The
Confider
in
Falshood
confounded
:
being
an
Answer
to
an
abusive
Book
lately
published
by
William
Wright
of
Dublin
,
against
Thomas
Carleton
his
Tenant
,
&c.
THE
first
thing
I
observe
in
his
Book
,
is
,
That
he
would
make
the
World
believe
that
the
Quakers
deceived
him
;
and
with
this
news
he
would
tingle
their
Ears
,
thereby
to
make
his
Monologies
,
or
Book
of
Bables
,
more
taking
with
the
Reader
;
and
the
reason
he
lays
down
in
the
9th
page
of
his
Book
:
he
considers
that
in
all
reports
that
are
spread
abroad
amongst
men
,
be
they
never
so
false
,
there
are
some
that
believe
them
,
especially
where
the
party
concerned
stirs
not
in
vindication
of
himself
.
These
and
the
like
considerations
moved
him
,
as
he
saith
,
to
do
what
he
did
.
And
in
the
20th
page
he
saith
,
one
mans
story
seems
fair
and
honest
till
another
be
heard
;
so
that
from
his
own
saying
it
may
be
concluded
,
be
his
reports
never
so
false
,
they
will
seem
fair
and
honest
,
and
be
believed
for
truths
by
some
whilst
Carleton
and
the
Arbitrators
say
nothing
for
themselves
;
and
no
doubt
many
such
his
Book
may
meet
with
in
the
world
as
will
be
ready
to
give
judgment
before
they
hear
both
parties
.
But
the
Quakers
did
not
deceive
him
,
for
it
was
his
own
false
heart
,
and
leaning
to
lies
for
refuge
,
and
for
his
great
transgression
against
God
,
that
he
was
deluded
and
decieved
,
and
fell
into
great
and
fore
temptation
:
If
we
may
believe
his
own
report
of
himself
and
what
he
hath
written
with
his
own
hand
;
in
the
first
page
of
a
Book
he
writ
against
his
own
Wife
about
7
or
8
years
before
this
Arbitration
was
;
so
what
can
we
expect
when
he
cannot
conceal
the
infirmities
of
his
own
flesh
;
but
writ
Books
,
yea
black
Books
as
he
calls
them
,
against
his
own
Wife
and
spread
them
abroad
.
And
to
my
knowledge
it
hath
been
his
practice
for
many
years
to
write
Libels
and
scandalous
scroles
against
divers
men
he
hath
had
to
do
with
,
which
he
dare
not
publish
in
print
as
he
does
the
Quakers
;
but
like
a
Serpent
in
the
dark
would
impeach
other
mens
honesty
and
advance
his
own
;
but
such
black
,
dark
Books
and
scroles
must
needs
proceed
out
of
the
bottomless
pit
where
all
such
things
are
hatched
.
But
to
come
to
my
purpose
,
that
is
to
answer
to
his
high
charges
,
and
to
give
a
little
more
light
and
understanding
to
the
unbiassed
Reader
,
that
he
may
not
err
in
judgment
by
believing
all
W.
W.
hath
put
in
print
;
for
I
remember
it
was
said
of
old
,
He
that
is
first
in
his
own
Cause
seemeth
just
,
but
his
neighbour
cometh
and
sercheth
him
out
.
Page
the
4th
.
He
saith
God
defend
that
he
should
either
wittingly
or
willingly
write
one
word
but
what
shall
be
real
truth
.
So
if
the
Reader
will
take
his
serious
assertions
for
truths
,
he
may
be
deceived
;
for
I
am
able
(
the
truth
being
on
my
side
)
to
make
it
appear
in
several
places
of
his
Book
,
that
he
hath
both
wittingly
and
wilfully
writ
that
which
is
not
true
against
Carleton
(
though
some
may
be
apt
to
think
W.
W.
is
no
such
man
)
for
all
his
large
pretence
to
the
contrary
;
yea
things
that
he
knew
was
not
true
long
before
his
Book
was
writ
;
but
I
see
by
experience
men
that
stand
in
disobedience
and
rebellion
against
Gods
witness
in
themselves
,
grow
worse
and
worse
,
deceiving
and
being
deceived
.
Now
I
shall
proceed
to
examine
his
high
and
false
Charges
one
by
one
,
and
give
my
Answers
as
truly
and
briefly
as
possible
,
without
tautology
or
needless
reiterations
as
he
hath
often
done
in
his
Book
.
Charge
1.
page
4.
I
let
to
Carleton
,
saith
he
,
184
Acres
of
Land
,
and
there
being
some
odd
Acres
,
part
whereof
being
Turf-bog
,
I
reserved
to
my self
for
firing
for
my
other
Tenants
,
and
also
for
Clay
for
my
own
use
,
and
that
I
should
sell
his
Clay
,
hinder
his
Tennants
from
digging
Turf
,
and
dig
Turf
there
my self
,
and
also
my
Tenants
,
&c.
Answ.
That
he
reserved
any
odd
Acres
,
either
of
Turf-bog
or
Clay
,
by
any
express
Covenant
in
my
Lease
,
or
any
express
words
in
our
bargain
,
that
I
absolutely
deny
:
It
is
true
,
there
are
several
Exceptions
and
Reservations
in
my
Lease
,
(
which
hitherto
I
have
duely
observed
and
kept
)
but
not
a
word
of
any
odd
Acres
of
Land
or
Bog
,
&c
,
so
why
should
that
reservation
be
wanting
(
if
any
part
of
our
bargain
)
when
the
other
was
put
in
;
he
knows
,
and
I
know
,
very
well
,
he
would
have
excepted
4
Acres
when
we
were
about
the
bargain
at
C.
W.
his
house
at
Clahamman
;
and
I
would
either
have
all
as
it
was
entirely
fenced
in
(
as
saith
my
Lease
)
or
I
would
have
none
;
upon
which
we
broke
off
,
and
paid
our
reckoning
at
the
Inn
;
and
after
he
was
out
of
doors
and
ready
to
take
Horse
,
he
turn'd
in
again
and
said
he
would
not
break
with
me
for
them
.
I
should
have
them
,
and
so
granted
me
the
whole
,
all
within
the
Fences
to
my
understanding
,
and
others
that
were
by
,
and
into
the
whole
put
me
in
possession
,
and
the
whole
I
have
enjoyed
these
five
years
last
,
and
have
nothing
but
my
bargain
,
both
by
the
bounds
of
my
Lease
and
plain
express
words
,
which
J.
N.
can
witness
who
was
then
standing
by
;
also
T.
A.
who
before
treated
with
him
upon
the
same
bargain
,
broke
off
for
4
or
2
Acres
of
Bog
some
days
or
weeks
before
,
as
I
was
like
to
have
done
,
if
he
had
not
granted
them
;
without
any
further
reservation
or
exception
:
for
confirmation
of
this
take
T.
A.
his
Certificate
as
follows
.
This
is
to
certifie
all
whom
it
may
concern
,
That
I
went
to
Ballynicargie
to
take
it
of
William
Wright
,
and
he
shewed
me
the
very
Lands
that
Thomas
Carleton
now
enjoyeth
,
and
he
and
I
agreed
of
the
price
,
and
I
was
to
have
a
lease
according
to
the
bounds
,
and
when
he
came
to
write
Articles
he
would
have
accepted
4
or
2
Acres
of
Bog
;
upon
which
I
left
him
and
it
,
because
I
could
not
have
it
as
we
had
agreed
.
Witness
my
Hand
this
17
th
.
day
of
May
1684.
Thomas
Anslow
his
mark
.
And
whereas
he
accuses
me
of
selling
Clay
,
I
never
did
,
by
positive
Sale
;
only
the
Clerks
of
the
Iron
works
gave
me
something
,
what
they
pleased
themselves
,
in
consideration
for
the
Clay
they
got
:
And
if
I
had
,
I
sold
none
of
his
,
for
the
Land
being
mine
the
Clay
was
not
his
.
Charge
2.
page
4.
Carleton
to
spare
his
own
Wood
in
the
Year
1680
,
set
his
man
Charles
Smith
to
cut
down
and
take
away
all
the
Birch
Trees
that
grew
upon
a
new
double
Ditch
of
Wrights
:
saith
he
some
of
them
being
above
3
foot
in
circumference
.
And
in
page
9.
he
saith
,
They
were
cut
out
of
season
for
the
stumps
are
dead
.
Answ.
That
my
man
cut
3
or
4
Birches
I
suppose
may
be
true
,
though
some
of
them
,
as
I
understand
,
was
dead
,
or
dying
before
;
but
that
the
Ditch
was
his
,
that
is
a
lye
,
for
the
double
Ditch
was
mine
,
and
with
no
little
trouble
have
I
maintained
it
these
several
years
;
for
the
Wood-cutters
,
Fellers
,
Stripers
and
Colliers
made
several
ways
over
it
to
my
great
damage
,
often
occasioned
my
Cattel
to
go
out
:
But
what
had
Wright
to
do
with
Birches
,
or
any
other
Wood
upon
the
Land
during
my
Lease
;
he
excepted
none
but
Oak
,
and
but
some
of
that
too
,
as
by
my
Lease
may
appear
:
but
he
wanted
matter
to
make
me
criminal
,
and
to
aggravate
it
the
stumps
are
dead
;
so
were
hundreds
more
cut
by
him
or
his
people
before
I
came
there
,
and
by
divers
of
his
Tenants
since
,
who
for
years
together
I
could
not
restrain
until
I
served
one
of
them
with
a
Writ
,
which
is
another
Charge
in
his
Book
:
one
thing
I
shall
here
mind
the
Reader
of
,
which
was
an
express
bargain
between
him
&
me
,
in
behalf
of
William
Fettrel
,
the
man
that
bought
the
Oak
Wood
of
him
;
which
was
that
I
should
let
the
said
W.
F.
have
Birches
to
build
a
Bark-Mill
;
and
he
promised
to
give
me
as
much
Oak
,
number
for
number
,
when
they
were
strip'd
.
They
had
of
Birches
96
pieces
,
besides
6
or
7
pair
of
Couples
and
Knees
,
but
to
this
day
he
never
gave
me
one
stick
of
Oak
in
consideration
,
which
is
(
besides
the
abundance
his
Tennants
out
off
for
2
or
3
years
,
)
far
more
considerable
than
twice
3
or
4
in
my
own
Hedge
;
but
breaking
word
and
promise
is
made
a
laughter
with
him
,
for
when
I
have
charged
him
with
his
promise
he
would
laugh
,
and
say
,
there
is
never
a
promise
made
,
but
it
is
either
broke
or
kept
.
Charge
3.
page
4
&
5.
Carleton
,
saith
he
,
is
bound
by
Covenant
in
his
Lease
to
keep
all
the
Houses
,
Walls
and
Ditches
in
good
repair
,
which
he
failing
to
do
,
Wright
is
damnified
at
least
30
shillings
in
his
Bedding
and
Papers
in
a
Closet
he
reserved
for
himself
.
Answ.
That
he
reserved
liberty
of
that
Closet
to
himself
,
I
grant
,
but
upon
what
terms
,
viz.
when
he
came
there
about
the
ordering
and
disposing
of
Timber
and
Bark
,
most
of
which
was
over
and
disposed
of
from
him
4
years
agoe
,
he
was
but
to
have
that
liberty
when
he
came
upon
that
occasion
,
and
not
otherwise
:
so
if
he
had
cleared
the
Room
as
he
ought
to
have
done
when
he
went
away
,
there
could
have
been
no
such
damage
to
him
;
which
as
I
am
informed
is
not
for
want
of
repair
neither
,
but
rather
by
Moth
,
Mice
or
Rats
,
for
this
is
the
effects
of
Fraud
and
a
wrongful
detainer
;
for
he
hath
detained
this
Closet
and
two
others
from
me
and
my
Assigns
ever
since
I
came
there
,
contrary
to
the
Covenant
of
my
Lease
,
for
which
I
want
satisfaction
,
for
I
have
the
great
damage
and
wrong
,
though
he
hath
made
first
complaint
,
&c.
So
this
is
the
way
he
requites
me
for
my
kindness
and
forbearance
;
so
I
think
it
is
now
high
time
for
me
to
amend
that
matter
,
and
let
him
take
his
Moth-eaten-Clothes
and
Papers
away
,
and
pay
for
the
time
he
hath
detained
them
unjustly
.
Charge
4.
page
5.
That
he
and
I
went
to
one
Pridham
a
Clerk
,
and
how
I
would
not
pay
one
half
of
the
Charge
for
ingrossing
the
Lease
in
Parchment
.
But
he
should
have
said
himself
would
not
;
for
I
no
sooner
proposed
to
do
it
,
being
I
was
to
stay
in
Town
,
but
he
quickly
closed
with
it
,
and
sent
O.
W.
to
one
Tayler
a
Cousin
of
their
own
for
Parchment
to
engrose
the
Lease
;
so
I
saved
him
his
part
of
the
18
shillings
the
man
demanded
:
I
think
it
is
very
fit
he
should
now
pay
that
would
pay
me
so
for
my
forbearance
,
with
so
many
base
and
abusive
aggravating
exclamations
,
as
may
be
seen
pag
5
,
7
,
9
,
22
,
&c.
of
his
Book
,
where
it
is
multiplied
as
so
many
various
actions
to
make
me
the
more
criminal
;
which
was
,
that
I
should
deceitfully
,
and
like
a
dishonest
man
,
contrary
to
the
trust
imposed
in
me
,
thrust
several
things
into
the
Lease
,
that
was
not
,
saith
he
,
in
the
Original
rough
draught
;
nor
never
spoke
of
,
saith
he
,
in
making
the
bargain
,
to
the
best
of
his
knowledge
;
and
all
these
several
things
being
examined
,
(
by
a
judicious
Reader
)
is
but
one
thing
nominated
in
all
his
Book
,
and
that
is
this
,
pag
7.
that
I
should
put
in
these
words
,
Save
only
what
Oak-Timber
the
said
Tho.
Carleton
his
Executors
or
Assignes
shall
have
need
of
,
or
shall
have
occasion
to
use
or
expend
upon
the
Premises
,
which
he
or
they
is
to
have
while
it
is
there
.
This
is
all
,
and
all
this
is
more
than
is
true
,
(
ergo
a
lie
)
for
I
thrust
it
not
in
,
it
was
agreed
on
before
;
for
I
have
yet
to
shew
,
and
that
to
my
comfort
now
,
in
the
first
Articles
of
our
Bargain
,
writ
,
signed
and
sealed
with
his
own
hand
,
where
he
himself
hath
granted
that
Covenant
of
the
Timber
,
and
three
Witnesses
to
the
said
Articles
,
viz.
James
Vnderwood
an
Attorney
at
Law
,
Tho.
Trafford
and
Will
.
Errat
;
take
T.
T.
his
Certificate
.
Whereas
Will
.
Wright
in
his
Book
lately
printed
hath
charged
Th.
Carleton
of
deceitfully
thrusting
in
into
his
Lease
that
clause
of
liberty
for
Oak
Timber
,
&c.
This
is
to
certifie
the
truth
to
all
,
that
I
was
present
when
the
said
Wright
and
Carleton
did
sign
Articles
of
their
said
Bargain
,
and
that
the
said
Articles
were
writ
by
Wright's
own
hand
,
and
that
the
said
Covenant
for
the
Timber
was
in
it
,
and
I
was
a
subscribing
Witness
thereunto
.
Given
under
my
hand
this
2d
.
of
the
4th
.
Month
,
vul
.
June
1684.
Tho.
Trafford
.
Also
take
this
Certificate
following
.
This
is
to
certifie
all
whom
it
may
concern
,
That
we
have
this
day
seen
Articles
of
Covenant
and
Bargain
made
the
19th
.
day
of
April
1679.
between
W.
W.
and
T.
C.
wherein
he
the
said
W.
W.
hath
granted
to
the
said
T.
C.
what
Oak-Timber
he
hath
occasion
to
use
upon
the
premises
,
and
he
is
to
have
it
so
long
as
it
is
there
:
And
we
are
well
satisfied
the
said
Articles
are
writ
,
signed
,
and
for
ought
we
know
sealed
too
with
W.
W.
his
own
hand
.
Given
under
our
hands
the
23d
.
of
May
1684.
-
Thomas
King
-
Michael
Holme
.
And
further
I
am
persuaded
that
this
Covenant
is
in
one
of
the
rough
draughts
still
,
if
it
could
be
seen
;
but
,
saith
he
,
not
in
the
Original
;
and
thus
he
would
delude
the
World
to
make
Carleton
odeous
:
Which
he
calls
the
Original
is
the
question
?
for
there
were
three
rough
draughts
;
one
was
corrected
by
my
hand
,
which
was
the
last
of
the
three
;
so
let
all
the
World
judge
what
honesty
appears
in
this
allegation
,
and
whether
this
is
not
wittingly
and
wilfully
done
.
And
if
he
were
not
a
vexatious
and
letigious
man
,
he
would
have
been
ashamed
to
have
shown
his
folly
and
deceit
so
far
,
as
to
shuffle
from
the
covenant
of
a
Deed
under
hand
and
seal
to
a
rough
draught
of
his
own
subtil
devising
.
Does
People
use
to
make
void
a
compleat
and
perfect
Lease
,
five
years
after
it
is
made
,
by
the
abrupt
and
crooked
lines
of
a
rough
draught
,
sure
the
man
is
hard
put
to
it
,
that
nothing
short
of
Printing
could
serve
to
make
himsef
and
his
actions
rediculous
to
the
world
,
and
that
which
is
worst
of
all
,
must
spread
his
own
infamy
in
City
and
Country
,
with
his
own
hand
.
And
further
,
when
Covenants
under
hand
and
seal
are
thus
wilfully
wrested
,
by
making
wilful
lies
,
what
usage
may
I
expect
in
other
things
?
let
all
the
World
judg
.
Charge
5.
page
5.
Carleton
,
saith
he
,
made
Spars
to
his
Fulling-Mill
,
all
of
fine
streight
young
Oak
Saplings
,
from
which
Wright
himself
was
prohibited
by
Henry
Temple
,
Esq
;
and
besides
,
saith
he
,
he
lost
the
bark
.
Answ.
A
pack
of
lies
who
e're
invented
them
;
he
is
the
man
that
now
hath
printed
them
.
By
his
words
he
had
nothing
to
do
with
the
Timber
,
and
consequently
nothing
to
do
with
the
Bark
;
so
what
is
this
to
him
,
the
Trespass
(
if
any
were
)
were
against
H.
T.
Esq
;
only
he
would
make
his
wilful
lies
manifest
by
his
own
scribling
hand
,
and
show
his
wicked
malice
against
me
;
for
there
is
not
one
Oak-Spar
in
all
the
Mill-house
that
we
built
the
first
year
before
he
sold
the
Timber
,
(
which
is
the
house
he
means
)
as
by
this
following
Certificate
may
appear
.
This
we
certifie
that
there
is
not
one
Oak
Spar
in
all
the
Tuck-Mill
house
that
Tho.
Carleton
built
upon
the
Lands
of
Ballynicargie
the
first
year
he
came
there
;
and
though
W.
Wright
says
they
were
all
fine
,
straight
,
young
Oak
Saplings
,
there
is
not
one
,
and
we
are
sure
the
house
was
never
stripp'd
,
nor
a
Spar
altered
,
since
it
was
first
set
up
.
Given
under
our
hands
this
23d
.
of
May
1684.
-
Edmond
E.
Chadwick
.
-
Simeon
Bins
-
Nicholas
Richardson
.
Charge
6.
is
about
a
Dunghil
,
(
which
had
they
been
right
placed
should
have
contained
all
his
12.
or
21
before
they
went
to
the
Press
)
which
,
saith
he
,
he
preserved
to
himself
;
neither
by
Word
or
Writing
,
say
I
;
(
this
is
some
of
his
subtil
mental
reserves
)
for
he
can
scarce
make
any
Bargain
without
some
hidden
underhand
reserve
,
reach
or
other
.
As
for
the
Dunghil
,
he
a
great
while
after
begun
to
say
he
would
have
one
of
them
;
I
said
I
thought
it
was
fit
it
should
stay
upon
the
premises
;
for
the
other
Land
was
set
to
Lease
,
and
so
was
that
it
laid
upon
,
and
this
was
all
the
hindrance
I
made
:
I
put
no
body
off
from
the
work
,
nor
see
no
body
about
to
take
it
away
;
neither
did
I
convert
it
all
to
my
own
use
,
as
he
saith
,
for
I
left
a
great
deal
of
it
there
when
I
removed
to
the
other
side
of
the
Land
:
however
a
story
of
a
Dunghil
will
serve
to
fill
a
Book
.
Charge
7.
Yate
Bars
,
and
other
materials
,
with
Boards
of
divers
sorts
,
and
Wain
Axletrees
,
left
in
Carletons
custody
,
were
by
him
,
his
Servants
or
Workmen
wasted
,
destroyed
,
and
made
away
,
and
how
he
suffered
his
Carpenter
to
cut
some
of
the
seasoned
Axletrees
,
and
made
Helves
of
it
for
Axes
,
Augures
and
Chissels
;
Yate
Bars
and
Boards
were
disposed
of
for
several
uses
for
the
said
Carleton
,
some
whereof
Wright
saw
cut
to
repair
a
pailed
Fence
,
which
Carleton
or
some
of
his
family
had
either
burnt
or
carelesly
lost
for
want
of
a
Pin
,
&c.
Answ.
In
this
Charge
is
couched
several
Lies
or
subtil
Assertions
;
one
Yate
Bar
and
two
Boards
I
made
use
of
in
the
Parlor
Chimney
to
break
the
wind
off
the
Fire
when
my
Wife
was
sick
,
and
this
by
him
or
his
Wife
is
reputed
little
less
then
fellony
,
though
I
have
often
profered
either
to
pay
or
return
them
;
and
all
my
Servants
,
People
or
Workmen
that
he
can
instance
in
his
subtil
and
large
Charge
,
is
only
a
Carpenter
that
cut
a
piece
of
a
slit
Ash
for
Chissel
Helves
,
neither
for
Ax
nor
Augur
that
I
know
of
;
nor
was
it
a
seasoned
Axletree
,
as
he
saith
,
only
a
slit
Ash
seasoned
without
door
under
the
drop
of
a
House
Eves
,
where
for
ought
I
know
it
and
its
fellows
stood
till
some
of
them
were
rotten
.
And
as
for
the
Gate
Bars
and
Boards
he
saw
cut
to
repair
a
pailed
Fence
,
which
Carleton
or
his
family
(
why
not
some
,
or
no
body
)
had
either
burnt
or
lost
,
&c.
This
is
another
of
his
witting
and
wilful
lies
,
for
he
knew
in
his
Conscience
this
was
a
Lie
;
for
the
man
that
prepared
the
pailed
Fence
,
did
confess
it
to
him
before
my
face
in
Jo.
Newbies
house
in
Dublin
,
that
he
did
it
when
the
Arbitration
was
;
and
he
knew
long
before
,
that
most
of
this
Charge
,
and
several
others
,
was
false
,
and
wilfully
(
contrary
to
his
own
knowledge
)
laid
against
me
;
for
the
parties
he
knew
that
had
confessed
to
him
some
years
before
,
that
they
did
those
things
unknown
to
me
,
and
for
their
own
private
concernes
,
and
not
mine
;
and
still
he
wilfully
and
wickedly
lays
them
to
my
charge
;
and
what
had
I
to
do
to
drive
a
Pin
in
dry
weather
;
it
was
another
mans
Fence
;
another
man
let
it
fall
down
,
and
another
man
made
it
up
;
and
this
he
knew
well
enough
;
but
who
is
so
wicked
as
them
that
presumptuously
sins
against
their
own
knowledge
,
as
this
man
in
many
things
hath
done
,
which
I
am
able
to
prove
by
more
testimonies
than
my
own
?
yet
who
is
so
oily
and
smooth
to
strangers
as
Will
.
Wright
?
Charge
8.
Is
about
Twenty
shillings
mistake
in
Accounts
,
&c.
Answ.
Upon
the
ballancing
of
Accounts
in
Thomas-street
,
as
he
saith
,
there
I
answered
all
he
could
charge
(
and
more
then
I
thought
was
due
)
and
he
was
then
,
and
is
yet
,
Four
shillings
in
my
debt
;
and
after
,
he
comes
over
again
with
this
,
I
have
bid
him
oft
make
it
appear
just
and
due
and
I
would
pay
it
him
,
though
I
know
it
was
seen
in
his
Pocket-book
put
down
with
his
own
hand
,
that
I
paid
it
once
to
his
own
Ditchers
,
and
that
one
would
think
was
often
enough
.
But
in
short
,
let
him
produce
such
Papers
and
Bonds
which
he
long
since
took
away
from
me
,
whereby
all
those
Accounts
may
be
examined
,
and
this
shall
be
rectified
,
for
I
have
no
reason
to
pay
it
twice
.
Charge
9.
Is
about
serving
a
Writ
upon
one
of
his
Tenants
for
a
Bundle
of
Wattles
,
&c.
Answ.
This
is
another
lie
;
for
I
gave
the
man
leave
to
get
Wattles
;
in
his
Charge
to
the
Arbitrators
he
calls
them
Two
penny
worth
,
here
he
saith
a
Bundle
;
I
believe
it
was
several
Bundles
,
for
it
was
as
many
as
wattled
two
Chimnies
;
for
that
I
did
not
serve
the
Writ
,
but
for
Injuries
,
Trespasses
,
some
just
Debts
and
other
abuses
I
served
a
Writ
upon
him
and
some
others
which
I
never
repented
to
this
day
;
and
I
never
served
another
,
neither
was
I
ever
served
with
any
upon
my
own
account
(
save
once
for
Tithes
)
in
England
nor
Ireland
in
all
my
life
;
and
I
have
dealt
and
exchanged
several
hundreds
of
Pounds
before
I
dealt
with
him
,
ergo
not
so
much
given
to
vexatious
Suits
as
himself
;
so
if
serving
a
Writ
be
any
error
or
sin
,
I
believe
his
Conscience
is
far
more
defiled
with
that
sin
than
mine
is
;
witness
his
many
letigious
Suits
for
many
years
in
most
of
the
Courts
in
Dublin
.
Then
he
tells
a
tale
of
Nuts
;
I
never
had
a
Nut
upon
any
such
account
:
but
I
think
,
as
himself
saith
in
his
Book
concerning
the
Arbitrators
,
he
is
drunk
,
but
no
with
Wine
.
Charge
10.
Is
but
the
4th
over
again
to
make
them
numerous
,
and
fill
a
Book
,
or
else
the
man
forgot
himself
.
Charge
11.
Thomas
Carleton
said
to
James
Eustace
one
of
Wrights
Tenants
,
that
his
Landlord
would
serve
him
as
he
served
sixteen
poor
men
in
the
County
of
Catherlough
,
who
were
indicted
upon
Wrights
account
,
and
he
let
them
all
go
to
Prison
,
and
never
regarded
them
,
but
they
were
glad
to
shift
for
themselves
,
&c.
Answ.
This
is
an
absolute
Forgery
as
it
is
laid
down
;
for
I
never
heard
of
so
many
being
inindicted
,
nor
of
any
one
of
them
going
to
Prison
;
what
I
had
was
from
William
Wright
his
own
mouth
in
Carloe
streets
,
I
believe
he
told
me
then
of
nine
,
I
am
certain
I
never
spoke
of
their
going
to
Prison
,
neither
of
so
many
being
indicted
.
I
sometimes
tell
what
I
hear
,
but
never
what
I
hear
not
,
nor
know
not
;
I
remember
I
told
Eustace
(
who
then
came
as
he
said
by
W.
Wrights
order
to
dig
Turf
upon
my
Land
,
and
he
came
to
my
bed
side
where
I
was
lying
lame
to
tell
me
what
he
intended
to
do
,
)
so
I
charged
him
not
to
do
it
without
my
leave
,
for
he
had
no
Land
there
;
I
told
him
there
were
several
poor
men
indicted
upon
his
account
at
Carloe
,
and
I
bid
him
not
be
so
confident
,
for
if
I
should
indict
him
for
it
,
it
might
be
he
would
not
bear
him
out
,
but
leave
him
to
snift
for
himself
;
and
upon
this
he
forged
that
story
against
me
;
and
this
is
the
sum
of
all
the
Reproaches
,
Scandals
and
Lies
with
which
he
hath
so
often
stuffed
the
leaves
and
lines
of
his
Book
,
which
he
seems
to
lay
down
as
the
first
motive
of
all
our
differences
;
so
now
let
the
Reader
judge
.
But
I
I
know
there
was
another
thing
was
the
occasion
of
all
,
which
had
I
answered
,
all
these
things
had
never
been
alledged
,
nor
the
world
never
heard
so
much
of
our
difference
;
and
that
was
my
refusing
to
turn
Tenant
to
his
Son
Ebenezer
,
who
came
with
a
Deed
of
Gift
from
his
Father
,
in
which
Deed
of
Gift
he
mentioned
all
the
conveyances
of
the
Reversions
of
that
Lease
by
which
he
holds
Ballinicargie
,
and
by
which
he
sets
it
to
me
;
I
say
he
makes
a
recital
of
all
to
himself
,
but
makes
no
mention
of
me
or
any
other
Tenant
upon
the
Land
,
neither
binds
his
Son
to
perform
any
Covenant
of
his
to
the
present
Tenants
,
and
after
reserves
power
to
himself
to
revoke
or
disanul
the
same
Deed
of
Gift
at
any
time
hereafter
by
giving
his
said
Son
a
Twenty
shilling
piece
of
Gold
;
which
had
I
done
,
and
once
altered
my
property
,
I
suppose
I
might
then
have
been
Tenant
at
will
,
and
repented
at
my
leisure
:
so
because
I
would
not
be
taken
in
this
snare
have
produced
all
these
occasions
;
and
since
that
,
in
a
Letter
I
have
yet
to
show
under
his
own
hand
,
he
saith
he
made
it
his
business
both
in
City
and
Country
to
inform
himself
what
I
had
said
against
him
;
so
that
it
seems
he
wanted
occasion
till
then
.
So
now
let
the
world
judge
what
usage
I
have
had
,
or
am
like
to
have
.
Charge
12.
But
to
aggravate
his
reflecting
malice
against
Wright
,
saith
he
,
he
said
to
Thomas
Booth
that
his
Landlord
would
serve
him
as
he
served
Francis
Thornhill
,
to
whom
,
saith
he
,
Wright
never
did
the
last
injury
to
the
value
of
a
farthing
.
Answ.
Whether
I
might
say
any
such
thing
to
Booth
I
do
not
well
remember
.
I
examined
Booth
and
he
denied
once
or
twice
that
he
told
him
any
such
thing
,
but
since
I
perceive
he
does
say
it
;
but
in
short
Francis
Thornhill
complains
loud
enough
of
the
wrongs
he
had
by
him
,
which
I
shall
not
now
argue
:
but
to
strengthen
his
Plea
against
me
he
went
to
Francis
Thornhill
to
get
something
under
his
hand
to
clear
him
,
who
told
him
he
had
rather
his
Hand
was
cut
off
then
ever
it
should
do
such
a
thing
,
This
I
had
since
from
Francis
Thornhill
his
own
mouth
.
In
page
9.
he
demands
satisfaction
for
advising
Thomas
Booth
to
dig
Turf
in
his
Meadow
;
there
is
but
a
Ditch
between
it
and
my
Bog
,
and
though
it
was
once
laid
up
for
Meadow
,
it
was
so
bad
that
it
is
now
turned
to
pasture
again
as
mine
is
,
and
for
ought
I
know
was
as
good
Bog
and
as
fit
for
Turf
as
mine
is
.
And
further
he
saith
,
I
said
this
to
aggravate
my
reflecting
malice
against
Wright
,
&c.
What
I
said
to
Booth
(
if
ever
I
said
it
)
was
long
before
,
for
ought
I
know
a
year
or
years
before
I
hindred
Eustace
to
dig
Turf
;
but
if
I
should
reckon
what
provocations
and
aggravations
he
hath
given
me
,
of
far
greater
moment
then
this
,
I
might
make
large
Volumes
;
whether
it
was
not
malice
in
him
to
keep
all
these
things
in
store
,
and
read
them
amongst
his
familiars
over
his
Cups
in
an
Ale-house
.
In
page
8.
he
saith
He
hath
put
down
but
about
half
,
and
what
he
hath
put
down
is
all
true
:
So
here
the
World
has
his
word
for
it
,
believe
it
that
will
;
when
any
one
has
tried
him
so
far
as
I
,
then
they
will
know
better
what
to
believe
.
Further
,
He
saith
he
hath
left
out
nine
or
ten
for
brevity
sake
:
But
rather
for
want
of
being
true
,
say
I.
Page
9
and
10.
He
makes
a
repitition
of
8
or
9
of
them
over
again
;
only
I
suppose
either
to
make
his
Book
or
my
Crime
bigger
.
Next
thing
I
take
notice
of
is
page
17.
where
,
he
saith
,
he
had
set
one
hundred
forty
Acres
of
Ballynicargie
to
Stephen
Racks
and
Robert
James
seven
years
before
ever
Carleton
was
concerned
,
which
,
saith
he
,
if
I
had
let
to
Carleton
were
to
bring
an
old
house
over
my
head
,
and
I
were
a
fool
and
a
mad
man
.
Who
would
think
such
a
man
that
is
so
serious
,
and
stands
so
much
upon
his
reputation
,
and
professes
so
much
honesty
,
truth
,
and
just
dealing
in
words
,
could
be
contradicted
.
For
such
a
Fool
&
a
Madman
is
William
Wright
,
for
all
his
vapor
of
seeming
honesty
,
that
he
set
forty
Acres
of
that
same
one
hundred
forty
to
Thomas
Trafford
but
one
year
before
Carleton
was
concerned
with
all
that
Carleton
now
holds
,
took
his
earnest
,
drew
Articles
,
hath
his
earnest
yet
,
but
to
this
day
would
never
perform
his
Bargain
.
See
what
honesty
is
here
;
Is
not
this
to
bring
an
old
house
over
his
head
?
so
now
see
the
impudence
of
the
man
.
For
further
satisfaction
take
Thomas
Traffords
Certificate
.
I
do
hereby
certifie
that
William
Wright
did
set
to
me
in
the
Year
1678.
all
the
Lands
of
Ballynicargie
that
Thomas
Carleton
now
holds
,
and
40
Acres
more
which
he
hath
since
set
to
Stephen
Racks
and
Robert
James
;
I
drew
an
Article
of
our
bargain
,
and
I
was
to
have
a
Lease
accordingly
for
a
considerable
number
of
years
,
and
was
to
pay
Thirty
five
Pounds
per
Annum
,
but
to
this
day
I
could
not
have
my
bargain
,
(
which
I
can
make
appear
was
worth
one
hundred
Pounds
)
but
hath
shuffled
me
off
from
time
to
time
,
in
hopes
to
make
more
of
it
.
And
I
can
truly
say
it
was
not
my
seeking
,
but
he
and
his
Wife
did
often
urge
it
upon
me
;
if
this
be
honest
dealing
let
the
impartial
Reader
judge
.
Given
under
my
Hand
the
second
of
the
4th
.
Month
called
June
,
1684.
Tho.
Trafford
.
And
again
Thomas
Ansloe
who
here
before
hath
certified
,
did
treat
with
him
about
them
forty
Acres
,
and
so
did
Carleton
himself
;
that
very
time
that
Carleton
and
he
bargained
,
and
the
Lease
to
these
two
men
was
but
made
after
Carleton
came
there
,
for
he
had
the
perusal
of
it
before
it
was
sealed
;
so
if
he
had
set
them
seven
years
before
(
which
he
knows
is
not
true
)
as
he
hath
lately
confessed
;
then
such
a
Fool
and
a
Madman
was
he
as
set
them
over
again
to
one
,
and
treat
about
them
with
two
more
that
very
Spring
Carleton
was
concerned
:
So
his
easiest
and
safest
way
to
come
off
,
is
honestly
to
confess
he
hath
wittingly
and
wilfully
printed
a
lie
.
But
,
and
if
he
had
set
this
Land
twice
,
it
was
but
as
he
did
about
the
Timber
,
and
when
I
pleaded
the
Covenant
of
my
Lease
,
then
he
forged
that
Lie
,
that
I
deceitfully
put
it
in
;
and
having
forged
it
,
must
persist
to
maintain
and
publish
it
in
print
;
and
this
snare
of
the
Devil
he
is
fallen
into
.
Page
22.
He
says
I
never
did
so
much
as
demand
a
stick
of
Timber
,
to
the
best
of
his
remembrance
.
And
yet
in
page
23
he
half
grants
it
;
however
,
I
do
affirm
I
did
do
it
,
and
can
bring
witness
of
it
if
need
be
,
(
which
is
more
than
I
was
bound
to
do
by
Covenant
)
I
asked
him
for
Timber
to
repair
the
old
Mansion-House
;
he
bid
me
let
it
go
down
:
I
desired
him
give
me
something
under
his
Hand
to
keep
me
undamnified
,
upon
which
he
turned
away
from
me
as
his
manner
is
.
Page
26.
He
saith
,
the
Arbitrators
were
partial
,
and
awarded
for
Carleton
,
and
against
him
,
whose
charge
,
saith
he
,
against
your
Brother
Carleton
was
every
word
true
.
See
how
positive
the
man
is
in
his
own
commendation
;
I
grant
it
might
seem
so
till
Carleton
was
heard
,
for
he
knows
how
to
set
a
smooth
face
upon
a
bad
matter
:
But
the
truth
of
his
twelve
Charges
I
now
recommend
to
every
impartial
Reader
to
judge
of
.
And
if
these
twelve
,
of
his
head
choice
,
or
rather
ill
choice
where
there
is
no
better
,
be
so
false
and
frivolous
,
what
can
any
one
suppose
his
other
nine
or
ten
may
be
which
he
forbears
to
mention
,
I
suppose
from
a
consciousness
in
himself
of
their
falshood
and
impertinency
.
Page
30.
He
saith
Covetousness
would
not
suffer
Carleton
to
be
content
.
He
should
have
taken
that
to
himself
;
for
Carleton
was
content
well
enough
if
he
could
have
enjoyed
that
which
he
paid
honestly
for
,
and
paid
before
hand
too
,
and
can
make
it
appear
,
(
if
it
were
not
for
being
tedious
both
to
my self
and
the
Reader
)
for
I
confess
this
kind
of
work
is
not
pleasant
,
but
that
I
am
engaged
in
my
own
and
the
Truths
defence
to
take
away
those
blots
and
stains
he
by
his
book
of
lies
&
bables
would
bespatter
me
&
my
Principles
with
before
the
World
;
but
for
that
,
and
for
giving
satisfaction
to
divers
who
waits
to
see
what
I
will
say
for
my self
before
they
conclude
me
guilty
of
all
.
I
could
have
sat
silent
,
with
a
quiet
and
clear
Conscience
,
notwithstanding
all
he
hath
done
,
and
could
have
left
Judgment
and
Vengeance
to
the
Lord
,
who
will
one
day
give
true
judgment
between
him
and
me
.
I
say
I
can
make
appear
how
he
hath
endeavoured
(
after
he
hath
got
my
mony
)
to
deminish
my
bargain
every
year
since
I
came
there
;
so
it
is
covetousness
in
him
will
not
let
me
enjoy
several
particular
things
which
I
bargained
for
(
though
he
was
paid
for
five
years
before
hand
)
which
I
am
able
to
prove
.
It
is
covetousness
in
him
will
not
let
him
keep
his
Word
,
Bond
,
or
Bill
of
Arbitrament
under
Hand
&
Seal
to
stand
to
the
judgment
of
four
men
,
of
whom
he
in
a
manner
begged
that
service
,
both
by
words
and
a
Letter
yet
to
be
seen
.
When
I
and
John
Burnyet
did
often
desire
him
to
take
men
of
other
Judgments
;
and
when
they
have
not
answered
his
covetous
,
will
,
then
asperse
and
abuse
them
at
this
rate
,
so
far
as
either
Tongue
,
Pen
or
Print
can
go
:
So
I
would
have
all
warned
how
they
arbitrate
for
him
least
they
come
under
the
same
doom
.
And
further
,
for
all
this
great
complaint
he
casts
upon
them
,
as
being
no
Christians
,
but
deluded
,
and
men
led
with
a
spirit
of
delusion
,
worse
then
Turks
,
Jews
or
Infidels
,
and
saith
they
wanted
nothing
but
Canibals
teeth
to
have
eaten
him
up
,
&c.
and
all
this
from
varying
very
little
from
his
own
counsel
and
advice
,
as
may
be
seen
in
his
Letter
,
page
the
13th
.
which
rightly
considered
by
judicial
and
impartial
Readers
,
doth
consound
and
make
void
a
great
part
of
his
own
Book
,
and
of
his
large
complaints
,
both
against
them
and
Carleton
;
for
by
their
Award
they
answered
his
own
mind
and
desire
in
every
thing
save
two
.
The
first
,
they
orderered
two
Surveyors
to
be
equally
chosen
,
and
what
Acres
they
do
find
over
and
above
184
Carleton
was
to
pay
proportionable
as
he
doth
for
the
rest
;
and
Wright
would
have
it
quite
off
from
Carleton
,
not
allowing
him
it
for
payment
.
The
second
thing
was
,
that
Wright
must
pay
both
the
Surveyors
.
This
is
all
they
have
varied
from
his
own
counsel
and
advice
;
and
yet
see
how
he
exclaims
and
renders
them
.
Can
it
be
paralleled
for
many
Generations
,
that
a
man
out
of
meer
malice
and
envy
,
for
such
trivial
impertinent
occasions
should
traduce
men
(
that
even
three
days
before
he
pitched
upon
for
honesty
and
fidelity
,
and
as
he
grants
could
have
put
his
life
in
their
hands
;
but
sure
if
they
had
caused
one
finger
to
bleed
he
would
soon
have
changed
his
note
;
)
should
I
say
traduce
men
so
hatefully
to
the
World
?
So
we
may
see
what
some
mens
fair
tongues
and
profession
is
worth
;
and
though
he
say
they
gave
more
heed
to
Carletons
lies
(
and
yet
cannot
prove
he
told
them
one
)
then
to
his
just
and
true
Complaints
,
whereas
indeed
they
gave
heed
to
his
own
counsel
in
his
own
Letter
,
which
was
,
that
if
Carleton
would
wave
his
Complaints
he
would
wave
his
,
as
is
to
be
seen
page
13.
of
his
Book
.
And
if
they
had
been
Men
that
would
have
been
biassed
and
led
by
the
Nose
either
by
him
or
Carleton
:
they
were
not
fit
for
Arbitrators
,
but
such
as
he
that
(
will
have
their
own
will
or
nothing
)
should
take
some
base
Sons
of
Belial
,
and
no
honest
upright
men
for
Arbitrators
;
for
I
remember
he
told
the
Messengers
that
delivered
the
Award
upon
the
first
sight
that
he
would
spend
one
hundred
Pounds
upon
Carleton
,
but
he
would
have
it
as
he
would
have
it
.
Also
further
at
Wicklow
Sessions
about
the
beginning
of
October
last
Thomas
Trafford
,
and
he
and
I
discoursing
of
our
differencs
at
the
Sessions
House
door
before
divers
of
the
Country
,
I
then
and
there
proffered
him
whatsoever
differences
were
between
us
I
was
willing
to
abide
of
any
two
Justices
upon
the
Bench
;
his
answer
was
,
he
would
abide
the
Judgment
of
never
a
Justice
in
the
Country
.
But
now
take
Wrights
resolution
or
conclusion
,
or
to
speak
his
own
phrase
,
his
pretty
Rhime
and
Reason
,
which
is
worth
the
noting
,
viz.
if
Carleton
had
continued
to
have
been
so
kind
as
he
was
the
first
two
or
three
years
,
viz.
made
him
welcome
to
Meat
and
Drink
several
Weeks
at
a
time
,
and
several
times
in
a
year
which
is
against
my
disposition
(
both
in
truth
and
nature
)
to
mention
or
upbraid
him
with
,
but
that
he
seems
to
boast
how
well
he
hath
satisfied
me
,
it
may
be
he
would
not
have
printed
this
scandalous
Book
,
&c.
But
this
the
Reader
may
note
in
his
Book
,
or
I
shall
note
it
for
him
,
that
during
that
two
or
three
years
kindness
he
even
then
gathered
up
these
impertinent
crimes
against
me
,
and
kept
them
to
this
use
,
either
in
a
dirty
Heart
or
Closet
,
and
never
had
that
moral
civility
to
acquaint
me
in
the
least
with
many
of
them
until
he
brought
them
before
the
Arbitrators
;
and
yet
he
elsewhere
says
he
thinks
he
satisfied
me
:
If
this
be
his
good
satisfaction
and
gratifying
kindnesses
received
I
have
enough
and
am
over
paid
;
this
I
acknowledge
to
the
whole
world
,
other
satisfaction
I
had
none
,
save
one
Barrel
of
Rye
that
I
remember
.
Lastly
what
I
have
here
writ
and
committed
to
print
,
is
but
to
answer
his
high
and
false
charges
,
and
to
take
off
those
loud
and
large
exclamations
and
complaints
,
or
rather
bundle
of
lies
,
whereby
he
designs
to
render
me
and
my
Principles
odious
to
the
World
,
and
thereby
gratifie
his
wilful
and
malicious
humour
;
but
I
see
the
Lord
hath
blasted
it
already
,
before
I
put
pen
to
paper
.
Wise
men
,
and
men
of
understanding
of
several
professions
and
ranks
sees
through
it
and
beyond
it
,
and
doth
very
much
condemn
the
mans
conceited
folly
,
thinking
he
had
been
wiser
then
to
have
committed
such
a
bundle
of
bables
to
print
.
However
,
for
satisfying
of
weaker
capacities
who
may
not
have
so
deep
inspection
into
things
of
that
nature
,
but
may
conclude
,
all
must
be
true
,
because
he
hath
asserted
it
in
print
:
I
say
,
as
for
clearing
my
innocency
both
as
to
person
and
principles
,
I
have
done
what
here
I
have
done
.
And
notwithstanding
all
the
provocation
he
hath
given
me
,
shall
not
yet
(
as
he
hath
done
)
commit
to
print
the
many
injuries
and
wrongs
I
have
received
from
him
for
these
5
years
last
past
,
which
had
I
known
the
mans
temper
so
well
before
as
I
do
now
,
I
should
never
have
concerned
my self
so
much
with
him
;
for
even
in
the
time
of
my
greatest
kindness
to
him
(
as
he
himself
hath
confest
)
when
he
sat
very
kind
and
familiar
at
my
Table
,
and
by
my
fire
side
,
yet
even
then
did
he
gather
and
pick
up
,
or
otherwise
forge
these
impertinent
crimes
against
me
for
want
of
weightier
matters
;
so
that
the
world
may
see
the
hollowness
of
the
man
;
so
that
from
my
heart
I
have
reason
to
thank
God
I
have
so
well
escaped
his
snares
,
(
for
anguis
sub
herba
latet
.
)
And
from
such
I
desire
the
Lord
my
God
may
ever
preserve
me
,
that
they
that
waits
for
,
and
seeks
occasion
as
he
hath
done
,
may
be
disappointed
.
Thomas
Carleton
.
Written
at
Ballynicargie
the
4th
.
〈…〉
Month
,
vulgarly
June
,
1684.