphrey Lyne by the ocular inspection of the originall manuscript did since demonstrate , but the only reason of the calling of it backe , as his Grace makes Heylen declare to us , was , the dinne and clamour which Burtown , then one of the Ministers of London , made against it . (w) (w) Moderat answer , p. 121. The Historicall narration was called in also for your pleasure .

Canterburie himselfe is nothing afrayed to lend his own hand to pull downe any thing that seemes crosse to Arminianisme . The certainty of salvation , the assurance of election , is such an eyesore , that to have it away , hee stands not with his owne hand to cutt and mangle the very Lyturgie of the Church , otherwise a sacred peace , and a noli me tangere in England in the smallest points , were they never so much by any censured of errour : Yet if any clause crosse Arminianisme or Poperie , his Grace doth not spare without dinne to expurge it , did it stand in the most eminent places thereof in the very morning prayers for the Kings person :

Here there was this clause fixed since the reformation ( who art the Father of thine Elect and their Seed ) this seemed to be a publike profession , that it was not unlawfull for King Charles to avow his certainty and perswasion that God was his Father , and hee his adopted Childe , elect to salvation . His Grace could not endure any longer such a scandalous speach to be● uttered , but with his owne hand scrappeth it out . Beeing challenged for it by Burtoun , and the out-cryes of the people , hee confesseth the Fact ; Onely for excuse , bringeth three reasons , of which you may judge : (x) (x) Star-chamber speach , p. 28 It was put out at the Ks. direction , in my predecessours time when the king had no children . First hee saith , It was done in his predecessours time ; Doth not this make his presumption the more intollerable , that any inferiour Bishopp , living at the very lugge of the Archbishop , should mint to expurge the Lyturgie . Secondly , Hee pretends the Kings command for his doing .

Doth not this encrease his guiltinesse , that he and his followers are become so wicked and irrespective , as to make it an ordinare pranke , to cast their owne misdeeds upon the broad back of the Prince . Dare hee say , that the King commanded any such thing motu proprio ? Did hee command that expunction without any information , without any mans advise ? Did any King of England ever assay to expurge the publike Bookes of the Church , without the advice of his Cleargie ? Did ever King Charles medle in any Church matters of farre lesse importance , without D. Lauds counsell ?

The third excuse : That the King then had no Seed . How is this pertinent ? May not a childlesse man say in his prayers , that God is the Father of the Elect , and of their Seed , though himselfe as yet have no Seed ? But the true cause of his anger against this passage of the Leiturgie , seemeth to have beene none other then this Arminian conclusion ; that all faith of election in particular , of personall adoption or salvation , is nought but presumption :

That this is his Graces faith , may appeare by his Chaplans hand , at that base and false storie of Ap-Evan by Studly , wherin are bitter invectives against all such perswasions as puritanik delusions , (y) (y) Satan like an Angell of Light stirring up in the heart of immortified persons a spirituall pride in a high conceit of their gifts , the assurance of their Election , illumination , conversiō , imaginarie sense of their adoptiō , &c. yea , he is contented that Chounaeus should print over and over againe his unworthie collections , not onely subscribed by his Chaplane , but dedicated to himselfe , wherein salvation is avowed to be a thing unknown , and whereof no man can have any further , or should wish for any more then a good hope . (z) (z) Pag. 82. Salus eorum satis certa quamvis ipsis ignota , ex gratia & infinita sua misericordia det Deus hanc spem & sua vissiman huius spei plerophoriam , ampliorē non expectamus , And if any desire a clearer confession , behold himselfe in those oposcula posthuma of Andrewes , which he setteth out to the world after the mans death , & dedicates to the King : avowing that the Church of England doth maintaine no personall perswasion of predestination , which Tenet Cardinall Pirroun had obiected to them as presumption . (z) (z) Stricturae , we think it not safe for any man peremptorily to presume himself predestinat . White also in his answer to the Dialogue , makes mans election a misterie , which God hath so hid in his secret counsell , that no man , can in this life come to any knowledge , let be assurance of it , at great length from the 97. page to the 103. and that most plainly .

A demonstration of Canterburies Arminianisme in the highest degree . But to close this Chapter , passing a number of evidences , I bring but one more , which readily may be demonstrative , though all other were layd aside . By the Lawes and practickes of England , a Chaplans licencing of a booke for the presse is taken for his Lord the Bishops deed ; So Helen approven by Canterburie teacheth in his Antidotum , (a) (a) Pag. 3. Or if you be so dull as not to apprehend that , yet must the publishing of this Libel rest in conclusion on my Lord high Thesauror the Bishop of London at whose house the booke was licentiate , which is so high a language against authoritie , against the practise of this Realme , for licenciating of bookes against the honour of the Star-chamber , on whose decree that practise is founded , &c. and for this there is reason , for the Lawes give authoritie of Licencing to no Chaplane , but to their Lords alone , who are to bee answerable for that which their Servant doeth in their name . Also the Chaplane at the Licencing receives the principall subscrived Copie which he delivereth to his Lord : to be laid up in his Episcopall Register .

William Bray , one of Canterburies Chaplanes subscrived Chounaei Collectiones Theologicae , as consonant to the doctrine of the Church of England , & meet for the presse . The Author dedicated the Treatise to my L. of Canterburie , it was printed at London 1636. In this booke , the first article , which by the confession of all sides drawes with it all the rest , is set downe in more plaine and foule tearmes then Molina or any Jesuite ; sure I am then A●minius , Vorstius , or any their followers ever did deliver , (b) (b) Pag. 18. Non vidio rationem in contrarium quare cum quae est ex Deo per unam eandemque actionem bonitatis a seipso emanantem , recta ordinatio fidei in Christum resipiscentiae , obedientiae , perseverantiae , sit causa salvationis perversa quae ex hominibus est damnationis , non in eadem unitatis ratione , electionis & reprobationis etiam causa agnoscantur . teaching in one These those three grosse errours .

1. That mens faith , repentance , perseverance , are the true causes of their Salvation ; as mis-beleefe , impenitencie , apostasie , are of damnation : Doeth Bellarmine goe so farre in his Doctrine of Iustification and merite ?

2. That those sinnes are no lesse the true causes of reprobation then of damnation .

3. That mens faith , repentance , perseverance , are no lesse the true causes of t●eir eternall Election , then mis-beliefe , or other sinnes of their temporall damnation . Let Charitie suppone that his Grace in the middest of his numerous and weightie imployments hath beene forced to neglect the reading of a booke of this nature , though dedicate to himselfe , albeit it is well knowne that his watchfull eye is fixed upon nothing more then Pamphlets which passes the presse upon doctrines now controverted , yet his Grace beelng publickly upbraided , for countenancing of this Booke , by D. Bastwick in the face of the Star-chamber , and beeing advertised of its dedication to himselfe , of the errours contained in it , yea of injuries against the King of the deepest staine , as these which strooke at the very root of his Supremacie and that in favour of the Bishops :

When in such a place Canterburie was taxed for letting his name stand before a booke that wounded the Kings Monarchick Government at the very heart , and did transferre from the Crowne to the Miter , one of its fairest diamonds , which the King and his Father before him did ever love most dearly , no charitie will longer permitt us to beleeve , but his Grace would without further delay lend some two , or three spare-houres to the viewing of such a piece which did concerne the King and himselfe so nearly . Having therefore without all doubt both seene and most narrowly sifted all the corners of that small Treatise , and yet beene so farre from reproving the Authour , from censuring the Licencer , his Chaplan , from calling in the booke , from expurging any one jot that was in it , that the Treatise the second time is put to the presse at London with the same licence , the same dedication , no letter of the points in question altered ; May wee not conclude , with the favour of all reasonable men , that it is my Lord of Canterburies expresse minde to have his owne name prefixed , and his Chaplanes hand subjoyned to the grossest errours of Arminius , and so to professe openly his contempt of the Kings proclamation , for the pretended violation whereof be causeth stigmatize , mutilat , fine excessively , imprison for time of life , very vertuous Gentle-men , both Divines , Lawyers , Physicians , and of other faculties .

What here can bee said for his Graces Apologie , nothing commeth in my minde , except one allegation , that the point in hand crosseth not the proclamation , discharging to proceed in those questions beyond the grammaticall construction and literall sense of the articles of England . Arminianisme is consonant to the articles of England , and not contrary to the proclamation .

The Authour indeed in his Epistle dedicatorie avowes to his Grace that the These alleadged , and all the rest of his booke doeth perfectly agree with the English Articles in the very first and literall sense , whereof the proclamation speaketh .

(c) (c) Nec videantur sensum articulorum ecclesiae Anglican● in literali & grammaticali nedum in affixo verborum sensu transgredi . And to this assertion the Licencers hand is relative as to the rest of the booke ; But of this miserable apologie , which yet is the onely one which I can imagine possible , this will bee the necessary issue , that the grosse lye , which good King Iames put upon the bold brow of impudent Bertius , for his affirming that one article of the Saints apostasie , let be other more vile Arminian Tenets , was consonant with the articles of England , must be throwne backe from Bertius on the Kings face , and that in as disgracefull a way as it was first given ; Montagew and Whit● , with his Graces permission , did give that venerable Prince long agoe the lye at home in English , affirming the perfect agreeance of the Arminian Apostasie with the doctrine of England .

But this affront contents not his Grace , except this barbarous medecine , under the shelter of his Archiepiscopall name be lie his Majestie over-sea , and over the whole world , where the Latine is understood .

Beside this shamefull inconvenience , another dangerous evill will necessarily follow from this Apologie , to wit : That the Arminian Doctrine may not onely be tolerated in England , which yet , if King Iames may be trusted , cannot faile to draw downe upon England a curse from God , shame from abroad , horrible shisme at home , but also , since their grossest articles are declared in print and in Latine , under the shaddow of Canterburies name , to be fully consonant to the very litterall sense of the Articles of England , all the members of that Church may be compelled presently without more delay to embrace those doctrines ; and that any man is permitted in England to beleeve in peace the Antiarminian Articles , wherein Queene Elizabeth and King Iames did live and dye , it is of meere favour and the Princes mercie , who readily by the Archbishops intercession is diverted from pressing the profession of those articles , according to the first and most litterall sense , which now is clearely avowed to bee after Arminius ; yea , Molina his minde .

CHAP. III. The Canterburians professed affection towards the Pope & Poperie in grosse .

The faction once suspected of Lutherianisme . IT was the opinion of many among us for a long time , that the innovating faction did minde no more then Arminianism , But at once , those who touched their pulse neerer , did finde a more high humour working in their veynes . With Arminius errours , they began incontinent to publish other Tenets , which to all meere Arminians were ridiculous follies .

The Elements of the Lords Supper began by them to be magnified , above the common phrase of Protestant Divines , a corporall presence of Christs humanity , in and about the Elements to be glanced at , a kinde of omnipresence of Christs flesh to be preached , a number of adorations before those Elements , and all that was neere them , both the Altar , Bason , Challice , and Chancell to be urged , many new Ceremonies , which for many yeares had beene out of use , to bee taken in , a great bitternesse of spirit , against all who ran not after these new guyses to appeare .

This made us thinke they intended to steppe over from Arminius to Luther . In this conception wee were somewhat confirmed , considering their earnest recommendation , to the reading of young Students the late Lutheran Divines , such as Hutter , Meisner , Gerard , with their crying downe , both in private and publick of Calvine , BeZa , Martyr , Bucer , and the rest of the famous writers , both ancient and late of the French & Belgick Churches .

Their giving it out also , that their martyred Reformers , Crammer , Ridley , Latimer , were of Luthers Schoole , & from him had learned those things , wherin the English church did differ from the other reformed of Calvins framing . But most of al , by my lord of Canterburies great diligence under hand , to promove and reward that late negotiation of M. Duries with the Churches over Se● , for the extenuating of the Lutheran errours , and procuring with their Churches , not onely a Syncretisme , which all good men did ever pant for , but also a full peace in tearmes so generall , so ambiguous , so flidderie , that were very suspitious to many , otherwise very peaceable mindes .

But at last Popery was found their mark . Those considerations moved us to thinke ▪ that the factious motion might possibly end at Lutheranisme without any further progresse . But it was not long , while every common eye did observe their bowle , to roll much beyond that marke . They published incontinent a number of the Romish errours , which to the very Lutherans were ever esteemed deadly poyson , the Popish Faith , the Tridentine justification , merit of workes , workes of Supererogation , doctrinall traditions , Limbus Patrum , the Sacrifice of the Masse , adoration of images , monastick vowes , Abbeyes and Nunries , the Authoritie of the Pope , a reunion with Rome , as shee stands .

Finding it so , we were driven to this conclusion , that as ordinarily the Spirit of defection doth not permit any Apostates to rest in any middle tearme , but carrieth them along to the extreames of some palpable madnesse , to some strong delusion for the recompence of the first degrees of their fall from the love of the Trueth , so also our Faction was carried quite beyond the bounds both of Arminiu● and Luther , yea of their owne so much once beloved Cassander and Spalato , and all the lists of that which they were wont to call moderation , to drinke of the vilest abominations , and the lowest dregs of the golden Cup of that Romish Whoore : For now my Lord Canterburie and his followers , are not ashamed to proclaime in print their affection to Poperie both in grosse and retaile . Let no man in this cast up to me any slander till he have heard and considered the probation of my allegations .

Poperie is a body of parts , if not innumerable , To make way for their designes , they cry downe the Popes Antichristianisme . yet exceeding many . There is scarce any member great or small in this monster , whereto the faction hath not kythed too passionate a love . But for shortnesse , I will shew first their affection to the whole Masse of popish errours , their respect to the Church of Rome , and to the Pope the Head thereof , than in particular to the most princip●ll and abominable parts of that Chaos . As for the whole of that confused lump , that they may winne the more easily , to the embracement of it , they cast downe in the entry the chiefe wall , they remove the maine impediment , whereby Protestants were ever kept therefrom .

What ever wee speake of some very few private men , yet all Protestant Churches without exception made ever the Popes Antichristianisme , their chiefe bulwark to keepe all their people from looking back towards that Babilonish Whoore.

No Church did make greater state of that fort then the English , & no man in that church more th●n King Charles blessed Father . Hee was not content himselfe to beleeve and avow the Pope that great Antichrist , but also with arguments invincible drawn mainely from some passages of the Revelation , cleared now as light , by the Commentary of the Popes practises , to demonstrate to all Neighbour Princes and States of Christendome in a monitorie Treatise this his beliefe , for that expresse end , that from this truth clearly proved , they might not onely see the necessitie he had to keep himselfe and his Subjects for evermore from returning to Rome , but they also by this one argument might be forced to cast ●ff the yoake of the Pope , when they saw him cloathed with the garments of Antichrist .

It was the continuall song of all the Bishops and Clergie in England , till D. Laud gott absolute credite with the Duke of Buckinghame , that the Popes Antichristianisme was an engine of such efficacie as was able of it selfe alone , if well manadged to overthrow the wals of Rome .

For this I give but two witnesses , two late English Bishops both of them deponing before all England to King Iames , and he accepting their testimonie , (a) (a) Caeterum agendo quam nihil agant , & ambitioso magnorum voluminum apparatu non nisi lituras scribāt , disputatione ista de antichristo , liquido constare poterit ; quia si causam hanc obtinuerimus esse romanum pontificem antichristum , de reliquae contraversia dubitandi , non erit relictus , locus , quia de Antichrists doctrina , quin pernitiosa sit & impia dubitari non potest . Abbots of Salisburrie in his dedicatorie Ep●stle to king Iames before his Treatise of Antichrist , & Downame of Derry in the first paragraph (b) (b) Illa mihi imprimus questio , quae est de antichristo , dignissima semper est visa , in qua decti determinandi omnes tum ingenij , tum industriae nervos contenderent ; illa enim de veritate quam nos in hac causa singulari Dei benificio tenemus , si inter omnes semel conveniret de reliquis statim contraversijs actum esset , debellatumque , neque aliquid in p●sterum periculi fores , quemquam ●mnino Christianum , cui sua ca● esset salus , detecto jam antichristo , agnitoque adhesurum . of his booke dedicated also to K. James upon that same subject . Notwithstanding my lord of Canterburie , For making the way to Rome more smooth , spareth not to cause raze downe to the earth this fort . Montagu & White his non-such divines , as we heard them stiled at his Graces direction by his Herauld Heylene , will have the kings unanswerable arguments proponed by him even to forraine Princes ; not onely counted weake but plaine frensies . This word doth Featlie cite from their Appeal . (c) (c) Pelag. redi . v. 2 ▪ tab. pag. 39. As for the Protestant arguments taken out of the Apocalypse , to prove the pope to be the Antichrist . Bellarmine calleth them deliramenta , dotages : And the appealer to show more zeal to the Popes cause straineth further , & tearmeth them apocalypticall phrensies . Christopher Dow is licentiat by Canterburie , to affirme that howsoever our Divines at the beginning of the Reformation in the heat of dispute did upbraid the Pope with Antichristianisme , yet now that heat being cooled , the matter to men in their sober blood appeares doubtfull . (d) (d) P. 53. Many learned in our church especially when the greatest heat was stricken betweene us and Rome , have affirmed the Pope to be the Antichrist , yet to them that calmely and seriously consider it , it may not without good reason be disputed as doubtfull his Graces Herauld appointed to speake for his lord by the State , doth correct this simple Dow , and puts the matter out of all doubt , assuring by good scripturall proofe , by a text miserablie abused , that the Pope is not , was not , and can not be Antichrist . (e) (e) Pag. 128. I have yet one thing more to say to you in this point , S. Iohn hath given it for a rule , that every spirit that confesseth not that Iesus Christ is come in the flesh , is not of God , but is that spirit of Antichrist , whereof yee have heard . So that unlesse you can make good ( as I thinke you can not ) that the pope of Rome confesseth not that Iesus Christ is come in the flesh , you have no reason to conclude that he is that Antichrist . And that in this matter there may heereafter betwixt the Canterburians and Rome remaine no shaddow of Controversie , their man Shelfoord , comes home to Bellarmine , well neere in omnibus , making Antichrist one single man ; a Iew preaching formall blasphemies against Christ natures & person three yeares and an half , killing by his hands Enoch and Elias . And least any footsteppe of this beliefe should ever appeare in the church of England , Canterburie confesseth that the place of the publicke lyturgie wherein it was imported , was changed by his own hand . (g) (g)

Star-chamber speach , pag. 32. the first place is changed thus , from , Root out that Babylonish and Antichristian sect , which say of Ierusalem , into this forme of words , Root out that Romish and Balylonish sect , of them , which say , This alteration is of so small consequence that it is , not worthie the speaking : or if there be any thing of moment in it , it is answered in the next , where the chiefe thing he sayes , is , that he was commanded to alter it by the King for to remove scandall from the Papists .

They are content to have the popes authoritie set up again in England

This scarre-crow being set aside , at once the Pope , the Cardinals and all their Religion began to (f) (f) His fifth sermon through the whole . looke with a new face . Anent the Pope they tell us first , (h) (h) Montag . antigage , pag. 41. Gens abium unaquaeque tandem suas sibi plumas repetendo surtivis coloribus denudatam , propriis etiam quod non oportuit , improbantque vehementer 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 circumcisā , nudam , ridendum , exsibilandam corniculā exposuerunt . that the reformers did him pitifull wrong in spoyling him , not only of those things he had usurped , but of many priviledges which were his owne by due right , and should have beene left to him untouched . Againe they will have us to believe , that the Sea of Rome was truelie Peters Apostolick chaire , that Peter was truelie a Prince among the Apostles , that the Pope is (i) (i) Cant. relat. of the confes . pag. 183 A primacie of order was never denyed to S. Peter , that Rome had potentioren principatum then other Churches : the Protestants grant , and that not only , because the Roman Prelate was ordine primus , first in order and degree , which some one must be to avoide confusion , but also , &c. Ibid. pag. 154. Austen sayeth indeed , that in the Church of Rome there did ever flourish the principalitie of an Apostolick Chaire , this no man denyes . Ibid. pag. 133. No man of learning doubts but the Church of Rome had a powerfull principalitie within its owne patriarchat . Montag . Antigag . pag 51. Damus à Petro ad aetatem Augustini in Ecclesia Romana Apostolicae cathedrae semper viguisse principatum . Ibid. pag. 57. Quae ratio erat olim singulorum in suis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Episcoporum , eadem erat in provinciis Metrapolitarum , in terrarum orbe patriarcharum , rectè autem ( quis negat ) consultum eratolim , & cautum per canones vetustae Ecclesiae , ut Romanus ille primus ( nec hoc negatur ) Episcoporum , cui tot per occidentem suffraganei adherebant , suam sententiam rogatus adhiberet , ubi fides Ecclesiae universalis , aut 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 in rebus ad 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 spectantibus agitabatur , & quicquid sanciretur suo suffragio confirmaret , priusquam ratum firmum fixumque legis vim & efficaciam per Ecclesiam universalem obineret . Ibid. pag. 80. Monarchae sunt Episcopi in suis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , monarchae in suis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , Metropolitae Monarchae Patriarchae augustiores , sed plures per unam Ecclesiam Catholicam : Praecipuae olim parti Chistiani orbis hoc est , cunctis ad occidentem regionibus cum authoritate quadam non illa suprema praefuit Pontifex , etsi non obstaret illa perdita ambitio etiam hodie preesset . Petets onelie successor , that within the bounds of his owne Patriarchat he is a Prince , he is a monarch . Thirdlie , that order and unitie do necessarly require one Bishop to have the inspection and superioritie over all Bishopes , and that this prerogative by good Ecclesiasticall right is due to the Pope . (k) (k) Cant. relat. p. 183. The Roman Prelate was ordine primus , first in order or degree , which some one must bee to avoid confusion . Montag . antid pag. 116. Certum est ratione vinculi communis inter Christanos ratione ordinis praecedentis inter Patriarchas universalis Ecclesiae curam ad Petri sedim confluxisse . Ibid. pag. 51. Eclesia acies ordinata multitudo , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , costituta . Vbicunque multi & multiplicitas , ut ordo eluceat , & harmonia conservetur , ab uno arcessenda est origo omnis . Vnde autem melius origo omnis quam ab Ecclesia principali , loco debetur haec praeminentia , loci primatum , & illum ordinis , & propter utrumque praestantiae habeat , si voluerit Romanus pontifex . Inter Ecclesiae sacerdotes communio & societas ejusdemque fidei integrae & illibatae professio , quoàd ordinem & interdum executionem non potuit nisi ab uno aliquo fieri & derivari ; Inde autem per consensum Christianae orbis derivabatur , hoc est , à cathedra & sede Petri Romano scilicet Episcopatis . Ibid. pag. 158. Illi certè principatum sacerdotii super omnes antiquatas tribuit , neque nos hunc abnuimus principatum , fontem esse sacerdotti , & summi Pontificatus apicem nos non reluctamur , est & sit . Fourthly , that all the authoritie which the English Bishops have this day , speciallie his Grace of Canterbury , is derived to them from the Pope and Peters chair , That if this derivation could not be clearlie demonstrat , the Clergie of England might justlie refuse all obedience to their Bishops jurisdiction . (l) (l) Pokling . alt. pag. 50 Miserable were we , if hee that now sits Archbishop of Canterburie , could not derive his succession from S. Augustine , S. Augustine from S. Gregorie , S. Gregorie from S. Peter . What a comfort it is to his Grace , that he can say , Ego sum haeres Apostolorum , I , and my predecessors have kept possession . Pokling . Sunday at the beginning . Our Diocesian can derive himselfe the successor of an apostle , otherwise we should have taken his call for the vocie of a stranger , & not have here appeared . It is S. Augustins resolutō , Successio Episcoporum ab ipsa sede Petri , is that which among other things by him named , keepes us in the bosome of the Church , & subjects us to our Bishops jurisdiction . Fifthly , that divers of the late Popes have been verie good men , yea , among the best of men , that those of them who have beene verie monsters of men , yet for that veneration which their high and eminent place in the Church of God , doth require all the stiles of honour in justice is due to them , even holinesse it self in abstracto , that to refuse them this , or their other titles is but brainsick puritanisme . (m) (m) Montag . oreg . Eccles. p. 114. Patrum nostrorum vel avorum memoria dua summi Pontifices virri optimi & doctissimi , Hadrianus sextus , & Bellarmini avunculus Marcellus secundus . Antid. pag. 47. Romanus Episcopus Pontifex maximus quidni dicebatur , scio vocatum benedictum , scio Papam & Pastorem nominari● , quid si haec omnia nomina usurpabat . Orig. pag. 417. Certis quibusdam titulis , & elogiis homines 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 constitutos ab omni retro antiqualite viti prudentes etiam & religiosi honorant , istos honorum lemnistos , non est cujusvis conculcare , sed nec palam reprehendere , aut iisdem derogate , id quod solent 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , Puritani Pontificem Romanum suam sanctitatem indigitare certissimus est character Antichristianismi : Non tibi , sed religioni dicebat olim Isidis adorator , cum asinus portans mysteria se putaret veneratum , honorem pari modo non Paulo alicui quarto Alexandro Sexto , Ioanni duodecimo & caeteris , si qui sunt prodigia & propudia honestatis , sed religioni exhibendum contendimus , hoc est , eminentî dignitati , quâ ultra alios in Ecclesia Dei praediti sunt , sed est haec pbrenesis hominum solummodo phanaticorum .

6 That the dignitie of the Episcopall office , specially the Bishop of Rome his eminency , was as far above the dignity of the Emperours and Kings , as the soule is above the body , or God above the creature ; yea , that the stile of God was but the Popes due : (n) (n) Montag . antip . pag. 166. Est quidem sacerdotium , ut rectè observat Pbil. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , itaque ut 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Iesu Christi , ut Dei atque hominum 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 summus à C ristianis omnibus , Divino instituto debetur honor & reverentia singularis . ibid. p. 40. Fatetur ultro sacerdotium aliquo modo in quibusdam supra regiam dignitatem eminere , cum vetustis & orthodoxis patribus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ( inquit Chry●ostom ) 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ( regem prius dixerat ) 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , & Nazianzen , in apologi a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . ibid. p. 162. Allusum est a piissimo rege ad illud Exodi , Constitui te Deum Pharaonis , communicat Deus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , seu Pontificio seu civili , sui ipsius 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 dii vocantur quis ringatur ob hanc 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , & merito quos locum ille suum voluit inter homines sustinere . 7. That Emperours and Kings did but their duety in giving reverence ; yea , adoration unto the Pope with great summes of money by way of tribute : (o) (o) Montag antid pag. 40. Non est mirum si Constantinus olim Pipinus , Carolus , & alii occurrerent , de equis descenderent , venientes exceperint , religionis antistites Christianae venerationemque exhibuerint . Quid mirum Turcarum Caliphis non ita pridem tot Sultanos tantam observantiam exhibuisse tam ampla vectigalia persolvisse : Non minora quondam principes & populi Christiani Christianis sacerdotibus imprimis Romanis pontificibus exhibuerint , exhibebunt etiamnum ad pristinos illos mores si tantum revertatur , & exempla pietatis maiorum . ibid. pag. 158. Adoravit Ioannem Iustinus , sic & Constantinus inferiores Ioanne sacerdotes , adoravit aut●m dicit author ille tuus dans gloriam Deo . 8 That the temporall principalities which the Pope enjoyeth this day in Italie , or elswhere , are but his just possessions , which none ought to invy him : (p) (p) Montag . antid. pag. 95. Habeat ille suas sibi opes & facultates , fundos habeat & latifundia , principatum & dominium per Ecclesia terras , & Petri possessiones obtineat , dummode contentus vetuctiorum principum liberalitate , alienam non invadat possessionem . 9. That the restitution of the Popes ancient authority in England , and yeelding unto him all the power that this day he hath in Spaine or France , would be many wayes advantageous , and in nothing prejudiciall to the King : (q) (q) Cant. relat. pag. 202 Hee that is not blinde may see if hee wil , of what little value the popes power in France and Spaine is this day further then to serve the turns of their Kings therewith , which they doe to their great advantage . 10 The old constitution of the Emperour , whereby all the westerne clergie is so farre subjected to the Bishop of Rome , that without him they are disabled to make any Ecclesiasticall law , and obliged to receave for lawes what he doth enjoyne , was very reasonable : Yea , if the King would be pleased to command all the church men in his dominions to be that far subject to the Pope they would be unreasonable to refuse present obedience : (r) (r) Montag . antid. pag. 156. Quod è codice allegatur Theodosiano decernimus , ne quid tam Episcopis Gallicanis quam aliarum provinciarum , contra consuetudinem veterem liceat , sine viri venerabilis Papae urbis alternae authoritate tentare , sed illis omnibusque legis loco sit , quicquid sanxit sanxeritve sedis apostolicae authoritas . Quicquid hic pontifici ( sayeth Montagow ) arrogatur id totum edicto debetur Theodosiano vel vetustae consuetudini , quicquid autem per rescriptum tribuitur imperatoris ad occidentales credo solos pertinebat ▪ & nec omnes , quibus juxta veterem consuetudinem Pontifex praesidebat ut Patriarcha : Decernat imperator de G●rmanis episcopis , Rex Angli● de Britannis suis , Francorum de Gallicanis , quod olim Theodosius decrevit , dicto erunt omnes obedientes . Onely by all meanes my Lord of Canterburies prerogative behoved to bee secured , his ancient right to the patriarchat of the whole Isle of Britaine behoved to be made cleare , that to his rod the whole clergie of the Isle might submit their shoulders , as to their spirituall head and Monarch , from whom to Rome there could bee no appeale , (s) (s) Cant. relat. pag. 171. It is plaine , that in these ancient times , in the Church government , Britaine was neever subject to the Sea of Rome , for it was one of the six diocies of the West Empire , and had a p●●mat of its own : Nay Iohn Capgraw , and William Mabinnesburrie tell us , that Pope Vrb●n the second , in the Councel at Bari in Apuleia , accoun●ed my worthie predecessor S. Anselme as his owne Compeer , and said , Hee was as the patriarch and apostolick of the other world , quasi comparem , & veluti Apostolicum alterius orbis & Patriarcham . Now the Britains having a primate of their own , which is greater then a Metropolitan ; yea , a patriarch , if yee wil , he could not be appealed from to Rome . in any cause which concerned onely the churches of the Kings dominions ; for in causes more universall of the whole catholicke Church , willingly they are contented that the Patriarch of Britaine and all others should submit to their grand Apostolicke father of Rome . (t) (t) Montag . Antid. pag. 57. Rectè cautum erat olim per canones vetustae Ecclesiae , ut Romanus ille primus Episcoporum , cui tot per occidentem suffraganei adherebant , suam sententiam rogatus adhiberet , ubi fidei Ecclesiae universalis , vel 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 in rebus ad politiam spectantibus , agitabatur supra . Everie one of these pontificall positions since the midst of Henrie rhe eights raigne , would have beene counted in England great paradoxes , yet now all of them are avowed by Canterbuerie himself , in that verie booke which the last yeare at the Kings direction hee set forth , for to satisfie the world anent their suspition of his Poperie , or else by D. Montagu in his books yet unrepealed , and cleanged of all suspition of Poperie by M. Dow , under the seal of his Graces licencing servant .

This much for the Pope . About the Cardinalls they tell us that their office is an high and eminent dignitie in the Church of God ; Their minde to the Cardinalat . for the which their persons are to be handled with great reverence and honour , (w) (w) Montag . ap. pag. 56 Penitere non potuit Baronium eruditissimū & laboriosissimum virum , industriae suae ac deligentiae , Cardinalitiame : niminde & merito quidem suo adeptus suscepit dignitatē . ibid. pag. 75. Virum illustri adeo nominis celebritate & eminentissima dignitate cōstitutum , honestum , probum , preterea in vita privata rigidem severum ac tantum non 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 nusquam nisi honorificentissime compellavi . that their office is a reward due to high graces and vertues , that some of them though the greatest enemies that ever the reformed Churches have felt , such as Baronius that spent all his time in opposing the trueth and advancing Antichristianisme , and Barromaeus (x) (x) Pokling . Alt. pag. 34. The Linchonshire Minister it his jearing veine flouteth Cardinal Baromaeus , whereas , if he list to read his life he may not be ignorant that the Cardinall was a man of exemplarie holinesse and spent the greatest part of his life in fasting , prayer , almes-deeds , preaching , exhoration , and doctrine , and did detest both impietie and vanitie both in word and deed . Me thinkes his conscience should checke him for his scornfull usage of a man who had the report of so vertuous and pious a Bishop . a bloudy persecutor of our religion and one of the fathers of Trent , that even such men are so full of grace and pietie , that it is a great fault in any protestant to break so much as a jest on their red hattes .

Where the head and shoulders are so much affected it is hard to restraine charitie from the rest of the bodie . These good men vent their passion no lesse towards the bodie of the present Church of Rome , then towards the Pope and the Cardinalls . Fo● first his grace avowes over and over againe that the Papists and wee are of one and the same religion , They affect much to be joyned with the Church of Rome , as shee stands . that to speak otherwayes , as the Liturgie of England did all King Iames dayes , were a matter of very dangerous consequent , and therefore he confesseth his helping that part of the liturgie which puts a note of infamie upon the popish religion , least that note should fall upon our owne religion which with the popish is but all one (y) (y) Cant. relat. p 36 The Church of Rome & Protestants set not up a different Religion , for the christian Religion is the same to both , but they differ in the same Religion , and the difference is in certain grosse corruptions to the very endangering of salvation , which each side saith the other is guiltie . of Star-chamber speach , pag. 36. My second reason is , That the learned make but three Religions to have beene of old in the world , Paganisme , Iudaisme , and Christianitie and now they have added a fourth which is Turcisme Now if this ground of theirs be true , as it is generally neceived , perhaps it will be of dangerous consequence sadly to avow that the popish religion is rebellion , though this clause passed in the ●iturgie through inadvertrance in King Iames time , this reason well weighed is taken from the very foundation of Religion it selfe . ibid. pag. 34. His Majesty expresly commanded mee to make the alteration , and to see it printed . 2 They will have us to understand though wee & the papists differ in some things , yet that this very day their is no schisme betwixt papists and Protestants , that protestants keep union and communion with the Church of Rome in all things required for the essence of a true Church & necessarie for salvation , that though they communicate not with some of her doctrines and practices , yet this marres not the true union and communion of the two Churches both in faith and charitie . That these who passe harder censures upon Rome are but zelots in whom too much zeale hath burnt up all wisedome and charitie . (z) (z) Pottar p. 3. 66. Wee darre not communicat with Rome , either in her publicke Liturgie which is manifestly polluted with grosse superstition , or in these corrupt and ungrounded opinions , which she hath added to the faith . These make up the poperie , but not the Church of Rome . In them our communion is dissolved , but wee have still a true and reall union with that and all other members of the Church universall in faith and charitie . ibid. pag. 74. To depart from the Church of Rome in some doctrines and practices , wee had just & necessarie cause though the Church of Rome wanted nothing necessarie to salvation . There is great difference betwixt shisme from them and reformation of our selfe . It is one thing to leave communion with the Church of Rome , and another to leave communicating with her erros , whosoever professeth himselfe to forsake the communion of any one member of Christs bodie , must confesse himself consequently to forsake the whole . And therefore wee forsake not Romes communion more nor the body of Christ whereof wee acknowledge the Church of Rome to bee a member , though corrupted . If any Zelots hath proceeded among us to heavier censures , their zeal may bee excused , but their charitie and wisedome can not hee iustified . Cant. relat. p. 192. The Protestants have not left the Church of Rome in her essence , but in her errors , not in things which constitute a Church , but only in such abuses and corruptions which worke toward the dessolution of a Church . 3 Thar the points wherein the two Churches doe differ are such as prejudge not the Salvation of either partie , that they are not foundamentall , and albeit they were so : yet the truths that the papists doe maintaine are of force to hinder all the evil that can cōme from their errours . (†) (†) Cant. relate . pag. 249. The foundation is and remaineth whole in the mids of their superstitions . Heylens answere . pag. 124. Suppose a great Prelat in the high Commission Court had said openly , That wee and the Church of Rome differed not in fundamentalibus , yet how commeth this to be an innovation in the doctrine of England . For that church telleth us in the 19. article , That Rome doth erre in matters of Faith , but it hath not told us that she doth erre in fundamentalibus . Halls old religion after the beginning : It is the charitable profession of zealous Luther , that under the poperie there is much Christian good , yea , all , that under the papacie there is true Christianity , yea , the kernell of Christianitie ? Neither doe wee censure that Church , for what it hath not , but for what it hath . Fundamentall truth is like the Maronian wine which if it bee mixed with twentie times so much water , holds his strength . Rome as it is Babylon , wee must come out of it , but as it is an outward visible Church , wee neither did nor would , Butterfields Maskell . Poperie is poyson , but fund●mentall truch is an antidot . A little quantitie of antidot that is soveraigne , will destroy much poyson . Pottar pag. 62. The most necessarie and fundamentall truths which constitute a Church , are on both sides unquestioned , ibid. By fundamentall points of Faith wee understand these prime , and capitall doctrines of Religion , which make up the holy Catholick Faith , which essentially constitutes a true Church and a true Christian . The Apostles Creed taken in a Catholicke sense that is as it was further opened in some parts by occasion of emergent heresies in the other catholicke creed of Nice , Constantinople , Ephesus , Chalcedon and Athanasius is said generally by the Scholemen & Fathers to comprehend a perfect catalogue of fundamentall truths , & to imply a full rejection of fundamentall heresies . ibid. pag. 109. It semeed to some men of great learning and judgement , such as Hooker and Morton , that all who professe to love the Lord Iesus , are brethren , and may be saved , though with erros , even fundamentall truths , & to imply a full rejection of fundamentall heresies . ibid. p. 109 It seemed to some men of great learning and judgement , such as Hooker and Morton , that all who professe to love the Lord Iesus , are brethren , and may be saved , though with errors , even fundamentall . Heretickes doe imbrace the principles of Christianitie , and erre only by misconstruction . Whereupon their opinions , albeit repugnant indeed to Faith yet are held other wise by them , and maintained as consonant to the Faith . 4 That the popish errours , let bee to bee fundamentall , are of so small importance as they doe not prejudge either faith , hope , or charitie , let be salvation .

(a) (a) Cant , relat. pag. 361 Holcat . Non omnis error in his quae fidei sunt est aut infidelitas , aut haeresis . In things not necessarie though they bee divine truths if about them men differ , it is no more then they have done , more or lesse in all ages , and they may differ and yet preserve that one necessary Faith intire , and charitie also , if they be so well minded , for opinions which flattereth about that one souls saving Faith , there are dangerous differences this day . Pottar pag. 38. It is a great vanitie to hope or expect that all learned men in this life should absolutely consent in all the particles of the divine truth , so long as the Faith once delivered to the Saints , and that common faith containing all necessary verities is keeped . So long as men walke charitably according to this rule , though in other things they be otherwise minded , the unitie of the Church is no wise violated : for it doth consist in the unitie of faith , not of opinions , in the union of mens hearts by true charitie , which easily tolerateth unnecessar differences . Some points of religion are primitive articles essentiall in the obiect of Faith . Dissension in these is pernitious , and destroyeth unitie . Other , are secundary probable obscure and accidentall points : Disputations in these are tolerable . Unitie in these is very contingent and variable . As in musicall consort , a discord now and then , so it bee in the discant , and depart not from the ground , sweetens the harmonie : So the varitie of opinions and rites in divers parts of the Church , doth rather commend then prejudice the unitie of the whole . Montag . Antigog . page 14. Truth is of two sorts among men , manifest and confessed truth , or more obscure and involved truth . Plainly delivered in Scripture are all these points which belong unto Faith , and maners , hope and charitie . I know none of these contraverted inter partes . The articles of our creed are confessed on both sides , & held plaine enough . The contraverted points are of a larger and inferiour allay . Of them a man may be ignorant without any danger of his soule at all . A man may resolve or oppose this way or that way with out perrell of perishing . Cant. relat . about the end . The coruptions of Rome materially , and in the very kinde and nature , are leaven , drosse , hay and stubble , yet the Bishop thought that such as were misled by education , or long custome , or overvalving the Soveraignity of the Romane Church , and did in simplicitie of heart imbrace them , might by theyr generall repentance and Faith in the Merits of Christ , attended with charitie and other verues finde mercie at Gods hands . Shelfoord pag. 235. Though there bee some difference among us in ceremonies and expositions , which destroy not , yet still our head Christ by Baptisme stands upon our bodie , and the substance of the Gospel is intire and whole among us by retaining the articles of the Faith , the volume of the New-Testament , and the practice there of by Faith and good workes . ibid. page 239. There bee differences which hinder our agreement . What then ? Among the Greekes there were divers Dialects , and yet they had but one language , they held together in the maine . So though Papists have a letter more then wee , and wee one letter for another , yet wee hold together in the radix . Paul could beare with differences , expecting Gods reformation . If you bee otherwise minded God shall revaile . For the present let us bee patient , and afterward God will shew where the errour lyeth . Why should wee presume so much of our skill , while wee are in our none-age , and know but in part ? Have not better men then wee beene deceived ? Have not dissenting Fathers and slyding Schoolists been alwayes borne with in points of Religion ? Fiftly , That a generall repenrance for all unknowne sinnes is sufficient to secure the salvation not only of these who have lived and died in the popish tenets before the councell of Trent , but even to this day not only their people , but their most learned Clergie , Popes , Cardinalls , Iesuits , living and dying in their bitter oppositions and persecutions of protestants , are in no hazard of damnation , though they never come to any particular acknowledgement of their sinfull opinions or practises following thereupon . (b) (b) Pottar page 77. Wee hope well of these holy soules , who in former ages lived and died in the church of Rome , for though they died in many sinfull errours , yet because they did it ignorantly through unbeliefe , not knowing them either to bee errours or sins , and repented in generall for all their unknowne trespasses , wee doubt not , but they obtained pardon of all their ignorances . Nay , our charitie reacheth further to all these that this day , who in simplicitie of heart believe the Romane religion , and professe it . But we understand only them who either have no sufficient meanes to finde the truth , or else as after the use of the best meanes they can have , all things considered , finde no sufficient motives to convince their consciense of errours . Chomley his defence of Hall , I dare bee bold to say that the church of Rome had not for many hundreth yeares before the councel of Trent , so good a forme of doctrine as the Tridentin catechisme doth containe . Sixtlie , They teach us that papists may not in reason be stiled either idolaters , or hereticks , or schismaticks . His Grace in that great large folio set out the last yeare , to declare to the world the fartherst that his minde could be drawen for to oppose poperie , is not pleased , to my memorie , in his most verhement oppositions to lay to their charge any of these three cirmes , neither doe I remember in all the search my poore lecture hath made , that any of his favourits in their writtes these twelve yeares bygone hath layed to the charge of Rome in earnest , either idolatrie heresie or shisme , but by the contrary hath absolved them clearly in formall termes of al those three cirmes . (c) (c) Shelfoord . p. 300 I am not in the minde that all images are idols , but only when they are worshipped for gods . This the word idolatria signifieth the wotshipping of images , with latria , that is divine worship , as it is used by Divines . Cant. relat. pag. 299. They keepe close to that which is superstition , and in the case of images come near to idolatrie . Montag . apar . page 79. Et certè quamdiù palam non deficiunt , à pietate & cultu Dei proprio ad idolatriam , etiam moribus impii , vita contaminati , tolerantur in Ecclesia non minus quam milvus & corvus immunda animalierant in arca Ecclesia 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 singulari . At nullus in arca erat idololatres , quia Christianam pietatem quatenus Christianam idololatres execratur . Montag . pag. 309. Dei cultum latriam quam appellant nec possumus alicui creaturae , nec debemus sive humanae sive angelicae quamvis excellentissimae impendere . Hoc fatibitur Bullingerus Pontificius & tota schola non insanientium adversariorum , nolunt enim illi quovis modo cuicunque creaturae latriam nequidem cultu relativo exhiberi . Montag . Antigag . page 319. You say , that images must not have latria : so we : let your practice and doctrine goe together , and wee agree . Dow against Burton obiecteth that my lord Canterburie did raze out the publicke booke of fasts , this sentence , Thou hast delivered us from superstition and idolatrie wherein we were utterly drowned , his chief answere is , That men may bee good Protestants , and yet not damne all their forefathers , who lived before the reformation , as hee must doe , who saith of them , they were wholly drowned in idolatrie which though M. Burton perhaps will not , yet some men may thinke it to be a reason sufficient for the leaving out of that sentence . Of idolatrie , because they teach not the giving of latria to any image or any creature .

(d) (d) Cant relat . page 306. Non omnes error in his que fidei sunt est aut infidelitas aut heresis . Pottar , page 102. Every sect hath some zelots so passionatly in love with their own opinions that they condemne all other differing from them to bee hereticall , so there liveth not a Christian on earth who in the judgement of many other is not an hereticke , ibid. page The Gyant in Gath was a true man , though much deformed with superfluous fingers and toes , but if one lose any vital part , hee is a man no longer , there is not so much danger in adding superfluities , as is in detracting , what is essentiall and necessarie , that the Church shall never bee robbed of anie truth , necessarie to the beeing of the Church , the promises of Christ assureth us , but that shee shal adde no unnecessarie truth wee have no warrant . Of heresie , because their errours taketh no part of the fundation away , but are onely excesses and additions consisting with all fundamentall trueth (e) (e) Cant. relat . page 316. If any will bee a leader & teaching hereticke , and adde shisme to heresies , and bee obstinate in both , hee without repentance must needs bee lost , while many that succed him in the errour onely , and no obstinacy may bee saved : I say , those howsoever misled , are neither schismaticks nor hereticks before God and are therefore in a state of salvation . Monag . Apar . pag. 28. Sectam & haeresin non faciunt ii qui constanter retinent doctrinam traditam , nec enim ille haereticus dicetur , qui per omnia Romanam fidem integerrimè profitetur . ibid. p. 389. Schismatici & singularitate rapti in transversus quales Scaliger , Calvinus , Pareus , & alii opinatores , quaero autem an quis ferendus sit homo novis terrae filius , qui contempto spretoque consensu majorum suas phreneticas observationes obtruserit Of shisme , because they goe on in the practice of their forbeares without introducing any late novations . 7. They declare it were very good we had present peace with Rome as she stands , her errours being but in opinions which charitie ought to tolerate , that the Church of England would gladly embrace this peace , that Cassander and the like who further this reconciliation are the men of the world most worthie of praise , that the Iesuits and Calvinists both purytanes who hinder this peace , are the most flagitious and intollerable (f) (f) Shelford page 238. Let us Christians leave off our divisions , the papists and wee call upon one God , our Father , upon one Christ , our Saviour , one holy Ghost , our sanctifier , and wee have but one meane to unite us to this holy Uni-trinitie , which is Baptisme , How then should wee not bee brethren ? O blessed Iesus , raise up one to bid the people returne , blessed bee that peace maker among men , Nulla salus bello pacem te poscimus omne . ibid page 296. Why judge wee so eagerly others for holding of errours , ane asy without them ? Some errours we may beare with , charitie teacheth me to judge that errours of Christians are not of intention but ignorance . For I beleeve that willingly and willingly , neither Papist , Protestant nor Lutheran would wrong their Head Christ , whom daily they professe . Montag . apar . page 45. Citius inter digladiantes Philosophos de summo bono , quam inter Protectantes & Papistas inaudita nomina superioribus saeculis , & subintroducta nuper inauspicato de controversis inter ipsos quaestionibus conveniet , sed viderunt posteri de dissidiis istis quae penè nihil sani , sancti nihil , in vita & moribus nobis reliquerunt , cum profani homines & politici sub praetextu & simulatione religionis suas improbas actiones , enormia desideria soleant palliare . Post mota haec certamina inter partes odiis decertatim vatinianis , atque eo deventum est utrinque insaniae & excessus ut ferre eos nequeant zelotae & furiosi plerique utrinque theologi qui non una cum ipsis velint insanire . Quam indignis modis Cassander vi● usque ad miraculum eruditus ipsissima modestia & pro bitatis anima , exceptus fuerit ab importunis utrinque Consoribus , Calvino nimirum propter editum illum aureum libellum de officio viri pii , & pluribus inter Iesuitas propter consultationem Paulo liberiorem ignorat nemo , quam fortunae aliam subire Andreas Tricius aliique qui impudenter noluerunt essa contentiosi . ibid. page 78. Hoc tempore tituli insilices protestantium & papislarum variantibus de fide ae pietate sententiis distraxerunt in diversum Christianum orbem , si qui sint qui bellum malint aeternum , qui velint odia exerceri immortalia traducant illi nostram quae solet odiosius exagitari tepeditatem vel 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 : Ego filius illius pacifici & pacificatoris qui fecit utraque unum desiecta macerie separalionis ; neque certè arbitror ab hac 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ab horret nostrae Anglicanae Ecclesiae suffragium & voluntas , quod nonnulli putant & vehementer contendunt , ibid. page 245. In Pharisaeis ad vivum depictas imagines intueamur eorum hominum qui Pharisaica nobis insituta in Christianismum retulere , puritanos intelligo & Iesuitas , sive ut verius dicam utrumque puritanos honestatis etiam civilis reduviae pietatis carcinomata , Christianismi dehonestamenta pacis & concordiae alastoras & pernities . persons of this age . All this and much more of such stufe you may see printed not onely with allowance but with applause by the chiefe of that faction his Grace himselfe . Montagow the first of the three none suches , Pottar in that his much beloved piece put out as he sayeth at the command of authority . (g) (g) Pottars Epistle to the King , it was undertaken in obedience to your Maiesties particular commandement . Shelfoorde in his pious Sermons printed by the Vniversity of Cambridge presse at the direction of the Vice-Chancellour D. Beel dedicated to the Lord Keeper of England , adorned with many triumphing Epigrammes both latine and english by a number of the fellows , and although called in , yet no censure to this day for all the complaints against it , to our hearing hath been put either on the author or printer , or licencer , or adorners or any Doctrine contained therein , but the worst that Burton could pycke out of it is all defended by Dow and Heylen at his Graces speciall direction and subscribed licence as wee shall hear anone .

I hope now that all true protestants pondering the passages I have brought , beside many mo , wherewith themselves from their owne readings are acquainted , will not only absolve my alledgeances of rashnesse and slander , but also wonder at the incredible boldnesse of those men , who in these times wherein the Prince and state are by so many and deep tyes obliged , and according to their obligations hath so oft declared themselves possionatly zealous for the maintenance of protestant orthodoxie that yet they should be so peart as to print in the royall city , and after long and great grumblings of the people & formal challenges of divers of the learned to reprint their clear affections to the pope and Cardinalls and the whole Romish religion , albeit truely this their ventorious boldnesse seemes not more marveillous then their ingenuitie commendable : For they have said nothing for the pope or Rome , but that which conscience would pouse any man upon all hazards to avow , who was so perswaded in the particular heads of controversies betwixt papists and protestants as they professe themselves to bee , to the end therefore that wee may see the former strange enough passages not to have dropped from their pennes by any inadvertance , but upon plaine designe and deliberate purpose ▪ wee will set downe in the next rowme the affection they professe to the speciall heads of poperie very consonant to that which they have alreadie said of that which wee count the whole lumpe and universall masse of Antichristianisme . The speciall heads of poperie are moe then I have leasure to relate , or you can have patience to hear enumerate . Take notice therefore but of some pryme articles which Protestants use most to detest in papists , foure by name their idolatries , their heresies , their superstitions , their abomination of desolation the masse . If from their own mouth I make clear that in these foure they joyne with Rome against us , it is like none hereafter shall wonder of any thing that yet they have done or said for the advancement of the popish party , and the subverting of the protestants Churches either at home , or over sea , but rather embrace their sobrietie and moderation who being minded , as they professe , doe not break out in many moe both words and deeds , for the destroying of the protestant schisme , and bringing all back to the Catholick Apostolick mother Church of Rome , & unto the feet of his holinesse the Vicar of Christ , the successor of Peter , under whose obedience our holy and blessed antecessors did live and die .

CHAP. IIII. The Canterbuerians joine with Rome in her grossest idolatries .

THE acts of Romes Idolatrie be many and various : None more open to the eye of beholders then these five , their adoration of altars , images , relicts , In the midst of their denyall , yet they avow their giving of religious adoration to the very altar . sacramentall bread , and Saints departed : For the first , their worshipping of the stocke or stone of the altar , if wee would impute it unto the Canterburians , they will deny it allutterlie , and avow , that they may well worship God before the altar , but to worship the altar , it self , to give to it that worship which is done before it , to give to it any religious worship any cultus , any 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , any 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , any adoration , they do detest it , as palpable idolatrie . So his Grace , so Pocklingtoune , so Heylene , so Lawrence , so Montagu do oft professe : But that you may see how little faith those mens Protestations do deserve , and that all may know either their desperat equivocating , or else their spirit of giddinesse , which makes them say and unsay the same things , in the same pages ; consider all of the five named authours , for al their denyall , printing with approbation and applause as much worshipping and adoration even of the altar , as any Papists this day living .

Begin with his Grace , you shal finde him in his Star-chamber speach , for all his denyall , yet avowing within the bounds of two pages , once , twyse , thryse , a) a) Pag. 47. A great reverence is due to the body , and so to the throne where his body is usually present . Ibid. pag. 49. Domino & altari ejus , to the Lord your God , and to his altar , for there is a reverence due to that too . Ibidem pag. 45. Therefore according to the Service-book of the Church of England the priest & the people both are called upon , for externall and bodily worship of God in his Church ; Therefore they which doe it not , innovat , and yet the government is so moderat , God grant it be not too loose , that no man is constrained , no man questioned , onely religiously called upon , venite adoremus . the giving of worship to the altar , and that such worship , which is grounded upon that place of Scripture , Venite , adoremus , which we suppose none will deny to be Divine adoration , But wee must understand , that the King , and the Church of England heere , as in all things must beare the blame of his Graces faults , that the King and his most noble Knights of the garter must be patrones to this practice , and the English Lyturgie the enjoiner of it : But his Grace and those that have the government of the church must bee praised for their moderation , in not urging this practice upon all their brethren . (b) (b) Pockling . altare pag. 160. I shall intreat the pious and judicious reader , to consider with meet reverence , what is recorded among the statuts of that most noble order ; non satis benè Deo atque altari reverentiam exhibuisse visi sunt , ut Deo & ejus altari proni facti debitum impenderent honorem , quoties praetergredietur summum altare in honorem Dei , debita genu flexione , reverentiaque consalutabit . Idem , in his Sunday no Sabbath at the end , If wee doe not onely bend or bow our body to his blessed board , or holy altar , but fall flat in our faces before his footstool so soone as ever we come in sight thereof , what Apostle or father would condemne us for , and not rather be delited to see the Lord so honoured . D. Pocklingtoune with his Graces licence , proclamed the bending of the bodie and the Prostration even to it . Heylene comes up at last to his Masters back , and tels us that the adoration before the altar is the honour of the altar it self , and that filling downe and kissing of the altar ; for the honouring of the altar was a very commendable practise . (c) (c) Antidot Lincolne preface to the King , altars were esteemeed so sacred , that even the barbarous souldiours honoured them with affectionat kisses . Ibid. Pag. 86. The altar being thought to be more sacred , had a far greater measure of reverence and devotion conferred upon it 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , a reverend salutation of the table , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , he and Pocklingtoun both page 142. commends that exhortation of the patriarch of Constantinople , in the fifth counsell , Adoremus primum sacrasanctum altare . Idem , in his answere to Bourtoun , page 137. If you look higher unto the use and practice of the ancient Church , you can not misse a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , an honour to the altar a 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , ad ad geniculationem aeris Dei . Laurence as he prints with Canterburies licence , but undoubtedly by an impudent lee , at the Kings speciall commandement , doth maintaine not only veneration , but religious worshipping adoration , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 and all , (d) (d) page 25. We finde in Ignatius 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , a honour due to the altar , and in Tertullian ad geniculari aris a kneeling to the altars : and in the councell , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , an adoration of the altar ; and in the synodals of Odo reverentian altaribus exhibendam , and in Damascene 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ; and in another divina altaria , and in the life of Marie the Egyptian 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , casting my selfe to the earth , and worshipping the holy ground , and the Grecians triple prostrations tria 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 before the altar in the old Liturgies . not only by a relative and transient worship as he speaks , (e) (e) Ibid. Although they gave a religious reverence to these places , yet they terminat that religious reverence in God not in the places : The throne is honoured for the King ; hee that respects the house for the owners sake , respects not the house but him . but also , which is a degree of madnesse , beyond any thing that I ever have marked in any Papist , he will have a Divine adoration given to the altar it self without any relation , or mentall abstraction , because of the union of Christs bodie with it which sits there as in a chaire of estate even as without scruple or relations , or mentall abstractions ▪ wee give to the humane nature of Christ , for that personall union of the godhead with it Divine adoration , whereof in it selfe it is not capable . (f) (f) Ibid. page 30. So much they said , but to justifie the practice of our Church : I need not say so much , for as although the humane nature of Christ receive all from the Divine , yet wee adore the whole suppositum in grosse , which consists of the humane as well as of the Divine . So because of Gods personall precense in the place , wee adore him without abstraction of his person , from the place , to wit , the altar . Pockling . alt page 153. Altars have beene in allages so greatly honoured because they are the seats and chaires of Estate , where the Lord vouchsafeth to place himselfe amongst us . Quid est enim altare ( as Optatus speakes ) nisi sedes corporis & sanguinis Christi .

For the adoration of the communion elements , As much adoration of the elemēts they grant as the Papists require . which Protestants count an Idolatrie so horrible , that for it alone they would not faile to seperate from the church of Rome , though she had no other fault , (g) (g) Apologie des Eglises reformes par Ioan Daile chap. 20. their minde is plaine by the practice which his Grace maketh Heylene in his State answere defend , we do passe their adoration in the act of communicating , albeit wee think it strange to see men who once were counted moderat and wise , by the touch of his Graces patron , to become so insolent , as to hisse and hout at the doctrine and practice of the best reformed Churches , as vile and monstruous , (h) (h) Hale remedy of profainnesse , page 128. away with these monsters of opinion and praictise , in this sacrament Christ Iesus is heer really tendered to us , and who can , who dare take him but on his knees . who in the act of receaving hath thought meet to sit or stand , rather than to kneele , we spake onlie of these their new adorations , which against the constant practice of the English church they are now begun to use , without the act of receaving , a number of low cringes towards these elements , when they take the paten in their hand , a low inclinabo before the bread , when they set it downe , another ; when they take up the chalice , a third ; when they set it downe a fourth , (i) (i) Heylens moderat answer , pag. 237. if bowing towards the communion table bee offensive to you at the administration of the Sacrament , I would faine know upon what reasons you stomack , that men should use their greatest reverence in so great an action thinke you it fit the Priest should take into his hands the holy mysteries with out lowly reverence , or that it is an innovation so to doe ? That these avowed adorations before the element , without the act of receaving , are directed by them , not only they say to the person of Christ , whom they make their essentially present , but also unto the elements themselves ; we prove it by no other reason but their former confession . Their adoration before the altar is done as they confesse unto the altar , much more their adoration before the elements , without the act of receaving must bee unto the elements : For I hope they will bee loath to affirme , that there is in the altar any worthinesse or aptitude or any other cause imaginable , which can make it capable of adoration , but the same causes are in the elements in a farre higher degree : The relation to Christs Body and Person , which they make the only foundation of those worships being much more true , more near , more clear in the elements , then in the altar , howsoever the Popish prostrations , and adorations , before the hostie ; which to all Protestants is so abominable idolatry , are absolved by these men , not onely by the clearing of Papists of all idolatrie everie where , but particularly by their impatience , to have the adoration of the elements to be called Popish . For in our book of Canons when in the copie sent up to the King , the adoration of the bread , Chap. 6. Was styled by our Bishopes the Popish adoration , my lord of Canterburie on the margine with his owne hand directeth to scrape out the word Popish , as we can shew in the authentick manuscript of that booke now in our hands .

Concerning images , In the matter of images their full agrean●e with Rome . behold their assertions , first they tell us that the pullers down of images , out of their churches , were but lownes and knaves , pretending onely religion to their profane covetousnesse , that they were truelie iconoclasticke and iconomachiam hereticks . (k) (k) Montag . orig. pag. 162. Imagines illa per Ecclesias constituta quae furorem effugerunt , iconoclastarum . ibid. pag. 174 sub praetextu reformatae pietatis , Deum , Ecclesiam , pietatem , per nefandissima sacrilegia eversis ubicunque monasteriis , templis , sacrariis , & redactis in fiscum maximis reditibus emunxerunt causantur sc. religiosi nebulones , &c. 2 That those who do pull downe or breake , or offereth any indignitie to a crosse to a crucifix , to a Saints image ; are but madfools , that those injuries reflect upon Christ and the Saints , and are revenged sundrie times with plagues from heaven ; (l) (l) Montag . antid. pag. 28. Verissimum est omninoquod affirmas 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , ut Caesaris imago in numismate , ut Miletii character in pala annuli , quod si quis Caesarem in charactere suo & numismate 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 in archetypum transit ea contumelia , quo modo si quis sancti alicujus imaginem dedecore afficiat , illum ego & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 optaverim , & suae temeritatis paenas dare . Studley in his glasse for schismatiks about the end , tels us , that hee knew a Churchwarden for the taking downe of a crosse , which he conceived to have beene by his neigbours idolized , to have al his swine stricken with madnesse , and therafter the man in desperation to have drowned himselfe : Whence hee exhorts all men to beware so much as to censure their antecessors of idolatry , for erecting such monuments of their devotion 3 That the church of England ( they take that church commonly by a hudge mistake , for their owne prevalent faction therein ) doeth not onely keep innumerable images of Christ , and the Saints in the most eminent and conspicuous places of their Sanctuaries , but also dayly erect a number of new , long , and large ones , very curiously dressed , and that heerein they have reason to rejoice and glory , above all other reformed Churches ; (m) (m) Montag . antid. pag. 24. Haeretici nequaquam à te censeri debemus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 asservamus enim deligenter , & cum cura Petri , Pauli , beatae virginis , sanctorum aliorum innumeras imagines , praesertim vero Iesu Christi redemptoris crucifixi , etiam in templorum cryptis , & larariis in parietibus , & fenestris quas tamen non adoramus . Ibid. pag. 26. 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 ut cum Theodoreto loquar , impugnamus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Sunt apud nos qùod aliquoties dicendum frequentissimae imagines in Ecclesiis per stallos , ut vocant , Canonicorum , per fenestras , ambones , vasa , vestimenta , & ipsa 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Pokling . altare pag. 87. In my lord of Lincolne private chappell , are to bee seene beside the altar , most richlie furnished closse to the wall under the east window , many goodly pictures which can not but strick the beholders with thoughts of pietie , and devotion at their entrance into so holy a place , as the picture of the passion , and likewise of the holy apostles , together with a fair crusifix , and our blessed Lady , and S. Iohn set up in painted glasse in the east window , just over the holy table , or sacred altar ; So that I must say , That who so lives in this diocese , must bee condemned of great impietie , that will desert his Lord , and not follow him giving a precedent of such devotion , so conformable of the rubrick of our Church . Heylens answere , page 174. For your particular instances , in the cathedrals of Durhame , Bristou , Pauls , &c. the most that you except against , are things of ornament , which you are grieved to see now more rich or costly , nor they have beene formerly . Pokling ; altare pag. 24. Our Churches ( by Gods mercy ) are a glory to our religion , beautified with goodly glasse windowes . Ibid. pag. 87. A fair Crucifix , and our blessed Lady , and S. Iohn set up in painted glasse in the east window , just over the sacred altar . 4. That these their manifold images , they use not onely for ornament , but also to be bookes to the Laicks , both for their instruction and kindling of their affections to piety , zeale , charity , imitation of the Saints ; (n) (n) Widowes Schismaticall Puritain , p. 10 Church pictures are an externall beauty of the Church , a memorie of honour to the dead , & S. Gregorie cals them Laymens books . Poklin alt. pag. 87. There are to be seen many goodly pictures , which can not but strike the beholders with thoughts of piety and devotion . Montag . antig page . 318 The pictures of Christ , of the blessed Virgine , and Saints , may be made , had in houses , set up in Churches , respect and honour may be given to them the Protestants do it , and use them for helps of pietie , in rememoration , and effectuall representing of the prototyp . Ibid. pag. 3●0 . Images have three uses , assigned by our schooles , Instruction of the rude , commone faction of storie , and stirring up of devotion , these you and wee also give unto them . 5. That towards the images of Christ and the Saints , the hearts of the Godly ought to be affected with a pious devotion , with a religious reverence , and that this reverence may very lawfully bee expressed , with an outward religious adoration ; yea , Prostration before the image , as well as before the altar , with the eyes of the adorer fixed upon the image ; (o) (o) Montag . adtid . page 30. Christiani omnes adoramus Christum , imagini & simulachro , non prosternimur coram imagine sorsan , quid ad rem vero ? Invitatio est ad pietatem , ex intuitu tolle scandalum , ita si velis prosternaris , etiam oculos defigas in crusifixum ante mensam Dominicam inclinamur , in genua procumbinus , venerationem exhibemuss , non tamen mensam adoramus . 6. That the Popish distinction of duleia and latreia is good , and well grounded , that the onely abuse of images is the worshipping of them with latreia ; that the Papists are free of this fault , that all their practice heere is but iconoduly , not idolatrie , that all our contraversie with them about the worshipping of relicts , and so much more of images , ( for to images , they professe a farre lesse respect then to reliques ) is but the toying of children , the striving about shadowes , that long ago both sides , are really agreed , though some for their own pride and greed delight to keep this contraversie about ambiguous words still upon foot . (p) (p) Montag . antid. page 16. Lateriam , illum cultum soletis appellare , neque ego nomen aut nominis rationem , vel subiectum improbavero , tum à duleia soletis distinguere , non alio fine , quàm quod rerum subjectarum rationes , secundum magis & minus inter se distinguanur . page 27. Tantummodo taxumus in imaginibus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 usu & utilitatem non sollicitamus ullo pacto . page 24. Pergamus ad , Ecclesiae Romanae 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Montag . orig. page 40. Nolunt illi quovis pacto creatura cuicunque lateriā ne quidem cultu relativo exhiberi sed non constat quis sit ille cultus latreiae soli Deo precise & peculiariter , debitus quibus terminis circamscribatur : quis ille qui solus creaturis debetur , quis ejus modus , gradus , mensura , partes , conditio , limitatio , omnia vacillant vel ignorantur , nec illud agitur ut constare p●ssint lusum diu est in hac questione & illusum per ambiguitates è privatis nempe vel contendendi vel ditescendi ; respectibus constet autem hoc , & facilè conveniet inter nos Magnam certè graciam ab Ecclesia Christi , & partibus inter se contendentibus iniverint , qui docerent quousque progredtin hoc sanctorum cultu , & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 possumus sine justo scandalo , animae pereulo , pietatis & religionis naufragio interim quod pueri solent , in hac re , ut in multis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 .

About reliques they agree with Papist . Concerning reliques they teach first that the carying of them about in cloaths by devout people is tollerable . (q) (q) Andrews stricturae For their reliques were we sure , they were true wee would carry to them the regard that becomes . It was rashnesse & nudiscreetly done of Vigilantius so to a base his termes concerning them , had they power of doing miracles we would have esteemed them so much the more , but in their own degree : yet the caring of them about in linnen cloathes , and kissing which Vigilantius did object , if he did it truely , we would rather bear with it , and excuse it is as proceeding from popular and privat divotion which will many times overshut it self then commend it . Next that those bones or that dust of the deceased Saints ought justly to be put in a casse of silk or of gold that they may be well hung about our necke and oft kissed ; that they may be layed up amongst our most pretious jewels . (r) (r) Montag . antid. page 17. Ossa sanctorum cineres , reliquias vase aureo , velamine precioso convolvebant . Ego certe cum Constantino , illas reliquias fasciis involuam , auro includam circumgestendas , admovebo labiis ac collo suspensa manibus oculisque crebo usupatas intuebor , vel in apothecas condam , & recludam inter preciofissima cermelia censendas . 3. That in those reliques there is oft found so much grace , holin●sse , ●●rtue , that all who touches them are sanctified by that touch . (s) (s) Montag . antid. page 16. Magnus Basilius ait 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Martyris ossa quicunque tetigerit ob gratiam illi corpori infidentem , fit quadam tenus particeps sanctificationis . 4. That to these relicts a great honour yea a relative worship is due albeit not a latria or divine adoration (t) (t) Montag . antid. page 16. Agnoscimus ecclesiam veterem sanctorū reliquiis & cineribus magnum honorem detulisse , & veneratione quadam relativa coluisse . Fiftly , That pilgramages to the places where those relicts stand are very expedient , that protestants doe reprove only these pilgramages towards the Church of the Saints which are made for greed or superstition , that papists do disallow all such as well as wee . (w) (w) Montag . antid. page 44. Neque peregrinationem religiosam ad loca ut appellant sancta quisquam improbaverit qui in rebus ecclesia Christiana veteris non est hospes ; improbat Molinaeus & meritio peregrinationes ut appellant malas , inventas vel ad superstitionem , vel ad questum , vel ad tyrannidam , quas & ipsas nemo sanus inter catholicos Romanos non improbaverit . 6. That all the contraversie which here remaines betwixt papists and protestants is about just nothing even about goates woll and the shadow of ane Asse . (x) (x)

Montag . orig. page 45. ut de lana caprina , vel 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 hic rixare videantur contendentes .

They come very neer to the invocation of Saints .

About the invocation of Saints whereof the learned of the papists are so ashamed that they disavow their owne practise thereof , (y) (y) Andrews structurae page 57. The Cardinall freely confessed to M. Causabon that he had never prayed to a Saint in all his life save only when he happened to follw the procession , and that then he sung ora pro nobis with the Clerks butelse not . yet our men tell us first that the Saints in heaven are truely our meditators with God of intercession , as Christ is of redemption . (z) (z) Montag . antid. page 20. Non anuerim sanctos esse orationis & intercessionis ut loqu● soletis mediatores , sed universum universos : precibus suis apud Deum interveniun● & orationibus mediantur , Cbristus solus & absque aliis est mediator redemptionis & quoad meritum passionis sua 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 intercessionis mediator . Again , that wee ought carefully to keep the Saints festivalls , to this end that we may be partakers of their intercession . (a) (a) Andrews strictura . page 8. We agree with S. Augustine , we celebrat the memories and hold the feasts of the blessed Martyrs as well for imitation , as that wee may be partakers of their intercession . Schelfords first sermon page ●4 . Upon the Saints dayes the Saints in heaven joine with us , now if the Saints in heaven after their manner aide us with their prayers , shall we be so base minded as not to pray with them ? Ibid. page 27. In observing Saints dajes and in dedicating remples to God in their name ; these who neglect this holy followship have a great losse , which none can see but they who have spirituall eyes 3. That albeit for common their intercession be universall , yet that sundry times they descend to particulars , They remember the estates of their friends and acquaintance as they left it at their death , they are informed of many new particulars by the Angels which hath been upon earth , and by the Saints which after their death hath newly come to the heaven , and that accordig to their particular informations they frame their intercession . (a) (a) Andrews answer to Cardinall Pirron . 20 chap. Wee wil hope well that Theodosius might interceed with God for his children , wee see no cause to the contrary . Montag . antid. page 22. Meminerunt amicorum suorum & rerum ase quondam in terris gestarum quoeirca ad Christum in coelo recollecti poterint devia ordinaria per Iesum Christum apud Deum patrem amicos , familiares 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 precibus commendare & adiuvare . .

4. If wee were certaine that the Saints in heaven knew our estate it were no fault at all but verie expedient to make our prayers to them that they might interceed with Christ for us . And though wee bee not certaine of their knowledge , yet all the fault that is in our prayers to them is only some idlenesse and curiositie but no impietie at all . (b) (b) Montag . antid. page 229. Save all other labour in this point . Prove only their knowledge of any thing ordinarly I promise you streight I wil say holy S. Mary pray for me . Ib , antid. page 23. Tu mihi proba & demonstra posse me certum esse de scientia sanctorum particulari quocunque tandum modo ac quisita ego certe quod ad me ipsum attinet sanctos defunctos beatam puta virginem , sanctissimos Apostolos , gloriosissimos Martyres non verebor adire interpellare , alloqui , supplicibus precibus deprecari habeant me commedatum & adiutum suis intercessionibus apud Deum patrem per filium . Idem antid. page 200. Perhaps there is no such great impietie in saying holy S. Laurence pray for me . 5. That none ought to reprove our prayers unto our Angell keeper . (c) (c) Montag . invocation of Saints page 99. If thus my self resolved to do infer ( holy Angel keeper pray for me ) I see no reason to be taxed with point of Popery or superstition much lesse of absurdity or impiety . Ibidem author . page 203. The case of Angels not guardians as being continually attendant alwayes at hand , though invisible , and therefore though we may say S. angel keeper pray for me , it followeth not , wee may say S. Gabriel pray for me . The Saint in heaven which the papists doe most idolize is our blessed Virgine to whome it is well knowne they give much more false worshipe , then true to the whole Trinitie , Concerning her the Canterburians affirme first , that she is created in another way then any of the race of Adam , that God did meditate fiftie ages upon the work of her perfect creation , that shee did live all her dayes without mortall sin yea without all actuall sin , yea without all originall . (d) (d) Anthonie Stafford Female glorie . page 3. Others of these first and purer times not without admiration observe that God was almost fiftie ages in the meditation of the structure of this stately palace . Montag . apar . page 301 Magno procul dubio opere templum illud 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 aparabatur , nec una de multis mater Domini in hunc mundum processit è materno utero . Ibid. page 338. Vicunque conceptam in originali peccato , vixisse tamen immunem à mortali peccato cum Augustino putaverim . Staffords Femal glorie in his proemiall verses , for Eves offence not hers she did begin to learn repentance ere she knew to sin . Idem page 20. She sent forth many a sigh for sin not having committed any , and bewailed that of which she was utterly ignorant idem page 8. The apostles sometimes were obscured with the fog of sin , but her brightnesse nothing vitious could lessen , much lesse alutterly extinguish . that she is now advanced above all the Angells to the highests created perfection that is possible to the daughter , mother , and spouse of God and that her very bodie is alreadie translated to the heavens . (e) (e) Femal glorie page 28. Nothing in her was wanting but the Dietie it self . Idem in the preface , Whether we regard her person or her divine gifts , she is in dignitie next to God himself . Ibid. Great Queen of Queens , daughter , and mother , and the spouse of God Idem . page 210. Her assumption by many of the Fathers , by all the Romish Church , and some of the reformed is held for an undoubted . 3. That God hath made her to bee true Ladie and empresse of the Catholike Church of all the earth , and of the heaven , and that all these honours she hath abtained by her due deservings and merits . (f) (f) Montag . apar page 312. Dominam profecto indicat Mariae nomen , nam revera facta est domina omnium creaturarum , Damasaenus ait , cum conditoris omnium effecta fuerit mater . Ibid. page 302. Certe nulli Sanctorum dedit Deus plura , nulli majora , nullum ne omnibus quidam Sanctis , tanta , hoc est elogia matris Dei Deus impertivit qui titulus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 omnes omnium creaturarum dignitates illud unicum privilegium supergreditur . Recte ait . B Thomas , beata virgo ex hoc quod est mater Dei habet quandam dignitatem infinitam . Ex his licet colligere ( inquit Baradas ) sanctissimam virginem infinitam haberè quondam dignitatem ex Deo , qui & è Bonaventura recitat , majorem mundum Deus facere potest majorem autem matem quam est mater Dei Deus facere non potest Fem gl . page 21. She undoubtedly deserved to be rapt up , if it were possible , a storie higher than was S. Paul . Ibid. page 80. Certainly all the ancient Fathers with one consent affirme that she deserves to be Empresse of all others who humbled her self below them all . 4. That all the Angels and Saints in heaven , let bee men upon earth are obliged to adore her and bow their soules unto her . (g) (g) Femal glorie . In the Panegyrirk , To whom do bow the fouls of all the just , whose place is next to Gods , to whom the hierachie do throng , and for whom heaven is all one song . Ibid page 3. Truely our belief may easily digest this that his omnipotencie would make her fit to bee Empresse of this lower world . Ibid. page 17. There were no doubt some of Gratitudes children , who lay prostrat before , & did homage to their dearest Lady . Ibidem pag. 32. The Saints glorious Empresse . 5. That she knoweth all things perfectly heere beneath upon the earth : For in the face of God in the glasse of the Trinity she doth behold all creatures . (h) (h) Femal glorie panegyrick . Whose place is next to GOD , and in her face all creatures and delytes do see as darling of the Trinity . 6. That it is but prophane puritans who refuse to say the Ave Maries , and to follow the example of their pious predecessors who wont so to pray . (i) (i) Ibid. pag. 220. The Puritans of this land are those I mean , they reject all testimonies of her worth as haile Marie full of grace , &c. They abhorre to hear her called Domina , because forsooth they challenge to themselves a greater measure of knowledge but a lesser of piety than did their antecessors by disclaming wordes and phrases familiare to antiquity . Of one thing I will assure them till they bee good Marians they shall never be good Christians . 7. That the devotions of the present Monks , Nunnes , and Princes who have enrolled their names in the sodality of the virgin Mary is worthy of imitation . (k) (k) pag. 23. My arithmetick will not serve mee to number all those who have registrate their names in the sodality of the rosarie , of this our blessed Lady . The Princes of this Isle have not beene defective in doing her all possible honour , and in consecrating chappels and temples to her memory . Many holy orders also are of this sodality as the Benedictins , the Cistertians , the Franciscans , the Cartusians , and many others . If all those testimonies and examples of great worth and pious people will not move us to honour her , wee shall be judged both unworthy of this life here & ignorant of that better to come . 8. That the old pious ceremonie of burning of waxe candels in all the Churches of England through the whole cleare day of her purification ought to be renewed . (l) (l) Ibid. pag. 153. This day the celebration whereof is instituted by the Church is called Candlemas , as much as to say , the day of lights , on which while masse was singing very many tapers were burning in the Church . Montag . orig. pag. 157. Diem ab illa solemnitate celebrem vocant praesentationis : nos angelice the purification of our Lady , vel communi sermone potius . Candlemasday adistributione vel gestatione cereorum ardentium . Couzins did put all this in practise in the cathedral of Durham mede burn in day light some hundreths of wax candles . Peter Smart for preaching against him was deposed and imprisoned , but Couzins for his devotion advanced from a poore prebend to a Provost of a Colledge and a royall Chaplaine in ordinar.

9. That the Christians obtained that famous victory over the Turkes in Lepanto by her intercession at their prayers with Christ her Sonne . (m) (m) Femal glory pag. 226. The originall of the sodalitie of the blessed virgin is derived from the battell of Naupactum gained by Iohn of Austria and the Christians , which victorie was attributed to her intercession with her Son . All this his Grace hath permitted under his eye to be printed at London without any censure , and when this doctrine was challenged by Burtoun , he was rewarded with the losse of his eares and perpetuall prison . The booke which he inveighed against let bee to bee recalled , is openly excused in print at his Graces direction as containing no evill but only innocent retorications . (n) (n) Heylens answer . page 123. As for the book in tituled the Femal glory you finde not in it that I see by your collections any thing positively or dogmatickly delivered contrarie unto any point of doctrine estabished and received in the Church of England . Some swelling language there is into it and some Apostrophees I perceive by you to the virgin Mary which if you take for invocations you mistake his meaning , no invocation hitherto in point of doctrine . Yea M. Dow with his Graces licence pronounceth that book to bee free of all poperie and that upon this reason , because the author professeth his tracing the steps of Doctor Montagow whom all England must know to be above all suspition of poperie . (o) (o) M. Dow page 54. In all these panegyrick straines of Rhetorick ( for such for the most part they seem rather than positive assertions ) Stafford hath not deviat so much to the one extreame as M. Burtouns marginall hath to the other in scoffing and calling her the new great goddesse Diana . And if it bee true that he hath not digressed in any particular from D. Montagu the B of Chichester as M. Burtoun makes him affirme , I dare boldly say M. Burtoun will never be able too finde the least point of Poperie in it : For it is well know , that Bishop hath approved him self such a champion against Rome , that they who have tryed his strength durst never yet come to a second encounter .

CHAP. V. The Canterburians avow their embracing of the popish heresies and grossest errours .

THE nature of heresie is so subtilized by our faction , that so farre as in hew lyes it is now quite evanished in the aire , and no mo heresies are to be found on the earth . With the Socinian Remonstrants , they exeeme all tenets controverted this day among any Christians , from being the Subject of heresie : For they tell us , that the belief of the doctrines uncontraverted by all is sufficent for salvation . (a) (a) Pottar cites from Causabon these words : Put by controversies these things , wherein al sects universally doe agree , are sufficient for salvation . And howsoever some of them will be content to count the Sociniam Arianisme , and Macedoniansme to bee true heresies ; yet , as wee shew before , all of them do cleare the Popish errours of this imputation . Alwayes not to strive for words , our assertion is , that the grossest of the Roman errours which in the common stile of Protestants , wont to go for heresies , are maintained by the Canterburians for catholicke trueth . For to cleare this , cast over the books of Bellarmine , and see if his grossest tenets be not by them embraced . In his first tome , his errours about the Scriptures imperfection , and doctrinall traditions , seemes to be most weightie . In his second , beside these alreadie named , his defence of the monastick vowes of , Limbus Patrum and Purgatorie are verie palpable . In the third , his ascribing too little too the Sacramenst of the Old Testament , and too much too the Sacraments of the New , his making all infants in baptisme too be regenerat , and all non-baptized too bee damned , his corporall presence of Christs bodie on the altar , his sacrifice of the Masse , auricular confession , extreame unction , are very grosse corruptions . In the last tome , his errours about faith , justification , merit , free-will , are among the chiefe . In all those , consider how farre our partie is long agoe declined to the left hand .

Begin with Scripture and traditions : The reformed churches in the harmonie of their confessions lay all down one common ground , They joine with Rome in setting up traditions in prejudice of Scripture . for their mutuall consent ; the Scriptures absolute perfection , wiehout the help of any doctrinall tradition : Hold me once this piller , the whole edifice of the reformation must fall . To batter downe this fort , the Papists plant two engines : One , that there is diverse Apostolicke and ancient traditions , both rituall and dogmaticall , which , beside Scripture with a divine faith must be firmely beleeved : An other , that Scripture must not be taken in any sense by us , but that wherein the ancient fathers of the church have understood it , or the present church do take it . In both these very dangerous corruptions our partie joynes with Rome : They glorie (b) (b) Heylens antid. Lincoln page 8● . sect. 2. Things that have beene generally in the Church of Christ , are generally conceaved to have been derived-from Apostolical tradion , without , any speciall mandat left in Scripture for the doing of them . Praying directlie towards the East is conceaved to bee of that condition , why may wee not conclude the like of setting up the altar along the wall . Many things come into our minde by a successionall tradition , for which wee can not finde an expresse command , wich yet we ought to entertaine , ex vi Catholicae consuetudinis ; of which traditions there are many , which still retaine their force among us in England . This Church ( the Lord bee thanked for it ) hath stood more firme for apostolical traditions , than any other whatsoever of the reformation . Samuel Hoards sermon , page 15. Wee yeeld that there are apostolical traditions rituall and dogmaticall , which are no where mentioned or enjoined in the Scriptures , but delivered by the word of mouth , by the apostles to their followers , for some of which these are reputed , the number of Canonciall books , The Apostles creed the baptisme of infants , the fast of Lent , the Lords day , the great feastivals of Easter and Whitson day , beside these , we confesse , there are and have bene many ancient Ecclesiastick traditions , from which as foundations grew those noted practices of not fasting on the Sunday , of adoring towards the East , prostration before the altar , of signing the baptized with the crosse , of exorcifing the partie baptised , and putting a white garment upon them , of receiving the Eucharist fasting , of mixing water with the wine , of sending it to such as were absent , of eating the consecrat bread in the Church , or carrying it home , of crossing themselve● when they went out , or when they went in , when they went to bed , or whe● theyr ose , when they sat down to meat , when they lighted Candles , or had any businesse of moment , to doe , that ceremonies and rites of this nature are unde● the power of the Church to ordaine we generally grant to our adversaries . White on the Sabboth , page 97. The reformed Churches reject not all traditions , but such as are spurious , superstitious , and no consonant to the holy Scripture , but genuine traditious , agreeablee to the rule of faith , derived from the apostolicall times by a successive current , and which have the uniforme testimonie of poins of antiquitie , are received and honourd by us . Now such are these which follow the historicall tradition , concerning the number , integritie , dignitie , and perfection of the books of Canonicall Scripture , the Catholick exposition of many sentences of Scripture , the apostles creed , the baptisme of infants , the observation of the Lords day , and some other feastivals , as Easter Pentecost , &c. baptizing and administration of the Supper in holy assemblies the service of the Church in a knowne language , the delivering of the Communion to the people in both kindes , the superioritie of Bishops over Priest and Deacons in Iurisdiction , and power of ordination . and triumph above all other reformed churches , that they do embrace doctrinall traditions , for which in Scripture there is no ground ; And of this kinde they reckon out some of great importance ; such as are , the baptisme of infants , the sanctifying of the Sabbath , the Apostles Creede , the giving of the cup to the people , praying in a known tongue , our knowledge of Scripture to be Scripture , the names and number of the Canonicall Bookes and their distinction from Apocrypha , of this kinde they maintaine large as many as Rome . For at the first word the● speake to us of six hundreth (c) (c) Montag . orig. pa. 396. Vbi iubentur in Scripturis infantes baptizori , aut in coena Domini sub utraque specie communicantes participare . 600. sunt ejusmodi in rebus sacris à deo institutis , ecclesiae mandatis , & usurpaatis ab ecclesia , de quibus possumus profiteri , nihil tale docet Scriptura , Scriptura haec non praedicat . among these traditions , which we must embrace with an undoubted faith ; They reackon up the authoritie of the Bishopes above the Priests , prostration before the altars , worshipping towards the East , crosse i● Baptisme , crossing of our faces at all occasions the standing of a crucifix upon the altar , and wha● else they please to urge , for which they can get no Scripture warrant . To this head they referre the verie customes of the Popish church in latter times , for which they have no scribe in any write● let be in any Father : (d) (d) Montag . orig. page 276. Nihil est memoriae proditum , quod ego quidem sciam hac dei apud vetustiores , sive historicos sive patres , prohabile tamen est hanc receptam ecclesiae consuetudinem de traditione vetustiore , an t scriptis etiam patrum vetustiorib● nunc deperditis dimanasse . Montag . apar . page 389. Ad me quod attinet , quid à sanctis patribus per illa tempora inventum , primo & usurpatum , nulla traditione priore commendatum , nullo usu veterum , ne quidem vestigiis leviter impressis , consignatum per tot aunorum decursum ad nostra usque tempora sine contradictione descenderit , non video cur non 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 vim suam obtineat & authoritatem . Absit enim ut universalis ecclesia vel in rebus de facto , & ecclesiasticis ritibus tam diu aberraverit . Ibid. page 382. Meminerimus Tertullianum olim statuisse cum applausu de hujusmodi consuetudinibus , si legem expostules scriptam , nullam invenies , sed traditio a praetenditur auctrix , consuetudo confirmatrix , & fides observatrix . Et Irenaeus , quid autem si neque Apostoli reliquiss●nt nobis Scripturas , nonne oporteret ordinem sequi traditsonis . Idem antig . page 42. That author sayes no more then is justifiable touching traditions : for thus hee sayes , The doctrine of the Church is two wayes delivered unto us ; first by writing , then by tradition from hand to hand . Both are of alike value of force unto pietie . Yea , all the injunctions of the Bishopes must be Ecclesiastick traditions , whereto the conscience must submit no lesse then to the precepts of God . (e) (e) White in his examination of the dialogue presseth not only this testimonie of Austine , Etiamsi Scripturae authoritas non subesset , totius tamen orbis in hanc partem consensus , instar precepti contineat , nam & alia multa quae per traditionem in Ecclesiis observantur , authoritatem sibi scriptae legis usurpaverunt , but also that of Eusebius , Quicquid in sanctis Episcoporum consiliis decernitur , id universum divinae voluntati debet attribui : And this of Bernards , Sive , Deus sive homo vicarius Dei mandatum quodcunque tradiderit , pari profecto obsequendum est cura , pari reverentia suscipiendum , ubi tamen Deo contraria non praecepit homo . In the meane time Scripture must bee stiled the booke of hereticks (f) (f) Montag . orig. page 353. Eusebius de Severianis hereticis loquens , ait , Hilege , Prophetis & Euang●liis utantur socrarum Scripturarum sensus & sententias , ut nostri salent purtani & novatores pro suo arbitratu interpretantur . Chounaei Colect . page 31. Sensum Scripturarum ex patribus ecclesiae deductum , traditum & conseruatum in ecclesia , & approbatum , quidni pro tali traditione agnoscamus , in cujus veritate acquiescendum , & à qua minimè discendendum sit . Montag . orig. page 318. Neque enim insanire solent sine Scripturis haeretici & mirificè easdem ad suos 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 solent applicare defendendos persuadendosque . a Lesbian rule . (g) (g) Montag . apar . page 382. Non ut nostri novatores de●dirant quibus quicquid est 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 respit & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 & ideo refigendum est ● vel ut amant loqui reformandum ad Dei verbum , hoc est ad Lesbiam plane regulam ●ipsorum cerebrositatem amussitandum . In no controversies no not in Sermons any use may bee made of it , except so farre as we can backe our deductions from Scripture , by consent of the ancient Fathers or present church . (h) (h) Pocklingtoun altare . page 129. The godlie and learned Fathers of our church , give strict charge to private preachers , that they preach nothing in their preachings which they would have the people religiously to believe and observe , but that which is agreeable to the doctrine of the old and new Testament , and that which the catholick fathers , and ancient bishops have formerly taught and collected from thence . White upon the Sabboth , page 12. The holy Scripture is the fountaine and living spring , containing in all sufficiencie and aboundance whatsoever is necessarie to make Gods people wise unto salvation . The consentient and unanimous testimonie of the true Church of Christ in the primative ages thereof is the canalis , or a conduit pipe to derive and convoy to succeding generations the celestiall water contained in the holy Scripture . Ibid. From Meisnerus hee sayeth , Iniuriam nobis facit Beeanus scribendo , nos docere solam Scripturam esse normam & iudicem contraversiarum fidei , imò & spiritum sanctum , seu judicem supremum praesupponimus , & ecclesiam ceu iudicem inferiorem libenter admittimus ; ideoque soli Scripturae officium iudicandi absque omni distinctione non assignamus . Idem page 14. The ecclesiasticall storie reporterh of Nazianzen and Basille , that in their studying the holy Scriptures they collected the sense of them , not from their owne judgement or presumption , but from the testimonie and authoritie of the ancients , who had received the rule of the true intellegence of Scripture from they holy apostles by succession .

In the doctrine of faith , justification , fulfilling of the Law , merit , they are fully popish . In our most important controversies anent faith , justification , fulfilling of the Law , merite , &c. they teach , first , that faith is no more but a bare knonwledge , and naked assent , that in the nature of it there is no confidence , application at all , that the souls confidence and application of Gods promises , are the acts onely of hope and charity , that justifying faith is the catholicke faith , a generall assent to the articles of the Apostolick Creed , that particular personail applying faith , but presumption and fantasie . (i) (i)

Shelfoord page 36 This one faith is called by Divines the Catholick faith , contained in the three Creedes of the apostles , Nice and Athanasius . The false faith is contrarie too this , the private faith , or fancie rather , by which men believe to besaved by them , that which is the mother and nource to vice , an enemie to all good life ; and that this is no the Catholick faith , shall appear , because that faith hath not a speciall object , as a mans self , or Gods speciall favour to this or that particular man , which is hopes object , but a catholick object , which is the whole first truth , and every member of Gods books , as the school to acheth , this faith goeth but to the truth and esse of divine things . Fait giveth those truths a being and substance in our minde , but after hope layeth hold on them in the wil and affections , and applyeth them to our selves , & charitie goeth in unto them . The apostle sayeth , That hee who cometh to God must believe that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him , not a rewarder of me or thee , as if the article of faith were personall .

Idem page 106. In the love of the heart lyeth the greatest apprehension . The greatest meane of our apprehending of him is by charitie , which layes hold on him in the will and reasonable affections , Chounai Collect. 82. Applicatio ex parte hominis , non ex alia ratione procedit , quam ex amplexu amoris & desiderii . Ibid. page 97. Det Deus hanc spem , & suavissimam hujus spei plerophoriam .

Again , they teach that justification is ascribed by the Apostle to faith onely , by way of beginning inchoative , because the assent to the trueth of God , is that first vetue which the chaine of all other vertues , whereby wee are compleet lie justified , for common , doth follow . (k) (k) Chonnaei collect , page 69. Inchoativè per fidem iustificat Deus , dat sc. propter Christum cognitionem , ex cognitione fidem , ex fide spem sive fiduciam , ex fiducia charitatem , ex charitate adhaesionem obediendi & complacendi defiderium , ex isto desiderio meritorum Christi salubrium applicationem , ex ista applicatione sanctificationem , seu observantiam mandatorum , ex istis omnibus in actu scilicet consummato justificationem , ex illa salvationem quae omnia tum efficaciter per canalem Dei gratiae , ex fide tanquam ex principio seu radice , per connaturalitatem omnium ad fidem , & ad se invicem effluere videantur , quaecunque ab aliquibus horum proveniunt ad fidem , tanquam ad omnium originem referenda sunt , & in hoc sensu arbitramur Apostolum , 3. ad Rom. vers. 28. loquutum fide homines justificatum iri scilicet per fidem elicituram ex consequentiis suis operationem . 3. That charitie is the forme of faith , and that to it , the act of justification is much more reasonablie ascribed then too faith . (l) (l) Shelfoord page 102. Charitie is called of schoole Divines grace it selfe . It is that law of the Spirit which freeth from death and sin . It is the maine refuge of a distressed conscience . It covereth a multitune of sins . It will not suffer them to appear : Without charitie workes are dead , as well as faith and other vertues . Hence the Schoole calleth charitie the forme of vertues . Ibid. page 106. Faith converteth the minde to God , but it is love that converts the heart and will to God , which is the greatest and last conversion ; for we never seek any thing till wee desire it . Our conversion is begun in the minde by faith , but it is only halfe conversion , yea no conversion of the whole man , except the love of the heart ( where lyeth the greatest apprehension ) follow it : wee see salvation by faith , but we obtaine it not , till wee seeke it by charities desire . Wherefore I conclude , that for as much as charitie is the most neere and immediat cause of our conversion , that it is also the most precious grace of God for our good , and the greatest mean of our apprehending him is by charitie , which layeth hold on him in the will and reasonable affections , therefore this must be the greatest meane of our justification . Ibid. page 109. The fulfilling of the law justifieth , but charitie is the fulfilling of the law , where the apostle preferreth charitie to justifying faith , he compareth them in the most excellent way , and it is most manifest that the most excellent way , is the way of our justification and , conversion to God , 4. That S. Pauls justification whereby we stand before the barre of God is nought , but our conversion and sanctification by our inherent righteousnesse . (m) (m) Shelfoord page 107. Iustification & conversion to God is all one . Idem pag. 10● . Charitie is the maine refuge of a distressed conscience . Montag . antid. page 142. A sinner is then justified when hee is transformed in minde , renewed in soule , regenerate by grace . Chomley in his answer for Hall to Burtoun , is not onely content to exeeme the Popish justification from all blot of a fundamentall errour , but seemes also to make all our contraversie in this point to be but a jugling about words ; yea , at last hee seemes to joine with the Councell of Trent in anathematizing our , doctrine : For thus , if I remember well , doth he speake . If any man shall say that men are so justified by the sole imputation of Christs righteousnesse , or by sole remission of sinnes , that they are not also sanctified by inherent grace of charitie , or also that the grace whereby we are justyfyed is only the favour of God , let him be accursed , and let him be so indeed for me . You will say this is nothing but meere jugling , I grant it , but yet it is not the direct denyall of the foundation , for here is both remission of sins , and imputation of Christs righteousnesse included , which though it be sufficient to justification in the Protestant sence , yet in the Popish sense , wherein sanctification is also required , it is not sufficient . 5. That the fulfing of Gods Law to us in this life is both possible and easie , that if God did command us any thing which were impossible , he should be both unjust and a tyrant . (n) (n)

Shelfoord pag. 121 That there is fulfilling of the Law in this life : Iames teacheth , if you fulfill the royall law , you do well . Were Gods Law not possible to befulfilled , the supposition should be idle , unfit for Gods word , a caption unbeseeming a writing by divine inspiration . To the keeping of this we must straine our soule , wee must nor flee to a naked imputation , where is required our confirmation . Hee hath predestinate us to be conform to the image of his Son . Hee hath fulfilled the Law , and so must we too . Ibid page 127. Christ hath merited , that the rigteousnesse of the Law , should be fulfilled in us , not by faith only , or by sole imputation , as the ignorant understand it , but by our actuall walking in the divine precepts . Ibid. page 136. To binde a man to things impossible , were a wrong both to nature and grace therefore the schoole verse sayeth .

Vltra posse viri non vult Deus alla requiri .

God can no more in equitie now require impossibilities at our hands , then hee could at first at Adams : Neither doeth hee , if wee believe S. Paul , who sayeth , I can do all things by Christ , who hath loved me . Ibid. page 139. If God should command things impossible , then should he be more cruell then a tyrāt , who will not offer to exact of his Subjects such a tribute which he knowes can not be payed : It is tyrannicall and cruell , and therefore impossible to God to require the abilitie which he himselfe took a way , and of those too that are his friends , and in league with him . Ibid. page 147. To say that the very best works of the Saints are uncleane , impure , mortal sins , is extreame blasphemie . Can the works of the holy Ghost be impure ? The least addition of evill in a good work makes it sinfull , because Bonum est ex integra causa , malum ex quolibet defectu . White on the Sabboth , page 157. urgeth those sayings , as from S. Austine , Neque impossible aliquid imperate potuit Deus quia justus est ; neque damnaturus est hominem proeo quod vitare non potest , quia pius est . Execramur blasphemiam eorum qui dicunt aliquid impossible homini à Deo esse praeceptum .

6. That not onely many do fulfill the Law without all mortall sinne , but sundry also do supererogat by doing more then is commanded , by performing the counsels of perfection , of chastity , povertie , and obedience : (o) (o) Shelfoord . page 184. By his preceps he informeth us of all the meanes that leads toward life eternal by his counsels , which go beyond his precepts ( because GOD hath given man freewill to get what he can in the state of grace for the state of glory ) he shewes some exceeding meanes to grow to this lifes perfection , and to improve the common reward of glory for the next life , as sell what thou hast and give it to the poore , and thou shalt have treasure in heaven ; heere we have counsell to change temporall riches for eternall , which are better . 2. Wee are counselled to change permitted fleshly pleasures for heavenly pleasures , where it is said ; qui potest capere capiat . 3. We are counselled to deny our selves and our lawfull liberties , ( to follow Christ through the worlds difficulties ; these are Gods counsels which in the primitive church were ) put in practice , but in our times they are put of with a non placet ibid p. 129. Of the counsels of the gospel which go beyond the counsels of the Law . S. Chrysost , sayes 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 . Christ hath commanded nothing impossible ; yea , many have gone above his commandemēts . 7. That our good works do truely deserve and merit eternall life : (p) (p) M●ntag . appeal p. 233. The wicked go to enduring of torments everlasting , the good go to enjoyning of happinesse without end ; thus is their estate diversified to their deserving . Shelfoord p. 120. seteth downe the commensment verses of Cambridge which in merite goeth as farre a Bellarmine , Virtutū sancta & spesinsa caterva . salutem divino ex pacto quam meruere dabūt . Chomneus p. 18. goes yet further , that our workes are the as true efficiēt cause of our salvation , as our wickednesse can be of our damnation , as we heard before Montag . antig . p. 153. That a work may be said to be meritorious , ex condigno , these conditions are required , that it bee morallie good , that it be freely wrought by a man in this life in the estare of grace and friendship with God , which have annexed Gods promise of reward . All which conditions I can not conceave that any Protestants doth deny to good works . 8. That our obeying the counsels of perfection do purchase a degree of glory above the ordinar happinesse , (q) (q) Shelforod p. 198. In that blessed estate there are degrees of joy & glory , a starre differs from another in glory , some ground bringeth foorth thirtie , some sixty , some a hundred fold . To this agreeth . S. Gregory , Quia in hac vita nobis est discertatiorum , erit procul dubio in illa discertio dignitatum , ut quo hic alius alium merito superat , illic alius alium retributione transcendat . And S. Cypriam in pace , coronam vincentibus candidam pro operibus dabit in persecutio ne purpuream pro passione geminabit Certent nunc singuli ad utriusque honoris amplissimam dignitatem , accipiant coronas vel de sanguine purpureas . Here shineth Gods justice in distributing rewards according to the varietie of his own grace in this life bestowed , and Christians works by their owne free will to the best , end employed , and because their are certaine excellencies of workes in overcomming the greatest difficulties , therefore the schoole after the former demonstration argueth priviledged crownes which they call aureola to be due to them which have conquered best to Martyrs for overcoming persecutions , to virgins for conquering the flesh , and to Doctors for putting the Divell to flight from their floks : All this latelie is printed by the faction , neither that onely , but ( which to us seemeth mervellous ) when great popular grumblings and sundrie publicke challēges hath beene made against the authors of such writs . These whom Canterburie hath employed to apologise for the worlds full satisfaction , hath not yet beene pleased to disavow any of those writers , nor to expresse the least signe of their indignation against any of their abominations , (r) (r) Heylens answer p. 127. For Shelfoords book whatever is in that mentioned should not trouble you , if he ascribe a speciall eminencie unto charitie in some certaine things , it is no more then was taught to him by S. Paul who doeth prefer it , as you can not but choose to know , before faith and hope , nor doth he attribute our justification thereunto in any other sense then was taught him by S. Iames. M. Dow p. 52. And I believe if M. Shelfoords justification by charity be wel examined , it will prove no other then that which S. Iames sayes , yee see how that by works a man is justified and not by faith onely , & I would demand of any reasonable man , whether the expresse words of that Apostle may not without aspersion of poperie be even openly and publickely maintained , if there be no sense obtruded upon them which may crosse S. Pauls doctrine , which M. Burtoun can never prove that they did whom he charged with that assertion . but rather by swetning all with excuses seeme to vent their desire to have all swalllowed downe .

In the doctrine of the Sacraments , In the doctrine of the Sacraments see their Poperie . from Bellarmins third tombe , they tell us first , that the sacraments of the old testament differ from the new , that the one confers grace , the other fore-signifies grace to be conferred , that the same distinction must be holden betwixt Iohns , and Christs baptisme . (s) (s) Montag . orig. p. 72. de circumcisione quae ritur quam gratiam conferat & primo ponitur non eo quod sit verum sacramentum veteris politiae in statu legis & naturae , ideo esse operativū illius gratiae qua ab luuntur peccata ut sit in baptismo novae legis . 2 Si quaeratur an ut baptismus sic & circumcisto quae figurat baptismum olim peccata visua sacramentali ex instituto divino opere operato , vel opere operantis aut alio quovis modo abolere & mundare poterat , qua de resunt diversae sententiae . Hereafter he hath brought at length the Fathers , to prove that Sacramenta veteris testamenti non causabant gratiam sed eamsolum per passionem Christi dandam esse significabant , nostra vero & gratiam continent & digne suscipientibus conserunt , he closes , manes sunt illa disputiones & acerba contentiones nonnullorum , qua apud scholasticos & doctores nonnullos ventilantur , quas sopitas optamus nos , Ibem p. 390. Baptismus Ioannis rudimentarius ait Damascenus imperfectus , & isagogicus , Cyrillus ut & lex vetus itaque novum baptisma post illud necessarium inquit Augustinus , post Iohannem baptizabat Paulus , post haereticos non baptizat Ecclesia , Christi baptismo actu remittebantur peccata , non remittebantur actu post Iohannis . Then in his own words , quid ergo ? An dabat gratiam baptismus ille ; sic visum non nullis perperam omino , nam ubi tum 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 baptismatis Christi & Sacramentorum novifederu , quibus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 gratiam conferre quam significant , preparatiore hoc agebat non 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 in spectantum cum re ipsa in Domini baptismo illud fiat , ab hac sententia quae est communis omnium antiquorum , si Calvinus recesserit cum sequacibus , aetatem habent , ipsi respondeant ; privati cujuscunque hominis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 non est communi protestantium sententiae ascribendum . Obtineat ergo per me Tridentinae synodi canon primus sessionis septimae : Si quis dixerit baptismum Iohannis habuisse eandem vim cum baptismo Christi anathemasit . 2. They tell us that all baptised infants as well reprobat as elect are in baptisme truely regenerat , sanctified , justified , and put in that state wherein if those who are reprobat and there after damned should die , they would be infalliblie saved . (t) (t) Montag . apeal . p. 35. We are taught in the Liturgi earnestly to beleeve , Iest it should be left to mens charity , that Christ hath received favourably these infants that are baptised . And to make this doctrine the more sure against novellists , it is again repeated in the Catechisme , that it is certainly true by the word of God , that children being baptised have all things necessarie for salvation , and if they die before actuall sin , shall be undoubtedly saved , according whereunto all antiquity hath also taught us . Let this therefore be acknowledged to be the doctrine of our Church . Whit against the dialogue . p. 95. avowes it as the doctrine of England , that all infants baptised have the holy Spirit , and are made the children of God by adoption , pressing that of S. Austine of all infants baptised . Quid dicturus est de infantibus parvulis qui plerique accepto in illa aetate gratiae sacramento , qui sine dubio partinerent ad vitam aeternam regnumque coelorum , si continuo ex hac vita emigrarent , sinuntur crescere & nonnulli etiam apostatae sunt . Albeit this same Whyt makes this tenet in his conference with Fisher to be the judgement only of Papists and Lutherans p. 176. They differ from Lutherans and Pontificians first , in that they restraine the grace of sanctification only the elect . 2. In that they deny externall baptisme to be alwayes effectuall at the very instant time when it is administrate . And on the other hand they avow that all those who die in their infancie without baptisme , by whatsoever misse , by whosoevers fault , are certainly damned so far as men can judge : For baptisme is the only ordinary meane which God hath appointed for their salvation , which failing , salvation must be lost , except we would dreame of extraordinarie miracles of the which we have no warrand . (w) (w) Cant. relat. p. 56. That baptisme is necessare to the salvation of infants in the ordinare way of the church ( without binding God too the use and means of that Sacrament to which hee hath bund us ) it is expresse in Saint Iohn chap. 3. Except a man be born againe by water he cannot enter , no baptisme , no entrance , nor can infants creep in any other ordinary way . And this is the received opinion of all the ancient Church , infants are to be baptised that their salvation may be certain , for they which can not help themselves must not be left only to extraordinary helps of which we have no assurance , and for which we have no assurance , and for which we have no warrant at all in scripture . Shelfoord p. 66. I can shew you of none saved ordinarly without the sacraments in regard of our Saviours exception in the 3 of Iohn . Except a man be born again of the water and the spirit , he can not enter into the kingdome of heaven . Montag . orig. p. 397. Adeo huic usui inserviunt aquae ut si tollatur lavacrum aquae alieni a Deo & faedere promissionis aeternae excludantur illi in tenebras exteriores , cum edicto divino statutum sit nisi quis renatus fuerit ex aqua & spiritu sancto non introibit in regnum coelorum . Scio hoc elusum à novatoribus , sed & Christi divinitatem ab haereticis negatam scio utrumque in contemptum Dei & dispendium animarum . 3. That the manifold ceremonies of papists in baptisme and all other sacraments are either to be embraced as pious ancient rites , or not to be stood upon as being only ceremoniall toyes . (x) (x) Samuel Hoards sermon supra , puts crosse in baptisme and sundrie other ceremonies of it among his rituall traditions . Montag . antid. p. 16. vestis alb , aoleum , sal , lac , chrisma , additamenta quaedam sunt ornatus causa . Ib. p. 15. Cum concilio quodam nupero non veremur profiteri ceremonias à maioribus hominibus religiosissimis usurpatas quod advarios pietatis usus valeant & exercitia quedam sunt quibus mens externarum rerum sensu & significatione ad divinum cultum ipsumque Deum attrahitur in Ecclesia retinendas & ubi abrogatae fuerant restituendas esse statuimus . Andrews stricturae p. 13. Chrisme , salt , candles , exorcismes , signe of the crosse ephata , and the consecration of the water , those being all matters of ceremonie , are therefore in the Church power on good reasons either to retaine are to alter . For their tenets in the sacrament of the supper , wee shall speak anone of them in the head of the masse . 4. They tell us that our dispute about the five bastard sacraments is a plaine logomachie . (y) (y) Andrews stristurae . p. 11. The whole matter about the five Sacraments is a meer . 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 5. They tell us that not only infants after their baptisme but even men baptised in perfect age who before baptisme gave sufficient count of their faith , yet they may not be esteemed full Christians while they have received confirmation by the imposition of hands , and that alone by a Bishop . (z) (z) pokling . altare . p. 165. And because the competentes were persons of full age they received also consumation by imposition of hands ut pleni Christiani inveriantur . About the orders , they tell us that they agree with the papists in their number , that the reason why they want their Acolits , sub-deacons and the rest , is but their Churches pouerty : (zz) (zz) Andrews stricturae . p. 12 The five orders is a point not worth the standing on , while the revenues of the church were able to mantaine so many degrees it can not be denyed but that there were so many , but by the Churches owne order neither by commandement nor example of Scripture , but what is this to the present estate of the Church scarce able to mantaine twon ? Which can scarce wel mantaine the two orders of priests and deacons . But which in their questions is worst of all , they side here with the papists in giving to all the protestant Churches a wound which our enemies proclame to be mortall , fatall , incurable . They tie the conferring of ordours by a full divine right to the office of bishops , they avow that the lawfull use of all ordination and outward ecclesiastick jurisdiction is by God put in the hands of their persons alone . Other reformed Kirks therefore wanting bishops , their ministers must preacù , celebrate the sacraments , administer discipline not only without a lawfull warrand , but also against the ordinance of God . When they are put in minde of this great wound given by them to all other reformed Churches , they either strive to cover it with the fig-tree-leaffs of an imagined case of necessity which never was , or else plainly to passe over it as immedicable . (&c.) (&c.) Heylens antid. sect. 3. pag 8. Let the bishops stande alone on Apolicall right , and no more then so , and doubt it not but some will take it on your word and then plead , accordingly , that thing of apostolicall institution may bee laid aside . When Bishop Andrews had learnedly asserted the episcopal order too bee of Christ institution , I have heard that some who were there in place did secrerly interceed with King Iames to have had it altered , for fear forsooth of offending our neighbour Churches . Andrews resp . ad epist. 3. Molm p. 195. Dixi abesse ab ecclesiis vestris aliquid quod de jure divino sit , culpa autem vestra non abesse sed injuria temporum , non enim tam propitios habuisse Reges Galliam vestram in Ecclesia reformanda quam habuit Brittannia nostra : Interim ubi dabit meliora Deus , & hoc quoque quod jam abest per Dei gratiam suppletum iri . Relatum inter haereticos Aerium qui Epiphanio credat vel Augustino necesse est fateatur , & tu qui damnes Aerium quo nomine damnas ? An quod se opposuerit consensui universalis ecclesiae . Idem quisentit an non itidem se opponit ac eo nomine damnandus erit . Montag . antid. page 138. Ordinationis jus & autoritatem ita credimus annexam episcoporum personis ut a nemine non episcopo ordinato & consecrato possit aut de beat adhiberi , irritam ordinationem omnem pronunciamus quae non a legitimo & canonico more proficiscatur , quod si a se oriantur aliqui & non missi ingerant caelesti huic muneri & functioni manus , viderint ipsi quid sint responsuri olim summo sacerdoti cujus partes usurpant , nos nostras non aliorum tuemur vocationes . Yea not only they ty ordination and jurisdiction to the person of bishops , but of such bishops who must of necessity shew the derivation of al their power , from the Pope as was shown before 6. In matrimonie they will keep not only the popish sacramentall words and signes , the popish times of lent and other dysmall-dayes , except the bishops give their dispensation , but also they will have the whole matrimoniall causes ruled by the popes cannons , yea , which is more , they avow that the Cannon-law by acts of parliament yet unrepealled , stands in vigour amongst them . (a) (a) Dow p. 184. By his favour I must tell him , that neither the law of God nor of the King doth disallow the use of the old canons and constitutious , though made in the time of popery and by the pope or popish prelats , which are not contrary to the law of God or the King . If he desire proof of this , let him consider whether the statute . 25. Hen. 8.19 . do not say as much as I affirme , which having regulated diverse things touching the exercise of ecclesiasticall jurisdiction . At last the statute concluds with this proviso ( provyded also that such Canons , constitutions , ordinances , and synodals provinciall being already made not repugnant to the laws & customes of this Realme , nor to the hurt of the Kings prerogative royall , shal now still be used and executed as they were before the making of this act , till such time as they be viewed , searched , or otherwise ordered by the said two & thirty persons or the more part of them according to the tenour of this present act . It followes then that till these thirtie two persons determine otherwise , old Canons may be still executed & retaine their ancient vigour & authoritie , & when that will be I know not , but as yet I am sure it hath not been done .

Except in some few things which are directly opposit to some late laws of the land and that Cannon-law they will haue extendid as far down as the very councel of Basil . (b) (b) Femal glory pag. 128. With this pious and gratefull ordinance , I conclude the visitation of our incomparable Ladie , he meanes the act of the late Councell of Basile , which ordained a festivall fo that visitation . And as far up as the constitutions of the first Popes . (c) (c) Pocklingtoun altar . pag. 52. There is mention made of the dedication of churches under Euaristus anno 112. & under Hyginus , 154. under Calixtus 221. And before them all in S. Clemence his epistles . These testimonies of Romane Bishops the Centurists do suspect : Where the doctrine and decrees of Popes , and those in the first and best times are confirmed by the doctrine and constant practice of the holy catholicke church , it seemeth great boldnesse in trhee or foure men to condemne and to brand their authoritie with the misterie of iniquitie . Which diverse of the papists themselves acknowledge to be supposititions , yet our men will defend them all , and with them the Canons of the apostles , the constitutions of Clemence and all such trash . (d) (d) Laurence , Sermon p. 18. the Apostles in their Canons , and these to , which are undoubtedly theirs . Montag . apar . p. 390. Ex antiquissimis illum facile principem & primariae authoritatis , quia erat Apostolorum 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 clementem nimirim 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 non preteribo , quem licet delicatuli nescio qui , ex utraque parte contendentium falsi postulant , & tanquam falsarium 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 : Nos tamen ipsius tanquam 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , contra quosvis suscipere patrocinium audemus , post doctissimum virum Turrianum .

In the sacrament of pennance they teach first , that auricular confession was evil abolished , and was verie expedient to be restored . (e) (e) White on the Sabbath in the preface . There might also my reverend good Lord , be a verie profitable use of some private forme of pasturall collation with their flock , for their direction and information in particular spirituall duties , such as was , privat confession in the ancient Church : Now the Presbyterian censures by their paralogisme taken from abuse , have with such loud and impetuous declamations , filled the eares and prepossessed the mindes of many people , that they are exceeding averse from this soveraigne and ancient medicine of consolation , prevention , and curing of the maledies of the soule . He approveth that of Gerardus , Privata coram Ecclesiae ministro confessio , quam auricularem vocant , quamvis non habeat expressum & peculiare mandatum ac proinde non fit absolutae necessitatis , tamen cum plurimas praestet utilitates & disciplinae Ecclesiasticae pars , sit non postrema publico Ecclesiae consensu recepta , ideo nequaquam temere vel negligenda vel abolenda , sed piè & in vero Dei timore , praesertim ab illis qui ad sacram synaxin accedunt usurpanda . M. Sp , Sermon printed with approbation . p. 18. Confesse as the church directs , confesse to God , confesse also to the Priest , if not privat in the eare since that is out of use . Male aboletur , sayeth a devout Bishop , it is almost quite lost , the more pitie . 2. That God hath given a judicial power of absolution to every priest , which every one of the people is obliged to make use of , especially before the communion by confessing to the priest all their sins without the reconcilement of any . (f) (f) Dow p. 35. It can not bee denyed , but that the Church of England did ever allow the private confession of sinnes to the Priest , it were very strange , if our church ordaining Priests and giving them power of absolution , and prescribing the forme to bee used for the exercise of that power upon confession , should not also allow of that private confession . M. Sp. Sermon p. 16. Since the Priest can in the name of God forgive us our sinnes , good reason we should make our confession to him : Surelie God never gave the Priest this power in vaine , he expects we should make the best use of it we can . He requires we should use the meanes we can to obtaine that blessing ; now the onely meanes to obtaine this absolution is our confession to him Ib. p. 19 If we confesse in humilitie with griefe and sorrow for them , if we confesse them faithfully not concealing any . 3. That God in the heaven will certainly follow the sentence of the priest absolving on earth . (g) (g) Ib. pag. 15. There is another confession that would not be neglected . Hee that would be sure of pardon , let him seek out a priest , & make his humble confession to him : for God who alone hath the prime and originall right of forgiving sins hath delegat the priests heere upon earth his judges , & hath given them the power of absolution , so that they can in Gods name forgive the sinnes of those that confesse to them . But is not this poperie , would some say , Now take the counsell that is given in the eight of Iob , Aske the Fathers , and they shall tell thee : aske then S. Chrysostome on Esay , and hee will tell thee , that heaven waites and expects the priests sentence heere on earth : For the priests sits judge on earth , and the Lord followes the servant , and when the servant bindes or louses heere on earth , clave non errante , the Lord confirmes it in heaven , words , sayes hee , so cleare for the judiciall and formall absolution of the priest , that nothing can be said more plaine . 4. Beside a private confessor , it were very expedient to have in every congregation a publik penitentiarie , who in the beginning of Lent on ashe-wednesday might in the Kirk sit in his reclinatorie , and sprinkling dust on the head of every parishioner , enjoyn them their lent-pennance , whereby they may truly satisfie Gods judgement for their sins , & in the end of lent or Shrif-thursday before Pasche give his absolution to those who have fully satisfied , (h) (h) Pockl. alt. pag. 57. The bishops made an addition to the ecclesiastick canon , that in every church a penitentiarie should bee appointed to remit penitents in the church , after they have done publick pennance . This kinde of confession Nectarius abolished in the church of Constantinople , howbeit the confession , whereof Tertullian and Cyprian speaks , was never abolished , but did ever continue in the Greek church , and in the Latine likewise : And to this purpose a solemn day was set apart for taking of publick pennance , for open faults , by imposition of hands , and sprinkling of ashes , namely Ashwednesday . This is the godly discipline whereof our church speaketh , and wisheth that it might be restored . And as Ashwednesday was appointed for putting notorious sinners to open pennance , so Thursday before Easter is appointed for penitents to receive absolution . This absolution they took upon their knees by the imposition of the priests hands . Ib. p. 63 , & 67. The Competents beginning on Ashwednesday in sackcloth & ashes to humble themselves , they were all Lent long purged with fasting and prayer : They were to stand barefoot on sackcloth , and watch on good Fryday all night Howfond a thing it is , sayeth Tertullian , to think to carrie away with us the pardon of sin , & not first of all to pay for our commoditie . The merchant before he deliver his wares will look to your coyne , ne sculptilis , ne rafus , that it be neither washed nor shaved ; and doe not thinke but the Lord will look well to your repentance , and turne it over and over , before you receive tantum mercedem perennis vitae . The Church caused those to take so strict pennance , that by their great humilitiation they might make some amends for that libertie which some took to sin . Ib. p. 24. Our churches are a glory to our religion . To the chancels belongeth the vestrie lavatorie and reclimatories , for hearing confessions . Shelfoord p. 125. If the Iust shall transgresse while they are within the law , they are bound to make satisfaction by pennance , which is , secunda tabula post naufragium : Ibid. pag. 129. The law is oft brooken by sins of omission and commission . I answere , as it is oft broken of us , so it is as oft repaired and satisfied , and so all is made whole againe , and so hee is in statu quo prius : hee riseth againe so oft as hee falleth ; either in number or vertue our sins of commission are repaired by repentance , our sins of omission are supplied by prayer . Extreame unction , if reports may be trusted , is alreadie in practice among them , but how soever , they avow in print their satisfaction with the Papists in this point , if so be the ceremonie be not made absolutely necessar . (i) (i) Montag . antig . pag. 267. That sacramentall unction is not to bee used . Let the sick use it if you will , we hinder you not , nor much care or enquire what effe●●● ensue upon it , but obtrude it not upon us as in sensu of the Sacram. in the time of grace .

Anent the Monastick life , They are for the reerection of monasteries , and placing of monks , and nuns therein as of old . consider how farre our men are from Poperie , they tell us first , that the putting downe of the Monasteries in England by Henry the eight , let be by other Protestant Princes else-where , was a worke exceeding impious , and verie prejudiciall both to the church and crown : (k) (k) Montang . orig. p. 303. In ecclesia Anglicana sacerdotes licet magis gaudere , & solent & debeant immunitatibus , tamen & frequentius & exuberantius , & libentius quam laici decimarum decimas , subsidia , annatas , primitias solvunt principi , ut vel inde facile discerni possit quantum detrementi regiis accesserit vectigalibus per illam desolationem monasteriis invectam per importunum Henrici octavi rigorem , & per parliamentarias impropriationes . Ibid. p. 384. Quales quales reformare potius , & ad normam veterum reducere debebant , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 non quod factum facinore flagitioso & 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 , araefuerunt ad haras , altaria ad lupanaria transferenda , sed reprimam me . Ibib. pag. 174. Sub praetextu reformatae pietatis , Deum , Ecclesiam , pietatem , per nefandissima sacrilegia , eversis ubicunque monasteriis , &c. 2. That the Monks for the paterne of their orders have the Prophets and the Apostles , and specially Iohn the Baptist : (l) (l) Montag . orig. p. 370. Ioannes primus hanc viam insistebat , illum deinceps ut in aliis sequebantur ascetae & solerogagitae . Ibid. p. 382. Ejusmodi vitae genere Ioannem jecisse fundamenta monasticae vitae , cum illustrissimo Baronio non abnuerim . 3. That their habits to their very tree-shoone hath Scripture warrant : (m) (m) Montag . orig. p. 369 Ioannes & interula & tunica & quocunque amictu vestiebatur , de Camelorum pilis id gestabat vestimentum , ut ipsa asperiias ad virtutem patientiae animum exerceret , nec princeps hoc institutum usurpabat Iohannes : ab omni retro antiquitate Prophetarum filii Elias , Eliseus alii eodem amictu utebantur , quin & positum in more qui rem quamcunque persuadere vellunt , habitu ipso se componerent ad illam rem efficacius insinuandam . William Wats sermon , p. 20. The sackclouth and ashes they received from Daniel and the Ninivites , and to live according to a strict rule , and order from S. Mark , & other apostles : so sayeth Cassian . Ibidem . pag. 28. Those if you censure for wil worship superstition take heed ye condemne not the authors of them , even our blessed Saviour , with his Prophets and Apostles . Ibid. p. 44. Whereas our blessed Saviour hath forbidden shooes to his disciples , he was heerein obeyed by the primitive montifiers , sandals were meere solls tyed on with strings . 4. That the Virgine Marie was truelie a Nunne , and that the Nunnes this day are much to bee commendid for the following of her paterne : (n) (n) Femal glory p. 22. The same author affirmes that she there lived a●●rettie Nunne . Ib. 23. Let us then imagine that this holy recluse confined her body to this sacred solitude , that shee might the more freely injoy the incōceavable pleasure shee tooke in her vowed virginitie . Ibid. pag. Shee was a votarie never to know man . Ibid. pag. 148. You who ply your sacred Arithmetick and have thoughts cold and cleare as the cristall beeds you pray by . You who have vowed virginity , mentall and corporall , approch with comfort , and kneel downe before the grand whyt immaculat Abbesse of your snowie Nunries , and present the alsaving babe in her armes with due veneration . 5. That the present Carthusians , Franciscans , and the rest of the Fraternities are very good and holy people , worthie in their very orders of Monastick life of our imitation : (o) (o) Ibid. p. 236. Many holy orders also are of this sodality as the Benedictus , the Citertians , the Franciscans , Cartusians and many other . If these examples of pious and worthie people will not move us , &c. 6. That their barefooted processions through the streets , That their Canonicall houres of devotion , at midnight in their Closters , that in great Festivall Eves their goeing at Mid-night , with confluence of people to town-churches is all commendable service . (p) (p) William Wats Sermon . pag. 3. Mamertus Bishop of Vienne did not uncannonicallie , to appoint a solemne mortification of three dayes fast , and to make a Letanie to be sung in a barefoted procession . Ibid pag. 20. To go barefooted , they receaved from David and from Esaias Ibid. pag. 45. Nazianzen maketh goers barefoote to be imitators of Apostolicall spirited people . Ibid. pag. 48. In the third , fourth and fifth ages , are examples plentifull of the nightly processions of the Christians ; yea , they went from their houses in the cities to some of their churches in the fields , singing Psalmes all the way through the streets in the hearing of the Gentiles . Ibid. Minutius Faelix mentioneth nocturna & oeculta sacra . For this purpose the night was divyded into Cannonicall houres or certaine times of rysing to prayer , whereof midnight was one , the morning watch was another Canonicall houre , I hope that notwithstanding our devotion serveth us not to imitate the Prophets and Apostles , and the Primitives , yet wee will forbeare to take part with the old hereticks in reprehending them . Ibid. Before a greater Festivall all the devouter sort of Christians constantly repaired to their Churches at midnight .

In the head of Purgatorie and Prayer for the dead , thus farre long agoe are the proceeded , first , How neere they approach to purgatorie , & prayer for the dead . they avow openly Limbus patrum telling us , that the Saints before Christ were not onely not in heaven , but truely in an infernall place , even in a lacke , where in one nook the Godly were in peace , and the wieked in torments , that Abrahams bosome was here , betweene which and hell a certaine gulfe made , but a tolerable distance . that Iacob , Samuel , and David , and other of the ancients were mourned for at their death , because their souls went not to heaven , but truely to a kinde of hell : their minde in these things , as their custome is , they propone in the words of some Father , that by the shelter of their authoritie they may keep off their own head the indignation of the people : (q) (q) Montag . orig. pag. 286. His qui in carcere erat spiritibus , hoc est defunctis , suo fato & inferno addictictis praedicavit quo in loco Puritani , & novatores spiritum , non animam Christi intelligunt . Ibid. apar . p. 476. Communem esse patrum sententiā , aliorumque doctissimorum scriptorum nostrae aetatis & confessionis sanctorum , animas ante Christi resurrectionem non fuisse in Coelo . Olim ( inquit Chrysostomus ) ad infernum deducebat mors , sed nunc assumit ad Christum Ideo dicebat olim Iacob , Deducelis senectutem meam ad infernum cum lachrymis . Ideo olim lugebantur mortui , at nunc cum Psalmis & hymnis efferuntur . Hyeronimi testimonia sunt innumera , ante adventum Christi omnes ad inferos ducebantur : inde Iacob ad inferos discensurum se dicit , & Iob pios & impios in inferno queritur retineri , & Euangelium docet magnum chaos interpositum apud inferos , & revera antequam flammeam illam ratam , & igneam rompheam ad paradist fores Christus cum la●rone reseraret , clausa erant coelestia , Nota quoque ut Samuelem vere quoque in inferno fuisse credas , & ante adventum Christi , quamvis sanctos inferni lege detentos locum esse ait , qui lacus vocatur & abyssus , in qua non erant aqua in qua animo recluduntur , sive in refrigerio , sive ad poenas . Again they tell us that Christ before he opened heavens gate to any soule , he went first downe , and loosed the souls in prison ; yea , if yee beleeve M. Maxwell ( who hath written much for the drawing of our Church the factions way ) hee went downe to the lowest hells , and delivered thence a number of Pagans such as Aristotle , Plato , Socrates , and a world of mo : (r) (r) Montag . apar . pag. 476. Postquam eo descendit Christus , inferorum claustra perfodit , deripuit , vastavit , spoliavit , vinctas inde animas liberando M. Maxwels demonstration , pag. 9. Whether the places of Scripture wherein mention is made of our Saviours spoiling of hell , and leading captivity captive , may perhaps bee understood of his powerful and merciful delivering from hell of some of the soules of vertuous Pagans , as of their philosophers , Lawgivers , governours , kings , queens , and other private persons renowned for their wisedome prudence , fortitude , temperance bounty , chastity , justice , mercie ; and generally for their civill carriage , and morall conversation , such as were Hermes , Trismegistus , Zoroaster , Socrates , Plato , Aristoele , Pithagoras , Homer , Phocilides . Theogrus , Epictetus , Cicero ; and such as were Hercules , Theseus , Cyrus , Solon , Lycurgus , Aristides , Simon , Timotheus , Epaminondas , Tarrina , Camilla , Nicaula , Panthea Penelope , Artemisia , and others the like : for my owne part , I doe professe such love to those vertuous wights , for their vertues sake , as I had rather condemne twenty such opinions as that of Limbus patrum , then to damne eternally the soul of one Socrates , of one Cyrus . . Our maine pillers against purgatorie they hew downe with the popish axes , when we reason that Scripture makes no mention of any third place betwixt Hell and Heaven ; they reply , that there are many things whereof Scripture makes no mention . When we reason that Scripture makes mention expressely of two places for Souls after death , they use the popish distinction , that after the resurrection there is but two eternall places , but that before the resurrection there may be three temporall : (s) (s) Montag . apar pag. 135. Obiiciunt , nullus tertius locus indicatur in Scriptura praeter infernum damnatorum & coelum . R●sp . Licet non indicaretur in Scripturis esse alium locum tertium , non tamen inde sequeretur non fuisse tertium , quia multa sunt quae non indicantur in scripturis . Locus ille Matthaei 25. Loquitur non de loco aut statu animarum ante Christum , sed de statu & loco finali post finem saeculi , cum duae tantum erunt absque dubio hominum societatis sempiterna . 4. When Papists urge upon us prayer for the dead , they will not contradict them ; yea , they commend oblations in the Lords Supper , and prayers there for the dead in particular . (t) (t) Andrews stristurae , p. 56. Anent offering and prayer for the dead , there is little to bee said against it , it can not hee denyed but it is ancient . Dow , p. 56. That the ancient Church had commemorations , oblations , and prayers for the dead , the testimonies of the Fathers , ecclesiasticall stories and ancient liturgies do put out of all question . P●kling . alt. p. 83. Commends that Canon whereby a priest after his death was ordained to bee punished , for making another priest his executour , with this paine , that at the altar for such a One non offeretur , noc sacrificium pro dormitione ejus celebraretur .

CHAP. VI. Ament their Superstitions .

IN the church of Rome , the Canterburians use to professe corruptions of two kindes , Few of all Romes superstitions are against thier stomack . errours and superstitions , as for heresies or Idolatries , they are loath any such crimes should bee laid to the charge of their mother church , how many and how greivous errours they finde Rome guiltie of they had need to declare ; for in the most of those , werein the Protestants place the chiefe of the Romish errours , you have heard them plainlie take their part , readilie it will prove no otherwise when wee come downe to try them in the particular heads ▪ wherein Papists are reputed most superstitious .

The superstitions which in Papists are most remarked in their private carriage are these four : In their frequent signing of themselves with the signe of the crosse : In wearing about their neck a crucifix or some such toy of an image or relique : In saying their prayers on their beads : In abstaning from flesh on fryday , wednesday , lent ; or some great feastivalls Eave ; Our men are farre from disproving of any of these practices . For the first , they avow that signing with the signe of the crosse at rysing or lying downe , at going out or coming in , at lighting of candles , closing of windowes , or any such action is not only a pious and profitable ceremonie , but a verie Apostolick tradition . (a) (a) Samuel Hoards Sermon . p. 15. Reckons out among his traditions , the crossing of themselves when they went out , or when they came in , when they went to bed , or when they rose , when they set down to meat , or lighted candles , or had any businesses of moment to doe Montag . apeal page 286. What hinders but that I may signe my self with the signe of the crosse in any part of my boody , at any time when I goe to bed , in the morning when I rise , at my going out , at my returning home , the ancient Church so used it , and so may wee ( for ought I know ) without just scandall or superstition . 2. They avow expresly the carrying of these holy trincats about their neck , in caisses of silver or gold . (b) (b) Montag . antid. p. 17. Ego certe illas reliquias fas●iis involvam ; auro includam , circumgestandas , admovebo labiis ac collo suspensas manibus , oculisque crebro usurpatas intuebor . Ibid. p. 24. Imagines praesertim Christi crucifixi asservamus diligenter & cum cura : sunt apud nos per fenestras , ambones , vasa , vestimenta . 3 The saying of their prayers ; yea , their Ave maries upon their beeds is to them an holy Arithmetick worthie of praise and imitation . (c) (c) Female glory , pag. 148. Among the other praises of his holy Nuns , this is one , You who ply your sacred Arithmetick , and have your thoughts cold and cleare as the crystall beeds yee pray by : And in his proemials , Omnis terra revibrat aeve 4. Wednesday , fryday , and Lent-fasts , are to them not only lawdable practices of the ancient church , but also traditions come from Christ and the Apostles which for religions cause all are oblidged to embrace . (d) (d) Montag . antid. p. 164. Quadragesimale jejunium libenter ego concesserim ab Apostolis constitutum , & apud vetissimos Ecclesia proceres usurpatum . Ibid. p. 9. Doceatur esse aliquid ab ipsis Apostolis institutum , utpote jejunium quadragesimale ; Causam non dicamquin haereseos accuser , si non ut ab Apostolicae authoritate sancitum propugnavero . William Wats sermon , page 50. Most precise and severe observers were they of Lent-fast , which the whole primitive Church did believe to bee of Apostolicall institution , so that they had their Saviours and his Apostles example for that strictnesse . I passe their observation of Wednesdayes and Frydayes fast weckly , which Epiphanius among many others assureth to bee of Apostolicall institution , Couzins devotion : It had also beene an ancient and religions custome , to fast all the Frydayes in the yeare , except those which fall within the twelve dayes of Christmasse . The Lent which now is , and ever hath beene reputed an apostolical constitution , and wee adde out of Chrysologus , that it is not an humane invention , as they call it , but it comes from Divine authoritie that wee fast our fouritie dayes in Lent , p. 221.

They embrace the grossest not onely of their private , but also of their publick superstitions . The popish publick superstitions are very many , but of these which that whole Church doth allow , very few comes to my minde which stand much against the stomack of our men : Those that come first to my thoughts are all pleasently digested ; Protestants wont to deride the popish conceat of their holy ground , of their consecrat walls , and the sanctuary of their Chancels , their turnings towards the East , their manifold toies in baptisme and the Lords supper joyned with the sacramentall elements , their hallowing above the Sabboth a multitude of Festivals , their pilgr●mages , their processions and many such their practises . In this behold the minde of our men , they tell us first that Kirk-yards by prayers and conspersion of holy water must be made holy ground ; that before these episeopall consecrations , no Christian buriall may be made therein , but after that the bishop hath used the pontificall ceremonies therupon , no Heretick , no Schismatick , no Excommunicat person may be brought there , no worldly , no common action there performed without the profanatiō of the holy place . (e) (e) Laurence sermon p. 9. Christians distinguished their oratories into an aetriū , a Church yard , a sanctum , a Church a sanctum sanctorum a Chancell , they did conceive a greater degree of sanctitie in one of them , than in an other , and in one place of them than another , churchyards they thought profained by sports , the whole circuit both before and after Christ was priviledged for refuge , none out of the communion of the Kirke permitted to lie there , any consecrate ground preferred for interment before that which was not consecrat , and that in an higher esteem which was in a higher degree of consecration , and that in an higher which was neerest the altar . Halls sermon at the consecration of a buriall place p. 38. Out of the consideration of the holy designation of these peculiare places came both the tittle and practice of consecration of cemiteries , which they say is no lesse ancient than the the dayes of Calixtus the first who dedicated the first Cemmiteries , albeit it was decreed by the counsel of Arles , that if any Church were consecrated the Church yard of it should require no other hallowing but by simple conspersion . p. 40. It is meer and necessary that those places should be set aside to this holy use by a due and religious dedication , by prayers and holy actions tending thereunto . if the Iews used these dedications how much more we . Ib. in the preface , an act worthy both of this common celebration and of that episcopall service of mine . Again they shew us that the church by the bishops anointing some stones thereof with oyl and sprinkling others with water , and using from the Roman pontificall some mo prayers , some mo ceremonies upon it , becomes a ground more holy : That before these consecrations though the people of God for many years have meet into a Church for divine service , yet it is no more holy then a barn , a tavern , a tolbooth ; but after these consecrations there is such holinesse in the walls , that even when there is no divine service , men at their comming in , and going out must adore and all the time of their presence stand discovered , and never so much as sit down , were the service never so long , except upon great infirmity . (f) (f) Tedders sermon p. 8. It is the consecration that makes them holy and makes God esteeme them so , which though they be not capable of grace , yet receive by their consecration a spirituall power whereby they are made fit for divine service and being consecrate , there is no danger in ascribing holinesse unto them , if we beleeve S. Bernard . quis parietes istos sanctos dicere vereatur , quos manus sacratae Pontificum tantis sactificavere mysteriis . When we come to Church sayes the holy Fathers of the devotion of those primitive times , corpora humi sternimus , they that shewed the least devotion did bow all the time that they were there , none presumed so much as to sit as being too bold and lazie a posture in Gods house ; but only for infirmitie or some other cause were dispensed with . There were some that would not have their shooes on their feet in the temple , a shame to them that have their hats on in Gods hoase . Shelford . p. 51. Some profaine Gods house by going out with heads covered as if God were not present and it were not his house when service was ended . Pokling . altare . p. 141. Churches when they were made they were consecrate , for a man may as lawfully and Christianly administer the sacrament in a barn or town hall as in any place that is not consecrate to such holy uses , Queenscoale p. 223. S. Giles Church in the fields being newly repaired after two years service , sermon and sacraments in it in D. Montany B. of Londons time , was required to be consecrat by his successor D. Lad , the people refusing the bishop , caused sequester and lock up the house for a moneth , and forces the Parish after fiftie pound fies to put up a crucifix upon the east window and receive the other orders of consecration . The fundation stones of the repaire of Pauls were solemnly blessed by the bishop , his main reasone for the urging of the visitation of Cambridge was , that two chappels there was not yet censecrat , notwithstanding of divine service in them for some score of years bygone . 3. That the Chancell and the Altar must not only be dedicat with prayers and unctions , but with lighted candles , burning in-cense , and many other such toies ; that it must be divided from the Church with vailes to keep not only the bodies , but the eyes of the Laicks from beholding the arke and throne wherein the body of the Son of God doth sit , as in a chaire of state , that none but priests must enter there and that with their triple low adorations at their approaching : That it is a favour for the King or the Empetour to win near that place for the short time of his offering . (g) (g) Pokl . alt. p. 141. Was not the altar the chiefest place which with most ceremony and devotion was hallowed ? was there not a feast annuall keeped in joyfull remembrance of the dedication of every Church . Doth not S. Austine say . Novit sanctitas vestra fratres , consecrationem altaris celebramus in quo unclus vel benedictus est lapis , as he cites the place in his Sunday Quenscoale . p. 198. In the collegiat Church of Wolverhampton in the countrie of Stafford , the altar and cloaths thereof were consecrat 11. Octob. 1635. As soon as the priests come to the Church each of them made a low congie at their first entring in the Church doore and after that three congies a peece towards the altar , so they went unto the chancell where a bason with water and a towel was provyded for the priests to wash in , where also was incense burning ; after they returned making three congies apeece . After the sermon every one of them had a paper in his hand which they tearmed a censer , and so they went up again to the altar : As they went they made three congies apeece , the communion being ended they washed their hands and returned giving three congies as before . Ib. 220. There are diverse high altars solemnly dedicated of late in diverse colledges of Combridge and Oxford adorned with tapers , candlesticks , crucifixes , basons , crosses , rich altar clothes , crimson , cushons , rich hangings . Pokling . alt. page 24. Optatus saith that erant ecclesiae ex auro & argento quam plurima ornamenta . ibid. page 80. At the upper end of the Chancell was a place railed in , whereunto none were permitted to enter but the priests . The Canon is cleare . Nulli omnium qui sit in Laicorum numero liceat intra sacrum altare ingredi . A dispensation indeed there was for the Emperour to enter in hither when he would Creatori dona affer●● but stay there he might not Laurence p. 10. Beyond these railes duo cancelli which distinguished the body of the Church from the Oracle , none out of orders came . A more awfull reverence was commanded to this part being barred from common view . Ibid. pag. 29. We have the Grecians triple prostrations from their liturgies , 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 Ibid. p. 12. The same God is through all the parts of the Church , but not in the same maner through all the parts thereof , for as they are different degrees of sanctiry in them , so is there a different dispensation of his presence in them , Ibid. p. 15. This followes upon the consecration , as there was a greater communication of the divine presence in those places than in others , so was there a greater communication of the same presence in some parts of the temple of Salomon than in others . And as that distinction in holy places continued after Christ so did the reason of that distinction too . The whole indeed is the house of God , for albeit the Lord be without these walls yet is he more within , as we are not presumed to be so much abroad as at home , though the Church conceived him to be present in all parts of this house , yet it conceived him to be present more in one part of it than another , in respect of that peculiar dispensation of his presence to that place of the Church , as of old to that place of the temple which was within the vaile , having an altar heere answerable to a mercy seat there , as also in respect of that union betwixt this place and his humane nature . Cant. Star . Chamber speach p. 47. The altar is the greatest place of Gods residence upon earth . I say the greatest , yea greater than the pulpit , for there it is hoc ectcorpus meum , but in the pulpit it is at most hoc est verbum meum , and a greater reverence no doubt is due to the body than to the word , and so in relation answerable to the throne where his body is usually present then to the seat whence his word uses to be proclamed . 4 That none of the ceremonies of the popish baptism , neither their salt , their spitle , nor exsufflation are superstitious . (h) (h) Vide supra cap. 5. (x) . 5. That a number of the Masse toies which yet are not in practise in England , yea all the guises of the Masse which can be proven to be ancient are all to be embraced . (i) (i) Lincolneshere Minister p. 163. I was shewed a latine determination read in one of out Universities , aiming to prove , that look what ceremonies were used about the altar before the reformation by power and force of any generall custome , though past over in deep silence by our liturgie , are notwithstandig commanded us by a kinde of implicit praecept , even unto us , that live under the discipline of the English liturgie . Heylene in his Antidot . lect. 2. p. 63. doth confesse the fact and doth not disclame the author therein , only leaves that Kings professor D. Colines as a man most able to justifie that writ . These are his words , as for your Sally on the author of the latine determination , I leave him to himself : Hee is of age to doe you reason in this , as well as in that other quarrell you have against him . 6. That who ever in the publick prayers hath their face toward the North , South , and West must be publickly called upon to turn themselves ever towards the East . (k) (k) Vide supra , cap. 5. B. 7. That in the Church not only in the time of prayer , but at the reading of the ten commands , all must fal on their knees , but when the creed is read all must stand upright on their feet , when the epistle commeth , all may sit down , but when the gospel begineth , all must again arise , during the time of sermon all must stand uncovered . That to these and all such pious practises we are oblidged by the sole example of the bishops or some few of them , even before the inacting of any law either of Church or state . (l) (l) Edward Bugheus , serm. pag. 9. We may not think it enough that we stand at the Creed , except we say it also with the Minister audibly with a lowd voice , nor is it enough for us to stand up at the gospel , but we must also bow at the name of Iesus , not as if we were ashamed of what we did , but with due and lowly reverence , neither is it sufficient to be bare in time of divine service , except we also reverently kneell on out knees when the commands and letanie are read . Shelfoord p 20. Let us learn of our Cathedrall Churches , for there our reverend Fathers , the prelats , make their reverence to God in this wise , both at their entry and their returne , wherefore to follow their good and holy paterne we are to do the like both at our comming in to Gods house and at our going out . Ibid p. 22. The fifth office of holinesse is to rise up from our seats when the articles of our faith are read , we also do more reverently to stand up at the reading of the psalmes before , after , and behind the holy lessons . We are also to stand at the reading of the gospell . The reason that the old Lytargick writters gives of this superstitious standing at the Creed and gospel more then at the reading of the lessons and epistles is , because these epistles among which they put the revelation the penteteuch and sundry other parts of the old testament , containes more base doctrine then the gospel which comes behind them , as the Master comes after his servant which goes before to make way . 8. That the conscience is oblidged not only to keep religiously the greater festivities of Yule , pasch , pentecost , & the rest which are immediatly referred to the honour of the Trinitie , but also a number of the festivals of the blessed Virgin , of the Saints and Angels : Those must not be polluted with any work or seculare affaire , as we desire to bee helped by these glorified persons intercession . (m) (m) Cousins devotions they offend against the fifth command that obeyes not the precepts of the ecclesiastick governours . The precepts of the Church are first to observe the feastivals and holy dayes appointed in the Church calendar vide supra cap. Yet Christs Sunday must bee no Sabbath ; bowling , balling , and other such games may well consist with all the holinesse it hath , yea , no law of God , no ancient Canon of the Church doth discharge shearing of corne , taking of fish , or much other husband labour upon that day ; but by the contrary acts both of church & State do warrād such labour ; yea , there is so great Iewish superstition in the land about Christs Sunday , that all preachers must be oblidged in their very pulpits to proclame the new book of sports , for incouragment of the people to their gamings , when the short houre of divine service is ended , and that under no lesse paine than ejection from the Ministere . (n) (n) Whits examinat p. 118. The injunction maketh no difference betwixt Sunday and the other holy dayes concerning working , in harvest no speciall priviledge is given it more then the rest . For King Edwards statute repeated by Queen Elizabeth saith , It shall be lawfull to every husband man , labourer , fisher-man &c. upon the holy dayes aforesaid in harvest or at any other time of the yeare when necessity shall require , to labour , ride , fish , or work any kinde of work at their free wils and pleasure . Ibid. on the Sabbath p. 217. In the new testament we read of no prohibition concerning abstinence from secular actions upon the Lord day more then upon other dayes . Et quod non prohibetur ultro permissum est . The Catholick Church for more than 6●0 . year after Christ , gave licence to many Christian people to work upon the Lords day at such houres as they were not commanded to be present at the publick service by the precept of the Church . In S. Ieromes dayes the devotest Christians did ordinarly work upon the Lord-day . In Gregorie the greats time it was reputed antichristian doctrine to make it a sin to work on the Lords day . Helens answer . p 111. His Majestie having published his declararion about lawfull pastimes on the Sunday gives order to his bishops that publication thereof be made in all their severall diocesses , the bishops hereupon appoint the incumbent of every Church to read the declaration to the people , and finding opposition to the said appointment , presse them to the performance of it by vertue of that Canonicall obedience which by their severall oaths they were bound to yeeld unto their ordinaries , but seeing nothing but contempt upon contempt after much patience and long suffering , some of the most perverse have been suspended as well a beneficio as officio for an example to the rest . 9. Pilgramages to Sants , reliques , and barefooted processions to their Churches are preached and printed . (o) (o) Vide supra caput . 5. w. Those throats which are so wide as to swallow down all these , it seemes they will not make great bones in all the other trash which in the Romish Church we challenge as superstitious .

CHAP. VII . The Canterburians embrace the Masse it selfe .

OF all the pieces of Poperie , there is none so much beloved by Papists , nor so much hated by Protestants , as the Masse , since the reformation of Religion , the Masse hath ever beene counted the great wall of division , keeping the parties asunder , who ever could free that ditch , whose stomack could digest that morsell , no man of either side was wont to make any doubt of his name , but that with consent of all , hee might passe for a true Papist ; and no wayes in any reason stand for a moment longer in the catalogue of Protestants : If then I bee able to demonstrate the Canterburians minde to be for the Masse , I hope no man of any understanding and equitie will require of me any further proofe of their popery , but with good leave of all I may end my taske , having set upon the head thereof this cape-stone .

In the mouth of both sides reformed and Romish , preaching and the Masse go for reall opposites , the affection of Papists to their Masse maketh them value our preaching at the lesser rate ; They cry downe so far as they can all preaching . the affection of Protestans to preaching maketh the Masse to them the lesse lovely : Our faction to make rowme for the Masse so far as they dare , so fast as they can , are crying downe preaching . They tell us first , that much of the preaching which now is at London , and over England is not the Word of God , but of the Divell , (a) (a) Cant Starchamber speach , pag. 47. But in the pulpit it is at most , Hoc est verbum meum , & God hold it there at his word : for as too many men use the matter , it is , Hoc est verbum diaboli , this is the word of the divel in many places , witnesse sedition , and the like to it . because indeed the best and most zealous preachers in their sermons do oft taxe Arminianisme and Poperie , and the wayes , whereby his Grace is in use to advanee both : This to him and his followers is doctrinall Puritanisme , much worse than disciplinary ; yea , it is sedition taught by the Divell : 2. They tell us , that the most of preachers , though voyd of the former fault , are so ignorant , idle , impertinent , clamorous fellowes , that their silence were much more to be wisht than their speach . (b) (b) And posthuma , pag. 32. Ex quo nuper hic apud nos vapularunt canes muti exclusi sunt clamatores isti odiosi ac molesti , ex quo pessimus iste mos invaluit , ex quo pruriginoso cuipue odious , patefactus hic quicquid libet effutiendi , Ecclesia in tonstrinam versa est , non plus ibi inepti●rum quam hic , Theologia in battologiam , banes non latrantes mutari in catulos oblatrantes , haud ferè scias quid optandum sit illud , ne si lentium , an hilatratus absoni , illud ne j●junium , an haec nausea . Because indeed grave and gratious Ministers are not either able or willing to stuffe their sermons with secular learning , and imploy extraordinar paines for to gather together a Masse of tinkling words , as Andrewes was , and his admirers are wont to do , for to spoile preaching of that life , spirit , and power , which ought to shine into it . 3. That the preaching which them selves approve & praises , is but sermonizing in pulpits , no necessar part of the Ministeriall charge , but a practice to be used of some few of singular learning & eloquence , and that only at rare and extraordinar times , as the Bishop , or the Star-chamber-court shall be pleased to give licence . (c) (c) Shelfoord , pag. 91. Beside these ten kinds of preaching which are able to stop the mouth of all itching eared professors , there is yet another kinde of preaching not fit for every Minister , but for extraordinarie and excellent men , called by God and the Church , to reforme errors and abuses , to promulge to the world new Lawes and Canons . And as this kinde is to be performed by extraordinarie men , so it is not alwayes so needfull , but when necessitie required : for when things are setled there needs no more setling , but only preserving , Wee ought not to have many Moseses , or many Euangelists , nor many Apostles ; Were people now to bee called and converted to the Gospel , then not only this kinde of preaching , but miracles also were needfull , when much needlesse and some unsound teaching by tract of time had sued into the ark of Christs Church , by the Prelats and Priests therof : Then in the 19. year of King Henrie the eight began licences to be granted by the Court of Starchamber , to preach against the corruptions of the time ; but now the corruptions are removed , the ancient and true doctrine of the primitive Church by setled articles is restored ; Therefore this extraordinarie kinde is not now so necessarie , except it bee upon some notorious crimes , breaking foorth among people . 4. That the only ordinar , profitable , and necessar preaching which God hath appointed , and the Church laid upon the back of Pastours , as their charge for which their tithes and stipends is due to them , is nothing but the distinct and cleare reading of the Service Booke . (d) (d) Shelf . p. 35. The principall part of the Ministers office is the true understanding , distinct reading , & decēt Ministrie of the Church service , contained in the book of Common Prayer . This is the pith of godlinesse , the heart of religion , the spina or vertebrae , the backbone of all holy faculties of the Christian body . Ib. p. 39. Were these read as the Canons directs aptly , that is , by just distinctions , and by a sensible Re●der , observing all the rules of reading , with pronunciation fit for the matter , and with due attention of the hearer , there would bee much profite and edifying . Ibid. pag 76. Gods Minister is thy Preacher , ●nd the divine service of the church Book is his sermon . In this service & this sermon is contained whatsoever is necessar for salvation . Ibid p. 78. The very reading is preaching ; yea , a lively and effectuall kinde of preaching . As for sermonizing in pulpits , when so it is permitted , it ought to be very short , and after the popish form , without any prayer at all , either before or after : That the custome of English preachers , who before Sermon pray for the help of the Spirit of God to themselves and their hearers , or after Sermon crave grace to practice what hath beene spoken is all but idle ; yea , intollerable novations to be abolished : (e) (e) Heylans answere , pag. 165. Whereas formerly you used to mangle and cut short the service , that you might bring the whole worship of God to your extemporarie prayers and sermons , now you are brought againe to the ancient usage of reading the whole prayers , without any diminishing in regard of preaching . As for your other cavils about the using of no prayer at all after Sermon , the innovation here is on your part , who have offended all this while , not only against the Canon , but act of Parliament , by bringing in new formes of your owne divising . As for the forbidding of any prayer before the Sermon , if any such be , it is but agreeable unto the Canon , which hath determined so of it long ago . The Preachers in King Edwards dayes used no forme of prayers , but that exhorting which is now required in the Canon . Neither this onely , but that the most able Pastours are not to be suffered so much as in their private studies to recommend their Souls to God in their owne words , but in their very private prayers , are to be tyed precisely to the words of the Service Booke . (f) (f) Couzins devotions in the preface . Let no prayers bee used but these which are allowed by the Church , what prayers so ever any man had framed for himselfe , let him first acquaint these that are wise and learned with them , before hee presume to use them : and that men may not think those rules are to be applyed to publick prayers only , and not to private , let them weigh those words in the councell of Carthage , Quascunque sibi preces , &c When wee speak to the awfull Majestie of God , wee would bee sure to speak in the grave and pious language of the Church , which hath ever beene guided by the holy Ghost , and not to losse our selves with confusion in any suddaine abrupt or rude dictats , which are framed by private spirits , and ghosts of our own in regard whereof our very priests and deacons themselves are in their private and dayly prayers injoined to say the morning and evening devotions of the Church , & when at any time they pray , there is a set forme of words prescribed to them to use , that they also might know it is not lawfull for them to pray of their owne heads , or suddainly to say what , they please themselves . 5. That the sermonizing which themselves permit , must bee in the greatest townes in the most solemne times but once a day , that the practice of hearing two Sermons in one day is to be corrected , that one in a month is abundant , and all the English Canons do require . (g) (g) Pokling . Sunday . Our Saviour in Capernaum on the Sabboth , preached but once a day , for immediatly after he went to dinner , Heylens answer , Pag. 168. If in the great cities and universities , sermons are limited to the same time of the day , or as your owne phrase is , to an houre only , assuredly it is neither new nor strange , nor need you bee offended at it , if by that meanes the people in those places can not hear but one sermon in the day , it being not many , but good sermons ; not much but profitable hearing , which you should labour to commend . Shelfoord , pag. 93. Better were it for our Church and people to have but one Sermon well premeditated , in a moneth , which is insinuated by the Canon , then two on a day , proceeding from a rolling braine and mouth , without due preparation . Heylens answer , pag. 166. Your afternoone sermon on the Sunday , if performed by Lecturers , are but a part of your new fashion , and having no foundation in the Church at all , it can not be any innovation to lay them by , and if the Curate performe his duetie in catechising , you have no reason to complaine for want of sermons in the afternoone .

6. That over all England , Lecturers whose sermons wont to be the far best , must be presently silenced , as those whose calling the Canons Ecclesiasticall of England can not permit . (h) (h) Heylens answere , 163. Why count yee the suppressing of Lectures for an innovation , whereas the name of Lecturers and Lectures are in themselves a new and late invention , borrowed from the new fashions of Geneva . In a word , that Sermons are the great occasion of the divisions and heart-burnings , which now trouble the Church and State , of the presumption and pride , and most sins among the people : That therefore it were very good to returne to the old fashion in the dayes of poperie , before the 19. yeer of Henrie the eight , where there was none , or but few preachings , that this is the onely means to reduce the land to that old honest simplicitie , equitie , pietie and happinesse , which was in our antecessors dayes ; (i) (i) Schelfoord , pag. 71. When men had more of inward teaching , and lesse of outward , then was there far better living , for then they lived alwayes in feare of offending ; and as soone as they had done any thing amisse , their conscience by and by gave them a nip , and a memento for it ; then they confessed their sins to God and their Minister , for spirituall comfor and counsell ; then they endeavoured to make the best temporall satisfaction they could by almes , prayers , and fasting ; and other good works of humiliation ; but now outward teaching not being rightly understood , hath beaten away this . Ibid. pag. 82. The besotted negligence of our delicat Puritans , is that which makes them to run so after Sermons : what doeth this singularitie work in them , but a contempt of government ? As weak stomacks , can not well digest much meat , so the common people can not governe much knowledge ; & when they can not digest it well , they vomit it up , they waxe proud , and wil contest with their Ministers . At what time were most heresies broached ? Was it not in the primitive Church , when there was most preaching , therefore thereafter they did slake it . Ibid. pag. 99. Preaching by reading is the ordinaire preaching ordained by God himselfe , and his Church , and this was the ordinarie preaching in our Church before King Henrie the eight . even to that old blindnesse , wherein of necessitie , we must give our soule to be led by the light of Sr. Iohn the Priest , our Father Confessor , for all this behold on the margine their expresse declaration .

Preaching being thus far cryed down , They approve the Masse both for word & matter . there will be the lesse ado to get up the Masse : For the word of the Masse is so lovelie to them , that they are delighted to stile their Service Booke by that name . (k) (k) Pokling , Sunday , Missam facere cepi , sayeth S. Ambrose , he began the second service as our church calleth it , quidam cogunt sacerdotem ut abbreviet Missam , sayeth S. August . that is , they make the priest to curtaile divine service . And least wee should thinke that it is but with the word of the Masse , that they are reconciled , they show us next , that they finde no fault with the very matter of the Masse , if you will give unto it a charitable and benigne interpretation . (l) (l) Montag . antid. Pag. 10. Missam ipsam non damnamus , quoàd vocem , quin nequit Missae 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 sano & recto sensu intellectum . Neither heere do they stand , but go on to tell us , yet more of their minde , that if transubstantiation only were removed from the Masse , they would make no question , for any thing it hath beside . And this , but most falsly , they give out for King Iames judgement . (m) (m) Pokling al , pag. 138. The King would like wel enough of the Masse , if the priests would shrive her of Transubstantiation . Yea , they go on further to embrace transubstantiation it selfe , so farre as concernes the word : And how much the matter of it displeaseth them we shall heare anone . (n) (n) Montag . antid. pag. 10. De vocibus , ne Missae quidem , imo ne Transubstantiationis certamen moveremus .

But to shew their minde more clearly towards the Masse , consider the Scottish liturgie ; This unhappie book was his Graces invention : If he should deny it , his own deeds would convince him . The manifold letters which in this pestiferous affaire have passed betwixt him and our Prelats are yet extant . If we might be heard , we would spread out sundrie of them before the Parlement house of England , making it cleare as the light , that in all this designe his hand hath ever bene the prime stikler ; so that upon his back mainly , nill he will he , would be laide the charge of all the fruits good or evill which from that tree , are like to fall on the Kings countreyes . But of this in time and place ; onely now wee desire to bee considered that to this houre , his Grace hath not permitted any of his partie to speak one crosse word against that book , but by the contrary lets many of them commend it in word and writ for the most rare and singular peece , that these many ages hath beene seene in any church , for all gratious qualities that can be found in any humane writ . Heare you the personat Jesuit Lysimachus Nicanor , that is , as we conjecture by too probable signes his Graces creature , Lesty of Dun , and Conner , extols that booke above the skyes : (o) (o)

Pag. 28. think no Church can celebrate the Sacrament with more puritie , sinceritie , gravitie , and none with more majestie then by this Book : Certainly it is purged from all stuffe , which you call Superstition , or the essentialls of the Masse , it is restored to the ancient integritie , the least thing that might tend to superstition , being thurst out of doores , as Ammon did Tamar , without hope of return : And if any superstitions would dare to enter , the doore is so fast shut , that they must despair of any entrie . What needs all such uproare then without cause ? I shall oblidge my selfe to made good these particulars : First , that you shall never bee able to finde any thing in that book , contrarie to the Word of GOD.

2. That it containeth nothing contrary to the practise of the primitive church , but which is most agreeable thereto .

3. That all the points which you condemne are not contraverted betweene our Classicall Divines and papists but agreed upon in both sides .

4. That there , is nothing in it , contrary to our Confession of Faith in Scotland ; yea , which is much , yee shall not show mee a Protestant Divine of any note , who ever did condemne this Booke of the least point of poperie , but on the contrare , did defend and commend it .

And yet wee did undertake to shew into it the maine , yea all the substantiall parts of the Masse , and this undertaking to the satisfaction of our nation was performed in our generall Assembly ; but to those men the judgements of nationall churches are but vile and contemptible testimonies . I have seene a paralel written by a preacher among us , comparing all and every particular portion of the Masse , as they are cleared by Innocent , Durand , Walfrid , Berno , and the rest of the old Liturgick Rationalists , with the parts of our Liturgie , as they may bee cleared by the late writs of the Canterburians , which ends not , till all the parts great and small of the Masse bee demonstrat in our Book either formally , in so many words , as the most considerable are , and that in the very popish sense , If you will joine to our book the Canterburian commentars : or virtually a necessity being laid upon us , upon the same grounds which perswads to embrace what in those booke is formally expressed , to embrace also what of the Masse is omitted , whensoever it shall bee their pleasure in a new edition to adde it . This paralel is readie for the publick when ever it shall be called for .

For the present , The Scottish Liturgie is much worse then the English . because those men make our gracious Soveraigne beleeve , and declare also to the world in print , that what we challenge in that book , doeth strike alike against the liturgie of England , as if the scots liturgie were altogether one with the English , and the few small variations , which possibly may be found in the Scottish , were not only to the better , but made for this very end , that this new book might better comply with the Scots humour , which now almost by birth or at least by long education is become naturally antipathetick to the masse , to make this their impudent fraud so palpable that hereafter they may blush ( if it be possible for such foreheads to blush at any thing ) ever again before our King to make any such alledgance , passing all the rest of that book for shortnesse , we shall consider some few lines in some three or foure leafes of it at most , wherein the world may see their malapert changing of the English liturgie in twentie particulars and above , every one whereof draws us beyond all that ever was allowed in England , and diverse of them lead to those parts of the masse which all protestants this day count most wicked . If this be made cleare , I hope that all equitable men will bee the more willing to free our opposition thereto , of all imputations , and specially of al intentions to encroach upon any thing that concernes the English church . For albeit we are confident the world would have excused us to have opposed with all vehemencie the imposition upon us ( a church and kingdome as free and independant upon any other nation as it is to be found this day in christendome ) without our consent , or so much as our advice , the heavie burden of foure forraigne books , of liturgie , canons , ordination , homelies , of a number of strange judicatories , high commission , episcopall visitations , officiall courts , and the like , though they had been urged in no other words , in no other sense then of old they wont to be used in England : For it is well known that those things have been the sole ground and only occasion of the grievous shismes and heavie troubles wherewith almost ever since the reformation , that gracious church hath been miserably vexed . But now all those things being laide upon us in a far worse sense as they are declared by the Canterburian imposers in their own writs , yea in far worse words , as all who will take the paines to compare , may see : we trust that our immovable resolution to oppose even unto death all such violent novations shal be taken , by no good man , in evil part , let be , to be thrown , far against our intentions , to the disgrace of our neighbour church , or any well minded person therein . We have with the English church nought to do but as with our most dear and neerest sister , we wish them all happinesse , and that not only they , but all other Christian churches this day were both almost , and altogether such as wee are , except our afflictions . We have no enemies there but the Canterburian faction , no lesse heavie to her then to us . What we have said against the Scots liturgie may well reflect upon them , and so far as we intend , upon them alone , and that for three of their crimes chiefly . First their forcing upon us , with whom they had nought to do , so many novations even all that is in England at one draught , and that by meer violence . 2. Their mutation of the most of those things to a plaine popish sense , which in the best sense that ever was put upon them , did occasion alwayes to England much trouble . 3. Their mutation of the English books not only to popish senses but even to popish words , and that in a number of the most important passages of the masse . This last here we will shew , holding us within the bounds of our few forenamed leafes , by which , conjecture may bee made of the rest .

Of all the limbs of the masse the most substantious for many evil qualities are those three , which ly contiguous together , the Offertorie , Our alteration in the Offertorie . the Canon , the Communion : The English at the reformation , howsoever for reasons of their own , thought meet to retaine more of the masse words then our church could ever be induced to follow , yet in those three portions of the masse they were very carefull to cast out what they knew Protestants did much abhorre in the church of Rome . But at this time , the Canterburians having gotten the refraiming of the liturgie in their hands , for to manifest their affection openly to Rome , do put in expresly that , which the English reformers put out , as wicked scandals . That this may bee seen consider severally the three named portions .

The Popish Offertorie in it self is a foul practice , even a renovation in the Christian church of a Jewish sacrifice , as Durand confesseth . (p) (p) Durand . lib. 4 fol. 65. Ritus igitur synagogae transivit in religionem ecclesiae & sacrificia carnalis populi translata sunt in observantiam populi spiritualis . But as it stands in the Masse , it have yet a worse use , to be a preparatorie peace-offering making way for that holy propitiatorie , which in the Canon followes . It is pretended to be a sacrifice for the benefite both of quicke and dead , for the good of the whole church universall , for the help of these in Purgatory ; but it is really intended to be a dragge , a hooke to draw in money to the Priests purses . This piece of the Masse the English did clean abolish , but behold how much of it our present reformers are pleased to replant in our booke : First , they professe in plaine tearmes the reduction of the Offertorie , and that not once alone , but least their designe should passe without observation , they tell us over againe of the Offertorie : 2. In the very fore front of this their Offertorie , they set up unto us whole fiue passages of Scripture , whereof the English hath none , all directly in the literall sense carrying to a Iewish oblation . 3. For the wakning of the Priests appitite ( which of it self uses to be sharp enough ) Upon the hope of present gaine to sing his Masses with the better will , they set up a rubrick , seasing and infefting the officiating Priest in the halfe of all the oblations , which hee can move the people to offer , and giving a liberty to him with his church-warden , to dispose on the other halfe also as he thinks good , expresly contrare to the Englsh , which commands all the almes of the people to bee put up in the poores box . 4. They will not have us to want the very formalitie of a Iewish offering , for they ordaine the Deacon to put the bason with the peoples devotions in the hands of the Priest , that he may present it before the Lord upon the altar , just as the Papists in this place ordaine to bring the paten with their oblations unto the Priest ; that hee may set it upon their altar . (q) (q)

Durand . lib. 4. fol. 64. Subsequens diaconus ipse patinam cum hostia pontifici representat , & pontifex seu sacerdos hostiam collocat super altare .

Ibid fol. 66. Sacerdos oblatione ? manu tangit , repraesentans illud Levitici , 14.4 . ponetque manus suas super caput hostia , & acceptabilis erit , & inexpiationem proficiciens .

5. The Priest is ordained to place and to offer up the bread and wine upon the Lords table , that it may be ready for that service , just the Popish offering , in that place of the Masse of the bread and wine , as a preparatory sacrifice for the propitiatory following . 6. The English prayer for the catholick church , is in our book cast immediatlie at the back of the offering of bread and wine , and that we may know it must bee taken for the Offertorie prayers that stands there in the Missall , and that for the benefite not only of the living , but also of the dead . The Masse clauses for the honour of the Saints , and help of those who are in Purgatorie , which the English scraped out , they put in againe : For as the Papists say , these Offertorie prayers for the honour of the Saints , especially of the blessed Virgin , and Apostles , and Martyrs , so they in this their Offertorie prayer commemorat all the Saints , who in their severall generations were the lights of the world , and had wonderfull grace and vertue , they might have put in particularly , as Couzins in his devotions doeth , pag. 371. The blessed Virgin Mary , the holy Patriarchs , Prophets , Apostles , and Martyrs : also they mention among the dead not onely these glorious Saints , but the rest of Gods servants , who have finished their course in faith , and now do rect from their labours , the best description that can be , if Bellarmine may be believed , of the Souls in purgatory , for whom not only thanks is given , but also prayers made , as Couzins , who is suspected to be one of the maine pen-men of our book , doeth comment this passage in his devotions , pag. 372. That at the last day , we with them , and they with us may attaine to the resurrection of the Just , and have our perfect consummation both of Soul and Body in the kingdome of heaven : There is no footstep of any of these things in the English Booke .

Our changes in the consercration . The piece which followes the Offertorie in the Missall , and in our book also , is the Canon , no lesse detested by all Protestants , then admired by Papists , as Bellarmine telleth us ; (r) (r) De missa lib. 2. cap. 17. Sacrum canonem ut summa reverentia sēper Catholici retinuerunt , ita in●redibili furore ●●retici huius tempori● lacerant . Many of the Prefaces and prayers thereof we have word by word , and what ever we want , these men in print are bold to justifie it all , as in nothing opposite to the trueth or Protestant doctrine : So the appendix to D. Fields third Booke , Chap. 1. But wee must consider the time wherein D. Field is made to utter such speaches , it is in the twenty eight yeare , long after the death of that learned and reverend Divine : It is in that yeare when his Grace sitting in the chaire of London , had gotten now the full superintendence of all the presses there , and could very easely ( for the promoving of his designes ) put in practice that piece of policie among others , to make men after their death speak in print , what they never thought in their life ; or at least , to speake out those thoughts which for the good and peace of the church , they keept close within the doors of their owne breast , and withdrew from the notice of the world ; it would then seeme reason to father these strange justifications , of the Masse , which are cast to Fields book so long after his death , as also many passages in these posthume works of Andrewes ; which his Grace avowedly sets out in the twentie ninth yeare , and those new pieces never heard of , which in the thirtie one yeare , are set out by M. Aylward , under the name of the English Martyrs , as also that writ of Overall , which Montagu puts out with his own amplifications , in the thirtie six year . These and the like pieces , must in reason be rather fathered on those who put them foorth , then upon their pretended authors , who readily did never know such posthume children , or else did take them for such unhappie bastards as they were resolved , for reasons known to them selves , to keepe them in obscurity , and never in publick to avow them as their owne .

In this Canon there are two parts most principall , which the papists call the Heart , and Head thereof . (s) (s) Innocent lib. 4. cap. 1. Ecce nunc ad summam Sacramenti verticem accedentes , ad ipsum cor divini sacrificii penetramus . The prayers of consecration and of oblation , this head the English strikes off , this heart they pull out of their book , that the wicked serpent should not have any life among them . But our men are so tender and compassionat towards that poor Beast , that they will againe put in that Heart , and set on that Head , The consecration and oblation they will bee loath to want . Consider then these mens changing of the English book towards both those , the two incomparably worst parts of the whole Masse . First , the English scrapes out all mention of any consecration : for however we delight not to strive with the papists any where about words , yet in this place while they declare expressely , that by consecration of the elements they do understand not the sanctification of the elements by the word and prayer , but a secret whispering of certaine words upon the elements , for their very Transubstantiation . (t) (t) Durand . lib. 6. Dicimus illud non conserari ; sed sanctificari , differt autem inter haec , nam consecrare , est consecratine transubstātiare , sancti ficare est ; sanctum & reverendumesficere , ut patet in aqua benedicta . Consecration in this place being so taken by the papists , the English rejects it , and will have nothing to do therewith ; but our men being more wise , and understanding their owne ends , put up in their rubrick in capitall letters formally and expressely their prayer of consecration . 2. The Papists to the end that their consecratorie words may bee whispered upon the elements for their change , and no wayes heard of the people , who perchance if they heard and understood them , might learne them by heart , and in their idlenesse might pronunce them over their meales , and so , which once they say was done , transubstantiat their ordinarie food into Christs bodie : For the eshewing of these inconveniences they ordaine the consecration to bee made in the outmost corner of the church , so far from the ears of the people as may be ; and for the greater securitie , they ordaine their priests in the time of consecration , both to speake low , and to turne their backs upon the people : For to remeed their wicked follies , the English expressely ordained their communion Table to stand in the body of the church , where the Minister in the mids of the people might read out openly all the words of the Institution . But our men to returne to the old fashion , command the table to beset at the East end of the Chancell , that in the time of the consecration , the priest may stand so far removed from the people , as the furthest wall of the church can permit , and as this distance were not enough to keep these holy words of consecration from the profaine eares of Laicks , our booke hath a second Rubrick , injoining expressely the priest in the time of consecration to turne his back on the people , to come from the North end of table , and to stand at such a place where hee may use both his hands with more decencie and ease , which is not possible but on the Westside alone ; for on the South side the commoditie is just alike as in the North. On the East none can stand , for the Table is joined hard to the Wall , and whosoever stands at the West side of the Altar , his back is directly to the people that are behinde him . They say for this practise many things , first , That in the good holy Liturgie of Edward the sixth , the priest was ordained to stand with his back to the people . (u) (u) Heylens antid. pag. 45. and 46. The Church of Rome injoyneth the priest to stand in medio altaris , with his face to the East , and backe to the people ; But the Church of England at the north side of the Table , albeit in King Edwards Lyturgie the priest was appointed to stand at the mids of the altar . Againe , that alwayes in the ancient church the priests stood in the uppermost end of the church , divided from the people behinde them , with railes , and vailes , and other distinctions . (x) (x) Supra saepe . 3. That Scripture is the ground of this practise , for so it was in the Jewish church , the priest when wee went into the Sanctuarie to pray , and offer incense for the people , they stood without and never did heare what he spake , nor saw what he did . (y) (y) P●kling . alt. pag. 99. The people might see the priest going into the Sanctuarie , they might heare the noise of his bels ; himself , his gesture , his actions they saw not , yet all this was done in medio Ecclesiae , but not among the people in the outward or inward Court , whereunto only the people were permitted to come . If from this practice wee would infer with Bellarmine , that the Priest in the consecration might speake in latine or in a language unknowne to the people , since God to whom he speaks understands all languages , the elements upon which the consecratorie words are murmured , (z) (z) Scottish service the words of consecration may bee repeated againe over more either bread or wine . understands none , and the people for whom alone the vulgar language is used , is put back from the hearing of the consecration ; we know not what in reason they could answer ; But this we know , that the maine ground whereupon wee presse the use of the vulgar language , not onely in the consecration as they call it , but in the whole service of God , I meane the warrant of Scripture , they openly deny and for it gives us no ground , but the old tradition of the church . (&) (&) White on the Sabbath , pag. 97. Such traditions are those that follow the Service of the Chruch in a known language .

3. When our priest is set under the East wall within his raile his back upon the people , he is directed to use both his armes with decencie and ease , what use heere can be made of the priests armes , except it be for making of large crosses as the masse rubricks at this place doth direct , We do not understand : only we have heard before , that they avow the lawfulnesse of crossing no lesse in the supper then in baptisme . 4. The prayer which stands heer in the English book , drawn from the place wherein it stood of old in the masse to countenance the transubstantiation of the bread and wine into Christs body and bloud , but standing in this place before the consecration it is clear of all such suspition : Our men are so bold as to transplant it from this good ground to the old wicked soile at the back of the consecration where it wont to stand before in the old order of Sarum . 5. In the next English prayer we put in the words of the masse whereby God is besought by his omnipotent spirit so to sanctifie the oblations of bread and wine , that they may become to us Christs body and bloud , from these words all papists use to draw the truth of their transubstantiation , wherefore the English reformers scraped them out of their book , but our men put them fairly in , and good reason have they so to do : for long ago they professed that about the presence of Christs body and bloud in the sacrament after consecration , they are fully agreed with Lutherans and Papists in all things that is materiall and needfull , as for the small difference which remaines about the formalitie and mode of presence , it is but a curious and undeterminable question , whereabout there would be no contraversie , did not the diuelish humor of the Puritans and Jesuites make and entertaine it . (a) (a) Mont. apeal . pag. 289. If men were disposed as they ought unto peace , there neded bee no difference in the point of reall presence : for the disagreement is only de modo praesentiae ; the thing it self , That there is in the holy Eucharist a reall presence is yeelded to on either side . For Andrews professeth to Bellarmine , nobis vobiscum de obiecto convenit , de modo lis est . Praesentiam inquam credimus non minus quam vos , verum de modo praesentiae nil temere definimus . There is no such cause therefore saith he why in this point of the sacrament we should be so distracted seeing we both confesse that which is enough . This is my bedy , and contend meerly about the means how it is my body , a point of faith undeniable though it be unsearchable and incomprehensible : From Hooker he pronounceth that there is a generall agreement about that which is alone materiall , for the rest he avoweth himself to be for peace and reconciliation and all to be so but Puritans and Iesuites whom the divel doth nourish up in a faction . Lawrence pag. 18. I like S. Ambrose , Lombard . Rosfensis and Harding who advise in this argument to forbeare the determination of the manner of presence and to cloth our rancie with indefinite and generall expressions . As I like not those that say he is bodily there , so I like not those that say his body is not there . For S. Paul saith , it is there , and the Church of England faith it is there , and the Church of God ever said , it is there , and that truly , substantially , essentially . We must beleeve it is there . We must not know how it is there . It is a mysterie they all say . The presence they determined , the maner of his presence they determined not . They said he is there , but the Lord knows how . Yea they seem to have come a step further to the embraceing of the very modde of the popish presence , for they tell of a corporall presence ibi that the body is there on the altar , and that essentially , yea so grosly , that for its presence there , the altar it self , let be the elements must bee adored . 6. They make an expresse rubrick for the priests taking of the paten and chalice in his hand in the time of consecration , which taking not being either for his own participation or distribution to others , why shall we not understand the end of it to be that , which the masse there enjoynes the paten and chalice their elevation and adoration , for the elevation was long practised and professed by some of our bishops , and the adoration when the chalice and paten are taken in the priests hands is avowed by Heylene . (b) (b) Heylens answere p. 137. Think you it fit the priest should take into his hands the holy mysteries without lowly reverence , and that it is an novation to do so . 7. In an other rubrick of our consecration we have the cautels of the masse , anent the priests intention to consecrat , expresly delivered unto us .

As for that wicked sacrifice of the Masse , Our changes about the sacrifice . which the Canon puts at the back of the consecration , the English banisheth it allutterly out of their book ; but the faction to show their zeal in their reforming the errors of the English church , their mother , puts downe heere in our book , first , at the back of the consecration their memento and prayer of oblation . 2. That prayer of thanksgiving which the English sets after the Communion in a place , where it can not be possibly abused , as it is in the Masse for a propitiatory sacrifice of Christs body and blood , they transpose and set it just in the old place where it stood in the order of Sarum , at the back of the consecration before the Communion . 3. The clause of the Missall , which for its savour of a corporall presence , the English put out of this prayer ( may worthily receive the most pretious Body and Blood of thy Son Christ Iesus ) they have heere restored . 4. That we may plainly understand , that this prayer is so transplanted and supplied for this very end , that it may serve as it did of old in the missall for a prayer of oblation of that unbloudie sacrifice by the priest for the sins of the world . Behold the first eighth lines of it , which of old it had in the missall , but in the reformation was spred out by the English , are plainly restored , wherein we professe to make and over again to make before Gods divine majestie a memoriall as Christ hath commanded . This making not only the Papists , but Heylene speaking from Canterburie , expones far otherwise than either Andrewes , Hooker , Montagu , or the grossest of the English Divines for a true proper corporall , visible , unbloody sacrificing of Christ , for which first the Apostles , and then all Ministers are as truely Priests though Euangelicall , and after the order of Melchisedeck , as ever the Sons of Aaron were under the Law , and the Communion Table becomes as true and proper an Altar , as ever was the brasen Altar of Moses . (c) (c) Heylens antid. pag. 6. sect. 2. The passion of our Saviour , as by the Lords owne ordinance , it was prefigured to the Iewes in the legal sacrifices à parte ante : So by Christs institution , it is to bee commemorat by us Christians in the holy Supper , à parte post . A sacrifice it was in figure , a sacrifice in fact , and so by consequence a sacrifice in the commemorations , or immediatly upon the post fact a sacrifice there was among the Iewes , a sacrifice there must be amongst the Christians : and if a sacrifice where upon to doe it : For without a priest and an altar there can be no sacrifice . There was a bloudie sacrifice than ; an unbloudy now , a priest derived from Aaron then , from Melchisedeck now ; an Altar for Mosaicall sacrifices than , for Euangelicall now . The apostles in the institution were appointed priests by Christ , where they received a power for them , and their successours to celebrate these holy mysteries . Hoc facite , is for the priest , who hath power to consecrat ; Hoc edite , is both for priest and people . Ibid. pag. 17. Hee maintained at length that in the Lords Supper there is a true , proper , corporall , visible , and externall sacrifice . 5. After the consecration and oblation they put to the Lords prayer with the Missals Preface , audemus dicere . Heere the Papists tell us , that their Priest by consecration having transubstantiat the bread , and by their memoriall of oblation having offered up in an unbloody sacrifice the body of Christ , for the reconciliation of the Father , doeth then close his quiet whisperings , his poore pipings , and becomes bold to say with a loud voice , having Christ corporally in his hands , Pater noster . The English to banish such absurdities , put away that naughty preface , and removed the prayer it selfe from that place : But our men to shew their Orthodoxie , repone the prayer in the owne old place , and set before it in a fair Rubrick the whole old preface . 6. The first English prayer which stood before the consecration , where the passages of eating Christs body and drinking Christs blood , could not possibly , by the very Papists themselves , be detorted to a corporall presence , yet now in our book , it must change the place , and be brought to its owne old stance , after the consecration and oblation , immediatly before the communion , as a prayer of humble accesse .

The third part of the Masse I spake of , was the communion ; Our changes in the communion . see how heere out men change the English Booke : The English indeed in giving the elements to the people , retaine the Masse words , but to preveene any mischiefe that could arise in the peoples minde from their sound of a corporall presence , they put in at the distribution of both the elements , two golden sentences , of the hearts eating by faith , of the Soules drinking in remembrance . Our men being nothing affrayed for the peoples beliefe of a corporall presence , have pulled out of their hands and scraped out of our Booke both these antidots . 2. The Masse words of Christs body and blood in the act of communion , being quite of the English antidots against their poyson , must not stand in our Booke simplie ; but that the people may take extraordinar notice of these phrases , there are two Rubricks set up to their backs , oblidging every communicant with their owne mouth to say their Amen to them . 3. The English injoines the Minister to give the people the elements in their owne hand ; ours scrapes out that clause , and bid communicat the people in their own order , which imports not onely their removall from the altar , their standing without the raile , as profaine Laicks far from the place , and communion of the Priests , but also openeth a faire door to the popish practice , of putting the elements not in the profaine hands , but in the mouths of the people . 4. The English permit the Curate to cary home the reliques of the bread and wine for his privat use , but such profanity by our Book is discharged : The consecrat elements are injoined to bee eaten in the holy place by the Priest alone , and some of the Communicants that day , whose mouths hee esteemeth to bee most holy : Yea , for preventing of all dangers the cautele is put in , that so few elements as may , bee consecrat. 5. Our Booke will have the elements after the consecration covered with a Corporall , the church linnings were never called Corporals any where , till transubstantiation was born , neither carried they that name in England , till of late his Grace was pleased by the pen of his man Pocklingtoune and the like , to disgrace them with that stile . 6. The English will have the Ministers and people to communicat in both kindes ; our booke injoines the Priest to receave in both kindes but the people onely in due order : This due order of the people , opposite to the communion of the Priest in both kindes , may import the removall of one kinde from the people , so much the more may wee feare this sacriledge from their hands , since they tell us , that our only ground for communicating of the people in both kindes is stark nought , that for this practice there may well be tradition , but Scripture there is none . (d) (d) Whit on the Sabbath , pag. 97. Such traditions are those that follow the deliverie of the communion to the people in both kindes . Montag . orig. pag. 396. Vbi iubentur in Scripturis infantes babtiZari , aut in caena Domini subutraque specie communicantes participare ; de his possumus profiteri , Nihil tale docet Scriptura , Scriptura haec non praedicat . Andrews stricturae p. 5. It can not be denyed but reserving the Sacrament was suffered a long time in the primitive church , in time of persecution , they were permitted to carrie away how great a part they would , and to keep it by them , and to take it at times to comfort them ; but for the sick , it was alwayes sent them home , were the distance never so great , and against the time of extremitie , it was thought not amisse to have it reserved , that if the priest should not then be in state to go to the sick partie , and there to censecrat it for him , yet at least it might be sent him , as in the case of Cerapion . Pokling , as we have heard , made it one of the matters of that Churches glory ▪ that they yet doe retaine in their Chanchels the old Repositories . Also that in diverse cases the ancient church did lawfully give to the people the bread alone , that the Sacrament after the publick communion , was oft reserved to be sent to the sicke , to bee taken at privat occasions , and laide up in the church in a publicke repositorie . Now it is well knowne , and the Papists presse this upon us , when they would rob the people of the cup ; that the wine was not sent to the sicke in a farre distance from the church , nor taken home by the people to bee used with the bread in the times of strait , nor set up in the Church in the ciboir or repositorie . These changes of the English Liturgie , which the Canterburians have made , in some few pages lying together of the Scottish service , if they be either few or small , your self pronunce the sentence .

The last Chapter , containing the Canterburian maximes of Tyrannie .

ONe of the great causes of Protestants separation from Rome , is the tyrannie of the Romish Clergie , whereby they presse upon , the very conscience of their people , a multitude of their own devices , with the most extreame and rigorous censures which can be inflicted either upon bodies or souls . And for the more facilitating of their purposes , they advance the secular power of Princes , and of all soveraigne Estates above all , that themselves either crave or desire ; alone for this end , that their clerks may ride upon the shoulders of Soveraignitie , to tread under the feet of their domination ; first the Subjects , and then the Soveraignes themselves .

The tyrannous usurpation of the Canterburians , are as many and heavie as these of the Romist Clergie . How much our men are behinde the greatest tyrants that ever were in Rome , let any pronounce , when they have considered these their following maximes : They tell us , first , that the making of all Ecclesiastick constitutions doth belong alone to the Bishop of the Diocesse , no lesse out of Synod then in Synod : That some of the inferior clergie may bee called ( if the Bishops please ) to give their advice , and deliberative voice ; That the Prince may lend his power , for confirming and executing of the constitutions made ; but for the work of their making , it is the Bishops priviledge , belonging to them alone by Divine right . (a) (a) Samuel Hoards sermons . pag. 7. By the Chruch I meane the Churches Pilots , who sit at the sterne . Heads & members divide all bodies Ecclesiasticall and civill , what ever is to bee done in matters of direction and government , hath alwayes beene , and must be the sole prerogative of the heads of these bodies , unlesse wee will have all common-wealths and churches broken in picees . Ibid. pag. 8. The key of jurisdiction , which is a power of binding and lousing men , in foro exteriori , in the coutts of justice , and of making lawes and orders , for the government of Gods house , is peculiar to the heads and bishops of the church . Ibid. p. 31. what was Ignatius and Ambrose , if we look at their authoritie , more than other bishops of the church : That libertie therfore which they had to make new orders , when they saw cause , have all other prelats in their churches . Edward Boughanes serm. Pag. 17. Submit your selves to those that are put in authoritie by kings , so then to Bishops , because they are put in authoritie by Kings , if they had no other clame . But blessed bee God ; they hold not only by this , but by a higher tenor , since all powers are of God , from him they have their spirituall jurisdiction what ever it be . S. Paul therfore you see assumes this power unto himselfe of setting things in order in the kirk , before any Prince become Christian , 1 Cor. 11.34 . The like power hee acknowledgeth to be in Titus 1.5 . and in all bishops , Heb. 15.17 . Ibid. pag. 18. Kings make lawes , and bishops make canons . This indeed it was of necessitie in the beginning of Christianitie , Kings made lawes for the State , and bishops for the kirk , because then there was no Christian Kings , either to authorize them to make such lawes or who would countenance them when they were made . But after that Kings became nourishing fathers to the Church in these pious and regular times , bishops made no Canons , without the assent and confirmation of Christian Kings , and such are our Canons , so made , so confirmed , Chounei collect . pag. 53. Reges membra quidem & filios . Eccesiae se esse habitos , reiecisse , contempsisse nonnunquam audivimus , obediunt , simulque regnant : Iura quibus gubernari se permittunt , sua sunt , vitalitatem nativam ex praepositis Ecclesiae , tanquam ex corde recipiunt , & vivacitatem ex ipsis tanquam ex capitibus derivant . Samuel Hoards pag. 9. Nor did they exercise this power , when they were in Counsell only , but when they were asunder also : Speaking of apostles as they are paterns to all bishops . 2. That in a whole Kingdome , the Bishops alone , without the privitie of any of the clergie , of any of the laitie , may abolish all the Ecclesiastick judicatories , which the standing and unrepealled lawes , which the constant customes ever since the reformation had setled , and put in their rowme new forraigne courts , which the kingdome had never known , scarce so much as by their name . (b) (b) Our Chrurch Sessions , our weekly presbyteries , our yearly generall Assemblies , whereof by our standing lawes wee have beene in possession , are closse put downe by our book of Canons , and in their rowme Church-wardens , officiall courts , synods for Episcopall visitation , and generall Assemblies to bee called when they will , to be constitute of what members they please to name , are put in their place . That at one stroke they may annull all the Acts of three or fourscore National Afsemblies , and set up in their roome a Book of Canons of their own devysing . (c) (c) So is their book entituled , Canons and Constitutions Ecclesiasticall gathered , and put in forme , for the governement of the Church of Scotland , and ordained to bee observed by the clergie , and all others whom they concerne . That they may abolish all the formes used in the worship of God , without any question for threescore yeares and above , both in the publicke prayers , in the administration of the Sacraments , in singing of Psalmes , in preaching the Word , in celebrating of Marriage , in visiting the sicke , and in ordination of Ministers : Neither this alone , but that it is in their hand to impose in place of these accustomed formes , foure new Bookes of their owne ; of Service , of Psalmes , of Ordination , of Homilies . All this our Bishops in Scotland have done , and to this day , not any of them to our knowledge can be moved to confesse in that deed , any faile against the rules either of equitie or justice , what ever slips of imprudence there may bee therein . And all this they have done at my lord of Canterburies direction , as wee shall make good by his owne hand , if ever we shall be so happy as to be permitted to produce his owne authentick autographs , before the Parliament of England , or any other Judicatorie that his Majestie will command to cognosce upon this our alleadgance . Readily Rome it self can not be able in any one age , to paralell this worke which our faction did bring foorth in one yeare . It is a bundel of so many , so various , and so heavie acts of tyrannie . Certainly , England was never acquaint with the like ; wee see what great trouble it hath cost his Grace , to get thorow there one poore ceremonie of setting the Communion table altar-wayes ; for there themselves dar not deny , that it is repugnant to the established Lawes of their church and state for any Bishop ; yea , for all the Bishops being joined , to make the poorest Canon without the voices of their convocation-house , or Nationall Assemblie ; yea , without the Parliaments good pleasure . (d) (d) Whites examination of the dialogue , pag 22. By the lawes of our kingdome , and Canons of our Church , many learned persons are appointed to be assistants unto bishops , and in our nationall Synods , in which all weightie matters concerning religion are determined , nothing is , or may be concluded , but by the common vote and counsell of the major part , of the convocation which consisteth of many other learned Divines , besides Bishops . Andrews sermons of Trumpets , dedicated to the King by Canterburie . As for the Churches lawes , which wee call Canons or rules , made to restrain or redresse abuses , they have alwayes been made at Church assemblies , and in her owne Councels , not elsewhere , Heylens antidot . pag. 29. I trow you are not ignorant that the kirk makes canons , it is the work of Cleargie men in their Convocations , having his Majesties leave for their conveening , and approbation of their doings . His Majestie in the declaration before the articles hath resolved it so , and the late practice in King Iames raigne , what time the Book of Canons was composed in the Convocation , hath declared it soo to . 3. They avow that all their injunctions though so many and so new , yet they are so holy and so just , that the whole kingdome in conscience must embrace them all as the commands of God . (e) (e) Whites examination , pag. 20. telleth us as it were from Eusebius , Quicqued in Sanctis Episcoporum conciliis decernitur , id universum Divina voluntati debet attribus . And from Bernard , Sive Deus , sive homo vicarius Dei mandatum quodcunque tradiderit , pari profectó obsequendum est cura , pari reverentia suscipiendum : ubi tamen Deo contraria non praecepit homo . That whoever will be so peart as to affirm in any one of them , the least contrarietie to the Word of God , he must have no lesse censure then the great excommunication , from which he must never be relaxed but by the Bishops own mouth , after his publick repentance and revocation of so vile an errour . (f) (f) Book of Canons , pag. 8. Whosoever shall hereafter affirme , that the forme of worship contained in the booke of Commoun Prayer , that the rites and ceremonies of the church , that the government of the Church by archbishops , bishops and others , that the forme of consecrating archbishops , bishops , presbyters , and deacons , as they are now established under his Maiesties authoritie , doe containe in them any thing repugnant to the Scriptures , or are corrupt , superstitious or unlawfull in the service and worship of God , let him be excommunicate , and not restored , but by the bishop of the place , or archbishop of the province , after his repentance , and publick revocation of such his wicked errours . That his bodily and pecuniall penaltie shall be at the free will and discretion of the Bishop . (g) (g) Book of Canons , pag. 37. In all this book of Canons whersoever there is no penaltie expressely set downe , it is to be understood , that , so the crime or offence bee proved , the punishment shall be arbitrarie , as the ordinarie shall think fittest . That the worthiest men of any liberall profession get savour to losse but their eares , to have their noses slit , and cheeks burnt for contradicting their innovations . (h) (h) Canterburies Star chamber speach in his epistle to the King , I shall rather magnifie your clemencie , that proceeded with those offenders , Burtoun , Bastmijck , Prinne , in a Court of Mercie , as well as Iustice ; since as the reverend Iudges then declared yee might have justly called the offenders into another Court , and put them to it in a way that might have exacted their lives . That the furthest banishments for tearme of life , is a priviledge which their indulgence may grant but to few . (i) (i) The world knowes , that numbers who have beene flying from episcopall tyrannie out of England , to the very new found lands , never to return , have beene by violence keeped back , and cast in their prisons : and wee see dayly , that numbers not onely of men , but even of sillie women are drawn back in Ireland from their flight , out of the kingdom to close prisons . That the vilest dungeons , yrons , whippings , bread and water , chaining to posts without all company , day or night in the coldest and longest winters , is but a part of their opposers deserving . (k) (k) Huntly in his Breviat reports , as a known case among many other , this one also , that M. Iohn Hayden a poore Devonshire Minister for preaching at Norwich a Sermon , wherein he let fall some passages against setting up of images , and bowing at the name of Iesus , was apprehended like a traitour , with the Constables bills and halberts by D. Harsnet then Bishop , and brought manacled to him like a fellon , and committed to the common Iayle close prisoner , above thirteene weekes , where hee was like to sterve ; the Bishop having taken from him his horse , papers , and all , thereafter he was sent by a pursevant to London , and keeped two full tearms . At last , by the high Commission he was deprived of his orders , thereafter the high Commissionars imprisoned him in the Gate house common dungeon , and Canterburie sent him to be whipped in Bredwall , and there keeped him all the long extreame cold winter in a dark cold dungeon , without fire or candle light , chained to a post in the mids of the room , with heavy yrons on his hands and feet , allowing him only bread and water with a pad of straw to ly on : And since on his reliefe hath caused him to take an oath , and give band to preach no more , and to depart the Kingdome within three weeks , without returning ; and all this for preaching after his first uniust deprivation , though no exception was taken against his doctrine . That the greatest Nobles of the Land , ought in Law to for-fault their Life and Estate , if they be so bold as to put their hand to a supplication unto their gratious Prince against their practices . (l) (l) Sundrie of our prime Earles and Lords did present a supplication to our King , after his Coronation , wherein the matter of their greatest complaint was , so far as ever wee heard , their challenging of the Bishops for what they had done , and were likely to doe . The copie of this privie supplication being privily convoyed by an unfriend , some two or three years thereafter , out of my Lord Balmerinochs chamber , was a dittay for which hee was condemned to die , for an example to all other Noble Men to beware of the like rashnesse , especially his Fellow-supplicants , who are all declared to have deserved by that fault the same sentence of death . Large Declaration , pag. 14. Nor could they have found the least blemish in our justice , if wee should have given warrant both for his sentence and execution , whose life was now legally devolved into our hands . Ibid. pag. 13. Wee were graciously pleased that the feare and example might reach to all , but the punishment onely to one of them , to passe by many , who undoubtedly had beene concluded , and involved by our Lawes in the same sentence , if wee had proceeded against them . That all this is but just severitie , and the very expedient meane to advance their cause , which they glory have well neere already close undone their opposites , (m) (m) Studley about the end of his wicked storie avowes , that since by severe punishment the number of the unconformists have decayed , that their cause can not bee from God . and which they boast shall still bee used , (n) (n) Canterburie in his epistle to the King before Starchamber speach , having magnified the Kings mercie , for saving the life of Bourtoun and his companions , is bold to advise the King not alwayes to bee so mercifull , in these words , Yet this I shall bee bold to say , that your Majestie may consider of it in your wisedome , that one way of government is not alwayes either fit or safe , when the humours of the people are in a continuall change , especially when such men as those shall work upon your people , and labour to infuse into them such malignant principles , to introduce a paritie in the Church or Commonwealth . Etsi non satis sua sponte insaniant instigare . Heylen in his moderat answer , pag. 187. hath many reasons and examples , to prove that Burtoun and his like deserved no lesse than publick execution : And yet these men are so gentle to Papists , that they glory in their meeknesse towards them , professing that to the bitterest of the Iesuits they have never given so much as a course word . So Canterburie in his Epistle the other yeare to the King , before the relation of the conference , God forbid that I should ever offer to perswade a persecution in any kinde against the Iesuits , or practice it in the least , for to my rememberance I have not given him or his so much as course language . But alasse it is gone now beyond boasts , when they are the second time upon the very point to kill millions of the Kings best Subjects , to dash together all his dominions in a bloody warre , as pitchers one upon another for the confirmation of their intollerable tyrannie , where long it hath beene tottering , and the reerection of it where it s owne unsupportable weight hath caused it to fall .

As for the power of princes , King Charles hates all tyranny the most of those this day who are Christians , and especially our gracious Soveraigne , are very well content to be limited within the bounds of the laws which themselves and their predecessors have setled in the church and state of their dominions , to make the preservation of those laws and of their subjects liberties ecclesiastick and civill according to them , the greatest glorie of their prerogative royall . (o) (o) His majesties speach in Parliament 28. p. 75. The peoples liberties strengthen the Kings prerogative , and the Kings prerogative is to defend the peoples liberties . To give assurance of their resolution never to abolish any old , or bring in any new act either in church or state without the concurrence of Assemblies and Parliaments . ( p ) Neither to impose any taxation on their subjects goods without their free consent there to given by their Commissioners in Parliament , (q) (q) Proclam . at Yorck April 25. 1639. We heartily declare and faithfully promise that , althogh we be now in armes , they shall be no wayes used either to force upon that our native Kingdome any innovation of religion , or to infringe any of the civill liberties or the laws thereof , accounting it our glory to preserve libertie and freedome among them according to their laws Therefore wee do once again by this renew our former promises for the mantenance of religion and laws , and this we do in all sinceritie of heart , we take God the searcher of all hearts to witnesse that as we are defender of the true Protestant religion which we from our heart professe ; so we trust , we shall by his goodnesse continue in the same , and never shall permit any innovation to creep in this or any other of our kingdomes . One of the articles of Dunce pacification is this . We are further graciously pleased , that according to the petitioners humble desires all matters ecclesiasticall shall be determined by the Assemblies of the Church , and matters civill by the Parliament and other inferior Iudicatories established by law ; which accordingly shall be keeped once a year , or so oft as the affairs of the Church and kingdome shall require . the extending of the prerogative to the making of new laws or abolishing of old , to the imposing of taxes by simple proclamation without Parliament our Prince doth so far abhorre , that he condemned a certaine writ for importing his Majesties intertainment of such motions ; Yea his Majestie by his Atturney generall called the Earl of Bedfoord and other noble personages to censure , for keeping such a writ wherein did ly so pernicious positions . (r) (r) The which seditious discourse and writting the authors thereof intended should be dispersed , as if the same had been intertained by your Majestie with purpose to put it in execution , and to alter the ancient laws of this kingdome , and to draw all things to your Majesties absolute will and plessure , and to dispose of your Subiects goods without their consent , and to make and repeale laws by your Maiestise proclamation only with out consent of parliament , which if it should be beleeved by your people , could not but raise infinit discontentment amongst them , the consequence whereof might bee of extreame and almost inevitable danger to your Maiesties person and to the whole frame of the kingdome . Where some Princes misled through passion & mis-information have deviat so far from the path of justice , as to intend by violence and armes the overthrow of the true religion and ancient (q) (q) Cant. relat. p. 112. In some kingdome there are diverse businesses of greatest consequence which cannot be finally and binedingly ordered but in , and by Parliament , and particulary the statute laws which must bind all the Subjects can not be made or ratified but there , the supreme Magistrate in the civill state may not abrogat laws made in Parliament , though he may dispense with the penaltie of the law quoad hic & nunc . liberties of their subjects , the opposition which the subjects are forced to make in this case against the oppression of their Prince , our gracious Soveraigne hath been so far ever from counting of it rebellion , of which crime the greatest royallists in England wont alway to absolve it , (s) (s) Bilson of subjection pag. 280. Neither will I rashly pronounce all that resist to be rebells : Cases may fall out even in Christian kingdomes where people may plead their right against the Prince and not be charged with rebellion : As for example , if a Prince should go about to subject his Kingdome to a forraine realme , or change the forme of the common wealth from imperie to tyranny , or neglect the laws established by common consent of Prince and people , to execute his own pleasure ; In those and other cases which might be named , if the nobles and commons ioine together , to defend their ancient and accustomed libertie , regiment , and laws , they may not well be counted rebels . Ib. By superior powers ordained of God , we do not mean the Princes privat will against his laws but his precepts derived from his laws and agreeing with his laws ; which though it be wicked , yet may it not be resisted by any subject with armed violence , but when Princes offer their subjects no justice but force , and despise all laws to practise their lusts , not any privat man may take the sword to redresse the prince ; but if the laws of the land appoint the nobles as next to the King to assist him in doing right , and withhold him from doing wrong , then be they licenced by mans law and so not prohibited by Gods law for to interpose themselves for the safegard of equity and innocencie , and by all lawfull and needfull means to procure the prince to be reformed , but in no case to deprive him where the scepter is inherited . Ib. pag. 54. Spoiles , m●ssacres , conspiracies , treasons , even to the destruction and murther of Princes by their owne se●vants , if a priest say the word , you count in your selves to be just , honourable , and Godly war : if others do but stand on their guaird to keep their lives and families from the blinded rage of their enemies , seeking to put whole towns and provinces to the sword gainst all law and reason , and to disturbe Kingdomes in the minoritie of the right governours , or if they defend their Christian and ancient liberties , covenanted and agreed upon by those princes to whom they first submitted themselves , and ever since confirmed and allowed by the Kings that have succeeded . If in neither of these two cases the Godly require their right and offer no wrong neither impugne their princes , but only save their own lives , you cry rebellious Hereticks , rebellious Calvinist , furie , frenesie , mutinie and I know not what , ye may persue , depose , muther princes when the B. of Rome bids you and that without breach of duety , law , or conscience to God or man as you vant . And that when neither life nor limme of you is touched , we may not so much as beseech princes that we may be used like subjects not like slaves , like men , not like beasts , that we may be convented by laws before judges , not murthered by inquisirours in corners , but incontinent the fume of your unclean mouth is ready to call us by all the names you can devise . that his Majestie hath thought meet before all Europe after the example of his glorious Father , and renowned predecesrix Elizabeth , to give his countenance , aid , and powerfull assistance to them all , when their just grievances and fears were laid out before his throne . If so be King Charles had esteemed the late wars of France of the Protestants against their king , the present wars of Holland and of the high Dutches against the Spaniard and Emperour an unlawfull defence let be a traiterous insurrection of subjects against their Soveraignes , We presuppone his Majesties justice would have been loath ever to have defiled his scepter by supporting them all with men and moneys , as oft he hath done , and yet doth avow the deed .

The Canterburians flatter the King in much more power than ever he will take . And inable him without advice of the Clergie , to do in the church what he pleaseth . While our gracious Prince is so far inflamed with hatred against all tyrannie , yet behold this wicked faction how carefully they go about by all the means they can , to draw his royall minde to that which naturally it doth so much abhore : For they tell us first , that the power of all true Kings is so simply absolute and illimitate , that for any man to reason what they may not is a crime no lesse than treason ; that they are far above all law (t) (t) Heylens moderat answer pag. 28. What spirit leads you that you are grieved with illimitat power which men of better understanding than you have given to princes . Ib. pag. 32. Princes are Gods de puts , of whom should they bee limited , if ye say by the laws of the land those themselves have made , a prince in abctracto is above the laws though in concreto a just Prince will not break the laws which himself hath promised to observe otherwise we say of princes : Principi lex non est posita that they do not governe only by the law but are above it , that he is sure and hath an absolute authoritie Ibid. p. 179 I will be bold to tell you that as it is a kinde of Atheisme to dispute pro & contra what God can do and what hee can not , though such disputs are raised some times by unquiet wits ; so it is a kinde of disobedience and disloyalty to determine what a king can , and what he can not . Lysimachus . p. 3. Hence it is that princes being Legislators are above their laws , and dispense with them as they think expedient . A prince is not bound to his own laws because no man can impose a law on himself . Aberdeen duplyes p. 22. The king is above the law as both the author and giver of strength thereto . 2. That the oath which a prince makes to keep the laws is but a personall deed , which can not oblidge his successor , that his oath and promise at his coronation to keep the laws , is to be exponed of his resolution to make his laws to be keeped by others : That all the oath and promises he makes at his coronation are but of his meer free-will and arbitrement , that by them all no true covenant or paction can be inferred betwixt the King and his subjects . (w) (w) Dominus Ioannes Wemius de Craigioun a man advanced by our bishops to be a lord both of Councell and Session in his book de primatu Regis printed in Edinburgh 1623. And going among them to this day with applause p. 18. Sed quid si princeps leges statuat adhibito etiam iurisiurandi sacramento , velin sua inauguratione promittat , se leges non laturum absque populi ordinumque non modo consilio , sed etiam consensu ac determinante sententia , siquidem non fuerit haec in prima regni constitutione conditio & imperii coaeva ac fundamentalis regni lex non sit ( quo casu dicerem non proprie esse regnum , sed aristocratiam , vel democratiam ) sed post regni constitutionem pactum tantummodo sit regis alicuius voluntarium , etiamsi forsan pollicentum ipsum obliget quoniam praestanda est sides dat a ne sine fide licet non sine iure regnet : successores tamen in regno quomodo constringet vix intelligimus , etiamsi inhonesta quoque sit ut ait quidam & illegittima omnis ea pactio quae inter patrem & filium , maritum & uxorem , dominum & servum , regem & subditum celebratur , quod dicto oportet hos audientes esse Ib. p. 39. Audemus dicere in monarchiis Reges supra leges esse iisque solutos , nemo enim sibi legislator , vindex aut iudex , distinctio non probanda principem quoad vim Legum directivam Legum non coactivam legibus subditum esse , non enim magis derigere quam cogere seipsum potest quis , cum actio onmis sit inter agens & patiens . Ib. 41. Si leges suas se observaturum pacto obligaverit princeps . Quod raro aut nanquam fit , etiamsi soleat princeps quisque legum suarum observationem hoc sensu promittere id est , ut a subditis observentur se effecturum , ad earum observationem teneri eum confitemur , sed religionis potius quam iustitiae legalis observatione . 3. That the prince alone is the lawgiver both in church and state (x) (x) Iohannes Wemius pag. 26. Legum latio praecipuum est supremae dominationis ac maiestatis caput . Ib. pag. 74 Legum ecclesiasticarum principes latores sunt , nec differunta civilibus ecclesiastica natione cause efficientis . 4. That in maters ecclesiasticall they themselves alone without the advice of any of the Cleargie may lawfully make what canons they please , and compell their Cleargie to embrace them (y) (y) Iohannes Wemius pag. 59. Potestatem in ecclesiasticis 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 posse a princibus iure suo extra concilia exerceri docent quas ita tulerunt leges imperatores atque iis Regis legibus Ecclesiasticis quae legi devinae non repugnant nequit quit bona cum conscientia obedientiam detrestare , quamvis non accessent ad earum constitutionem Pastorum ecclesiae consensus . Ib. p. 93. Etiamsi extra concilia jubendi autoritatem habeat Princeps , tamen libentius obsequuntur subditiillis principum statutis , quibus pastorum in conciliis honorantur iudicia . 5. That it is a part of the Kings prerogative to have power to impose upon all his subjects such confessions of faith , such liturgies , such canons as he thinks meetest without the advice of any church Assembly (z) (z) Large declaration p. 222. Did not wee and our Councell be equall authority command these innovations of canons & liturgie ? Was not then ye Prelats practice of then as well warranted as this confession of faith , and the band annexed , which were never brought in by acts of Parliament or Assembly , but meerly by our royall Fathers prerogative , and put in execution by the authority of his councell ? 6. When it is his pleasure to call an Assembly , the members of that ecclesiastick court are onely such as he is pleased to call , whether of the Clergie or of the Laitie . (&) (&) Johannes Wemius pag. 66. Laicos saepe à principibus advocatos in Concilia videre est ; quibus non modo consultivam sed & definitivam vocem permitterent . Iste fuit electionis mittendorum ad Concilia modus , ut Ecclesiarum presulibus quos vellent mittendi liberam plerumque potestatem permitteret princeps , quod illis exploratius quam sibi esset qui ad eam provinciam aptiores : Non quod principi penitus neganda sit , quod autum aut nonnulli , particularis personarum quae consilio eum leges Ecclesiasticas laturum adjuvent designatio . Istud enim esset principum juri detrahere . Ex singulis diaecesibus moderatus aliquis numerus eruditorum ac prudentiorum Presbyterorum , Diaconorum , & Laicorum à principe aut metropolita principis delegate eligebatur . 7. That when they are called only the Princes voice is decisive , the voice of all the rest at most but consultive , or if any of them become decisive , it is by the Princes favour or at least permission . (a) (a) Iohannes Wemius pag. 89. Consultivam habent vocem Pastores tanquam juris divini consulti , definitivam princeps ut judex ; dante illis consilii , his judicii potestatem Legis latore Deo , penes quem solum summa in spiritualibus imperii residet . Ib. pag. 70. Vocem . habere qui congregantur Presbyteros non qua Presbyteri , sed qua Ecclesiarum sunt legatià principe vocati . Ib. pag. 74. Definitiva sententiae dictio corum est , qui à principe summo moderatore eos consulente , vocemque decisivam iis dante vocantur . Ib. Asserimus non agitato in conciliis fuisse saltem quae majoris momenti essent negotia , nisi quatenus ea princeps per legatos proponeret aut patribus descripta traderet . 8. That church Assemblies are only politick conventions not grounded upon any devine right , and so to be used or disused as the prince shall think expedient . (b) (b) Iohannes Wemius pag. 126. Nullo in scriptura mandato nititur concilia . celebrandimos ; sed à principibus Ecclesiae curam suscipientibus , & cum non essent principes , à pastoribus ipsis volentibus ortum habuit . 9. That it is in the power of all Soveraignes whihher Monarchick , Aristocratick , or democratick , to appoint for the government of the church in their dominions such officers and spirituall courts as they finde most meet and agreable to their temporall estates , to erect bishops , and put down Presbyteries , to erect Presbyteries and put down bishops . (c) (c) Iohannes Wemius p. 78. & 79. Officiorum Ecclesiae modus 〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉〈◊〉 est , & à principe pastoros Ecclesiae non consulente praescribi posse affirmamamus , putantes cum serenissimo nostro Rege , summis quibusque imperitantibus concessum esse externam in Ecclesiasticis regiminis formam suis praescribere , quae ad civilis administrationis modum quam proxime accedat , dummodo à fidei veraeque religionis fundamentis ne tantillum abscedat . 10. That all this power to conclude every ecclesiastick affaire which can be subject to the jurisdiction of any ecclesiasticall synod doth belong alike to all soveraignes whether Turkish , Iewish , Pagan , hereticall or Christian and Orthodox . (d) (d) Iohannes Wemius pag. 124. Regi omni confertur Ecclesiasticae jurisdictionis potestas per regium quod à Deo habet munus ; licet Regi tantum Christiano aptitudo oû recte utendi Christi gratia donetur Tamet si primatus ecclesiastici ius perfectius administret Rex Christianus : Primatus tamen ius , officii seu vocationis non facultatis aut exercitii ratione Rex obtinet . Quae Regi supervenit gratia regiam in eo potestatem perficit , non facit potestatem , non repellit , gratiae interna , nedum professionis externae defectus .

Concerning the Kings power in matter of Stat , They give to the King power to do in the State what ever he will , without the advice of his parliament . they teach first , that a Parliaments is but his arbitrarie Councell , which in making or annulling of his Lawes , hee may use or not use as hee pleaseth . (e) (e) Ioannes Wemius , p. 17. Neque verò putan dum est , quia solet rex ex modesta & prudenti virium suarum diffidentia non nisi de ordinum consensu leges ferre , absolutam ideo ei imponi , eiusque successoribus necessitatem illorum obtinendi consensus , ac si nullo modo iis liceret perse , sine eorundem suffragiis , bonas edere constitutiones , quibus qua quaeso conscientia non parebunt omnes . Ibid. pag. 19. In Monarchia Regis sola voluntas de substantia legis est : praevia cum populo consultatio , & si utilis imò ultilissimae sit , necessaria tamen non est . Itaque cum imperatore Iustiniano dicendum videtur ; explosis ridiculosis ambiguitatibus , verum conditorem & interpretem legum esse solum principem , & legem legislatoris , non Consiliarii esse , non ex vi consensus & consilii habiti , sed ex regia legislatoris ●i obligantem . Ibid. pag. 38. Non erubescimus Iuristaturum reiicere opinionem , qui volunt in monarchiis non obligare legem nisi à populo acceptetur , cum monarcha sit legislator , & lex lata qualex obliget , adeo ut ad eam acceptandam , cogendi sint subditi post legis a monarchae lata publicationem , temporisque quoàd populi notitiam pervenat sufficientis lapsum , potest sine ulla acceptatione publica legis observatio praecisem ingeri . Heylyns antid. pag. 66. The declaration of his Majesties pleasure in the case of S. Gregorie is to be extended to all other cases of the same nature . It is a maxime in the civill law , Sententia Principis , ius dubium ●eclarans , ius facit quoad omnes . Item Quodcunque imperator per epistolam constituit , vel cognoscens decrevit , legem esse constat . Id. in his moderate answere , pag. 29. Only these commands of the King are to bee refused , which are directly against Scripture , or include manifest impietie . Hee learned this from his opposite the Lincobishire Minister , pag. 68. I say that all commands of the King that are not upon the clear and immediat inference without all profylogismus , contrarie to a cleare passage of the word of God , or to an evident Sun-beame of the law of nature , are precisely to bee obeyed ; nor is it enough to finde a remote and possible inconvenience that may ensue . 2. When he is pleased to call a Parliament , it is his due right by his letter to ordaine such Barrons to be Commissionars for the Shires , and such Citizens to bee Commissionars for Burrowes as hee shall bee pleased to name . (f) (f) Ioannes Wemius pag. 23. Baronum ut & civium ad Comitia delegatos non ita absolute à Baronum vel Civium delectu pendere volumus , ut non possit rex , quos ille maxime idoneos censuerit eligendos nominare , praesertim cum pro legibus ferendis ijsque quae administrationis sunt publicae statuendis Comitia indictae sunt , in quibus liberum denegare regi arbitrium , quos aestimarit prudentissimos quibuscum deliberet sibi in Concilium asc●scendi , esset ex rege non regem eum facere , statuumque voluntati ad regiae depressionem eminent à nimis subjectum . 3. That he may lawfully exact when he hath to do what portion of his Subjects goods hee thinks meet , and by himselfe alone , may make such Lawes for exactions in times to come , as seemes to him best . (g) (g) Joannes Wemius , pag. 19. Omnia fatemur quae in regno sunt regis esse , qua rex est , id est , qua paternus regni dominus , adeoque qua postulat ipsius qua rex est , aut publica regni conditio : posse regem de singulorum bonis disponere , praesertim ubi omnes in regno terrae in feuda concessae fuerint à rege , aliquod penes se dominium retinente . Id. pag. 17. Licet non de jure omnium bona exigendo , tamen de jure in omnes leges ferendo , sine omnium consensu statuere potest . Montag . orig. pag. 320. Omni lege , divina , naturali , vel politica licite semper reges & principes suis subditis tributa & imposuerunt , & licitè quoque exegerunt , cum ad patriae & reipublicae desensionem tum ad ipsorum & familiae honestam procurationem . Hanc doctrinam accurate tuetur Ecclesia Anglicana , in qua sacerdotes licet magis gaudere & soleant , & debeant , immunitatibus tamen & frequentius , & exuberantius , & libentius , quam Laici decimarum decimas , subsidia , annatas primitias solvunt . 4. That no Subject of his Kingdome can have any hereditarie jurisdiction , but any jurisdiction that either any of the Nobilitie , or any other Magistrate or officer possesseth , they have it alone during his pleasure ; that at his presence , the power of all others must cease , and at his death evanish and be quite exstinguished , till by his successors by new gift it be renewed . (h) (h) Joannes Wemius , pag. 136. Cum regis sit in suo regno judices , & magistratus constituere , qui ipsius sint in judicando , & jubendo vicarli , potest tex jubendi , judicandique jus ac magistratus judicesque constituendi potestatem inferioribus concessam , prout regno utile esse visum ei fuerit abutentibus auferre , & nulla proprie est sub . Rege patrimonialis & haereditaria jurisdictio , rege solo jurisdictionem tanquam propriam habente , aliisque quibus eam non dat , sed communicat , tanquam depositam accipientibus . Igitur non ut terras , ita & jurisdictionem simpliciter , & ut loquuntur privative , rex alienare potest , nisi rex esse desinat . Ibid. pag. 157. Si judices sint principum vicarii , nulla est eorum principe presente potestas , cum solius absentis teneat quis locum : & si quae est alicubi , & aliquando videatur , non nisi jus est , ●●dicium regium volente Rege declarandi ; ut ita ex judicam ore proferatur Regis sententia . Ibid. pag. 17. In statuum caetu non tam judicantibu● ipsis quam assistentibus imperium exercet rex , quandoquidem praesente jurisdictionis sente , evanescat aboram omnium jurisdic●●o derivata , ut fluviorum perditum nomen & potestas , cum in mare discenderint , Ibid. pag. 143. Principus occasis evanescit judicum omnium tam ordinariorum quam delegatorum jus . Negari non potest tam apud Romanos quam alios in usu fuisse , ut qui in demortuorum succederent locum reges , quamprimum regnorum gubernacula capesserent , magistratuum judicumque jurisdictionem confirmarent , ut ostenderetur extinctis regibus nullam esse inferiorum authoritatem , nisi successorum edicto confirmentur , saltem patientia tacite approbentur . 5. That Scotland is a subdued Nation , that Fergus our first King did conquer us by the sword , and establish an absolute Monarchie for himself and his heires , giving to us what Lawes hee thought meetest (i) (i) Corbet p. 45. There was no law in the Kingdom of Scotland before the kings gave it : For before Fergus his days we were genus hominum agreste , sine legibus , sine imperio . He and his successors gave lawes . Ibid. Fergus did conquere us . 6. That al the Lands in Scotland were once the Kings propertie , and what thereof hath beene given out for service , yet remaines his owne by a manifold right . (k) (k) Corbet , pag. 45. Fergus and his successors divided the whole land which was their owne and distinguished the orders of men , and did establish a politick government : This is cleare ex archivis regiis , ubi satis constat regem esse dominum omnium bonorum directum , omnes subditos esse ejus vassallos , qui latifundia sua ipsi domino referant accepta , sui nempe obsequii , & servitii praemia . 7. That to deny any of the named parts of this power to the King , is to destroy his Monarchike government , to dethrone him and make him no King , to subject him to his people and make them his masters , or at least collegs in the Empire . (l) (l) Joannes Wemius , pag. 18. Quo casu dicer●m non proprie esse regnum , sed aristocratiam vel democratiam . Ibid. pag. 23. Hoc esset ex rege non regem eum facere . Ibid. p. 38. Quod si alicubi non habeat rex potestatem leges serendi , nisi ex populi in comitiis consensu , & sic fundamentaliter limitato , propriè Rex non est , ac non tam acceptans est populus , quam cum Rege , ut collega Regem ferens . ibid. pag. 53. Non est imperium illud vere Monarchicum , sed principatus quidam , & imperans ille , non Monarcha aut Rex , sed tantum Princeps , & ut Venetorum dux residente in optimatibus , aut populo imperii summa . But thanks be to God , that our gratious Prince hath so oft declared himselfe to bee farre from all such thoughts ; yea , that my lord of Canterburie himselfe , is forced whiles to let drop from his fingers cleane contrare maximes . (m) (m) Relat. of the Conference . pag. The statute Lawes which must binde all the Subjects can not bee made but in , and by Parliament : the supreame Magistrate in the civill state , may not abrogat Lawes made in Parliament . Ibid. pag. 158. Tiberius himself in the cause of Silanus , when Dolabella would have flattered him into more power than in wisedome he thought fit then to take to himself , he put him off thus : No , the Lawes grow lesse when such power enlargeth , nor is absolute power to bee used , where there may be an orderly proceeding by Law .

Even in no imaginable case , they will have tyrants resisted . Lastlie , they teach us in the matter of resistance , first , that do the Prince what he will , he may never be resisted by any or all his Subjects , that not only a private man must give over all defence , though most innocent of his own life against the Prince , though his most unjust violence ; (n) (n) Ioannes Wemius . p. 21. Teneri videtur subditus seipsum fame perimere , ut principem salvaret propter conservationem boni publici , singulis a dempta est adversus principem quae naturalis dicitur iuris defensio , seu iniuriae depulsio . but the whole state can do nought without rebellion against God , but flee or suffer , when the Prince , whether by him selfe or his officers doth destroy the true religion , established by all Laws and the liberties of the land , dear bought of old & peaceably brooked in many ages , also the lives of many thousands of the best Subjects without the pretence or colour of any just cause . (o) (o) Canterb. relat. Pag. 205. where the foundations of the faith , are shaken by princes there their ought to be prayer and patience , but no opposition by force . Aberdeens duplys . pag. 25. The way for all Christian Subjects to conquer tyrants , and the remedy provided in the New Testament against all persecutions , is not to resist powers which God hath ordained , lest we be damned , but with all meeknesse to suffer that we may be crowned , It is evident by Scripture , that it is unlawfull for Subjects in a Monarchicall estate , to take armes for religion , or for any other pretence , without warrand from the Prince . The renowned Thebaean legion of 6666. Christian souldiers without making resistance as they had strenth to have done , suffered themselves rather to be slaine for their Christian profession by the Officers of Maximinian , the Emperours executors of his cruell commandements against them . Corbet . pag. 42. For your examples from reformed churches , since we live not by examples but by Lawes , I will not stand upon them , from facts to prove the lawfulnesse of resisting is ridiculous ; none of those by resisting , gained so much as by suffering , as experience too late doeth show . Againe , that all this subjection must be used , not only to our native King , but to any forraine usurper who can get footing among us , and it were the Kings of Spaine , as their predecessors the hereticall Gothish Kings got footing in the Romane Impyre . (p) (p) Aberdeens Duplys . pag. 29. Such was the doctrine and practice of many other great lights , which shined in the days of Iulian the Apostate , and in the dayes of the Arrian Emperours , and Gothick Arrian Kings . That even against them , the States of a Land with a good conscience could use no defence , though before their eyes , they should see them execut the cruell tyrannies of Nebuchadnezar , put out the eyes of the King , kill his children , lead himself and his Nobles away to a far land in fetters : Though with Nero , (q) (q) Corbet . pag. 26. Qui Mario , Cajo Casaeri , qui Augusto , ipse & Nerom , qui Vespasianis vel patrivel filio , ipsi Domitiano crudelissimo ; & ne per singulos ire necesse sit , qui Constantino Christiano , ipse & apostatae Iuliano . Ibid. pag. 36. If the Iewes in the dayes of Assuerus had beene of this new Scottish humour , when an utter extirpation was intended by Haman , both of themselves and their religion , they would have taken Ames : but their prayers and teares were their defence in their greatest extremity . for their mere pleasure , they should set the royall city in a faire fire , or execute the plot of Haman by murthering all the seed of the Iewes , all zealous Protestants up and downe the Land in one day . Such maximes exceedingly opposite to the honour of God , the safetie of the Kings person and crowne , the welfare of the people , these men cause to bee printed and let them go about without any censure at these times , when by royall decreers , they have pulled into their hands the full commandement of all the Presses , and the absolute jurisdiction over all the Book-sellers shops in the Kingdome , and kythes frequently their zeale against any Books that give but the least touch to their mitres , by inflicting no lesse censure then fire upon the Books , pilloring and nose-sliting on the Authors , and whipping thorow the streets on the carriers .

All these extraordinary prerogatives , Wat they give to Kings , is not for any respect they have to Majestie , but for their own ambitious and covetous ends . whereby the faction advanceth supreame Magistrats so nere unto God , and their favorits so far above the skyes , (r) (r) Ioannes Wemius in his preface to the Duke of Buckinghame , Reges in diviniorem sortem transcripti ▪ cute & specie tenus homines , reipsa boni genii censendi sunt , in quos ut humanos loves divini honoris offines pene & consortes , oculos animosque nostros defigi convenit , Tu Heros nobilissime coruscas , velut inter ignes Luna minores , quem in summo augustioris gloriae solstitio divina prorsus virgula constitutum nemo potest diffiteri . seeme to flow not from any love they carie , either to their crownes or the royall heads that bear them , but meerlie out of their self-respect to their owne ambition and greed , that Soveraignitie being advanced to an numerasurable hight , may be a statelier horse for them to ride upon , in their glorious trivmphings above all that is called God . For otherwise , yee may see how farre they depresse all Soveraignes when they are layed in the ballance with them selves . they tell us , that the King can bee no more the head of the church , then the boy that rubs their horse heeles , (s) (s) Smart Sermon , pag. 1. M. CouZins uttered these trayterous speaches in an open and affirmative manner ; that the Kings highnes is no more supreame head of the church of England , then the boy that rubbs his horse heeles , and this as we are credibly informed hath beene proved against him by the oathes of two sufficient witnesses . 2. That the heart whence the native life & vigour of the Ecclesiastick Lawes doeth flow , is alone the Bishops and not the King . (t) (t) Chounaei collect . supra cap. ult. A 3. That Kings and Emperours ought to reverence ; yea , to adore Bishops and to pay them tributes . (w) (w) Montagsupra cap. 3. O. 4. That every Bishop is a Prince and a Monarch , as farre in dignitie above the greatest secular Prince , as the soul above the body , or God above man . (x) (x) Montag , supra cap. tertio . (z)

FINIS .